The watchman and southron. (Sumter, S.C.) 1881-1930, July 26, 1899, Image 1
1
m an
Sn 8UMTJE& WATCHMAN. Kstabllahed April, IS50.
"Be Just and Fear not-Let all the Ends thou A ms't at, be thy Country's, thy God's andlTrnth's.
THE TRUIE SOUTHRON, Eatablished Jane, 1366
Consolidated Aug. 2,1381.
SUMTER S. C., WEDNESDAY. JULY 26.1899
New Series-Vol. XTIII. No. 52
?k Wi mK at Soutirant
Squished Srary Wednesday,
N. O. Osteeiij
SUMTER, S. C.
TERMS :
{1.50 per annum-io advance.
ADTIXTISIM1I?:
One Square first insertion...................Sil 00
Every subsequent insertion ..... .. 50
Contracts for three months, or longer wil
be made at redaced rates
All communications which sabserve private
interests will-fee charged for as ad versements.
Obituaries and tributes of respects will be
charged for.
Swearing to Falsehoods.
The . Administration Ignores
Protests of Philippine
Correspondents
HOBE CENSOR MADE NEWS
OF CONDITIONS IN LUZON.
Washington, July 18-At the
cabinet meeting today the "round
robin" sent by the American news
paper correspondents from Manila via"
Hoog Kong yesterday was discussed,
and it was decided to allow the matter
to drop. Officially the matter will be
ignored, and Geo. Otis will be allowed
to treat it as be may deem best.
A cable from Co!. Denby, a member
of the Philippine commission, was
read. It showed s fairly t-a tis fa cte ry
state of affairs, one of the cabinet
officers said, bat it did not say that
peace negotiation with Aguinaldo were
io progress.
Secretary Hay also had a cable from
Ambassador Cb cate relative to the
boundary Hoe negotiation., bot it was
not encouraging.
AT THE WAE DEPARTMENT.
Washington, sly 18.-It was stated
nt tho war department that no attention
whatever would be paid to the "round
robin" of the Manila correspondents.
The protest was not sent to Ger. Otis,
and it is said it will not be, and Geo.
Ods will not be called apeo -for an
esp a nation. Io addition to this it was
intimated that very encouraging oews
had been received from the Philippines
and that the situation was much better
than had been generally believed.
SERENE AS A MAY DAY.
Washington, Jaly 18.-Tha follow
lng statement was given out tbis
afternoon at the state department :
"The state department yesterday
received from the Philippine commis
sion an important dispatch conveying
these facts :
"By the co-operation of the military
and the commission, municipal govern
ments have been established ia seven
important towns ia the provinces o
Manila and Cavit . These are working
admirably, and coe good effeot of them
is tbfit considerable cumbers of the
insurgents ore constantly deserting and
coming io, some of them with arms
The system will soon be extended to
other towns which are asking for it.
Continued success in this direction iii
mean tthe beginning of the end. The
commissioners state that the general
situation is as described io the message
of Gen. Otis of the 26.h of Jane,
cseept that a number of ports in the
southern part of Luzon, io Leyte an
other islands to the south have since
then been opened to trade. Dispatches
from Dr. Schorman on his return from
his trip through the southern part of
the archipeltgo were of the same
purport. A disposition to accept
American sovereignty and to welcome
oar troops was everywhere manifested.
"The report of Gea. Otis, of the
26th of Jane, referred to by Commis
sioner Denby io the above dispatch,
stated that as a coosc^seoco of the rainy
season little island campaigoiog was
now possible in Lozoo. We ocoupy,
said Geo. Otis, a large portion of the
Tagalo country. The lines stretch from
Imus oa the sooth to Ssa Fernando on
the north, oearly 60 miles, and east
ward into the Laguna prorinee. The
insurgent armies have suffered great
losses and are scattered. The only
large force which bolds together is
about 4,000 io Tarlac province and
northern Pamgaoga. There are scat
tered forces ia bands cf 50 and 00 io
other portions of Lozoo. Io Cavite
and Batangas provinces they oould
possibly assemble as many as 2,000.
