The watchman and southron. (Sumter, S.C.) 1881-1930, October 18, 1905, Image 1
man aw
?HS SUMT?B WA?CHKAH, Batablished April. 1350?
"Be Just and Fear not-Let all the Ends thou Aims t at be thy Country's thy God's and Truth's.'
THE TBUK SOUTHBON, Established June, 18*
CosolMafed lag. 2,1881.
SUMTER. S. C.. WEDNESDAY. OCTOBER 18. 1905.
New Series-Toi. XXY. No. IS
Ci? 'i?fatfi? at?i Sontk?n
t
Published Story Wednesday,
-BY
OSTEEN PUBLISHING COMPANY,
SUMTER, S. C.
TCBUB :
fl 50 per an nam-in advance.
IDTIBTlSIMIIi:
Dae Square first insertion..................$1 CO
? rerj subsequent insertion........ .. 50
Contracts foi three months, or longer will
b made nt reduced rates.
AU co a ta un icario DB which subserve private
interests vi!) be charged for as advertiementa.
Obituaries and tributes of respects will be
?a&r?ed for. \
R. W. PORTER TELLS STORY.
-Hie- injure* Man Relates How He
Spent the Hours of Returning
Consciousness.
Mr. R. W. Porter, the Kershaw
man who was struck in the head and j
so dangerously injured at the time
Mr. R. A. McDowell" was foully mur?
dered, and who was brought to the
^Columbia hospital with his life hang?
ing in the balance* one week ago last
night, is now regarded by his physi?
cians as being out of danger and his
recovery is only a matter of days.
For the first time since he has been i
here, a representative of The State
was allowed to see him yesterday. Mr.
Porter was eating his supper when j
the reporter was admitted. Mrs. Por?
ter was with him and tenderly waited
upon him during the meal.
* The wounded man was reclining on
his cot, but was strong enough to
raise himself upon his elbow while he
^ took his supper. His head was
% swathea in bandages that cover it en?
tirely above the ears and eyes. There
are stillv black bruises around both
eyes, which Mr. Porter thinks were
-received when he fell after being
struck.
Mr. Porter is entirely rational, but
was no more able to recall anything
of the attack "than when he awoke at
the Wateree bridge the morning af?
ter the trag, dy. Speaking slowly and
Jr. a \oice that sometimes trembled
from v;eak::css, he related how he re?
members as if in a dream that his
.first moment of memory was when
khe was walking along the road to
'ward the bridge. He was dazed and
had no pain or sensation of injury,
but felt that there was something
wrong with his head. He can now re?
call that one of the first things he'did
was to take off his hat and look at the
A plac? that had been broken in it by
V the blow. He does not know, but feels
vaguely that some on called his at?
tention to the hole in his hat. He has
no impression of who this was, if it
really happened. He was conscious
then, that his face and hands were
covered with blood and all night
long he could feel the blood dripping
from the ghastly wound in his head,
but never once did he reaize what it
meant or feel the necessity of calling
for help.
When he grew faint from the loss
of blood he sat on an embankment
on the side of the road for awhile and
then walked to several trees that grow
in a pea field, bordered by the em?
bankment on which he had been sit'
tin. Here he remained until daylight,
when he was slightly more revived
and then went to the house of the
bridge keeper at the Wateree j river
bridge, and was washing the caked
Mood from his face at a pump when
Mr. Ammons, the rural mail carrier,
took him in his buggy and carried
bim to Dr. Dunn's office in Camden*
The hat worn by Mr. Porter when
he was struck was seen in his room
at the hospital. It is a new, black
stiff hat. There is a hole about ha'f
an inch in width and about two inches
long, where the blow was struck
through it*, on the right side in front
the brim is broken across the front
and there is also a break in the back
that looks as if it had been punced
with a small stick or other jagged in?
strument. The band inside of the
hat is smeared with blood.
