The watchman and southron. (Sumter, S.C.) 1881-1930, June 07, 1913, Image 8
NAMING THE LOBBYISTS.
HOMK SF. NATO IIS KNOW TIIF.
AUKNTH OF SPFCIAL INTLR
TFRFSTS.
^nai-.r Knivi swum That Well
Known Facts Justify F.vcry Wonl
I'ttrretl by President Wilson ? In?
vestigating May l*rod m ? ic.-ult
1 -
Waehlngt< i. June 3.?"Social lob?
bying' In Washington Justifies every
word President Wilson uttered In re?
gard to the presence of an "Insidious"
lobby at the capltol, Senator Kenyon
of Iowa declared on the witness stand
today before the senate Investigating
committee. It was the first un?
equivocal statement in support of 'he
president's attitude since the inquiry
began.
The Iowa senator explained that hi
balteved the most "insidious" und
powerful lobbying possible was the
practice of flattering senators by hav?
ing them out to dinners, to theatres
and on automobile rides, kngrutlatlnrf
the host with the distinguished guests.
Pointing to the sworn testimony of
Edward Hlnes. "a lumber king," be?
fore the Lorlmer election investiga?
tion that he entertained senators at a
local hotel at dinners at a time when
the lumber schedule In the Payne
Aldrich bill was before the senate,
Senator Kenyon declared It was his
belief that senators were being en?
tertained In this "insidious" way at
present.
He also denounced ex-senators for
capitalising their privilege of the
floor by using It to lobby. Referring
to one ex-senator representing many
railroads in Washington and often
seen on the floor of the senate, he ad?
vocated the enactment of legislation
to prohibit an ex-senator from being
a lobbyist.
Senator Hughes of New Jersey and
Senator James of Kentcuky told the
investigators for the first time of the
trials and tribulations of majorltv
members of the finance committee
with the many persons who had flock?
ed to Washington to present their
views. Neither knew of any attempts
to corrupt senators, but both de?
clared they could have done better
work If they had been bothered less.
These senators, as did Senator La
Fellefte, who followed thern on the
stand, suggested that legislation for
registration of lobbyists would be a
good thing.
Several senators let It be known
today that they had received by reg?
istered mail what purported to be a
reproduction of a letter from the
American Cane Growers Association
of,the Cnited States sent to members
asking for contributions to a fund for
the use of "a large committee in
Washington." The copy was dated
"New Orleans. April 2, 1913," and
read as follows:
"Dear Sirs: Your sssociation has a
large committee in Washington now
using every effort possible to try to
aave the sugar Industry.
"We have hesitated about calling
on you but as we are now overdrawn
In the bank. It Is absolutely neces?
sary that we have funds at once und
therefore call on you to please send
one-half of your subscription, say b
cents per 1.000 pounds on the crop
Of 1911.
'This la very Important and v..
would like to have remittances at
once.
"Yours very truly,
(Signed) "Charles A. Farwell."
"Preslden
The copy came In an envelop.- post
marked Washington on the back of
which In Ink was written the nume,
W L Base.
Senator Runsdell, who received one
of the letters, said the American Cane
Orowers* Association had BOOS *n ex?
istence for ten years or more, that
It maintained an office in New Or?
leans and conducted an open cam?
paign In behalf of the sugar pro?
ducers of I*oulslanu. He adde 1 that
for several weeks the orgam iztion
had kept an office In a Washington
skyscraper with its name over the
door
The letter did not appear In tin
lobby Investigation, but it proba -l
will
It was reported tonight gsOfi than
two score suhoocnas ha<t . n Leute.|
by the committee for witnesses who
it Was believed might be able, to
throw light on the methods of
the alleged sugar lobby*1 mid
to have been established here
when the tariff hill was taken Hp
Member* of the sesnmlttee declined
to discuss those who had been sum?
moned, but It was acW ,,,.w ledged un
officially that high .fibers of the so
called "sugar trust" were among those
summoned.
President Wilson, it was reported,
had furnished a number of names
Which appeared on the subpoenas
Hoth the White House and the COSS
mltt**emen wert* silent on the sunjcct.
j
Mone-llodge.
