University of South Carolina Libraries
THE VERNFR EARLE CONTROVERSY. SENATOR EARLE MAKE8 STATEMENT AND GIVES THE RECORD. [The following artiole waa handed to us on December 2Gtb, but owing to the crowded condition of our col umns we were unable to handlo tbe copy for our issue of last week.] Editors of The Keoweo Courier : My attention has been oalled to an artiole in your last issue by Repre sentative E. E. Vernor. However muoh we may regret a controversy between officials, who should aot in harmony for tho people of Oconee county, it become* necessary for me to controvert some statements made in that artiole. In the tirst place, he states that he accused me of passing certain bills in the Senate which I denied. I desire to state frankly that I have at no time and in no place denied the pass age through the Senate of two bills, one of whioh became a law, enlarg ing the powers of the Oconee Water, Light and Power Company. If Mr. Verner has ever accused mo of pass ing any otbor bills that be did not approve of I do not know of it ; and, in fact, I never know that he was opposed to the bills above mentioned until after bo had opened his cam paign for the Legislature last sum mer. During tho session of tho General Assembly of 1905 James Thompson, who seemed to bo the chief ono in terested in tho Oconee Water, Light and Power Company, wrote me and asked if I could not securo for the said company tho right of condemna tion by a bill similar to that which was then pending before the Legis lature enlarging the powers of tho Parr Shoals Power Company. This was during tho latter part of tho ses sion, and I had no time to confer if anything was done along this line, so I wont to Solicitor Johnson and asked that a bill be drawn in accord ance with tho request of Mr. Thomp son. As soon as possible I intro duced this bill and had it printed, but it did not meet my approval and I amended it in quito a number of particulars before it left the Senate. Some of the amendments, however, wore overlooked by thc clerk in writing thom into the bill, and I re quested Mr. Vernor to make certain amendments in the House because of this fact. Mr. Verner afterwards carno to mo in the Senate, and I gave him another copy of the bill with tho amendments which I desired written in that copy and asked him to see that they were incorporated in the bill in the House. The bill passed tho House and became a law. I would be glad if the copy of the bill could bo found, beoauso I know that the amendments, or certain amend ments which I proposed, would be found written therein in my own hand writing. I do not care to go around and make loose statements as to what certain things aro when it is easier to toll tho pi.un truth as it is. I give below the bill itself : "An Aot to Ratify and Confirm the Charter of The Oconee Water, Light and Power Company, Grant ed by the Secretary of State on the Second Day of December, 1904, and to Confer Additional Powers on Said ?Company. "Whereas, tho Secretary of State, on the second day of December, 1904, upon compliance by tho corpo rators with tho requirements of law regulating the formation of corpora tions, including full payment of char ter fees fixed by law, issued a certifi cate of incorporation to The Oconee Wator, Light and Power Company, creating it a corporation for certain purposes designated and specified therein ; and, whereas, it is desirable to ratify tho same and to grant addi tional powers ; thorofore, "Soction 1. Bo it enacted by tho General Assembly of the State of South Carolina (a Concurrent Reso lution having passed each House by a two-thirds votejnllowing the intro duction of this bill), That tho said charter grantedgby the Seoretary of State to The Oconee Water, Light and Power Company, on the second day of December, 1904, be, and tho same is hereby, ratified, confirmed and made valid to the same extent as if the same had been granted to said The Ooonee Water, Light and Power Company I directly by the General Assembly of the Stato of South Carolina. "Seo. 2. That the right, power and privilege to construct and maintain a dam or dams in and aoross Little River, at High Falls and on Conne ross Creek, at or near J. D. Isbell's, in Goonoo county, be, and the same is hereby granted to and conferred upon The Ooonee Water, Light and Power Company, together with the right, powei and privilege to acquire by purchase or by condemnation pro ceedings all lands which may bu nee? eBsary for rights of way for tho con struction and maintenance of wires, pipes or other contrivances for the transmission of water, light and power, or that may be neoessary in tho construction and maintenance of wire or other contrivances tor the transmission of power under the power and authority conferred by this aot : Provided, There shall be provided suitable fishways and the fore-bay and tail-races shall be pro tected by suitable wire gauze of not larger than one-half (\) inch meshes, so as to prevent fish going into the water wheels. "Seo. 3. That the power of con demnation of lan::;, abject to bc over flowed shall be exercised in the samo manner as now provided by tue 'awe of this State for the condemnation of lands for railway, canal and turn pike purposes. "Sec. 4. That the said power com pany shall have tho right and power to operate ns well as to build and erect cotton and other mills, and to engage in the manufacture and sale of cotton goods and other goods. ?