The watchman and southron. (Sumter, S.C.) 1881-1930, February 08, 1911, Image 1
iH, M MTU \V\TCH\IAN, fcatah!
Consolidated Aun*. 2,1
SPECIAL JUDGE ROW.
M \J<'K < \l l?V\ I II iss| ks st ati
MINI
Hay* II?? W?>nl<l Not s. r\c ?* S|icvlul
Judsje If Hy M hk| H Would <ih c
OnVit-r to ih < iii? i.land l?ar?Did
- 1 il Honor.?From Messrs.
lu. . e ami ShMiid.
Newberry. I' d.. 3.?Major James F.
J. Caldwell. who wan appointed t>y
Oovernor Mease to hold the ap?
proaching lltchland l .?ort, pours oil
on the troubled waters separating
the executive and Judicial depart?
ments in a calm statement Issued to?
day. In whh h lie states that so far .is
|M Ig concerned the matter rests en?
tirely with tie Uiehland bar. Major
Caldwell ha* Ions; been recognised as
one of the State's leading lawyers and
no is a son who has proved his de?
voted love for South Carolina. The
;atement of Major Caldwell follows;
1 have not made the oath roqulred,
and I have not received a commis?
sion), a few minutes after hearing
gfsajgfsjag Mosjaj over tbe telephone, i
wrote lo K. W. Shand. Esq., and a
letter to I?. H Nelson. Esq.. both of
the Columbia bar. In each of which
letters I stated ;he terms on which
I would acept tbe appointment. i
had an answer from Mr. Shand laat
night. 1 have not heard from Mr.
Nelson.
"I wrote Chief Justl e Jones a per?
sonal letter yesterday. He is at lib?
erty to give it such circulation as he
may see fit. did not know until
yesterday that dr. Kay had been se?
lected by tbe tar of Richland to pre?
side over the court or that his ap
pafntment had been recommended l >
the supreme court. Personally. It
does ent matter to me whether I hold
that court or not. I do not need pe?
cuniary profit from that source, cr
from any other source and as a met
ter of fact, with my way of living I
should not expect to sain a dollar be?
yond my expenditure. And I have
written Chief Justice Jones. 'I have
passed beyond that period of life
w-hwn a man need care for slory.' I
do not deem* it proper for me to ois
**an tn* Isejal uapact of the eaae. 1
think It still lo**: proper for me to say
one wx>rd about the personal or partly
personal e? .n t r o ve rsy between the
ehlef executive and the supreme
court. The crux of t> i ??.? the
point ?>n which the matter hinges?
is to me. th* wish of the Khhlnnd
bar. Without their cooperation I
ecu Id do nothing. They might con?
tinue every caee. Or If I should un?
dertake t ? try a case, I and all Other
persons must f-el uneertuln what I
could derld*. The prOtt I OfajSj mm
judlce' might be rahied at any mo?
ment from the beginning to the end
of any trial hl l)M < ircuit curt and In
the supreme court. And I will never
consent to hazard the rights of liti?
gants by my iosjbtful claim to office.
"Oovernor Hleaso called me by
telephone about noon on Wedn i >
the let instant, and on my answering.
Inquired If I Iroal I ? nt to hold the
term of the court of common pleas
for Richland county, to begin on Mon?
day, the 6th Instant. I replied that I
was willing to hold that court, but
added that I would not do so unless
the appointment was acceptable to the
local bar. To this he replied that it
?ana all right?or to that effect?and
after saying some words by wav of
kindly thought of me. he ceased to
speak. Ills manner Indicated to mv
mind that he wished only to ask If it
would suit gat |g hold the court. I
was left t ? easjJaatjBfsj whether the
liar of UtofcHM aCfltfCd me or wie tb
er they desire some other person. I
had no saaajsj of knowing whether
that lir had taken any action or
whether the Justices of the supreme
court had mad| a recommendation to
appoint some one to hold the court or
whether, if that court had npplled to
him to make in apfointment. It had
re. .nun nded m\ particular pel son
f??r the apf "io nt.
