The watchman and southron. (Sumter, S.C.) 1881-1930, June 21, 1905, Image 1
ir
FBS s?aiTfcK WATCHMAN. Rstah?iBhed April, i860. *Be Just ana Fear uor--Let all tte Ena? thou Aims - at - hy Country s ihv .'.rod -. and Truth's THE TRUS SODTHRON, Established june, I SQ
Cosolidated Aug. 2,1881. . . SUMTER. 8. C . WEDNESDAY. JUNE 21. 1906. New Series-Vol. XXIV. So.48
-BY
- OSTEEN PUBLISHING COMPANY
SUMTER, S. C.
TSRHS :
$1 50 per auoam-in advance.
?9V1ST1BKK1I!:
O ie Square first insertion....*..$1 CO
Erery subseqnent insertion........ ?.. 50
Contracts for three months, or longer will
b : made at redacedrates.
All communications which subserve private
interest? wii? oe ebarged for as ad versements.
Obituaries and tributes of respects will be
3har?ed for.
HI6HES eOTTOiTPHISES LIKELY.
---~
% C. COWAN MAKES EXHAUS?
TIVE ANALYSIS OF THE MAR?
KET SITUATION.
He Estimates That, Considering Un?
precedented Demand and Present
Crop Condition, the Chance for
a Famine in the Staple Are
Great.
C. C. Cowan, whose opinions on the
market are always of the greatest in?
terest to the trade, will today send out
a letter that suggests some new ideas,
perhaps, and is a very interesting ex?
pression of opinion, to say the least.
Following is^the letter in full:
Now that the authorities have giv?
en us the acreage and condition of the
new crop, and the season ip sufficient?
ly advanced to give us some clue to
the general prospects, and crop esti
m&es by premature grassers rango
from 30,000,000 to 12.003,000 bales,
let us tolrea look at the situation and
see if we. can divine whar develop
. ments the future may hold in store.
And .n all of our reasoning and cal?
culating we must bear ia mind that
thc rf suits produced by stitist'.cs are
dependent almost entirely upon thc
existing conditions in trade and the
existing prices; that a crop of 13,500,
000 is worth higher prices to a trade
condition requiring 13,500,u00 than a
crop of 10,000,000 is worth to a trade
condition not requiring 10,000,000;
that a surplus of 2,000,000 is less of a
weight on a prosperous market than
a surplus of 500,000 is on a market
suffering from poor trade; that when
cotton is depressed balow its legiti
. mate value it can advance in the face
of bearish statistics, and that when it
is boosted above its legitimate value
it can decline in the face ot bullish
? statistics.
We recall how in the fall of 1899
cotton advanced considerably from
the previous low point notwithstand?
ing the excessive stocks of cotton and
goods which accumulate in conse?
quence of the two bumper crops of
over 11,000,000 each, because cotton
had been depressed below its value j
and trade was on the mend. We saw
cotton decline from previous high lev?
els in the falls of 1903 and 1904 with
famine supplies of cotton and goods,
partly because cotton had been forced
. above its legitimate value, but mainly
because trade was exceptionally poor.
J?ow then, the census report tells
us that there have been 13,600,000
bales ginned in the South this season.
Whereas some of that was marketed
in August last, we will assume that an
equal amount of the new crop will
come in sight this August, and we will
deal with a yield for the fiscal year of (
13,600,000 bales, less 100,000 bales j
which will be lost to the trade on ac?
count of country damage, etc. Add?
ing the visible supply on Sept. 1, last,
of 470,000 bales, we will assume that
the total supply for the season is in
round figures 14,000,000 bales. Of
the 13,500,000 of this crop available
we have marketed 12,420,000 bales,
leaving apparently in the planters'
hands 1,080.000 bales, added to the
present visible supply of American of
2,440,000 bales, leaves us 3,520,000
bales to draw from for the remaining
12 weeks of this season.