^"Sec. 5. That this net and said charter shall remain of force until amended or repealed by tho General Assembly of tho Stato. "Approved tho 22d day of Febru ary, A. D. 1005." This bill passed with Mr. Verner's consent as above stated, and there can be no reason to object to the powers therein conferred, because the samo powers conferred upon this company by this bill are conferrod upon .ail road, telegraph and tele phone companies and others to con demn rights of way for public use, and that is all that this bill seeks to give. It will bo observed that the condemnation proceedings must bo tho samo as those for railways, etc., and that is not dono by two or three friends picked up in the community. It must be lone by a jury of twelve men empanoled by the Clerk of the Court, and tho compensation, which is fixed by them, must be paid before the right of way can bo used. It might be well to state in this con nection that our Constitution forbids the taking of private property for any other than a public uso. There fore the use which the right of way has to be put must be a public use, such as water for tho community or town or lights for the town. In 1906 Mr. Thompson informed mo that they had been unable to ac complish anything in the way of douelopmont, and that they had cer tain property rights at a point on Keowec river and nttt point on Whitewater river, and asked me to no arae^d the Act of 1905 as to allow this company to develop powe.- at these points if desired. I had the Act of 1905 copied, inserting these two places on Keowee and White water rivers. There was no other change in the bill, and it stood ex actly as it reads above. This last bill passed the Senate and was in the House several days when Mr. Lof ton, of Charleston, informed mo that tho committeo had left it to him to act upon this bill, and asked mo to appear before tho committee at a certain hour. On tho Bame after noon tho Railroad Committee, of which I was a member, had a very important meeting, and I was obliged to attend it until after tho hour of adjournment of Mr. Lofton's com mittee. When I went to the com mitteo room I found that they had adjourned. I spoke to Mr. Lofton afterwards about this bill, and he said that tho committee had still loft it with him to aot upon the bill, and asked me if I still cared to appear before thc committeo, and I informed him that my duties in the Senate demanded my constant attention and I did not think I would be able to appear before the committee, and I told him if the committee saw pro per to report the bill unfavorably it was all right with me ; that I had done my part. I noticed, the next morning, by tho Journal of the House, that the bill had been unfavorably reported and rejected. I recall the fact that Mr. Vernor was reported unweii, and in company with Mr. Sheldon, I called opon him at his room at the boarding honse, bat I am certain that no business matter connected with legislation was mentioned at that time. I reoall further that Mr. Vernor vgas reported unwell about the last days of the ses* sion, and Mr. Sheldon having already gone home indisposed, I called upon Mr. Verner at bis room to see him and see if I could do anything for bim. At this time nothing was men tioned with reference to the bill above mentioned, as the bill had been tabled and rejected several days pre vious. I do not know what confer ence or consultation Mr. Verner may have had with any ot'.era, and that does not in any way vr euit the issue. I leave it to the peor who heard him in the oampaign tu who have read the artiole ref erre . to to recon cile his statements if it is possible to do so. They do not appear to be at all consonant. Mr. Thompson's statement follows. Respectfully, J. R. Earle. December 24, 1906. James Thompson Corroborates. Senator Earle has asked mo with reference to certain bills enlarging the powers of The Ooonee Water, Light and Power Company. I will state that I wrote Mr. Karlo and asked him to got a bill through the General Assembly giving this company certain powers of condem nation, etc., during the sessiou of tho General Assembly of 1905. Mr. Earle sont me a copy of tho bill as amended by him. This bill is the same as I lind printed in the Acts of the General Assembly, 1905. Just a few days before Mr. Earle went to Columbia to attend the session of 1906, I asked bim to insert a point on Keowee aud a point on White water rivers in the Act of 1905. A few days aftor the General Assembly convened Mr. Earle sent me a copy of the bill amended as I had re quested, to wit : Mentioning two places ?on Keowee and Whitewater rivers. There wns no other change in the bill as printed in the Acts of 1905. I would Uko to state that the rea son I asked Senator Earle in regard to the additional powers for our company, that I noticed where the Legislature was giving some to other companied in different parts of the State, and that had I been able to accomplish at that time what wo had set out to do, would have meant about a one-half million dollar in vestment in Oconee county by Northern capitalists. Jas. Thompson December 24, 1906. inp ensued, soil Impoverished soil, like impov erished blood, needs a proper ertilizer. A chemist by analyz ng tlie soil can tell you what ertilizer to use for different products. If your blood is impoverished /our doctor will tell you what rou need to fertilize it and give t the rich, red corpuscles that i re lacking in it. It may be you leed a tonic, but more likely you iced a concentrated fat food, uid fat \A tho element lacking ii your system. There is no fat food that is io easily digested and assimi uted as Scott's Emulsion of Cod Liver Oil It will nourish and strengthen he body when milk and cream ail to do it. Scott's Emulsion M always the same; always >alatable and always beneficial vhere the body is wasting from my cause, either in children >r adults. We will tend you m ?ample tree. Bo suro that this pic ture in tho form of a label is on tho wrapper of every bottle of Emul sion you buy. SCOTT ft BOWNE CHEMISTS m toan St., )few Tort 50c. and $1.00. AU Druggists. ? TRIP TO EUROPE LEHER NO IO. Luceme, Aug. ll, 1906.-Three months to-day since I left home. Two months from to-day we will land in New York, if nothing hap pens. I have received two letters from you sinoe I got here, and it is needless to say how much I enjoyed them. We were unable to stop at the best hotel here, because ' all the rooms had been engaged for weeks ahead, but I am really very glad, for this is a very good house. It is juBt full of Amerioans, and they all seem to be nice people. We are muoh like a big family. We have been here nearly ten days and will probably remain a few days longer. Then we will move on to Interlaken. I have enjoyed every minute of roy stay here and only, wish we could stay a couple of weeks longer. You oan't imagine what a beautiful pince this is. The town is built right along the edge of the lake, with the most beautiful shady walks all along the water's edge. Tbe mountains rise right straight up, that is, they seem to, and you oan see plenty of snow np near their HU ?nm i ts. They are always draped with olouds, which reminds me very much of a girl in a ball dress. Our hotel is right on tbe lake and commands a fine view of all tbo mountains, as well as the lake itself, and you havo a very beautiful pic ture to look at all tho time. Here wo al?o havo a finn breezo and de lightful climate. Everything is chook full bere, and we see continually people trying everywhere to get lodging. We have also a fine walk along the lakeside, shaded with fine horse chestnut trees, and in the evening Bverybody strolls along this walk. It's quite a pleasure to watoh all the women, in evening dress, and most >f the men in tuxedos. We have been in swimming nearly every day siuce coming here, but I don't fanoy that very much. I went to a ball hero a Pew uighta ago-carried Miss Her ald, of New York-and had a very nice time, indeed. I met some girls from Bridgeport, Conn., whom [ had met in Berlin, and they seemed about aa glad to meet mo as I was to neet them. We all bad a good Lime. I saw some of the finest Jresses I over looked at. I ainu sat with satisfaction before rhorwaldsen'8 "Lion of Lucerne," iodicated to the Swies Guard, 786 of (vhom fell August 10, 1792, defend ng the royal family of Louis XVI rom a revolutionary mob. The pos ture of the colossal body lying across ,he shield, marked with the fleur de is, the broken spear, the prone, out stretched paw and the wonderful expression of almost human feeling, ire pathetic. Tho figure is 28x18 eet and was exeooted by Ahorn, a iculptor of Constance, after the du lign of tbe great Danish artist. It s out from the solid rock. We took a trip to the top of Mt. :tigi the other day and thought it ip-top, only it was real cold. From here we bad a magnificent view for ibout twenty-five miles all around. )n one side you have mountains as ar as the eye can see and lots of hem covered with August un. v, md on the other you have tho lake iway down below, so that it looks ike a little basin of water, and Lu serne's big hotels look like a villago >f ant hills. While up there I got ome Edelweiss and am sending you \ spray, which I hopo|will be in good ?ondition when you get it. Interlaken-Letter No. 11. Interlaken, ?Aug. 18, 1906.