The watchman and southron. (Sumter, S.C.) 1881-1930, February 25, 1914, Image 8
DR. ?. B. SAUNDERS
TELLS OF HER WORK
Says She is Fighting to Clear Her Name and
Reputation and Not to Hold Her
Position.
? I.mms that she \v \s not ACCORDED 1 Allt TREATMENT 11Y
MAM or HWTfTl and (JfffMOl members OF Hommtal
htaef who MM CHARGES \(ia1nst IM?on STAND FOR
three hoiks THRtsDAY UBFOJUD INVESTIGATING COMMIT.
tee.
Columbia, Feb. 19.?' I am contend?
ing for tne clearing of my name and
my reputation and not for the reten?
tion of my posit.on. ' d? <-hired Dr<
Eleanor B. Saunders, woman physi?
cian at the State Hospital for the In?
sane, before the asylum investigating
committee of the general assembly
this afternoon.
I considered the letters of Gov?
ernor Blease and the remark of Dr\
GrlAn a slander,'' said l?r. Saunders,
la a statement simple in its narrative.
Every listener bent closer us Dr.
Haunders told of the executive meet?
ing of the regents on December 12,
when she was condemned on charges
of interfering with other members of
the medical staff, and neither her
father nor attorney was allowed to be
present. Not in a spirit of denuncia?
tion, but with womanly dignity, Dr.
Rounders impressed Mr hearers with
the fact that the position is not what
she is trying to retain; it is her good
name and her reputation which she
wants cleared of charges whim, she
says, ore unfair, unjust and untrue.
In telling of the ixcuitive meeting
of the regents on December 12. when
ahe was suddenly confronted with
complaints from other members of
the medical staff with no previous
knowledge, and when alone with her
accusers, she said this afternoon thai
she tried vainly to tell them her work
at the asylum had been only for the
best Interests of the Institution an i
In an effort to build up the Hospital
and advance the comfort and well be?
ing of the poor unfortunates there,
and of how Dr. Griffin insulted her
and ahe left the room In tears.
Dr. Sounders said that if Governor
Blease intended to slander her, it was
unfair that he should say it was best
for her that the matter be closed. ' It
was unfair that the governor should
set both as my prosecutor and my
Judge." she said. In that meeting, eh*
seid, her professional integrity and her
personal conduct were assailed, and
the charges made by Governor Bleast
and others were unjust, unfair and
antrue, and she considered them a
slander.
"I saw no reason why I should ac?
cept the accusation," she said, ref* r
rlng to the alleged unfairness of her
treatment before the executive session
of the refents and of her dSSHaallOB
to accept the suggestion to end tho
matter, "as it was best fat the yottltg
lady." ss stated by Governor lib is<
and the regents in their resolution re?
fusing thr request of her father Rep?
resentative G. I... Sanmb-rs. to reopen
the investigation.
Dr. Saunders said she refused to al?
low the matter to be hushed up and
the evil tongue of silent gMgtfflloil be
noised abroad and its poisonous inllu-1
ence net at work, She wanted tin
full light turned | n and the whole
matter threshed out in the open, si!
said. All she asked was for a fair trial
and this was refused her by Governor
Blease and the board of reg? Ms, sin
staled.
How without social 11C? ?. OOatlnttC
ly on duty, nnd w:th n I OWteidS prac
lb e, she had I foi even ears
to upbuild ami upiirt Um Mate Ha
pttal for the Insane, nnd that v. hat
work she did in other departments
was In the spirit of co-operation and
with so knowledge that Hu r.? was o)>
Jection from the head* of those de
partments, was told this afternoon by
Dr. Saunders. the WOOnSJI pa .m< um.
whose removal UM reSJOBtl ha\r >,t it. (]
would have ended what th? y say
friction at the asylum.
Dr. Saunders said she knew nothim:
of any objection from other im inle t .
of medical st iff until >he was haled
before the regents on PsgembOf IS,
without previous netloe, and ihs <ssnv
plaints made kattre, Everything she
did. she stated, w.n ss.'li the IpproVal
of Dr. Babcoek, the superint? ndent,
and none of tho other heads protested
at the time, and not until DlMWlll
IS. 8he said that up to that time slm
had no knowledge that b r w.nk
. fher than setbtfactnry to the regents,
to Oovernor lma^\ ?" ?he supcrin
tendent and to the psjMta,
Beginning with ?er appolgjtgSSnl t"
the medical staff |g M;,v. IHfi Dr.
