The Laurens advertiser. (Laurens, S.C.) 1885-1973, July 03, 1901, Image 1
THE SOUTH NOT TO BE REPUBL1CANIZED.
High Tariff Legislation a Menace to Our Material Prosperity.
TRUSTS AN KNRMY TO SOUTHERN BUSINESS INTERESTS.
WHAT WIO MOST N! KI? IS AOOK88 TO THE MAMKBT8 OtfTllK WO Uli?
ttdilor Constitution; Your recent
admin.hie editorial on iho tariff mi its
relations to future party policy, must
be UIV excuse, U" any be needed, tor
tins c immunicutioo.
We have heard much of late about
the elimination of the neuro question
from Southern politics, ami the conse
quent upbuiidiug of a strong Republi
can party in the Southern States, based,
as the rumor runm tit, on the further
ance of our material interests -as
though adherence to Democratic pi ill
ciples would retard our progress.
Assuming for the sake of argutncni,
and that only, that the 'ace issue is
eliminated, and that the Southern pco
plo are now entirely trie to pursue
their "business'' interests, they can
scarcely he expected to Sacrifice lho-e
lHleiestft by adopting the cc> uomic
policies winch, from beginning up to
this date, have characterized the Re
publican party.
It is a serious mistake to suppose
that sentiment alone has controlled in
making the North Republican ami the
South Democratic. Aside front war
passion, now, happily, abated, the Re
publican parly has always adopted an
economic policy that was distinctly
sectional and hostile to the South.. Its
first task was the abolition of slavery,
and no sooner was that accomplished,
at fearful cost to the South, lhau it be
gan its high tariff policy, which was
a less open, but equally effective,
method of carrying on an economic
win against tin- South scarcely sur
passed In material hardship by the Re
publican pension poliey umicr which
the South pays her proportion tosh ue
of $150,000 0C0 annually to tin e in
mon treasury, only to see it paid out
among beneficiaries residing mostly
beyond her borders. Doing in the mi
nority, she could offer HOSUCCOSSful 1- -
sistauce.
I'rcvioUH lo the civil war the aveiage
tariff rate varied from ? poi cent, in
1780, to -ji> per cent, in 18H5; lo -to per
cent in 1828 (known as the ''Tariff <>f
Abominations"), lo 24 ptr cent. in.
1842, to -J7 per cent, in 1847, ami lo
2~> per cent, in 1S57.
Then came the Hopublicau tariff of
1801, about 510 per cent., of 1804-05
about 17 per cent., ol 1890 about ?l)
per cent., ami finally the Dingley tariff
of 1S!?7, estimated at about ?7 percent.
This liepublican legislation, espec
ially in its inception, was not intended
to benefit the South. Had it borne
equally upon all sections it would have
failed, in large part, of its purpose. It
was framed by a hostile, sectional
party that took special care of its own
local interests at the expense of the
minority section, though in later years
there has been an eagerness to enlist
recruits by sheltcting a few .Southern
products, which arc certainly entitled
to equal favor in whatever discrimina
tion is to be mado now or in the fu
ture. The Federal Congress, with its
North in majority, Will never pass a
taiiff bill in whbse tpecial privileges
the South will be permitted to partici
pate on equal terms with the North.
Our best hope lies in cutting down the
special privileges rather than in trying
to grab our share ol the spoils.
Whatever benefits the South may
have derived from the. uniformity
clause ol the constitution in reference
to taxation, they were wholly dispro
portionate to the benefits received by
the North. This disadvantage was
not due to any fault or want of wis
dom on (ho part of the: gcneiation of
Southern people then in life, but to
our social, Quancial and material en
vironment, created by forces operating
before that generation was born.
It is important in this connection to
bear in mind one of I he simplest and
plainest truths of political economy,
namely, that a tariff < 11 imports is in
effect a tax on exports.
