The watchman and southron. (Sumter, S.C.) 1881-1930, February 10, 1912, Image 8
AYAKING
OLDER
NATIONS
Pslsstins and High Politics?A Deep
Discontent Pervades the People and
Myriads of Them Have Emigrated
to the United States.
By WILLIAM T. ELLIS.
Jerusalem.?Of all the old nations,
Palestine is the one la which the
world Is most interested. Over these
compe>ratirely few square miles have
?wept most of the force* that have
?side history Here wer? given to
Bus race those influences which have
most to change the history of the
two thousand years. Ruins of
self s dossu civilisations strike the
eye of>ths traveler through the land.
TsjL notwithstanding all. the life of
dee Syrian peasant \U not greatly d'.f
f scent from what It was In the time
of Abraham.
Wonder of Wonders, this old order
It now undoubtedly passing away.
Is the most Interesting of all the
here for the discerning traveler
It Is a revolution wrought by tue
return to this land of forest which
had their inception hers. After affect?
ing most of the surface of the globe,
they have come bsck to do thsir work
m tns place of thsir birth.
Paisstlue Is more deeply traveled
by the prevailing unrest of the times
thsn any other nation I have yet vis
Hed. Pressed upon from many sides
by the most modern influences, made
sensitive to human rights by centuries
of oppression. It Is small wonder that
the Syrians wsrs most enthusiastic In
nailing the new regime, with Its prom
Ina of "Liberty, Justice, Fraternity,
Banality.** In those phrases is em
bodied all that the people have covet
od In va far generations. Now they
want these boons, and they want them
right away. Failing their Immediate
realisation, they turn their facet
toward America.
From Ons Land of Promise to Another.
One morning I witnessed -the week
l;r sxodns of Bethlehemites at the Je
nasalem station of ths Jaffa railroad
1* was a scene for a painter's brush
The young people who were leaving
for America wsrs diessed in foreign
style; only the young men stPl wore
ths fes of Turkish subjtcts. This they
would eichange for hats as soon as
./ got on board ship. The stern
red old men, clad an their fathers
been clad before them for gen
stations, grimly tried to suppress all
of grief; they must abide the
conditions to the end. The women
not wail aloud, as Is the usual ori
d way. over the departure of sons
sjed darf hters; for these fine-looking
sttowg~'sutured women are almost
Anglo-Saxon In their appearance
to the strong strain of Crusa
blood In their veins Ths flight
Bethlehem to America has been
unusual)> large because of these tra
SU Ion* I qualities of aggressiveness
and Independence. The lost to Syria
In great, for the Bethlenomltes art fa
?sous workmen, es pec 'ally in the carv
lug of mother of pearl.
The magnitude and Importance of
migration to America from Syria
hardly be overestimated. More
a quarter of a million are now
ths new land of Promise, to which
many mors have their 'aces turned
as government sett ths conscription
after 160 Chiittlnnt in Jsru
It could find only 20, ths oth
sen having fled, mostly to America
The return of emigrants to America
?ad their letters home have a power
fnf laflaence in Increasing the unrest
All over ths Lebanon, which hap
autonomous Christian government
I where property la therefore safe,
> returned emigrants have built fine
ml then, in a surprising
w of cases, have left them and
back o America, usvally taking
isnber of their nelghl>ors along
town of Zahlen. Id ths Lebanon,
ass) SO.Ooe of Its people In ths United
States, where they have created a new
? with ths time narnf. More re
de still In the case of Mamma
aus, which now has 800 of its native
ssrn remaining here, while 1,200 are
an America.
American Oil "ths Light of Asia."
In other ways America is contribut?
ing; directly to ths awakening of this
std nation. Probably ths most typical
accessory of ths life of Pales
la the water Jar, carried on the
of women. As it was In the
ays when Rebecca went to the well
rltb a clay jar upon her head, so It
itlnues until now. But a change
fn coining. The water Jar, as an in
?titution. la beginning to crack. Stand
aro OH tins are taking its place. I
saw a woman at Jacob's well at Sy
sfear carrying water on her head in
Me of these square tin cans. The
water, by tho way, wss used lu mak?
ing mortar for the building of the new
3reek ?hurch over the well. At the
fountain of the Virgin. In Nazareth, 1
Ssrs watched the village dornen fill
:heir jars and curry them off on their
i. just ;im Mary used to do at rh"
spring; hut some. I noticed, cm
rled the tana ft cans of the Standard
OM company.
