University of South Carolina Libraries
THE LAWYER. Essay Delivered by Associate Justice Eugena B. Gary, Before the South Carolina Bar Association in Colombia, S. C., on the 17th Day of January, 1907. A curious novel appeared in the literary world a few years ago, to which its author had given the peculiar name of "She." It contains a weird description of English travellers landing upon the savage coast of Africa, where they found marks of a past civilization. There was the ancient stone wharf imbedded in the mud, and there was, also, the long-forgotten canal. It tells how they struggled up the lonely river, and - * - e tT A.\ ; across tne morass to tne L,ity 01 i\or, men m tuuia. Those of you who may have read the story will recall, no doubt, the vivid picture of the deserted and crumbling Temple of Truth. Within its inner court was a statue of the goddess, who once had innumerable worshippers. On a pedestal *here was a magnificent marble globe, upon which stood a sculptor's dream of female loveliness. A veil was over her face, and her hands were extended in supplication. There it stood, divine amid the desolation, silvered in the moonlight which softened while it illuminated every outline; and thus it had stood for ages ? Truth bescechiug the world to lift her veil. When we read this description, two thoughts were suggested: first, that the statue was a more beautiful o low f h 3 n f Ko ctn flip d^IliUUl UI UJC dUlllilllDLi auuu ui uiv* lavr, tuau mv uwui,mv of Justice, blind-folded and holding in her hands the evenly-balanced scales, for the reason that her eyes should be opened, in order that she might keep watch over the temple, and thereby, be better enabled to detect truth from falsehood, which requires all her faculties; and, second that no member of our profession, can hope for lasting fame, who is not inspired to search for truth. A victory otherwise founded is but temporary. Pasquier's advice to his son was: "Do not undertake any cause, which you do not believe to be good, for in vain will you attempt to persuade your judges, if you are * not first persuaded of the justice of your cause. Combat for the truth, not for victory." L'Agnesseau, the great jurist said to the Bar of France: "Never pride yourselves on the miserable honor of having thrown obscurity over truth; and, more .sensitive to the interest of justice, than the desire of a vain reputation, seek rather to make the goodness of your cause, than the greatness of your genius appear. Let the zeal which you bring to the defense of your clients, be incapable of making you the ministers of their passion, and the organs of their secret malignity." England's greatest queen said, she wished her advocates to remember, that they were counsel not so much p?o domina regina, as pro domina veritate. There never has been a time in the history of the legal profession, when it was more incumbent upon its votaries, to lift the veil from the eyes of Truth; for there never has been a time when the temptation to depart from the traditions of the profession, and when the responsibility upon the lawyer, as a citizen, to the Government was greater. The future of the Republic is, perhaps, more dependent upon the attitude of the members of the Bar towards the Government than upon all other classes combined. Chancellor Kent well said: "The responsibilities attached to the profession and practice of the law, are of the most momentous character. Its members by their vocation rmrrl-it Ko fnr orAat r?nKlir Hutipc: r?f lifp and they may be said to be, ex officio, natural guardians of the law, and to stand sentinels over the Constitutions a-nd liberties of the country." De Tocqueville, the first great observer of American institutions said of the United States, seventy five years k ago: "In America there are no nobles or literary men, and the people are apt to mistrust the wealthy; lawyers, therefore, form the highest political class. ... As the lawyers form the only enlightened class whom the people do not mistrust, they are naturally called upon to occupy most of the public stations. They fill the legislative assemblies, and are at the head of the administration; they consequently exercise a powerful influence upon the formation of the law, and upon its execution." 