Formerly, it was an element of
weakness for a part of the surplus to
be carried over by the planters. But
since the South has shown its finan?
cial ability to carry 5,000.000 or 6,000
000 bales of cotton without any signs
of distress, it does not matter much
in what proportion the surplus at the
end of this season may be held by the
planters, the spinners, or In the visi?
ble supply. The merits of the situa?
tion will be about the same. But,
without attempting to approximately
predict in what proportion the surplus
will be divided between the three, let
us assume a division which would
seem a natural result. If the move?
ment averages 72,000 baies per week
for the balance of the sfa*?on the
planters will be rid of all of their cot?
ton excepting 220,000 bales. This
much is usually carried over by them
i.: norma! ?ea?ens. ?uder nr-rma
conditions tne s>pimiers of the \vorl<
? cairy over stocks equal to f:om on
to two months' consumption, the av
I erage being about six weeks' supplies
At the ends of the past two famin
? years they held only two to thre*
j weeks' supplies, I place the con
sujiption of American cotton thi
season at 12.000,000, although som<
authorities place it at 12,250,000. Th<
spinners have secured 10,500,00(
bales plus their stock on Sept. 1 last
estimated at 550,000 bales, or 11,050,
000 bales total. If their takings av?
erage 183,000 bales weekly from no^
on* or 2,200,000 bales, their total sup?
ply will be 13,250,000 bales, whict
would leave mill stocks sufficient foi
only five weeks' consumption, a sup?
ply below the average, and danger?
ously limited with the mills so enor?
mously committed ahead. This woulc"
leave a visible supply of Americar
cotton of 1,100,000 bales, which was
considered a moderate visible ir
former seasons when it used to range
?from 1,000,000 to 1,500,000 bales anc
; cotton ranged in price from 8 tc
10 1-2 cents per pound. My guess or
the distribution of the surplus Sept. 1
next visible and invisible, woulc
therefore be about as follows:
Held by planters, 220,000 bales
normal.
Spinners' stocks, 1,250,000 bales
small. /
Visible American, 1,100,000 bales
moderate.
Mind you, we must get away from
freak and famine conditions and com?
pare with normal conditions. With
the above estimate verified and trade
only normally good, cotton should
?range between 8 and 10 cents as the
crop news comes good or bad. We are
figuring on good times now, not hard
times.
Xow, let us consider the possibili?
ties and probabilities and endeavor to
reach a reasonable conclusion as to
the chances at present for a supply
of the raw material the coming seas?
on. But first, let us assume various
yields for the coming crop and arbi?
trarily distribute the surplus which
would remain from each on Sept. 1,
1906.. assuming next year's consump?
tion to be 12,000,000 bales. It is ob?
vious that if the next crop is 12,000.
000 the statistics on Sept. 1, 1906 will
be the same as those on Sept. 1, 1905,
or about as follows: Held by plant?
ers-220,000 bales-normal; spinners'
stocks, 1,250,000 bales-small; visi?
ble American, 1,100,000 bales-mod?
erate. With a crop of 11,500,000
bales we would have about as fol?
lows: Spinners' stocks, 1,250,000
bales-small; held by planters, 120,
000-small; visible supply, 700,000
very small. With a crop of 11,000,000
we would have: Spinners' stocks,
I, 000,000-very small; held by plant?
ers, nothing-famine; visible supply,
570,000 bales-famine. It is useless
to proceed further down the scale, for
any yield under 11,000,000 bales
would intensify the famine conditions
resulting from a crop of not over 11,
000,000 bales.
Xow then, how large a yield seems
possible for the growing crop? De?
duct 11.4 per cent from the acreage;
assume that there is no reduction pei
acre in fertilizers; asume that the
present season will prove as perfect
as the last; assume that the boll wee?
vil over an increased area will destroy
no more late planted cotton this sea?
son than early planted cotton last sea?
son, assume a late open fall, and the
yield could be 12,000,000 maximum.
How large a yield seems possible
for the growing crop? Deduct from
the present crop of 13,000,000 e bales,
II. 4 per cent acreage; assume that
the season will continue only 5.8
points lower in condition than last
year, remembering that the conditions
shown in August, September and Oc?
tober last year were respectively the
next to the highest on record; a con?
dition of 77.2 per cent being 7 per
cent lower than one of 83, deduct 7
per cent also, making a deduction of
18.4 per cent from 13,600,000 bales,
and we have 11,000,000. Then as?
sume that the boll weevils and frost
will, between them, destroy 200,000
bales more this year than last, and we
would have a crop of 10,SOO,000
bales.
