The watchman and southron. (Sumter, S.C.) 1881-1930, March 16, 1910, Image 1
rC SI M i l k WATCHMAN, Establl
onH?2i<lated Aa?% 2,188
Cb* Bhtcbttrm ml) ^uitbron.
-Published Weiloe^l.n anil Suiiinluj
* -BT
OSTEEN PUBLISHING COMPANY
81"mter, s. C.
Terms:
11.10 per annum?In advance.
Advertisements:
On? Square ttret Insertion.$1.00
?5very subsequent Insertion.60
?L Contracts for three months, or
Meager will be made at reduced rate<?.
All communicators which sub?
serve private L.terest* will bo charged
for as advertisement
Obituaries and tributes of respects
wMl be charged for.
mii STATUE PRESENTED.
sooth < \koi.i\\ noNoits her
(.RE AT STATESMAN.
^Teremonle?? of Presentation and Ac
eeptniu ? lake flu? . nt Capitol
N sterdav Morning ? Kenutors
Lodge ami Smith. Representative*
Alken. McCall. Elnley, U?ver, John?
son and Ellrrbe Speak.
0 Washington. Man h 12 ?The Capi?
tal was the scene of a notable event
today when In the presence of a dis?
tinguished sssemblage a statute of
John C. Calhoun. the great South
Carolina separatist, was unveiled in
Statuary Hall.
mm The unveiling ceremony took place
TU 11 o'clock and was conducted whol?
ly by South Carolinians. The cords
holding tog.-th- r the dr apery around
th?? marble figure were loosened by
Mrs. Bratton and Miss Olst. both
da ugh te in of th? Palmetto State, and
^mmedlsaely afterwards the verbal
ceremonies were begun. Governor
Ansel presided and former Governor
Mauldln delivered the principal ora?
tion.
The statute Is a bold piece of work,
depicitlng Its subject in strident at?
titude. It Is placed on the south
rTnda of Statuary Hall, between the
figures of Ethan Allen and Lewis Cass,
S4*4t?gtrtly If ao? defiantly, faces
the efftgv of Webster. Calhoun's
( greatest antagonist, which stands
1 calmly on Its pedstal on the north
LsMde of the hall.
The cer- m e .-a of acceptance took
f place In the Senate and House after
the completion of the exendses In the
hall. It was In the two houses that
the Representatives of the two ante?
bellum htdllgerent States met to
Msce more bury the hat. tut. Senator
Hmdge and Represent 11 i\MeCall
r speaking f.?r the New Lngi md Com?
monwealth, and Senator Smith
and a number of South Caro?
lina's Representatives for that State,
i \n address was made In the Senate
LAdso by Senator Chamberlain, of Ore
1~ w r l.mlge and McCall
spoke euloglsth ally of the personality
of the subject of the exercises.
The Calhoun fatally was represent?
ed at all the pr.e 'ings by Patrick
and John c. CalfcOttB, grandsons of
,Jhe statesman, ami by several grand
??hlhlren. The} oeeupied esj.lally
assigned seats In all places, in the
Senate the President's ami Vice Pres?
ident's rows were reserved for them.
Ml WINs r.oo VERDICT.
-?Imi ? find?. \ erdlct for Stale In
ih>rkcie\ Msartagjs Caan,
Momk's Corm r. Manh 12.?After
being out less than an hour, the jury
In the case <.| the State against for
? mer Treasurer John i >. Edwardi ;??> l
gathers thl aft< rn >on ri turned a v? r
wslh t against | be defend 11 the
full amount sued for, a little more
than $5,500.
This has l?e< u one of the hardest
fought ram s . \ er tried In Lerkeby
County
t)m aani itewi eel ? aa alleged
^Wih r t ige In the at the for
mer treasurer and the suit was
air i e-t lorn md bis i.oml am n. Mr.
Edwards \\ is r. ?ppoine .1 to oftl
for the third term In January. I'jOT
He took agfea, and hl? sureties were
gv ^1" Lr.ni L I. S. I. <'rawford
H^n-i w i i. Mir im i )., smber,
1907, upon the examination of bin
office g| the Comptroller General's
office as required ??> law. It was found
that there was an apparent dsdclency
of eotisl b Table si/. No settlement
as made, and In a short time there
ter <io\. rnor Ansel suspend* d Mr
i i irds and appointed Major llrown
Ing as tn usurer In his stead. The
suit w as subsequently brought against
Mr IM wards and his sureties
We do not want to be put down n:<
pessimists. ? < .n't thoroughly
free with tlM UlSOCy that there Is
nothing entirely bad In the world.
aiei gagaagkdasj pjeedi la sTtTTthlng?
