The sun. [volume] (Newberry, S.C.) 1937-1972, November 12, 1970, Image 25
NEWS-SUN-CITIZEN — TRICENTENNIAL EDITION
Newberry County, S. 0., November 12, 1970
Sf. Luke’s Lutheran Church Was Organized In 1828
Wesleyan Methodism
Came To Whitmire In 1916
Wesleyan Methodism came to
Whitmire in the year 1916, when
the Rev. John Hames erected
a Gospel tent at the intersec
tion of Broome Street and Rail
road Avenue, at the site that is
now Cody Owens trailer park.
After a successful meeting a
Wesleyan MethodistChurchwas
organized. As our records of
the times are incomplete we do
not have a complete record of
all the charter members, but a-
mong those that joined at the
time were, Miss Annie Mary
King (Malone), Mr. J. T. Gas-
king, Mr. and Mrs. J. W.
Helmns, Rev. M. C. King, Mrs.
Sallie Crocker. Rev. D. 0. Pow
ers came as the first Pastor of
the new church and continued
until his death in 1937.
As there was no church build
ing at this time and no pros
pects for one soon, Mr. and
Mrs. A. W. Crocker, pened
their doors at 411 Grant Street
for services.
Another person that came to
Whitmire at this time, a per
son whom many loved and most
every one knew, Mrs. Maner
Maclderath Shelton (a widow).
She came to play for Rev.
Hames in the tent meeting, and
became acquainted with Mr.
Bob Reid, whom she later mar
ried. After his death she seem
ed to adopt Whitmire as her
family, sharing the joys and
sorrows of the people until her
death about 1958.
About 1919 the first church
building was erected in the
same location as the present
one, at Broome and Ducket.
There was very little money
available and the chprch was
built in part if not all with
voluntary labor. As the work
ing schedule at the mill was 10
hours a day and five hours on
Saturday, the members and
friends of the church would ga
ther after work to build the
church.
After the Church building was
erected, a Sunday School was
organized with Mr. J. T. Gas-
king as Superintendent, Mr. E.
M. Lackey, Song Leader, Mrs.
Maner Reid, Organist, Miss
Pauline Crocker, Secretary
Also, there was a Wesleyan
Missionary Society organized
with Mrs. Sophie Darby as Pre
sident, and a Y.M.W B., with
Mrs. Ida Price as Superintend
ent.
In the beginning the church
was a small one room building,
but as time went on the church
continued to grow, both in the
size of the building and in mem
bership. At the time of the death
of the Pastor, Rev. D. 0. Pow
ers in 1937, there had been se
ven Sunday School rooms added
to the building.
At the death of Rev. D. 0.
Powers, Rev. L, W. Barbee
came as Pastor and continued
until 1940, at which time he felt
the call to evangelistic work and
resigned.
During the pastorate of Rev.
Barbee, a parsonage was bought
and the Church Building was re
novated inside and the outside
was brick-veneered.
Under the supervision of Rev.
Barbee, Rev T. B. Rhoades,
Rev. W. M. Crocker, and Rev.
M. C. King organized a Wes
leyan Church atWattsville, with
Rev. M C. King as the first
pastor.
The Rev. J. D. Scoggin came
as pastor in 1942 and served
until 1942. Rev. C. T. Bryant
served as pastor through the
war years of 1942 until 1947,
at which time he excepted a
call to the First Wesleyan
Church (College Church) at
Central.
The Rev. W. S Allred came
in 1947 and continued until 1951,
after which Rev. A. L. Vess
came and served until 1953.
In 1953 Rev. E. L Alexan
der came to Whitmire and
shortly thereafter the Church
entered into a buildingprogram
to build a new Church Building.
“On October 11, 1958 at 2:30
p.m., marked another day of a-
chievement for the First Wes
leyan Church of Whitmire. A
group of church members and
friends gathered at the site of
the new church sanctuary and
brake the ground and dedicated
it to the glory of God and the
furtherance of His Kingdom.
The service seemed most fitt
ing as it could only have been
possible by the help of God and
the co-operation of the people.”
The Rev. E. L Alexander con
tinued in Whitmire until 1963,
at which time he accepted a call
to the First Wesleyan Church
in Central»
Rev. W. S. Allred returned
for his second pastorate in 1963
and continued until February of
1967, at which time he resigned,
and the Rev. C. R. Tegen came
as interim pastor to serve un
til Conference time in July.
