The watchman and southron. (Sumter, S.C.) 1881-1930, February 08, 1913, Image 7
INCOMK TAX \MK\l?flM \W>
KD TO (ONM ITITIOX.
With lUttflcailon by ;ih Slate* Six
tecnth Kiuh Section I-. \nw Part of
KuiMlamriital Uw of Hit- l .imI?It
Provide* for 1 ?Irret Tuxr* on F-ani
tng* of C h i/?? 11x <.f \n> Stair. With?
out Reference to Population?Hill
Kmbodtlng l*ro|MK??l Will he In?
troduced at Speeial Session of Ncxi
Cougrem
'.'ashlngton. I ? t. -Direct tales
on the incomes of citizens of the
Cnlted States, whether derived from
idle capital or from the conduct of
business, were made possible today by
ratification of the 16th amendment
to the federal constitution. Delaware
Wyoming and New Mexico indorsed
the Income tax amendment through
their respective legislatures, complet?
ing a list of 38 States that have ap?
proved it. two more than the three
fourths necessary for its tlnal adop?
tion.
Following is the list of States which
ratified the income tax amendment:
Alabama, Arkansas. Arizona, Califor?
nia, Colorado, Georgia, Idaho. Illinois,
Indiana, Iowa. Kansas, Kentucky,
Maine. Maryland, Michigan. Minne?
sota. Mississippi. Missouri. Montana,
Nebraska, Nevada, New Mexico, New
York. North C-irol'na, North Dakota,
I >V lahoma, Cregon. South Carolina,
South Dakota. Tennessee. Texas,
Washington. Wisconsin. Louisiana,
?hlo. West Virginia, Wyoming.
The following rejected it: Connect!
,t. New Hampshire, lthode Island,
fUh
Ri action, or only partial act? >n,
-was taken in the eight other Stab s.
Leaders in congress predicted to?
night that through this authorization
the law which will be passed to levy
the tax upon American Incomes will
be Introduced as soon as the extra
session opens. Its exact terms have
not been decided upon, but It Is be?
lieved it will exempt all Incomes be?
low $4,000 or $5,000 and wlii provide
<i tax of 1 pefl cent upon the majority
of personal Incomes that do not run
to an excessive figure.
Informal notice of the final adop
| I of the new amendment was given
to tbe senate by Senator Brown of
Nebraska, who introduced the resolu?
tem in 1909 upon which the proposal
for an Income tax was submitted to
the States. Drafting of the bill to
put the tax in effect. It is expected.
* ill fall to the lot of Representative
Hull of Tennessee, a member of, tho
house ways and means committee, i
who drrw the excise tax bill proposed
last year by th?* Democratic house,
but which did not become law.
The Income tax will be designed to
supplant the present corporation tax
and will apply to the Incomes of In?
dividuals, firms and corporations. In
a statement tonight, RoBfeex ntative
Hull declared he favored making the
new tax an integral part of the finan?
cial system of the Patted Mates to
remain In full force without regard to
fh# -haracter of tariff bills that con
may enpri from time to time.
I feature, which It is adieved
SJ included In the law, will be
don for "collecting at the source"
of the in ome. This feature, now in
operation in England, would require
firms to certify to amounts they pay
to Individuals in salaries or fees or
pay the tax direct to the government
it is nottevee' this would remove much
complaint that might be made if the
government had to investigate every
cltlxen's income and would prevent
evasion of law.
The annual amount that the gov
, ernment may realise under the In?
come tax Is estimated by Democratic
leaders In congress at approximately
$100,000,000.
This would Include the $;in,ouo,(?00
' ;l. cted und. r the present corpora?
tion tax.