1 1 1 '1 1 1 1 _i J 1 in t ranee, oesiae ner mauea cnivairy, siooa an oraer of men, known as Noblesse de-la-robe, whose only patent of nobility was admission on the roll of advocates, and from whose ranks were taken the magistrates^ who as members of the parliament of Paris, represented the feudal court, and council of the ancient kings. While we have no class of nobility in this country, the members of the legal profession have to a great extent, and, in the main to the satisfaction of the people, discharged the I duties that devolved upon the nobles of other countries, ft This is shown by the fact that nearly every President, B Vice-President, Speaker of the House of Representatives, I and Head of Department since the organization of the Government, has been a lawyer. Nearly every Secretary of the Treasury, has been a member of the Bar, without previous training as a financier. Alexander Hamilton, a distinguished lawyer, was the y first Secretary of the Treasury. Talleyrand, the great French diplomat, said, that the three greatest men he ever met, were Napoleon Bonaparte, Charles James Fox, and Alexander Hamilton, and that of the three Hamilton was ?i the greatest. ^ It was a lawyer who wrote the Declaration of Independence, promulgating the freedom and equality of all men before the law, and their inalienable right to life, liberty, property and the pursuit of happiness. The groundwork and cardinal principles of the Federal Constitution, emanated from the brain of the lawyer. In the Fifth and Sixth Amendments to the same Constitution, which were passed at the first session of Congress, providing for presentment before the grand jury; against being twice put in jeopardy for the same offense; v V against the defendant being compelled to be a witness against himself; against the citizen being deprived of life, liberty, or property without due process of law; against private property being taken for public use, without just compensation; providing that in criminal prosecutions, the accused shall have the right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury of the State and district, wherein the crime shall have been committed; to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation; to be confronted with the witnesses against him; to have compulsory process, for obtaining witnesses in his favor; and to have the assistance of counsel for his defense, are rights which now seem as if they had always been enjoyed by the people, but the framers of these two sections knew, that there was not a right therein mentioned, that had not been denied the people in the past, and that had not been bought at the price of the patriot's blood. T '? (Aromncf in rf>?tQtinPr L.aWyCIS IlclVC rtlWd^s uct-u iuivuh/jv ... 0 tyranny, because they knew when their rights were infringed, and dared maintain them; and their services have always been conspicuous upon the field of battle. In proportion to membership they have held a far larger number of commanding military offices, than any other class of citizens outside of the regular army. As an illustration, there were thirty-three Generals from our State during the Civil War, of whom more than onethird were lawyers, viz: Maj. Generals M. C. Butler, M. W. Gary, and J. B. Kershaw; and, Brig. Generals M. L. Bonhani, James Chestnut, James Conner, S. R. Gist, Maxcy Gregg, Johnson Hagood, Samuel McGowan, Abner Perrin, and W. H. Wallace. There is, however, now a feeling throughout the land, that the legal profession has been commercialized, and that the members of the Bar, through the temptations held out by corporate influences to enter the business world, have departed from the traditions of the profession, and ceased to discharge their primal duty as citizens, in behalf of the people. We can not shut our eyes to the criticism for it emanates in large measure from those, who stand highest in our ranks, and who have at heart, the best interests of the profession. x As evidence of this fact, we quote the words of Mr. Charles F. Chamberlayne, in an address entitled "The Soul of the Profession," to wit: "A change has occurred both in the source of criticism, and the vehemence of its insistence. Eminent and 'well-esteemed counsel, like Edmund Wetmore, of New York, Alfred Hemenway, of Boston, or Henry St. George Turkpr nf Virginia' suitablv eauiDDed bv study, experience, and familiarity with the subject, addressing professional brethren under full sense of responsibility, unhesitatingly point out certain prevailing tendencies, which they regard as detrimental. Hon. John G. Dillon, with all the force attendant upon his distinguished position, reiterates the statement. A conscientious President of the United States, addressing the alumni of his alma mater and of her law school association, finds no topic more pressing in its claims upon his attention, or more appropriate to such an occasion, than that of the necesity for a radical change, in the attitude of legal advisers, toward clients seeking to violate or circumvent the law of the land. No enemy hath done this. It is our own familiar friend, the man who his at heart the ? ? ? 