The Anderson daily intelligencer. (Anderson, S.C.) 1914-1915, November 26, 1914, Page PAGE FOUR, Image 4
WE ANDERSON INTELLIGENCER
FOUNDED AUGUST 1, 1840.
1S6 North Mala Stree t
ANDERSON, S. C
W. W. 8MOAK, Editor and Bas. Mgr
L. M. GLENN.("tty Editor
PHELPS SASSEEN, Advertising Mgr
T. B. GODFREY,_Circulation Mgr.
E. ADAMS, Telegraph Editor and
Foreman.
I>*nber ot Associated Press and
Receiving Complete Dally Tolegrspblc
Service.
Entered according to Act of Con
tr?es ss Second Class Mall Matter st
the PostofDce st Anderson, 9. O
TELEPHONES
Editorial and Business Office.821
Job Printing .093-L
SUBSCRIPTION BATES
Semi-weekly
One Vesr .I1.G0
Six Months .76
Dafly.
On? Year .15.00
Six. Months . .2.60
Three Months .... L25
The Intelligencer is delivered by
carriers in the city. If you fall to
get your naper regularly please notify
us. Opposite your natuo on tho
label of your' paper' Ia printed date to
whleh our paper ls paid. AH checks
?nd drafts OAnihtf be drawn to The
Anderson Intelligencer.
o o o o o o o o o 0 0 o i. > o o o o o o j
Mora Shoppings
Before X'rnas.
j The Weather.
South Carolina: Fair Thursday and
THOUGHT FOR THE DAT
This Is the best day th? worm, has
ever seen. Tomorrow will bo better.
-R. A; Campbell:
I .'I il I ? : I j
' WB ARE THANKFUL- ' ,,u ?
That the l*>rd God:: of ?ott?" is
pleased If we are but thankful. .
. a ...
Th?t we live in ?^e'Urilted States
itt America and not in warring Eu
,$Ptr*i . ;" ,fri i.ius -Wt?;: nDltf'A .
' ? O' ?? ..
< ' That the mon of no more nations
have been called upon to butcher
their brethren.
That the music of the church bells
fllu our eera this morning and not
tbs roaring of cannon.
? '?- .?o'' ? .
"Tiu?t ttf^^oitOr of T?i? Intelligencer
i?? City Attorney G. Cullen Sullivan
both have hables Ast euu laugh.
That Cher!"-ton hasn't any mere
"points of historical interest" about
lt than It shouts over already.
, That wo ltfh lu Anderson and not
Greenville or Spartanburg. to say
nothing of i Greenwood.
.-,<; rid.. Q
That thi'J?ipJie; Ridge railway Is
soon to b?$' a.',n>v?paasenger station
up town and. discard the old one.
That the set ol whiskers adorning
the chin ,o^_Gen. Carranza !B of his
own sprouting and doesn't be ion/', to
us.
That we are today eating turkey
and not endeavoring to shoot Turkey
foll ot holes with our battleships and
armies. ?
That the Mexican revolution hasn't
been settled and thus dried up our
only source of war news on this half
of the sphere.
" ?? O'
That in the recent campaign for the
cleaning up of the city the Interests
i of law and order were in Ute hands ot
G. Cullen Sullivan.
That wa don't live in tho same town
with a father in Georgia who mauled
'?AB san because ne "sopped" molasses
(on both side* ot his bread.
-9- . . .
: Th?t Browning was . inspired* to
4 write:
"God's in His heaven:
All's right with the world."
That styles in men's hats are so
varied this season we caa waar our
isst winter's lld without anybody de*
tectlag lt ie not of the new crop..
That Governor Binase cant blame
anybody else for hin record, for he
often boasted that *-' could novar be
. said any una but Blesse was gover
nor-while Blesse waa filling that ot
CAPT. WATKINS' HE PL Y
Captain ll. II. Watkins has another
broadside In this issue of The 'nielli
gencer, in reply to the last communi
cation of city Attorney Sullivan. In
this rom munica! ion lie replies to some
of the statements made by Mr. Sulli
van tn lils communication published
in The Intelligencer of last Sunday,
November 22. Capt. Watkins is a rogi
ca! writer, and makes some very plain
statements as lo the propriely of the
city attorney's accepting the commis
sion to investigate the legality of the
franchise. Ile also takes him to task
for the allusion to th? fact thal Capt.