"I \vr..? (To\ern??r I'd i*e very soon
a lett. r. >a\lnu' ?hat I win willing to
hold *J0M feirf. pecs/Mod e'ther that
the Imr Ott III-bl ind d-sired sag <t
that th- v i m ej nie an other ? holen,
1 grsjg gsjfptist i i?? The Record that
gcasstag thai i ha' i.r appointed lo
hold lb.il i at i>\ ? o n t. A nd I
ha\" been more suri rised to re.ol
In the newspaper-* ib i I ha-? been
commissioned t?? preside lu thai
t ourt.
??Governor BlOSJOS Is Inucetirate In
saying that I ha\e !?? ? i commissioned.
The ?...r?tir\ of State sent lue by
mall, received yesterday morning, the
seeond. a ounirunieatIon to the iffeet
that I had b? ? n appointed and that on
my nendln.r to him. the *e. r.-tary of
State, the oath on the bnck of his
communication, make aceordlng to
881.
IU* JllSt M
3U
MUOii CAIMELL ?H??NES.
?OV, ei i 181 FH1ENU GETS OUT
? t MESH,
1: i < t Lovcrnoi Mill Rsjfsjsea to Act
On Recommendation of Supreme
< oun mill Designate* Judge K. C\
Wutis to BoM Court in Itu iiluml.
?<halves supreme Court With Dis?
regarding Law.
Colnanl la, !'? >?. i.?Major Jas. p, J.
Caldwoll, af Near berry, sent to Qov
ernor Pleas*- this afternoon a tele?
gram that m.iy rolteVf tenseness of
situation in reaped la appointment of
Special Judge |q pr--side at the Rleh
land countv term al Court of Com?
mon Pleas, commencing Monday. Mr.
Caldwell's messag? follows:
"(lovernor IUt as ?:
Thinking It my duty in the circum?
stances to do so, I respectfully decline
the appointment of Special Judge
which you offer me. I write mofe
fully today."
Governor Hlease said on receipt of
Major Ca Id-well's telegram that he
would designate Circuit Judge R. C.
Watts, of Cfcemw, to hold the Rich
land cocrt, Judge Watts being disen?
gaged.
"Under the Constitution." said the
governor, "the Supreme Court ought
to have recommended some dlsengag
at Circuit Judge in the first place, if
any judge was disengaged, Instead of
recommending the appointment of a
Special Judge."
It Is true that Judge Watts and
Judge Memminger are both disengaged
for next week but both of them are
very busy politically, as candidates for
the Fifth Justiceship of the Supreme
Court, the election for which will
I likely be held next week.
HLEAse's soc ial DEBUT.
i.o?er nor Will Give Kcriptiou at
Mansion Wednesday Evening.
Columbia. Feb. 4.?Governor and
Mrs. Hlease, who made their social
debut in Columbia at the Rembert re?
ception to the General Assembly
Thursday, will themselves compliment
the legislators next week. Engraved
fcivitatloaa to a rm epthm ut the exe?
cutive mantson Wednesday evening
have heen distributed today. The
newspaper men reporting the two
houses are all Invited.
law and In proper form, I should re?
ceive my commission.
"Governor Hlease may have been
precipitate to get, and not entirely
courteoun towards tie- supreme court,
but 't is not for ma to ensure my
friend who sought to do me honor,
and who, 1 am sure, thinks that he
is exercising authority given him
1 the OOnstltution and the statute
law of thi State. Nor have I any?
thing to say against the Justices of
the supreme cour*. I have no doubt
that they ha\e done just what they
thought they ought to have done.
"I conclude that the matter really
rests with the Columbia bar. I am
sanguine that their wishes, expressed
today or tomorrow, will determine the
result, for i feel confidant that both
the governor and the supreme court
will be lanxlous to assist them in the
disposal of the many and Important
interests committed to the manage?
ment of noun eel."
Annool Without Recommendation.
Governor Phase said Friday after?
noon, In response to an Inquiry, that
his appointment of Mr. J. F. J. Cald
\\ell to preside at the Kichland court
was made bnfort be i,;oi received any
recommendation on the subject from
the supreme court or had been in- j
formed of any action on the matter by
he Ku hland I lar BSSO i,it ion.