What good can be found In a bad egg,
for Instance??L\
im d April, 187*0. 'Be Just ai
1. ^8UM
OIL COMPAQ'S APPEAL I
_ !
PimaLI'HOW ORDERED BY I'. s.
CIRCUIT COURT.
Federal Supreme Court Will Hear
Arguments. <.ra\c PtagtagS Against
Money Kings Announced b| Circuit
Court?gmoteSSS World \n\iou>d>
Await outcome <?r suit.
Washington, March 14.?The most
serious legal battle that "Standard
Oil" has tVCf laced will confront It
11 >day.
This Is the day set by the Supreme
Court ? t the United States to hear
arguments on the appeal of the Stan?
dard nil Company, of New Jersey from
the adverse judgment of the United
States Circuit Court for the Eastern
district of Missouri, which order the
dissolution of the \Yw Jersey corpor?
ation as an illegal combination and
monopoly in restraint of Tnter-State
commerce. To point out the allege 1
errors of the Circuit Court in its find?
ings and In its decree, the keenest
Intellects within command have been
procured. To argue for the affirm?
ance of the decision of the lower court
Mr. Wickersham. the Attorney Gen?
eral of the United States, himself will
head a brilliant array of counsel for
the Government.
The Circuit Court announced grave
findings against the seven individual
defenda its. John D. Rockefeller, Wil?
liam Rockefeller. Henry M. Flagler.
Henry H. Rogers, John D. Archbold.
Oliver H. Payne, and Charles M.
Pratt, the Standard OH Company, of
New Jersey, and other defendant com?
panies.
The court found that In 1899, by
an exchange of stock by the seven in?
dividuals, the Standard Oil Company,
of New Jersey, acquired the legal title
to a majority of the stock of nineteen
companies, which In turn controlled
a large number of others, all but one,
engaged In the oil business.
What Is found as to this combina?
tion was this:
That since 1899 the affairs of all
these companies have been managed
by the prlucln.il company ?is the W'sl
? of a single person, so as to fix for
them the price of crude oil, the rates
for transportation and the selling
prices of its products.
That the par value of the combined
capital stock In 1899 was about $100,
000.000, and that In 1903 It was $150,
\ ooo.ooo.
That twelve of these compales own?
ed 54,565 miles of pipe lines.
That six of thes companies had 3,
"74 selling stations throughout the
United States.
That these companies from 1899 t >
1907 produced more than one-tenth
Of the . rude oil obtained in this coun?
try.
That they owned and operated more
than one-half of all the tank cars
used to distribute its products.
That they ;nanufactured more than
three-fourths ? f all the crude oil re?
fined in the United States.
That they transported more Inan
four-fifths of the petroleum der>? 1
from the Pennsylvania and ludlans
oil fields.
That they marketed more than
four-fifths of all the illuminating oil
vent forth from the United State.*.
That they exported more than four
fifths of all the illuminating oil sent
forth ff on the United States.
Thai tb. y sold more than four
fifths of all the naphtha sold in the
United States.
That they sold more than nine
tenths of all the lubricating oil sol i
to railroad companies in the United
States.
On this finding the court decreed:
j That the organisation ol ItM wm ?
omblnatlofl or conspiracy In restrain*
of Inter-State commerce in petroleum
and Its products, such as the first sec?
tion of the Sherman Anti-Trust Act
declares is Illegal; that the eeven in?
dividual defendants, the Standard Ol?
Company, of New Jersey, and "0 oth?
er companies had entered into a com?
bination or conspiracy to monopo?
lize and had In fact monopolized a
substantial part of Inter-State com?
merce In violation of the second sec?
tion Of the Sherman Anti-Trust Act;
that 33 OtheT comnpnles accused were
proven not to be In this combination.
