The Newberry herald and news. (Newberry, S.C.) 1884-1903, May 10, 1893, Image 1
r- <. ~-F.
B.TEPRICE $1.50 AY
5TBIHD 1865. NEWBEIPRRY, S. C.,q WEDND-,AY,MY0
3ONALSON's RWLY TO TILLIA".
.2bWW4ddent of the sate A ne GleW
n Gewraof a rsee, Or hIs Mnd
Shows the Saly of TIma-e
Beam- for Indluding hi
Namin the Bek Lbt
resensd to Pred
dent ClevelancL
jpeeial to News and Courier.]
--May &-Through the
of Mr. J. W. Bowden, editor
the Cotton Plant, The News and
is able to give the reply of
t Donaldsonto Governor Till
charges in advance of the publi
of the Cotton Plant. The an
mrof President Donaldson is clear
adido tbe point. What will the A111
iine do about it? Here is the letter:
.-RzNvnLr., S. C., May 1, 1893.
r.. Editor: In replying to Governor
THIIman's confession to having black
sId me to President Cleveland and
s~eaeson he assigns for so doing I
al not attempt. to "link" Mr. Till
as a citizen and Mr. Tillman as
bvernor, nor vice versa, but to deal
th him as man to man, recognizing
-Ahthet, -as the public will also, that if
conduct In this matter is shown to
be-tre and noble and manly It will
olyive lustre to the office which he
rand that, on the contrary, if his
' ourie has been untrue, Ignoble and un
manly his oflice as Governor will not
Abidld him from the contempt of all
tinking men.
WhenI first saw the reports in the
that the Governor of the
stebad included my name in a'black
to Mr. Cleveland I, in common
_- ith the people generally, gave but
citle'redit-tolt, but receiving nostate
from the Governor denying it I
W ehim a letter of inquiry, which
t'r6be-saw fit to ignore. I shall take
buhis blic statements, however, and
anwer them seriatim.
Hedisclaims any "reference" to my
character, or any feeling of
'aentment or desire to injure me, and
4etbeeliberately proceeds to charge
ith "betrayal" of the Alliance
"treachery to the people and to
AllIance," thus making a deadly
brut: my character and reputation.
W:read of one Joab of olden time,
k"oile maddened and blinded by
i0elasly, pursued a faithful
the King, one who was on a
Sidfon to unite and harmonize the
V1ii%nee and when he had overtaken
2hhi. this Joab, while stroking the
his victim, in great show of
op shp, thrust the cold steel under
ib._Eerhapa Governor Tll
et 'flearnthat-'to stab a
baracter, whether openly, as
i di Amas's person, or under
of sup2osed secrecy In a black
he President, means death to
-A DIRTY TRICK EXPOSE=.
- ifrst reason given by the Gov
~w~to prevent "further betrayal of
IeAlliance" is that I was repudiated
?abthe Democrney of Greenville Coun
yjetc. Sofar asmy failing tobe
eeeda delegate to the May Conven
lo aI concerned I have the records to
.-.~-sov,for they are in the hands of
heeas -honorable men as live in
Greenville County, that in caucus of
Reiformers, held just before the meet
o bg of the County Convention, a ballot
Swas taken for delegates to the State
Oonventon to bevoted for in the open
-onvention. About one-half of the
- dalots cast for me were not reported,
andstilthe number of ballots counted
Sfor:me made me an alternate, which,
according to a rule of the caucus, re
~ uired that my name be printed on the
ticketa to be used in the open Conven
tiona. Having failed, therefore, by the
counting-out process to keep me off
hieleket, it was 4discovered, In the
Convention, after a large number of
-them were distributed to the unsuspect
log members, that my name wras left
40 the tickets. This arousing suspi
-eIon in the minds of some, an investiga
hoe a.mad, and the facts as above
M atated sworn to and publisheda by the
a-testitgating committee, it was but
zataral, therefore, (and certainly noth
4hag could be more gratifying to me)
~~tmy friends with whom I had so
n~og associated in the work of reform,
-nsn he persecution that was at
tntdtowards me, should rally
- smuto asman to my support in the
~C~aeConvention. Is It not a remark
A-able position for the Governor lo put
the members of that Convention in
~.-when he states that "through the in
Sueinnce of a few Alliance men" they
Sconferred the most honorable and re
sponsible position within their gift
spnone so unworthy as he would
~'have me appear?
If there were any "presumption" in
-~.that Convention as to my being op
-.posed to the nomination of Mr. Cleve
-l-and, I was notraware of it then nor
since, till the Governor makes the bold
statement that such was the case. To
be entirely frank he makes that state
ment In the face of Indubitable proof
to the contrary, for my position to
wards Mr. Cleveland was given to the
press as early as February, 1891, and
-was printed in the newspapers all over
this8State, and in other States as well,
and I know he read my views as then
SUP!0BT OF CLEVE-A No BETRAYAL
OF THLE ALLIANCE.
The Allance gave no evidence of
~igupon my preference for Mr.