Rev. Marvin Quarles came
as pastor in July 1967, and is
serving until the present. The
highlights of events since Rev.
Quarles became pastor was the
merger of the Wesleyan Me
thodist Church of America, (of
which we wore a part) and the
Pilgrim Holiness Church in
1968. At which time the name
was change from The Wesleyan
Methodist Church to “The Wes
leyan Church." The morgageon
the Church was paid off in Jan
uary of 1969, and a Parsonage
Building - Fund was begun. In
November of 1969 the construc
tion of the new parsonage was
begun. In March of 1970 the
Pastor and family moved into
the new parsonage, which is
located on the Newberry High
way.
Prior to the turn of the cen
tury there was a beautiful grove
that almost covered four blocks.
These lots bordered on O’Neal
Street, Boundary Street, and
Langford street. The large pal
atial home almost in the cen
ter was the home of the late
Dr. Gilder, the extra large
grove in this spot was known
as Leavell’s Grove. This large
space was also used for cir
cus show grounds. Since the
recent building program this
space now has four streets that
did not exist some thirty years
ago. In this space there are
now about forty homes. This
Leavell’s Grove was once used
for an unusual event. In the
early part of the summer of
1894 a man by the name of
Rev. Pierce ‘Mike’ Kinard of
Epworth, S. C. conducted a
tent meeting in this grove. The
tent was on the O’Neal street
side and at the conclusion of
this meeting there were thirt
een persons that binded them
selves together and petitioned
The Presiding Elder,a Rev.
Harmon, of the Cokesburv Dis
trict to grant them the privi
lege of organizing a Methodist
Church. The petition was
granted and a minister by the
name of the Rev. S.A. Nettles
was assigned as the first pas
tor. The first place of worship
was a little one room school
house that stood where the New
Educational Building now stands.
At that time Central Methodist
Church was known as the First
Methodist Church and the new
church was known for a short
while as The Second Methodist
Church and The First Metho
dist was in watch care for the
new church for a while. The
thirteen charter members were
Miss Louise Lyles, Miss Minnie
Lyles, Miss Hattie Vaughn,
Miss Ophelia Vaughn, Mrs.
Frank Hampton Jones, Mrs.
Minnie Jones, Mrs. Nettie Jones
Mrs. Sarah Jane Davis, Mrs.
Martha Isabella Thornton, Mr.
Judge Rice Thornton, Mr. John
Henry Chappell, Mrs. Mary
Prince Chappell, Mr. Frank
Baxter. The present member
ship now exceeds 400.
The list of ministers once
serving O'Neal street were
Rev. S.A. Nettles, 2 year, Rev.
W.B. Verdin 6 months, Rev.
John W. Speake (Who built the
first church) 3 1/2 years, Rev.
B. D. Lucas (Who later went as
a missionary to China) 1/2
Bev. E.T. Adams (A direct
relation of a former U.S. Pres.-
ident) 2 1/2 years, Rev. G
E. Edwards 2 years, Rev. John
Henry Graves 2 years; (The
church just recently torn down
was built during the time that
Rev. Graves served, he also
received the honor of having a
street named for him, the street
was later changed to Charles
Street., Rev. J.B. Kilgore, 2
years, Rev. John T. Miller,
2 years, Rev. Will C. Kelly,
2 years, Rev. A.M. Gardner,
2 years, Rev. Gobe Smith 2
years, Rev. Ben. L. Knight 2
years, Rev. R.F. Cogburn, 2
years Rev. W'.F. Gault, 4 years,
Rev. R.O. Webb, 4 years, Rev.
J.E. Brown, 1 year, Rev. M.A.
Cleckley, 2 years, Rev. J.E.
Merchant 4 years, Rev. M.M.
Brooks,5 yrs.,Rev. N.K.Polk,
4 years, and the Rev.
C. F. DuBose, Jr, 5 years, Rev.
J.W. Tomlinson 4 years, Rev.
John W. Davernport 4 years,
Rev. P aul Petty, 4 years, Rev.