After I had talked with Judge
t'opes." said the governor, "and had
found that he could not qualify in
time for the Rlchland term com?
menctng next Monday, I made up
my mind whom I would appoint as
Spectol judge, The appointment was
I made before I had received the su?
pine- court's recommendation that
I Mr. I?. < \ Pay be appointed and be?
fore i had he ird of Mr. Ray's en
loraement for the place by the Rich
land Par association."
i be RMthtnd Bar,
'The Rlchland Bar nesoclatloni"
d President R, \\. fthand, Friday
afternoon, in r< pori ? to an Inquiry,
I recommended Mr, Lav for appoint?
ment as special Judge before we knew
j thai Qovernoi Hlease. had decided on
l Ma im- ('abi a . i!. of had any Intlma?
, ihm that another was conaldered for
the honor, Whether lh< appointmenl
of Major Caldwell was mad. before
the recommendation ,,f th< supreme
court was rec, iyed by the i >>? < rnor, I
do not know."
?id Fear not?Ix-t Ml tU end* Thon Ali
MTER, S C? WEDNES]
ROOT ATTACKS LOBIMEB
i
\i . VORHER DKXOUNCFS HLIS
ELECTION AM? WHITEWASH.
Vote mi Republican Urges Some
mend of nilnoli to Rise ami Clear
Name of Q**eal State.
i Washington Fob, ?Senator I*.*???t
of Near York today leaped suddenly
t<> a position of leadership among the
antl-Lorlmer foroei it1 the senate and
caused tti" cane temporarily to be
lifted above the attach upon the in?
dividual so as t<? bate the l)lotch upon
the name of the state of Illinois.
When Mr. Hoot concluded, Senator
Hab-, the veteran Republican leader
Of the senate, pleaded with tremulous
VOlCS for some friend of the State, and
he suggested Senator Cullom to make
a reply to Mr. Hoot's speech, which
j would i I ?n rate not Lorimer, hut Il?
linois.
"1 r* funs to believe that so great a
paoplls are rotten to the core," said
Senator Bailey of Texas. "If we are
to try k natori on the misconduct of
legislators) then the senator whose
right Is challenged now is not the only
one who must yield till seat. His col?
league, Mr. Cullom, was elected by
one of those legislatures and no man
here believes that he was a party to
any of these evil practices, but still
the cast; of Lorimer is the case of Cul?
lom."
Senator Lorimer has numerous de?
fenders who replied to Mr. Root's at?
tack upon him and the method of his
election.
Chief among them was Senator
Hsyburn of Iowa, a member of the
Lorimer Investigating committee, who
e barged that some persons had en?
tered Into the attack upon Lorimer
in the spirit of a man hunt. Before
Mr. Root had proceeded far it de?
veloped that he went beyond the posi?
tion of others, who have condemned
the election of Lorimer as having
been accomplished by bribery. He
dismissed as immaterial the contro?
versy over the question of eliminating
the total vote on joint ballot as well
ns from the number received by Lor?
imer.
The r dtenness shown by the testi?
mony, contended Mr. Root, was suffi?
cient to Invalidate the election of Lor?
imer and he asserted that all of the
following of Lee O'Neill Browne, the
Democratic leader in the Illinois as?
sembly, was COITUPt and the votes of
that following should have been
eliminated.
Pew senators left their seats dur?
ing tin* speech and the galleries were
orowded With hundreds of others in
the corridors, waiting for chances of
admission, which never eame.
' We are bound." continued Mr.
Hoot, "to act Upon the universal
knowledge that the facts we have es?
tablished Implicate others than those
absolutely known to have been in?
volved."
Mr. Loot reached the conclusion
that deducting the seven tainted
VOtee, Mr. Lorimer had been left
without a majority, a fact which, be
said, "invalidates his election."
This was squally true he said,
whether the corruption fund had
been used either to increase Lorlmer'i
VOtS or to reduce the total vote.
Mr. Hoot Inveighed strongly against
the methods by whb h it is sought to
sustain Mr. Lot inter. He declared
that the senate could not afford to
sanction such methods.
"If they stand the senate can not
stand." he said. "If they stand the
government of the United States can
not stand."
Mr. Hoot characterized Browne and
his 30 followers as "a band of rob?
bers" and declared that all their votes
should be rejected in Lorimer*S elec?
tion.
The conclusion of Mr. Hoot's
speech was marked by an unusual
scene.
