The sun. [volume] (Newberry, S.C.) 1937-1972, January 14, 1949, Image 2
THF NRWRKRRY SUN. VEWBERRY. N. C.
Washington Di9CSt^
Public Health Bill Faces
Tough Battle in Congress
By BAUKHAGE
News Analyst and Commentator.
WASHINGTON.—The dim roar of an approaching battle
in congress is being heard over the horizon. The struggle will
concern S.1320, the national health insurance and public
health bill.
This measure was opposed in the last session by an organization
formed by the American Medical association which turned out to be, in
terms of dollars spent, the biggest lobby in Washington, and that is a
record. *
Why does the
oppose the bill?
edical association
BAU&HAGE
Supporters of the
legislation say be
cause the major
ity of the doctors,
like the majority
of the people in
the country don’t
understand it.
Many doctors
think it would foul
up their practice
of medicine with
politics. Many also
say it would de
stroy normal pa
tient-physician re
lations because
the patient would
have to take what
mddical treatment he could get on
an assembly-line basis. This latter
assumption is based on a misappre
hension of what is actually^! the
bill which I’ll mention later.
The former charge is a predic
tion and can’t be answered categor
ically. I can understand it. When I
was in college, I got a summer job
on the Chautauqua daily. Chautau
qua is a pretty big summer commu
nity, and health is important. A
young medical student friend of
mine whose father had a pull got the
job of inspecting cowbarns of farm
ers supplying milk to Chautauqua.
I made the rounds with him once.
Re examined the bovine living con
ditions thoroughly and some were
pretty vile. He made notes and put
them in a report recommending that
purchases from a particular farmer
be suspended until the bams were
•leaned up.
What happened? He got a
•harp call-down from his supe
rior. After that, inspection con
sisted in opening cow-barn
doors, holding the nose, and
looking the other way.
That happened many years ago,
and I have heard that Chautauqua
pounty is noted for its model dairies.
But there is always a lurking sus
picion that when a politician puts
his Anger in the pie it turns sour.
The only specific answer to this
charge of politics that I have dis
covered is one offered in a pamphlet
gotten out by the Federation of
Women’s Clubs which says: “the
plan allows. for the representation
of the people paying for it.”
Perhaps a better answer lies in
the fact that the American Federa
tion of Labor and the CIO, both of
whose leaders know just about as
much about how politically-con
trolled institutions operate as any
organization heads in the country,
favor the bill. It has been supported
by many individual doctors and by
tbe Physicians Forum, and the
Committee of Physicians for the
Improvement of Medical Care.
But what is “it,” this national
health insurance bill? Are you fa
miliar with its purpose, what it pro
poses to do and how it proposes to
do it?
Let’s go back. What was the most
shocking revelation in the World
War II draft statistics? I’d be will
ing to bet the thing that most pain
fully surprised the whole country
was that one-third of our youth of
military age was unhealthy.
Out of fifteen million regis
trants, five million were re
jected for physical or mental
disabilities. Kural residents as
a group were even less healthy.
Forty-one out of each 100 rural
registrants were turned down as
4-Fs. It had been just the op
posite in World War I when
farmers entdistanced city folk
in good health.
From these figures, we suddenly
discovered that the American youth
wasn’t such a hale and hearty in
dividual as we had thought. Later,
as you may not know, we learned
that 325,000 Americans die every
year who could be saved with prop
er medical care.
About twenty per cent of our peo
ple can afford all the medical care
they need.
Half our families—those with an
income of $3,000 a year or less—
find it hard, if not impossible—to
pay for even routine medical care.
Thirty per cent of our fami
lies in the $3,000 to 45,000-a-
year bracket would have to go
into debt or make other sacri
fices to meet the cost of severe
or chronic illness.
So you can see why America is
twenty-three per cent unhealthy.
From the beginning Americans
have believed that sound minds are
the responsibility of the state, hence
the public school system. A sound
mind isn’t much good in an unsound
body. So, say the supporters of the
national health insurance bill, it is
logical and thoroughly in keeping
with American principles to tax ev
erybody so that everybody can get
medical care. They argue that free
dom from persecution by germs is
as much the business of the wholi
people as freedom from persecv
tion, censorship, or any of the othei
restrictions our ancestors came to
America to avoid.
I won’t go into the history of the
bill. It was written after years of
study, six years of public hearings
before congressional committees.