?sunders rapidly sketched dm sj
things she had dorn t., bring the white
female gSpaflgSSnl uml. i g#f I lurg"
up to a high stale of ellb I. m y and
how the Interests of ea- h patient
were looked after. Her Inter* st m th.
patients, the m.nv kindly things she
did for the familb* ot unfoi I unat. V
h?.\v she gtwajl tried to make the pa?
tient feel at ROOM and the home peo?
ple satisfied, how she examined the
different cases, and tested for causes
in an effort to cure the patients, the
many improvements in sanitary and
other ways and how each year she
had tried to get more knowledge to
further help her in the work she is
doing, was easily gleaned from tilg
simple way in whieh Dr. Saunders
gave her side of the ease to the com?
mittee.
Without any idea of trespassing or
interfering, she said, she often help?
ed in other departments and there
had . been the most cordial relations
wuh every one, as she thought, and
what she did was in a generous end
< oopetatiw spirit, she said, and sud?
denly, in December, she was dragged
before the board and the "unjust and
unfair" ( barges made against her and
sb was condemned unfairly and un?
truly.
Dr. Sounders, told Of how she went
to Governor Hlease with her head
nurse the Saturday prior to the meet?
ing of the regents last July, when the
charges of subordinates at the asylum
were made, she said she had stated
she would not apply for re-election if
ii'T work was not thoroughly tatlsfac
tory to every one. She told of having
thanked governor for his assistance
In getting the hospital nurse put on
an c iual footing with othor nurses,
snd said that the governor told her
he would use his inllm nee to have hoi
retained. She stated she went away,
and after the re-election, went about
her duties, and in her efforts to help
the patients and upbuild the hospital
thought no more of it, knew nothing
of uny OOmplalntSInguinal her, until en
December 11, when she was served
with a notiee to appear before the
reg? nts the following day.
Dr. Saunders choked with emotion
when she related having seen for the
?rst time the letter written by Gov?
ernor BlOggt to Dr. Babeock demand?
ing her removal, and she said the
governor's charges she considered
wert? against her character and they,
she stated, were untrue, and unfair.
She termed he* experience before the
regents and Governor Hlease on De
OOniher l- "ha rowing," and reiterat?
ed how in \ain she tried to tell the.n
she had done 00 wrong, and how she
refused to accept the action o1 the
? ntf to hush up the matter, for rhe
demanded that her good name be
I 1. atod and slu wanted the full liglu
turned on, and let everything stand in
the open.
Dr. Saunders answered effectively
some statement * about nurses' funds
whieh she had handled, by presenting
receipts, books, and statements show?
ing businesslike efficiency of the great?
est manner in her handling. She had
vouchers and roeelpti i<>r everything
and had cancelled cheeks for every
thing ghe had paid out and clear re
? ipts from Treasurer Hunch for all
ti" money she turned over to him.
Hor answer was so effective that the
eoUft room broke into cheering and
u trag some time before chairman
Ifauldln could restore order.
Dr. BaUOdors went into detail in an
SWSf to everything charged against
hor( and her friends tonight are Jubl?
l int over What they consider the corn
plot,- vindication ??f herself. She Im?
pressed the committee with tho fact
that her WOVM at the asylum was In
tin- spirit of largeness with the later*
SOts Ol Ihe p ilients ever foremost, and
petty Jealousies had no part In her
. m tr Hor soM? sacrifice and her
. fh .. a. y snd hor loving kindness and
lender mercy for Ihe unfortunates
which crowd the usylumi and her ef?
forts to rollOVe their suffering, she tool
In VtVld fOShlon. She was on the
st:-iel nearly three hours and when she
< on< luded many pressed forward to
congratulate her. Many ladleg wore
in ihe uudieiu o<
Dr. \V. A. I'ulnier. ailOthor member
or the medleul staff at the asylum
preceded Dr. Bounders mi the stand,
but he added nothing new to the In?
quiry.
The committee will finish lomorroa
afternoon and wind up the Inquiry
They ask any more persons ooncerned
or who deolre to give testimony t<? be
present tomorrow ;ift? i noon ;it 8.110
o'clock^ when it Ig hoped thai the con?
eluding session of the Investigation
will be lu id.
CHARGES INTERFERENCE.