Hon- small a yield seems possible
for the growing crop? We have,
roughly speaking, 3 per cent less acre?
age and 3 per cent better conditions
than in 1903 when the crop was 10,
000,000 bales. If conditions continue
not over 3 per cent above that season
and we have an early general frost on
an abnormally late crop, which would
destroy at least 500,000 bales, we can
have as small a crop as 9,500,000
bales.
If we have a good average yield per
acre, or 197 pounds of lint cotton per
acre, which is the average for ll
years, including the four bumper
??MI-WCHIIMHIH J. -i r. - i.
crops, the yield will be 11,000/
bales. If we have less than a gr
average yield per acre we shall havi
still greater cotton famine.
I assume the acreage to be 2S.11
000 as estimated by the correspor
ents of the Agricultural Departme
1 ignore Hyde's afterthought that t
acreage only meant acreage actua
' planted. If they plant on to June :
?the acreage will be as large as li
year; and if they plant on to July
it will be still larger. But they a
not going to plant on, and the cott
would make nothing if they did. T
planting was stopped in order to t
to save the planted areas from t
grass. However, any little plantii
done after May 25 is more than offs
by abandonment of acreage. I ha
just returned from a trip through
part of the eastern belt where th
claim that the crop conditions are tl
best in the South. All the cotton
saw that was cultivated to go?
stands was no further advanced thi
it should have been on May 10. The
was as much of it grassy, or not u
or badly beaten by rains and needii
cultivation. I get worse reports fro
the middle and western districts, tl
worst of all coming from Texas. I
reference to weather 'reports it will 1
seen that during the last crop the
were complaints of low temperatur
and dry weather about the time tl
crop was being cultivated, and th
gave them clean fields and plants wi'
good tap roots. This crop has be?
soaked with rain during its simili
stage of development, and with i
surface roots, must have weath
made to order to avoid failure, as
can withstand neither continuous ra
nor dry weather. The boll weevi
now cover 35 per cent of the tot
cotton area. In consideration of a
this I cannot feel sanguine of am
thing more than a good average yie]
per acre, no matter if conditions c
improve, which would mean a crop <
11,000,000 bales.
In the New York Commercial <
Npril 27 last I called the attention <
the trade to the enormous short ir
terest existing in spot cotton in th
form of goods sold ahead. Before 1
o'clock that day Theodore H. Prie
being a bull that day, had appropriai
ed my argument and was distributin
it here and sending it over the wire
over his own signature. Howeve
that does not detract in the least froi
the force of the argument.
The situation presented to us by th
spinnersof the world is something en
tirely new to the cotton trade an
gives us problems to solve, facts t
consider ?'-nd risks to guard again?
ture. Xever in the history of the cot
ton trade has there been such pros
perity and such demand for goods. I:
former seasons we have known th
mills of some countries to be sol
ahead for six months while those ii
some other country would not be do
ing so well. But here we have then
allsold ahead to an average date o
12 months, and at such an enormou
rate of consumption that it require
1,0'?0.000 bales a month to keep then
running. And the sales have beei
made at most profitable figures, mucl
above the present price of cotton
Still there is no let up to the demanc
for goods, and they are steadily ad
vancing and the mills are still sell?
ing ahead.
I estimate that since the beginning
of this season the spinners have sole
goods requiring 20,000,000 bales ol
cotton, and they cannot stop selling
altogether. So far they have had ir
old stocks and takings about 11,000,
000 bales and are short about 9,000,
000 bales, and are still selling at high?
er prices. A part of this short inter?
est is carried by cotton dealers whe
have sold ahead to the mills, and a
part of it is carried by the speculators
\vho have sold the future hedges that
have been bought by the spot deal?
ers and spinners, but the short in?
terest is th er just the same.