? me of the Important result! of
an income tax.' said Representative
Hull, "will be the curbing < f unneces?
sary federal expenditures. When a
great part of the governments in?
come is derived by a direct ;ax upon
the citizens of the nation they will
scrutinise more carefully the appro
prlatlon? made by congress.'*
Probably It will remain for Presi?
dent-elect WWson to make official an?
nouncement of the Income tax amend?
ment is the ' onstitntioa\
I., date the State department htm
re-.i\e.| imin.H of approval by the
legislatures of onlv 14 States. West
vtrginit. Delaware, Wjeasing aad
New Mexbn not basing reported on
their notion. Th. department can not
Hot upon earthing less ihan the of
total certificate of Hie governors and
?gl i et it |?Si of State
K\ en w io n ah of ihe rertlfl< I
are at hand. Ike executive will not
be In a position formally to announce
that fuel In a matter ol H import?
ance, it is necessary la move with es
ire me caution and Heeretarj Knox,
the custodian of tin certlfh des, will
i?fer the at to the sollcltoi of ins d<
pirtrnent of stale for examination
ns to their soiii? lerne)
Already some questions have been
raised as to the legality of the i
turn?. One was in the rase of Ken?
tucky, where the legislature Initially
adopted the amendment In advance of
the receipt from Secretary Kimx of
the formal communication which
should serve as a basis for a State'!
notion, n clonaoquncc of this haste,
and the use of a newspaper clipping)
the language of the enacting resolu?
tion was slightly erroneous. As soon
M the error was discovered an at?
tempt was niadu to correct it by reen
ectlon, in consequence of this haste,
which had raised the issue, it is re
Onlled that Secretary Scward In 1818
practically referred to congress the
question whether the 14th amendment
had been properly ratified by the
States because of some such irregu?
larity.
It Is probable that Secretary Knox
will not announce the ratification of
the amendment upon the basis of the
returns but will await the receipt of
certificates from some of the States
which havo not yet acted on the
amendment, but are reasonably cer?
tain to do so favorably. In tbls case
and allowing for the time required for
a painstaking examination by the so?
licitor, It probably will be after the
fourth of March before the president's
notice can Issue of the addition of the
income tax amendment.
BEACH TRIAL TUESDAY.
Millionaire New Yorker Before Court
Tills Week on Charge of Slashing
Throat of Wife. Kfgrem Star Wit
net**.
Alken. S. C, Feb. 2.?Tuesday,
about noon, in the court of general
sessions in Aiken. Solicitor Gunter will
sound the case of the State vs. Fred?
erick O. Beach, millionaire New
Yorker, on a charge of assault and
battery with intent to kill. The State
will contend that Beach, through Jeal?
ousy. Htruck his wife, formerly Mrs.
Htvemeyer, on the head with a fence
paling of the Beach winter home in
Alken, on the night of February 8f>,
last.
Mr. and Mrs. Meach and Mrs. J. B.
Taller, of New York, Mrs. Beach s
sister, are in Aiken nwalting the
sounding of the case. Mr. Beach will,
when arraigned, enter a plea of not
guilty, and the court will proceed to
strike a Jury from citizens of Aiken
county.
The State's star witness in the pros?
ecution of the case will be a negro
woman, by the name of Pea?] Hamp?
ton, who. they will seek to show, \\ as
struck down with the same fence pal?
ing used on Mrr. Beach. Just a min?
ute before the attack on Mrs. Beach,
other testimony, it M understood, will
be submitted fr< m an Atlanta detec?
tive who was employed by the city
of Alken to work up the case.
The principal witness for the de?
ft rise will be Mrs. Ib ach, herseh, who
will reiterate the story she told the
night of the attack, that she hoa~d
someone at the front gate of the resi?
dence, went out to see who it was
and found a negro man wearing an
overcoat standing outside the gate.
She said at the time that the negro
bad a note in his hand, which he said
had been sent to an inmate of the
Beach home. As he extended his hand
to give her the note, and she was
nbOUt to take it, the negro jumped at
lo r and salihod her throat. Imme?
diate?, she says, the negro made hi*"
Saeaps, In the attack Mrs. Beach lo*t
a back comb from her hair and an
Ser-ring, both of Which were later
found, and which will be offered in
evidence, as Will the knife which Mr
I'.each is said to have used.