These same cans furnish most </
the tin that Is used In Asia. Aa
have Oatrh'd Ion ? u a .ans of . am- : \
sonring antes of Standard Oil >
Interior I bsve reralh-d tb)S Stadl
of Utile i .n unit hla - hops I 1
all over Asia, wlwreln the native
workmen wore baiting oul I hast
ami r mhifiiitng them Into | stOft sj
article* for doniesw gat In Bgypi
I Once K.'m:Imi a r ? ggf] hOW
air Men ana at Blstiopviu?-. was M
to carry It without breaking was my
problem. I put it up to the first tin?
smith I met, and in ten minutes ha
had transformed part of an American
oil can into a weil-made coffin for
pussy. "The Light of Asia," Standard
oil Is called out here, because it hi
displaced olive oil and candle dips I
an lllumlnant.
The School Teacher and Statesman?
ship.
There is no novelty in the state
ment, which has been repeated by ev?
ery observer that has ever been in
Turkey, that the greatest part Amer?
ica has in the awakening of this em?
pire?and no other nation has had a
greater?is through the American
schools, which have leavened the
whole lump with American Ideals.
These are breaking down, to some de?
gree, the religious sectarianism which
Is the curse of the country. They are
even making the new generation of
Moslems tolerant. A case In point is
that of the Maroni tea, whi were so
blttar that they would not even let a
foreign traveler pitch his tent in one
of their villages. Now Iba people them
selves are forcing their religious lead
ers to admit or provide schools.
It it In a stiff Maronite district, out?
side of Beirut, that the only woman
physician In Turkey who possesses a
license from the government to prac?
tica haa har headquarters. Dr. Mary
Eddy Is a wonderful American woman,
of tireless energy, masculine initiative
and extraordinary skill, whose experi?
ences in itinerating among the Arabs
and throughout Syria read like a ro?
mance. Now she hat opened the first
tuberculosis sanitarium in the empire,
and she plana a nation-wide anti-tuber?
culosis campaign. In this she Is sup?
ported by the American Red Cross
at Beirut, established by Consul-Gen- !
< iv hero In Janta*)em. It. has existed
for more ;' ;hi a score of >ears, and
out wa ruh app< an to ba more pros?
perous than at any otl ?' time In us
history. It numbers more than a hurf
dred persons, non< ol whom, strang<
to lay, ll B lOClalitt. 71:cy claim to
b ? m< r< ly < bis family, with no partic?
ular theories to work out. They have
ali tlii:. .- la eotrmon, and each doe*
the Work for Which bd or seemf
Lest Qualided. While a large percea
tagf? of the American colony are
Swedes, ths majority of the ^rc/.:;
hold American citizenship. They tio
an extensive bui iuesa in pressed
flowers and olive wood articles, and
their store is ftdmlttadly the foremost
in the city, showing that aven In the
Orient the om-prieo principle can be
made to pay. An official at the Amer?
ican consulate said to me, when we
were discussing the colony, "I notice
that when anybody in the city wants
anything done he usually goes to the
American colony." Thus the American
trait of efficiency has come to be the
dominant characteristic of the com?
munity.
Like the ill-fated American colony
at Jaffa, this one was started on s
peculiarly religious basis. A Chicago
lawyer and his wife came out here ta
wait for the return of the Messiah.
They held extreme views on many sub?
jects, including the making of money.
Hard times eventually drove them to
work, and now, while the religious as?
pect of the colony has fallen very
much Into the background, it is a no?
table commercial success. There was
no marrying or giving In marriage in
the earlier years of the community,
and frequent and grave charges were
made against It. especially in the mat?
ter of free love. The members them?
selves, and their friends, have always
Cameli Laden With American Oil.
eral O. Bie Ravenaai. Thus it may
be teen how the American influence in
Turkey is working in humanitarian
and Inspirational ways.
Europe's Designs on Palestine.
In contrast with the altruistic la?
bors of America for Turkey and es?
pecially for the Holy Land, is the con?
duct of the great European powers,
who are playing a skillful game for
the ultimate control of this land, and
even making use of religious preju?
dices to that end. Russia fosters and
supports pilgrimages. As one instance
of her interest iu this direction, it
may be said that she maintains in Je?
rusalem a hospice where 10,0c0 pil?
grims may be entertained at one time.