1? i i honor, wortn, ana dignity wnicn we ourselves are uuuuu to cherish." We will first set forth the views of eminent members of the Bar and then state our own conclusions. Mr. Bryce, of England, in discussing our Bar in his American Commonwealth said : "I am bound to add, that some judicious American observers hold, that the last thirty years have witnessed a certain decadence, in the Bar of the great cities. They say that the growth of the enormously rich and powerful corporations, willing to pay vast sums for questionable services, has seduced the virture of some counsel, whose eminence makes their example important." President Roosevelt, in an address last year at Harvard, uttered these words : "We all know that, as things aofnallv orp manv r>f thp influential and most hiffhlv ?" J ? remunerated members of the Bar in every centre of wealth, make it their special task, to work out bold and ingenious schemes, by which their wealthy clients, individual or corporate, can evade the laws which were made to regulate, in the interests of the public, the uses of great wealth." Ex. Chief Justice Parker, of New York, concludes an address as follows : "In closing, I would emphasize anew the thought that, as the lawyer finds himself the beneficiary and heir of great privileges, which yield co;nmanJin* opportunities, it is more incumbent upon hiin, than upon any other, to recognize that those privileges and powers, impose obligations from which there can be no escape, as, indeed, there ought not to be, except by meeting and welcoming them in the completest sense possible. If, at any time it shall become apparent, that the sanctity of the ballot is either threatened or assailed; if the administration of the law, whether civil or criminal, becomes either lax or careless; if the evils in any industrial movement manifest such power that they threaten monopoly, or put popular rights in peril; if the executive, the legislative, or the judicial branches of our system shall, either by design or accident, tend to trench unduly or dangerously, upon the rights of any of tfye others, the one man who should resent and resist the dangers thus threatened, is the American lawyer. The traditions of his profession, the execution of the high trust confided to him, the example set him by great lead ers through many generations, all demand that he should exercise the greatest watchfulness, and show the highest courage." At a banquet in honor of Mr. Justice Brown, upon his retirement from the Supreme Court of the United States, Mr. Justice Harlan, in speaking of lawyers said: "Now more than ever they should fulfil their great function as guides to their fellow citizens, and lead the people in ways that make for the safety of government, and the security of personal rights. . . . Whether the gloomy forebodings of the pessimest will soon be verified; whether lawlessness ' ? fVio luir ic l/-?ncr tn rnntinnp in nnr I dUU d JLCL11U1 ^ IU CllO 1?T? *w? 6V*I^ W .? w ? J country, whether public and business life is to become for marly years affected by corruption* will depend, Gentlemen of the Bar, very largely upon the members of your profession. If the lawyers stand, as one man, firmly and coura-J cro<->iic1v for law and nrHp.r. for eaual and exact iustice. for the rights of all as established by law, and for cleanliness in public and business life, the people will heed their counsel, and follow the ways of right and truth and justice, marked out by them." Mr. Edward M. Shepard in concluding an address said: "Every lawyer, by virtue of his very profession, holds a relation to public affairs over and above his relations as a mere citizen. The men of our calling are, as men of many other professions and trades are not, bound to promote a sound framework of laws and jurisrvur \I il i t in n Thp pnnrmnns share which pL UUtil^L IUI UUl V1V1AI</Ub?w?<* > .-w corporate oaganization now has in modern industry, its enormous influence upon every phase of modern life, inexorably impose upou lawyers who advise and guide corporations a special and weighty and most honorable duty. If the men of our pofession make it clear to the American people that in their public relations they are concerned to enforce truth and publicity upon corporations and upon all who derive from our laws any sort Df franchiss or right, we may, I think, count it certain that the justifiable criticism and much of the ignorant hostility and suspicion from which lawyers suffer will disappear." Mr. Lewis D. Brandels, of Boston, in an address before the Harvard Ethical Society, uses this language : "By far the greater part of the work done by lawyers is not done in court at all, but in advising men in important matters, and mainly in business affairs. . . . The questions which arise are more nearly questions of statesmanship. The relations created call in many tnstances, for the exercise of the higest diplomacy. The magnitude, difficulty, and importance of the questions involved, are often as great, as m the matters of state, with which lawyers were formerly frequently associated. The questions appear in a different guise but they are similar. The relations between rival railroad systems, are like the relations between neighboring kingdoms. The relations of the great trusts to the consumers or to their employes, is like fhcif of f^nrlal