They are demoralized from recent de
feat. The most of the people are ter
rorized by the insurgent soldiers aod
desire peaoe and American protection.
They no looger flee frost our troops
unless forced by insurgents, but gladly
welcome them. -There bas been no
recent burning of towns. The popula
tion within our lines bas become dense,
taking op land cultivation extensively.
They are kept out of Manila as much
ts possible, as the city population was
becoming too great to be cared for. The
only hope of tba insurgent leaders is in
id fros the United States. They pro
olaio the near overthrow of the present
administration, to be followed by their
iod3peodense aod recognition by the
United States Tais is the influence
whieb enables them to hold oat. Mach
contention prevails among them and no
civil govornment remains. The trade
with ports not in oar possession, the
former source of icsargent revenues, is
now interdicted. Gen. Ods doubted
the wisdom of this policy, BS people io
those ports are without supplies or food
and the merchants sufferiog great los ss.
He meditated at that time the restora
tion of trade privileges although the
insurgents might reap some benefit from
it, a plan which has since been partially
carried into effect. The courts are in
successful operation under the direction
of able Filipinos. Affairs in the other
islands are comparatively quiet, await
ing results in Luzon. Ali are acxioas
for trade, and repeated calls for Ameri
can troops are received. He is giving
his attention to the Jolo archipelago
and the Parlawan islands.
**Gen. O 3 speaks cf the general
desire of the volunteers to reenlist. Re
has provided for the enlistment of the
two regiments which have been author
ized and has esr ed permission to organ
iza a third regiment."
OTIS, THE OPTIMIST.
The publication of the correspond
ents' protest against the severity of
the censorship at Manila . has placed
another problen before the president
and the solution is now being vari
ously guessed at The correspond
ents only intimated ; others are giving
particulars
Gen. Otis, it is established, bas
doctored the press dispatches to suit
himself. That is bari enough and
without the shadow of justification
A Washington dispach to the Kew
York Tribune, the administration's
staunch friend, discloses that Gen.
Otis'has been exceedingly chary in
giving official information of affairs.
His *'consecutive reports were seen
to be non corroborative." His cable
dispatches were few and brief and
"the press reports practically ceased
after the early part of June," the
censor having assumed greater pow
ers. The Tribune's correspondent
goes on to say :
The anxiety was increased by the
apparent reluctance of Gen Otis to
give desired information, his grudg
ing replies to queries about the men
he would need in the faiy and his
stubborn reiteration that 30,000 men
would be enough for all purposes
Although that was his statement
six. months agc and since that time
little or nothing^ has been gained,
Otis stuck to his original estimate.
The Tribune's dispatch continues :
For four months official telegrams
had come from Gen. Otis clinging to
his belief that the rebellion was over
and only now, when events have
justified none of the series of rosy
predictions, it is beginning to be
openly admitted that Gen. Otis has
noi; known what was going on in the
country under his control and that he
bas failed to form any adequate idea
of the Filipino character
Further, it is stated that "Gen.
Otis has permitted four months to
pass without sending a single mail
report to the war department, pre
ferring to confine himself to brief
and generally indefinite cable dis
patches " Evidently the source from
which the president has been receiv
ing these "ultra-optimistic views"
which "have not been borne out by
subsequent events" is no less a
person than Otis. If in no other
way, Otis will attain fame as an op
timist
While the Tribune gives the
Washington view of 0:is, the Boston
Globe publishes o dispatch cabled
from London by James Creelman, the
celebrated war correspondent. Creel
man describes Otis very particularly,
having spent several months in the
Philippines He starts off with this
declaration :
i have been in the Cuban campaign
as weil as in the Philippine, arid I
can say honestly, without the slight
est prejudice, that Gen. Otis is much
more responsible fo* the disastrous,
humiliating condition of affairs in the
east than Gen. Shafter was for the
calamities in Cuba, for the war de
partment furnished Gen. Otis with a
perfectly equipped, well fed army,
and he had months of dry weather in
which to fight against an imperfectly
organized enemy.