Whether a given tariff rale on im
ports produces an exactly equivalent
burden on exports may be open to
doubt, hut thai a tariff tax levied on
goods coining into a country lessens
the exchangeable value of goods going
out of the same country is not denied,
?o far as I am aware, by a mnglc rep
utable thinker or writer on the sub
ject. Any business man can make his
own practical application of this truth.
From that truth it necessarily fol
lows that a tariff on imports falls with
special severity on those particular in
dustries which furnish the experts
given in exchange for the imports.
What industries havo borne tins
special burden?
In 1k'20 agriculture* furnished hi perl
cent, of our total exports, and with j
alight variations it still furnished in
1880 aa high as 82.25'per cent. One
of the most important items was tlio
South'a great contribution of her raw
cotton, which from the lirst was es
sentially an expiated product, and
which was greater in proportion than
the exported product Of any other sc<
tion.
It is easy, therefore, to lix the status
of ttie cotton grower as a hurden-bcur
cr under the tariff.
But in recent years we have turned
to manufacturing our raw rotten, ard
bavo already gone beyond the capacity
of the home market. In 1900 our ex
ports of uncolored cotton goods, such
as we generally make in the South,
amounted to $13,220,448.
Of the same kind of cloth we im
ported only $8$7*604, a mere bagatelle,
showing not only that our mills need
no protection hi this line, hut that a
bo ill' rate on theso manufactured Cot
tons would not be of any practical
value, no maitbr bow high jou might
tlx it on paper. No man can devise a
tariff scheme that will materially help
a heavy exporting industry operating
under the Jaws of competition, if it
can undc'scll its rivals in f mdgn i
markets, it can certainly do tbe same j
thing in its home inarkit with freight
(barges in its favor.
Our manufacture!a of uncolorcd cot
ton gooila ate, therefore, in the same
situation now with the growers of raw
cotton, and iu that fac thcio is much
hope for those patient plodders of the
I soil who have lolled bo long lo m iko
[others rich. And th? \ are not with
out othor prospective allies, fur ovi ry
industry that roaches a vigorous ex
porting development becomes ipso
facto, an economic enemy <>i n liigh
tariff, excepting always, ami, of course,
: those brigauds <?t' commerce, iiu1 trus's
that uro able to crush competition at
homo and exact for their uooda a pre
mium in tbo home mirk tjliveruud
above tlir prior uekcd in ih>' foreign
market.
No two industries in the South are
moro directly antagonistic lo I lie lie
publican high tariff Hum cotton grow
ing and cotton mnuufacluiiug. in
view of this fact, bow (strange it stems
that this new movement lo Republi
can Izo the South should appatently lie
lathered by the cotton mill presidents
of our neighboring Slates of Noun and
South Carol mal Perhaps ihe. stock
boldots will soon apply the proper cor
rective. It is possible, loo, Unit the
men behind the looms may have some
thing to say about it. The Democratic
parly has always favored our acecss lo
tbo markets of the world. The Re
publican tariff helps lo ?Inn those
markets against us.
W hat has been said of cotton grow
tug and cotton manufacturing is rela
tively true ot Southern coal and pig
iron, both of which have outgrown
home consumption. The "oil gushers"
of Texas certainly need no piolcclion.
That recent mooting of manufactur
ers in Detroit, at which foreign mar
kets were demanded for surplus pro
duels and tariff reductions advocated,
gives abundant proof that many other
industries in other sections of the
country have reached ihe binge of i x
portntion, which economically inter
preted, means ihe stage of lurilT re
duction.
From the present indications the ex
port in ^ imlu-11 ies of the. Untied St alt s
will soon be in u position to tlomaud a
r< lorin ol llic Im iIT und in c nforce ih u
demand at the ballot box, though Ihej
will be bitterly fought by those nu^;s
that have monopolized tin: home mar
ket and that acll to foreigners cheaper
than to homo people.
What our cotton producers and cot
Ion manufacturers inosi need is a
market for their products Such is
the volume of our output that no suf
ficient market can he found Without
going to foreign countries.
