The watchman and southron. (Sumter, S.C.) 1881-1930, June 23, 1909, Image 2
DISPENSARY INVESTIGATE
SOLOMONS TESTIFIES IN I
DISPENSARY HEARING.
Hampton Man Questioned Ye*t<
Hi Attorney,, for the State Con
In* an Alleged Scale of Coii .nl*
aloaa on Order? die Denies Ever
Having Paid Rebate* to Memeber*
Of DL>pon*?ary Hoard.
Columbia. June 17.?H. L. Solo
stnona, who mpresented the Big
Spring* Distilling Company in thla
State during the old state dlapen
reime. was within close
of being arrested this morn
tag when he appeared as a witness
Sjsfore the dispensary wlnding-up
?commission Although It wss not of
tlclally glvsn out thst the arrest would
t>e made. It wss generally understood
ghat when s recess was taken during
the examination of the witness. It
warns for ths purpose of securing a
warrant on the charge of perjury.
There was a whisper going around
ths room to this effect, and Mr. SoK.
aeons himself wss Informed of the In?
tention of the State. Attorney Gen?
eral Ly>n. Mr. Stevenson and Mr
2*attoa. of the commission, left the
sxxjm and conferred In the office of
Mr. Lyon. When they returned the
examination of the witness was cc
tinned snd brought to a conclusion.
The Information leaked out that
there was in the room at the very mo?
ment the witness wss being examined
m man who could tell of certain trans?
actions of which the witness hsd test?
ified that he knew nothing. This was
especially in regard to the alleged
""seals of commissions" said to have
t>een hied up by whiskey representa?
tives and others at the local hotel
wrhere these gentlemen met on occa?
sions. The name the prospective
ssttnssu was not given but the under
wtaadlng Is thst his testimony would
have wsrrsntsd ths commission hav?
ing: ths arrest made. Of course, the
charge has not been made that the
witness was guilty of perjury. I?
vase the srrest had been made there
weald have been necessary only such
evidence thst would cause a prime
-finale case to be made out against ths
v ?rthneen.
Mr. Solomons' testimony dealt
largely with the denials he mads to
i anatters brought out by Col. Felder's
,- OjusWMsating. He dsnlod sver having
Tald a sent to members of the ooard;
.. denied that He had sver been a party
to a certain scale of prices that were
' Ami id tats jlty by representative's of
?ssrhetLer houi*es snd members of the
"board, as wss Intimated by queUions
asked by Mr. Felder.
Tt was brought out beyond the
shadow of a doubt by the line of
^questions pursued by the State's rep
? iesssitstlTTin todsy thst the commis?
si on Is In possssslon of evidence that
will tend to throw much light upon
?*be d'.pensary proceedings. The stroi.e
InOsnstsuns ag to meetings held for
; arsanat*?m rebates and commissions
teat: no doubt that the state Is sure of
lti ground.
When the commission got down to
swsrk this murning there were several
unexpected snd Interesting matters
brought out. First of all. at the con?
clusion of some discussion on the
Lnnshsn claim Attorney Felder stated
that the State claims this amount, al?
leged to be due the Lanahan firm, by
default. This was sfter Mr. Clark,
attorney for the Lanahan Arm. had
declared that the f.rm would not send
tier* the book containing the formula
for Hunter Baltimore rye. This an?
nouncement came as an aftermath to
thi cull, which has been repeatedly
made for this book by the commis?
sion Tbe claim ts not completed yet.
am there will be Argument? before the
commission when It makes the final
adjustment of the matter.
I ere was a Sharp passage of words
t*t*e?n Mr. C'ark and Col. Feller
Again today. It came about when Mr.
t'lnrk ad. i. commission in
t >>, nn'n tt ton of tb ? hooks. (' d.
; .. ? t ..,k this as an IndieattOfl that
Ik* ws^ being ignored in the proec d
Ing. Mr. riark after some few re?
torts, appealed to the commission
~th .t tb,? pi . ? ?.? ding r?? on In an or?
derly m??nn.r " Col Felder stated
that he Mp>epeeed It !??? treated with
Um . ?nttcsy lo which i am entitled.'1
*L further stated that he had for?
borne many things during the pro
??? "mi on account of the age of
garuaeeti but would not stand for any
roor*. The storm passed over In e
trx n u-nents.