?levdaaSS betrayal of them, either
ttbat~ttme or since. Moreover the
onb.entionl voted down a resolution to
jucthe delegates to Chicago, as
'a leeords show. As to tye resolutions
~ftu~wrdSadopted condemning Mr.
Oevlsfd'Bformer administration, it
~5teremembered by delegates who
Fwith ae on the way to CJhlesgo
that I thought the resolution as expres
sive of the sense of the Convention
must have its bearing upon their ao
tion.
I went to Chicago, hot as a delegate,
to vote in the Convention, but to meet
the Democraticnationalexecutive com
mittee, in order to organize with that
committee for the work ot- the cam
paign. I associated with them "open
ly" Iconfess; most of the committee, I
believe, were supporters of Mr. Cleve
land, and the results of the Convention
indicated that there were quite a num
ber of voting delegates also. who were
In favor of his nomination. I felt then,
as I do now, that I as a free white
'South Carolina-Democrat had as much
right to mycholce of Mr. Ceveland for
the Presidency as Governor Tillman
had for his choice.
As already stated, my position for
Mr. Cleveland was well, understood
before the May Convention met. Node
mand was made upon me by that Con
vention, and I deny the charge that I
consciously deceived any one, either by
silence-or by speech. The next count
in this wonderful indictment is that I
pledged-myself if elected President of
the State Alliance not to seek any
office, etc., and this report, I am told,
is being very Industriously circulated
in Alliancecircless though It were a
fact, which it believed will, as is hoped
for by those who seek my Injury, have
the effect of breaking-the unity of the
Alliance In supporting my efforts as
its official head to build up and main.
tain the true principles of' the Order.
The exact truth is I did not seek the
nomination of the presidency of the
State Alliance, but on the contrary ex
pressed to many of those who ap
proached me on the subject that I pre
ferred to decline, and I am sure -that
every member of the State Aliance
who voted for me will bear me out In
the statement that I did not in the
slightest degree express or imply any
such pledge, nor was any such require
ment laid upon me by anyone whom
soever. I did say after my election
that I would do all within my power
to build up and advance the Interests
of the Order, which*I have done and
will continue to do.
It might be Interesting right here to
inquire of the Governor whence-comes
this new born zeal for the welfare and
safety of the Aianee on his part? I
believe that at one time he was made
President of the Edgeffeld County Al
liance, and that notwithstanding he
had published far and wide-to show
his disinterested patriotism-that he
wanted no ofce save that of a trustee
of an agricultural college, yet he did
not hesitate to embrace the first oppor
tunity to hold office of another kind.
When Alliancemen all over the State
revert to his defiance of the Order and
its principles, as he demonstrated -it at
the meeting of the State Alliance at
Spartanburg, they will no doubt look
upon his great and sudden Alliance
virtue in this case s somewhat ludi
crous and grotesque.
In the last count he charge1me with
"treachery to the people and to the
Alliance," in that I injected into the
railroad bill of '91 "two objectionable
features," viz: The right of appeal on
the part of the railroads to the Courts
and the feature of the bill which al
lowed the election of railroad commis
sioners by the General Assembly. To
any one with the information and In
telligence of a schoolboy a reply to
these charges would seem superfiuous.
Mr. Tillman when Inaugurated Gov
ernor took a solemn oath to sustain
the Constitution of this State and of
the United States. I, with every other
member of the Senate and House of
Representatives, took the same oath.
The constitution unquestionably guar
antees to the citizen the right of appeal
to the Courts, which right Is one of the
bed rocks of civil liberty, -and yet the
Governor of a great State, who has
sworn to sustain the Constitution
thereof, feels justified In proceeding
seriously and deliberately to Washing
ton and apparently under cover of
secrecy asks the chief executive of the
nation to decapitate a man who, as
State Senator, refused to betray his
trust by denying to the citizen his
rights under the Constitution-for in
its last analysis that is what this rea
son, as given to Mr. Cleveland, means.
BUNCH M'BEE AS A BooRA NG.
So far as ?elates to Bunch McBee
having suggested to me that the right
of appeal be Inserted in the bill, I have
to say that Mr. McBee never once men
tioned the matter to me, nor to the
best of my recollection did he ever dis
cuss the bill in my presence. I have
been told, by the best authority, that
the railroad men, after failing In their
efforts to defeat the bill In the House
and Senate, concurred very fully with
the Governor in his desire to deny the
right of appeal to the railroads, as that
would have rendered the whole Act
unconstitutional and consequently
nugatory.
Again, I Incurred the displeasure of
the Governor by allowing the Legisla
ture to elect the commissioners Instead
of the people. As a matter of fact I
was in favor of a clause being Inserted
In the bill to have the commissioner.
elected by the people, one every two
years, but It was thought best by some
of the Reform Senators not to do so at
that time, for the reason that there
could be no election by the people till
the next general election, and that as a
matter of necessity the Legislature
must elect as the nearest approach to
the people. It was also thought best
not to increase opposition to the pass
age of the bill by inserting that provis
ion, inasmuch as the-same Legislature
would sit the next winter, when it
would be easy to amend the Act.
