University of South Carolina Libraries
j ' a te ned re s o hanttLi aacetN$ o th t ce at ktiie il adaf as n co etalaw euri o a. T ht tr~m ",ll+ullt iri A; , J t ; _e fct t aiolvd wn ues e an(l l e a nk. fnds ;out zcuet rhIo n a aitetof r .: . Oh - order' to get owera eight rate. rt)~t1 &Co -toothe ubill' latdin to laintliff who took the billI o7 lading' as collae ;;eral security "fo'r a :loan. The, note Wre ;: paid ;when. due Sand the bank the finds out 'h e et hnl e lintl,i-tead of ( otd; ,hd ek Wth , of $I8, Tios a acton of tecet d to bhto n e tin be more 'this tirAUrt i ,a8 w ether" thepa to4- is efrtitled to eover the Sanunt lge; to;be du in the he fact that n the oil nll Inten tionally rprese.i.th.t the linters to be cotton .certainly :amonnte. ? to a fraudulent m~isrepresent. tion of. a sutbs$tingfact. uit ws rt,es urged by thae learne4 l;ounsel fox the ciefendgnt _that there,Wae nd n tent ol tle p rt of the aded Ant that the I r resent ets ho)uld be a ed.upon b~y th4 pla1n ti, ;as t _defendant no knowledge thMath bill dfling was to be'transfered to plaintift. We think this contention is un: sound pori both reason, and au 4orltyr In the case fr Munro "v. afrdn9r, f reV.' 81, g court said; An intention t ae. cive i: Rnaterial, ut if the false hood Aset,'d or n ipsed is in inatiweor charga)! 3alculata ed directly to defraud &nd injure Bome one ii, p.aiticulgr,'or all pei'. ~sons gener~fy ~aintIp o k0 tay b teby c elv4 rei < alxtii ad d that tdf r ade falae represen tat to te comu od ty de. ien,t,bll of ladii: If li$ roa h of =!Warrani t ,, t eqinestion O privitn be teen the partte "ight osibly arise, bit we think it 'ca have nd application to the case at bar. T ye'fedefend hts also contend hat a bill .f .Qding is nothing moe than a contract between the: rilway jcompany and the shipper' andjis not negotiable, and-thereore.the defendant had no reSson anticipate the fact that he plaintiff or any one else might be defrauded. But the SUPpflQne urt ofouth Garogii lna;ThonVi4vs. lilroad Co,, 8 .' C 587 lays dow the law that while a bill of lading is not xnego at1ble it ie quasi-negotiable 'aid that titl th@?opasses bytrns -or d l i nd that. it is in be hi ghe,gre iporta tt the large erceurivirsally 1?o;n tpybe:lt .pon thetais er of bills of; Ied#ng, that there ' old.le .o4ence in their .re ~cltals. . S,~nai s. Sinlair, 1 Ball. 174, nk o $atav1 vs. R. R. Co. 60 Am , Brooke vs. R. R. Cod. 108 Pend, 526, We think that the defednant when he pro cured the false bill of lading wa: changeable with the knowledge that the sane-was to pass. thru the:Charmer of Commerce and would in ll. proability, fall in the",haidoe a third party. For the, epons hexein stated the judgnment Ia versed and the cae remnanded. S. C. PrepetAso iation Meets The $outh Carolina Colleg Press Association met_tnis weel at Erskine, The Uiver ity wae represened by J , S. Dudley, edi= tor-In hief of th; aroliian, R. achw 4, e,kecti de 4nmnittee man 'ro :'the arolh iit etaff and Z(R. Jt9 editor-in-chiej of th Ganeeoek. !II elegtfon waa Instructed by te t~o e~~ societie te Invie te ~el1e0 burnaliste te n eet at t1 e Pvesty next year n rewspape:'s are a poteki ~ ato~~ tudnt ife arnd th ilvrityll t ortunate It ~ettin~ the .inspiratlon to b~ frId frpmnhaylmle the Prem A ie1aion hiee 1ere. ~ Thior-Made suit. Or Speciahty SuIt n Overcoats-.$12.50 to $35.00. Cern.r Men and Talor Streeta Stp and Think! Of getting a business educa tion at a first. class business ..college for only $25.00' - . Call or Write B. B. Williams, Jr. 24 Thornwell, U. S. C. REMEMBER BOYS! PRINTING -FOR- --- ATHLETIC GOODS PL US Habenict-McDougall Co. 163 .M9in.St. Phone 690 There's more to printing than simply paper, ink and type. Printing plus Service --The - State Co.'s kind gives you When you want the best and most immeasurably more for your opto-dao. as well as, mest reason able in price in the way of money. Send your '.'Copy" AS , to us-our intellegent inter for presents or own tiso, don't select e- nyu rpsto nue unt4 you have seen our selectiidn. etmyu rpsto nue )w.AN DnOS. ~ reuts. 41fep.rEniQn sbe. 1 hw045 PHONE~ 700 FULL D SUIT FO Th SteC o. Pe ErO -uL atd ~E .RCHAN4' TAULOR FRIEDMWAN'S CuARBERs 12e6 tDY STR1D0T BRE (Ol Y M C~A.~uldg~ 64 . SHOld.P I. A u