TN sales book showing one sale t ?
th. t as, In which the formula was
acr.f .isd. was produced. This was for
g% nl ?: -erve. and
the i i tula v. ?*s aa f dlows* "Fifteen
ejwlion? oi spring Garden. Intensac.
g Hook Spring barrels." gaaggdatg to
the entry. There was another entry
showing that 1<>0 cases of Hunter
pints and the same amount of half
pints wer#? sold here, und G II
Charles' name \% is In the left hand
Weener of the page, wherein Othef
transactions, as pointed out by coun
wL ?h* entry was made showing the|
name of the salesman of the firm.
What is Intensac" This 1? tbe
Ion which has hothei?>d many
hsve considered th?> prOOOdlagS
the commission recently. Today
Clark Introduced as evidence a
f the material, showing what this
ance is. The can reads that in
c Is an artificial sweetener, "a
de soda salt of pure saccharine
times sweeter than sugar." "It
be used entirely or partially to
replace sugar." The directions add
that 1 ounce of lntensac equals 31 1-4
pounds of sugar, 1 pound of intensac
equals 500 pounds of sugar and 5
pounds of Intensac equals 2,500
pounds of sugar. ,
Mr. Clark also produced an ana'.vs's
of Hunter rye, which set out that the
whiskey Is good stuff and has the
characteristics of genuine whiskey.
He had sent to a laboratory a bottle
of the rye and a partial examination
was made; \a more complete analysis
Is to be produced later on. This
chemist stated In a letter which was
read to the commission today that he
knew of no test by which the constit?
uent parts of whiskey could be sep?
arated, that he would like to know
of such a test, but fears that none ex?
ists.
Col. Felder objected to the state?
ment of the chemist. He said that
there are variances between the ana
l>sis of chemists, and this should be
considered by the comm.lt.sion. He
has heard that a whiskey expert is in
this city now and will have him be?
fore the commission to testify.
The Lanahan matter was brought
to an abrupt close when Col. Felder
asked about the formula for Hunter
rye being brought here. He stated
that an executive session might be
had so that the public would not be
given the trade secret of the firm. Mr.
Clark, having replied that this formu?
la would not be given, Col. Felder
asked that the claim be placed on the
minutes as "claimed by the State by
default."
In connection with the Lanahan
claim Col. Felder stated that the books
showing dealings with Farnum had
not been brought, that Farnum was
the representative in this State of
Lanahan, that he collected from Lan?
ahan and paid some of the money to
the State board of directors. ?
Mr. Brlce of the oommisslon stated
that the commission knew these to
be facts, and urged that the books be
brought. The books of the Lanahan
Arm are here now and will be kept
for further examination. The matter
Is ended for the present.
Claim of the Carolina Glass Co.
The claim of the Carolina Glass
Company, of this city, was considered
this afternoon before the dispensary
winding-up commission. Two wit?
nesses were examined, and the mat?
ter will be taken up again tomorrow.
This claim has been very much dis?
cussed throughout the State, and was
reopened along with the other claims
recently. The amount of the claim is
$23,013.75, and the contention of the
glass company is that the State was
not overcharged. There was a great
deal of testimony taken on this claim
by the legislative committee, which
has been brought up again. The con?
tention of the State was outlined by
Gen. Anderson, who conducted the
matter this afternoon for the State,
when he said: "We admit the audit
\j correct as far as the books go, but
the State has certain counter claims
which we believe will reduce or extin?
guish altogether the claim of this
company.'*
In the course of the testimony Mr.
Brlce, of the commission, made the
statement that according to the evi?
dtnee which he has read in this cat.e
the glass company owes the State In?
stead of the State owing the glass
company. He wished for some testi?
mony to be offered to rebut the testi?
mony upon which he based this con?
clusion. He wished to give the com?
pany Justice in their claim, but this
testimony was against them. Mr.
i'rlce stated also that the evidence
showed that there had been close re?
lationship between th company and
the members of the State board.