Creelman says of Otis in his capac
ity of censor :
While the army in the field was
anxiously awaitii g orders during the
advance on Maiolos, he spent a whole
boor reading iny dispatch, etriking
out names of officers mentioned for
gallantry, chan cing descriptive pass
ages, erasing all mention ot the pari;
played by the navy, and even occu
pying five minutes in -.electing si
single word. This is the same expe
rience which other correspondents
have had during the war. Gen. Otis
bas wasted hours of valuable time
during the most critical days in
revising press dispatches, coloring
them to suit his own views On the
night of tbs cburge at Taliban ri ver
I went to Gen Ods7 palace, having
ridden in from the battlefield. The
general insisted on changing the
dispatch I submitted to him, and
actually struck cut the name of Col.
Funston, whose regiment swam the
river under fire that day, saying : "I
propose to make all the heroes that
are made io this war." Col. Thomp
son, the press censor, bas refused to
allow me to mention regiments dis
tinguishing themselves in battle,
saying he was ordered to do so by
Gen. Otis.
During Gen Wheaton's advance
to Parig and beyond with the flying
brigade Otis ordered all press dis*
patches stopped unless they described
the enemy fighting furiously and said
enormous losses were inflicted by our
troops. As a matter of fact, on this
occasion the insurgents were con
temptible in numbers and ran away
except in cases of one or two small
bands, and their losses were very
slight. Gen. Otis7 conditions for
press dispatches were so outrageous
ly dishonest that I refused lo send
any dispatches rather than to tele
graph official lies.
Corroborative testimony of wit
nesses who have had no opportunity
to agree upon a story is very valua
ble and the similarity between Creel
man's account and the eleven's state
ment adds weight to the words of
each and the two reports correspond
so fully as to establish the truth of
both -The State.
THE MEN WHO KNOW.
There has been a rather general
belief among the opponents of im
perialism that when the volunteer
troops should return from Manila
they would, so to speak, take the
lid off the Philippine situation.
This conviction is now justified by
facts
A San Francisco dispatch to the
New York World begins with the
following summary statement :
Volunteers of Oregon and Califor
nia who have just returned here from
Manila on tbe transports Newport
and Ohio were polled last week by
The World regarding their opinion
of the Philippines, the Filipinos and
the war. The twelve hundred men
were practically unanimous in saying
that.
The expansion policy is proving a
costly failure It will take years,
perhaps generations, to conquer the
natives
The Filipinos, if eventually subju
gated, will never make even moder
ately good citizens, and will be a
source of constant trouble and ex
pense, necessitating an immense
j standing army, with large garrisons
j on each of the more important islands
to keep them io subjection.
The World sent stenographers on
board the transports on their arrival
Wednesday to take the answers of
the returning soldiers to these ques
lions :
1. Do you think Philippines worth
fighting for ?
2. How long do you think it would
take to conquer the rebels ?
3. Would you live there if you
could 1
4. What do you think of the
natives ?
On the first question the sentiment
of the men was overwhelmingly in
the negative
The First Oregon is a body of
picked men above the average in
intelligence It was the opinion of
four-fifths of them that Uncle Sam
made a grave mistake when he set
about to annex the eastern archi
pelago.
The veterans varied in their views
as to the length of time that would
be required to conquer the Filipinos.
Of the field officers and men 7 per
cent were of the opinion that subju
gation could be effected within one
year if the campaign were in the
hands of competent men ; 62 per
cent placed the maximum limit at
fiv.e years, 15 per cent, at ten years,
and of the rest some believed that it
would mean an intermittent warfare
for generations, and others that the
islands and tribes could never be
entirely pacified
The volunteers were practically
uuauimous in saying that the Filipi
nos would never make good citizens,
that the benefits of civilization would
be wasted upon them, and that the
Americanization of the isiands would
necessitate the extermination of the
Malayas the American Indian was
exterminated
Few of the soldiers would care to
return to the Philippines to live.