Those who have opposed the meas
ure have made their chief argument
a contention that it would be anoth
er step toward a socialized state,
that it would indeed socialize the
medical profession. On point one,
the supporters say truthfully “that
argument was once - raised against
the public schools, city water-works,
municipal sewage systems, electric
light and power plants, which are
now accepted as a matter of
course.”
Under the national health insur
ance bill, the federal government
would collect the money and man
age it along with the social security
fund which it does now, disburse
it to the states for the services ren
dered by the doctors and approve
of the various state set-ups.
The actual arrangements for
the services of the doctors who
would go right on with their
private practices as well if they
wanted to, would be made be
tween doctor and patient. The
patient, unless his family doc
tor refused to join up, would
have his services just the same,
only they would be free. The
doctor wouldn’t have to accept
any patient he didn’t want.
Part of the money would go to
the states for research, medical
education ana various preventive
services. How much would it cost?
One and one-half per cent of your
earnings up to $3,600 which your
employer would match. If you are
self-employed, you would pay three
per cent up to $3,600 of your own
earnings. And that, say the bill’s
proponents is no more than you pay
now (on the average) to a voluntary
group health agency if you belong
to one and it's less than you would
pay to a private physician.
Physicians’ rates and mode of
payment will be established by the
vote of the majority of the physi
cians in the given area or locality.
Since the worst shortage of
doctors is in rural areas, it is
expected that with assurance of
adequate pay through the na
tional insurance fund, more
physicians will be attracted to
those areas. Also the fund will
help to expand local public
health services, rural hospital
and ambulance service.
Aside from the poorer health in
farm communities, maternal mor
tality is higher and, as every farm
er knows, accidents are high. There
are 54 deaths per 100,000 population
on farms, only 20 per 100,000 in in
dustry.
In the controversy over this meas
ure both sides point to the experi
ence of other countries. They claim
the national insurance system was
inaugurated in Germany in 1883.
One American Medical association
member says medical care declined
under it. He probably knows more
about it than I, but the statement
was certainly a surprise.
Similar complaints have been
made against a similar plan which
has just been inaugurated in Bri
tain. But a recent poll taken in-Eng
land says 91 per cent of the physi
cians have joined up which would
seem to show they approved of the
way it works even if they opposed
it in the beginning. And the people
voted it the most popular measure
passed by the present government.
The British Medical association did
not oppose the bill as a whole but
fought against certain portions, par
ticularly those which they thought
might make them “servants of the
state.”
These facts I have checked as
nearly as I can and I do not believe
they will be disputed. As to the opin
ions, they remain as such. And
you can’t look into the future. From
what I can learn, the supporters of
the bill believe that it will be one of
the first introduced in the new con
gress, that it will reach the floor
by February and that the chances
for its passage are good.
• • •
Llanfairpwllgwyngyllgogerychwy- !
mdrobwllllantysiliogogogocb is said
by the National Geographic Soci
ety to be the longest place-name in
the world. But it’s no good for a
cross-word puzzle.
• • •
Coconut chips are now available
in five-ounce tins. They may be used
as snacks for bridge parties, but
the red, white and blue ones still
will be preferred for poker.
• • •
You’ll never find a sandpiper
and a fiddler crab playing in tha
same orchestra.
FASHIONABLE . . . Mrs. Alfred
Gwynne Vanderbilt was selected
as one of the 10 best-dressed
women of 1948 in a poll conduct
ed among fashion designers by
the New York Dress Institute.
HUNGARIAN OATH Istavan
Dobi, a leader of the Small
Holders party of Hungary, is
shown as he took the oath of
office as prime minister of
Hungary. He succeeded Lajos
Dinnyes.
r SOG ,
oftHtRS!
DOG ,
XM5l22£BS
r B«J
[ 1 o-,,. .
t itww* MAtssig
i ‘Wiwi'i reufnmjn <—
CARDINAL HELD ON TREASON CHARGE . . . Accused in an official
government communique of "espionage, treason, black market cur
rency deals” and of “seeking to overthrow the democratic govern
ment of Hungary,” Josef Cardinal Mindszenty, Roman Catholic primate
of Hungary, has been arrested by tbe Communist-dominated govern
ment. Ironically, tbe 56-year-old cardinal also was arrested by the
Nazis in 1944 for seeking to promote democracy.
, J-
I*
—w
PONTIFF RECEIVES U. S. UNDERSECRETARY . . . Pope Pius Is
shown conversing in the Vatican with George Allen, U. S. undersecre-
.ary of state, during the latter’s visit to Rome while en route to a
conference of the United Nations Economic, Cultural and Social
organization. The pontiff gave Alien a private audience in order to
discuss matters pertinent to UNESCO,
MEANEST YET . . . Gretchen,
sad-eyed dachshund owned by
Allen Boyer of Chicago, views
sign warning of pet poisoners.
