The Newberry herald and news. (Newberry, S.C.) 1884-1903, September 03, 1891, Image 1
ESTA-BLISHIED'1865. NEWBERRY, S. C., THURSDAY,_SEPTE.MBE3,19.___PRC$L0AYA
DEFECTS OF THE DEMANDS.
A Dispassionate Discussion of the Ocala
Platform-Some Practical Suggestions
it Would be Well for the Peo
ple to Consider for
Themselves.
[Prof. R. Means Davis, in the Winnsboro News
and Herald, August 25.1
I have read with interest the Ocala
platform, printed in your columns at
the request of the Blythewood Alliance.
As you say, it raises burniag questions,
and should be read with the greatest
care, not only by All voters, but by all
who have a cent of property or an iota
of patriotism. It will not do either to
accept or reject these demands as a
whole without earnest study of them.
Some of them raise issues that have
been inooted a long time and are still
unsettled problems among the leading
economists and statesmen of the world.
I propose simply to ask some ques
tions in order to attract attention to the
significance of these demands. Each
reader of your paper can answer the n
for himself.
(A.) After all is not government a
compromise? There is scarcely any
good measure without its attendant evil,
a truth that becomes more apparent the
more it is studied, %nd the wisest legis
lation is that which secures as much
good with as little evil as possible. More
than this cannot be expected. The
statesmen who is cock sure on any
measure often meets with disappoint
ment when theory is put into prac
tiee.
National banks have their good points
and their bad ones. For those who de
sire a redeemable bank carrency, the
system of national banks is the best
that has ever been devised in this coun
try. It was copied from the New York
law, and it might be applied to this
State, if Congress would abolish the
tax on State State bank circulation
Its power to control the money market
is rather an Incident of capital than of
special form of banking. The repeal of
the tax on State banks would destroy
the monopoly, without closing the
banks as banks of deposit.
The redemption of United States
bonds is rapidiy reducing national bank
circulation, so that their bills are even
now but a small part of our currency,
and will probably ere long practically
disappear, thus removing the obnoxious
"feature" altogether. Then arises the
question whether the system, guarded
as it is against fraud by stringent laws,
might be retained for the deposit and
discount business- Should it be swept
away before good State banks are es
tablished? For it must be remembered
that those people who are not so fortu
nate as to come in under the sub-treas
ury plan must have somewhere else to
borrow from.
(B.) Can the Government loan money
at 2 per cent. when individuals cannot
without loss? Who must bear the loss?
The people at large?. But the people at
large are not allowed to borrow. Must
they bear loss where they reap no bene
fit? Why then not let everybody in the
land borrow on the same terms? If I
have a gin factory full of gins, ought
not I to have the right to raise money
on them as well as on the cotton that
gces through them? Ought not the
merchant be allowed to borrow on his
stock of goods in order to tide over a
tight time instead of pressing pay at 10
12per cent. when the Government, or
which is his Government as much as
anybody else's is supplying his neigh
bor at 2 per.cent? If I teach school, or
sit on a jury, and receive a warrant on
the county treasurer which is empty,
because the people are not ready to pay
taxes, ought not the Government to
discount this public claim as well as
advance money on private property? Is
a "plan" that does'nt cover all these clas
ses of persons consistent with that fun
damental and best plank of the whole
platform, "Equal right to all and special
privileges to none?" Is the pria-ilege of
bor-owing at 2 per cent., when an
equally estimable neighbor has to pay
]0 or 12 for his loan, a special privilege
or not?
I ask nothing about the practical
working of the sub-treasury plan, for I
have not been able to learn exactly
what the plan is that is now advocated
instead of the bill.
(C.) Why should we demand $50 per
. capita in United States currency? Is
t his to be in addition to the S1,000,000,
000 advanced through the sub-treasu
ries? Howv shall all this money be
kept in circulation after the farmers
pay back their loans to the Govern
ment? If, as is 'claimed, the pre' of
commodities depends on the amount ot
money in circulation, will a cow be
worth $100 in the fall, when all this
money is afloat, and only $50 in the
spring, when half this elastio currency
has been covered back Into the treasury?
This is a very pretty question.
If England, the richest country in the
world, gets along with about $2 a head,
why do we need more than twice as
much? Why should the relation any
how be between dollars and men, in
stead of between dollars and business?
Do 9,000 colored rice hands on our coast
need as many dollars as the same num
her of men in trade in Charleston or
New York?
What allowance may be made for the
use of banik checks as money? Is it
true that only 3 per cent. of trade in
England, and 8 per cent. in the United
States is transacted in money, and the
rest of the checks and book settlement?
- Does this teach that, iznstead of much
more Government money we need
many more good banks in which peo
ple may make deposits and check
against tV-mn, allowing one check to
pass through several transactions, by
which means the people can regulate
their own business without calling on
the Government to stretch its powers to
a very dangerous extent, and can secure <
practically that elastic medium which I
the Government cannot furnish, it
seems, without going into the broker- j
age business?