In discussing the evidence in the
i ase Mr. Lyles said: "We are ready
i.nd willing for anything to be brought
against us, but we are satisfied that
nOthlOg can be brought against us.'
It was brought out by the attorney
t<?r the Stnte that It appeared from
entries in Ledger ? that the south
Caroling dispensary had advanced the
Stim of $S,140.19 before any goods
were received from the Carolina Glass
Company, Mr. Lyiei stated that be
proposed to show that the shipments
had been made and thai the money
\> i- only payments on tin> goods
Hooks wore Introduced to show the
i?* plod of time when deals were made
will? the CUroltni Class Company.
???ii. Anderson sii?i that he would in
iroduoe books to show that the dato
ul tke Brat bid made, date of nrst bid
awarded, all Invoices ami several
communications appearing in minutes
relating lo the Carolina Glass Com?
pany,
a severe flora passed through the
Locust Bill section near Greenville!
blowing down and demolishing the
borne of Mr Bataofti oatchlni the oc
< upants of the house under the build?
ing. They escaped uninjured after
the ritorm Muck other damage was
dOBi tO Oropf And timber in that sec?
tion.
GUSS COMPANY CLAIM.
WAS argued FRIDAY before
DISPENSARY COM MISSION.
Cicn. Anderson Yery Pointed?Claims
That the Company Was Orguni/.cd
To Hun Out Competition and Tliey
lloosted Pri es.
Columbia, June 19.?The case of
the Carolina Glass Company was
argued yesterday before the dispen?
sary commission. Very little new evi?
dence was submitted at this session,
and there may be no more evidence
|q be submitted. In the argument
yesterday Gen. Clifford L. Anderson
distinguished himself. Gen. Anderson
some two years ago was offered a
place on the Supreme Court bench in
Georgia but declined. He yesterday
proved his reputation as a lawyer of
analytical mind.
It was announced in The State yes?
terday that W. B. Smith Whaley was
In the city and efforts were made to
get him to tell the commission what
he knew of the history of the glass
company, but he had left on a.i early
train.
Gen. Anderson In opening the argu?
ment laid down the broad statement
that instead of the State of South
Carolina owing the glass company
arything, that concern is indebted to
the State. He alleged that the glass
company was conceived In a spirit to
defraud the State.
In proof of this he cited the affi?
davits of Brevard D. Miller, who with
W. B. S. Whaley first proposed the
building of the glass factory. Mr.
Miller had declared that he had drop?
ped out of the organization because
the majority wished to give a block
of stock to L. J. Williams and an?
other to H. H. Evans, then members
of the board, said stock to be carried
under the name of W. G. Childs as
trustee. There is no direct evidence
to show that this compact was ever
carried out, but there is corrobora?
tive circmstantlal evidence, Gen. An?
derson claimed. He declared that the
stockholders would never have put
$60,000 Into such a precarious enter?
prise had they not had some idea that
their bids would be accepted. The
first act was to get the dispensary to
put in an order on borrowed "sam?
ples" before the glass company ever
started its flumes, and this was a vio?
lation of the laws which required that
all bids be' submitted with samples.
The next act was to buy the unexplr
ed Flaccus contract for 22 cars. This
was for the purpose of stifling compe?
tition.
The Flaccus Company had received
an award in January, 1900, and this
was In August, 1902. The Flaccus
Company had been given an award of
150 cars which lasted for all of this
time and had not yet been filled.
There was no competitive bidding af?
ter the first one or two awards and
the glass company practically had a
monopoly and gradually raised the
prices. Gen. Anderson claimed that
Oh a certain basis of prices the State
had been overcharged $240,000; on
another basis it was an overcharge of
$130,000 and finally, on a basis of the
average of prices submitted, the over?
charge was ?98,000.
Mr. Lyles made a very strong argu?
ment in reply. He said that the chair?
man of the dispensary board, Mr. L.
J. Williams, months before the glass
company was organized, had declared
to the dispensary management ahe
difficulty in getting supplies of glass.
The glass business is like nothing else.
The furnaces are shut down through
the summer and unless the orders are
placed considerably in advance they
may not be filled.