In these flimsyreasons given by the
Governor for his course he again over
reached himself, for It Is well known
that the Reform Senators had a bare
majority in the Senate, and that with
out their united support no-part of the
bill could have been passed. Why did
he not blacklist them all? In this con
nection I will also state that upon all
the important bills the Reform Sena
tors held meetings and agreed upon
what they wished passed, after which
one of their number was -chosen to
take charge of the bill and conduct It
on the floor of the Senate. In this
railroad bill this duty was devolved
upon me to make all motions, offer
amendments, etc., astgreed upon. So
It will be readily understood that each
of the other Reform Senators Is as
chargeable with this crime in the Gov
ernor's sight as I am.
I have thus given the facts In this
case in refutation of the tissue of per
versions and. misstatements made in
the Governor's charges against me,
and I fedl happy in the knowledge
that there are scores of men who are
personallyavquatnted with every cir
cumstance -mentioned and who can
testify to- the facts as: I have stated
them, some of whom have already
done so by letter.
TMLXAN'S HYPOCISY.
In conclusion allow me to call atten
tion to some things that are significant
In the Governor's statement. He dis
claims a,y desire to do me harm, and
then stamps upon my character the
words "betrayal and treachery." He
says "the Alliance has nothing to do
with it, either directly or indirectly,"
and yet tries to defend his conduct to
wards its President on the ground of
his love for the Alliance.
He intimates by the mention of
Bunch McBee that I was in collusion
with the railroads and that I "ap
peared to be governed by self-interest
rather than patriotism," and yet he
will not deny that as citizen and pa
triot he told the people, when first he
asked them to make him their Gov
ernor, that the corruption and de
bauchery in the State was due to the
use of free passes by members of the
Legislature and State officials. Was it
self-interest rather than patriotism"
that governed him when after his elec
tion he re6eived more passes than per
haps anyone who preceded him? Com
mon prudence, it, would seem, as well
as self-preservation, ought to have
steered the Governor clear of Bunch
McBee. "Trly-whom the gods would
destroy they Airt mke mad."
Llstly ih i .eg1ets .nhe sessity
"whieh hasfarced- arehearsal-of these
undis0tedfacts." OfthisI -have no
doubt whatever, for I was told that
the Governor has said to - several par
ties that his letter to President Cleve
land 'was intended to be regarded as
confidential, -but as it leaked out the
necessity came upon him to explain,
and then, although the Alliance has
nothing to do !with it,-either directly
or indirectly," he winds up by taking
refuge In the sanctuary of the Reform
Movement and the Alliance. "To Cme
sar he has appealed, to Caesar he shall
go."
As to the Reform Movement I am
ready to-ompare-records with him as
to loyalty, consistency- and length of
service. In the Aluine-cause, with
which Ihave been identified from its
infancy in this State,d have worked in
its almost every departmnent. If there
is a brother-in the Order who i willing
to charge me with the betrayal of trust
or treachery to the brotherhood I amn
prepared to answer for my steward
ship. I shall willingly leave this mat
ter to the honest and discriminating
judgment of those whom Gov. Tiliman
says I have betrayed and abide by
their verdict.
M. L. DONALDSON.
Mr. Donaldson would have an
swered Governor Tiliman's charges
last week had he had the time.
A. K.
MR. DONALDSON PROMPTLY DEFRNDED
BY AN ALLIANCEMAN.
[The Cotton Plant.)
To begin.with I will state that I am
no offie-seeker, but a man who likes
to see lustice done and one who de
spises underhand doings In any way.
It Is very evident to me that there has
been an undercurrent running for some
time for the purpose of undermining
Mr. M. L. Donaldson.
Gov. Tillman says In the Cotton
Plant of April 22: "My reasons were
these, and -ag'ain they have no refer
ence to Mr. Donaldson's private char
acter, but to his public acts." Now
what does that-mnean? Mr. Donaldson's
public acts hava been very beneficial
to the State of South Carolina. There
are hundreds of men who are now
reaping the benefit of Mr. Donaldson's
forethought In getting the stock law for
South Carolina. He knew at the time
when he voted as he did he was hurt
ing himself politically for the time
being, but knew that he was doing his
duty, and like a man he did it.
I know men now who were against
the passage of the istock law who
would not have it repealed now for
anything.
If the Allancemen of South Caro
lina allow dust to be thrown in their.
eyes regarding the standing of their
trusted and honored President I for
one will feel ashamed of them.
I voted for TilImanin both elections,
butif he takes the ground he has done
towards the State President, although
I beas agrain of sand upon the sea
shore, yet I will vote no more for him.
I am- almost sure there are men in
South Carolina who are jealous of Mr.
Donaldson and have started mud
slinging and then got behind the fence
to watch the result. I am alluding to
no one, for I do not know who is or
has been at it, yet I think it the case.
Whoever t may be ought to be thor
oughly ashamed of themselves, and
they will when the people find them
out.