The court enjoined the principal
company ami its directors from exe/
i bring any control over the subsidiary
i ompanlesj it enjoined the subsldary
companies from declaring or paying
any dividend! to the principal com?
pany, but not from distributing rat
ably to the shareholders of the prin?
cipal company the stock of the sub?
sidiary company; It enjoined those
found to be in the "illegal combina?
tion" from continuing In it or form?
ing a new combination by means of
aggregation of the physical proper?
ties In the hands of one member of
the combination, and forbade those
In the combination from engaging In
9
id Four not?Let all the ends Thou Aln
TER. 8. 0., WEDNE
BOYS' COHN CLUB.
K1XTY-SIX MEMBERS ENROLLED
UP TO DATE.
The Bttmter County Roys' Corn Cluh
Mel in the Court House With
0? Member*, All Contesting for
Prise*,
Prom The Daily Hem March 12.
The Bumter County Boys' Corn
Club met in Its regular monthly meet?
ing the court house today with 6G
members present. The club has grown
beyond the expectations of those in
charge of the work. It is encourag
ing to tee more than three score em?
bryonic farmers getting their seed and
making preparations to plant corn,
the king of cereals.
There were talks by several gentle?
men present. Mr. H. L. Scarborough,
who has taken a great deal of Interest
in the work from the start was the
Aral speaker. He dwelt upon the op?
portunities that are now before the
farmers, and of the importance cf
heaping records. Talks were male
by Mr. T. J. Kervin, Prof. J. F. Wil?
liams and Prof. B. D. Cain.
Seed corn, Gherio's prolilic, was
distributed to the boys, each being
given enough to plant an acre.
The fol.owing ru.es were adopted:
1. Boys joining clubs and entering
contests must be under 18 years of
age, Sept., 1909.
2. No boy shall contest for a prize
unless ho becomes a member of a
club April 1, 1910.
3. The memebrs of the clubs must
ngree to re^d the Instruction.?? of the
; ?emonstr it on Work.
4. Each boy must plan his own
< rop and do his own work
5. Exhibits must be delivered to
the county superintendent of educa?
tion by October lGth.
6. The amount of the ytetd and
the method of measurement must. I e
certified by each boy and attested by
at least two disinterested witnesses,
who shall be satisfactory to the coun?
ty superintendent.
7. Each boy is required to donate
one bushel of ear corn to be sold for
the purpose of perpetuating the prize
fund.
A CONFEDRATE COIN.
Half Dollar Struck at Mint in New
Orleans Bold In New York for $:*,
760.
New Tork, March 1.1.?One of the
original Confederate half-dollars
struck off at the United States mint
In New Orleans in 1ST, 1, after it fell
Into the hands of the Confederate
government, was sold today by a local
coin dealer for $3,750. The buyer was
a wealthy New York collector, whose
name is withheld.
Inter-State commerce until the com?
bination was discontinued.
The counsel arrayed in defence of
the Standard Oil includes John G. Mil
burn, of Buffalo, N. Y., in whose homo
McKinley died, D. T. Watson and Jno.
<?. Johnson, leaders of the Pennsyl?
vania Bar, and Moiits Rosenthal, the
legal pillar of the Standard Oil inter?
ests. Of these, Johnson made the
principal argument t?> the Supreme
Court. In the defence In the tobacco
The defence has urged that
the corporation-, which entered into
the organlsath i Of 1899, had not been
competitors since Is"!'; that the
stockholders of the principal company
were the Joint owners of the stock
of the subsidiary companies, and had
th rlgl t to convey their stock in the
?attcr to the fornn r In trust for them?
selves, and congress was without pow?
er t<? restrict their acquisition, their
nu thod of holding, or their deposi?
tion of their title to tiuir property
or their us.- of it; that the corpora?
tions whose stock were Invested In
the Standard Oil Company of New
Jersey are private corporations and
not charged with a public duty, as
were the railroads in the Northern Se?
curities case; and that If any re?
straint of trade resulted from the or?
ganisation it 1899 it was neither di?
re immediate, nor substantial.
Attorney General Wlckersham prob?
ably will make the principal argument
to the eourt In favor of the dissolu?
tion. Frank B. Kellogg, of Minne?
sota, and Charles B, Morrison, of Chi?
cago, have been most active in the
preparation of the case against the
defendants. Their arguments were
upheld In the main by the lower
court.