Her two canine playmates died
after eating meat containing
ground glass.
STUBBORN . . . For violation of
Canada’s liquor act, Vancouver
police padlocked Aladion Fan-
ini’s home. He refused to leave
the premises when he was told
the windows would be ham
mered shut if he did. Said Fan-
ini: “I gotta lotsa birdseed for
my canaries. I stay inside for
six months.”
FREE INDIA’S FIRST NATIONAL CONGRESS . . . With the nation
al flag of the Dominion of India being carried by one of the riders, a
huge elephant leads the procession that marked the opening of the
55th session of tbe Indian national congress at Jaipur. This congress
is unique, however, in that it is the first to be held since India won
its independence. >
c
PEACE MARK . . . Genevieve A.
Irish of Burlington, Vt., exhibits
book mark that was gift of Pres
ident and Mrs. Truman to White
House staffers. Inscription is:
"I would rather have peace in
the world than be President.”
FRAN CO-ITALIAN RAPPROCHEMENT—OR SHAKE . . . Robert Sc hu
man (left), French foreign minister, and Count Carlo Sforza, foreign
minister of Italy, prepare for a jovial handshake as they meet at
Cannes, French Riviera, for a little International chit-chat. They talked
over problems common to both their countries, principally the threat
of communism. Both have struck telling blows against communism
in their nations* governments.
Blast at Marshall
A LTHOUGH the state department
tried to throw a monkey
wrench ir> his typewriter, Maj. Gen.
Claire Chennault of the famed Fly
ing Tigers lias defiantly gone ahead
with his memoirs. Now he is ready
to set the match to a literary ex
plosion that will rattle the windows
inside Secretary of State Marshall’s
office.
The China ace tells his own story
as he lived it—shooting from the
hip. Summing up Marshall’s mis
sion to China in his unpublished
memoirs, Chennault observes sour
ly:
"Net result of the 15-month
Marshall mission to China was
the rescue of Chinese Commu
nists from military disaster,
blunting the offensive edge of
the generalissimo’s armies,
and setting the stage for the
Communist offensives of 1947
that netted them most of Man
churia and a large part of
north China.”
Chennault charges that Marshall
gave safe conduct to half a mil
lion Communist troops to slip out
of a Nationalist trap through Kal-
gan pass. Later these same troops
sealed up the pass in violation of
their safe-conduct pact, then came
back with Japanese arms to wrest
. Manchuria away from Chiang Kai-
shek.
These arms were taken from Rus
sian stockpiles, Chennault claims,
yet Marshall’s arms embargo cut
ol'f American supplies from the
Nationalist armies. Since all their
equipment was American, they
couldn’t use it without American
replacements.
“Marshall has learned consider
ably more about Communist tac-
1 tics since his China days,” blasts
Chennault, “But he has never
candidly acknowledged his mistakes
in China or made any attempt to
j rectify them.”
Marshall’s Distrust
Chennault gives a clue to his bit
ter feelings against Marshall in dis
cussing their early relationship.
Marshall believed the Flying Tigers
chief was disloyal to the late Gen.
“Vinegar Joe” Stilwell, then in
command of the China theater.
Marshall also thought Chen
nault had failed in east China,
and even doubted his personal
honesty. Once Marshall stated
flatly that he would never ap
prove another promotion or dec
oration for Chennault.
Chennault points out in his un
published memoirs that the Rus
sians have watched their German
neighbors go down to defeat twice
in two-front wars, and have care
fully avoided the same pitfall.
While Germany was menacing her
western flank, Russia kept out of
open war with Japan even though
pitched battles were fought along
the Manchurian border. Russia was
also wary of taking on an exhausted
Japan in 1945 until victory over
Germany was complete.
World Government
"As a practicing warrior for
many years,” concludes Chennault,
“I am convinced that war is com
pletely futile. It settles only the
problems of the past and creates
new problems for the future. There
is no place in the world today for
the narrow, competitive national
ism that sparks the tinder of war.
My experience as an airman has
taught me the puniness of the elab
orate, artificially erected, man
made borders of political states.
"1 am convinced that the peo
ple of this planet must move
inevitably toward a single form
of world government if civiliza
tion is to survive. It is our task
now to see that this world gov
ernment comes as a mntual fed
eration of free peoples rather
than through the ruthless dom
ination of a master slave state.”