There are hundreds of men in South
Carolina who know Mr. Donaldson
and respect him. It was through foul
play that Mr. Donaldson was not
elected delegate; his votes were never
counted, Is my belief. Men of Green
ville County. keep your eyes open and
your ears also, and as the old man who
was snoring on board the cars, and
when told so raked how the passengers
kdew he wae snoring. They told him
because they heard him. His answer
was, "Don't believe everything you
hear."
Always believe In right and justice,
I am a true Democrat.
A. L. EUBANK.
Travelers' Rest, S. C.
NO MORE TO SAY.
(The State, 5t1i.1
Governor Tillman, when asked yes
terday if he would make reply to
President Donaldson's statement, said
he did not see anything in it to reply
to, and he would therefore have noth
ing more to say on the subject.
THE ASSISTANT BISHOP.
Rev. Dr. ElIlIson Capers Elected to 1igh
Bonors in the Episcopal Church.
CHARLEsTON, S. C., May 4.-The
vote for the assistant bishopric in the
Diocesan Convention to-day resulted
In the election of the Rev. Dr. Ellison
Capers. The ballot was held at noon,
and without nominating speeches.
The vote was as follows: Clerical vote
-The Rev. Ellison Capers, 17; the Rev.
R. E. Barrett, Atlanta, 7; the Rev. T.
W. Winchester, Virginia, 3; the Rev.
John Kershaw, 2; the Rev. A. M.
Smith, 1; the Rev. T. D. Bratten, 1;
the Rev. Joseph Carey, 1; the Rev. J.
S. Lindsay, Boston, 1. Of the 4,8
parishes 35 voted for Dr. Capers, 3 for
Kershaw,.. I for Dr. Barrett, I for the
Rev. C. C. Pinckney, 1 for the Rev.
John Johnson, 1 for the Rev. John
Eliott of Washington, 2 for Dr. Brat
ten. Three parishes divided.
Dr. Ellison Capers, the new assistant
Bishop of the diocese, was born in
Charleston, and is a son of the late
Bishop Capers. He received his early
education at the Methodist High
School at Cokesbury, in Abbeville
County. He was graduated from the
Citadel Academy in November, 1857.
ind after his giaduation be accepted
the place of assistant instructor at the
Citadel. When the war came he was
elected Colonel of the Twenty-fourth
South Carolina Regiment. His career
in the Western army was very distin
guished, and upon the death of Gen.
Stevens he was made Brigadier-Gen
era! of Stevens' brigade.
At the close of the war he was elected
Secretary of the State of the provisional
Government in 1865.
Following the bent of his mind, he
shortly afterward entered the ministry,
and filled the pastorate of the Episco
pal church in Greenville for several
years. He then removed to Alabama,
but returned to Greenville at the earn
est request of his congregation. He. is
now rector of Trinity church, Colum
bia.
BISHOP CAPERS' SALARY FIxED.
LSpecial to The State.1
CHaARLETON, May 5.-The Diocesan
Convention adjourned to-day, after
fixing the salary of the Bishop at $2,000
and that of the Assistant Bishop
at $4,000. Trinity church, Columbia,
was selected as the place or meeting
for the next convention, on the second
Wednesday. in May, 1894. Bishop
elect Capers preached at St. Phillip's
church Sunday..
"MIND YOUR OWVN BUSINEsS."
The Insolent Message Sent to the Chief
Executive of the Nation by Gov
ernor Pennoyer of Oregon.
POETLAND, Oregon, May 3.-The fol
lowing telegraphic correspondence to
day passed between Secretary of State
Gresham and Governor Pennoyer:
WASHINGTON, May 3.-Governor
Sylvester Pennoyer, the Capitol, Salem,
Oregon: Apparently reliable reports
Indicate danger of violence to the Chi
nese when the exclusion act takes effect,
and the President earnestly hopes you
will employ all lawful means for their
protection in Oregon.
W. Q. GEESHAM.
")[MID YOUR OWN BUSINESS."
Governor Pennoyer immediately sent
the following reply:
S ALEr, Ore., May 3.-W. Q. Gres
ham, Washington, D. C.: I will attend
to my own business. Let the President
attend to his.
SYLVEsTER PENNOYER, Governor.
"AN INSULT TO OREGON."
Governor Pennoyer, In speaking to a
reporter, said: "Gresham's telegram is
an insult to Oregon. 1 will enforce the
laws of the State, and the President
should enforce the laws of Congress. It
comes with poor grace for the President
to ask me to efiforce the law, while he,
without warrant, suspends the exclu
sion law."
Hood's Cures.
In saying that Hood's Sarsaparilla
cures, Its proprietors make no idle or
extravagant claim. Statements from
thousands of reliable people of what
Hood's Sarsaparilla has.done for them,
conclusively prove the fact-HOOD'S
Barapaill CBES.
HooD's PILLs act especially upon
the liver, rousing It from torpidity to
its natural duties, cures constipation
a.nd asstst diesation.
A STREET FIGHT IN COLUMBIA.
Mr. Calvo, of The Register, Strikes Mr. N.
G. Gonzales, of The State, who Responds
Very EmphaticaMy-A Storm of
Blows, but Neither Seriou-y
Hurt.