M.B. Fryga, 4 years, Rev. Hoyt
Graham 2 1/2 years, Rev. El
bert Johnson 1 1/2 years.
The church was known as
O'Neal Street MethodistChurch
South until 1939 when it became
united and was then known as
O’Neal Street MethodistChurch
In 1968 and to-day it is known
as O’Neal Street United Metho
dist Church. The church has
gone through phases of remod
eling and adding Sunday School
rooms. The most extensive
being when Rev. W. F. Gault
was Pastor, later again when
Rev. M.M. Brooks was Pastor.
O’Neal Street has many
records of service to its cre
dit, under Pastor Gobe Smith
the very first Boy Scout troop
in Newberry was organized in
the year 1913. The church has
sent seven ministers out into
the ministry, three ladles have
become wives of ministers. Two
of its members have served the
City of Newberry as mayor and
four have served as aldermen.
The church has always been
well known as having an out
standing choir and had the very
first electric organ to come
to Newberry County. The church
also has had a very outstanding
Women Society of Christian
Service and also has a Meth
odist Men’s Club. It has for
many years had great interest
in its’ youth programs.
To-day it has three fourths of
a block on O’Neal Street with
its New Parsonage, New Edu
cational Building and just re
cently a new sanctuary. Each
building is modern in every
respect with modern heating and
air conditioning.
In 1826 a Missionary Com
mittee of the Synod of Lutheran
Churches in South Carolina was
appointed to preach, to help ne
edy and destitute churches and
to organize other churches.
Rev. J. G. Schwartz was one
of the travelling missionaries
for the Synod and organized the
congregation that was to become
St Luke’s in 1828. The meet
ing at which this organization
took place was known as the
Baptist Meeting House, located
about two miles southeast from
the present qjmrch building.
Evidently it was used by all
people of the neighborhood as a
place for Sunday School, prayer
meeting and preaching service
when an itenerant preacher
came along. In 1830, a small
plain church building was built
on land given by John Enlow
which is the present site.
The earliest available record
of the congregation is dated
February 2,1832 and shows Rev.
Jacob Moser as pastor and a
list of eighty members. The
Rev. William Berley served St.
I.uke’s as Pastor while teaching
at the Lutheran Seminary at Lex
ington. In 1845 under his pasto
rate the church building was re
placed with a larger one and the
materials in the old building
sold to Colony Luthern Church,
also organized under the min
istry of Rev. Berley. The new
church was built with a gal
lery for slaves to sit during the
service. The door that led to
the gallery was known as “Aunt
Lucy’s Door* named after one
of the best known slaves. During
the time from 1845 until slavery
was abolished, St. Lukfs had a
membership of 38-40 slaves.
While pastor at St. Luke’s
Rev. Berley also organized
Grace, Prosperity. After Rev.
Berley’s resignation, Rev. T. S.
Boinest became Pastor of St.
Luke’s and Colony, but because
of his interest in and work with
Luther Chapel (the presentRe-
gyU
deemer, Newberry), he re
signed to devote full time to
Luther Chapel.
The dark days of the Civil
War seemed to have a great
effect on St. Luke’s. As there
was no pastor, Rev. Smithdeal,
Pastor of Grace, Prosperity,
and Rev. Boinest of Newberry
performed pastoral duties for
the congregation. In 1869, the
synod grouped churches into
pastorates. St. Luke’s, Colony
and Grace formed Pastorate No.
13 and was served by Rev. Jacob
Hawkins. He was a son of St.
Luke's congregation and his
parents were charter members
of the Church. I t is interest
ing to note that he (Rev. Jacob
Hawkins) was born in 1828, the
year St. Luke’s was organized.
Three times he was pastor of
his mother church and died
while her pastor in 1895. He was
a writer of rare ability, author
Grace Lutheran Church
Was Organized In 1859
O’Neal St. Methodist
Church Has Grown From
13 Members To Over 400
In 1859 in Frog Level (Now
Prosperity) Newberry County,
South Carolina, situated on the
line of Greenville and Columbia
Railroad, a Lutheran Congre
gation was organized. Two par
cels of land were deeded in
trust to the Rev. William Berly:
one parcel on December 28,
1857 and a second on Feb.
6, 1858.