He admitted the transaction with
Flaccus, but declared that the State
board had declared that Flaccus had
already delivered more than the num?
ber of cars named in the contract,
and that the Carolina Glass Company
really had paid $1,600 for something
it did not get. "Why, then, should it
now be required to make good? The
Flaccus people had construed their
contract to mean 150 cars of 1.360
cases each, but the dispensary board
had declared 850 cases to be its idea
of a carload.
Mr. Lyles contended further that it
was unfair to make comparisons with
sales to parties In other States, for
the dispensary quart bottles weighed
12 ounces each and the ware sold to
other customers weighed but 10
ounces each.
Mr. Lyles concluded with an earn?
est argument to show that no unfair
or illegal profits had been charged
and that the glass company really had
but moderate success...
Mr. Lyles derided the Brevard Mil
lev affidavit which he declared to have
been contradicted by th^ testimony of
some of the most reliable men of the
State. Furthermore he declared that
Mr. W. G. Childs had stated on the
witness stand that his account as
'trustee" had been on behalf of his
minor children.
Gen. Anderson In reply made a stir
ring arraignment of condtlons. He
Islsted that Brevard Miller's afflda
,1?. Instead of being contradicted suc?
cessfully had really been strengthen?
ed. He declared that the evidence of
5V\ G. Childs had not been satisfying
tnd that there was in evidence a let?
ter from Selbels to MJIIer showing
hat H. H. Evans and T. J. Williams
\ad Indicated that they would be kind
o this Infant Industry.
He made a very careful argument
n which he took up a great many
>ther details.
The commission now has the case
inder advisement.
Engineer W. H. Turner, of Colum
)!a. and Fireman J. T. Carlisle, a
'atlve of Falrneld, were killed Thurs
isy by the derailment of a freight'
rain at Styx, a few miles south of
Columbia. Both men were married.
TROUBLE IX HAWAII.
Hawaiian Grand Jury Brings in Addi?
tional True Bills Against Japanese*
Charging Conspiracy to Commit
Murder.
Honolulu, June IT.?Following the
indictment of several of the Japanese*
strike leaders last Friday, the terri?
torial grand jury returned additional
indictments today against Y. Soga, F.
Makino, M. Xegoso, K. Kawamura, Y.
Tasaka and Y. Anashira for conspir?
acy to commit murder and to incite
others to crime. An indictment for
assault was found against Sugwara,
who is accused of attempting to col?
lect funds for the strikers by violence.
In addition to these indictments 13 of
the striking Japaneses at the Wai Pa
lu plantation were indicted for at?
tacking a police officer and rioting.
As a result of the vigorous action of
the authorities the strikers are much
depressed.
ATTEMPTED ASSAULT.
School Teacher Brutally Assaulted by
Xegro.
Columbia, June 19.?The George
] t nvn sheriff advised Governor Ansel
yesterday (Friday) that he has a sus
\ pect in ail, who, it is thought, at
, tempted an assault on a school teach?
er of that Counts', on Thursday after?
noon. Governor Ansel telegraphed to
protect the prisoner. When found the
J teacher was bloody with the desper
l ate struggle. The negro caught the
I school teacher while out driving with
a child.
DEMOCRATS FOR IXCOME TAX.
Minority Caucus Reiterates Members'
Declaration.
Washington. June 17.?When the
income tax question comes up in the
senate tomorrow. Senator Aldrich,
chairman of the finance committee,
will again move that action be de?
ferred until after schedules in the
tariff bill have been completed.
This action win carry with it Presi?
dent Taft's programme for the enact?
ment of a law taxing net earnings of
corporations and the adoption of a
resolution submitting the question of
the amendment to the constitution so
as to permit congress to levy and col?
lect a tax cn incomes without regard
to apportionment among the States.
Mr. Aldrich will make the state?
ment that he bei lere? consideration
of schedules may be finished b\ lion
day an?i he wttl suggest that the post
ponemc:.. of ihe income lax and cor?
poration tax measures be held until
that time.
At a caucus of the Democratic sen?
ators today it was decided that the
minority shall stand by their declara?
tion in favor of the passage of an in?
come tax law at the present session.
The caucus was well attended.
HOBBY MAX DHOWXED.