She stands behind the Greek church,
and. equally Important, the Greek
church stands behind her. A wide?
spread ecclesiastical support Is of
more value out here than a warship.
France is no longer allied to fcfco
church, but just the same sne is the
protectress of f 11 Roman Catholic in?
terests. Nobody Is so blind as to sup?
pose this Interest represents religious
seal.
Both these nations, as well as Great
Britain also, seem to he hopelessly
outdistanced by Germany. The "ka'.ser
impartially supports Protestant and
Catholic, anl also goes out of his way
to throw elaborate, if artificial, buo
quets to Islam, all in the interest of
Germany's schemes here. The Ger- .
man name has been written large all
over Syria. Up In the famoas ruins
of Baalbeck, which Emperor William
visited in 1898, may be seen an incon?
gruous marble and inlaid motherof
pearl tablet, recording his sentiments j
of appreciation of the ruin and of Ab- j
dul Hamid?both ruins significantly |
coupled. On the tomb of Saladin the
Great, who drove the Crusaders from
Palestine, is still preserved a faded
wreath of flowers, laid there by tho
Christian emperor of whose eulogy
of Islam the Mohammedans have made
so much. A gold wreath, with a pen?
dant which is apparently a posthu?
mous decoration, was presented to the
tomb by William. But as the decora?
tion contains the figure of a cross, its
presence is counted sacrilege by the
more fanatical Moslems, and it is nec?
essary to keep two guards always on
duty In the tomb to prevent the for?
cible removal of the wreath.
The most conspicuous Object! In th*
landscape of the Holy Land, except
Mount Hermon, are the two towers, or
steeples, erected on the Mount of
olives by the Germans and Kussians.
These are the first objects that meet
the traveler's eye, from whatever di
rec'ion he comes. They may he seen
from far over tho Jordan; by them the
Holy City's site may be located from
Motui? Neho Local residents point to
certain features about these towers
which indicate that in time of war
they could be readily used for other
than religious purposes. Naturally,
the ohjc t <>f |hi pri sent activities of
the powers which havo ambitions of
their own for S\ria is to be ready for
all eventualities.
An American Communistic Experi?
ment.
The ?mlv communistic experiment of
which I nave knowledge that has no*
COBJS 'o an early and Inglorious end
Is Wl known as the American col
the city Thursday morning.
hotly denied these, and called them
slanders. At present the members !
marry, although all eat at the same
table and share the same life. They
seem uncommonly happy, and are In :
especially good repute with the na- I
tives, to whom they show hospitality, j
Certainly their life is in lovely con- |
trast to the bitter religious sectarian- j
ism here.
'Copyrifht, 1911, by Joseph B. Bowles.) j
Lighthouse Without a Keeper.
"What do you think of a perpetual ?
lighthouse, needing no keeper and yet |
as regular in its flashes of light as j
one maintained by the government?" ,
asked Albert I). Vail Wyek.
"This natural light never fails, and
that means much for navigation. It
is a volcano on the island of San Sal- \
vador. This volcanic lighthouse is
r.bout eight miles inland from the port j
of Acajutla. It is a veritable pillar
of cloud by day and the flash of its
light by night has been valuable to
mariners for years: It can be seen
far out at sea and a burst of flame
has gone upward every neven minutes
without the variation of a second for
many years.
"A lighthouse fee is collected of all
vessels that put in at the harbor near?
est the volcano and no skipper ob?
jects. He knows that the volcano Is
rrore reliable than the lighthouses
kept by human beings on other coasts
and the novelty of the light is worth
the price charged by the government."
The Jews in Palestine.
A wonderful result is following the
opening of Palestine to the Jews, by
proclamation of the Turkish constitu?
tion. The influx now in progress is
?normous. Jews are reckoned by tens
of thousands in Tiberias, Jaffa, Safed
and Haifa, while the Hebrew popula?
tion at Jerusalem now numbers at
least 100,000, or four-fifths of the
whole population. Thousands are
flocking from Persia and Russia. The
Jordan valley, which was the property
of the ex-sultan, Abdul Hamid, Is be?
ing bought up by Jewish syndicates.