The ones will probably be concluded
in one day, and acquittal is expected.
SCHOOL TROUBLE AT MANNING.
tnfortunate Disruption Threatened
for Linie to Result In an Indefinite
mnspesMAon of CSuasea,
Manning, Feb. |, ?An unfortunate
dtsruptkm took plate In the- Manning
graded nnd hiuh school last Friday
which for a time looked as if it might
result in an Indefinite suspension of
the anhool it appeari that s ques?
tion Ol discipline fof infraction of
tubs by some of the pupils having
been referred to and ruled upon by
the trustees, a majority of the faculty
tendered their resignations. They
wer,- requested by the 'trustees to re?
consider the matter, and in the mean?
time Superintendent Newton tendered
his resignation, which was accepted
by tie' trust?rs This morning work
was resumed as usual In the lust
gra??e, but tie- other teachers held
off until MaJ \ Levl on behalf of
tin trustees announced thai the reg?
ular ? \e i < i., i would i>e resumed to?
morrow niornlnn with Miss Vlolel
Brow n. on, of I le hi lt m I.I <? a- Ii -
? 'IS nCtlnS. U|>e I litte ||e|e nt 11111 it Of
rangements could Im made for .?
.. ssor to Prof \e \n ton Tin fad I hul
tie first grit de work was continued
today by the- regular b icher, Miss
Itichardson, served tu oh late i lol I
suspension of Ihr school for the lime,
Qov. W.111 ? w Wilson hai an?
nounced thai Joseph Patrick Tumulty
will continue as his private secretary
.ion he becomes pr< sldent.
JNO. Y. G ARLINGTON TURNED
LOOSE BY BLEA8E.
Governor Opens Prison dates for Prin?
cipal In Semlnole Steal. Prisoner
on Parole During "Good Behavior**'
1 riform.it Ion received Tuesday
morning la to the effect that John Y.
Qarllngton, one of the principals in
tin- notorious "Semlnole Steal." which
rifled the pockets of the ablest busi?
ness men of this and many other
states about 4 years ago. was today
paroled by Governor Cole L. Blease
"during good behaviour."
Qarllngton has been in the State
Penitentiary for a little over a year.
He was convicted of breach of trust in
connection with the Semlnole swind?
le, and was sentenced to serve 3 years
at hard labor for the State of South
Carolina. Not very long ago Qarllng?
ton was allowed to go to the bed?
side of a sick relative at Laurens; he
was away only a short time, but now
the governor has given him freedom
for as long a time as he will 'be
good."
"The Semlnole Steal." as the case in
which Oarlington was a principal ac?
tor, is familiarly known, has had too
much notoriety already to be un?
familiar to the people of South Caro?
lina and the South In general. Fram?
ed up in a manner that would have
done credit to the most solidly found?
ed corporation In the country, the
Semlnole Securities Company not
only dragged money from the pockets
of modest salaried men seeking in?
vestment, but also took neat piles from
some of the ablest and wealthiest
business men in the State.
The Railroad! and Public Opinion.
Manufacturers Record.
With accustomed perspicuity Presi?
dent W. W. Plnley of the Southern
Railway Co., recently discussed rail?
roads before the Chamber of Com?
merce at New Haven, Conn. In his
consideration of the relation of the
carriers to the public, he began by
quoting from a late magazine article j
by Woodrow Wilson, in which it was
said that a man of eloquence, but
without conscience and reckless of
consequences, could set this whole
country atlame, that is, through the
minds of its people; also that from
end to end of the country it is be?
lieved that something Is wrong. He
likewise quoted from "The Crowd," a
book by Gustave L#e Ron, to illustrate
the great force upon the popular
mind of mere atllrmatlon without rea?
soning or proof, but iterated and re?
iterated so that sifter a time the crowd
believes the affirmation, while for?
getting who made it.
