The watchman and southron. (Sumter, S.C.) 1881-1930, November 01, 1919, Image 1
?SB ^JMTEB WATCHMAN, Esteb
Consolidated Aug. 2,1
DECLARES COAL
STRIKE ILLEGAL
It is Beyond Pale of* Law De
clares Attorney General
Palmer
PFOOF OF THE FACT
TO BE FURNISHED
Plan to Block Industry By
Shutting Down the Mines Not
Lawful
Washington, Oct 29.?The govern
ment will establish the "illegalilv"1 of
the strike of coal miners "without in
aby - way impairing the general right
to/strike" as the "general right to
strike is not an issue in any sense
. whatever in the present situation," it
was declared in a statement issued
trmght after a conference in the of
fice of Attorney General Palmer at
which, he discussed the situation with
' Secretary Wilson, Director General
-Hmes, Secretary Tumulty and Assist
ant Attorneys General Ames and Gar
^an.
The. statement, which it was said
fully represents the attitude of the
'. government, declared that the im
pending coal strike "was ordered in a
manner, for a purpose and with a
.. necessary effect, which taken together,
put it outside the pale of the law."
The government will act in the
strike under the provisions of the
: Lever _food control act, enacted as a
j .war measure but still in force.
^?'T3he position of the government in
the impending coal strike was an
nounced tonight by Attorney General
Palmer as follows:
"There can be no doubt that the
government has the power in the pub
tic .interest, under the law, to deal
?^kh'ft&e projected strike of the bitu
minous .'coal miners, without infring
tn'g'.upon the- recognized right of men
; ia 'any line of industry to work where j
t^y^piease and quit work w-heh they
jteaseJ, ^Thc illegality of this strike
ct^ahd' will be. established without
f.i any ; way impairing the general
fright to strike, and the general right
'\. to jstr%e is hot an issue in any sense
" vthkisfer in the present situation. This
is true because the circumstances dif
.^SE^Cfake ? -tfes case-from the- cscse^ifc*
\ 8?|r-crther strike that has ever taken
jylft'ee in; this country.
"It does not follow that every strike
is lawftil merely because the right to
Strike is recognized to exist Every
case must stand upon its own bottom
and be governed by its own facts,
therefore when the president said in
lUs statement last Saturday that 'such
a strike in such circumstances' is
laot only unjustifiable but unlawful
reference was had only to the. condi
tions in the impending situation.
"The proposed strike was ordered
in a manner, for a purpose and with j
a necessasy effect, which taken to-1
gether, put it outside the pale of the
law. After the war began, the pro
duction of fuel was regarded as one of
the subjects of such peculiar public
importance as to justify a special
statutory enactment. The fuel ad
ministration was created to supervise j
the subject and matters of wages as
"Well as prices were considered and'
Sanctioned by the fuel administration, j
After the cessation of hostilites the i
fuel administration suspended certain I
of its orders but did not terminate)
them, and they are subject to rein-1
statement at any time ' upon the |
president's order and the statute un- I
tUvr which the orders were made is|
still in full force.
"With this situation existing the
convention of United Mine Workers
at Cleveland, last September, decided
to annul all wage contracts on No
vember 1 and took the unprecedented
step of deciding in advance of any op
portunity for consultation either with !
the government or with the coal op- j
?rators to strike on November 1, un- j
Jess satisfactory new arragnements
Should be made.
"Without any expression from the i
workers themselves, their organiza- j
tion promulgated a demand for a 60 j
per cent, increase in wages, a six!
hour day and a five day week, and j
authorized a strike to be effective No- j
vember 1, before the demands were
even presented to the operators. The ]
demand for a new wage agreement i
Covered only a part of the coal fields j
where operators had been given no j
opportunity to even consider demands j
for increased wages or decreased j
hours.. All this has been done while j
the miners in every field, through i
their right of collective bargaining!
had entered into a solemn contract, j
with the operators, fixing wages and j
hours for a definite period which has j
not yet expired. The operators upon ;
the insistence of the president indi
cated their willingness to negotiate and
arbitrate provided the strike is de
ferred while the miners rejected the'
president's request for abitration as:
a means of settlement and refused i
to defer the strike.