[Special to News and Courier.j
COLUMBIA, May 4.-Mr. N. G. Gon
zales, editor of The State, and Mr.
Charles A. Calvo, the proprietor of The
Register, had a totally unexpected en
counter- to-night about 9 o'clock in
Main street, as a result of which both
have braised eyes. No serious bodily
damage was done to either.
The encounter took place almost in
front of Palmer's tin and stove est4b
lishment, on the right side of Main
street, between the offices of the two
newspapers, about fifty or seventy-five
yards from the Register office. Nothing
was said during the encounter that
would indicate the casus belli. Mr.
Calvo attacked Mr. Gonzales.
It was some time after the difficulty
that anything became generully known
about it on the streets. Mr. Gonzales
says it was a novel experience for him.
He was on his way up the street from
Capt. R. S. Desportes' residence when
he passed a man at the point named.
The man .had some papers under his
arm. He did not notice him beyond
this, thinking of something else at the
time. His attention, he says, was at
tracted by the falling of some papers,
and in a moment afterwards the man
he had nassed uttered some unintelli
gible words and savagely attacked him
from behind. He says the assault was
totally unexpected by him. As soon as
he recovered somewhat, he states, he
was about to force Mr. Calvo down
when a man came from across the street
and caught his right arm. He did not
recognize Mr. Calvo until he grappled
with him. The stranger who caught
him was Engineer Jack Smith, of the
Richmond and Danville Road. While
he was being held, Mr. Gonzales says,
he had to try and defend himself with
his left arm.
A you'ng son of Mr. Calvo came up
about this time and also proceeded to
strike Mr. Gonzales. He says he de
manded Mr. Smith to release him, and
the youth said that he had only come
to defend his father and if Mr. Gon
zales would desist his father would.
Mr. Smith released Mr. Gonzales and
led Mr. Calvo off, the latter saying
something about the former difficulty
they had five years ago.
Mr. Gonzales says he cannot imag
ine why he was attacked, unless it wast
on account of an editorial he wrote
some days ago characterizing a state
ment in the Register about the farmers
attending the Carnival as an attempt
to make the Columbia Conservatives
surrender their manhood or submit to
a boycott of their business interests.
Mr. Gonzales says he considers the
attack "a cowardly one, being made
from behind in the dark, and is sorry
hie was prevented from giving Mr-.
Calve a lesson in the decency of fair
play."
Such is Mr. Gonzales's statement of
the affair.
Mr. Calve's statement agrees with
that of Mr. Gonzales in all the :nain
facts as to the fig~ t, but he says he at
tacked him fo:n the front when he
met him. He frankly states that he
was the attacking party, and says that
when he met the man who had been
insulting him through his paper for
the past yearbis blood boiled within
him, and he could not resist the im
pulse to personally attack him.
All the parties concerned have been
summoned to appear before the Mayor's
Court to-morrow morning to answer
the charge of disorderly conduct.
In giving the above account of the
affair I have endeavored to give only
the facts as I could gather them as a
disinterested party.
*E. J. WATsoN.
EDITOR KOESTER'S ACCOUNT.
COLUMBIA, May 4.-C. A. Calve, Jr.,
proprietor of The Register. met N. G.
Gonzales, editor of The State, at 9.30
o'clock this evening a few yards from
the Register office. Gonzales had
passed and repassed the Register office,
an unusual proceeding for him, espe
cially at that hour of the night, and
calculated to inspire the idea that he
was hunting the proprietor or editor of
the Register.
Mr. Calve is a man of high courage,
and when he met his detractor his
anger rose, and dropping the night's
mail (which according to habit he was
brInging to the office) he stepped in
front of Gonzales and saying, "You
-- - --," struck Gonzales in the
face, breaking his glasses and cutting
his face. Gonzales struck Cslvo in the
face, under the eye. Calve replied
with two more blows, and Gonzales,
who weighs at least forty or fifty
pounds more than Calve, clinched
with him and came near forcing him
through the glass window. Calve
freed his hand, and again struck Gon
zales in the face.
Mr. Jack Smith, an old man, rushed
in to separate them. Mr. Calve's
young son, who was standing in front
of the office, saw the fight and rushed
up.; Thinking Smith was helping
Gonzales he assisted his father. Gon
zales, who had cried for help, yelled
that it was not fair for two to attack
one. The boy replied that he (Gon
zales) was fighting his father, and he
would help him. The pair were sepa
rated.
Calve came to his office, attended to
his business and returned home. He
was summoned to attend the Mayor's
Court in the morning. -He will admit
having attacked Gonzales.
It is said that Gonzales claimed that
(Cale attacked him from ~the rear.
This is not true. The attack was en
tirely unpremeditated on Calvo's part,
nor did he know that Gonzales or his
son were anywhere near. -
GEORGE B. KOESTER.
CALVO PAYS $20.
LSpecial to News and Courier.j
COLUMBIA, May .5.-Messrs N. G
Gonzales and Chas. A. Calvo, Jr., ap
peared before Mayor Fisher this morn
ing in response to a summons. Mr.