The business world Is awaiting the
o\d. ome of the suit, to know what ef?
fect it will have upon the future, n<>t
only of the standard Oil, but of oth? r
combinations with points In common.
The department of justice is waiting
for the decision of the court, In order
to shap I the government's attitude to?
ward other organisations, <>f which
complaint have been made.
ia*t at be thy Country's, Thy God's am
SDAY. MARCH 16. 1
GAMBLING IN COTTON, i
- i
AN ADVANCE OF A DOLLAR NET
PER DALE WEEK'S RECORD.
_i I
Ratten, Brown and Scales Currently
Reported to be Particularly Bullish 1
On .May Cotton and Fear is Felt of
a Corner.
New York, March 11.?The striking
feature of the week has been the i
manipulation of the May option and
an advance of about $1 net per bale.
The so-called "big four"?Mesrs. Pat
t n, I layne, Scales and Brown, who
are openly bullish?are credited with
being bulls on that delivery in par?
ticular, and with having received re?
cently on March contracts, something
like 50,000 bales. According to cur?
rent rumor they are likely to take
4 0,000 more, and ship the cotton to
Fairope in order to facilitate the man?
ipulation of the May option here. The
other well known spot dealer here
privately bought 8,000 bales of that
m-'tith.
Liverpool right or wrongly has been
painly affected by the May corner
Spot stocks have increased. The con?
tinent has been buying more freely
there. Manchester is reported to be
doing a better business. Wall street
has bought on recessions. So has the
South, including New Orleans.
Finally, the weather in Texas has
continued for the most part dry. In
the Gainesville section of that State
it is said that the conditions are the
dryest for 20 years past. On the oth?
er hand heavy rains have latterly fal?
len in the southern part of Texas, and
a preciptation seems to have occur?
red in some localities in the western
section of that State.
The question which the cotton trade
is asking is whether Europe with its
improved trade will fix the price of
cotton for the rest of the season or
whether it will he determined by the
conservative spirit which is the dom?
inant note in the American branch of
the cotton business at this time. The
May option in the meantime is the
centre off interest.
COTTON SPECULATOR MOBBED.
English Cotton Brokers Mistreat Pat?
ten.
London, March 11.?A hostile dem?
onstration on the tloor of the cotton
exchange at Manchester and one di?
rectly contrasting it for friendliness
on the corn exchange at Liverpool
were met with today by Jas. A. Pat?
ten, the Chicago Wheat and cotton
operator, in the first. Mr. Patten
was mobbed and probably escaped in?
jury only by being rescued by the po?
lice; in the later he was greeted with
cheers .and other manifestations of
friendliness. Mr. Patten will sail from
Liverpool tomorrow for New York
on board the Cunard line steamer,
Mauritania.
The brief visit in England of the
Chic ago operator has been spent most
ly about the Liverpool markets and
today he made up his mind to run
over to Manchester to see the city
and visit the cotton exchange. It was
known to Mr. Patten that there had
been threats of an unpleasant recep?
tion should he visit "Cottonopolis,"
but he refused to believe they would
be carried into effect. These threats
it is said, emanated from persons on
the exchange who had lost large sums
as a result of Mr. Patten's operations
in Chicago, and from others, who held
him responsible for yesterday's rise
in the price of cotton and who believ?
ed that his visit to England had f-^r
its purpose the manipulation of the
market.
Hardly had Mr. Patten touched the
floor of the Manchester exchange be?
fore the outburst came. TTe was hoot?
ed and jeered by the throng and then
surrounded and hustled into the street.
Phe crowd followed even here and did
not desist its manifestation of dislike
until the American had been placed
in a cab by the police and starten! for
the railway station, where he took the
firs! train back to Liverpool. While
unhurt. Mr. Patten was greatly sur?
prised and irritated at the dislike the
people of Manchester had shown for
him.
Arriving in Liverpool, Mr Fate, n
just had time to visit the corn ex?
change 1 Cfore it closed for the day.
Tlie tloor was crowded with'-members,
who evinced their sympathy with him
for the treatment that had been
shown him in Manchester by taking
off their hats and cheering him when
he referred to the incident.
if the people of Loulslans us an?
nounced in the press dispatches can
raise hogs lor shipment, surely the
people of South Carolina should be
able to raise onough hogs for their
own use.?Winnsboro News and Her?
ald.