' Married I o<? I hui sda\ in Manning
by the Rev M. J. Klser. of Paxvllbv
Mr Hsrney RhHt Hodge und Man
Dorothy Stone, both of Paxvllle
DO TRUSTS OBEY COURT ?
CONTEMPT of COURT PROCEED
INgs OONflDBRRD against
STANDARD oil co.
s|HH'iai i{? 'jm ?i i of Attorneys IMscuesed
lly Wilson Administration?Viola?
tion of Court's Orders in Tobacco
Case Rgejgtv*i Attention.
Washington. June ?Whether de?
cree* 0)1 tile Cnited States court dis?
membering the Standiird oil and To?
bacco "trusts" are being tarried out
was considered today by the Wilson
administration with a view to possi?
ble institution of the most ImportantI
anti-trust moves yet contemplated by'
the president and Attorney General
Mejteynolds.
In the Standard Oil case the at?
torney general received from Charles
H. Morrison ami Oliver Pagan, his
special assistants, a report of the re?
sults of their investigation of condi?
tions In the oil industry and began
consideration of the question whether
v.ie facts disclosed will Justify the
department of justice In beginning
contempt of court or criminul pro?
l ? edings against oil interests on
charges of violations of the dissolu?
tion deeree. Tonight this question was
unsettled.
In the tobacco case practically the
entire meeting of the cabinet was de?
voted to considering whether surface
? onditions in the tobacco trade war?
rant the attorney general In begin?
ning an investigation similar to that
Just finished In the Standard Oil case,
to detern ine whether the decree of
dissolution is being violated and
whether all semblance of a "tobacco
trust" has disappeared. The attor?
ney general after the meeting was
noncommittal as to whether the In?
quiry will be undertaken.
Consideration of the workings ol
the decrees in the two big cases?
the Standard oil at the cabinet meet?
ing and the tobacco at the depart?
ment of justice?took place today ap?
parently by coincidence. Around the
"rule of reason" principles first enun?
ciated by the United States supreme
court in these cases, has been built
ptuetlcally all of the anti-trust lit?
igation since. The opinions have been
the guiding stars for the attorney
general, so far as the Sherman anti?
trust law is concerned.
Mr. Mclteynolds, who as special as?
sistant to the attorney general orig?
inally prosecuted the "tobacco trust,'*
has been studying the workings of the
decree ever since he er.tered the cab?
inet. It Is known that he disagreed
with forme; Attorney General Wiek?
ersham as to the adequacy of tue
adopted plan of disintegration. It bat
been understood that his objections
centered around the pro rata distri?
bution among shareholder of the
trust" of stock of the 14 corpora?
tions into which the American To?
bacco company was disintegrated. II?
was quoted at the time as saying the
plan deserved "an expeditious com?
mitment to the scrap heap."
The report made to the attorney
general by Messrs. Morrison and Pa
gun In the oil case |g the result of
several months' investigation. They
have studied conditions in various
localities and paid particular atten?
tion to the soaring prices of oil.
Their conference with the attorney
general today was inconclusive and
it will be continued tomorrow. The
nature of their Undings has not been
made public.
In the preliminary report made to
format Attorney General Wlckersham
Just before hi retired from other these
attorneys declared that their then
partial Investigation raised a serious
doubt as to whether the standard OH
trust had been actually dissolved.
They found that unfair competition
bad bOta eliminated and the last few
months of their investigation have
been largely devoted to an effort to
j ascertain whether the control and
management of the disintegrated
parts of the "trust" and the con
trol of the prices of oil still are dl
i ei t*d by the same concentrated In?
tetests as previously*
G1TLTY or FORGERY,
-
Young Mao Confesses to Charge
Against 1 link?Was Law|er anil De?
UnHlia,
Manning?, June i?c. m. Iteyonlds,
?rhu came to Manning ;t year ago and
hung out his shingle for the practice
of law. m the court of general eea?
?Ions today pleaded guilt) to ? charge
of forgery. He was sentenced to s[?end
one year In the sei sic- of ?in- State,
but the sentence was suspended lin ?
ing good behavior, it will be en?
foread if n South Carolins grand Jury
in the future buds ? tine bill against
the defendant charging ?liy offense.