2. The trade in futures has been car
ried to a great excess and has often I
iNjured business. So far as it is used for
purely speculative purposes, it is a great
curse. Be t is the evil inherent in the
system itself, or is it but an incident?
What special harm is there in a farm
er's making a contract with a buyer to I
sell his crop to him in the fall at a fixed
rate? Shall a farmer be prevented from t
securing advances in Charleston on the I
promise of shipping so many bales at t
such a price, and then, if heprefers,pav
ing the price instead of delivering the
cotton? Shall a manufacturer not be per.
mitted to contract to deliver a certain
number of bales of cloth to China in
six months? These are in principle pre
cisely the same as the transactions on
Wall street.
There may be a sharp set of rascals
in Wall street, but may there not be an
equally sharp set of rascals, perhaps,
with antagonistic interests to watch
them? Each crowd has its corrospond
ents through the land gathering crop
statistics. Between the two most accu
rate reports are obtained. And the
Fairfied farmer can, if he inquires,
learn as much about the crop as any
body else. The price, after all in the
long run is regulated by demand and
supply. Sometimes the yield baffles all
calculation, as, for instance, this year;
but it can easily be seen how muci
wider the speculation would have been t
if there had not been this systematic
collection of statistics. Years ago there
was at least fifteen cents a pound differ
ence in the price of cotton at Winns- t
boro and New York. What is the t
difference to-day? When we choke off i
the "gamblers" we throw the burden of I
collecting facts on the Government, or
on the producers th2mselves, who have (
other work to do. It costs money to
get crop reports and the people must
pay either directly by tax or subscrip
tion, or indirectly through prices. Fur
thermore, in view of the present great
glut of cotton, is it not probable that
the price is kept where it is only be- I
cause a lot of speculators have been
caught in future and are bulling the
maket to save themselves from ruin?
Otherwise, there is no special reason
why cotton now on hand should be
sold at all. Here is proof again, it seems
that even an evil often has its compen
sating good.
To prevent the sale of.futures alto
gether would be to paralyze all credit
transactions, for unless the law be so
absolutely bombproof as to prevent all
future sales whatever, it will find some
loophole for escape. It Is a dangerous
stretch of power in a government to tell
a man he shalt not buy anything for
future delivery. Laws, too, may be
imperative, but unless upheld by pub
lie opinion, juries will not enforce them.i
Would it not be better to endeavor
to regulate such sales than forbid
them?
3. The present Silver Act of C" gress
does these things: First, it keeps the I
silver dollar on a par with the gold I
dollar, when the bullion in it is 25 cents I
cheaper. Second, it adds about $70,
000,030 a year to our currency. Third,
it uses all the silver that is mined in
this country. Fourth, it gives the Gov
ernment, that is the public at large, all
the profit arising from coining 7.5 cents
worth'of silver bullion into a dollar
coin. What is there in all this to
"condemn?" Suppose the free coinage
of silver, which is "deman.ded" would
take the profit of coinage from the publc
and give it to the silver miners, and
allow Europe and Mexico to "dump"
their surplus silver over here at a big
profit and then run the risk of having
our gold leave the country, a lot of sil-1
ver dollars remaining with us, which
the world refuses to consider as worth a
dollar when we go to pay for our im
ports, would this be a much better law1
than the one that has been "con
demned?" This is what very many of
the world, even ot those who are not
"goldbugs," believe would be the effect
of free coinage of silver in the United
States.
4. Alien ownership of land is becom
ing an evil, that is to say, ownership of
large tracts of land. We afy consider
whether it is better to ihave no market
for land or to sell it to some foreigner.
For instance, is it better to leave the
Catawba water power undeveloped or
sell it to an English syndicate? Had
we rather do without a railroad in
Fairfied than allow foreign capital to
build and own it? If an Englishman
comes along and offers you ten dollars
an acre for a farm which you have been
uable to sell to a fellow-citizen for
five dollars wvould you think the law
forbidding alien ownership of land a
good or a bad thing? After a syndicate
had developed Catawba Falls would
you be willing to tax yourself to enable
the State to acquire it by sale from
alien owners? Do you desire to in
crease your taxes to enable the General
Government to "take possession" of
millions of acres of alien and railroad
lands in Colorado and Wyoming? This
is what the fourth "demand" means.
1It is well to understand it.
15. The fifth plank is admirable in
gneral and in detail. It condemns
class legislation, the fostering of one in
dustry at the expense of others, and a
high tariff; and it demands agraduated
inome tax and economical govern
ment.
1The only objection to an income tax
is that people will not tell the truth to
the ta'ngaI haer, and cannot be caught
at their fibs. This is a very deplorable
charge, but is almost fatal to the plan.
>ur incomes truthfully? If there is any
heating, the biggest rascal gets off the
ightest.