Watkins ls no longer a resident of the
city, but has removed to the suburbs.
The principal Issue between these
gentlemen seems to be the prepara
tion of the "White Way" contract, and
their disagreement as to the few de
tails In this transaction. Dismissing
these details as of little Importance
in the main. Capt. Wutkins makes
this statement: "Whatever may have
been the facts of the preparation of
the contract, I was called upon to ap
prove it, and did approve it, and hav
ing done so I would not suffe; myself
to be employed as an attorney to de
ny or contest lt? validity even though
I did no! lu express terms, as I am
Informed he did, assure my client
that It was a valid contract."
('apt. Watkro? expre?ses the opin
ion that seems to be prevalent over
the city, mid accepted as. correct by
many of those who have discussed
the matter, that even if "the city could
avoid its agreement, I would hang
my head in shume' before even sug
gesting that 'My Town' is ready to
repudiate its contract. It would shame
mo to think that any citizen would
do so after he had sat quietly and al
lowed the company to spend immense
sums of money on the faith of the con
tract, and knowing that these expen
ditures had been accepted by the city,
and had added greatly to its upbuild
ing and convenience."
Capt. Watkins reverses tho posi
tions of the city and the company for
the sake of argument, and makes a
telling comparison. He argues that
it is a moral question as well as one
cf law, and that the city should stand
on as high ground as the -company
docs.,He concludes dds article with a
statement of his belief In the integ
rity and honesty of the* people of.
Anderson, and that they would not
stand for repudiation of their con
I tract. ...
T^r Jr*cl!lgoBcer believes that the
people really wish to know what ia
right in thia matter, and further ir the
city really has a good franchlso. With
this in-view The, Intelligencer propos
er to publish within the nest few.days'
the franehiss contracts' fw th<y white
way. end Tor the longer term. We
trust that the people will rend these
articles and decide tor themselves
whether or not the city has been
"dtped" and made a bad bargain.
Meanwhile the columns of thia paper
are open for a discussion of the mat
ter from any standpoint, and wo shall
be pleased to give space to rational
articles on any side of lt. Let thc
people think or it and discuss it j
rONVICTS TURNED OUT.
Governor Blease has again made a
wholeaale liberation of convicts. To
day la thanksgiving day, and he has
turned out over on? hundred
of the "citixens in stripes." This
will * make more than fourteen hun
dred he has extended clemency to
since h|\hjds bean^ governor, and al
most resulta in closing the doors'of
Ute State penlntetlary. Of course
there are tooee in every penal Insti
tut ?.-.n wSo skcsld uot "? ?here, and
when such cases ere, found, it is prop
er to extend clemency. Bot lt ls
hsrdly conceivable (hst there aro so
many unjustly convicted In South
Carolina, aa that the Governor should
Interfere in so many cases. "Justice
tempered with mercy" .is what we
need, and whst should be the policy
ot the State's chief executive.
A BIG EDITION
the Tuesday's edition of the Char
leston Evening Post consists of sixty
six pages, and ls commemorative of
the "new Charleston spirit." It is a
splendid example of the energy ot
this afternoon paper, and shows that
"Tho City by the Sea" ls very much
allte; and that she has a very much
alive newspsper in the Post. Bound
_,__? .?.._ *~L... _ ..?'?-- -. .
Oinn* oi mu maur wilt ITO {?UkUVU tn
the nubile libraries and reading rscrn
of the chambers fit commer?a in every
state ta the Union.
HE CANT BI BEAT
The report comes from Anderson
thst they will elect Will Lyona Sheriff
In Islg. As we hsve often usted you
cannot beat an Abbeville man. so if
he runs he will be elected.-Abbeville
Medium.
That the "dear peepul" will be do?
privad next sv.mmer ot the bi-annual
visitation of the stat* political cam
paign, circus, with Ita elevating and
profound Discussion ot great princt
Mes*afr jgovernjnunt ' ?
j
TURKEYS LAST THANKSGIVING
m ?j . iWv ? iirk^v tis of rnee, ......... ..... - . .
.. S L Sweet Mrd bf CraJiberry,
Of thee I sing,
I love thy neck: andwiiurs,
Legs, back and other things.
My heart with rapture sings,
On this glad day.
