The watchman and southron. (Sumter, S.C.) 1881-1930, June 10, 1896, Image 6
Tillman's Bond Deal.
History of a Peculiar South
Carolina Refunding Plan.
From tbe New York Times.
BALTIMORE. June 3 -Senator Till- j
toan, of South Carolina, has been ;
very free with his criticisms jai the i
National Administration for its man- j
uer of conducting bond operations, j
and in the recklessness of his !
rhetorical frenzy has not hesitated tc I
impute improper motives to . the
President and Secretary Carlisle In
view of these facts a little history of
one of his own bond deals is instruc?
tive and interesting.
About $5,250,000 of South Caro-.
Hua 6 percent bonds fell due July '
1, 1893 Tillman was Governor of
the State then, John G?ry Evans,
tbe Senator's closest political and
personal friend, and said to be slated
as his.colleague in the Senate, was
the Administration leader of the
Legislature, and Dr. Bates was State
Treasurer.
The Legislature, at its session in
1801, adopted a refunding bill, sug?
gested by Governor Tillman. This
provided for an issue of ?6,000,000
4 per cent, bonds to fond the out?
standing 6 per cents, and Treasurer
Bates and the Governor were ap?
pointed commissioners to manage the
matter in behalf of the State.
The acts of Messrs. Tillman, Bates
and Evans are outlined in the evi?
dence in a suit developed in this city
for the division of the commissions
involved in the transaction, the
brokers and the syndicate which
took the bonds having quarrelled !
The action was brought here because
the funds involved were held by a
Baltimore trust company.
The evidence shows that one of
the first steps taken by the commis?
sioners was to give a monopoly of
the entire transaction to a Mr.
Rhind, a broker of Augusta, Ga ,
whose name does not even appear jn
the commercial reports. Mr. Rhind
testified that early in 1892 he was j
approached by Mr. Evans, now Gov- !
ernor, and asked to place the South
Carolina 4 per cents He obtained
exclusive option on the entire trans
action from Governor Tillman late in
May, the contract being that he was
to receive a commission of 5 per
cent, on the $6,000,000-a matter of
$300,000.
Mr Rhind failed to make the
trade, however, and in October sur?
rendered his option. Then Governor
Tillman and Treasurer Bates took a
turn at it They visited New York
j and roamed through Wall street. On
returning home they declared that a
4 per cent. South Oaiolina* bond
would not sell even at 95, attributing
the State's poor credit to the course
of Charleston bankers and other
political opponents of the State Ad-1
ministration.
Mr. Rhind again was called in to j
take the job in November, 1892. He j
. managed to interest a New York 4
broker in it, after hiving exhausted !
all his own efforts and influence.
And bete the curious fact may be
noted that Mr. Rhind testified that he
at first did not approach this broker
on the subject, although maki?g
headquarters in his office, regarding j
him^as too small ari operator to nn
? dertake eo big a trade. Yet this
broker is rated high in reports, while
Mr. Rhind, who controlled, the op-1
tion. and was trying to use it, is not ?
rated at all.
With the assistance of the New j
York man a syndicate was formed, j
headed by the ?ate F. O. French, of j
the Manhattan Trust Company, which
agreed to take $5,250,000 of 4 1-2
per cent. South Carolina bonds on a
nominal basis of par fiat. This ar?
rangement fell through when ?ir.
French died.
The New Y^otk broker then enlist?
ed the aid of a Richmond broker,
and the two again went to work, the
Legislature having met.in the mean?
time and started its machinery to
pass a new refunding bli!, which, it
now appears, by the evidence of the
persons interested, was suggested by
the brokers, through Rhind, to Till?
man and Evans. Mr. Evans was not
only the Administration representa?
tive and leader in the Legislature, but
he was at the same time the attorney
of Rhind, having been engaged in
that capacity, according to his own
sworn statement, when Rhind was ap- j
pointed fiscal agent. j
It is, therefore, established by un?
doubted and unchallenged testimony
that Governor Tillman not only let
out the job of selling the bonds of
his own state exclusively to one man ,
mouths before the time of sale, but ?
permitted brokers in Wall street and !
elsewhere to dictate legislation to his
Legislature and allowed a paid attor- j1
ney of the purchasing parties to con- j
struct and steer through the Legisla- !
ture the Act under which the bonds j
were to be issued. j.