Calvo acknowledged attacking Mr.
Gonzales, whereupon he was fined $20,
which was paid and the case dismissed.
The matter is thought to be at an end.
Every Why Hath a Wherefore.
Mr. Editor:-The following essay
was read before the Luther Alliance of
Luther Chapel by Mr. H. A. McCul
lough and so pleased all who heard it
that.he was requested to give his con
sent for publicatiorr, which he did:
Far back ia-Shakspeare's time we
hear the servant Dormio exclaiming,
Hold, sir; stop, I beseech you, pray you
sir, why am I thus beaten. And the
master Antipholus answered, Dost
thou not know? Nothing sir, but that
I am beaten. Shall I tell you why?
Ay, sir, and wherefore; for they say
every why bath a wherefore. The
master said the why is for flouting with
me, and the wherefore for urging it the
econd time.
Thus we see our sentence was ut
tered by .a man in an unpleasant
situation, so it is repeated by a man.of
like passions and desires. Now I ex
elaim to the committee, Hold, I beseech
you, why have 3 ou thus placed me?
But I suppose they would answer, dost
thou not know? I'say nothing, but that
I am here. Thus - they say, shall we
tell you why? And I answer, Ag,
mnesdames, and wherefore; for they say
every Why bath a wherefore. But
they will say the why is for flouting
with the subject, and the wherefore
for urging it the second time.
This sentence is not only pernicious
to the whites, but also throws the good
ld darkey out of his equilibrium, and
auses him to say what mortal'man
never wished to say; yet as bold as an
postle he will withstand her to the
face. This sentence was once given on
% public examination for school teach
ing to diagram and parse. And of
,nurse the impetuous old darkey at once
eaped upon it with both feet that he
might conq,uer it before it got away.
And this sbis mode of procedure:
"Every is de subject, cause it tells te
number of dem whys, and must always
be kept on the line. Why is de prepo
5ition, 'cause it tells what de people
think, and should stand close by de
5ubject. Hath is dem compliments,
cause it 'grees wid de subject in de mas
mulin gender, and should come on.a
broken line near de end. Doth is de
monstrons pronoun, 'cause it stands
next to de wherefore, and should be
put upon an infinitive frase. De where
fore is de interjection, 'cause it 'spresses
strong or sudden feelings, and should
come down on a'lebel wiid de subject."
After he had thus diagramed and parsed
is sentence be hermetically sealed his
paper, handed it to the examining com
mittee trusting in Provideinee to bring
him through.
Froni a psychological view, every
event has a cause, which is equivalent
to say every why hath a wherefore.
This term is applicable to our Christian
Alliance: the Alliance is the wby and
the object we had in view in organizing
is the wherefore. And if we abese th'e
why, we also abuse the wherefore, or
if we erase the why we have no where
fore; or .erase the wherefore and the
why is superfluous. And as They are
so important and inseparable, let us
foster them as a mother her infant,
knowing that the Alliance is intrusted
to us, the young people of the church;
and if we pale her fair name we are re
sponsible for both the why and the
wherefore. So we should be zealous
and cautious and learn a lesson from
the kind old darkey, viz., to keep the
subject on the line. And not to be
sacrilegious at all, but simply deviate
a little, we may get another impor tant
phase from our subject. To be or not
to be, that is the question. Or to love
or not to love, that is the watchword
with the young. To love and to be
loved is a why with a glorious where
fore, but to love and not be loved is a
why without a wherefore; he is like
the old darkey's compliments, he is on
a broken line. Let us for a '.moment
assume that the boys are the whys and
the girls the wherefores, and how nice
the sentence reads: every why hath a
wherefore. While this may not be
applicable to all, it is surely true with
some present. It is often the case
where two boys are rooming together
for one to be taken and the other left.
Now let us reneat our sentence and
close. The boys are the whys and the
girls the where fores. The superstitious
old darkey said, "de why is de preposi
tion, cause it tells what de people think,
and the wherefore is the interjection
'spressing strong or sudden feelings."
So we are the preposition and shall tell
you what we think, and you are the
interjections and must express to us
your strong and sudden feelings. And
fnally we shall teal our lives as the old
darkey did his paper, and stand before
a committee to be examined and trust
in Providence that they may bring us
through.
Bessie H. Bedloe, Burlington, Vt.,
bad a disease of the scalp, causingr her
bair to become very harsh and dry, and
to fall so freely that she scarcely dared
to comb it. Ayer's Hair Vigor gave
er a healthy scalp, removed the dan
Iruff, and made the hair thick and
glossy.
WILL THEY LYNCH JERVEYf
The Solicitor of the Second Circuit Declares
his Disinclination to Prosecute the Lyn
chers Because his Relatives ars Prob
ably Implicated in the Crime, and
Suggests that Solicitor Jervey
be Entrusted with
that Duty.
[Special to News and Courier.]
COLUMBIA, May 4.-The "Denmark
outrage" has a sequel. It has ,given
Governor Tiilman an oppotunity for
a bit of irony and to "payback in coin"
for a statement made it a mass meet
ing. Had not-Solicitor Jervey spoken
at the meeti6g here it is pretty safe to
say that nothing woald have ever been
beard of the present turn in the case".