A consumption of 1,000,000 bales a
month and a short interest in spot
cotton of 9,000,000 bales! Who in the
cotton trade has ever heard of such
things as these? Who has ever had
any experience that would be of value
in dealing with such stupendous sit?
uations? WThat gyrations we may
have, and who would know what to
do under critical or unexpected de?
velopments? Speculations carried
up to Sc a pound last season, but
trade was poor and the mills were
not committed ahead to any great ex?
tent. Where would it ever stop this
year if this monstrous short interest
in spots should become alarmed? And
what would happen to the large short
interest in futures? There would be
fluctuations and dangers that would
try men's souls and finances as
they have never been tried before in
the cotton trade. On the advance we
would hear of no mills shutting down,
unless they should have to default
their contract.-. We would hear of no
cotton being shipped back here from
eastern mills and Liverpool for de?
livery. We v.-ouia hear nothing of the
demand f >r spots being: checked by
the advance in the market. We had
all of these to contend with in the big
bull movement of the last two sea?
sons. Xo, nothing of the kind this
time, for the spinners have got to
have an average of 1,000,000 bales a
month of American cotton coming to
them for the next 12 months, for they
have sold the goods. And if they can?
not get the cotton that fast they are
going to buy the futurs for protec?
tion.
I warn you that cotton values are
resting upon a magazine like gun?
powder. If all things come phenom?
enally favorable for the growing crop
we may range around these prices for
some time. With a crop of 12,000,000
next season cotton might sell tempo?
rarily as low as 7 1-2 cents some time
next fall. But with a crop of much
less than 11,000,000 some one wiser
than I would have to guess how high
it would go and how fast. Should a
crop disaster set fire to this magazine
cotton could advance to 20c as easily
as it could to 10c."-New York Com?
mercial.
WATSO N-IvEXD A LL AFFAIR
Dr. Kendal] and Dr. Watson's Broth
cr Make Statements.
The difficulty of Thursday night in
Columbia between Dr. F. D. Kendall
and Dr. J. J. Watson was discussed
fully on- the streets yesterday as Dr.
Watson is well known in this city.
The Item publishes below a statement
from Dr. Watson's brother, and also
one from Dr. Kendall:
Dr. Kendall's Statement.
"After the collision he was tele?
phoned for and went to the scene of
the wreck and gave medical attention
to the wounded. C. D. Nelson was
the most seriously injured. Dr. Ken?
dall had him taken to the home of
Mr. Thomas Agnew, at 1317 Plain
street, where he frequently has pa?
tients taken care of while giving them
attention.
'.Shortly after midnight he was sit?
ting in his office, which is next door
to Mr. Agnew's, talking to Messrs. P.
I. Welles and Wardlaw Moorman. Dr.
Watson knocked at the door. When
he came in he stated that Mr. Nelson
had boarded several years with his
mother and he wished to remove Mr.
Nelson to her home.
"Dr. Kendall invited Dr. Watson to
sit down until he finished with the
gentlemen who were in his office.
Then he went with Dr. Watson to Mr.
Agnew's, saying that he had no ob?
jection to the removal of Mr. Nelson
f Dr. Watson thought he was in con?
dition to be removed.
"Dr. Watson decided that it would
be safe to remove Mr. Nelson and said
he would send McCormick's ambu?
lance for him.
"Dr. Kendall replied that he would
wait up until the ambulance came
and see that Mr. Nelson was gotten
out of the house all right.
"Dr. Kendall returned to his office
and was writing at his desk, with his
door open.
"When the ambulance came up the
people with it made so great a noise
that Dr. Kendall, not knowing to
whom his protest was addressed, told
them to make less noise, as there
were other sick people at Mr. Ag?
new's.
"Dr. Watson, who, with his
brothers, Stanmore and Ashie, was
with the ambulance, evidently took
the protest as a personal affront, for
when Dr. Kendall came up he struck
at his face. Dr. Kendall catching the
main force of the blow upon the back
of his hand, which he threw up to
protect himself. One of Dr. Watson's
brothers sprang between them and
the fight was stopped.
Dr. Kendall then told Dr. Watson
to get his patient out and never speak
to him again.