[1 Truth's."
THE TRUi
910._NewSeri
BAD FOB B?LLINGER. "
DAMAGING EVIDENCE AGAINST
SECRETARY OF INTERIOR.
Chief Engineer Ravis of ReclatmnUon
Service Contradicts Statements of
Ballinger and Aecuases Him ol
Double-Dealing?Seems to Have
Favored Land Grabbers.
Washington, March 11.?With Ar?
thur 1?. Davis, chief engineer of the
reclaimation service on the stand, the
attaVk upon Secretary Ballinger con
tinued today before the congressional
committee of investigation. Mr. Davis
was called as a witness by Gifford
Pinchot's attorney.
Although expressing reluctance to
testify Mr. Davis proved to be well
fortified with maps, dates, data, etc.
He contradicted flatly many state?
ments made by Secretary Ballinger to
President Taft, and ended the day by
declaring that the reclamation ser?
vice is still in danger of distintergra
tlon as a result of Mr. Balinger's at?
titude toward it.
Mr. Davis declared that "in lang?
uage as strong as politeness and prop?
er respect would permit" he had told
Secretary Ballinger himself that his
entire course had tended to a demor?
alization of the service.
With regard to a statement by Mr.
Ballinger to the president that he had
restored many lands withdrawn by
Secretary Garfield on the strength of
recommendations from the reclama?
tion service that these lands were no
longer needed for reclamation pur?
poses, Mr. Davis declared that all of
the recommendations made by the
reclamation service were in response
to direct orders issued by Mr. Balling
er. These orders were repeated, he
said, many times, but were never put
in writin . Director Newell of the
reclamation service, he said, protested
vigorously against the secretary's ac?
tion.
Mr. Davis said Secretary Ballingcr
had written a letter to Dr. Thomas E.
Will of this city repeating the state?
ments that lorvds had been restored
upon recommendation of the acting
director of the reclamation service
that they were no longer needed. The
witness said he was the acting direc?
tor referred to; that he had never
made any such recommendation.
Mr. Davis asserted that Mr. Ballin?
gcr was wrong in stating to the presi?
dent that Mr. Garfield's withdrawals
divl not truthfully show what they
were made for. There had been no
subterfuge, he said, and if there had
been any appearance of subterfuge it
was his fault and not Mr. Garfield's.
The witness revealed in his testi?
ng my that there Is Quite a feud be?
tween the reclamation service and the
geological survey. Tt was on report?
of the reclamation service that Secre?
tary Garfield acted in his withdrawal
of power sites. Secretary Ballinger
had depended entirely upon the geo?
logical survey. Mr. Davis did not
hestiate to criticise the survey and
declared that the narrow strips which
had been withdrawn along streams by
the geological survey did not prop?
erly protest the power sites.
The direct examination of Mr. Davis
had not been concluded when ad?
journment was taken until tomorrow
morning.
PROMISES WARMER WEATHER.
Weather Bureau Predicts Week of
Comparatively Iliuli Temperature.
Followed h\ Cool Wave.
Washington, March 13.?Compara?
tively warm weather will prevail over
most of the United States during most
of the present week, according to the
prediction of the weather bureau to?
day. About the middle of the week
a period of cooler weather will set in
over the extreme West and advance
thence to tin* Atlantic coast, reaching
there by the early part of next week.
BLOODHOUNDS SEEK BURGLAR.
Dogs From Penitentiary Sen! to Lex?
ington County.
Lexington, March 13.?Blood?
hounds were brought from the State
penitentiary last night to run down
a burglar who had entered the home
of a negro, and stole a suit of clothes
and some other articles.
The negro house is occupied by
Frank McCain, a negro section hand,
ami he put up the money. The house
was entered between seven and eight
o'clock but it was not until after 11'
o'clock that the dogs arrived in an
"Automobile. Although every effort
as made to get a trail, the do^s
could led get a scent, and the party
returned to the penitentiary at an
? arly hour this morning. There Is
no clue as to the guilty party, but
sheriff Corley will continue to work
on the case.
SOUTHRON, Establb' _oVX M
_ * [
[es?Vol. w vv ? Ao. 6.