-We srrived here yesterday and havo >oen near to freezing. This is not tear as fashionable a resort as Lu cerne, but I think the sceu. -y is nuoh finer. We are right among 'cry high mountains and snow can .e seen over most of them.v Snow ell on the|?mountains last night and 0-day, while here we have been laving a very cold rain, just as we iave at home in February. I enjoyed my trip from Lucerne sore veryl muoh, for these little Iwiss trains climb mountains like eritable goats and we have all indu of beautiful scenery along the /ay. It all would remind you very auch of a picture machine-one aoment you are looking down on a seautiful little lake sud valley, with irobably a little Swiss village ?nd eautiful orchards, then you pass brough a tunnel and when you come oat see nothing bat mo ant nins with high peaks all covered over with clouds, and then another little valley comes iuto view. At oar different stops along the way I bought a few cards and sent you, which I hope you have received. While in Zurich I met two of the nicest boys I ever knew. They wore from New Jersey, and we came on to Lucerne together and stopped at the same httel. We were together about two weeks. They were very kind to Mr. H. and myself. I was siok for a couple of days while at Lucerne and they took Mr. H. right off my hands, had him go on all sorts of trips with them, etc., whioh gave me a chanco to rest quietly at the hotel until I had recuperated. You know people on a trip like this get Jp> know each other mach qaioker tli an they do at home, and I shall always remember this part of the trip as the best. They left us a few days ago and I certainly miss them. One who lives in Hoboken has made me promise to spend a wock with bim when we return. I guess we will bo here for proba bly four or five days, when we will move ott tu Lausanne and Geneva. We will get to Paris later than we expected. I am not at all disap pointed, however, and would rather spend a week more hero and a week less in Paris, for I don't care so much for cities and have seen enough of them. Geneva-Letter No. 12. Geneva, Aug. 27, 1906.-It will be about a week before I got my Paris mail, so I am going to write you now. We moved from Interlaken to Bern and Lausanne, as I guess you know by the cards I sent you. Bern was v?ry warm and we stayed there only a couple of days. Lausanne was also warm, but so far we havo found Geneva very pleasant. Lake Geneva is not near as pretty as Lu cerne, as there are no high moun tains bordering it, but wo have a good view of some in the distanoe, among them being Mount Blanc. This is a great hotel and very fashionable, with a beautiful garden in front and a good orchestra to play. While at Interlaken I got a pic turo of Castle Chilton and have sent it to you. Hope you will like it. If you want anything special from Lon don you had bettor write as soon as possible, provided it doesn't cost too much. Geneva is not nt all a pretty town, but we have a delightful breeze most of the time. This town certainly has fine jewelry stores. I only wish I had the money to buy a Swiss watch, but of course I can't.. Kow to Avoid Appendicitis. Moat victims of appendicitis are those who are habitually constipated. Orino Laxative Fruit Syrup oures ohronic con stipation by stimulating the liver and bowels and restores the natural action of tbe bowels. Orino Laxative Fruit Syrup does no*- nauseate or, gripe and is mild ?nd pleasant to take. Refuse substi tutes. Dr. J. W. Boll. The Daughters of the Confederacy bave given out a contraot for the re production at the Jamestown Expo sition of Beauvoir, tbe residence of Jefferson Davis, at Gnlfport, Miss. A Square Deal Is assured you when yon buy one of Dr. Pierce's family medicines-for all tlu^ in gredients entering Into them ure printed on tho bottle-wrappors and their formula aro attested under oath as hoing complete and correct. You know just what you ure paying for and that tho Ingredients urn gathered from Naturo'a laboratory, beliiK selected from the most, valuable native ' medicinal roots found growing In our 1 American forests and whilo potent to euro , aro perfectly harmless even to tho most dollcato women and chlldron. Not a drop of alcohol enters into their composition. A much hotter agont is used both for ex tracting and preserving tho modlclnul principles used In them, viz.-puro triplo- i refined glycerine. This ? trent possesses' ? Intrinsic medicinal properties of Its own, hoing a most vaiuablo anti-septic and anti- 1 ferment, nutritive and soothing domul- < cont, A i (?1 .verine plays an Important part In i Dr. Plorco's Golden Medical DIscovory In j the enro of indigestion, dyspopsla and j woak stomach, uttondod by sour risings, heart-burn, foul brouth, coated tongue, poor appetite, gnawing fooling in stom ach, biliousness and Vclndrea derange ments of the stomach, liver and bowels. Resides curing all tho above distressing ailments, tim "(leiden Medical Discovery" Is a speedie, for all diseases of tho mucous - membranes, as catarrh, whether of the nasal passages or of tho stomach, bowels I or pa iv ie organs. Evon In Its ulcerativo . stage? lt will yield to this sovereign rem- 1 Fvly If Its uso be persevered in. In Chronic