"Immediately Dr. Watson applied
a vile epithet to Dr. Kendall and
sprang forward and struck him and
continued fighting him. Dr. Kendall
had a pen-knife in his hand, and.
while warding off Dr. Watson's blows,
struck him twice with the knife. At
the second blow the blade parted
from the handle.
"While Dr. Watson was attacking
Dr. Kendall, one of his brothers had
hold of Dr. Kendall's right arm, his
knife being in his right hand. It is
not known whether he was attempt?
ing to hold Dr. Kendall while he was
being assaulted or trying to separate
the two doctors.
"Dr. Kendall returned to his office
and Dr. Watson walked to Dr. Knowl
ton's office, at the next corner, and
Dr. Knowlton dressed his wounds, af
ter whichTie was removed to his
h o mt- on E landing street.
"The throe Watson brothers being
together and one of them having :
twice commence ! an assault on him, ?
Dr. Kendall thought best, after his
knife broke, to secure his pistol. He
went to his office for it. but Mr. Ag?
new closely followed him and advised
and urged him to stay in his office,
which he did."
Mr. Watson's Statement.
Dr. Watson's brother, Mr. Ashie
Watson was asked for a statement.
He said:
"At ll o'clock I received a phone
message from the train dispatcher's
office at the union station, where I
am employed as a train dispatcher,
telling me of the collision and that
Mr. Nelson, who has been an intimate
friend of mine for several years, was
seriously injured. I went immediate?
ly to the scene of the wreck and was
informed by bystanders that Nelson
had been taken to the Columbia hos .
pital. I went to the hospital and
found that he had been taken to Dr.
Kendall's office. I went immediately
to the doctor's office but he was not
in and I learned that he was over at
Dr. Oliveros', and I was on my way
over there when I met Dr. Kendall
and asked him if Nelson was serious?
ly injured. His reply was that he so
considered him. I asked for permis?
sion to see Nelson, but was refused.
Dr. Kendall told me I could come
back the following morning. I then
asked if he was in an unconscious
condition and the reply was that he
was unconscious.
"I then went to the office of my
brother. Dr. J. J. Watson, to see if
there was not something we could do
to see him and have him removed to
the Columbia hospital where he could
receive medical attention. He ad?
vised me to take the matter up with
Superintendent Williams of the Sa?
vannah division, and .obtain his per?
mission to see Mr. Nelson. I cid so.
but Mr. Williams was not in a posi?
tion to grant my request, as it was a
matter entiirely with the street rail?
way company. I then called up Mr.
Nelson's brother at Rock Hill <y T
the long distance and obtained hi>
permission to move Charlie at once,
but in the meantime Dr. Watson tel?
ephoned for and received permission
from Mr. Williams to see Nelson. He
went to Dr. Kendall's office and was
permitted by him to examine Mr. Nel?
son. He found him in a conscious
condition and was highly pleased
when he saw him. Dr. Kend?.ll then
gave his consent for Mr. Nelson to be
removed and my brothers. Dr. Wat?
son and Stanmore Watson, and I went
to McCormick's for the ambulance.
"We returned to Mr. Agnew's resi?
dence, which is next door to Dr. Ken?
dall's office, and as we started to enter
the gate we heard Dr. Kendall shout.
'Stop there, stop there." We immed?
iately obeyed his command and he
turned, stepped in his office, picked
up his hat and something else off the
table, I don't know what, and came
toward us remarking. 'Why don't you
stop?' Dr. Watson replied that he
had stopped. Dr. Kendall said, 'You
did no such thing, sir,' in a very
abrupt manner. Dr. Kendall was ad?
vancing during this time and- Dr. Wat?
son dropped the end of the litter he
was carrying and went to meet him/
They began to fight. I rushed be?
tween them and managed to separate
them. Dr. Kendall stepped off two or
three steps and threw his hand into
his hip pocket and then shifted it to
his side pants pocket. I asked him
what he was doing and he replied:
'Getting my knife, getting my knife.*
Dr. Watson, by this time, had re?
turned to the litter, remarking, 'Oh
well, it's all right.' .1 paid no further
attention to Dr. Kendall and ills knife
believing that the little difficulty had
ended. Just at this time Dr. Kendall
made a second advance, at the same
time speaking in a dictatorial man?
ner. I met him and begged him not
to talk that way and requested him
to go back to his office, as we could
get the young man out all right. He
paid no attention to me and proceed?
ed to within a step of Dr. Watson and
shaking his finger in the doctor's face
said: T have always treated you as a
gentleman, but don't you ever speak
to me again.' Dr. Watson, replying
with an epithet, said in a law voice.