"Some of the wage contracts were
made with the sanction of ihe federal
government, operating through the
fuel administration, to run during th<v
continuation of the war or until April
1. 1920. May others, however, run
Until a time still in the future with
out regard for the continuation of the
war.
"While it is perfectly plain that
the war is still on and any contract
running until its conclusion is still in
force, whatever weight may be given
to the argument that the successful
Kfced April, 18(0. "Be Jest a
881. S
COAL SUPPLY IS
TO BE ALLOTTED
Fuel to Be Distributed to Es
sential Industries As
Needed
CURTAILMENT MAY
REACH FIFTY PERCENT
The Government Has Perfected
Plans to Minimize Distress
During Strike
Washington, Oct. 30.?The revival
j of the fuel administration to deal
with conditions resulting from the
coal strike will not be necessary, Dr.
Garfield advised the cabinet today,
holding that the war time powers of
that body are now vested in the
railroad administration which will
have full authority to distribute coal
to essential industries.
While the revival of the fuel ad
ministration is being urged by gov
ernment officials to prevent hoarding
and profiteering, the department of
justice announced that it had power |
to handle the situation under the food
control ?ct.
An executive order restoring max
imum prices for coal will be issued
by the president, probably today. Of
ficials wculd not say what maximum
price has been determined upon.
Secretary Lane announced at a spe
cial meeting of the cabinet that the
government would not hesitate to cur
tail the consumption of coal by indus
tries fifty per cent, in order that coal
on baud and that available from un
affected nonunion mines might be
equitably distributed to essential in
dustries. The curtailment list used by
the war industries board during the
war would be taken as a basis, Mr.
Lane said. Plants engaged in the
manufacture of munitions might be
cut on? entirely he stated.
operation of the war, no longer re
quires such, contracts, it has no appli
cation whatever to the large number
of such contracts, which expires at a
fixed date .without regard for the war
period.; The armistice did not end the
war and the courts in many cases
Jb&Ke. held that the war emergency,
statutes ""are" still in force; the same
rule must ? apply to ' war emergency
contracts. The congress had held to
this position so. late as October 22,
when an act of congress was approv
ed making even more effective the
fuel and fuel control act. ?
"The suspension of the restrictions
as to the price of coal is not neces
sarily permanent and conditions war
rant a renewal of these restrictions at
this time; and yet the government, if
it reinstates the order fixing a maxi
mum price, would be absolutely help
less to protect the people aginst ex-1
orbitant prices if the contracts made
under its sanction should now be de
liberately broken. This does not mean
that a change could not b^ negotiated
and either agreed upon or arbitrated
if proper protection of the public be
accorded in the settlement; but it
does mean that the public welfare in
the war-time emergency must still be
same permanent interest to be serv-1
ed by both parties. The government j
is the protector of the public wel
fare.
"The proposed strike, if carried to I
its logical conclusion, will paralyze
transportation and industry. It will
deprive unnumbered thousands of men
who are making no complaint about
their employment of their right to
earn a livelihood for themselves and j
their families; will put cities in dark- j
ness and, if continued only for a few j
days, will bring cold and hunger to j
millions of our people; if continued j
for a month, it will leave death and !
starvation in its wake. It would be
a more deadly attack upon the life of
the nation than an invading army. j
"By enacting the food and fuel con- j
trol act, Congress has recognized the
vital importance in the present cir?j
cumstances of maintaining produc- j
tion and distribution of the necessi
ties of life, and has made it unlawful
for any concerted action, agreement
or arrangement to be made by two or
more persons to limit the facilities
of transportation and production, or
to restrict the supply and distribution
of fuel, or to aid or abet in the doing
of any act having this purpose or ef
fect. Making a strike effective under
the circumstances which I have de
scribed amounts to such concerted j
action or arrangement.
"It is the solemn duty of the De
partment of Justice to enforce this
statute. We have enforced it an many
caSes. We must continue to do so. ir
respective of the persons involved in
its violation. I hope it will not be
necessary to enforce it in this case.
"Indeed. I am hearing from many
sources that large numbers of miners
themselves do not wish to quit work
and will not do so if assured of the
protection of the government. of
which they properly feel themselves
a part. It is probably unnecessary for
me to say that such protection will
everywhere be given, so that men may
exercise their undoubted right of con
tinuing to work under such terms
and conditions as they shall see fit.