Catarrh of tho Nasal passages, lt Is well, ' whilo taking the "Golden Medical Dis- < jovery " for tho necessary constitutional treatment, to cleanse tho passages freely , two or three times a day with Dr. Sago's . Catarrh Remedy. This thorough course 1 )t treatment generally oures the worst < sises. In coughs and hoarseness canned by bron- < shlal, (liront and lung affoctlons, exoopt con ni m pt ton In tts advanced stages, tlie "<?eldon ] Medical DIscovory " u a moat efficient rem }dy, eapoclally in thoso obstinate hang-on 1 ?on i caused hy Irritation and congestion of tho bronchial mucous membranes. Th? "bis- 1 ?IIVITV " is not so good foi acute coughs axla ng from sudden colds, nor mu?t lt be ex pected to euro consumption in Its advanced doges-no medicine will do that-but for all the obstinate, chronic coughs, wh?r.h, If neg lected, or badly treated, lend up to consump tion, it ls tho best medicino that can bo taken. MRS. WW? IM BADLY 111. THROWN FROM MUTHERN TRAIN NEAR MADISON CHRISTMA8 EVENING. 4 'reA The Atlanta Georgian of Decem ber 27 oontained the following arti cle, which will he read with deep regret my the many Oooneo friends of Mrs. Fred W. Auld, of Elberton, Ga., who, before marriage, was Miss Lizzie Vernor, of Retreat : "After being thrown from a South ern railway train two miles beyond Madison, S. C., and lying for over two hours in the freezing weather in an unoonsuious condition, Mrs. Frj W. Auld, of Elberton, is now ly! in the Presbyterian Hospital in Al lanta, suffering from outs, bruises and a fraotured arm, and at present the surgeons oannot Bay whether or not she will live. uMrs. Auld and her husband were returning to their home Tuesday, after visiting friends in Westminster, and when near Madison Mrs. Auld started from the uoaoh in whioh she and her husband were riding for an other coach to see her brother. "While on the platform between the two cars, a lurch of the train threw her off, and it was not for some time that she wa? missed. When her husband discovered that she was not on the train he got off at the next station, when, securing a horse and buggy, ho went back along t,u^ railroad track, and two hours after wards he found his wife prostrate and bleeding on the ground. "She was brought into Atlanta on Wednesday afternoon and was taken to the hospital in an ambulance. Her condition is dangerous and she may not recover. In addition to her in ternal injuries Mrs. Auld is suffering from thu exposure." Cured ot Lumbago. A. B. Camnan, Chicago, writes, March 4, 1903: "Having been troubled with lumbago at different times and tried one physician after another, then different ointmouts and liniment?, gavo it up alto gether. .So I tried once moro, ana got a bottle of Ballard's Snow Liniment, which gavo me almost instnut relief. I can cheerfully recommend it. nud will add my namo to your list of sufferers." Sold hy Walhalla Drug Co.; W. J. Lunney, Seueca. Good Job'for Brave Sheriff. Washington, December 27.-The following letter o? the President to Attorney General Bonaparte was given out at tho White House last week : ? "Washington, Dee. 17.-Dear Mr. Bonaparte : Somo three years ago, Sheriff J. L. Merrill, of Carroll county, Georgia, lost his ohanco for re-election by his action in beating off a mob of several hundred white people who were trying to take a negro out of jail and put him to death. Sherifi Merrill and hi'i depu ties fired on the mob, killing and wounding several men and beating the others off. Because of this he was defeated for re-election. Con gressman Adamson brought the mat ter to my attention, saying that he hated to see a man who had done such a service as a public offici^L-- ' defeated booause of the very? f?o?$> that he had rendered the service^ He told me that Governor Terrell had offered the man a place, the best he had to give, which carried a sal ary of #50 per month. I told the Congressman I thought I could beat that, and got him a place at\$1,200 a year as custodian ot the grounds of the Federal prison at Atlam^aw I hear he lian done well. If ifWAis Jone well, can't we give him a ^Wo motion ? Sincerely yours, "Theodore Roosevelt." The relief of coughs and colds through laxative influonoe, originated with Beo's Laxative Cough Syrup, containing honey ?nd tar, a oougb syrup containing no aplates or poisons, whioh is oxtensivoly mid. Seouro a bottle at once, obtain a guarantee coupon, and if not fully satis fied with results, your money will be re funded. Sold by Walhalla Drug Co. ; W. J. Lunney, Seneca. Four Men Wounded. Williamson, W. Va.,. Doo. 27._ Pour men were wounded in a pistol battle Tuesday night. Leander Gil kerson and John Browning, while drinking, attempted to take oharge of a local store. Deputy Sheriff Tames Starr was called to arrest them. Shots were exchanged. The ieputy sheriff was shot and is in a Britioal condition. Gilkerson was probably mortally wounded. Starr ?nd Browning were also injured, but will recover. Sae* the _yf The Kind You Wm m Signatare of