Mr. Hale o? Maim- pleaded for a
reply to the New York senator's
speech, Declaring that the senate
could not have been comfortable
j while Mr. Hoot was making his "pow
I erful argument" and confessing that
I - hims< If had not been, he said he
1 hit 1 been impressed with the s, riotis
S ness ? r the situation,
i "As I listen, d to the distinguished
??< iiutnr's lamentable and melancholy
[arraignment," said Mr. Hale, "the
I Illinois ? nator disappeared entirely
and i become Impressed with the
serious reflection upon the great ?tate
whose name is Involved,"
When Mr. lialley < <11?<t attention
t" tbe f o t t. at Mr. Lenne r bad nol
been present during the day's pro
ceedtngs, thereby rendering his dls<
appearance Impossible, Mr. Hale re?
plied Hat be had not referred to the
physical presence of the Illinois sen?
ator 'mt had meant merely to say that
Lorimer bad been so completely over
Ug't at t>e thy Country's, Thy God's ai
DAY, FEBRUARY 8, 19
WORKING P?3 CIM SIC?.
SOUTH CAROLINA AM? MINNE?
SOTA ARE MAIN COMPETI?
TORS.
Near Columbia Delegation's Argu?
menta and Thru Decide to Pay This
I City a Visit.
Columbus, I ?hio, Feb. 3.?South
j Carolina and Minnesota today i?r?>
sented their claims to the officers and
I
: directors of the National Corn expo
| sltlon for the next exposition. The
.Minnesota legislature is willing to
make a huge appropriation for new
buildings on the State fair grounds
if the exposition is landed, particu?
larly for the next two succeeding
j years. President Funk declared the
show would go where it could do the
most good.
"if that's what you want, come
South, to Columbia South Carolina,
said A. D. Hudson, president of the
j South Carolina Corn Breeders' asso?
ciation."
"The South needs you. We need
y< u badly. The South stands on the
threshold of a great development.
She is just awakening. 1 want to tell
you the corn show would revolutionize
the South."
He pointed out the work of Jerry
Moore, champion boy corn raiser, as
the example of what could be done
in the South.
The officials accepted an invitation
to visit Columbia alter the show.
They will view the city and consider
its advantages.
The Southerners extended an invi?
tation from the legislature and from
Qov. Cole L. Please.
(Hhers who spoke in support of
Columbia's claim were: A. G. Smith,
Wade Hampton Globes, mayor of Co?
lumbia; R. B. Herbert, A. E. Gonzales,
who spoke on behalf of newspapers
of the South; R, 1*. Hayes, son of
the former president; Prof. J. N.
Harper and M. V. Richards, land and
industrial agent of the Southern rail?
way.
A. O. Eberhart, governor of Minne?
sota, representatives of the State fair,
Louis Bettes, president of the St.
Paul Commercial club, and G. A. Will,
representing the Minneapolis Com?
mercial club, w?re speakers for Min?
nesota. They declared every one In
their State a booster and said the un?
excelled advantages of the twin cities
and the State fair grounds thould take
the show to Minneapolis.
Among those who will come here
tomorrow for "Conservation day"
are. Giflford Pinchot, W. c. Brown,
president of the Neu York Central
railroad; Daniel Willard, president of
the Baltimore ft (>hlo, and Geo. w.
Stevens, president of the Chespe?ke
?fc Ohio.
REPUBLCAN LEAGUE HELPS.
Progressive Republican League Rend?
ing Its Energies to Have Measure
Passed for Popular Election of
Members of Senate.
Washington, Feb. 5.?The recently
organized National Progressive Re?
publican league, through Senator
Jonathan Bourne, Jr., or Oregon,,
president of the league, sent telegrams
to the governors and legislators of
various States today asking them to
bring influence to bear on their re?
spective m nators in favor of the joint
resolution providing for the election
of senators by direct vote.
The telegram Is as follows:
"The joint resolution proposing an
amendment to the constitution pro?
viding for the election of United States
senators t?y direct vote wil1 1 e acted
upon by the United states senate
within a few days, it is not certain
that it will r< dve the necessary' two
thirds vote, it Is certan that 'JO per
pent of the people are In favor of it.
Will the senate represent public sen?
timent upon this question. Do you
know how your senators stand? If
their position Is in doubl wire and
w i lie them. Bring the force of pub?
lic opinion to 1 ear upon th- m. it Is
a critical time, Vour influence may
determ ne the result, Wire them to?
day."
shadowed as the issue as to he elim?
inated from considerate n. This has
not i" er? an arraignment of Mr. Lorl
m< r, but of the State of Illinois, Mr.