The Act provided for ?5,350,000 ! -
4 1-2 per cent bonds, to run twenty j j
and forty years. These bonds were i
to be dated and issued July 1, 1893, ,
but they were to begin to bear inter?
est as from January 1, 1893. In I,
other words, a bonus of six months1 :
Uterest, or 2 1-4 per cent, amounting j i
ito $118,000, was offered to whoever j,
would take the bonds and pay dollar ?
for dollar for them.
The syndicate organized by the ; :
New York and Richmond brokers j i
agreed to take the bonds at par and j (
to accept three-fourths of 1. per c?
of the bonus, amounting to $39,0|
making the net cost of the bonds
its members about 99 1-4. The
maining 1 1-2 per cent, or $73,0(
ostensibly went to Mr. Rhind, t
man who had been chosen by )
Evans, the Administration leader
the Legislature, the man who 1:
em. ^yed Mr. Evans aftd Major W.
Gary, Mr. Evan's uncle, as his alt
neys, and who had the option on I
entire bond issue before it had be
provided for by the Legislature.
It does not appear that Mr. Rni
took any active part in the organi:
tion of the syndicate. It is. in e
dence that he borrowed ?500 fr<
the New York brokef with which
meet his traveling expenses. The
is nothing in the testimony to sht
what services Major Gary who
a citizen of Georgia, performed, t
the sworn statements show that
was paid $1,000. Governor Evar
who was supposed by people in Sou
Carolina to be acting in the inten
of the State, testifies that he car
North in Mr. Rhind's ^behalf, a
after the squabble over the divisi
of the commission arose urged on t
members of the syndicate the pr
priety and justice of allowing .V
Rhind to receive his share, then ti?
up in the Baltimore Trust Compai
by litigation. The expense accou
of the syndicate shows that Gover
or Evans was paid ?100 attorney
fee and that Treasurer Bates w
paid by the syndicate ?2,330 88 f
"services."{
Mr. Rhind testified that he had n
yet. so far as his part of it was co
cerued, paid Governor Evan's fee
learned what it would be It a
pears on the recorc. that at least tv
of the three State officials active
engaged in the negotiation of tl
bonds were employed and paid fc
the purchasers.
The impression given to the persoi
most actively engaged in behalf of tl
syndicate at the time is clearly set fori
io the testimony. Certain members
the syndicate expressed curiosity an
interest, natural, perhaps, io the ci
cumstaDces. They ioquired why it W?
that of ?118,000 bonus offered by ll
State to purchasers of the bonds, on!
?39,300 was available for the actu;
purchasers who were to furnish tl
money, while $78,700 was to go to Mi
Rhind. who was furnishing no mone
and apparently taking Dd active part i
the dicker. The Richmond broker toi
them he understood-presumably froi
Mr. Rhind-that the bulk of that sui
was to "be divided amoDg parties i
South Carolina vho had political infk
ence.". The New York broker, wh
was in close association with Mi
Rhind, aod whose opportunities fe
kuowledge were best of all, replied tbs
they "would better not investigat
tLat ; that it was to go to people wh
would better not.be known." '
It reads that way in the testimon
taken.
When Mr. Rhind was on the stand
he was not pressed regarding his use c
his part of the boous, and offered o
explanation.
It is not in evidence in this case, bu
it is a fact capable of easy and diree
proof, that Mr. Rhind, while holdiDj
the option O?I the bond issue and en
deavoring to induce He formation of ;
syndicate to take ii, stated that h
would not get more than eoough froa
it to Day for his rime and expenses. ?
is also true that, members of the syoui
cafe who were willir-; to dea! direct!}
with the State and take the bonds foi
a commission of three-fourths of 1 pei
cent were officially informed that nt
proposition could be considered unlesi
they were sent through Mr. Rhind
that not even an offer of par net, with?
out any commission, would be consider
ed, although at that very time Mr
Rhind was demanding at 2-| per ceol
commission.
When the time came for division ol
the bonus of $78,000 the New York
man took ?20,000 and the Richmond
man ?5,000, for .special services aud
expenses. Mr. Rbind got ?48,500,
and Major Gary ?1,000. A peculiar and
perhaps significant circumstance is that
Mr. Rhiod took bis ?48,500, no? in one
draft on the Baltimore Trust Company,
but in three separate drafts, all payable
the same day-one for ?25.000, one
for $9,000, and one for ?14,500.