Columbia, Kol?, lt.- lt. Iilack
burn, M. D., pathologist at the State
Hospital for the Insane, was the'
principal witness before the legislative
committee yesterday. He read a part
Of his testimony given at the now fa?
mous meeting of the board of regents
on December 12, In which he made
tie- general charge that Eleanor B.
Saunders, M. D., the young woman
physician, had hampered him in his
work. The committee asked for u
specific instance. The witness re?
peated his general charge. His prin?
cipal complaint was that she had tak?
en some of the apparatus from the
laboratory where he was to work.
l>r. Saunders made a brilliant cross
examination of the witness. Dr.
Blackburn claimed that he was not
glvan a square deal by Dr. Saunders.
He said that he thought he was hin?
dered all the time by Dr. Saunders.
He paid her ability an unconscious
tribute when he stated that from a
recent Incident she "seemed to be ev?
erything, Including the superintend?
ent."
Brnost If. Cooper, M. D., the young
physician who was displaced as path?
ologist by the board of regents, was
another witness of the day. He told
of his agreeing to give Dr. Saunders
lessons in the Wasser man blood test
and said that a third party was al?
ways present when the demonstrations
I were given. Dr. Blackburn, he said,
I told him that "politics" had played a
I part in the selection of the assistants.
This statement was denied by Dr.
Blackburn.
J. L. Thompson, M. I) , first as?
sistant physician, returned to the wit?
ness stand at the session yesterday to
oloar up some statements with re?
gard to th - discharge of a. nurse and
the gulclde of a patient. Dr. Thompson
submitted documentary evidence to
prove that he was not to blame in
either case.
There was a large crowd present in
the supreme court room yesterday af?
ternoon when the hearing was called
at ::.nu o'clock. The hearing will be
roaumod this afternoon at the same
hour. Several witnesses will be heard
today and there is a chance that the
Investigation will be concluded to?
morrow. The committee will make
report at this session of the general
assembly.
MATRONS ENJOY VALENTINE
PARTY.
Mr*. J. A. James Entortalng the Book
Club at Summerton.
Summerton, Feb. 20.?Mrs. Joseph
Alston James entertained the Matrons'
Hook Club Friday afternoon with a
.valentine party. The whole lower
floor wa?] thrown in suite and tin
dec< rations in true valentine style
wore festoons of little red hearts.
Three tables were arranged. At tin
Orot the guests were given pencils
and paper and requested to compose
original valentine verses; at the sec?
ond correct head! had to be fitted to
comic valentines, which had previous?
ly been beheaded* and at the third
i broken hearts were mended. After?
wards the guests Were presented with
a bow ami arrow and each in turn
tried her skill at "archery" the mark
being a small heart in the centre of
a large one. Mis. Win. li. Anderson
proved tu be the most skillful at this
and was awarded the prize, a hand?
some table runner in handmade Irish
crochet.
A salad course and coffee were
served.
The invited g?OSts wore Mis. Win.
H. Andeison and Miss Ablie Whaley.
Miss Mabel Harper and Miss Ethel
Moore were hostesses to the Embroid?
ery Club Wednesday afternoon. Al?
ter several games of rook the guests
wero given paper and pencil and
requested to design emboridory pat?
terns. Afterwards a delightful sweet
course and coffee were served.
The Baptist Woman's Missionary
Society w.is entertained by Mrs. M.
Wr. Cordon at her home on Tuesday
afternoon.
Mrs. Lucas (;f Florence and Miss
Mamie Burgess of Clinton art" the
guests of Dr. and Mrs. Joseph Bur?
gess.
Mrs. Leon B. l>avis spent several
days in Charleston last week with her
mother, who had been taken there lor
i roatment.
Mis. Ellison Capers spent Thurs?
day in Bumter shopping.
HUDSON'S ( All KILLS BOY.
Congressman Was not Occupant ?t
Time, However,
Laneti Ala., Feb. 22,?Congressman
Hobson's automobile in which h<
loured Chambers county yesterday, is
said to ha\ e run over and kille 1
the 8-year-old son of .lames Kapp, at
Rlvervlew. Copt. Hobson was not in
the tar at the time. A chauffeur
named Lindsay was in charge of the
machine, and II is said the hoy van
to it and jumped on the step. Th
throbbing of the automobile, it Is
Stated, tbi? w the boy off and under
t he u heels.