T have never spoken to you,' and they
clinched. Dr. Kendall stabbing him
once high up under the right arm
with his left hand and once in the left
side with his right hand. I did not
have hold of Dr. Kendall at this time
at all and as soon as he made the
stabs he turned and ran toward Main
street, past his office and jumped over
his fence into his front yrd. Every?
thing up to this time had taken place
on the pavement in front of Mr. Ag?
new's residence. We then hurried to
Dr. Knowlton's office to ascertain the
POWDER
Absolutely Pure
HAS tm SUBSTITUTE
extent of his wounds. My brother?
Stanmore, and I left, our brother ir*
charge of Dr. Knowlton and returned;
to the litter which had not been moved,
from the street. We had a police ofv
fleer and Mr. McCormick assist us in
getting Mr. Nelson out and placing;
him in the ambulance and I took him.
home.
"I wish to state that there was ab-?
solutely no noise made by us up ta
the time of the difficulty and we were?
cautioned by Dr. Watson before ar-s
riving at the house to be very careful
and make as little noise as possible.'*
A ROYAL MARRIAGE,
Princess Margaret of Connaught Weds
Heir to Swedish Throne.
Windsor, June 15.-Princess Mar-?
garet of Connaught, granddaughter*
of Queen Victoria, was married today
to Prince Gustavus Adolphus of Swe?
den, son of the Swedish Crow?r Prince,
The ceremony was performed in St,
George's chapel on the grounds of
Windsor Castle, the Archbishop of
Canterbury officiating. The brief cer?
emony of the Church of England waa
used. The request of the bride andi
groom that the wedding be as quir: aa
possible was carried out. King Ed?
ward. Queen Alexandria, and th?
Crown Prince of Sweden attended the?
wedding, with thc members of tho,
diplomatic corps.
WHY TOGO WON.
Rojestvensky's Ships Were Fillet^
With Mutinous Sailors.
St. Petersburg, June 15.-The cor?
respondent of the Publishers' Presa
has learned from an authoritative;
source that the official report made
on Admiral Rojestvensky's recent
overwhelming defeat, which has been
kept from the public, says the sailora
on his vessels were in a discontented,
mood throughout the voyage to "ha
far east. Several times there were?
outbreaks among the sailors who re?
belled against the poor food served,
them. Every prison on the shipa
was filled with mutinous sailors who
were released Just before the battle
began.
ARMISTICE ARRANGED.
Russian Paper Reports That Hostiii?
ties in Manchuria Will Cease.
St. Petersburg. June 17.-The NVOQ
Yremya has information from what
it considers an authoritative source
that an armistice has been arranged.
JAPS SUFFER SLIGHT DEFEAT.
Two Positions Lost By Russians Fri?
day Reoautpured.
London. June 19-A dispatch to
the Reuter Telegram Company, fron;
St. Petersburg, says news reached
there from Godsiafan, Manchuria,
saying Russians have recaptured;
L.'*o Yang Wo Pen and Sumiencheng,
fror* which they were driven on Fri?
day by the Japanese troops. Dispatch?
es last night gav* official report from
Oyama in which he recounted the
taking of these positions, which was
defended mainly by a force of over
5.000 cavalry and twenty guns com?
manded by General Mistchenko.
MERCHANTS BANISHED.
American and European Firms Or?
demi to Leave Port Arthur by
Japanese
Chefoo, Jane 19.-European and
American firms, with established busi?
ness houses in Port Arthur, which was
captured by the Japanese after a ?on?
and notable sfege- have been notified
by the Japanese that they must leave
the town and remove their merchan?
dise.