To sum up, accordiog to the sworn
evidence on record :
Mr. Rhind, who bas no special prom?
inence or standing in business circles,
and who was not a citizen or resident of
South Carolina, was approached by the
present Governor, Evans, then the re?
cognized Administration leader in the
Legislature.
He was given by Governor Tiliman
and Treasurer Bates an exclusive option
to place ?6,000,030 4 per cents at a
commission of 5 per cent fourteen
months before the time for the bonds to
be issued.
He failed to effect this, and Governor
Tillman declared that, after a personal
visit to New York, he became con?
vinced that a 4 per cent bond could not
be placed. The Governor again gave
an exclusive option to Rhind to place a
1 1-2 per cent loan. The syndicate
formed to take this fell to pieces. For
the third time Mr. Rhind was giveo the i
exclusive option.
The men who composed the syndi- j
jato got ?39,000, or three-quarters of \
1 per cent. The men who organized
the syndicate got. from Rhiod ?25,000, j
r>r less than one-hair of 1 per cent.
Mr. Rhiod realized ?49,000, or nearly j
1 per cent, on the option given bim
long i o advance of the time for placing I
'he ioan. So far a? that part of it is j
30ocerned it appears to have been a free ;
gift from tbe State of South Carolina to
a chosen citizeu of Georgia, who
employed the present, Governor Evans
and h's uncle as his attorneys.
The 8-,OOO and odd paid Treasurer
Bates by the syndicate is said here to
have been for servicies io removing the
mooey sent by the syndicate from
Charleston to Columbia
Governor Tillman demanded that
the syndicate pay fur its bonds io cur?
rency in Columbia. That was in June,
1893, just about the time of (he panic,
aod it was represented to him that tue
curreucy couid not be obtained except
in silver, which would load six freight
cars. He replied with tbedeclaratioo that
tbe six cars should be delivered to him
at the State line, aod that he would
order out the troops to escort it ro Co?
lumbia.
"By -," be exclaimed to the
banker who was negotiating with him;
"you cao'r scare me by threatening to
pay io silver." But he was finally
pacified aed induced to accept exchange
03 Charleston.
It is possible that the continued em
ployrnen of Mr. Rhiod and the renewals
of the exclusive option to bim were the
results of confidence be inspired io his
ability and that his fortyoioe thousand
dollar commission ie his exclusively, not
to be shared with anybody, lt is also
possible that tbe duties of Mr. Evans
now Governor, as attorney for Mr.
Rhind did not interfere with or affec;
bis actions and course to the Legislat
ture aod that he could and did separate
bis private interests and bis public du?
ties entirely- It is further possible that
State Treasurer Bates earned the ?2,
OOO paid him by the Syndicate fairly
and fully In the language of Marc
Antony, they are "all honorable men."
lt is not possible, however, for Til 1
? man and his followers, in view of this
transaction, with any consistency to
accuse the President and Secretary Car?
lisle of mismanagement, waste, favorit?
ism or worse, or denounce with horror
tbe idea of attorneys or members of
trusts, orcporattoos and syndicates sit?
ting in Congress.'
. - -
Gathered in Augusta.
Tillman, Evans, Rhind and
Gary meet There.
Specal to The State.
AUGUSTA, June 7.-All of the
principal parties who were connected
with the South Carolina bond deal,
again brought so prominently before
the public by the charges in the New
' York Times, are in Augusta, with
the exception of State Treasurer
Bates Governor Evans came here
yesterday and t? day Senator Till?
man arrived, although it was sup?
posed that he was still in Washington.
Mr Rhind and Major Gary live here
The presence here at this time of all
the parties concerned particularly in
j view of Governor Evans' statement
j that he and Treasurer Bates would
reply to this article in The Times,
shows that they have ail been
awakened to the gravity of the
charges at last
Senator Tillman, now better known
as Pitchfork Ben, came down from
Washington on Tuesday. Ile has
been spending a few dcys quietly at
his home He will not return to
Washington before congress ad?
journs.