Juniper from the Indian reserva?
tions of New Mexico and Arizona may
prove an excellent source of material
for lead pencils, Manufacturers are
searching the world lor pencil w.I
The dozens of bargain "pick-ups'' in men's, women's and
children's clothing, shoes, etc., that you will be able to
find right here right now. It's just between seasons
when you need fairly heavy clothes to keeo off the chil?
ling winds, and we have some dandy offerings in this line
to make you. Our Mr. L. Alpert is in the northern mar?
kets buying our big spring and summer stock, and we
will keep up our big bargain giving period on everything
in the store until our new lines begin to pour in.
If you need anything in wearables for yourself or any
member of your family, it will pay you to drop in and
look at what we can offer you.
L. ALP
North Main
Street
Svimter, S. C.
CRISIS AT EL PASO.
EXCITEMENT AT FEVER HEAT IN
BORDER TOWN.
Mexicans Attack American Camp Un?
der Tovcr of Darkness BUI are Driv?
en oft?Feeling Against Mexicans
Becoming Intense and Clash May
Come at Any Hour?Bcntou Case
Being Van ii to Inflame Populace.
El Paso, Texas, Feb. 21.?Under
cover of darkness a body of Mex?
icans attacked the camp of troop M..
thirteenth cavalry, but were dri\'( 11
away when Corporal Jensen, who was
on guard duty called his comrades
' to arms. No Americans were injured,
but cue Mexican was dangerously
wounded. it is believed the Mexi?
cans were trying to release the fed?
eral prisoners who wore held prison?
ers when they fled across the holder
at the time of the battle at Ojlnaga.
[tftenae feeling is growing against
the Mexicans and race riots arc tear
0.1.
Gen. Villa, taking with him the
soldiers who took part In the execu?
tion of William Benton, the English
1 man, hits returned into the interior of
Chihuahua, it is believed in an effort
to bloc u the investigation of Ben
tons' death.
Enrique Augulre, a Mexican, was
executed with Benton. The rebels
claim that both were implicated In B
I plot against Villa's life.
WELL WATER DEVELOPED HEAT.
N?> solution Given for Myster) in Kan?
sas Town?Water Pure,
Glrard, Koa?, Feb. 19.?No solution
of the mystery that developed a
month ago when water in the city*.-;
wells 1,200 feet deo;>, rose to 120
degrees, was offered in a report by
C. A. Haskins, State engineer, made
today to city officials. Mr. Haskins
said he could not lind no cause for
I the heat, but pronounced the water
pure. The water's temperature now
is 90 desreces.
Girard Officials received hundreds
of letters from all parts of the United
States asking about the water. One
letter concluded: "Kansas people are
a\\ I ill liars."
DO irOU KEEP BEES?
Or, Do You Feel Interested in BCC
koeplng?
In either case please send your
name and address on a postal card
1 to the undersigned, at Sumter, s. C. I
will be glad to mail you a catalogue
j
1 and price list of Bee Keeping Sup
I plis lor 1914, and also to give Other
Information that may be desired.
Money is the most healthful und
nutritious sweet to la- obtained, it la
already in form for assimilation, and
can be eaten by dedicate persons.
Those who cannot eat cane syrup
without trouble usually have no
stomach trouble, from eating honey.
There are tons of honey going to
wosto ail around us every year, that
would gathered by ??! few colonies
of lees on every farm. Those who
have fruii trees should keep bees to
InBure an abundananco of fruit, as
the bets pollinate the fruit blossoms
N. Q, ?STREN,
MANY OBSTRUCTIONISTS IN UP?
PER HOUSE DELAY PASSAGE
OF CONSTRUCTIVE
BILLS.
Rules of Body Allow Much Speaking
ami Little Action?Number of bub
Panged by House Held up in Senate
?Members Realise Nearness of
Election and Blow to Vote Either
Way.
Columbia, Peb. 22.?Of questionable
greatness as a deliberative body, the
senate of South Carolina is beyond
j the shadow Of a doubt one of the
most delberate bodies in history. Its
record tor taking the longest time to
I do nothing begs comparison. Cold!
molasses is an express train when!
compared to'the senate.
Of course, ne xt summer there will J
I be an election. Everybody luiOWS
|thL?, but nobody else is taking it to j
hearl ?ko certain obstructionists sen-j
ators, who are such timid, shrinking
j little fellows that not for world: [
j would they allow any of the progrcs
, ilve measures which the house has
I passed to come up In the senate, in
j the 11 ret place, they might have to
vote on them, which would be a great
blow to their modesty, in the second
place, the people might be told next
summer how they voted on them,
whii h would put them to the trou?
ble of explaining, in the thrid
place, it is better to let what is, be?,
especially just before election.