6. The demand for Government su
)ervision of railroads is ajust one. They
njoy great privileges and owe a proper
ervice to the public. The value of all
he railroads in the Union is put at
bout $9,000,000,000 this year. The cen
us of 18SO gave the value of all in the
Jnion at $10,000,000,C0o. Their pres
nt value I have not seen stated. It
an be seen, however, that to purchase
he roads, therefore, would require al
nost the full farm values of the coun
ry. At 3 per cent the interest on this
>urchase would be $270,00,000. Would
he railroads after paying all costs of
nanagement, return this? How many
ailroads pay dividends to-day? Would
hey bring more money to the Govern
nent than to the stockholdors, when
he object of owning then is to make
ates cheaper? Would the Government
ppoint managers for business or po
itical reasons and change them with
very election? Would the South Caro
ina Republican leaders manage our
oads better than Inman, McBee or
tndrews? Which of these would Har
ison appoint.
7. Why should United States Sena
ors be elected directly by the peop:e?
o prevent bribery and corruption, of
ourse. Will this evil be prevented by
browing the election into the hands
>f the people? In what way? When
tanford or Jones or Stewart wants a
eat in the Senate, it matters little to
im whether he buys enough votes at
he polls to elect him directly or enough
o elect legislators who will elect him
ndirectly. If a voter will send a bribe
aker to the Legislature, what will pre
ent him from sending a bribe giver to
he United States Senate? The elec
ion of Harrison, it is claimed, came
brough a purchase of voters at the
olls, not of Presidential electors. Stan
ord must now control the whole State
if California. It would be easier and
:heaper for him to be able to confine
is efforts to his own election alone.
:s it not easier to corrupt a State nomi
iating convention, whose members as
emble for a day and then di.solve,
han to corrupt a Legislature? Where
)ublic opinion sanctions corruption
Loes it matter in what form the elec
ion comes?
If any one examines the Constitution
nd the debates of the Constitutional
Jorvention he will see that the pro
rision regarding Senators is a funda
nental feature of our Government.
[he Senate represents the State in its
:orporate capacity, the House repre
ents the people. The State elects
rough its Legislature, the people
hoose their representatives directly.
he seventh demand of the Ocala plat
lrm would wipe out this recognition
>f State rights. Is it worth while to
nake this change when there is no cer
ainty of attainining the desired end,
which is to secure a purer form of elect
ng Senators?
Let me not be understood as oppos
ng all the measures to which I bree
hown objections. But since there aae
o many orators engaged in portraying
he brightest features of the Ocala plat
orm, it is well for some one to call at
ention to some of its possible defects.
HARRISON ON THE~ SOUTH.
The President Prepares to Wave the
Bloody Shirt.-A Speech to the
People or Vermont.
MONTPELLIER, Vermont, Aug.26.
resident Harrison spent the night at
it. Albans and reached here at 11
'clock this morning. He was intro
luced to the Assembly, which was in
ession, and spoke briefly in acknow
edgment of his welcome. He spoke at
~reater length to an open air assemn
>lage.
The following is an extract from his
peech:
"It is a great thing to be a citizen of
he United States. The association of
he States is a geographical necessity.
Ve can never consent that hostile
>oundaries shall be introduced with all
has such divisions imply. We must
e one from Maine to California, one
rom the Lakes to the Gulf, [applause,]
Lnd everywhere in all that domain we
nust insist that the behests of the
ederal Constitution and of the laws
vritten in the Federal statute book
hall be loyalty obeyed. [Applause.]
. statesman of one of the Southern
tates said to me, with tears in his
hyes, shortly after my inauguration:
Mr. President, I hope you intend to
~ive the poor people of my State a
~hance.' I said in reply: 'A chance to
o what? If you mean, sir, that you
~hall have a chance to nullify any law
mnd~that I shall wink at the nullifica
ion of it, you ask that which you
)ught not to ask for and that which I
annot consider. L Applause.]
"If you mean that obeying every
ublic lawv and giving to every other
an his full-rights under the law and
Constitution they abide in my respect
md in the security and peace of our
nstitutions, then they shall have so
rar as in my power lies an equal chance
with all our people. [Applause.]
"We may not choose what laws we
will obey. The choice is made
for us. When the majority have by
Lawful methods placed the law upon
he statute book, we may endeavor to
repeal it, we may challenge its wisdom,
but while it is law it challenges our
>bedience." [Applause.]
"Some years ago Ayer's Cherry Pec
toral cured me of asthma after the best
medical skill had failed to give me re
lief. A few weeks since, being again
troubled with the disease, I was
promptly relieved by the same reme
dy."-F. S. Hassier, Editor Argus,
Tale Rock, Nebr.
BUTLER HITS BACK.
The Senator's Plain Talk About Dr. Stokes
-Strong Denial of Statenents About
the Prosperity Speech-Doubled
Teamed In Spite of an Agree
inent to the Contrary Dr.
Pope's Mistake.
[Charleston World.1
ASHEVILLE, N. C., August 24.-Sen
ator Butler arrived here yesterday
evening from the North, where he has
been since the day after his Prosperity
speech, in attendance on the session of
the naval committee of the senate.