When I asked him about the bond
matter he said he would not reply to
Thc Times aiticle; he no had time to
notice every such charge "made by
lying correspondents'' of newspapers,
and when the charges were presented
in some form by a responsible party
he would answer them. If Govenor
Evans and Dr. Bates wanted to an?
swer, al! well and good. He said he
was in Augusta en route to Indiana,
where he will deliver a series of
speeches this week at Lebanon, Car?
terville and other points. Next
week he will deliver speeches in Ken?
tucky.
Senator Tillman says there is now
r,-~ question about the attitude of the
Chicago convention as to free silver.
Kentucky's action made the result
cocksure. He says it is bound to be
for free silver from first to last He
is of the opinion that a Democratic
national victory depends on the man
placed at the bead of the ticket. He
says Boies is now considered the
most likely man in Washington, but
he fears Boies is too recent a convert
to Democracy to win. He says the
Republicans are beginning to show
signs of great uneasiness
Tillman does not talk of his own I
boom at all. He says the Chicago
convention is going to be for 16 to 1
all right, but the "bust is going to be
made by the gold bugs."
E J. W.
--.???-. -
Cycles and Railroads.
A London correspondent of tbe Paris
.Messenger, in speaking of the usual and
general exodus from ??lat city during
the Whitsuntide holidays, says that the
excursions from metropolis were almost
wholly made on wheels. On Whit
Monday it was impossible to hire or :
even to buy a bike in London. The
railways begin to feel the effect of their
form of transportation, which exceeds
the most extreme anticipations At tbe j
same time the rush for bicycles was a
sort of relief for railway, omnibus and j
other vehicle passengers, which the rap- |
id transit companies, however, did less j
enjoy than their fugitive customers, j
A sad side of tho matter appears in the j
statement th;.f business is seriously af?
fected by thc es pensive new craze.
Baltimore Sun.
\
i
Visiting Condemned Men.
HABANA, June 7.-Consul General
Fiizhugb Lee to-day visited the men
who were captured on the filibustering
American schooner Competitor aud who
are now confined in toe Cabaua fortress
under sentence of death. General Lee
found the prisoners lodged in unhealthy
quarters and will request Captain Gen?
eral Weyler to order that they be given
better accommodations The consul
general also saw Julio Sanguiliy, ac
American citizen, who is under life
imprisonment tor conspiracy against
the peace of Spain ami whose case is
now before the court of cassation in
Madrid
It is said that Gen. Lee, as a special
favor, requested Captain Generai Wey?
ler to release Mr Dawiey, the corre?
pondent of Harper's Weekly, who wa
arrested a few days ago. The requeat
was granted aod it is expected that
Dawley will be released from Morro
Castle to-morrow.
Amazons in Cuba.
Key West, June 7.-It bas been
learned here OD undisputable authority
that Maceo bas an army of 20.000 men
and they are strongly fortified in the
mauntains of Pinar del Rio, the Span?
iards having utterly failed to drive them
from their strongholds. Maceo has
eight caonou, two of which wore cap?
tured from the "trocha'' on his recent
attack, when it was reported that he
was repulsed
The report that Maceo bas four com?
panies of woman soldiers has been con?
firmed. The Cuban women have such
a dread of Spanish brutality, that, many
of them prefer fighting on the battle?
fields beside their husbands and broth?
ers to being thrown into the forts at the
Spaniards' mercy
In Maceo's recent attack on the tro?
cha, these amazons tockjpart aod fought
?ercely, u*ing machetes on the Span?
iards. -The attack was made north of
San Marcos and General Bermudez
crossed into Habana . province vrith
1 500 men.
-_mr>- ?-???? -tau
TOLEDO, Juoe 6 -AU the Toledo bi
cyle factories except two, aod which
employ altogether about. 6,000 men, arc
to shut down for au indefinite period
next week. This is said to be the first,
movement towards curtailing the out
put of wheels, and the primary object
of which is to force prices up to the
$100 notch on standard machines. It
is further stated that the factories in
many other cities are to follow suit.
Pianos, Organs and Sewing Machines sold
on easy terms, and exchanged for old ones at
the S amter Music House, in Masonic Temple
Thousands ol Women:
SUFFER UNTOLD MISERIES.
BRADFIELD^
ACTS AS A SPECIFIC
? By Arousing to Healthy Action ail har Organs.;
It causes health to bloom, and!