The facts present a situation which
challenges the supremacy of the law.
and every resource of the government
will be brought to bear to prevent the
national disaster which would inevi
tably result from the cessation of min
ing operations."
man
ind Fear not?Let all the ends Thou At
UMTEK,, S. C, SATURI
WAR ENDS WHEN
TREATY IS SIGNED
t
_ t
Proclamation Will Be Issued As
Soon as Senate Ratifies
German Treaty
STATEMENT FROM
THE WHITE HOUSE
Peace Will Not Wait on Con
sideration of the Austrian
Treaty
Washington, Oct. 28.?War time
prohibition will be brought to an end
by presidential proclamation imme
diately after the senate ratifies the
German peace treaty, it was stated
today at the White House. Officials
explained that the war time act pro
vided that it be annulled by the pres
ident when peace had been declared
and the army arid navy demobilized.
The White House announcement
clears up any doubt whether the war
will be legally ended with the ratifica
tion of the German treaty. Some of
ficials had expressed the opinion that
the war emergency would not pass
until the Austrian treaty is acted upon
by the senate.
New Haven, Oct. 30.?Mrs.'1 Ella
Wheeler Wilcox, author and poetess,
died at her home in Branford where
she has been ill for some months af
ter a nervous collapse while en-?
gaged in war work in England. I
GOVERNMENT TO
USE IRON HAND
Steps Will Be Taken Promptly
to Meet Coal Strike Sit
uation
INTENDS, TO ENFORCE ~ -
CRIMINAL PENALTIES
Food and Fuel Control Law Will
Be Enforced to Protect Miners
Who Want to Work
Washington, Oct. 29.?The govern
ment moved swiftly tonight to meet
the nationwide coal strike order fori
Saturday.
P?fusal of the miners' organization
at Indianapolis to withdraw the order
calling out half a million men brought
instant announcemeivt that drastic ac
tion would be taken to keep the mines
in operatfon.
As to those miners who go on
; strike and thereby curtail production
f the food and fuel control law with
its recently added criminal penalties
[of fine and imprisonment will be en-1
forced without regard to persons. This
attitude of the government. Attorney
j General Palmer made clear, does not
affect the right of workers to strike
for redress of grievances in other1
cases where no violation of the law is!
involved.
I Every resource of the government!
j in the words of Attorney General Pal- j
I mer. will be used to prevent the "na- j
I tional disaster"-certain to follow thei
! stoppage of work.
Adequate police protection, with
j troops as a last resort if neces
sary will be given those men desiring,'
I to remain at work. Reports from
j government agents show that a big
I part of the miners ordered to quit
! work will stay on the job.
I Rights of the public will be pro
j tected through revival of price con-:
j trol regulations suspended when the \
? fuel administration went out of ex- j
I istence February 1. This means an1
early drop in the price of soft coal |
! and gives assurance aginst profiteer- j
\ in?- , i
I Mr. Palmer's announcement of the j
j government's plans made after a con- !
I sultation with Secretary Wilson. Di
rector General Hines. Assistant Attor- j
j ney General Amos, in ch:\rge of pro
I secutions under the food and fuel j
' control law. Assistant Attorney Gener- j
I al Garvan. directing criminal prose
; cutions and investigations of the de-;
partmont of justice. Secretary Tu-!
! multy. representing the president, and j
Dr. H. A. Garfield. former fuel admin-'
istrator. did not mince words in deal-;
: ing with the strike.
"The proposed strike.* the an- !
nouncement declared. "would be a'
more deadly attack on the life of the
j nation than an invading army. The
I facts present a situation which chal-:
lenges the supremacy of the law. j
Director General Hines later issued)
a statement showing that the produc
tion of coal this year has been be
I low normal.