Volum a might be written without
half telling the shuddering abhor?
rence with which these obstructionist
? nators regard Hie Mlley bill to.
safeguard primary elections, the
Lawson-Harper-McCravey bill to re?
quire children between the ages of 8
and 12 years to attend school after a
majority of the electors in any school
district vote in favor of it, the Har?
per bill to require the registration oi
all births and deaths in South Caro?
lina, or any one of a half dosen otlu r
1 iils of a constructive nature which
the house has sent to the senate and
Which are either buried in a senate
committee or are resting In peace on
the senate calendar.
I Cue thing is Well settled ill the
mind of every one who has followed
the halting progress of the South Car?
olina Bcnatf?it is not going to do
anything it does not have to do In
the way of legislation, cxc? lit pOSS tie-,
approprialh n bill and the county sup?
ply bill, at this session. Of course
the appropriation bill must become a
law, or there Won't la' any of those
nice little green ami blue warrants!
on the Siat - treasurer to pay the m n
ator's board bills, etc,
I*; somebody had only thought ol
timing the length of the varioui
speeches In the South Carolina sen.de
this session, ami adding up the total
lime, the people Would have been
surprised at the number ol hours
spent in talking. Ev? rybody knows
that in the legislature there are two
purposes to whieh Bpeech-maklng can
be put. The lust, and only excusable
one. of these is to explain a bill. The
second, and very reprehensible one,
of these is t<> kill time on one bill
to prevent some other bill from com?
ing up. Unfortunately for progressive
legislation, the senate has not adopt
cd a time limit on speeches. In the
in use for the past three ir fo?r
weeks, no member, except the auth?
or of a bill, could speak more than
10 minutes, and then not more than
twice on the same subject. Conse?
quently, the time for voting on a bill
comes comparatively quick in the
house. But, in the senate, lung ca?
pacity alone places a limit on speech?
es. It is very hard to tell sometimes
In the senate whether a senator is
speaking to obstruct or to hasten leg?
islation. Motives are dillicult and
dangerous things to try to assign to a
human being. There are men in the
general assembly who hold that when
the issues are well defined on any
measure spechifying does not change
a single vote. Many speeches are in?
tended lor home consumption ind
when the newspapers do not print
them fully enough to please the
speakers, having no ink to waste and
while paper costing like fury a pound,
how the heathen rage!
There are men of action In the sen?
ate who would like to see some of the
progressive measures the house has
passed become laws, but they are as
helpless as new- born babe under the
ruh which allows the obetructiontata
to speak forever and ever, amen.
FERTILIZER TRAFFIC HEAVY.
Hi veral Tiainloads Arrive from Char?
leston Daily.
The fertilizer season has set In
heavy now, the traffic for the past
Wi ? k having been about the same as
that which was experienced last SSSv
son in the heaviest part of the sea*
son. Daily two or three trajnloada
come In or pass through here from
Charleston, the shipping point.
A n< w system has been tri*- 1 of late
In the shipping of fertilizers, a system
which bids fair to prevent congestion
and delays in handling of the season's
output. As soon as the trains arrive
at the point e>f destination the crew
makes up another train of empties and
at once returns to the shipping point.
In this way the crews are not kept
on duty for more than sixtee n hours
at a time and the shippers secure cars
to till, while at the other end of the
haul, the ears are being emptied.
One additional engine has been add?
ed to the yard force during the day
to aid in taking care of th? added traf?
fic: during the fertiliser season. This
makes a force of three shiftin, er >ws
..t work dining ihn day and one at
night on thi? local Ircight yard.
Besides the fertiliser t rathe other
traffic h is been good, the inc rease be*
inj; steady every month since last
June.
WILL NOT HASTEN ACTION.
British Ambassador Says ills Govern*
incut Will Wall on lulled State*.
Washington, Pen, IS.?At the Brit?
ish embassy Ambassador Spring
Rice announced that his government
will take no action in the BentOU C USB
Until the state department commu?
nicates the results of its investigation
to him. The ambassador wishes it
understood that he will not press the
state department for action In the
Benton c ase. He is fully satisfied thai
the United states will submit < 1 ''r
and impartial report of conditl 'tis
surrounding the execution ol Benton.