Keynobls toda> told the court that
he Ml only II years of age and has
never been admitted to the practice
of law in this Mate. He said, how?
ever, that he bad !><?? n admitted |o
the hat ol I lorida.
He announced that he i aim |o Man?
ning as a goto* live
He Infi Manning I his nfteri.n In
a n aulom ddle.
MACHINE POLITICIAN BRAZEN.
HITCHCOCK PROUD OF THE WAY
HE MANIPULATED POST
OFFICE,
in K<-|?i\ u> Iteport <>r Burleeon Com?
mlttce Report Assort* Thut state?
ments arc UrstltUtlotte and 'Inac?
curate?Kcitcmtcs Claim That He
Made Department Self-sustaining.
Silver City, N. M., June 3.?On ar
rivlni at stiver City today from the
liogollon mountains, where he has
been spending some wet its, former
Postmaster General Hitchcock was
shown the statement issued a few
days ago by Postmaster General Hur
leson, attacking his administration of
the poetOfftce department. Mr. Hitch?
cock issued the following statement:
"A committee, composed in the
main of newlv appointed assistants,
having less than three months' ex?
perience in postofllce business at
i tempts in a report to the present head
of the department to discredit the
financial showing made by the postal
service under President Taft s admin?
istration.
"After reporting alleged discrep?
ancies that are insignificant when
compared with the great sums known
to have been saved by their predeces?
sors, this committee of novitiates
proceeds in its published statement
to enlighten the American people as
to the character of the postal service
they have been receiving. Their
statement is as inaccurate as it is
i gratuitous, for the public well knows
that never was the postal service con?
ducted more efficiently or mail han?
dled With greater precision and dis?
patch than in the closing years of
the Taft administration. During that
administration nearly o.OOO new post
offices were established, delivery by
letter carriers was provided in about
300 additional cities and over 3,000
new rural routes, aggregating about
75,000 miles, were authorized.
"Notwithstanding the great exten?
sions of service and the heavy in?
crease, in expenditures they required,
the postofllce department was plaVed
on a self-sustaining basis and fhat
was itH condition when on the 4th
of lejaTCh it passed into the hands of
newly appointed officers who .seem
thus far to have been exhausting
their time and their energies in a
vain attempt to detract from the rec?
ord made by the devoted public ser?
vants they succeeded.
"The postal committee of the DeMo
cratie house of congress endeavored
last year in a similar manner to at?
tack the and.ted accounts of the pos?
tal service, but after Investigation
that committee was fair enough to
admit that the department had be?
come substantially self-sustaining.
The returns as to surplus or deficit
sr?- Djade up not by the Postofllce de?
partment but by the treasury depart?
ment where all postal income is re?
ceived and all postal accounts linally
audited.
"The secretary of the treasury re?
ported the wiping out of the postal
deficit and the record thus certified
to In his fiscal report Is likely to
stand in history."
JIM CROW LAW DISCUSSED.
Conference Between H. It. Commis?
sion and Attomei for Pullman Com?
paay.
Columbia, June :j.?o. s. Fernsld,
general counsel for the Pullman
Company today held a conference with
the members of the railroad com?
mission of South Carolina relative to
negroes riding in Pullmans. The con?
ference follows the sending of a let?
ter by the commission to the com?
pany complaining of a negro riding ir
one of the cars of the company in
South Carolina, it was announced
today that the commission had ad?
dressed a letter calling for the cooper?
ation of all the Statea of the South In
an attempt to se< uro legislation to
prevent negroes from using the same
cars as the white passengers.
COLUMBIA TO HAVE RACING.
JockOS Club of New York Proposes
?0-Day Meet this Fall.
-
Columbia, June 4,?That a thirty
day racing meet will be held in Co?
lumbia in November or December
prior to the te xt racing meet in
Charleston was the statement tar?
ried this afternoon hj tin- Columbia
Itcord in a promim-ntly displayed
Story. This publication gives the in?
formation that the time has not been
definitely decided on, hul that it will
pr. < < ile the nexl Charleston meet, and
that it will be held under the aus?
pices t?f the Jockey <'iui? ol New
Voik A thirty-day racing meet took
plate in Colombia in Ihe latter pari
ot I11, ami it a ill be recalled it re
suited in failure, it is said that the
same parties who backed that meet
are behind the movement lo get the
111111\ day meet this fall.