The chief obstacle lo foreign mark
ets is our exclusive tariff system, which
bears bo unequally upon us. Wo can
not soli permanently to other nations
unless wo permit them to sell to us.
Trade, m its last aunlysis, i-. an ex
cl angu of products.
The Uamillonian doc rino of pro
tection to "infant industries," to round
off and perfect the symmetry of our
national growth, rested on a genuine
scientific basis, although the South
was compelled to make the heaviest
sacrifice for this national good to the
enrichment of the North. But in most
lines we t.ave now passed beyond the
siage of "infant industries," and the
national welfare no longer demands
such sacrifice.
It is an economic wrong, and ought
lo be for any free, peoph an intolera
ble injustice that they should he taxed
to protect an industry that sells iis
pioductS ill foreign countries cheaper
than at home. Why should we pay a
premium in order that our trade com
petitors may get a discount?
To illustrate, Southern llussia is
now entering into competition with us
in the production of cotton. Hut
American steel rails to equip a road in
Russia to open up cotton lauds can be.
bought in the English market cheaper
than those same rails can he bought m
the American market lo equip a road
through cotton lands in Georgia or
Texas.
The steel company is only one of the
many thus Sheltered by the tariff.
These trusts, like the serpent in the
fable, are biting the breast that warm
ed then) into life.
Our government 03 'cnditures arc
too colossal and our industries built up
on protection scaffolding are too many
and too insecure for us to talk serious
ly now about demolishing the tariff
system, hut common sense and com
mon justice cry out for reform of its
abuses.
The Republican parly, judged by Us
past, is not competent for (his work.
It would be difficult for good Ameri
can citizens to lind belter employment
just now than knocking bricks off the
top of the tariff wall.
Hy ?II moans lot us have, broad con
ceptions, independent thought, and
free discussion, to the end that we
may lind out the. truth for the. good of
the country rather than of party, lint
independence, of thought does not re
quire us to become Republicans?nor
docs it permit such transfoi mat ion
under existing conditions. The Re
publican party cannot establish itself
Hi the South by proclaiming a nieie
[ sentiment of renewed btotberly love,
which we fully reciprocate, nor by dis
tributing a few Federal offlces. It will
have to change ils economic, policy,
tbo distinguishing characteristic of
which is now a high trusl-brecding
protective tariff that is antagonistic to
the, Soulh's business iutcreMs and also
to the national weil arc.
William II. FLEMING.
Augusta, Qa., Juno 1!?, 1001.
Some people are always fussing with
the weather. If it rains they pine fur
dry weather, and it it is dry they quar
rel with the dust, if it is cold they
pine for summer, ami when it is hot
they long for winter. What is to he
done with such people?
I CASTOR IA
The Kind You Have Always Bought
For Infanta and Children.
Bears the
Slguuturu of
RHEUMATISM and CATARRH CURED
-IJY
Johnston's
Sarsaparilla
QUART BOTTLES.
IN THE SHADOW OF BEATH.
a Whole family Carod.
Mrs. C. II. Kingsbury, who keeps a
millinery and faucy goods store at St.
Louis, Gratiot Co., Mich., and who is
well known througho'it the country,
Bays:
1 was badly troubled with rheuma
tism, catarrh and neuralgia. I had
liver complaint and was very bilious. I
was in a bad condition; every day I be
pan to fear that 1 should never be a
well woman; thut I should havo to
Bettle down into a chronic invalid, and
live in the shadow o'' death. 1 had
JOHNSTONS SARSA.'ARILLA rec
ommended to mo. I TOOK FOUR
IU1TTI.ES AND IT CURED ME, and
cured my family both. I am very glad
that I heard of it. 1 would cheerfully
recommend It to every one. I have
taken raauy other hinds of medicine.
1 prefer JOHNSTON'S to all ol them."
MIC1I1UA.N OHI O CO., Doti-olt, Utob.