Supposing he had not had access to the
South Carolina papers, your represen
tative sought an interview with him
touching the echoes of the Prosperity
meeting. Senator Butler was asked:
"Have you seen a copy of the Cotton
Plant with a criticism by Doctor
Stokes, the editor, of your speech at
Prosperity?"
"No, I have not, but a gentleman on
the train from Washington yesterday,
told me of it, and promised to Fend me
the paper, which I hope to get on my
return to Edgefield to-morrow. From
what this gentleman said of the edito
rial I should say that Dr. Stokes could
easily and successfully aspire to the
position of prince of-well I will not
say liars, because that would not be
parliamentary or decorous, but I will
say an adept in perversion and mis
representation. However, I will be
better able to speak of it after I have
read it."
"Here is a letter from Dr. S. Pope
copied in the Charleston World of
Aug. 22, from the Cotton Plant in
which he says among other things:
"General Butler begged the question.
He was told by Captain Talbert, when
he was referring to the appointment
clause of the Vance bill, that it was a
bill doctored by Governor Vance after
it was sent to him in order to make it
unpopular and that it was uhfair to
refer to it as the sub-treasury bill. Gen
eral Butler replied that be took it as he
found it and insisted on presenting it
as the bill. General Butler also referred
to men who wanted to borrow money
At 2 per cent. per annum as men who
desired to borrow but did not intend to
pay back-and yet the government at
Washington is to-day borrowing money
at 2 per cont., the great State of Ohio
at 2.65 per cent. and the State of New
York at 3 per cent. or less-yet when
individuals at the South desire to bor
row money from the government at 2
per cent. based on cotton as a security
they are told that men who desire to
borrow at 2 per cent. on this security
don't expect to pay what they borrow."
"Is that a fair representation of what
you said in your Prosperity speech?"
"Let me see the whole letter," said
the Senator. After reading Doctor
Pope's letter, Senator Butler said:
"Now, I am very, very much sur
prised to see such a statement from
Doctor Pope, for I have known him
most pleasantly for a great number of
years, and while I have always re
garded him as an earnest advocate of
whatever he thought right, I had the
opinion that he was an honorable, fair
man, ..4-would strike right out from
the shoulder; but this letter of his
shows that he either did not hear or
comprehend what I said, or has wil
fully perverted it. 1 should be very
soy to think the latter, and shall,
therefore,inquire of him if he is correct
ly represented.
"As to the sub-treasury bill from
which I quoted, having been 'doctored
by Governor Vance' to make it unpop
ular, Doctor Pope will pardon me if I
say I do not believe one word of this
accusation against Governor Vance.
He is an honorable man, and would not
be guilty of such a trick. But Governor
Vance is able to take care of himself,
and doubt less will do so if this charge
should be brought home to him.
" 'General Butler also nrferred to men
who wanted to borr3w money at 2 per
cent. per annum as men who desired
to borrow but did not intend to pay
back.' This is what Doctor Pope says.
Well General Butler said nothing of
the kind; nothing that could be dis
torted by any fair minded man into
such an expression, and no man in that
large audience ought to have known it
better than Doctor Pope. I must, there
fore, conclude that he misunderstood
me, for I am not prepared to believe
that he would intentionally misre
present what I said. Fortunately, I
have preserved the notes from which I
spoke, and I believe full stenographic
notes were taken of the speech, and in
due time I will refer to them.
"As to the other portions of the letter
of Doctor Pope, I have nothing to say.
I have no knowledge of any 'applause'
having been manufactured for one side
or the other. For myself, I care very
ittle for such things, especially if I
have anything of a serious nature to
say; and I thought the introductory
remarks of Doctor Siigh on that subject
timely and appropriate, and I so ex
pressed myself in the opening of my
remarks."
"Is there anything further you would
like to say in regard to Doctor Pope's
letter?"
"Well, let me see; yes,;here is a re
markable and startling announcement:
"But Captain Talbert in the after
noon utterly demolished the arguments
of our distinguished Senator. Yet,
strange to say, there was not a news
paper reporter there to report his
speech nor was General Butler present
to hear it, although the general and
some of the reporters returned to Co
lumbia on the same train with Captain
Talbert. Why was this? Were they
afraid that the captain's speech would
mar the glittering generalities of
the general? Gentlemen of the press,
"Now, the less said on that particular
subject the better it will be for some of
Doctor Pope's immediate allies. Let
me state what occurred at Doctor
Langford's house, whose hospitality I
enjoyed the nigh t I stayed at Prosperity:
Mr. Hardy, chairman of the committee
of arrangements, called on me at Doc
tor Langford's the evening before the
speaking and informcd me that Doctor
Stokes and I would be allowed an hour
and a half each; that Doctor Stokes
would open the debate in an hour's
speech and rrserve a half hour of his
time to reply to me. I readily assented
to this, whereupon Mr. Hardy re
marked that t' *hree hours occupied
by Doctor c sokes and myself would
take up the time before dinner, and
that after dinner W. J. Talbert would
deliver an adddress on alliance matters.