Having thus outlined the danger ex?
istent in present conditions. Mr. Fin
ley said that the striking accord be?
tween the words of Mr. Wilson and
Mr. Le Ron suggests the wisdom of
grounding public opinion in economic
truth concerning the problems of our
day so that affirmation and its repe?
tition alone will not establish the be?
lief that wrongs exist when they do
not. Then he proc eeded to consider
the transportation question.
Bonte Of his statements concerning
the magnitude of railroad business in
the United States are very impres?
sive. One Of them is that the operat?
ing expenses of our railroads in a
\ear would pay for the cost of build?
ing the Panama Canal ($376,000,000)
five times over and yet leave sufficient
to fortify five such canals and build
battleships to defend them; also that
a distinguished authority estimated
the annual requirements of the rail?
roads for additional capital to keep
pace with the growth of traffic and
its demands to be from two to three
times the total COSt of he canal, and,
furthermore, that one railroad bad
Invested In Its property out of its earn?
ings an anount approximating the
canal's cost, and which might have
been distributed In dividends but for
the company'i conservative manage?
ment. He also remarked that the rate
of taxation ol railroad property gen
earally has increased fully ISO per
cent since 1890, and it Is sun increas?
ing.
Discussing railway rates, Mr. Plnley
expressed the opinion thai it Is essen?
tial for the development of transpor?
tation service that it shall he recog?
nised as right for a railway "to make
a charge for each service thai shall
be reasonable as measured by thai
service bavins fair reference to Its sal
ue " He opposed I he Idea of ti\ime
charge s for service so a^ to yield a
pi edctc rminetl rate of net Income,
w hi. It in thought full h nowledge
would demonstrate to "uncconom*
ic und Im possible." He also said t hat
small let Income tor a railroad would
not just if> charges "exorbitant or tin
reasonable as measured by the ser
vi< e pi ? I'm med, ' n. it her w otlld, I irge
tiei incoint justify reduction ol
? bit).. "r< rsonahly low as mensured
bj t hat si andard " * Jon i i nlng this
latter it may be remarked Ihn! ?Iii
t ' uli will pi obably be < ncountered
In anj < ffoi t to obtain popular at ? til
to his expressed conclusion.
Taking up the mattet of wages, the
speaker said he believed that if any
Interruption to railroad service result
ed from a difference between em
ployen and employes the public
should hav< f.rb Information upon
which to base Intelligent opinion as
to the merits Of tin- dispute. In Can?
ada this is accomplished by the in?
dustrial pursuits investigation law,
whi<di statine relies largely upon th<
force of enlightened public opinion.
Mr. Plnley thought, however, that tie
provisions of this law should be adopt?
ed in the Un ted States, but, Instead
of thr ?e members, the special board to
be named in eat n case submitted for
arbitration should have tive mem?
bers, one to be selected by each party
to the controversy, these two to
choose two others, and the two last
named to select the fifth member. Pro?
vision must be made for filling out
the board in the event of protracted
disagreement between the first two
men chosen. He directed attention to
the importance of maintaining service
at all times and to safeguard it from
strikes and lockouts.
One of his most significant utter?
ances was this: "Even under the
most favorable circumstances, how?
ever, the railways cannot return earn?
ings to the property in amounts suf?
ficient to enable them to meet the in?
creasing demands for service. To a
large extent additional carrying ca?
pacity will have to be provided
through the investment of new capi?
tal." He also pointed out that the
cerdit essential to the obtaining of
new capial depends on the proportion
of gross earnings saved as net in?
come, and, furthermore, that railroad
prosperity and the ability of the lines
to adequately perform transportation
depends very largely upon the State of
the public mind toward them. There?
fore, the attitude of the Government
should be to instill into the public
mind confidence in the railways. He
quoted President Hadley of Yale as
saying: "We must lend a hand to
the men who are getting things done.
We shall deal with the problems of
corporate regulation and with the
abuse of corporate management more
effectively if we are willing to appre?
ciate efficient service."