Paris. Oct. 20.?General Coanda. j
former Rumanian premier has lveon ;
i named as head of the Rumanian ;
peace delegation. Coanda will ar-j
j rive in Paris soon and will probably
bring instructions relative to signing'
the Austrian treaty. 1
mat at be thy Country'*, Thy God'a i
)AY, NOVEMBER 1, 19]
2 AUSTRIAN GEN
ERALS BLAMED
j Censured For Orders Issued Be
fore Armistice Became
Effective
CLAIM THEY LAID DOWN
THEIR ARMS TO ITALY
Italians Captured JThree Hun
dred Thousand Prisoners as
Result
Vienna, Oct. 29.?Generals von
Arz and Waldstaet, of the Austrian
army. who. have been severely cen
sored for ordering the cessation of
hostilities November 3, 1918, thirty
hours before the armistice with Italy
became effective were heard today in
a secret session of the commission
appointed to investigate the charges.
It is claimed that, the Italians co i
cluded their offensive and captured
more than three hundred thousand
prisoners during the period men
tioned, all Austrian posts having been
ordered to stop firing.
J. F. Wise, member of the House
of representatives from Charleston,
has sent his resignation to Wilson
Gibbes of Columbia, clerk of the
house, and Mr. Gibbes Tuesday sent
a letter to the Charleston legisla
tive delegation, asking that they name
a date for an election of Mr. Wise's
successor.
WORLD LABOR
CONGRESS OPENS
Secretary of Labor Wilson Se
lected to Act as Chairman
of Conference
MANY LABOR ORGANI
ZATIONS ARE INVITED
Employees Association Also
Asked to Be Represented By
Delegates 1
Washington, Oct. 29.?The first
move of the international labor con
ference, which formally opened here
today, was to take steps to obtain the
virtual participation of the United
Statv in the conference although con
gress has decided against the appoint
ment of delegates prior to ratifica
tion of the peace treaty.
On motion of Baron Mayo des Plan
ches, Italian government delegates.
United States employers' and workers'
organizations were invited unani
mously to send representatives to take
part in the conference, which is still
I in a state of "being organized."
j While no attempt was made to ob
j tain the appointment of governmental
I delegates, as such action would have
I been in direct conflict with the decis
i ion of congress, the United States
I will be represented in the conference
: through Secretary Wilson, who open
jed today's session and probably will
j continue as conference during the ma
jjor portion of its deliberations. Mr.
Wilson will be proposed by the or
ganization committee as permanent
chairman during the period of organ
ization at the meeting tomorrow, and
j in view of the universal custom of
J selecting chairmen of international
! gatherings from the nation acting as
I host, no objection is expected.
Secretary Wilson said that he would
accept the nomination in view of his
. interpretation that the organization
i of the conference can not be complet
ed until the league of nations is cre
ated, and that the United States is
[charged by the Versailles treaty with
! the organization of the conference.
The American Federation of Labor
and the chamber of commerce of the
! United States were invited hy the or
jganization committee to name the
worker and employer delegates, re
I spectively, to represent this country.
Samuel Gompers, veteran chief of the
federation will repreesnt the workers.
Decision as to the choice of the cham
ber of commerce will await the ar
rival here tomorrow of Homer L. Fer
guson, president.
BUBONIC PLAGUE
IN NEW ORLEANS
New Orleans, Oct. 30.?Henry Dus
Rendorfen a fruit handler at the ba
nana docks, died yesterday from what
was diagnosed chemically and mi
croscopically as bubonic plague. No
other cases have been reported.
Celevlarid. Oct. 29.?The discovery
of a radical plot to spread terroi
throughout the nation hy another se
ries of bomb explosions next spring
was announced hy the police here to
day, following the arrest last night
offive men and one woman sus
tfl tokpt planning the destruction of
jBgiUge station here.
m? Xntto'B."
THE TB ?I
L9.
SENATE VOTES
FOR PROHIBITION
Enforcement Law Passed Over
President's Veto By Ma
jority of Eight
CONGRESS FOR ANY
THING AGAINST LIQUOR
Law Makers No Longer Fear the
Liquor Trust But Heed Anti
Saloon League
"Washington, Oct. 28.?The senate
passed the prohibition enforcement
act over the president's veto* today
and made" immediate effective ma
chinery for preventing sale of bever
ages containing more than one-half
of 1 per cent alcohol.