At the annual convention of
Synod, which convened on Oct
27, 1859, the Rev. Samuel Bouk-
night, President, reported:
‘Sometime in the month of
September, I received a letter
from the Rev. W. Berly, stating
that he had succeeded in having
a church erected in the Town
of Frog Level, in Newberry
District and that it had been
dedicated to the service of God,
on the fourth Sunday in August
by the name and title of “New-
ville*. This was certainly a
wise and timely effort for that
place, as it is surrounded by
a population whose feelings have
been identified with our church.
This being a central point
affords facilities from every
direction and must therefore
always command a large con
gregation.*
His words have been fully
justified by the achievements of
this Congregation during all
its History. Many of the min
isters, laymen and laywomen
have been prominent in the life
of the Lutheran Church and
many historical events have
taken place within its doors.
The first Church structure
was torn down and a new edi
fice erected in 1878 at a cost
of $850.00. This church was
dedicated on October 2, 1878,
and received the name anu
title of “Grace Church*, which
name the present church bears
in this the 111th. years of its
existence. In 1907 the present
church edifice was started. The
cornerstone was laidNovember
21, 1907 and the building de
dicated May 1,1910.
The roll of early organizers
contains the following names:
David Kibler, Mrs. Mary Kibler
(David), Mrs. Elizabeth Maffett
Lang C. Kibler, John Duncan,
Mary J. Shealy, C. Adeline
Shealy, Nancy C. Shealy, A.A.
Kibler, Dr. A.G. Kibler, Luther
Long, John Bailey, Martha Ma
this (Kibler), Ella Dicker!, M.
Jane Boozer, James William
Werts, J. A. Kibler, J. M.
Kibler^Mrs. Margaret Bowers,
William Bridges, Mrs. Joseph
Mathis, Mrs. James C. Maffett
Mrs. Ann Kibler, Miss Jeho-
sheba Kibler, Miss Terza L.
Kibler, Mrs.SarahSpence, John
Simpson, John Maffett, Mrs.
Emma Nates, Martha Wilson
(Quattlebaum) James Werts.
Alice Haftman, Mrs. Mary
Barre, Dr. W.L. McFall, Mrs.
Mary A. McFall, David B. Ki
nard, Eliza Nates (Schumpert),
Mrs. Carrie Boland, Mrs.
Nancy Matthews, Miss Vina
Moore, Mrs. Sallie Werts Co
unts, Miss Reedy Moore and
Mrs. Frances Werts.
Members of Grace entering
full time service are: Rev. M.M.
Kinard, D.D., Rev. A. Jackson
Bowers, D.D. Rev. James D.
Kinard, D.D., Rev. Virgil Y.
Boozer, Mrs. Gertrude Simpson
Leonard, Rev. E.H. Kohn, Rev.
Day B. Werts. Rev. James Lee
Shealy, Mrs. Lillie Kyzer Leck-
inger, Rev. and Mrs. Charles
B. Dawkins and Mr. A1 Potter.
The present officers of the
congregation are; Vice-Pres
ident, B.C. Bedenbaugh, Secre
tary, Miss PhylisShealy, Trea
surer, Lewis C. Hawkins, Fin
ancial Secretary, W.E. Martin,
Treasurer, Lewis C. Hawkins,
Financial Sectrtary, W. E. Mar
tin, Treasurer of Building Fund,
Otis K. Shealy, and Treasurer
of Memorial Fund, Mrs. James
Lee Counts.
Rev. G. Alvin Fulmer, is the
pastor of the church.
NEWS-SUN-CITIZEN TRICENTENNIAL EDITION
Newberry County, S. C., November 12, 1970
ofHawkin’s Catechism and edi
tor of the Lutheran Visitor.
Rev. H. S. Wlngard served as
Pastor for a short time. During
or shortly after his pastorate
Grace Church withdrew from
Pastorate No. 13. St. Luke’s and
Colony were served by Rev. J.D.
Bowles. It was during his pasto
rate that the first parsonage was
built and occupied by the Pastor
of the Church. Rev. Bowles was
followed by Rev. Jacob Hawkins,
his second term, Rev. Monroe
Epting and the return of Rev.
Jacob Hawkins who served until
his death in July 1895.
Rev. George S. Bearden be
gan his work shortly there
after. The records show that
he married Miss Katherine Lu
ther of Prosperity in 1895. Mrs.