The cotton crop i- improving ami
there have been nu complaints of
gl H*<S.
SECTION OF TARIFF BILL RELAT?
ING TO INCOME TAX MIST
BE AMENDED.
Officers <>t* Mutual Insurance Compa?
nies Claim That They Will be Taxed
Twice and Declare Measure Unjust.
Washington, Tun?* 4.?Before the
senate acts on the Underwood tariff
hill the Income tax section will be
amended to remedy a defect which,
it was discovered today, would make
the measure unconstitutional. When
the framers of the income tax pro?
vision fixed January 1, 1913, as the
date from which to compute incomes
for taxation, they overlooked the fact
I I
that the constitutional amendment
authorizing an income tax was not
proclaimed as ratified until February
25, 1913.
I This fact was brought to the atten?
tion of the senate finance subcommit?
tee Which has the income tax under
consideration and an amendment
probably will be drafted at once.
I 1
Aside from the constitutional de?
fect arguments have been presented
in favor of making the taxable in?
come accrue for the first year from
July 1 or later. As far as the con?
stitutional limitation is concerned, it
would be legal to compute incomes
for 1913 from March 1.
Senator Williams' .subcommittee
still has under advisement the scores
of protests Hied by officials of mu?
tual life insurance companies against
their inclusion under the provisions of
the income tax law and the commit?
tee still is considering an ame ndment
which would give such mutual con?
cerns exemption if they are able to
prove, after the tax has been assessed,
that they are not conducted for profit
and that all of their surplus earnings
are participated in by their policy
holders.
Among the briefs on this subject
fded with the subcommittee is one
by B. Steiner, a business man of
Birmingham, Ala., which includes
corresepondence with Representative
Underwood, chairman of the house
ways and means committee. In a
letter to Mr. Underwood Mr. Steiner
cited the objections to taxing incomes
of mutual life insurance companies,
maintaining that this would result in
a tax on the policyholders, who would
really be taxed twice. Replying to
tnis Mr. Underwood wrote:
" Von seem to ove rlook the fact en?
tirely that these companies are be?
ing taxed under the present corpora
tlon tax at exactly the same amount
as they will be taxed in our income
tax; that wo are not levying on them
what they do not pay at present. An
ordinary corporation is organized for
the benefit of its stockholders; a mu?
tual life insurance company is or?
ganized for the benefit of its policy
holders In one instance the indivi?
dual holds the stock, in the other in?
stances the corporation is operated to
earn dividends or net profits for his
benefit."
In reply Mr. Steiner epitomized
the arguments of the insurance; presi?
dents and others who are working
for an amendment to the sections as
follows:
' When you state that the tax pro?
posed under the income tax bill is
for life insurance companies, sub?
stantially a continuation of the pres?
ent corporation tax, you are in gen?
eral terms correct, but not altogether
so. The federal court holds, under
the present corporation tax, that so
called dividenda in companies operat?
ing on the mutual plan are not divi?
dends and can be deducted by a com?
pany in making its returns. The lan?
guage of the present bill clearly di?
rects that these aocalled dividends
shall not be deducted, and therefore
that they shall enter Into the net in?
come of a company for purpose's of
taxation.
"Moreover, by Implication at bast,
under this bill, every maturing en?
dow nmerit and every cash surrender
value amounting in any individual
: case of $4,OUU or over would be lax
eel; and if such payments, plus thu
other income of the recipient, amount
to $4,000, it will also be taxed. This
phase of the tax would not fall on a
company's nel Income, but will be a
direc t and heavy burden on indivi?
duals to whom the payments are
made.'
Action by the subcommittee, to be
ratified by the llnunce committee, in
putting live stork ami grain on the
free list, returning on the free list also
meats, Hour and oatmeal, it is uxpect
|cd. will arouse protests from farmers
and farm organizations, bul the com?
mittee will hold to this solution of the
problem presented in the Underwood
bill ol equalising agricultural raw im
lerials and then produc Is,
The senate llnunce subcommittee,
which has been wrestling with the
iigrlcultt ai schedule and which de?
tided yesterday upon the free listing
ol live stock and wheat, is reported
tonight to be undecided as yet on its
report regarding oats ami buckwheat.