IIa! said, and he added that he did
tint Wal.t the Case disposed of until
Senator Cullom or some othe friend
of the Slate "should arise, and if pos?
sible free the state from the Inevit?
able result of the i barges of th.>
ator from New VoiU. If we may b?
llevc what has been said there exists,
ami there has existed for years, a
most unconscionable practice and
habit of corruptW n."
id Truth's." TILE TKTJ
U.
SLAIN Bt.AMSRY WOMAN.
HUBERT M. FLOYD is SHOT I ?>l R
TIMES BV MKS. \. M. HAYES.
Woman Says Floyd Insulted Her mid
She Killed Him?Husband Rushes
in and Finds Man Dying.
Conway, Feb. 5.?Shot lour times
an l instantly killed by Mrs. X. M.
Hayes in her horn" at Tabor, X. C,
just across the Horry line, late yester?
day evening, was yesterday the fate
(jf Robert M. Fmyd, a native of this
county and a student at the South
Carolina Medical college at Charles?
ton.
Three shots took effect in the b' vv
and <>nc in the centre of the ton
Only a few minutes befoi ?8
j death, Mr. Floyd h^.d driven uA? to
the Hayes home and had been invited
in to spend the evening by the hus?
band of the young woman. Floyd
went in the house and while Mr.
Hayes was ungearing the horse, he
heard four pistol shots. He rushed
in the house where he found Iiis
friend lying dead and his wife stand?
ing by.
Her only answer to Mr. Hayes's
questioning was that Floyd had In?
sul, cd her and that she had killed
him.
There is no telephone connection
between this place and Tabor but sev?
eral passengers on last night's train
brought news of the killing around
which a cloud of mystery appears to
hang. The killing is the talk here
today as all the parties are well known
in this county and prominently con?
nected.
Mr. Floyd arrived in Tabor yester?
day from Charleston, having come
home to spend Saturday and Sunday
with his parents near Galllvant's ferry.
Parties living in Conway were on
the train with Mr. Floyd when he
got off at Tabor. He stated to them
that he stopped there to look after
his farm during the day, that a horse
and buggy would meet him either at
Tabor or at T-oris, a nearby town, and
that he was going to spend the night
at Tabor and drive out to his home
this morning.
Probably no further cause other
than the woman's statement will ever
be known as Mrs. Hayes was alone
in the house when she did the shoot?
ing.
Prom a brother of the dead man it
was b arned that Mr. Floyd had gone
to the house, where he met his death,
for the purpose of collecting for
books which he hail sold during his
vacation.
There are conflicting rumors as to
Mr. Hayes' meeting Mr. Floyd at the
gate and asking him in, although
it is known that the two young men
were ? lose friends. Mr. Hayes tuns
a barber shop at Tabor and it is
stated that on Saturday evenings the
rush of business at the place makes
it necessary that Mr. Hayes remain
at the shop very late.
News of the awful occurrence was
a shock to the people of this county
and especially in Conway where Mr.
Floyd has lived and worked for a
number of years. He was colporter
for the Waccamaw Baptist association,
which work carried him into the best
homes of this county and of Marion
county, where he traveled quite a
good deal during the past several
years.
Three years ago he resigned this
j work to accept a position as head
bookkeeper In the Hank of Conway,
now the First National Bank of Con?
way. He spent several months In
this capacity until tin summer "f
Htoy, when he resigned this position
and made the race in this county for
clerk of court. He mad" a splendid
race but was defeated and later cn
, tered the South Carolina Medical col?
lege at Charleston where he would
have graduated in April.
It was Mr. Floyd's intention to open
a drug store in Conway this summ "'.
j While here during the Christmas holi?
days he practically completed the or
j ganlzatlon of a company for this pur*
' p >Sc.
Young Floyd was a son of Mr.
j and Mrs Math Floyd of near Galll
> int's ferry In this county. II?' was
I about ?'?> years of age, of splendid
? educational qualifications, having
j taught In tie schools <>f the count)
dress md pleasing personality
lit was modest and gentle and
?s hy he sh bi killed In this m in
e.ef and within six or < Ighl ml
after his arrive1 at the home of ..
fri< nd can n< t be explained b< t
Mrs. Hayes, the slayer, la a young
A-oman. She la a daughter of J. J. E.