President Finley will undoubtedly
have the sympathy and support of all
fair-.minded men for his conclusion
that the railroads, being regulated to
protect the rights of the public, are
rightly entitled to protection in their
property rights and to enjoy such lib?
erty in their affairs as is necessary to
the success of a busines. None want
the companies to perform transporta?
tion service without profit, for lack of
profit means more serious loss to the
people who use the railroads than it
docs to the railroad companies them
I selves.
Greenville Girl Ends Her Life.
I
Greenville?Rather than leave
home to go to school and angered by
her mother's plea to do so Annie Al?
len a pretty 13-year-old daughter of
Mr. and Mrs. Walter Allen of this city,
yesterday ended her life by shooting
herself through the heart with a 32
Iver Johnson revolver.
Only one bullet was tired, but this
was sufficient to cause instant death
to the pretty little girl. The deed
was committed in an outhouse near
the residence.
The report of the pistol attracted
the attention of her mother, who was
In the house at the time. The mother
rushed out to her daughter, but It was
too late, for the child was Gu n
breathing her last. A physician was
summoned and then the coroner was
notified.
Murriugc License Record.
Marriage licenses were issued Mon?
day to Mr. Jos. m. Werts and Miss
Nora Brunsen of Bumter; also to Mr.
ES. Burchill Hudson and Miss Una Lee
Hudson of Privateer, one colored
couple secured a license Monday, Har?
rison White and Susan B. Washington
of Remlnl.
Geo. H. Hurst,
l M'l || I Mvl It \M> I MUM Ml It
Prompt attention to da) or nlglil
calls.
\l OLD .1 l>. C'KAIG STAN I), 202 V
Main street.
I>a\ Phone 5il?. Night Phone 201.
T"
"Butter-Nut Bread"
A particular loaf for particular
people, none genuine without
the label.
HAVE YOU SEEN
The New Ford?
Ford Cars and a full line
Ford Parts always on b
Come in and take a lov
D. C. SHAW
The Ford
SUMTER. S. C.
They Have Arrived
Seed Irish Potatoes
We liave just received our first shipment of the famous old
IRISH COBBLERS, EARLY ROSE, and RED BUSS. We have
them in any quantity; buy them by the quart or at extra otogaj
price by the sack. I^ct us have your orders early, as now is the
time to begin planting for early table use.
SPECIAL: We are exporting daily a shipment of FROST
PROOF CABBAGE PLANTS. Let us have your orders for them.
Sibert's Drug Store,
W. W. SIBKRT, PROP.
8 South Main Street. Phone 283
iitnini;itiisi:niiii;itnii;!intiiiiii;i;:isiisiniisninn?ininni!iiiniiiiiniiiiiiiiiimi
YOUR OLD TEETH.
You will be surprised to know what
Dr. C. H. Courtney can do with your
old teeth.
He can increase their usefulness
many times; can possibly add others
to them improving your looks as well
as your health.
Delays are dangerous and always so
with decayed teeth.
Sumter Dental Parlors,
DR. C. H. COURTNEY, Prop.
OVER MRS. ATKINSON'S MXLLINKRY STORE.
WHEN IN NEED OF A GOOD WORK
SHOE
EASY. HONEST AND WELL MADE.
Ask For the
CRAFTSMAN LINE
Manufactured By
Witherspoon Bros. Shoe Mfg. Co.
SUMTER, S. C.
Sold by all RESPONSIBLE merchants.
Buy them and cut your Shoe hill 25 per cent.
Satisfaction guaranteed.
LAND LIME.
We ars prepared to furnish this producl al prices that will enable
every farmer t?? use it. We have .1 ven low price this year and
nothing will do your land won .l especially run down lands.
or 1 'n> Mid sour land, it i- n< ? in for all leguminous crops
such ns Alfalfa, clover, vetch, peaa. ?tc. Gel ear prices in car
lots or io smaller quantities, Samph ? on request.
BOOTH-HARBY LIVE STOCK COMPANY,
SUM fER, S. C.