For some unaccountable reason Gov
ornor Tillman has come'to the conclu
sion that there is reason "to prosecute
a whole people and make a farce of the
trial" An order was to-dayjent to the
able solicitor of the 1st circuit. Mr,
Jervey, to take hold of the prosecution
of the Denmark lynching cases. It
locks very much like a fixed-up job,
but no doubt Mr. Jervey will look after
his laurels and take hold of the matter
and do the best he can. So far as is
known there has never been just such
a proceeding in the history of the
State.
BELLINGER'S SPECIOUS LETTER.
Here is the letter of Solicitor Bell;n
ger to Governor Tillman. It is worth a
careful study:
BAXNWELL C.H., May 3, 1893.
To His Excellency, Governor B. R.
Tillman, Columbia, S. C.-Dear Sir: I
desire to call your attention officiafly
to the recent lynching at Denmark in
c-nnection with the following state
ment: So far no warrant has been sworn
out by any one against any- person sup.
posed to be connected with the affair,
and the proceedings and verdict of the
jury of inquest give .no information
upon which the prosecution can be
begun.
Under these circumstances, if the
case is to receive 'that investigation
which its gravity seems. to require, it
becomes the duty of the Executive
officer to institute pr'ceedings in the
premises,
. Inasmuch as the violation of the law
was-committed in-, community in
which I have many relatives and con
nections"it is not improbable that some
of them were implicated,' especially
when it is stated that the. entire com
munity was engaged in the enterprise.
Such being the case any effort on my
part to bring the. perpetrators to jus
tiee Weal1beemlisrriisiig i'tn
probably lay me open to the charge of
partiality and insincerity.
I would, therefore, respectfully' re
quest that your Excellency - would
charge the solicitor of one of the ad
joining cir:uits to take charge of the
case, and would suggest that Solicitor
Jervey, whose circuit adjoins this
county and who probably best under
stands the situation, could give the
matter satisfactory attention.
Assuring you that I shall be ready
at any time to render such service as
the case and my-office requires, I am
very respectfully,
G.. DUNCAN BELLINGEE,
Solicitor of the 2nd Circuit.
THINKS HE HAS JEEVEY IN-A HOLE.
Just before leaving the offie Ge
ernor Tillman prepared this spicy let
ter to Solicitor .Tervey:
COLMiBIA, May 4, 1893.'
Hon. W. St. J1. Jervey, Charles
ton, S. 0.-Sir: I am in receipt of a
letter from Mr. G. Duncan Bellin
ger, solicitor of the 2nd' circuit, in
which he states that by reason of the
fact that his relatives and conIactions
are probably implicated in the l ecent
unfortunate affair at Denmark'i"ny
efforts on his part to bring the perpe
trators to justice wodd he embarrass
ing and probably 'ay him open to thie
charge of partiality and insincerity.".
He, therefore, asks me to direct the
solicitor of one of the adjoining cir
cuits to take charge of the case arrd
prosecute the persons who have over
ridden the law. He further suggests
yourself, and I therefore direct you to
proceed to Denmark -at your earliest
convenience for the purpose of thor
oughly investigating the outbreak and
taking the necessary steps to vindicate
the law and punish the lyncbers.
I comply with Mr. Bellinger's re
quest the more readily bccause your
well-known zeal and legal ability give
assurance that you will do your whole
dt.Yours, very respectfully,
B. B. TIhLMAN, Governor.
P. S.-Mr. Bellinger will of course
take your place in any work in your
own circuit which may interfere with
your compliance with this order. .
Governor Tiliman referred Solicitor
Bellinger's letter to the Attorney-Gen
eral's office and received a report to
the effect that he had the right to
order the change. .The law on which
the Governor basis his Grder is:
Section 511. Solicitors shall do the
duty of the Attorney-General, and
ive their counsel and advice to the
Governor and other State officers in
matters of public concern whenever
they shal'l be by them required so to
do, and assist the Attorney-General or
each other in all suits and prosecutions
in behalf of this State, when directed
so to do by the Governor or called
upon by t' .e Attorney-General. They
may defend any person brought to
trial before any criminal Court of tiis
State when their duty shall not re
quire them to prosecute such persons,
or their assistance be not required
against such person by the Governor
or Attorney-General.
sOLICITOR JEEVEY PREFEBS TO SEE
THE GOVERNOR'S OEDER BEFORE
EXPEESSING HIMSELF.
OEANGEBUEG, May 30.-Solicitor
Jervey, who has-been drawn into the
Denmark outrage by Governor Till
man, left Orangeburg this -evening for
Charleston. He was seen at the depot
before leaving here and said that al
though he had heard of the Governor's
action, he was not prepared at that
time to state what he would do. He
proposed to see Governor Tillman'
rder before he outlined his erse. n's
THE MIRACLE OF TH5 NILE.
A Sterile Desert Transformed at its Oyer
flw Into a Fruitful Paradlse.