SENATOR VEST ON THE DOG
When All Other Friends Desert
He Remains True to His
Master.
One of ihn most eloquent tributes
ever paid 10 the dog was delivered by
Senator Vest, of Missouri, some years
ago. He was attending court in a
country town, ami while waiting for
the trial of a ease in wilicll ho was in
(crested he was urged by the nitor
uoys in i dog case to help thetu. He
was paid a lee of $2o0 by the plniuliff.
Voluminous evidence was introduced
lo show 'hat the defendant had shot
the dog in malice, while other evidence
went lo show that I ho dog had attacked
tlio defendant. Vest took no part in
the trial and was not disposed lo speak.
The iltorneys, however, urged him to
make a speech, else their client would
not think he had i ained Ins fco.
Heilig thus urged lie arose, scanned
the I'tico of each juryman for a moment,
and said;
" (ienllemeu of (ho Jury: The besl
friend a iunu lias in (ho world may turn
against him and become Iiis enemy.
Ills son or daughter that he lias reared
with i >vini? care may prove ungrateful.
Those who are nearest and dearest lo
us, those whom wo trust with our
happiness and our good name, may be
come traitors to their faith. The
money that a man has he may lose. It
Hies away from him, perhaps when he
needs it most. A man's reputation
nvy he sacrificed in a moment of ill
considercd action. The people, who
are prone to lull on their knees to do
us honor when success is with us may
he the Aral to throw the stone of
inlice when failure sritics its cloud
upon our bonds. The one absolutely
unselfish friend that man can have in
this selll4*!) world, the one that never
d< sells him, the 0110 that never piovcs
ungrateful or treacherous, is his dog.
A man's dog stands by him in pros
perity ami in poverty, in health and in
sickness, lie w ill sie? p on the cold
gl'OUIl ., wbei'O the wintry winds Mow,
and the snow (bivOS tieicely, if only
bo may be near his niastei's side. He
will kiss tbo hand Hint has no food to
oiler; he will lick the wounds and
sores that come ill encounter with the
roughness of the world. He guards
the sleep of his pauper master as if he
were a prince. Wie n all Other friends
desert he remains. When riches take
WIUg8 and reputation falls lo pieces he
is as constant in his love as the sun in
its journeys lb rough the heavens.
" If foilune drives the master forth
an outcast in the world, friendless and
homeless, the. faithful dog asks no
higher privilege, than that of accom
panying him, to guard him against
danger, to flgbl against his cnennos.
And when Ihe last scene of nil conies
and death takes the master in its em
brace, and his body is laid away in
the cold ground, no matter if all Other
friends pursue their way, there by the.
graveside will the. noble dog be found,
his head between bis paws, his eyes
sad, hut open in alert watchfulncss,
faithful and true even in death."
Then Vest sat down. He had spoken
in a low voice, without a gesture. He
made no reference lO the evidence or
the merits of the eaeo. When he
finished judge and jury were wiping
their eyes. The jury tiled out, but
soon entered with a verdict in favor of
the plaintiff for $000 He had sued
for $200. It is even said that some of
Ihe jurors wanted lo hang the defen
dant.
Lkt lTs Act Quickly. -The farm
ers of (lie state in general will do well
to heed the. admonitions contained in
the. admirable address recently issued
to the farmers of Ncwborry County, by
Mr. Milton A. Carlisle, chairman of
the. Exposition Commission for New
berry County. He calls upon them to
" begin the preparation of farm pro
ducts for exhibits at Charleston,", ami
tells them that it is to " the Internst of
every progressive, farmer to make an
exhibit of those crops " wheat and
oats which are now being har
vested."
Mr. Carlisle says: "Sell cl now from
the best of your wheat and oats in one
or more bushel lots. Also select a
dOKOQ sheaves or bun des, of tho best
of each, and preserve them in as good
condition as you can." The farmers
arc also urged to begin preparations
for " Exhibits of nil Other crops espe
cially cotn, tobacco, rice and potatoes,"
and Mr. Carlisle explains the (IrstslOpS
in preparing exhibits of these crops.