Vpparently there still is some dispo
it ion to recommend that a duty be
retained on both, The subcommittee,
originally voted pot a duty <n
oats of six cents a bushel
dispensary auditor mitch um
therefore: reduces roy?
alty on beer.
Charleston Breweries Bay Less to
State So That They can Meet ? om
petition of Wholesale Hliiul Tigers
in "City by the Sea."
Columbia, June 5.?Harvey W.
Mitchum, state dispensary auditor,
said yesterday that he had ordered
the royalty paid by three breweries
in Charleston to the dispensary board
reduc ed from l"? cents to cents on
each "box" of beer because the
"wholesale blind tiger dealers in
beer" could sell cheaper on account
of the extra amount paid by the other
breweries.
Dispensary Auditor Mitchum said
that the Charleston county dispensary
board does business regularly with
three local beer bottling establish?
ments. According to a dispatch from
Charleston received by The State the
breweries are conducted by James S.
Parnum, Henry Doe scher and H. R.
Bremer. In addition the board buys
Lemps, Pabst, Budweiser beers regu?
lativ and other beers on demand, the
companies having no resident man?
agers.
"I reduced the royalty from 4."
cents to 2"> cents on the box because
the wholesale blind tiger beer deal?
ers could afford to sell beer cheaper
to the dealer* than the county dis?
pensary," said Dispensary Auditor
Mitchum, yesterday.
According to figures announced by
the dispensary auditor the sales by
during the past three months have
the dispensaries in Charleston county
been decreased by about $26,000. He
attribute* the decrease to the "blind
tieers.'
WILL LIMIT IT'S ACTIVITIES.
Tariff, Currency. Emergency Ap?
propriation and Election Coses
only to Be Considered by Congress.
Washington, June 2.?House Dem?
ocrats In caucus today restricted the
legislative programme of the extra
session to tariff, currency, emergency
appropriation, election <v.ses. Com?
mittee assignments as submitted 1}
chairman Underwood and his col"
league* of the ways and means com?
mittee majority, were adopted by
the caucus without change. The pro?
gramme, as presented by Representa?
tive Underwood, was made binding
on Democratic members of the house
'standing committees. The resolution
by which this was accomplished pro?
vided that no standing committees?
except the committees on ways and
means, appropriations, banking and
i currency, elections, printing, account!
and rules?shall report bills or reso?
lutions to the house or have them
placed on the calendar without per?
mission expressly granted by the
Democratic caucus. The caucus
chose Representative Shaekleford of
Missouri for chairman of the new
committee on good roads and named
Representative Dickinson of Missouri
to succeed him as member of tho
ways and means committee.
While the committee list was under
consideration Representatives Boeher
{
of Missouri and Tribble of Georgia
complained that Representatives
M?her of New York and Hensley of
Missouri had been "jumped to make
room for Representative Lewi* of
I
Maryland, as chairman of the com?
mittee on labor. Mr. Lewis was rank?
ed by the other two members on the
committee in the last congress Rep?
resentative Tribble said if organized
labor was to dictate the selection of
a chairman of the house committee
on labor he would like to know why
bankers should not dictate the chair?
manship of the banking and currency
committee, farmers the agriculture
committee and so on.
The caucus gave Representative
Lloyd of Missouri a silver being CUD
in appreciation of his service as
chairman of the Democratic congres?
sional committee. Representative
Palmer, presenting the cup eulogized
Mr. Lloyd's management of various
campaigns.
WILL order election.
Su|M*rvisor Receives Petitions for Vote
on Dispensary.
Florence, June 15.-The petition::
for an election on doing awas with
the dispensary have been handed to
tin- count) supervisor. He sayi thai
as far as he has knowledge they ale
strictly m accordance with the re?
quirements of law, and he will order
the election to be held 111 AUgUSt,
The prohibitionists have an excellent
organization, with committees large?
ly ni experienced prohibition lighters.
The otln r Hide is unorganized as yet,
but will probably get in line soon foi
a tight to retain the Institution. Ilotb
sides geem confident ol bihm ess.