Bearden still resides in Pros
perity. Rev. Bearden served*
other churches in supply ser
vices while at St. Luke’s as
well as being editor of a Church
paper. He was followed at St
Luke’s by Rev. H. J. Mathias
and then Rev. S. P. Koon who
served until 1912 when he re
signed to become President of
Summerland College, an insti
tution of the South Carolina
Synod for Women. During Rev.
Koon’s pastorate.he organized
Silverstreet Church, mostly of
members from St. Luke’s and
has often been called a child of
St Luke’s.
A Sunday School Annex was
built and renovations to the
Church were made during the
pastorate of Rev. B. W. Cronk.
He was followed by Rev. W. H.
Roof and Rev. E. H. Seckinger
who served until 1926. At this
time the congregation numbered
317 in membership and the
church property was valued at
$7,500.00. During the times
when there was no pastor, na
mes such as Rev. R. A. Good
man, Dr. A. J. Bowers among
others were common to the Chu
rch service.
Rev. J. B. Harmon accepted
the work of the pastorate in
1928. The Centennial Anni
versary of the congregation was
celebrated on August 9, 1928
(Thursday) with a large crowd
of members, former members
and friends. Former Pastors
and Supply Pastors were pre
sent or sent greetings for the
occasion.
In 1937, Rev. J. Virgil Long
was called as Pastor and serv
ed until 1943 at which time the
Church Council released him as
Pastor so that he could enter
the ArmedForces as Chaplain.
Thus, for the third time in his
tory, war had called upon the
congregation to give of her sons
and this last time of her pastor
as well. (It is interesting to note
that at this time Rev. Long serv
es as pastor of Colony, one of
the congregations that was a
part of the parish at an earlier
date.)
In 1944, Rev. C. E. Seastrunk
began his work and continued
ontll 1950. Rev. Thomas F.
Suber, D. D. served from 1951
until his retirement In 1962, and
served as Pastor Emeritus un
til his death In 1969. Under his
leadership and direction the new
church building was constructed
and the debt eliminated.
The present parsonage was
built in 1962 and first occupied
by Rev. J. Hilton Roof who be
gan his pastorate on August 15,
1963 and serves as the present
pastor. The congregation has a
membership of 830 baptised
members and a property eva
luation of $126,952.
Sons of the congregation who
were ordained to the Ministry
are as follows: Levi Beden
baugh, pastor of some of the
more prominent churches in S.
C. graduated with the first class
of the Theological Seminary at
Lexington. Wilson Bedenbaugh
brother to Levi, became an or
dained minister, but there is no
further record of him. Jacob
Hawkins has already been men
tioned in this history. Elijah
Hawkins, un'cle of Jacob
Hawkins, graduated with Levi
Bedenbaugh in 1836 but no fur
ther record is made. J. S. El
more, son of the congregation
served in the South Carolina
Synod. Cornelius Boozer was a
son of charter members of the
congregation. L. P. Hawkins did
most of his ministerial work in
Virginia and Pennsylvania. P.
E. and J. A. Shealy, brothers,
were confirmed in St. Luike’s
but later transferred to Grace,
Prosperity. P. E. is now de
ceased and J. A. resides in
LeesviUe. Vernon A. Frick was
ordained in 1953 and is an ad
opted member of St. Luke’s
having grown up in St Peter’s
(Piney Woods) Chapin. He now
serves Union Lutheran Church,
Salisbury N. C. Clyde Beden
baugh was ordained in 1954 and
presently serves as pastor of
Luther Memorial Lutheran
Church, Hollywood, Fla. Gerald
Smith, ordained in 1970, is ser
ving as assistant pastor at Mt
Calvary Lutheran Church, Ex
celsior, Minnesota. Larry
Smith, also ordained in 1970 is
serving as pastor of the Peak-
Sprlnghlll Lutheran Parish,
Peak, S. C.
of Whitmire
Sends Birthday Greetings
To All Of South Carolina On
Her 300th Anniversary.
1670-1970
Special Wishes To Newberry
County During Their
Tricentennial Celebration
1670
1970
SOUTH CAROLINA
TRICENTENNIAL
Belk Simpson Co.
Main Street
Whitmire, S. G.