So is the large and beautiful and fer?
tile plain of Esdraelon. The value of
land is already quadrupled. One day
the world will wake up and rub its
eyes with wonder when it discovers
what is going on.
To Honor Distinguished Woman.
Mme. Curie, codiscoverer with her
late husband of radium, has been In?
vited to come from Paris to America
next year for the purpose of taking
part in the International Chemical
congress, which is to be held in Wash?
ington, Last year the Chemical So?
ciety of America eh e ted Mme. Curie
an honprai j member.
Maybe Not.
"You ought to wear clothes, de?
clared the missionary, "Clothes are as
Oheap as dirt."
"Put are they as healthful?" de?
manded the South Sea Islander.
Room In Front.
Conductor Move forward there,
please).
Casey (who has moved along twice)
-Divii a bit furder! ?>i paid me nickel
C ride, not t' kape on walkln'.
Mi. H, is. Hair, assistant superln
BS* ryraz& yxs,-Yi.&ia& '
OLDEB
VA
A Land of Strange Contrasts Is Tur?
key in It? State of Transition?
Western Styles Crowding Out Old
Customs, Creating Incongruities.
By WILLIAM T. ELLIS.
Constantinople.?Standing on th*.
top of one of the ruined towers of
the Bosphorus, which Mohammed the
Conqueror, built in 1433, when he laid
siege to Constantinople, I studied the
strange city which lay extended be?
fore me as a magnificent panorama.
Viewed from a distance, Constanti?
nople is a city of wonderful contrasts,
it links the present with the past.
Before these stones were piled, form?
ing by the walls of the castle the
name of the Prophet, this was the cap?
ital of a Christian empire, and it still
bears the name of the first Christian
Roman Emperor. Many traces of its
ancient splendor abide. The Byzan?
tine glories may still be seen in part
by the tourist, who will also find evi?
dences of the Crusaders' activities
here where the two continents Im?
pinge.
rp these blue waters have sailed
throughout the centuries all kinds of
craft Now in sight of one are a few
Turkish warships, a small American
gun boat, the darting caiques of the
turbaned boatmen and freighters of
many nations, together with cumber?
some large native crafts with the
kinged masts. This gateway is so im?
portant to the world's peartT that by
international agreement no warships
may pass through it. European poli?
tics are more concerned with Turkish
affairs than with any other single
subject. So the marvelous rejuvena?
tion of the Ottoman empire Is of deep
Interest to civilization.
Paradoxes of Progress.
The present stage in Turkey's rapid
awaking is that of contrast. The
palaces along the Bosphorus, practical?
ly all of them owned, until the Revo?
lution, by Abdul Hamid, are rather
tawdry creations at best, but they are
in contrast with the miserable hovels
of the people, whose dwellings are
meager beyond the western compre?
hension. The word "home" as a
synonym for house can scarcely be
used here in Turkey.
Along the water front Is a palace
which was used by the Parliament,
until fire gutted it. Not far away is
the present palace of the reigning Sul?
tan, who is a mere shadow of the ab?
solutism of his deposed brother. In
terspersedt between palaces are the
residences of Pashas, and more or
less prosperous citizens, with the lat?
ticed windows of Ihe harems turner',
toward the water. There is the ro?
mance of the mysterious about these
dirty lattices?a western woman would
surely keep them clean?and about
the iron-barred tunnels that lead un?
der the houses to the water. One
cannot help speculating as to the
tragedies that have been enacted
along these shores. The system of
Seclusion for women that Islam or?
dains lu.s many disadvantages, one be?
ing that it requires a man to build a
high wall alongside of his house, to
keep bis neighbor from overlooking
his ha:*em.
Schools are beginning to come to
their own in Turkey, but the minaret
atill dominates the landscape, and
the wailing cry of the muezzin five
times a day is a familiar sound to all
parts of the city.
An Inadequate Fire Alarm System.
On yonder hill a cannon booms when?
ever there is a fire in one of the vil?
lages along the Bosphorus. The plan
in the city proper is for a watchman
on one of the great Are towers to re?
port to others who patrol the streets,
and these others go crying, in jackal
tonos that make one think of the
souls of the lost, the general vicinity
of the fire. Whosoever will may then
run to the scene of excitement and
share in the possible loot. A few
BiOdern lire engines have been intro?
duced Into the city, but it has been
my fortune chiefly to see the inade?
quate box ? arried on the shoulders of
runner? who are accustomed to get
to the \ - Bometlme before the whole
city hat b ?? a burned down, and hire
tbemreh1 out to the property own?
er? l ? \ e witnessed several con
nap attoos, one of them devastating
fifty 1 out OS.
