University of South Carolina Libraries
THE OPINION "Of tbe Hm. Judge Cbeves. On the Act to amend the <3d Section of - the ioth article of the Constitution.^ By ihejthird section of the tenth article of the jCctiiHiajiio&LQjLthis state It M.decfircd, tfiat *' at the Conclusion of thexircuits, the Jud ges shall meet and rit at Columbia, foe the^prpose of Rearing and de termining ajl motions which ^ may be made for ncw< trials and in ar rest of judgment, and such points of law at may be submitted to them. From Columbia tSey snail gfoceed to Charleston, ?nd there Jaeat . and determine^ such motions for new trials. aad in arrest of judgment, r and^sucli points of law as may be 'submitted to them." ^ ? . At the meeting of the Legtsla , 1 /.aire in 1815, it -was proposed, ind ff -><at its meeting in 18 16, it was final- | ly agreed, according to the pr? * visions of the Constitution, to a II- mend .the third section of the temh ?pSttidle thereof, so as as fol . ? shallv at such* times ? - lad a&ces &r isball be prtscribti'by ' 0{t ?f Ligtiiaua* <>f /bt*d*qumm ? and -sit 'tor the purpose - of hearing iningalhmottons for new in .arrest of judgment, ar^.1 sue h points of$& as may be sub This -amend went '-?ftto* CeiiTsri -nirtpttsiijwS' finally ratified W W-forra ot*n ac^^fthe-ixgislature on the-; ?9<h day-W'dpCefaber, 1816. ? But tbe vote by which the Legisla tu? Anally agreed to the amend ment most nttfissarily have been ta'-l ?ken .before this fatification. r / ?n Itt of Assembly, ratified F it i?, enaqjpth 1/ vi j'jjfc/ W T? Constitutional Court at the caftdu rtWwiiofthtS spring??fctiHs in Colum ' bia, the J udge??shall & soo^W Criminal cases shall ^disposed or>! adjourn and proceed to Charleston, , and, there continued sit from day utuil ll* day of July, ' tinlewthe 'cases* are sooner dispo kj of." m <*&?(** LchJM heatirtJM Under this amendment of the Item iW' sembly, it is ther theju I. stitU^n?\. sTOTprcstnt C''*rhi* niw.tioii divides TL his question aivtdc* l^^w4rhef under | culir tetrhs of the act dL Wythe court can be held ? ad. Whether under the amend ment of the Constitution this act is constitutional ? If it be determined I to be unconstitutional, then oh the same grounds the provisions of the sftial <M in arrest der such restrict) ders ,of*oum?'?/rUrttfcr this pr6 Vission, the Jmlges conttiiWr to meet in Charleston, (as in * Battle,) and (here heard all such motions ce*cons from rife'^diifti zsmtAkE* courts ? conceiw. for new trials in arrest of judgment and points of law, as originated there, and ife tb? Circuit Courts. Soon after, pn the present constitution of the^tate was fraiDcd and adopted and contained in ic the es met at Columbia at the, conclusion of the circuits/Jwjt'dt GHarfeston they conttnitecfTOliear and determine motions for new tri als, &c. as before. I am uncertain ? % w whether motions originating in the Circuit Court* were helard in Char- 1 leston or not ; though under the act . of 1789, (Grimkc,* 4.70 J one Judge was em powered to hoki the court : in:'. Charleston i yet it was usually, j if not always held* By la majority of thie Judges. In these statements ! may not be precisely accurate ; but ; I am substantially so, and ' suffici ently so' for the purposes , of this j 'argument. ?; By the act of 1798 (4 Fayj^ 240) Courts of Sessions and Cottt- , mon Pleas, invested with the same powers as the Citfcuir Courts be fore mentioned, were* established in the* several judicial districts of the state, and ?