Mr. Porter will probably not leave
the hospital for another week. He
spoke very feelingly yesterday of the
kindness that has been shown him by
his friends and even by many here
whom he loes not know.-The State*
THE OLNEY MURDER,
Middletown, N. Y., Oct. 14.-There
were no new developments in the
triple murder mystery this morning.
The authorities are at sea and the
Pinkerton man is simply going over
the same ground again that has been
gone over many times before. There
is one man being sought for who lives
near the Olney house and who has
been missing since the day of the
murder, when he was known to haw
h^d "o^'derable money. Every ef?
fort :r. being made to find him. Mrs.
Ing?rick's condition remains about
the same.
SULLY AND SMITH SPEAK.
THE DOCTRINE OF FAIR PRICES
FOR COTTON ABLY PRE?
SENTED.
Hundreds of Farmers, Merchants and
Bankers Fill the Opera House to
Hear Daniel J. Sully and E. 1
D. Smith-A Lasting Im?
pression Made and Cot?
ton WiU Be Held.
From The Daily It?m October 13.
From all sections of this county and
from adjoining counties, the farmers,
white and black alike, were assem?
bled in the Opera House this morn?
ing and filled it to its utmost capacity,
while Messrs. Daniel J. Sully, of New
York, E. D. Smith and H. F. Hyatt
poured into their attentive ears words
of life and hope for the south's pros?
perity, for its freedom from the
shackles of speculation of the means
of taking advantage of the God-given
monopoly of the fleecy staple that
furnishes eighty per cent, of the
clothes of the world, and depicted in
glowing terms the dawn of that event?
ful day when the sduth shall again be
queen of the world, and when cotton
shall rule as its industrial king.
The day of awakening is at hand;
no more shall the faraier of the south
bow down in humble supplication io
the speculators and manufacturers of
the north and Europe, but Vi th the
principles of Southern Cotton Grow?
ers association animating our people
and being deep rooted in their hearts,
and with such men as these leading
them on in wisdom's path and setting
the light before them, there is no
doubt but that the down-trodden
farmer of the South will rise up in
one mighty and united"* action, over?
throw the power that has enslaved
rthem for more than sixty years, ?nd
j in the full strength of new-found
! manhood, regulate the value of the
currency of our country, the envy of
the ?ntire world-the South's cotton.
Mr. Sully Speaks.
The meeting opened with the rendi?
tion of a beautiful selection by the
Second Regiment band. At its con
I elusion, Daniel J. Sully, one of the
South's greatest benefactors, the man
who advanced cotton from 6 cents
to 17 cents in a few months, was
pleasingly introduced by President A.
B. Stuckey, of the Sumter County
County Cotton Growers' Association.
Mr. Sully spoke impressively and with
a full knowledge of the cotton situa?
tion, and his remarks were given the
closest attention.
He expressed his delight at being
present to address such a representa?
tive body of South Carolinians. He
thought that he was in a position to
understand the value of the cotton
product, and he desired to impress
upon the farmers there assembled
certain facts relative to the real value
of their staple product. In consider?
ing the value he took up first the con?
sumption of cotton.
The South, he said, provides 80 per
cent, of the cotton of the world. Eng?
land and Europe" have spent millions
in an endeavor to foster cotton gr zw?
ing in their dependencies in order to
become independent of America; but,
in all of their efforts, they have fail?
ed. In 1903 when they discovered
that they had lost their grip upon the
cotton situation they diverted the use
of their millions from fostering the
growth of cotton in their colonies, and
used the same money to beat down
the price of cotton here. In 1905 the
farmers organized in New Orleans to
hold their product, and it was not un?
til July that England and Europe
realized that the farmers were sin?
cere. They marshaled all of their
energy and money in order to beat
down the price; they failed in Sep?
tember, but when the government re?
port of 71.02 on the cotton crop was.
flashed around the globe, the price
fell. He did not propose to enter into
a criticism of the government, but
would say that he would like to have
an explanation of what ?-.the figures
meant. He showed how the mills
were combined against the farmers
to get the price of cotton below 9
cents, and if they win, cotton will
never again bring more than 7 cents.