V ? ? are no telephones in the city,
except I etween government offices, no
pub'ic I ghting system and no electric
cars. The reets are incredibly bad,
yet at one c< rner of the foreign quar?
ter of Pers I saw these three won?
ders: R Constantinople street being
widened, a steam roller at work, and
tl e cypress trees of the Moslem
graveyard being cut down' The ged
of change 1 as Certainly cone to Tur?
key'
The Cooiie and the Automobile.
That the old order is passing is
patent to everybody who knows how
to look at things In the large People
cannot have even ? form of constitu?
tional government, and yet treat oi
section of the community as mere
beasts of burden. The newspaper, a
moving picture show, the automobile
and the school book are forerunners
of the Inevitable new day. No* that
Constantinople has reckless red autoi
driven through Its narrow overcrowd?
ed streets, it is bound to have also a
chariot of progress of which this is
symbol,
There is not room on the same high
W83 Of Civilization for a twenty horse
OY ? r automobile and a man Strug
Made] the load of an ox. Con
tendanl of the Atlantic Coast Lint
stau? inople has had tie latter for
centuries, it is now gefing the form- \
er. '1 he incredible burdens which
these Koordlsh coolies or hamals bear
would seem like iietiou to the west- ,
e;D world. Frequently I have seen a j
man carrying a do/en chairs on his j
back; another bore at one time thirty
six of the big square oil-cans wi.ich '
the Stauda: d Oil Company has made
a not uncor: mon load. I saw a man j
with a Gri . d llapids roll top de?k and j
the office chair fastened to it, en his
back. A packing case is one of the
commonest ot loads. I saw a coolie
crossing the Galata bridge with a cof- j
fin on his back. Now if the awaking J
J of Turkey means am thing, It must
mean the emancipation of the com- j
inon people rroui Tacse Tl&c'enl ' Jr
' dens.
Big Hats and Moslem Veils.
The advent of the western styles
j involves unforeseen difficulties for an
I Oriental people. It is easy for the
Turk in baggy trousers and shoes that
slip off, to sit cross-legged on the
floor; when he dons tie, trousers and
patent leathers he must abandon this
fashion. The new furniture of mod?
ern style to which Turkey has be?
come ro devoted postulates home
somewhat after the idea of Europe
! or America. The new food and the
I new ways, all are insidiously under
I cutting the old order.
The dress of the women offers per
I haps the best illustration of this.
Most Moslem women H die along the
streets like water birds on land,
draped from head to heO in hideous
black ezars. Whether they are old or
young, homely or handsome, nobody
can tell. This custom involves mys?
teries which no mere man can solve.
How two heavily veiled women can
recognize each other on the street is
I beyond comprehension. Sometimes
the veils are getting perilously thin,
I in the case of the younger women
! and their wearers do not hesitate to
j stare at their pleasure on foreign
men.
j 3ecause she is robed so outlandish
ly on the street is no reason why the "
Moslem woman has not the eternal
j
ter say that, there ;s now or the Boj
phorus a new rlassi'V&tiOD of war
?hips?"first class, second class asd
secoud-hand." They tell u that the
Young Turks were afraid to trust
themselves to bring the r-hips from
Germany, so they had (if rmau o.Tw ers
man them until just outside the Dar
danslles, where they ran up the Tur?
kish tlag The German officer? de?
manded two hundred ai fifty ? t .c
and marks for their services and re?
fused to haul down the Turkish flas
until the sum was paid. Rumor has it
that one of the ships broke down en
route. At any rate, the Turkish gov?
ernment paid the money and the ships'
sailed uo the Bosphorus, streaming
bright new crescent flags behind them.|
That New Turkey has BOa&Stfcing 'o
learn in the way of naval administra
tion was evident from a little expe?
rience of my own. Late one night 1
had need to cross the Bosphorus in a
smaV st and the boatman ran close
to r f the new warships. Instead
of turning a searchlight on to us a
dozen men began to yell to warn us
off. For two or three minutes there
seemed to be a small riot on the ship,
but not once was there a light flashed
on us though the crew's fear was that
we might be Greeks bearing torpedos.