' joy to reign throughout thc frame.
It Never Fa?Ss to Regulate...
"My wife has bern: under treatment of lead
, lue physicians ttnve years, without benefit.
.Afterusliifr tiiree bottles ol' BKAPrlEL?'?.
FEMALE REGULATOR she can do her own]
'cooking,miikinc and -nishintr."
ST. S. BRYAN. Henderson, Ala.
BRADFIELD KEGULATOH CO., Atlanta, Va.]
Sold by druggists at SI. CO per bottle.
Chamberlain's Eye and Skin Ointment
Is unequalled for Eczema, Tetter, Salt
Rheum, Scald Head, Sere Nipples, Chapped
Hands, Itching Piles, Burns, Frost Bites,
Chronic Sore Eyes and Granulated Eye Lids.
For sale by druggists at 25 cents per box.
TO HORSEOWNERS.
For putting a horse in a fine healthy con?
dition try L>r. Cad"'s Condition Powders,
They tone up the system, aid digestion, cure
loss of appetite, relieve constipation, correct
kidney disorders and destroy worms, giving
new life to an old or over-worked horse. 25
cents per package. For sale by druggists.
For sale in Sumter, by Dr. A. J China.
TASTELESS
KS JUSTAS GOOD FOR ADULTS.
WARRANTED. PRICE 50 cts,
GALATIA, ILLS.. Nov. IG, 1S33.
Parir. Medicino Co., St. Louis, Mo.
Gentlemen:-We so?ct last year, WO bottles of
GROVE'S TASTELESS CHILL TONIC rind have
beucht, ihr^e ^n-ss already thia year. In ai! 'W ex?
perience i?i 14 years, in the driiu business, have
never sold an -?niele that gave such universal sutia
?actiuu as your Tonic. Yours tm ly.
ABNEY, CARR &CO
SOLD-NO Cure. Xo Pay, t?y A. J. Chin*
J. F. W. DeLorme, J. S. Hoghson & Co.
F. W. DeliORjTIE,
PHARMACIST.
Prescription Specialist.
Prescription department in charge of graduate of Philadelphia
College of Pharmacy.
List of Soda Water Drinks for this Season :
: Our Omi1 Lemon Phosphate-ocer 5,000 glasses, dispensed
last season.
Apricot,
Banana,
Blood Orange,
Cherry Ripe.
Pineapple,
Plum,
Quince,
Red Messina Orange,
Red Currant.
Tuti Frutti,
Peach, Chocolate, Lemon.
Vanilla. Ginger, Rasberry,
Strawberry.
The Above Flavors in Ices or Soda
Water.
Fruit Phosphate,
O-ianse Phosphate,
Raspberry Phosphate,
Wild Cherry Pbo-jhare.
Grape Phosphate, and others.
. Ice Cream Soda,
Milk Sh?ke,
Egg Phosphate,
Egg Lemonade.
Lemonade,
Lime,
Coca Cola. Wine Cocoa.
SOMETHING NEW EVERY FEW
DAYS DURING THE SEASON.
Prices same as last season*
"TROPICAL FRUIT BLEND;'
THE PLACE TO GO.
F. H. WARREN,
Manufaturer of all kinds of Harness
and Saddlery and Dealer in
HORSE BLANKETS,
LAP ROBES,
TURF GOODS AND
GENERAL STABLE
SUPPLIES.
First Class Work and Satisfaction
Guaranteed.
SEND FOR PRICES.
. 223 Meeting Street,.
Charleston, S, C,
Oct. 16-0
BEAUTY HATH CHARMS
and all the charms which beau?
ty likes best to don are shown
in our grand display of fash?
ionable jewelry for this season.
Jewels like these would en?
hance the charms of the most
fascinating belle, and surely no
fair one would despise such
brilliant aids to her beauty.
Like personal loveliness, they
conquer admiration on sight ;
they score new victories at ev?
ery inspection. Those who
look over our stock do not
willingly stop- with examina?
tion. Beauty may nov/ be
made easily irresistible by a
few judicious purchases from
our display of up to date jew?
elry.
L. W. FOLSOM,
'Jeweler and Optician,
SIGN OF THE BIG WATCH,
Oct. 16.