He urged the necessity of combining
! with earnestness and determination,
and he said that it was essential that
it be done this year, and if we do not,
we never will.
The spindle industry of Europe has
its entire output sold to 1907, and the
sales have been made upon a basis of
13 cent cotton. The farmers must
make them pay that price for it.
Today, on your streets, cotton is
selling for 9 1-4 cents, and the mills
in their greed for gain are even anx?
ious to force their price still lower,
in order that their margin of profit
may be increased. But if this cotton
is held and the mills realize they can?
not get it at their own price, it will
of necessity create competition among
themselves, and the price of the sta
pie will go bounding upward.
Wool has no future market. Ii
1903 it was worth but 7 cents pe:
pound on the sheeps' back; today i
brings 28 cents, an increase of 40'
I per cent. The difference between th<
wool and the cotton market lies in th<
fact that cotton has a future market
wool has not, therefore, the price o
cotton is regulated by futures.
The farmers of the South have ?
product without which the world ii
its physical and industrial life coule
not move. Do not think that by hold
ing cotton you are aione,"*by your
selves-the whole South is with you
every bale received on your marke
is wired around the world. Upor
these receipts depends the price o:
cotton. If the South withholds it?
cotton from the market the spinners
and speculators will soon find that th?
value of cotton is the price demand'
ed by the producers.
President Smith.
Senator R. L Manning next intro?
duced Hon. E. D. Smith, president ol
the State Cotton Growers' Associa?
tion. Xo one, he said, felt * mort
keenly or unselfishly the condition ir
which our people find themselves to?
day.
It appeared to him that cotton was
being held better everywhere than it
is in Sumter. If commercial prosper?
ity for the South is desired, cotton
must be held. The name of Sully will
always be synonymous with the day
of the commencement of the prosper?
ity of the South. When we were un?
able to strike, he, though of the
North, struck a blow for us that cost
him his fortune, but which brought
millions to the South. '
Theodore Price is a shrewd specula?
tor; he speculated principally in
Southern fools, and he had a fertile
field in which to ply his trade. Price
and his associates act along simple
lines, and have amassed their for?
tunes by getting cheap raw material
and receiving a high price for the
manufactured article. The cheaper
the cotton, the greater the profit on
the cloth.
Where could the world get its sup?
ply of cotton if not from"~*us. It hus
been said that when Theodore Price
sells, the world sells, and when Price
buys the worid buys, and that the
destiny of the South is wrapped up
in Price.. But the destiny of the
S mth is wrapped up only in the silken
fiber of cotton, the commodity of the
South-the currency of the South.
High price of cotton is indicative ol
prosperity, low price, or commercial
stagnation.
We challenge foreign competition.
In IS66, when our land was devasta?
ted, the price went to $1.S9 per pound
in New York. Six years from that day
it brought 65 cents per pound. Why
not competition then? The other
nations of the world could not com?
pete with the South in the production
of cotton when cotton was selling at
that high price. What of today?
Why were we unable to make a
fight before? After the devastation of
the South the Northern banks loaned
to the Southern banks, the Southern
banks to the Southern merchant and
the Southern merchant to the South?
ern farmer, so when the notes became
due the Northern bank would pull by
this chain of papers the cotton from
the field to the market, and it was
sold at a price fixed by the North.
The time" has come for the farmers
to stick, and they will stickt I was
laughed at when I preached the doc
trin of "10-cent-cotton," but the re?
sults speak fdr themselves. There is
only one question involved; you have
the cotton and you can fix the price.
The only problem is the manhood to
hold it.
The speculators boast of their mil?
lions with which to fight. Hold your
cotton until their contracts become
due; then let them spin their cotton
cloth out of greenbacks! Hold it un?
til you get your price and then make
them pay 1 1-2 cents extra for wor?
rying you. The reason that the farm?
er cannot stick is that the merchant
and banks force the cotton out of his
grasp. Ask for time from your credi?
tors, but stick. Beg, borrow or steal,
but don't sell! The only way to ac?
complish the desired end is to hold.