Of a piece with this bit of adminis?
tration was the naive remark of an
admiral the other day, that he was
obliged to surrender his place on a
naval board in order to go to the in?
terior to take charge of a military
barracks.
Cholera, Rat-Traps and Religion.
The cholera Is raging in Constanti?
nople at present and it affords an op?
portunity of observing the difference
between the old and the new. Lime
is sprinkled in the gutters by the city
but, for the most part, the people
who, bo far as the Moslem population
are concerned, are arrant fatalists,
say 'Kismet," and do not amend {.heir
unsanitary ways. That modern scien?
tific knowledge is beginning to perco?
late is shown by the lively sale of rat
traps which street venders display as
a sort of cholera cur s, explaining that
the cholera germs are carried by rats
_I
Constantinople and Its Beautiful Harbor.
feminine interest in dress. One of
their sisters came along the other day
wearing a "Merry Widow" hat and a
hobble skirt and as I passed I noticed
these queer veiled figures stop and
turn and look as long as the new
fashions were in sight. What will
happen to the economic system in
Turkey with its low scale of income
when husbands have to pay for Paris
millinery and their wives have a right
to wear them, is more than I can
project.
Immediately after the revolution
many Moslem women took off their
veils as they appeared in public
places. Such is the state of the Tur?
kish mind, nowever, to oe aescnned
by no other words better than by the
English phrase "absolutely rotten"?
that this could not endure.
A Turkish official himself explained
to me the reason why he could not
hope for the unveiling of the women
for a generation or two. The men of
today are utterly devoid of western
ideals concerning womanhood. What
western women, who understand the
language, have to endure as they
travel and live in Turkey, has never
yet been written. It needs a new
mind in the people before some of the
conditions that are the Kalt of civiliza?
tion eaa fully obtain in Turkey.
New Warships and Some Stories.
Almost bumping into the ancient na?
tive crafts of the Bosphorus are a
number of new warships of which Tur?
key Is very proud. The Turk loves
weapons, big and little. YVi lie the
order for disarmament has gone out,
it yet remains true that in the cities
as well as in the rural parti men
"tote a gun" as they say in Texas,
and carry a knife stuck into the vol?
uminous glidlo. 1 never traveled with
a pistol in my belt in plain sight un?
til I went out Into tho interior of
Turkey where every man has to be
his own policeman.
With this warlike disposition it is
natural that the 'lurks should be In
terested in their fleet. Their pride in
the two Warships recently purchased
from Germany la n >! woolly shared
h. the foroi ?? community. The lab
adquarters in rhu
?confusing the ruboaic plague with
cholera.
As is well known, there It a direct
relationship between cholera and
Islam, for Mecca is the seat of the
plague. All pilgrims bathe in a holy
well at Mecca which analysis has
shown, contains more germs than the
sewage of London. That holy water
is carried over the empire and dump?
ed into the village wells. A more dia?
bolical scheme for inoculating a na?
tion with disease can scarcely be con?
trived, yet the faithful will not per?
mit the government to touch this
sacred well.
Of course there Is modern medicine
in Turkey and by a new law nobody
is allowed to practice without a di?
ploma. None the less the faith In
charms abides and I have seen graves
and specially sacred trees, covered
with rags from the bodies of diseased
persons, who hope thereby to obtain
a cure in exactly the same fashion as
that prevailing in Japan and Corea.
Probably the most satisfactory
archaeological museum in the world
is that at Constantinople, with man;
priceless treasures. Yet this collec
tit n has been made by taking toll ot
the enterprise and learning of west?
ern nations and educational lnstitu
tions. All arcl aeologists at work in
the Turkish empire aro obliged to
give the government first choice of all
their finds. In sharp contrast With
this wonderful museum :s the fact
that all over Asia Minor priceless
srchaelogical relics in the way of in?
scriptions and statues, are to this day
being broken up and burned to make
lime for the villagers.
New Turkey must go a long way be?
fore the finds herself standing in iho
equality of fellowship with the wide
awake and enlightened nations of the
world.
(Copyright. Ml, by Joseph P.. BowtsoJ
A Conaiatert Change.
'My dentist has : :\ i \ o 1 is ? ?
fession and gene i
bualm *s '*
"1 s. a. BttU tr?
out of his patrons'