NOTE: In his memoirs, Chen
nault also blasted the tough hide of
“Vinegar Joe” Stilwell, called him
the "best four-star battalion com
mander in the army.” (A battalion
normally is commanded by a ma
jor.) Stilwell, according to Chen
nault, used 1917 tactics to fight war
in the 1940s.
Cabinet Christmas
Secretary of State George Mar
shall spent Christmas at Walter
Reed hospital, recuperating from
a kidney operation. Defense Sec
retary James Forrestal went to
Hobe Sound, Florida Air Sec
retary Stuart Symington and Vice
President-elect Barkley ate their
turkey with the airlift pilots in
Germany. . . . Army Secretary
Kenneth Royall was in Berlin with
the ground forces. . . . Treasury
Boss John Snyder, Mrs. Snyder and
daughter Drucie were in St. Louis.
. . . Commerce Chief Charles Saw
yer, his wife and five children spent
the holiday at home in Cincinnati.
. . . The Tom Clarks put in their
usual busy day carrying cheer to
underprivileged children. The at
torney general paid his annual
Christmas call at the National
Training School for Boys, while
Mrs. Clark carried gifts from jus
tice department personnel to the
Capital’s receiving home for chil
dren.
COLLEGE AND BIG BUSINESS
A congressional committee re
ports that American colleges are
partners in real estate projects,
chain restaurants, mail order
houses, department stores, gas sta
tions and many other enterprises.
One practically owns and operates
■ spaghetti plant and piston ring
factory. Another has money invest
ed in a Limoges china and leather
industry. One of the biggest univer
sities has apartment house, office
building and Radio City Center
projects running into millions.
•
Our colleges have to invest their
endowment funds some way ana
it is perfectly legitimate to do what
they have been doing, but the
charge is made that, since the in
come of educational institutions is
exempt from taxes, the colleges are
in unfair competition with business
men and cost Uncle Sam millions
in taxes every year.
*
About that we wouldn’t know
too much, but it is disconcert
ing to a man to find that the
little lady he has been So tender
ly calling Alma Mater is an in
dustrial tycoon, a member of a
dozen boards of directors and
maybe a top distributor of po
tato chips, catsup, auto tires
and lubricating oils. /
Can it be that Alma, instead of
being the dignified and handsome
gal carved in marble on the lovely
campus, should be pictured with a
prematurely bald head, a counting-
room twitch and a strictly business
look? Instead of a sweet and alool
lady interested mostly in the arts
and sciences, is she a holding cor
poration, an inner tube manufac
turer and a promoter of chain lunch
rooms?
Don’t tell us that Dean Dumplin
.and Professor Highforrid have in
truth been responsible for the kid’s
education but that the spaghetti,
mustard, orange drink and real es
tate businesses have been a big
help, too.
_*
Down there on the gridiron is
It possible that the lads have
been giving their all for dear
old Schlotz, Brown, Hailock A
Whiffle, Inc., the Cronkhite
Doughnut Machine corporation
and the Grand Union Radio
Ornament Industry? Is it possi
ble that the old grads should
sing it “For Siwanikosh, for..
Country and for Whooziss’ Re
frigerators”?
. 9
These are disillusioning times.
We like to think of the faculty
worrying only over a student’s
progress in philosophy, literature,
Greek and mathematics, and never
in an all-day conference over
whether to put a few hundred grand
into a department store, a row of
de luxe apartment houses or a new
tooth-powder idea.
m
Of course it costs money to run
universities. All those funds have
to be invested where the return
will be good. But we hope the paper
isn’t delivered the night the news
comes out that L.ttle Lester has haa
to be withdrawn from college be
cause his old man couldn’t keep
him in and at the same time pay
the rent, food and clothing bills
sent in by the college’s business
affiliations.
« * •
The Nationalized Pub
England ia| considering national
ization of the pubs (bars atid taverns
to you). Government operation of
hangovers is something new. But it
is a further indication of how far
the idea of state control of every
thing, up to and including the dark
brown taste and the morning after,
is going.
•
For generations, it would have
been thought far below the dignity
of any government to run a saloon
and put itself in the position of re
plying to unceasing orders of “make
mine the same, Joe.” But today a
proposal that the state operate pool-
rooms, bowling alleys and men’s
smokers would hardly astonish any
body.
*
Just the same, we hate to
think of any sovereign state be
coming a combination saloon
keeper, bartender and bouncer.