The man that makes one bale is just
as responsible as the man that makes
a thousand. Every man who does
not join the fight to get out of cotton
all we are entitled to is a traitor to
the South and not worthy of respect.
Once he was asked if he did not think
that the methods that he was pur?
suing to advance the price of cotton
would ki.l the goose that laid the
golden egg. He replied that his ob?
ject was to kill the scamps that stole
the golden egg.
To the merchants and bankers he
once asked the following questions:
1. Do you, or do you not believe
that cotton is the currency of the
South?
2. That it is the predominant in?
dustry of the country?
3. That the South has a monopoly
of it?
All being answered in the arfirima
tive, it was easy to prove that they
could regulate its price, and the im?
portance of doing so.
When a bale of cotton comes to
town who comes up? to ..-ut the bale
and sample it. Who is on the other
side? One of the representatives of
the wealth and brains of the country,
the other a representative of the
South's poverty and ignorance. An
unequal combat. Why can't you say:
Stop, don't sell; here's my warehouse,
here's my bank. Give him the mon?
ey that he needs, and hold the cotton.
Our fathers fought for political
supremacy forty years ago, we must
fight for financial supremacy now.
Their fight was lost but our fight
must be crowned with victory?
Mr. F. H. Hyatt, State treasurer of
the Cotton Growers' Association, was
introduced by Hon. A. B. Stuckey.
He had left his speech at home
but brought with him plenty of plans
and specifications for warehouses.
Yesterday he spent in Darlington
where $10,000 was subscribed for a
warehouse, which would be com?
pleted in thirty days. He urged the
farmers to hold their cotton, and
urged them to say to the rest of the
world: "Pay us our price, or you will
freeze while we starve."
THE DORCHESTER CASE.
Friends of Former Treasurer Whet
sell Think the Comptroller Acted
With Undue Haste.
St. George, October 13.-In view of
the fact that only the charges of
Comptroller General Jones, in regard
to the .irregularities in the office of
Treasurer J. 'M. Whetsell, of Dorches
I ter county, have been made public,
the friends of Mr. Whetsell desire
that the public should know the stat?
us of the charges made against the
county treasurer yand the facts lead
j ing up to his suspension from office.
The facts relating to the matter as
told by the county treasurer and his
friends are these:
In 1901 the books of the treasurer's
office for 1900 were audited by Mr.
Jones, who was then chief clerk to
Comptroller General Derham, and
found to be correct and the receipts
signed by Mr. Jones for that year are
still in the hands of the treasurer. Al?
though the law requires the books of
the county treasurers to be examined
every year, the treasurer of Dorches?
ter county was not checked up until
a few weeks ago. when Mr. Wilson,
clerk in the Comptroller General's of?
fice, investigated them. This investi?
gation proved that there were no ir?
regularities that could not be explain?
ed by thc county treasurer since the
books were audited by Mr. Jones in
1901, but Mr. Wilson went back of
this date and found, it is claimed, fafcse
credits which amounted to some
S2,100. although Mr. Jones had re?
ported the books correct up to that
date.
Mr. Wilson promptly reported these
irregularities to the Comptroller Gen?
eral in Columbia. Mr. Jones, it is
said, came to St. George himself the
following day and made this astound?
ing proposition to Treasurer Whetsell:
"If you will pay this shortage we will
continue you in office, and report only
your clerical mistakes, which amount?
ed to only a few dollars."
Mr. Whetsell refused to pay this
money, calling the Comptroller Gen?
eral's attention to the fact that he had
his own receipts, bearing hi" signa?
ture to the correctness of the books
up to 1901.
Then it was that Hr. Jones threat?
ened to have him dismissed unless he
made good the shortage, and Mr.
Whetsell refused. His dismissal by
the governor on the charges present?
ed by Mr. Jones came as a surprise to
Mr. Whetsell, as he was not aware of
the governor's action until he read it
in the News and Courier.