The majority declared that a white
man could never become acclimated
there, and of the handful who ex
pressed a desire to go back nearly all
admitted that they were actuated by
the beiief that fortunes might b? made
during the boom following American
supremacy.
Not one man could be found on the
transports who cared to reenlist.
The men are very bitter in their
comments regarding the conduct of
the campaign around Manila. As
they had not beea mustered out, most
of them were guarded in their criti
cisms, bat their "Wait until we are
mustered out !" had a significant
ring. However, there were many
bolder ones who spoke out frankly,
and what they said had the unani
mous saction of their comrades.
The Oregonians declare that Maj.
Gen Otis is a failure and that the
campaign will be futile so long as the
government delays sending out a
competent general They expressed
the belief that the war was being
permitted to drag along in order that
a clique of high officers might win
rapid promotion, and asserted that
the situation around Manila was
worse for the Americans when they
left than it was on the day of the first
insurgent attack upon our lines.
The World's dispatches goes on
to give brief statements from scores
of the soldiers bearing out the fore
going summary. The names of the
.men are given and their companies
designated. The most noticeable
thing about the interviews is that
althoHgh most of the men hold a
very bad epinion of the Filipinos'
character they do not at all underrate
their capacity for resistance and have
no illusions of early conquest. As
The World shows, nine tenths of the
men believe it will take five years or
more to subdue the insurgents, and
a good many thiuk that if Otis is
continued m command they will
never be subjugated. The general
commanding clearly does not have
the confidence of his men, and these
interviews will heighten the belief,
already rapidly growing, that Gen.
Otis is incompetent for the work to
which he has been assigned
The imperialists will of course en
deaver to weaken the effect of this
testimony, but it cannot fail to have
much influence upon public opinion.
These soldiers are not "weak senti
mentalists'7 nor "traitors to the flag."
They cannot be accused of wishing
to destroy American prestige. They
are plain, practical, hard-headed men
from a Pacific State in which" expan
sion is supposed to be overwhelming*
ly in favor. They do not as a role
sympathize with the Tagals-judging
from their expressions they hate them
quite enthusiastically. They have
been on the ground and fought over
it for months ; they have had practi
cal experience of the climate in the
dry season and the rainy season ;
they have dispersed the rebels" to
the admiration of the country ;
and so their testimony is worth mere
than the hopes of ail the imperialist
politicians and the editors who
hold that we have an easy job
io Luzon. These men are not
shirkers-they have done their
duty and more than their duty.
They are not talking for effect, to se
cure their discharges-they are about
to be discharged. Their testimony,
therefore, as to the ineffectiveness of
the brilliant and "successful" opera
tions of the last few months and the
hopelessness of permanent conquest
without years of sacrificial warfare
cannot be sneered away.
Census Supervisors.
The Democratic congressmen from
this State have endeavored to have the
censas officials for this State appointed
from the ranks of the Demooracy. But
the Republicans wanted the plums for
themselves. It bas been reported that
there would be a division of spoils.
The State will be divided into six
districts and eaoh district wiil have a
supervisor. The followiog seems to be
the slate which will go through :
J W Wheeler, Charleston ; S A
Pearce, of Columbia. These two are
Republicans. The Democrats are :
D H Russell, of Anderson ; Capt
George W SbeU, of Laurens ; T J
Cunningham, of Chester, and T J
Breeden, of Bennettsville.
Col. 5. A. Pearce of this city, it is
said, will be in charge of a satrapy.
Col Pearce is well known io business
circles, having been engaged in the
completion of the canal. He is oow
general seoretary of the Merchants'
aod Manufacturers' Club, having been
elected at a recent meeting of the trus
te: . Hs says be has not received his
ccmmission, but is reasonably sure of
bis appointment. He does not know
anything about the number of assist
ants to bc employed and wili not until
he receives instruction. He does not
want to be orowded with letters wi h
applicants for positions, but will in due
time make a selection with reference to
the business capacity of those to be
associated with him in this work The
director general, Mr. Merriam, will
appoint the other officials, but upon the
recommendation of the supervisor -
The State, July 20.