It isn’t going to be nice when
the folks take to blaming bad
Mickey Finns on bureaucracy or
demanding a change of adminis
tration on account of what
seems to be a government im
posed headache.
• • *
VANISHING AMERICANISMS '
“Let’s all chip in 50 cents and make
the present something good.”
*
“The gentleman wants everybody in
the place to have a drink on him.”
•
You can’t do that, it’s against the
law.”
m m m
We are all for the two-million-
dollar fund for musicians’ welfare,
but hope it won’t offer too much en
couragement to the guy upstairs
wh« Is taking saxaphone lessons.
CLASSIFIED
DEPARTMENT
AUTOS, TRUCKS & ACCESS.
For Sale—IMS Ford Trask, 8.W.B., Stake
body, extra tire, radiator shield, heater,
6.508 actual miles. Original owner. Prac
tically new. J. L WASHINGTON. F. O. Be*
75, Aone 1418M, Orantebarg, 8. C.
BUSINESS A INVEST. OPPO*.
MONEY IS BEING MADE in outdoor thea
tres. Let us help you build and equip your*.
Cost: will amaze you. Don’t delay!
WILSON-MOOBE ENTERPRISES, Uo.
P. O. Box ?034 - Atlanta 1, Ga.
ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT
POWER UNIT—Electric. 110-volt A cur-
rent, 3,000 Watts, Onan generator with 2 cyL
water cooled engine practically new with
spare parts kit $275.
- - Sharon, S. C.
spare ^
J. J. HILL
HELP WANTED—MEN
HOUSE TO HOUSE SALESMEN
Make 50% selling New-Molene, Dr. Hollands
old fashioned ir.utton suet rub for colds.
Send 25c for cample and particular j.
UNIVERSAL REMEDIES CO., CordoU, Qa.
MISCELLANEOUS
DIESEL FOR SAW MILLS: reconditioned
“ ‘75 h. JK.
Also am
international model U-Zl, $7W
12 months; SIMMONS DIESEL A EQUIP
MENT CO., Dial 7121, Walterbora, 8. C.
ORANGES, tree
cash with order.
ZIMMERMAN, ~
ORANGES
ee ripened, $1.50 per bushel,
•der. Express collect. A. W.
, Box 251, Pinecastle, Fla.
SEE TOUR ELECTRIC LIGHT CORD in the
dark with Luminous plastic Pull whiclr
glows in the dark. Satisfaction or m
back. Mail 15c for one; 7 for $1.00. *
FURMAN
943 Edgewood - Trenton, New J*
mon @ 10c~lb. C %creen wire, galvanized, 30'
32" and 36' rolls @ 7c square foot.
C. A W. HARDWARE CO.
Hawkinsville, Ga.
rheme in.
Buy U. S. Savings Bonds!
Get Well
QUICKER
From Your Counts
Duo to a Cold
FOLEY’SiSc££
ALL-VEGETABLE
r LAXATIVE
NATURE’S REMEDY (NR) TAB-
LETS—A purely yegetable loxtriv* to
relieve constipation without the usual
griping, sickening, perturbing icnsa-
tions, and does not cause a rash. Try
NR—you will see the difference. Un
coated or candy coated—their acdoo
is depdhdable, thorough, yet gentle aa
millions of NR’a have proved. Get a
25c box and use as directed.
WIG-NIGHT ,C *UMo!rr'"
FUSSY STOMACH?
RELIEF FOR AGIO
INDIGESTION,j;
GAS AND
HEARTBURN'
mm
THE TUMMY!
I IS ASPIRIN AT ITS BEST
Beware Coughs
From Common folds
That HANG OH
Creomulsion relieves promptly because
it goes right to the seat of the trouble
to help loosen and expel germ laden
phlegm and aid nature to soothe and
heal raw, tender, inflamed bronchial
mucous membranes. Tell your druggist
to sell you a bottle of Creomulsion
with the understanding you must like
the way it quickly allays the cough
or you are to have your money bade.
CREOMULSION
for Coughs,ChestColds.BronchiHs
WNU—7
02—49
HIGH-SCHOOL GRADUATES!
NURSING
IS A PROUD
PROFESSION!
— many opportunities for graduates In
fine hospitals, public health, etc.
— leads to R. N.
— a well-prepared nurse need never ba
without a job or an income.
— open to girls under 35, high-school
graduates and college girls.
^—ask for more information
at the hospital where yon
would like to enter nursing.
| COMMUNITY
BOOSTER
Our home-town pa
per is the best ad
vertisement for our
community. Sup
port it and help