Mr. Whetseil and his friends claim
that he has been unjustly treated, that
if these charges had been brought to
his attention in 1901 they could have
been explained satisfactiroly by his
clerk and bookkeeper, who at that
time had charge of his office.
The matter will be brought up be?
fore the next legislature, when Mr.
Whetsell will demand a thorough in?
vestigation, and he is certain that he
will be vindicated.
There is a strong feeling against
Comptroller General Jones for his ac?
tion in the matter, as every one seems
thoroughly to believe in the honesty
of Mr. Whetsell.
The Supreme Court has sustained
the verdict of the Greenville Court of
General Sessions in the case of John
Waldrop, white, who was sentenced
to life imprisonment for murder.
The Lancaster county delegation
has recommended Mr. J. E. Black
mon for appointment as treasurer of
the county, vice W. C. Cauthen, de?
ceased.
THE COURT'S DECISION.
The Opinion of the Supreme Court in
the George YV. Murray Case.
The decision of the Supreme Court
reviews the testimony and gives the
conclusions so clearly that extracts
from the opinion are here quoted:
The remaining exceptions raise the
question whether there was any tes?
timony tending to sustain the allega?
tions of the indictment that were put
in issue and contested by the defend?
ant. In order to constitute forgery
by uttering or publishing a forged
instrument of writing three impor?
tant factors are requisite: (1. It
must be uttered or published as true
and genuine. (2) It must be known
by the party uttering or publishing it
as false, forged or counterfeited. (3) j
It must be with intent to prejudice,
damage or defraud another person.
We will first consider whether there
was any testimony to the effect that it
was uttered or published by the de?
fendant as true and genuine.
?It was offered in evidence by the
defendant upon the trial of the action
for specific performance of contract,
instituted against him by Scipio Chat
man and James Chatman, and he tes?
tified that it was genuine.
The next question for consideration
is whether there was any testimony
tending to prove that the defendant
knew that the writing uttered or pub?
lished . was false, forged or counter?
feit. There is abundance of testi?
mony to the effect that said writing
was forged.
James Chatman testified that he du.
not sign the lease. Scipio Chatman
testified that James Chatman did not
sign on the 4th of November, 1899, I
while he and James were at the house
ol defendant, when the negotiations
for the lease or purchase of the land
were consummated. Marion W. Cato,
who witnessed the agreement, signed
in duplicate.by Scipio Chatman and
George W. Murray, testified that he
did not sign his name as a witness to
the instrument or writing which set
out in the indictment, which purports
to have been signed by George W.
Murray and James Chatman and wit?
nessed by him.
Witness testified that there was on?
ly one kind of ink used by Murray and
others when the papers were signed
on the 4th of November, IS99, and it
was black, yet the alleged forged in?
strument was written in blue ink and
on white paper, while the duplicate
writing, signed by the defendant and
Scipio Chatman was on blue paper.
E. F. Miller testified that he printed
the blank on which the lease in ques?
tion was written along with others,
for the defendants, during the early
part of the year 1900. On those
blanks then printed appear the num?
bers "190"-in two places.
It is at least a reasonable inference
from these facts that the defendant
knew the writing was forged.
The next question that will be con?
sidered is whether there was testi?
mony tending to show that the writ?
ing was uttered with a fraudulent in
intent. * * *
The facts which constitute the of?
fence are here found. The intent is
only matter of circumstances, which
naturally follows and springs out of
the facts. No other than a fraudu?
lent intent can be inferred when a
man makes or passes a false deed as
law for a true one. The law will
presume as the foregoing case (in
odium fraudis) that it was done with
-a fraudulent intention. The defend?
ant testified that he did not know un?
til the proceedings for specific per?
formance were commenced that the
parties claimed that only one of them
had signed the contract, and after?
wards when he found out that only
one of them had signed, he mention?
ed it in his answer.