11 was treated by the city attorney in
CQ&toiti Watkins Retalies io ,thc n^?"*??-w to ^?rj^
? - - ^ ?g . ; ehlse, but if he was met with the
0/1*1/ /lLttOYnG?J SllltiVCltl ; ?arno spirit that characterizes tho city
___. t.. ? attorney's discussion with the editor
' j of The Intelligencer, there may be
TO THE EDIT0F? OF THE 1NTEUL.I- -the Southern Public Utilities Com- | found therein some justification cf the
GENCER: I pany. will not feel T that 1 deserve to ' impatient spirit with which Mr. Tay
1 Know that tho people of Anderson have my views di&coun'.ed by calling j lor ls so grlevlously charged,
and the readers of your paper are not attention to the fact that i am no Now as to the preparation of the
concerned with .controverse i of a per- longer a resident ?t the city.. It is white way contract, I stated that 1
ional nature. They are entitled, how- truo that for some'year,1 for reasons did not change a word of it so fax as
ever, to a knowledge bf tho pcrsonnl ?kat I think would be'approved by the I remembered.. I still do not. rcmem
conduct and motives of men .who deal -clty attorney, I have lived In the sub- t>er making or suggesting any change,
wtth public intereets in t?o far as ?""bs of tho city 'J* a; roode3t home Mr. Sullivan states thal I'did and if
these lntercstf are affected , thornby, which has not the advantage of water his recollection lp .positive in the mat
whether these be the conduct and mo- works and ha? to be lighted with ker- ter; i am willing to accept his stater
Uves of paid officials of the public or osene-lamps, but this fact hs?: not d~ meut as correct, anti * cheerfully apo!
Bf private persons and corporations, prived me of the pririTeg'e of contrib- ogise for any In justice whl?h I may
having dealing with tho public. I UT,NK as roy mean?'have permitted to have done him through lack of.mom,
?ave for some time thought that much tho puNte enterprise* ot the city. I ory or otherwise. . I hope he vyill now
of the prejudice that at times pre- am certainly glad t^t nfeither the etty be equally fra? k in saying that the
vhlls against corporatlopa ls due to attorney nor nnyjweAelhb; drew thc preparation of the contract was first
the tact that the people are not in- ,lne ?* expatri?t lori, in older tb deny confided to him alone and not to na lr
r?rmed of the corporate Bide of the me this privilege. Ttam glad, to know conjunction with each other; that the
question. The natural and proper re- that tho city attorney has given this representatives of the council and
luctance of business men to discuss humble non-resident the privilege Mr. Orr went to his office and gave
their affairs in the public press ls re- more than once o' expressing symp..- him all tho data for drawing the con
spoualble frequently for the, public tQr ior_h|s efforts itt behalf of good tract, end that *?? too* <*.<jwn th
ressafnittg ia ignorance of mattera up- SovernuicH? without any suggestion necessary data without my being pres
an which they should be Informed. I tDRt niv admiration was tho less ac- ent or without any suggestion that I
nave an ?biding faith in the fairness ceptable because I.did not live In the be called; that he was charged with
Bf the people upon all matters about City. ThcBe expressions wero In Uno tho bnslness of preparing the con
whlch they have full knowledge. Thtt? with *."?? friendship and admiration \ tract, and not I; that .he made the
has been forcibly Illustrated in tho which I have alwaya had. and still. complete draft of his proposal of the
natter of the franchise) ot the South- haye, for the city attorney. They , contract before coming to my office or
.rn Public Utilities Company, wblch wo*"? sincero, and were without any J conferring with me. I think he will
has been thought by many to be an suggestion that the efforts cf tho city J further agree that there was not the
exclusive forty year franchise. I attorney wore the less commendable j slightest argument over the terms of
hopo you will publish this document even, though tho very'undesirable cen- the contract or any attempt on my
for the Information of the public, who ditton* had been allowed to ' develop I part to change any portion of lt in
are entitled to know its terms, as well under hi? long administration oe ?uohjordcr to render lt more favorable to
Sa th? i?f?,? of the wh"e way cr;t?- attorney If ! wore *o ?on?w !??? ex-jibe Tv?p??>y ? S? sure that if ssy
tract. , ample IE int* ?l?ca*?ioa. I might aug-1 change* were made, they were made
?2 one ~-_7 cr ssciher. f.l^ ?p** ,w " regret that the public ?.??w ?o purpose ot clearing up doubt
rectly or through enterprises in ?o long deprived of the splendid- work ! fol evpressICM^?|n? ^^rs^r;v?r-f
which I have held stock, I have con- Which ho finally accomplished and Hamey to the-terms-of the contract so
tributed In some small degree to the that an earlier clean-up at the hands as tc render it more complete and
city's revenues ever since I nave of so efficient a prosecutor had not satisfactory to both parties. I am