I asked Mr. Hardy if he thought it
entirely fair, after inviting me there to
spea z, to give two advocates.of the
sub-treasury the opportunity to reply
to me, and-that if Mr. Talbert referred
to my speech I should claim the right
to have a half hour to reply to him.
Mr. Hardy assured me more than once
that Mr. Talbert would make no re
ference whatever to the debate between
Doctor Stokes and.myself.
"After this assurance, officially made,
I did not remain to hear Mr. Talbert's
speech. Possibly Mr.. Talbert was not
aware of this assurance and agreement.
Possibly Mr. Hardy may not have been
able to control or direct the character
of Mr. Talbert's remaris. One thing is
very certain, the agreement was vio
lated but I do not know that I should
have referred to it but for this talk and
balder dash about my 'running away',
my 'arguments being demolished,' etc.
They must mean this part of the per
formance as a joke. The next time I
make an agreement of this kind, it
shall be in writing, and the next time
I correspond with Doctor Stokes I will
keep copies. He read his letter to me
to the Prosperity meeting, but neglected
to read my reply. He also gave his
letter for publicition and refused to
give my reply, as I was informed by
the reporters, so you see it stands me
in hand hereafter to preserve copies."
General Butler is looking well, and
will be in full trim for the speaking at
Batesburg which is on the card for
September l8th. He leaves here to
morrow for his plantation in Edgefield,
where he will spend some time, and
will probably remain in Edgefield until
the Batesburg meeting takes place.
The General's family, who have been
here for some time, leaves to-morrow
for Hihland, where they will spend
the rest of the summer.
SENATOR BUTLER'S ST. UING REPLY
TO THE COTTON PLANT.
(Special to News and Courier.]
EDGEFIELD, Ar-ust 26.-On Senator
Butler's return to-day from attendance
on the naval committee of the Senate
your correspondent handed him a copy
of the Cotton Plant of the 8th instant
containing Dr. Stoke's editorial criti
cism of his Prosperity speech, and also
the Cotton Plant of the 1.5th with the
resolutions of the Snell's Alliance, and
inquired if he desired to say anything
in connection therewith.
After reading both Senater Butler
said in reply:
"I have lived to very little purpose
for something more than half a century
in South Carolina if it is necessary for
me to vindicate myself against such
disgraceful falsehoods as those con
tained in these two papers. I had never
met Dr. Stokes until the Prosperity
meeting. He appeared to be a well
mannered, fair man, and I treated him
as such; but this performance of his
shows clearly that he is devoid of prin
ciple and honorable qualities. He
knows fdll well that I did not utter the
sentiments he attributed to me, or any
thing approaching them. He heard
every word of my speech and had a
half hour to reply to it. Why did he
not then and there in my presence
rebuke such sentiments? Why did he
stand mute and permit the farmers,
whose special champion he assumes to
be, to be villified and denounced in
this way? Why does he sneak to his
sanctum and ten days after deliberately
pen this editorial, bristling with per
version and falsehood? Why all the
circumstances convict him either of
self-stultification or, what is worse,
wilful falsehood.
"I never uttered such sentiments or
anything approaching them, and Dr.
Stokes knows it.
"As to the snell Alliance resolutions
I have nothing to say, further than
that they do me gross injustice. They
bear the ear marks of Dr. Stokes, and,
of course, are predicated upon the false
information he deliberately palmed off
on the members of this Alliance. It is
pitiable to see a man, who claims to be
intelligent, guilty of such disgraceful
methods to carry a point, but he shall
not practice them ripon me if I can
reach the ears of the people he is seeking
to influence and poison against me by
falsehood and misrepresentation. If
there is anything the people of this
State detest and despise it is a sneak
and a liar."
Sena,tor Butler will be at Batesburg
on the 9th of next month, the day of
the public diseussion at that place, and
will be glad to meet Dr. Stokes and.
repel his accusations face to face.
Sufierers from indigestion, loss of ap
petite, liver or kidney complaints. rheu
matism or neuralgia, would do well to
give Ayer's Sarsaparilla a trial. For
all such disorders, no medicine is so
efective as this, when faithfully and
perseveringly used.
An Ohio lady was so frightened by a
snake that her glossy black hair turned
white as snow. It was soon returned
to its original color by Hall's Hair Re
n3wer_
APPAILING RAILROAD DISASTER.
A Train riunges From a High Briige
Fifty Feet Below-Twentiy-Three Per
sons Killed and Twenty-Five Others
Injured.
CHARLOTTE, N. C., August 27.-A
dreadful wreck* occurred on the
Western North Carolina this morn
ing, two miles above Statesville, at
3 o'clock, at the long high trestle over
the Catawba River. A rail had been
removed at the entrance of the bridge,
precipating the whole train into the
river. News from the scene is meagre,
but it is certain that between twen
ty and thirty people were killed and
others injured. Auditor Sanderlin of
this State is reported among the pas
sengers. The bodies are being taken to
Statesville as rapidly as they can be re
covered. Much anxiety is felt in this
city as friends and relatives of many
here are returning from the mountains
every day.