Eleven different fats in emulsions
have been tested to determine
whether they would allay cough ai.d
increase weight. The effects with
cod liver oil proved to be variable
The beet results were given by beef
fat, olive, peanut and cocoanut oil, and
the experimenter has concluded that
a mixture of these four fats, with the
addition of a little clove oil, is much
superior to cod liver c'l.
STANDARD COTTON
TARIFF FIXED.
New Rates Lower Than Geor
gia or North Carolina.
After many months of deliberation,
daring wbicb period tbe railroad
traffic managers and cotton men bave
been given lengthy and complete
hearings, the State railroad commis
sion bas at last adopted a new stan
dard tariff of rates on cotton for the
State of South Carolina. The tariff
as adopted the commission proposes
to let stand and will not make any
changes. Yesterday copies of the
new tariff were forwarded to the
traffic managers Gf all the railroad
lines in Sonh Carolina, and the com
mission does not anticipate that there
will be any complaint from them.
The new tariff is considerably
iower than that recently suggested
by the commission and is lower than
either the present Georgia or North
Carolina rate Indeed the new tariff,
it is said, will likely be lower than
any in the country. The commission
proposes to give the tariff 6heet to
the public on Monday next, and it
will be published Tuesday. It will
become effective 30 days after the
25th inst , thus giving the notice
required by the railroad law of the
State.
The commission in making up the
new tariff has given the most careful
consideration to the arguments pre
sented by the interests and has pre
pared a tariff that is considered "just
and equitable One factor in the
cotton problem in this State now is
the rapidly increasing number of cot
ton mills and the consequent increase
in the number of short hauls.
There has been a demand for some
time for the reduction of the rates on
cotton io South Carolina, and no
doubt many will hail with pleasure
the announcement of the redaction
provided for by the commission.
The State, Joly 22.
Many of the papers continue to
print statements and alleged argu
ments intended to convince the public
of the superiority of the round cotton
bale over the square bale One of
the latest claims is that exporters
will pay about 40 cents per hundred
more for round bales thau for square
bales This, however, does not
count for anything, except as an
offset to the tare cn square ba es.
The Enquirer does not think it has
any prejudice in the matter; but!
under the circumstances it is con j
vinced that the best thing that the
cotton growers of the south can do
is io hold on to the old equare bale
It will be well for them to secure
uniformity of size if possible., and
also to insist on the best wrapping
they can get. Most of the wrapping
is done so carelessly as to be very
expensive to the man who sella the
cotton. Bat the round bale is not
needed, notwithstanding any real or
imaginary advantages The best
patents of machinery for making
round bales belong to capitalists who
have no intention of selling out at
any reasonable price. Their idea is
to substitute the round bale ma
chinery for the square bale presses
on terms that wili insure to them
perpetual control of the round bale
machinery After that there will be
no more competition in cotton and the
trust will fix the price at the gin.
To prevent the growth of a trust is
comparatively easy ; but a healthy
trust once grown can be pulled down
again only with the greatest difficul
ty -Yorkville Enquirer
Marconi has two rivals in his wire
less telegraphy, one io Austria, who
claims to have se Hspatches a dis
tance of 39 mike without the tall
steel towers employed by Marconi,
the other a young Englishman, who
not only dispenses with the towers,
but has improved transmitters and
receivers which focus sad confiue
the message to a space of not more
than an inch wide, thus preventing
messages being caught by others.
He claimed also that he can send
messages a distance of 150 miles.
People interested in coincidences
are noting that Raphael Semmes's
Confederate vessel, the Alabama,
which was sunk by the Kearsage,
was numbered 190 by the English
builders, and that the United States
battle ship Alabama, now being built
at Cratnpu' ship yard, bears the same
builders' number-190.