[From London Natuij
By no one, perhaps, haye the.l.
pressions produced by the vrii
phases of the river been so poetical
'described as by Osburn, who thus de
scribes the low Nile:
"The Nile has shrunk within
banks until its stream is contracted to -
half its ordinary dimensions, andi it
turbid, slimy, stagnant waters scarcely,A
seem to flow in any direction. Broad
flats or steep banks of black, sun-baked
Nile mud form both the shores of the
river. All beyond them is sand and
sterility, for the hamseen, or said
wind of fifty days' duration, has se
ly yet ceased to blow. The trunks and"
branches of trees may be seen here
and there through. the dusty, hazy
burning atmosphere, but so entirely
are their leaves coated with dust,t
at a distance they are not distinguish- -
able from the desert sand thaf sur
rounds them. It is only by the mo
painful and laborious operatidn
watering that any tint appri
to greenness can be preserved .07R: -
season' even in the pleasure gardens
Pasha. The first symptom of theted..
rible season is the rising of thanoth
wind (the Etesian wind of the.Greek&'
blowing briskly, often fiercelyd
the whole of theday. The1oliUeiof
the groves that cover Lower Egypt 1S
soon disencumbered by it of the du
and resumes its verdure. The Aeref
fervors of the son, then at his,hig,bes -'
ascension, arealso mostseasonablymlt
igated by the same powerful agency
which prevails for this and the t
following months throughout the6n
tire land of Egypt."
Then at last comes the inundation
"Perhaps there is not in nat
more exhilarating sight, or one m
strongly exciting to confidencein Godj
than the rise of the Nile. Day by.diy
and night by night its turbid
sweeps onward majestically over ihi
parched sands of the waste, hoW
wilderness. Almost hourlyas
slowly ascended it before the.
wind, we heard the thundering
some mud bank, and sai by,t
of all animated nature to thei
the Nile had. overleapt' ano
struction, and that it%b6ondi
were diffusing life and joy thght
another desert There are fewnmpie
sions lever received upon te -
brance of which I -welf
pleasure thandhaaf seewg
.burst of theNilbeUto-oneo
channels di its annual overow.
niAture shouts for joy. The men, te1
ihliaen, the buffaloes, gambol:
refresting waters, the broad WavMf;
sparkle witi shoals of fish, and _0
every wing fltir'over themin
Nor is this jubilei iature edi.
to the higher orders'of crE&tion. Th
moment the sand becomes rbse~~
by the approach of they feti+ an
waters, it is literally alive with'
innumerable. It is impossible tosdi
by the side of one of these 0e
streams, to see it every modm4nt:
swereping away some obstructiontoits
majestic course, and widening as jt
flows, without feeling the heart to er
pand with love and joy andcofen>
~iau he. great Author of this 'andel -
miracle of mercy -" ~-~
The effects of the inundat'i'on
burn shows in andther place, "ehihit -
themselves in a scen'e of fertility and --
beauty such -as will scarcely be found
in another country at any season of
the year-the vivid green of thesp'ring-*
ing corn, the groves of pomegranate T
trees ablaze with the rich scarlet of
their blossoms, She fresh breeze laden ---
with perfumes of gardens of roses and
orange thickets, every tree and every
shrub covered with sweetrscented
flowers. . These are a few of the nat
ural beauties that welcome the stranger
to the land of Ham. There is consid
erable sameness in thiem, it is true, for
he would observe little variety in the
trees and plants, whether he first en
tered Egypt by the gardens.of Alexan
dria or the plain of Assouan. Yet~ is 1
the same everywhere, only bicause
would be impossible to 'make any
addition to the sweetness of the odors,
the brilliancy of the colors or the ex
quisite beauty of the many 'forms of
vegetable life, in the midst of which he
wanders. It is monotonous, but it is
the monotony of paradise.
"The flood reaches Cairo on a day
closely approximating to that of the
solstice. .it attains its greatesd heighit
and begins to decline near the autum
nal equinox. By thie win'ter solstice
the Nile has again subsided within its
banks and resumed its blue color. Seed
time has occurred in this intervaL The
year in Egypt divides itself into'three
seasons-four months of sowing and
grow th, correspondirig nearly with our
November, December, January, and
February ; four months ofia
from March to June ; the four months
of the inundation completing the
cycle.'
MI Am so Tired"
Is a common exclamation at .this sea
son. There is a certain bracing effeet
in cold air which is lost when .the
weather grows -warmer; and when
Nature is renewing her youth, -her ~
admirers feel dull, sluggish and tired.
This condition is owing -mainly toth.~
impure condition of the blood; and k.
failure to supply healthy tissue tht
various -organs of the body. It is
markabli how susceptible the system
is tothe help tobe derived from agood
medicine at this season. P
just those purifying, bniding-uip quali -
ties which the body craves, Hood a
Sarsaparilla soon overcomes that tr
feeling, restores- the appetiepuis
the blood, and, in short, imprsvp
ous health. its thousands of
as with one voicedeclare "Iiu
Weak Strong."