RALEIGH, N. C., Aug. 27.-Eighty
five passengers were on board of the
train wrecked at Statesville. Killed
already brought to Statesville are re
ported as follows: Percy Barnett and
Charles Barnett of Hendersonyille,
Sam Gorman of Asheville, William
West of Salisbury, a fireman, a lady
unknown, Julius Phifer, a drummer;
a porter unknown, Charles Webber of
Carson, Conn.; a colored man, un
known; an old lady, unknown; Mrs.
Poole of Williamston, N. C. ; W. J.
Fisher of Campobello, S. C.; a white
man, unknown; W. S. Winslow of
Asheville, N. C.; William Houston of
Greensboro, Wm. Davis'of Statesville,
J. B. Austin of Hickory, Rev. J. M.
Sykes of Clarksville, Tenn.; Doc Well,
(porter) of Louisville, -y. ; Mr. Mc
Cormick of Alexander, 3uncombe
County.
State Auditor Sanderlin, was badly
hurt. But few of the people on the
train were saved. The Asheville fire
company, returning from a convention
at Durham, was aboard and it is sup
posed many of them were killed.
A LATER ACCOUNT.
CHARLOTTE, N. C., August 27.
One of the me t disastrous rail
road wrecks known in the annals of
this State occurred this morning
about 2 o'clock at Boston's bridge, two
miles West of Statesville, on the West
ern North Carolina road. Passenger
train No. 9, known as the fast mail,
which is made up at Salisbury pulled
out on time (a. m.) loaded with pas
sengers. It was composed of a baggage
and mail car, second and first class
coaches, Pullman sleeper and Superin
tendent Bridges's private car. This
sleeper, which comes from Goldsboro,
usually contains a good number of
passengers from Northern points, and
last night was no exception. The run
to Statesville was made on time, a
distance of five miles; but just after
leaving Statesville there is a high
stone bridge spanning Third creek, and
down into this creek plunged the en
tire train, a distance of eighty feet,
wrecking the whole train and carry
ing death and destruction with it.
Twenty passengers were killed out
right, nine dangerously injured and
about twenty badly bruised and shaken
up.
The scence at the wreck beggars de
scription. The night was dismal,
and to add to the horror of the situa
tion the water in the creek was up. It
was only . through the most heroic
efforts of those who had hurried to the
scene of the wreck that the injured
were not drowned. The accident
was caused by the spreading of
rails. The bridge was not injured
and trains are running on schedule
time. The dead bodies are now lying
in the warehouse at Statesville. The
injured are having the best of care at
private residences and hotels. Follow
ing is the list of the killed :
Win. WVest, engineer, Salisbury, N.
C.; Warren Frip, fireman. Hickory,
N. .C.; H. K- Linsler, baggage master,
Statesville, N. C. ;'Wm. Houston,
Greensboro, N. C.; P. Barnett, Ashe
ville, N. C.; WV. E. Winslow, Ashe
ville, N. 0.; Charles Bennett, Header
sonville, N. C. ; W. J1. Fisher, Campo
ello, S. C.; J. B. Austin, Hickory,
N. C.; T. Brodie, drummer, New
York ; J. M. Sikes, Clarkesville, Tenn.;
Mrs. Poole, Williamston, N. C.; Jule
Phefer, traveling salesman ; Doc Wells,
colored Pullman porter ; John Davis,
Statesville, N. C.; Mr. McCormick,
Alexandria, Va.; A. S. Lind and wife,
Lexington, Ky.; B. N. Estes, Jr.,
Memphis, Tenn.; John Gage, Ashe
ville ; R. E. John~son, newsboy, S. C.;
Conductor Spaugh ; Sleeping Car Con
ductor, H. C. Cleeper, and Flagman
Shoaff.
Among those who escaped with inju
ries more or less serious are: Cole B.
Cameron, Northampton County, N. C.;
Otto Ransom of IR orfolk, Va.; WVorth
Elliott of Hickory; N. C.; Geo. Bowle
of Atlanta; Col.O0. WV. Lawson of Louis
ville, Ky.; Miss Lewellan Poole of Wil
liamston, N. C.; Mrs. R. C. and Miss
Ophelia Moore, Helena, Ark. Mrs.
Poole was drowned before aid could
reach her. Three bodies have been
identified. One of these these is an old
lady; another is a lady with a ticket in
her pocket which reads : "Mrs. Gieorge
McCormick and mother, El!mwood, N.
C., to Alexander, N. C." The third is
also a lady. Upon her finger is a ring
engu. ed "T. H. WV. to M. R. R." It
is thought that all the bodies have not
been taken out of the debris, which is
piled up so high that it is impossib.le to
make a thorough examination. Crowds
have flocked to the scene all day and
the accident has cast a gloom over the
~entire community. Not a soul came
out of the sleeper alive. Miss Ophelia
Moore of Helena, Ark., died after being
toakn out of the wreck.