I llarrelson of Lorls and a sister- of D,
j I?. Harrilson of Lorls, formerly county
I superintendent of education in this
' county and later a member of the
v
E SOUTHKOX. Established .?un<. lt<M
Vol. XXXI. No. 49
imm ftttlCH iii SEME.
SENATORIAL ELECTION PLAN
PLACED l\ POHrnON FOB
\< TION.
Idaho Man Calla signal lor C ross
Tackle Buck and Moml-pat l or
waids ire Pushed Hack.
Washington, Feb. I,?After a series
<.f thrilling e *nces, Senator
Borah, BUppO' progressive Re
| publican a A moeratic senators,
made t jfS ous advances through
*r
the ' the old guard Republicans
a vx ed the resolution for election
^ oators by direct vote of the peo
j in a most advantageous position
squarely in front of the enemies' goal.
The moment the Lorimer case was
laid aside today, Senators Nelson and
Horah clamored for recognition. Vice
President Sherman gave Mr. Nelson
the floor. He moved to take up the
bill to regulate the leasing of Alaskan
coal lands, whereupon Mr. Bo. ah
promptly moved to lay that motion
on the table, which failed 3G to 41.
I Most senators thought this settled the
I question.
I After the senate had proceeded
with the Alaskan bill for a bbort time,
j Mr. Nelson wave way to Senator War
' ren to make a motion.that the senate
j adjourn until Monday. Mr. Borah de?
mand- d a roll call and this time he
won. Thus encouraged Mr. Borah
asked that the resolution be made
the unfinished business. On the roll
call it appeared that this resolution
might be given preference and Sen?
ator Penrose hurriedly moved an
executive session. Such a motieVi
under the rules of the senate may
be made at any time and therefore
I Mr. Borah again found himself el?
bowed out of the way. As the ques?
tion on executive session was being
I put to the senate, Mr. Borah made a
j demand for a roll call, secured a suf
fient number of seconds and the call
' was ordered.
On what was regarded as th*? most
significant vote of the day, the execu?
tive session was denied, 36 to 40. All
. of those who voted in the affirmative
ara regarded us lined vpon against
popular elections of senators, and
j those who voted in the negative are
i known to be in favor of this policy,
I All of the affirmative votes were cast
j by Republicans, but a number of in
, surgent Republican senators voted
with the Democrats against the cb>sed
j session.
I Recognizing that Mr. Borah had
? the votes no further objection was
I made by opponent! of popular elec?
tion of senators and the resolution
became the unfinished business of the
senate without a roll call.
ONE DEAD. ANOTHER DYING.
Deputy Sheriff atul Police Chief Vic?
tims of Unknown Negro.
Wilson, N. C, Fob. 3.?This town is
laboring under the greatest excitement
of its history, < anted by the murder
of Deputy Sheriff George Munford and
the probably fatally injuring of Chief
of Police A. O. Glover this afternoon,
by a negro desperado, name un?
known.
This morring the officers here were
notified to look out for negroes who
broke into a store at Dunn last night.
This afternoon one of the negroes was
located in a house near the Norfolk
Southern Railroad yards, and the of
fi. ^rs went to make the arrest. As
i Munford and Glover entered the front
door the negro opened fire. Munford
was shot through the head and Glover
through both lungs. The former died
in less than an hour and the latter is
j expected to die at any moment. The
! negro escaped. Bloodhounds were
brought here on a special train and
j are now following the trail. Several
I arrests were made out the prisoners
; were exonerated.
Troops to Pre* nl Lynching.
Raleigh, n. c Peb. 3.?Governor
W. \V. Kit? bin tonight ordered Com?
I pany K, 2d reg ment, Wilson l ight
I infantry, to be subject to the order of
the sheriff ol Wilson county to pre
venl s lynching tint ', as the oul omi
, of the killing of I ?? r?y Bh? riff Mun
ral assembly from this county.
She and Mr. Ua>. ? were married
about three yeara ago. since which
lime th< y have lived happily together
it L >rls, where the husband conducted
i store and ran a barber shop. Dur?
ing the fall they left Lorla and moved
to Ta' or. a North Carolina town,
about seven miles from a j is. Mr.
and Mrs. Hayes have one child
about a year old.