lnrds to commoners or deDendents. . . . Such questions as the regulation of trusts, the fixing ol railway rates, the municipalization of public utilities, the relation between capital and labor, call for the exercise of legal ability of the highest order. Up to the present time the legal ability of a high order which has been expended on those questions has been almost wholly in oppositiou to the contentions of the people. The leaders of the Bar, without any preconceived intent on their part, and rather as an incident to their professional standing, have, with rare exceptions,, been ranged on the side of the corporations, and the people have been represented, in the main, by men of very meager legal ability. If these problems are to be settled right, this condition cannot continue. Our country is, after all, not a country of dollars, but of ballots. The immense corporate wealth, will necessarily develop a hostility, from which much trouble will come to us, unless the excesses ol capital are curbed, through the respect for law, as the excesses of democracy were curbed seventyfive years ago. There will come a revolt of the people against the capitalists, unless the aspirations ol the people, are given some adequate legal, expression; and to this end co-operation of the leaders of the Bar is essential. For nearly a generation, the leaders of the Bar, with few exceptions, have not only failed to take part in any constructive legislation, designed to solve, in the interest of the people, our great, social, economic and industrial problems, they have failed likewise to oppose legislation prompted by selfish interests. They have often gone further in disregard of public interest. They have, at times, advocated as lawyers, legislative measures which as citizens, they could not approve, and have endeavored to justify themselves, by a false analogy. They have erroneously assumed, that the rule of ethics to be applied to a lawyer's advocacy, is the same where he acts for private interests against the public, as it is in litigation between ? r ? ' _ f .iL! 1 private individuals. ... it is tnis coniusion 01 euuccu ideas, which has prevented the Bar from taking, at the present time, the position which it held formerly, as a brake upon democracy, and, which I believe it must take again, before the serious questions now before us can besolved." In an address emtitled "Lawyers and the Trusts" delivered by Mr. Walter S. Logan o'f New York, before the Louisana State Bar Association, he spoke as follows: "In vain did our fathers fight against taxation by an English Parliament, in which we were not represented, and in the disposition of the proceeds of which we had no voice, if there is to be pat in its place, a taxation by the holders of monopolies, in which, also, we are not represented, and in'the profits of which, we have uo share, and whose rule may well become far more grinding, than that of George III. Write it down, all ye, who have pens to write. Speak it, ye who have voices, to which the people listen. Make it the first plank in every political platform, and the first article in every civic catechism: Monopoly enriches only monopolists. It makes the people poor. . . . A monopoly to get to the danger point, has to be a corporation. But corporations are creatures of the State. . . . The people, therefore, have a complete control over corporations, which exist only by their will. Of course the power to create and destroy, implies the power to regulate. Combinations that are considered dangerous to the public, may be absolutely prohibited, or permitted only under conditions that protect the public. The difficulty is not to prohibit. That is easy. The difficulty is to draw jthe line so that corporations and combinations that are beneficial shall be protected and those that are dangerous shall be destroyed or curbed. As President Roosevelt puts it, 'we must try to distinguish between the good and the bad trusts. We must not kill the patient in curing the, disease.' That is where the work of our profession comes in. The power of taxation too, is in the hands of the people. It has always tbe power to reach the corporation by a franchise tax. The individual needs no franchise from the legislature. He gets it from his Maker. flil" *T "* IV l' '^irT^TXT'^JPj-11^ >^?*?