?,AJC-iKS
deeding atcnic. CT children rho want build
inp: U??. should take
BROWN'S !K().\ BITTERS.
It is pleasant to take, cures Malaria, luci,
gestion. t?iliousce.is and Liver Complaints.
NOTICE.
To inj Moirs aili tie Pile.
1AM FORCED TO SELL ALL MY MEATS
for the cash from thia date on-aod
Strictly Cash-over the counter. Thanking
yon for past favors, I ask continued patron?
age uoder the above rule.
EUGENE HOGAN".
May 30, 1896.
OTTO GARHAROT,
FLORIST AND GARDENER,
INFORMS HIS CUSTOMERS and th
public that he is prepared to furnish fine
?rticles in
Fruit Trees, Ro?es and all kinds of Flower
Plants,
Also Calla gt" Plaids and other Varie?
ties of Vrgetnhle Plants.
100 Cabbage Plan rs S .25
1,000 " ' " 2.00
100 Pansy Plants, 1.00
He offers bis services to lay out gardens and
"nd them in good shane. Reasonable terms.
Men 1 .
GUARANTEED IN WRITING. Stu?
dents complete in HALF the time at HALF the
expense required elsewhere. Ten to thirty
placed monthly. Actual Business Depart?
ment equipped with genuine commercial bunk
and office fixture?, superior to the equipments
of any other college it) America. Purely
prac:ical instruction and daily drill :n real
bank and office transaction. Penmanship by
the only graduate pen-ariisi. in Georgia. The
only Southern College tully abreast with the
Spirit of progress and teaching Electric
Shorthand, the lightning system of the cen?
tury. The only college which it is cheaper
to attend Mian to remain idle. Premiums
t.om Four Expositions. Enrollment 700 i|pr
ver.r. Address at once GEORGIA BUSI?
NESS COLLEGE, Macon Ga.
Nov. 6.-o
SUITER RESTAURANT.
MEALS TO CEDEE AT ALL HOTOS
OYSTERS AND GAME IN SEASON.
Special attention io Lunches for Ladies.
Prices Moderates
Your patronage solicited. Liberty Street
near Watchman and Southro7i Office.
Oct. 2. ? .
Just Opened,
ALL FRESH GOODS,
LOW PRICES.
J. A. FOXWORTH
Inform? his friends and the
public generally that he has
opened a choice stock of
Family Groceries,
j VEGETABLES aili FRUITS,
In the Tuomey Block
-fourth store North.
He invites all to give him a call, and
will try by offering the best goods at
bottom prices, to give satisfaction.
J. A. Foxworth.
Oct. 16-v.
BUY HONE BOT THE GENUINE.
8:C00 Merchants sell Hawkes' Spectacles
successfully. Half of them handle other
Spectacles wi;hout success,
Showing the Grear Popularity of HAW?
KES' GLASSES over all others.
These Famous GUsses are Stted to the eye
at A. J. China's Drug Store, Sumter. S. C.
Deo. 11- o.
HARB Y Sf CO.,
WHOLESALE BROKERS,
Cotton Storage Warehouse
PROPRIETORS.
UP-TOWN OFFICE:
COURT HOUSE SQUARE,
500 Tons Ammonialed Guano
500 Tons Acid Phosphate.
500 Tons German Kain it.
COTTON SEED MEAL, AND MEAT SALT
FOR SALE.
GET OUR PRICES.
We keep on hand a full line cf heavy
groceries.
FEED AND SEED OATS,
DRY SALT MEATS,
LARD, MEAL, GRIST.
FLOUR, SUGAR, RICE,
COFFEE, POTTED
MEATS. Ac, tc.
???" Correspondence solicited
Nov. 27.
Hardware, Cutlery
and Guns,
WOODWARE,
TOWARR,
POTWARE,
AGRICULTURAL IMPLEMENTS
For sale at lowest market prices.
MARSHALL, WESGOAT CO.'
CHARLESTON, S. C.
Ocr. 16-x.
DENTIST.
ot?, ce
0."2I1 STOKE OF SUMTER DK? GOODS COKPAXY,
-utiauce on Main Street.
Between Dry Goods Co. aod Dur.-in; & Son
OFFICE HOURS:
9 to 1.30 : 2 tc 5 j :!ock.
April 9. 2