The vote was 65 to 20, or eight
more than the necessary two-thirds
majority. While there was a wrangle
over taking up the measure in place
of the peace treaty, which had the
right of way, there never was doubt
as to how the senate stood. It was
overwhelmingly "dry" like the house,
which repassed the bill within three
hours after the president had vetoed
it.
Before congress at 3.40 o'clock
finally clinched enactment of the en
force ment ;law, despite presidential
objection to linking war time and
constitutional prohibiton acts, there
came from the White House the an
nouncement that war time la^r?
which was put into effect after the
cessation of hostilities?would be an
nulled the moment the senate formal
ly ratified the German peace treaty.
It was the most definite of all of
ficial or semi-official statements bear
ing on the war time act. Prohibition
leaders were olainly disturbed by the
news, for they had counted firmly
upon the country reaching the effec
tive date of constitutional prohibition
?January 16, 1320?wthout reopen
ing of saloons. /
Despite the clamor set up by wet
and . dry forces over the White House
pronouncement, senate leaders said
they would proceed with considera
tion of the treaty as heretofore. Sen
ators who have taken an active part
in tne prohibition campaign branded
as unfair and absurd reports that they
would delay the treaty simply to keep
the liquor traffic from getting a foot
hold in the comparative.y short pe
riod remaining before the country will
go dry for good.
Formal denial was issued from the
headquarters of the Anti-Saloon
league that its officers would take no
part in any movement calculated to
delay the treaty. League officers
stuck to the opinion that it would be
necessary to first ratify the Austrian
treaty before lifting the war time pro
hibition ban, which was said to have
been the ruling of Attorney General
Palmer, and they declared their po
sition was not altered by the fact
that President Wilson prepared to
cut through legal doubt and wipe out
a law the necessity for which he be
lieves to have passed.
With today's action by the senate
the department of justice is ready to
deal with any offenders against the
drastic provison of the new act. At
best heretofore, prosecutions were
more or less haphazard and necessar
ily so, it was said, because cf loosely
drawn language of the act, but the
new law gives ample means of break
ing up the traffic.
So drastic is the enforcement act
that a man, for instance, may be
fined or put in jail for displaying a
picture of a brewery or a keg, but his
right to store liquor in his own home
for his own use stood up against all
attacks in committee and both houses
of congress.
v Warning went tonight to dealers
selling 2 3-4 per cent beer, without
apparent risk heretofore, that the
new law fixed one-half of 1 per cent
as the legal limit of alcoholic con
tent.
The roll call in the senate follows:
For overriding the veto:
Republicans?Ball. Capper, Colt.
Cummins, Curtis. (Fcrrnald, Freling
huysen. Gronna. Halle, Hardin, John
son of California, Jones of Washing^
ton. Kellogg. Kenyon. Keyes, Knox,
Lenroot, Lodge. McCormick, McCuru
ber, McNary. Moses. Nelson, New,
i Xewberry. Norris, Page, Phipps, Poin
dexter, Sherman. Smoot, Spencer,
Sterling, Sutherland. Townsend,
Wadsworth. Warren, Watson?38.
Democrats ? Ashurst, Bank head.
Dial. Chamberlain. Fletcher, Gore.
Karris. Harrison. Henderson. Jones of
! New Mexico. Kendrick. Kirby. Mc
i Kellar. Myers. Hugent Overman,
! Owen. Pomerene. Shephard. Sim
mons. Smith of Arizona. Smith of
Georgia. Swanson. Trammell. Walsh
of Montana. Williams and Wolcott?
.'7. Total for 55.
Against:
Republieans ? Borah. Brandegee. J
McLean. Edge, falder. Fall. France,
LaFollette and Penrcse?9.
Democrats?Gay. Gerry. Hitchcock,
King. Phelan. Ransdel, Robinson, I
Shields, Thomas. Underwood and i
Walsh of Masachusetts?IT. Total
>gamst 20. I
-
Constantinople, Oct. 29.?Favorable
Titicism hns^jp^ri caused here b;
dispatch fro^HBdish and American
societies t? Wect that th4^jwted
States \v| R-M'v: cith^j B
ian orjf Km^ales.J &
mm
i SOCTHRON, BettMMw? im?, ??
VoLXLIX. Mo. 23.