*b' E The franchise tax is at its worst, wheh it id graded | down, as it frequently is; that is, when the small corporation, is compelled to pay a larger proportionate tax, than the larger one. The true grading should be a grading up. The^hundred-million-dollar corporation should be taxed proportionately more, instead of less, than the one-million dollar corporation. The graded franchise tax, wise-. ly conceived and properly carried out, would fix that limit at the point where it would be unprofitable to go beyond it. This is a work that can be well done by lawyers only, and by lawyers who get their pay from the public that is to be protected, and not from the combinations that are to be curbed. v Regulation and taxation are two methods, by which the people may always prevent a corporation, from be- j 3 coming an intolerable monopoly. There is no danger?2g either from the disease or the remedy, if the lawyersof the? ^ land, will firmly and forever refuse to allow their retainers, to extend to their acts of citizensaip, and, if they will co& 0', sent to take as a sacred trust the leadership, that the com* j munity is only too glad to give them, if they will only '!j hold themselves free to accept it." We will next state our views. In the first place, it is unquestionably true, that the sphere of action in the legal profession has been enlarged, ' *' by reason of the fact, that the lawyer has entered the world of business, in connectio'n with the practice of his profession. He no longer merely advises his clients as to the law, - ^ but they consult him as a man of affairs relative to the ? ? ' .1 4 - I conduct of business, in whicn fte irequenuy iaKes an active and leading part. In the light of such criticism as we have reproduced, it would be folly to deny the fact, that some of the members of the Bar who have entered this new field, have ignored the traditions of the past, and violated the ethics of the profession. Such lawyers, as has been said, "have erroneously assumed that the rule of ethics to be applied ' to a lawyer's advocacy, is the same where he acts for private interests against the-public, as it is in litigation between private individuals;" and, we believe' that the failure to observe this distinction, has given rise to most of the criticism. We, however, most emphatically enter our protest against the statement that the Bar, in the main, has become commercialized, or that the standard of its ethics 1 has been lowered, or that it has departed from its traditions. We are told that a short time ago, the legislature ' i resolved to investigate the gas situation in New Yorlc . City. A committee went down. One lawyer afteir another was sought and all refused for a -fee to assist~tiio ? committee. They were attorneys for a powerful Company or its subsidiary corporations. One lawyer told the chairman, if he took the people's side, he need never look for business from the public service corporations. Finally, nn* lawvpr was found, and he was a match for the dozen lawyers, who confronted him for the Trust. He had right on his side. I have an abiding faith in the patriotism of the legal profession, and feel assured that lawyers will be found, as was the case in New Yofk, who will respond to the call of duty, and see that the rights of the . people shall not suffer, even at the hands of other members of the profession,, and who will yet bring about a : proper adjustment, of the trusts and monopolies, to the : Government. We, already, see efforts in this direction, in the insti1 tution of proceedings against certain monopolies and corrupt influences throughout the United States, and that ; lawyers are rendering valuable aid in behalf of the Gov ernment. The ideals of the legal profession are today higher ? ^ ?'* " " than they ever have been, which fact-is attributable, in large measure, to the Bar Associations. There are more able lawyers than ever before, in the history of the profession. We are satisfied that the legal profession, will show in the future, as it has demonstrated in the past, that the ; ablest champions of the people's rights, with few excep- I tions, are to be found among its members. fl % " J -1 A. M In conclusion we adopt tne ntting ana eioqueut . words of Mr. Alphonso T. Clearwater of the Kingston (N. Y.) Bar: "Always in the history of constitutional governments, : 'the Bar has been the staunchest and most potent supporter of liberty andThe laws. Always it has stood for thft, which is highest and finest in civic life. Always its support has been tempered with a sanity, a wisdom, a ^ grasp of the fundamental, and a disdain for the trivial, which has won for it a commanding position, in the esteem of men; and, notwithstanding, many of us have ? u., 4-v.a ...o.m'/ia T An nnt hplipvft that the great bodv lciucu uy lijc. >> aj jl viv . ? 0 ^ of the Bar is tarnished, or that it has become* mercenary, or that it has lost its lofty ideals, and if we will but appeal to our better selves, will .give heed to the solemn vow j inscribed at the head of the Scroll we signed upon our { admission to the Bar, w'nen the roll of the centuries shall be called, among all the avocations which will answer at / the end, the Bar of America will appear with its ancient ' armor reburnished, and its lustre then will be undimmed," ?-? Calvert & Nickles ? Headquarters for ? W hite Hickory W agons Cwensboro Wagons, Bock Hill Buggies, Summer Buggies, Cheap Buggies, TTamflf s. LaDrobes. etc. Calvert & Nickles. Feb. 2i. 1904 tf ? ~* -.J