"ceased to be a resident of the city'." saved the city the disgrace and crime kure that if I had.desired to make tra
it had not occurred to me, therefore, which ran riot so long. In this con- portant changes vitally affecting the
ihrt I waa committing ?le? majest?*' aectlon lt might not oe an unwarrant- Interest of my client tu a contract of
when after my name had been re- liberty to wonder at the absent- .such Importance, my writing would
peatedly brought into print In coonee- mindedness that led tho city attorney, have been plain enough to\be read
lion with a great public issue. I ad- without criticism and with due cern-'by a stenographer who ts very faroil
tl rea sed to you an article which the ptacency. to bask in the editor of The .'lar with my writing. Certainly no
city attorney was kind enough to Intelligencer's enthusiastic praises for! change waa made of sufficient Import
eharacterue as "dignified and moder- h,a work of reform, and equally to ?nee to Impress itself upon the m?m
ate In tone," calling attention to cer- wonder at the promptness with which ?dry of Mr. Orr or myself, since his
tain facts which I thought that the he exclaimed "Bah!" and. cried, "Say, recollection Coincides with my own.
public were entitled to knew and editor when did you hU the town any, Whatever may have been the facts of
Which were In danger of being ob- way?" when this editor dared to ex- the preparation or the contract, I was
.eared hy partisan r>4 personal dis- press honest views differing from called upon to approve it, and did ap
saaelon. I hope that cn maturer con- those of the city attorney on a great,prove lt. and having done so 1 would
ilderatioa the city attorney, to whoso public Issue and to ask pertinent aot suffer myself io be employed aa
lalary is contributed in a- small de- Questions to which lt might seem the ha attorney to deny or. contest ita va
ges* hy the taxes which I pay. and in tax payers are entitled to :.hBwer. I Jldity even though I did not In express
i mach larger msaoarerJry rey client, I do not know in weat spirit Hr. Taylor terms aa X am informed he did, a&
Thankworthy
Among other things, we are
thankful for a "store with a
conscience." A store where
the confidence of the public
has been merited and re
tained; a store where there
is a feeling of co-operation
between buyer and seller;
where there is more to busi
ness than the idea of barter
and trade.
* We are thankful for your ap
preciation of our spirit of
of service.
$t?f?rtl44^ Ca
- PH m mini _ J
"The Sion <6tth a Conda**
(Closed today-Open Friday. \
rafe my ellam that it was a valid contracts on behalf of his company.
:ontract. 1 ' ' and that it was equally the duty of
I have not bean:called upon to ex- the city and Ita attorney to.see to this
press any legal opinion .?w>n the va- on 1,3 behalf, ir Mr. Taylor, had act
li-lity of the franchis? grn.1ted the ed in good faith, s?pposlng he had
city, and I did not mean tq do so'in I such aut hority, but, aa al matter of
ray article. ? I will, say, nnweyer, that ?fact, did not have lt, ami his attorney
even it I believed1 that by reason of ! acted in like good faith. it t'oiuld seem
legal technicalities unknown. to eith-i.to be , thc -. duty now, .to...dP. ail In
er party and unsuggested by even the their power to induce the company's
able legal representative or the city, stockholders to stand by this agree
at the time of the adoption of the ment. Will the city and its ?attorney
franchise, the city could avoid its permit themselves to stand on less
agreement, I would hide my head in high ground? And ir Mr. Taylor's
Bhame before even suggesting that stockholders had stood by and aliow
"My Town" is ready to repudiate its "ed him to sign contracts with the city
contract It would shame me to on their behalt and In carrying out
think that any citizen would do BO ? t?1? agreement the city had incurred
after he had sat quiet and allowed the j great expense in consequence thereof,
company to spend immense sums of could these stockholders now, with
money on the faith of the contract, proper self respect, repudiate the con
and knowing that these expenditures tract? Suppose the position as to the
had been accepted by the city and had white way had been reverse-!; snp
Qdded greatly to its upbuilding and P0?? the <"lty had spent ten thr.ua:
convenience. I am informed that the dollars in erecting it under a contract
city attorney spent much tithe in the | with the Utilities Company to furnish
(dody, of the franchise question before tbe electrical ourrent for Its Illumina
it* adoption. Indeed. I am told that l'on; and suppose there Were no oth
BO~niucfi time'was consumed'that the et* source from- which th?B- current
city council vqted in addition to his could be obtained, and that the ir
regular salary an. extra fee or |r>00 vestment were made worthless by a
for 'services, rendered in ' connection failure of the company to furnish the
with the franchise matter and other light;-What would be thought of Mr.