MARTIAL LAW
IN KNOXVILLE
Governor Roberts Asks For Fed
eral Troops to Keep Order
in City
THERE IS FEAR
OF STREET RIOTS
Strikers Threaten to Use Force
to Prevent Operation of the
Street Cars
Nashville, Oct. 27.?Following a
conference by long distance telephone
with Gen. Baxter Sweeney, adjutant
general of the Tennessee National
Guard, Governor Roberts tonight caus
ed for three companies of federal
troops from Camp Gordon, Atlanta,
with full equipment to entrain at
once for Knoxville.
The following telegram was sent
to Maj. Gen. E. M. Lewis, command
ing officer of the Camp:
"Please entrain two infantry com
panies and one , machine gun com
pany, total 300, for Knoxville,. fenn.
E. B. Sweeney,' my adjutant* gen
eral, is there in charge.
(Signed) "A. H. Roberts, Governor
of Tennessee."
The governor stated that this meas
ure was taken simply as a precau
tionary move, not having been occa
sioned by any renewed rioting, in
Knoxville today. Acting, however, on
the advice of General Sweeney,- the'
mayor of Knoxville, the district at
torney, Col. Carey F. Spence, and oth
er citizens, the governor said that he
wished to assure Knoxville adequate
protection in case of disorder arising
from the rumored sympathetic strike.
"It is geenrally understood in Knox
ville," the governor said, " "that ? a
sympathetic strike, calling out- over
6,000 workers, mainly in the textile
industry, will be ordered at a huge
mass meeting that is being held ia
Knoxville tonight, Labor agitators
have been speaking in all the factor
ies and shops today trying to ififlanie
the workers to a point where the
general strike order tonight will -be
obeyed.
"Acting, therefore, on-advices from
Knoxville, L decided -tc^-caiUoitt-'-the,
federal troops as a precautionary
measure. I deemed that course #M&r
than waiting until the city was re
duced to a state of anarchy and then
try to restore order. I am hoping that
the situation will pass off without any
need of these troops, but General
Sweeney thought it wise for me ,to
take this step before I left Nashville,
as the labor meeting will be over arfd
the general strike on if it is called
before I leave here, in all probability.
Although it had been his intention
to stay in Knoxville only over Tuesr
day to attend the meeting of the East
Tennessee Law" and Order organiza
tion. Governor Roberts announced to
night that he would stay in Knoxville
as long as the situation seemed to
warrant his presence. It is his in
tention to keep in the closest touch
with the progress of affairs there.
ALL READY FOR
GREAT STRIKE
Executive Board of Miners Un
ion Making Final Arrange
ments
Indianapolis. Oct. 30.?The execu
tive board of United Mine Workers of
America met here today to finish the
preparatory work incidental of the
coming strike of soft coal miners!
That no development could avert the
strike was stated, bat some change in
the attitude of operators might re
sult in shortening of the t ieup, ac
cording to union men.
OFFICERS OF FAIR
ARE RE-ELECTED
J. N. Kirvin of Darlington Again
Made President r
Columbia,. S. C, Oct. 29.?J. N. Kir
vin, of Darlington, and A. B. Lang
ley, of Columbia, were re-elected
president and vice president, respec
tively, of the State Agricultural and
Mechanical Society, under the auspices
of which the State Fair is held, at
the annual meeting of the society held
here tonight. The following execu
tive committee was elected by con
gressional districts:
First, J. Swinton Whaley, of Lit
tle Edisto; Second, J. I. Johns, of A1-.
lendale; Third. T. J. Kinard, of Nine
ty-Six; Fourth, John D. W. Watts, of
Laurens; Sixth. Bright Williamson,
of Darlington, and Seventh, S. J.
Simmers, of Cameron. The members
of the executive committee, with the
exception of J. I. Johns, were re
elected. The secretary and treasurer
will be elected at' a meeting of the
executive eommlttee to be held next
spring. The present secretary is D...
F. Kfird, of Columbia, and the treasr
urer is David G. Ellison, of Colum
Oia. The meeting instructed the ex
ecutive committee to ask the Gen
eral Assembly for an appropriation
of $12.500, of which $5,000 wfll go to
ward prizes for agricultural exhibits,
and $7,500 towards defraying ex
penses.