A 31TSSIO-VARY AMOYfl THE SLAIN.
NASHVILLE, Tenn., Aug. 27.-Among
the killed in the accident on the Wes
tern North Carolina Railroad to-day
was the Rev. J. M. Sykes, a graduate
of the Southwestern Presbyterian Uni
versity, of Clarksville, Tenri. Dr.
Sykes had just been assigned to mis
sionary work in China and was to have
left for that country on September 26
rext. He was married.
SLIGH AT SARDIS.
He is Amused at the Newlerry Edito.s and
Boom the Subtreasuty.
LClinton Gazette, August 27.1
At 10.30 the chairman, Capt. J. Andy
Jones, came forward and announced
that Dr. F. M. Setzler would open the
proceedings with prayer. This done,
the chair intZoduced as the first speaker
of the day, Rev. J. A. Sligh, member
of the House of Representatives from
Newberry, a widely known agitator in
behalf of 'he oppressed farming inter
ests of the State, and a much and popu
lar gazetted orator and kllianceman.
Mr. Sligh's address was lengthy, elo
quent and full of soundness of princi
ple. He by way of prelude, made some
most flattering remarks respecting the
noble qualities of the good people of
Laurens County. He said: "You of
Laurens County have done as much,
if not n.ore than the people of any
other county in the State to redeem
and uphold the fair name and welfare
of grand old South Carolina,
Instead of my coming among you to
teach you regarding the situation and
to lay before you the issues involved in
this great warfare against the wrong, I
should be at your feet learning more of
the source of this great revolutionary
,ipheaval that is now quaking the
foundation not only of South Carolina,
but of the whole country. The people
are beginning to think and to act for
themselves; the people are learning fast
and are the faster asking for more in
formation, for light, for truth; and you
ought to do it for your own benefit. It
ir a revolution, it is on us, it i in our
hearts; and it must, it shall come. It
will not be smothered until it has ac
complished its purpose, as sure .s na
tions have their rise and fall. Mark
my words, it will end in a peaceable
revolution and then, and not until then,
will there be peaee at last. There Is no
class of men under the blue canopy of
heaven, superior to the farmers in pa
triotism, loyalty, honesty, and truth
fulness. And when we as a class rise
up in our might and majesty as one
mighty man, restless, and will not be
silenced, thsre is a cause; there must
be a remedy. There is a cause; cause
produces effect. The opposition blame
Tillman, Shell and others including
myself, for the entire restless condition
of things in the State. Well, Tillman
and others did start the ball rolling
that opened the eyes of the oppressed
and eet the people to thInking for the
public good.
I am right well amused at the editors,
especially those of Newberry. They
always cry out against a man when the
farmers put him forward as their leader.
These same editors, you see, wants to
boss the job themselves. They want
the high placL o nd the fat of the land.
A Western speculator will say, it's an
overproduction of corn, or wheat, that
causes low prices. Over one million of
bales of cotton are on hand yet await
ing better prices; but who bnows? It
may be caused by underconsumption, a
lack of business to take up and con
sume the cotton that causes the present
depression in prices. Myself and family
would use more of cotton goods if we
had the money, but how shall we get
it? The Alliance wants the farmers to
have more money; there is not enough
money in circulation. Others talk
about what the farmers ought to do
to avoid overproduction of cotton. I
want to know whether or not the
present state ec things came of overpro
duction. Whoever heard of overpro
duction coming from a lazy man? The
farmers are often dubbed "lazy" when
he goes to town. The faimers lost
much more time last year attending
political gatherings and learning about
the condition of things than in any prc
vious year, and they made last year the
largest cotton crop of recoird. lImme
diately after the war there was plenty
of money; cotton sold at from 8 to 20
cents per pound fifteen years ago.
There was no trouble to make money
then; but now we are growing rapidly
froa bad to worse. Property was
worth more a year ago than it is to-day,
with cotton selling at 6 cents. No
money in the country, money becomn
ig scarcer every day, no property
wanted, no prosperity in the country,
your home mortgaged, and that to be
foreclosed giving the shylock leader a
title. And a general l'r' of confidence
all round.
Very few men, including our Congress
men, know much about the financial
condition or problem. After the war
there was about $50) gr capita; more
money in circulation in '00, '07 than in
'91. TIhe population has doubled since
then and there is less money~to conduct
the business transactions of the people.
Tho remedy for all these evils is the
Subtreasuiry plan. It is called a hum
bug and its friends are called fools by
the opposition. The Subtreasury bill
that we want and must have is not the
old Senator Vance bill, but a better one.
We want relief, if not by the Subtreas
ury, we must have relief from some
source. The farmers have hit the nail
on the head by suggesting something
as a remedy for the evils, and if the
Subtreasury is not what we want, it is
something like it. There are 3,500
national banks in the United States; 5
pe cet. of the people have the privi
lege of enjoying the fruits of the na
ticnal banking system, while the other
95 per cent. suffer the consequences.