&? courts which * previously existed were abwjL__ , (2 Faust, 240) The ftc*ty crea ted courts were to t>e h?!d bv tpe or more Judges. The court in' Charleston which isr we have seen, hid till tfeis. period 'exercised, in some sort, the aujhcmty diction of a Court in Bank, was di gested thereof by this act, and wgs put on a footing with rheicoUlrtfw the. other, districts of tbeyttstnJ T"L ^ r J _ - - . Cl 1 ? v ? ' ? . J* I ffy to ex of these tribtir tive which Jias them, viz.; "The? 'Court of appeals^*' not constituted as such, seenj by the Const itu jjpfl any law, and have no sc identity from the Circuit , i j nor are their leading func tions, or indeed any of them of which I am aware, of an appelate character. Motions for new trials rTlT'M Court ofj- Appeal distinct tribunals. MterfioitiOnaP ;tfcated ?? as ftf^bjcidcn^ rtiWViot I thihk t! not suffer, on any account, the dr lay of a term in criminal eases. If? however, the Judges cannot now and : arrest: of jiiJ.j/.nent are, ac - cording to the proper consiitn:;o;i of our courts, co be nule the tribunals In whicU tho^e inals are had and in which those judg .mz&ty arc tu be entered up. If then the meet sng-^f 4k- Judges, at Columbia, be a & *re coikfcncration of the ^circuit *fiinct ions and juris dictttm,- at that pfctre, of ^tfte-cotirts whose business i&. rtt urnaqlc t hcrc.^ for* revision \ apd their meeting in Cfaa f%on, a like -.concentration tnere of die functions and juii<dic tion of thjC remaining courts, th^ tribunals whicll j( X. c^s^'l!c ac these pW?T Ifesjpecrivcly arc ^per fectly^ separate and distinct. 1 he Constitution as it srtjpd before a mcndmcntdo<;snot direg. ihe judges to adjourn , by way of ccnnr>uancey to mectat Chajri^iton? It dircc|;s thenito meet at CAmibia and when they have done thei||pusincs^there, to proceed ^^fKaVff&ori ana th^rc which confusion ai*d * mufcbnception may have arisen) SffmBDb ^fec "ToUnid1 in the Constitution. The courts, Sn^tb' we mityye*} l$Mnr ift tobedfc* WhBffio ;? custom^ basineiai' ^ Wtent tribunals* rheir own ckrks aether mccr*l each ? distin^V ^graphical, :tibo, aodVi%t?psc.u> c I^twn^~tj&i?%grt0n this one J and I the more wilhofcly lcve.it be-. cause ! thipk n>oifc itecd nut-belaid rid to establish this Mcparate idsouvv, he cause* as I understand. pound ?pt hdw. ,*Mw ^feafl *V %?T,u?n . thence (ih#l! . Jj >?V '<. .?Ucg?d ? .eototatioo of 1; at; Columbia, ,tb9t?h?ir, ft* on ih$ir i " the Judges roe**' at a Ma I ? t WWt it ormpes WHtrtWfPH, there ibonaU are sc Jtidges had /consider- v nd tha act *wm r A> i*. Crock- 4 cWain* <very irirtnUtjn of the ?h6ti1d meet* rtnO^uhi'.t ifm t tfifn time . factke, und^r Constitution, e of the afct, J** it. This (4 Jfdmitted that S -- - -*? - ^ a . a t - ? a M. . -. ? a ^ a . . . a twentlon Wcfds miglit have a ?fi : put upon themt JsflilwVn^nifofi is most obviously in accordance wilt* Jhr wttch' I contend. A old ^course of pf.cftW, , - tVlms re^stablistyerfby ' ? ?Wh Kef ft established by the^Don ihe Conititmional 'C06rt? for of the state hadbt cn held. Was r _ the intentiotr of the Legislature* ithoot one wefrd df grao*^ or apology,' when words are of attch easy command, tc* other h.iTof bound to deem mot e reverentlHtoUnila^ tive Wisdom, impartialit