Mr. Sum Hughes Perithel in Watej
of Bull Creek.
Conway, June 14.?The re]
reached town today of the urownii
late yesterday evening of Mr.
Hughes, son of Mr. L. F. Hughes, foj
merly a '?trehent of Conway, n<
farming near the town. The drow
ing occurred in Bull Creek, at Ed<
Lake, v here Mr. Hughes was emploj
ed by the Eddy Lake Lumber Cot
pany.
Moses Stevens, a negro of Aikj
was convicted of arson, having bui
ed the barn of Mrs. M.. C. Mosel?1
He will hang at Aiker*. The tei
mony of his wife and mother caui
his conviction.
Scholarship and E France Examli
tlons Clemson Agii * ural Collegf
At the Court House on Friday. Ji
2nd, 9 A. M., the Scholarship and E
trance Examinations to Clemson Ari
cultural College will be held un<
the direction of the County Board
Education.
Applicants must be at least 16 yef
of gge and must be prepared to em
the Freshman Class. There are
Scholarships in the Preparatory Cla '
Thfs class is only open to a limit
number of boys who cannot rea
high schools and who are living
sections of the State where school 1
cilities are poor. Scholarships arc
worth $100.00 and Free Tuition. The
next session of Clemson Agricultur
College will begin Sept. 8, 1909.
Apply to the County Superintende.
of Education after June 20th f?
needed information concerning tl
Scholarship Examinations.
For catalogs, further information
and cards upon which to make appl
ction for entrance to the College, ad?
dress
P. H. MELL. President
Clemson College, S. C.
6-9-tt W. & S.
Winthrop College
SCHOLARSHIP and EXTRAXC
EXAMINATION.
The examination for the award c
vacant Scholarships in Winthrop Col?
lege and for the admission of nc1
students will be held at the County
Court House on Friday, July 2, at 9,
a. m. Applicants must be not IgM
than fifteen years of age. When Schoi
arshfps are vacant after Jtry 2. the*
will be awarded to thr?e making th-;
highest average at this. - vamlnatio*
provided they meet lh<> condition
governing the award. Applicants fo
.Scholarships snould write to Presi
dent Johnson before the examination
for Scholarship examination blanks.
Scholarships are worth $100 an
free tuition. The next session wM
open September 15, 1909. For furtl
er information and catalogue, addr< -
Pres. D. B. Johnson, Rock Hill, S. (
W. & S. to 7-2-09.
GREAT PREMIUM OFFERS
TO 'SUBSCRIBERS OF THE
Semi-Weekly Watchman and Southron
$1.50
ONE YEAR'S SUBSCRIPTION, 104 ISSUES, OF THE
s3smi-Weekly Watchman and Southron
AND A PAIR OF ADJUSTABLE TENSION SPRING SHEARS
steel shears, or a hamilton safety razor all for
THE STEEL PHEA11S given away are manufactured of the very htgesl grade ?teel, perfectly tempered au<l lieavlly nlckle-plat d
on a highly polttdiid turf ace. The patent tension Mprlng tHkeaupall trie wearon 11 ?? rivet, no thai tlie cuftlug edges will never wear dal t.
A simple turn of the little thumb-screw will adjust the blades to cut anything from the thluesi and muni dellc?te fabric lot lie heaviest
material,
HOW TO OKT THE SHEARS Send us 11.80 wltli ?"? cents ^additional f?>r postage, and you will feeeire theSheara by n
i Min in;?11 :mi*i the Html-Weekly Watchman and Houtlirou for otie year. The ehears are offen d u an a?ulit loned Inducement t.. subscribe.
Better <lo li now, an the iiumnet i> limited,
the shears are free-you only pay for the paper.
<nji c^Q U the regular subscription price of the Semi Weekly Watchman and Southf ort. It is published
_!_ every Wednesday and Friday and contains a summary "t .ill the important local, domestic and for?
eign news, and is an up-to-date of publication, together with special features from contributors
with a departmentdevoted to Agriculture, Poultry, Stock Raising, and other useful information for the ill*
aronnd Southern producer.
The Osteen Publishing Co., &
sumter,
South Carolina.