Florence has voted wet In the elec?
tions held previously, bj a small ma?
jority. The sentiment at Lake City is
a new eb nient in the county, and both
sides seem to count that section with
them in the Ughl
AMBASSADOR CHINDA PRESENTS
NOTE PROM JAP, AN TO SEC?
RETARY BRYAN.
Statement is >1 in Terms ami In?
vites further Discuss tow or < on
troverted Potato?Why the Webb
Ad Is Discriminatory and Violates
Treaty.
Washington, June 4.?Japan's re?
joinder to the Tinted States reply to
her protest against the California
anti-alien land law, delivered person?
ally by Ambassador Chinda to Secre?
tary Bryan late today, sets out why
the Tokyo government continues to
regard the Webb law as discrimina?
tory against Japan in derogation of
the equality of treatment prescribed
by international law and a violation of
the treaty of 1910.
Nothing in the nature of an ultima?
tum is contained in the note. Its
general tone is to invite further dis?
cussion of the controverted points,
and it contains nothing tending to
i.lake up a final issue. Secretary Bry?
an and the ambassador agreed that no
details should be made public.
Ambassador Chinda went to the
state department by appointment just
before 4 o'clock. Merely acknowledg?
ing receipts of the note and promising
to consider, Secretary Bryan requested
the ambassador to wait while he read
the communication and when he had
finished there was an informal discus?
sion.
Secretary Bryan was deeply inter
ested in the points made in the
Japanese rejoinder, which are be?
lieved to have been directed to the end
of demonstrating that the action of
the California legislature, taken in
connection with the recent action of
the Arizona legislature and the pro?
jected legislation in other Western
Staus tended to impair the equality
of treatment to which Japanese were
entitled under the general principles
of international law, more than to the
charge that the Webb act constituted
a technical violation of the treaty of
191a between Japan and the United
States
The Japanese ambassador was St
the department for an hour and a
half. He returned to the embassy
tu prepare a reply to his government
? . .? sating the nature of the reception
of Its communication by the state de?
partment.
Secretary Bryan went directly to
the White House, where he left the
Japanese note for the perusal and
consideration of President Wilson. It
is expected that when Counsellor
Moore returns to Washington tomor?
row he will be called into conference
by the president and Secretary Bryan
to consider the outline of a response.
The Japanese note was very long
and of its nature entirely argumen?
tative. Secretary Bryan and Ambassa?
dor Chinda were in accord that no
good purpose could be served at this
time by a public discussion of the
delicate question, and therefore both
officials gave notice that any attempt
to publish what might purport to be
even the substance of the three com?
munications which now have passed
between the two governments must be
based entirely upon speculation. It is
known, however, that the whole tone
of the rejoinder today is that of a
dignified and orderly presentation of
Japan's view of the case, concluding
With an invitation to further negotia?
tions.
SPARTANS UNDER BLUE LAWS.
-
Social Clubs Only Places to Slake
Thirst on Sundays.
Spartanburg, June 4.?The lid was
down tight In Spartanburg Sunday?
that is, so far as the sale of soda wa?
ter. Ice cream, cigars and cigarettes
was concerned. For the drat time in
years the ordinance forbidding the
sale of anything but medicine on
Sunday was enforced to the letter. It
was one cd' the beutest days of the
'year, too, but neither money nor tear?
ful entreaties were able to procure
cold soda with which one might coed
his parched and burning throat.
It is true one drug store took out a
lunch Stand license and sold butter?
milk and soda crackers, but this was
tin- only place where one could slake
his thirst legally and respectably.
The social clubs at which lager
beer is dispensed are reported to
have done the largest day's business
in many a month. Tin? club pro?
prietors wore pleaaed smiles and said
they we re not In the b ast opposed to
the enforcement of the "blue laws'
The Itaraca classes endorsed the
"blue laws." aise?. So it eenms as
though evcrybod) ought to have been
satislled.
People from the OswegO and St
Charles sections report a very severe
thunder .>te?rm e?ut that way Wednes
day afternoon, accompanied by an
extremely heavy fail of rain.
The rain Wednesday evening was
sufficient to cool off the atmosphere
fen a while- and lav the dust impio\
Ing weather conditions over Wednes?
day.