The following appears in the testi?
mony of the defendant:
Q. You have stated that up to tho
time these proceedings were started
? you thought both these parties signed
the contract?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And you set up in your answer
that Scipio Chatman had signed this
contract, you began to look up your
papers, and you found that paper
signed by James Chatman.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And you set up in your answe:
that Scipio didn't make any contract
with you, but James Chatman did so,
and that he had abandoned the land
and gone away?
A. Yes, sir; and so he had.
Also the following:
Well, you have stated to the coun?
sel that when you swore out this no?
tice and affidavit to turn these people
off, that you swore it out as having
been a contract with the two of them ?
Yes, sir.
Q. And afcerwards when you
found one had signed you mentioned
it in your answer?
A. Yes, sir.
Marion W. Cato testified that the
Royal
Baking
Powder
is made of Grape
Cream of Tartar.*
Absolutely Pure*
Makes the food
more Wholesome
and Delicious.
defendant approached him about tes?
tifying in the case, and said he want
ed him to say he witnessed "those pa?
pers."
The testimony tended to prove that
there was a scheme on the part of de?
fendant to show that only James Chat
man signed theVease, and that he had
i
abandoned the land and gone away.
This would have been prejudicial to
the rights of Scipio Chatman.
The question whether there was a
fraudulent intent depended upon all
the facts and surrounding circum?
stances of the case, and we are unable
;o say that the verdict is without any
testimony to support it.
It is the judgment of this court that
the judgment of the Circuit Court be
affirmed.
FIRE IX BAMBERG.
Southern Depot and a Lot of Mer?
chandise and Cotton Destroyed.
Bamberg, October 13.-Tonight
Bamberg suffered one of the most
disastrous fires in Its history. Shortly
before 9 o'clock the alarm was sound?
ed, and it was discovered that the
freight depot of the Southern railway,
a wooden building, was on fire. To
the depot was attached a long cotton
platform which was crowded with
cotton and merchandise of various
kinds.
The fire burned rapidly and nothing
was saved from the depot. A few
bales of cotton and some merchan?
dise were saved. Several cars on the
sidetrack werer rolled away and saved
but four freight cars loaded with cot?
ton and two empties were burned.
COTTON BEING HELD. ?
.A-,
The Prospect Uuder Improved Ware?
house Storage Conditions.
Although there are scarcely any fa?
cilities for storing cotton in Sumter,
and the Standard Warehouse is not
yet completed, still cotton is being,
held in every section cf the county^
In the city alone there are more than*
500 bales stored at the cotton com?
press, and the barns and storehouses
on nearly every farm are filled, with;
bales of cotton. The receipts at this:
season of the year are much smaller
than they were at the same time last
year, and a great portion of the cotton
that is now being marketed was soldi
last year to be delivered this fall. and.
is bringing more than ten cents..
The determination to hold has seiz?
ed the people, and the}' are not will?
ing to sacrifice the fruits of their la?
bor. The first section of the Stand?
ard Warehouse that is How in the
process of construction will be com?
pleted within thirty days, which wilt
furnish warehouse room for from TOO
to 1.000 bales. The other sections
will be rushed, and when completed
will have a capacity of 5.000 bales.
This marks only the beginning of
the grand movement. The merchants
will soon be in a position to accord
their customers a means of holding
their cotton, and. the heavens are al?
ready reflecting . the bright dawn of
the eventful day when the price of
cotton will be regulated by the Seltn?
em farmers and merchants.
THOS. E. MOSS DEAD.
Washington, D. C. October 16.
News has been received from the
Philippines of the death of-Thos. E.
Moss at Manila. He was a vetertan
of the Civil War, and-at one time at?
torney general of Kentucky. He died
playing chess with his son-in-law,
Captain Wheat, who is chief of the
telegraph division of the Philippine
constabulatory.
Gen. Moss was born in Greensboro,
X. C., in 1S39. His wife was Miss
Margaret Bright, a daughter of Jesse
Bright an anti-bellum senator from
Indiana.