The national banking s. stem will be a
thing of the past if the Subtreasury bill
passes. They know it and that is why
the enemies of the bill kick so hard
igaiLst the measure. The Alliance
wants to issue $50 per capita, and will
lo it if we press on to success. The
Democracy of New York is in sympa
,hy with John Sherman of Ohio be
ause he is for the national banking
;ystem and against the Subtreasury.
The speaker declared solidly against
.he third party movement. "Don't go
yut of the Democratic party," said be,
'you can't do it and look your wives
ind childrin iu the face. Stay in the
grand old party that redeemed South
"arolina in '76, we cannot afford to
leave it for all time to come. There is
no third party in the State. Mr. Has
kell P.ad a handful of followers tried to
institute a third party last year-they
went to the bottom never again to rise.
-o third party, no, never!"
We would be pleased to publish all
)f Mr. Sligh's speech, but knowing at
,he time that there would be a lack of
ipace in our columns, we only short
banded a brief synopsis. It was abun
lantly instructive.
PRESIDENT POLK'S DILEMNA.
Ele Must Fight a Duel or Lose His Influ
ence in the Alliance.
RALEIGH, N. C., August25.-There is
>pen warfare between the Democrats
md the Farmers' Alliance. The Dem
>cratic machine leaders have been of
he opinion for several months that the
;peeches, acts, and deeds of President
Polk were rank treason to the Demc
:ratic party, and so expressed them
;elves, but, as a matter of precaution
Lnd to prevent the organization of the
People's party throughout this State,
:he Democratic press and politicians
2ave refrained from making attacks on
Polk and the Alliance.
In Polk's paper, the Progressive
Farmer, of this week there appears a
:ut representing a Confederate soldier
>n one side of.the bloody chasm and a
Federal soldier on the other shaking
aands across the chasm. In the centre
Lre the words: "People's party." Right
inde the Confederate soldier these
words: "A solid South for fear of ne
,ro supremacy." Under the Federal
ioldier are these words: "A solid-North
,or fear of Rebel brigadier rule." At
'he bottom of the cut are these words:
'Anticipated twenty years ago by Hor
tce Greeley. Taken up -ow tye
Farmers' Alliance." Then follows a
Long extract from the speech of Polk at -
Dcala.
Because of the appearance of this cut
the general belief is that the People's
party is here and has come to stay.
The same issue of President Polk's
paper makes a bitter attack on Messrs.
Ashe and Jernigan, editors of the News
and Observer, and publishes a circular
letter sent out a year ago by Ashe,
which stated that the News and Ob
server advocated the sub-treasury bill.
Polk then denounces Ashe and Jernm
gan as guilty of a wilful attempt to de
ceive the farmers, because the News
and Observer holds the sub-treasury
bill to be unconstitutionaL.
He says that such conduct shows that
Ashe and Jernigan are totally depraved
and are unworthy of the confidence of
any honest and respectable person.
In reply Polk is denounced as a cow
ard, a traitor to the Democratic party,
a failure and humbug as a farmer, as
dishonest in his transactions with sev
eral individuals, and a "fea.ther-leg" in
every particular. J. L. Ramsey, an
assistant editor of Polk's paper, is also
denounced as a vulgar coward.
Messrs. Ashe and Jernigan intend.jto
force Polk and Ramsey to resort to the
Code for satisfaction. If they fail they
will try to break Polk down by making
him contemptible by holding him up
every day as a "feather-leg," which is
a miserable, abject coward, a pitiless
scoundrel, and a poltroon of the most
disgusting character.
No one believes that Polk will fight.
Ashe and Jernigan believe in settling
disputes according to the Code. Ramn
sey is absent, and his friends say he
will show fight as soon as he returns.
Several offers fo act as seconds have
been made to both parties.
Polk arrived here yesterday, and to
day he held a council with.his friends.
It is known that he was advised he
must fight if he would maintain his -
position as the leader of the Alliance.
Polk will speak in Charlotte to-mor
row, and will then return here.
It is said, confidentially, by his
friends that Polk will challenge Ashe 1
and Jernigan, and will insist on a meet
ing, the fight to continue until one or
both are disabled. Polk's friends here
declare that if he backs down now he I
thw lIne ilg opee.ill be odious ever hereafter, and that
Alliance men are rallying to Polk all
over the State, as the result of this at
tack, and openly declare for the organ
ization of the People's party.
So to Speak.
Woman is wonderfully made ! Such
beauty, grace, deli.cacy and purity are
alone her possessions. So has she
weaknesses,irregularities,functionaldXe
rangements, peculiar only to herself.
To correct these and restore to health,
her wonderful organism requires a res
torative especially adapted to that pur
pose. Such an one is Dr. Pierce's Fav
orite Prescription-po: 'essing curative
and regulating properties to a remark
able degree. Made for* this pups
alone-recomnmendedfor no other ! on
tinc-lly growing in favor, and nium
beri.g as its staunch friends thousands
of the most intelligent and refined
ladies of the land. A positive guaran
tee accompanies each bottle-at your
druggist's. Sold on trial!