Interests of the city. If this be true Taylor or hlr attorney or any of lils
md not thf council .whlctt"pgld^he:feei'iutoekholder8; >vh,o, having waited un
anfljjven the Utttnlfei Cordpnnt.;whose- til? Imotley,.. *vvu? exnenued. should
take?^ coiKributca^vWefcor^ofh hove -tbeSs.ljfte\amlbnr'to\re|JUdlate the ccn
the right to expect that the city at- tract on the ground that the offl<
torney would both know and advise of .acting for the company had escet^jl
any. 1'h?g*Hf?. ?H. jfteLr . qrt?p.n T. .3?? -..gd. tho^ authority conferred by their
not. know .whether- extra compensation 1 hy-laws T The utilities Company 'baa
has been provided, or ?ill be provided not only, spent the" money for ""the
for'thO'weeks of labor'which the city white way, but it has spent approxi
httorney hes spent,in-arriving at his mately," ?sp.<10p lb 'extending ils water
present opinion., but it would seem niainB and "living better fire protec
jast, Jf. he ls now giving a correct tion ; lt has made reductions in rates
opinion he should certainly receive as that Its. written contract did not re
large extra compensation as he re- lulre.r-had' thia waa done without a
ceived for supervising a work which thought or suggestion thst Mr. Tay
b* now declares to be illegal. 'or's verbal promise to do so was in
Acother matter, and I will close valid because not in writing. Would
this already long article. In tbe final ?t not be unjust to thc reputation of
paragraph ' of his ', communication ht our city to suggest that we would fix
launches against Mr. Taylor and my- ior ourselves a less exalted standard
?.If thin char?;?! "I prsaUme that I than that demanded of this company?
these gentlemen do not mean to per- lt may be that our people are in favor
mit the people of Anderson to decide of repudiation, but I do not believe
this matter by vote at an election, lr lt and no one can make me believe
Intend to keep them from voting on 't of "My Town" until it has been
it If in their power to prevent" proved. I do not believe that upon
Really. I had supposed that the ques- mature consideration tho city coali
tion of submitting laces to a vote c" would insist upon their recent res
of the people was the perogailr? ot elution because I do not believe that
their representatives on the city coun- U would take such action on the city's
ell, and ntit bf non-residents like my- contract after it had considered both
self who enjoy the distinction of "lax- a,rtes of the question. I do not believe
allon without representation." Tho that our people, who love the city,
suggestion is more adroit than well who have gloried in its' past,'anc w
founded; it ts intended to suggest td lork forward with confident hone in
the1 people that Mr. Taylor and t are its future; Will penrilt it'l? be 'said
denying them a substantial right No that Andersen stands 'fop repudiation.
3?0 's????i?? Le misled' by such'argo- * heiiovu'that the people ' wish the"
meat A ls a? absurd as If one should vexed question laid to rest, and wish
suggest to tho stockholders cf the to be permuted to-'Jm?' nands in the
Southern Public ' Utilities ' Company work of fuUire progress. And I will
that the city council of Anderson abd n?t bellevo otherwise of the people
its attorney were responsible for whom I have known, and loved and
their not voting on the question, trusted, and worked with for1 the last
What IS the difference? Mi. Sullivan quarter of a century, until they speak
knows that it was Mr. Taylor's duty 'or themselves and say I am mist "t?n.
and that of bia attorney to soe to it ' H. H. WATK"
that he bad authority to sign these November 25. .1914.
- - |
n
it
.: /; I i ;
Reach" Foot Balls
$1.00 to $5.00
"Reach" Punching Bags
ANKLE AND WRIST SUPPORTERS
Gifts that wotild picase any boy. THE REACH trademark guar
ta te es sattsfaclK/u wad perfect goods, .
Sullivan Hardware Co*
Anderson, S. C.', Belton, S. C., Greenvil;e,: S. C.