?Lb liitCAL HISTOrF
LETTER LEFT BY EX-SENATOR
EXPOSES ALLEGED POLITI?
CAL DEAL.
New Yorker's Posthumous < ommuni
cation Charges Late Former Presi?
dent With Trickery in 1888.
Washington, March 11.?The con?
troversy as to whether President Ben?
jamin Harrison promised to appoint
the late Senator Thomas C. Platt sec?
retary of the treasury in return for
the support of the New York delega?
tion in the national Republican con?
vention of 1888 continues. The story
of Mr. Platt's declaration that such
a promise was made and broken is it?
self interesting.
William E. Curtis, a newspaper
writer, says that shortly after the
publication of the John Sherman
memoirs, in 1895, Mr. Platt gave him
a sealed letter not to be opened until
both he, Platt, and President Harri?
son should be dead. Mr. Curtis says
he opened this letter the morning Mr.
Platt died, that is Monday morning.
The alleged letter he printed in one
of the Washington papers. In sub?
stance it says that at the Republican
convention of 1888, Stephen B. Elkins,
now senator from West Virginia, went
to Senator Platt, at the head of the
New York delegation and producing a
letter from Gen. Harrison, said that
if the New York delegation would
vote for Harrison, Mr. Platt would be
appointed secretary of the treasury.
It further says that for the same con?
sideration, as further payment for his
prospective job in the cabinet, Mr.
Platt gave his personal check for
j $150,000 for the election of Harrison,
which $150,000, Mr. Platt says, was
what turned the election in New York
for Harrison and elected him.
It is all interesting, being very
much like the case of Roosevelt and
Harriman. Roosevelt promised Har
riman that if he would raise a large
fund to be used in the election in New
York he would invite him to Wash?
ington td assist in the preparation of
bis message to congress. And as in
the case of Harriman, Platt declared
afterwards that the bargain had been
violated.
First of all comes Mr. fElkins and
d? nies that be, in the name of Gen.
Harrison, promised Mr. Platt the
place in the cabinet. He says that he
did promise that Mr. Platt should be
c >nsulted about patronage in New
York. Now comes another alleged
'"?sthiimous lcter. this time from Gen.
Harrison, saying that he never prom
? 1 Mr. Platt a cabinet appointment,
and that he never had any idea until
after the election that Mr. Platt want?
ed such an appointment.
But J. Sloat Fassett, now a repre?
sentative from New York in congress,
who was associated with Mr. Platt
and the Ne w York machine at that
time, declares that the alleged post?
humous letter of Senator Platt is sub?
stantially correct that Mr. Platt was
promised the appointment, and that
be himself, Mr. Fassett, went to
President Harrison and urged upon
him the keeping of the promise.
Tt is generally heiieved here, so far
as T can learn, that there was some
j kind of a deal with Mr. Platt f ^r the
New York delegation and that when
he produced that $150.000 to elect
Harrison he had some such thing in
view, doubtless believed he would
surely get the appointment as secre?
tary of the treasury: but it Is thought
to have been a misunderstanding. No
such bargain would have been put In
writing. Gen. Harrison did write a
letter during that convention of 18S8
t" Tom Platt, and sent it by Steve El
kitis. B"t the cautious Elkins instead
of delivering the letter outright mere
ly read it to Platt and kept it. Exact?
ly what was in it Elkins does not say
though be says be has it still. Per?
haps be will produce it. And per?
haps he will not. Tt depends upon
What is in it.
Put this is evidence to all of the
methods of bargaining and sale used
in tbece Republican conventions. Tt
is not the first time; and it is doubt?
ful if it will be the last.
Charlotte. N. C March 11.?Hand?
ing his wife his poekethook and ring.
With the remark: "1 have just drunk
carbolic acid and am going to die,"
Lewis C. Baker, a trusted attache of
the Continental Insurance Company,
threw himself across the bed at his
hlme early this morning, and in less
than an hour died in great agony.
Baker slipped out and secured the
a. id. while waiting for beakfast and
drank it before entering the house
no one witnessing the act. He was a
native of Rock Hill, S. C, where hi
was a successful mill man, coming
ktor* six yt ars ago to engage In the
insurance business. He was forty
two years old.