Is Malt Extract a Beverage?
The Point of Fact Involved
in the Question,
THE OPINION OP THE ATTOR
NEY GENERAL.
Colamb a, July 19.-Nearly every
dreg store in the State keeps for sale
malt tceic, or other malt extracts.
The question has been raised if such
sale is oot io violation of tbe dispensary
law, as malt extract contains a percent
age of alcohol.
The State board of control, as with
all snch knotty problems, left the
responsibility with the attorney gener
al's office, asking the judicial department
of the executive government for aa
opinion on the subject.
Mr. Ganter yesterday replied to the
State board that the question was really
a matter of fact and not of law.
The analysis of the chemist of tbe
South Carolina College sbow3 that these
ma t preparations contain from 2 per
cent, of alcohol by volume to more
than 6 per cent by vol me.
The law prohibits the handling of
liquors "which contaio alcohol and
which are used as beverage," etc.
Under this section the question arises
"Is the malt tonic cr extract used as a
beverage ?" In this eonneotion Mr.
Gunter says :
"If used as a beverage its sale is
prohibited ; but if used strictly as a
medicine its sale is not prohibited.
This is not a qaestisa of law to be
passed upon by this office, but a ques
tion of fact to be left to a jury to
determine. From a review of the
authorities io reference to the sale of
alcoholic liquors I Sod that io effect the
following rules are laid down :
"First. Whatever is generally and
popularly known as intoxicating liquors,
such as brandy, whiskey, beer, etc., is
within the prohibition of sneh a statute
as above quoted and may be so declared
as a matter of law by tbe court.
"Second. That whatever is generally
and popularly known as medicine or as
an article for the teilet and whioh is
recognized and the formula for its prep
aration prescribed io some standard au
thority and is not among liquors ordi
narily used as intoxicating beverages,
such as bay rum, paregoric, cologne and
tinctures generally, is net within such
an act and may be so declared as a
matter of law by tbe court notwithstand
ing tsuch articles contain alcohol.
"Thud. That as to articles interme
diate between the above classes, com
pounds of intoxicating liquors with
other ingredients, whether provided for
a sirgle case or compounded cpDO a for
mula and sold under a speoifio name aa
bitters, tonics, extracts, etc , such as
now under consideration-whether they
ar8 prohibited by this act is a question
for the jury.
"As to this latter class the facts of
eaoh particular case must determine.
The test by which the jury must deter
mine is not the presence of alcohol ; bot
the adaptability of the substance as to
the one use or the other, as a medicine
or as a beverage As bas been judi
cially stated, 'If the compound or
preparation be such that tbe distinctive
character and effect of intoxicating
liquor are gone, that its nee as ao intox
icating beverage is practically impossi
ble by reason of the ingredients, its
sale is not prohibited by this section.
The mere presence of alcohol does net
brioc the article within the eeotion
quoted, for the ioflueo3e of tbe alcohol
may be counteracted by tho ether ele
ments and the compound be strictly and
fairly only a medicine But if the aloo
bel lemaios as a distinctive force ic the
compound and such compound reason
ably liable to be used as an intoxicating
beverage, it matters not tbat it contains
ingredients of a beneficial force in coun
teracting diseases or strengthening the
system, its sale is is prohibitedfl
Tallulah, La , July 21.-Five Ital
ians were lynched here last night for
the fatal wounding of Dr. J. Ford
Hodge. The dead men are of a class
which has been troublesome for
some time, and it is believed that
they had planned to kill the doctor.
Some of them, it is said, have families
in Europe, but they have no relatives
here.
The A. & P. Roberts Company, of
Philadelphia, has received a contract
from the Seaboard Air Line for the
building of two plate girder bridges
one to cross the Congaree River,
near Columbia, and the other to span
the Wateree River, near Camden.
^ ABSOLUTE PURE
Makes the food more delicious and wholesome
OYAL BAKtNO POWOEB CO., HEW YORK. _