He concludes : "Let us all act and
act quickly and vigorously in golting
no exhibits."
Htiflpborrivfl and blackberries require
a well drained soil highly fertilized.
Tbi'V <b> besi when tho ground i?
mulohed.
OABTOniA.
THE CONVICTION OF WM A. NEAL.
Former Superintendent of Mute 1*. nihmii ir\
The Jury R* commended Him to Mercy of the (Join t
The trial of Col. W. A. Nonl, former
Kuporintcndonl of Hie State pouitcu
liary, for failure to turn overiuonoy to
Iiis sneers-or wit hin the lime pro
scribed l>\ law, was hold last week in
Columbia ami tin- jury returned a ver
dict of guilty with recommendation to
the mercy ol the court. Tills ease has
uitraded much attention in the state,
not only on account of the prominence
of the dofouduut ami hisa'jtlvil^ in poli
tics lining the past ten your** or more,
hut also from the fact that he was ac
quitted last year upon a charge that
was even more serious in connection
With the duties of hisolllco.
The case was given lo the jury at
twelve o'clock on Saturday and at live
the. court was Informed that a verdict
had been leached, When the jury
had been brought into court, a slip of
paper was handed to the clerk by the
foreman. This slip contained the Ver
dict which read: "The State agaimi
vv. A. Nonl. Guilty, with recommou
tint loll to the mercy of the court. J.
M. Vail Metre, foreman.Meal was
in the court room at the lime, lie
did not evnco any surprise when the
verdict was rend.
Tins is one of the few violations oi
law in which motive is loft out .if the
question, yet the penally is quite se
vere. The statutes declare thai a pub
lic olllcer found guilty of ihe charge in
tin: indictment shall, upon conviction,
bo liable to a line of si.nun ami im
prison niCIlt for not exceeding UvolVt
months.
oSection 304" of the criminal st.ilmcs
of 18% 18 the law under which the in
dictment was bused. Lt declares: >-li
shall he the duty of every sheriff, judge
id probate, clerk of court of common
pleas, county treasurer and .013- other
Stale or county olliccr, entrusted with
funds by virtue of his ollicu, upon io
Illing from Ollico to turn over to his
successor all moneys received by him
as such olliccr, within 30 duy? from the
lime when his success 0 shall have, en
lured upon the duties of bisoUlcu," etc.
The lea tu res ol the ease, on Saturday
were the verdict returned by the jury ;
( ol. Nelson' scathing criticism ol the
penitentiary directors and of tbo com
mittee winch investigated the affairs
of the penitentiary; the splendid argu
ment oi Gen. Ilelliugor and tbo charge
of Judge Gary. After the construc
tion ol the law by the judge, the jury
could not lind a verdict of 1101 iruillv.
The Stale seems to have In en ma
terially helped by the resort of the de
fense to the ( lea that Ncnl was addict
ed to the use of morphine. It appear*
ed that this was a despernlc chance for
the defense, and (Soil, 'ielliugor's
shrewd and logical cross questioning
drew from the physicians who testified
lor the di tense an admission that a
man is morally responsible as long as
he knows right I rout wrong.
Judge Gary held that if Nonl collect
ed the money in quostion, and del not
expend it for legitimate ponilenliaty
purposes, r.nd then failed to turn n
over I i his successor within thirty days,
iln II he was guilty under the statute.
The payment to the. bondsmen was
notacompliai.ee with the statute and
not a defence.
Judge Gary held that the law ex
cused two classes: Children ami
idiots or the insane. To plead insanity
it must he shown that the parly could
not distinguish between right and
wrong. If the party knew the differ
ence between right and wrong insanity
was not a defence, but if he did not
know the difference between right ami
wrong it was a complete defence.
When the verdict WAS brought in
and read Mr. Hoggs moved for a new
trial, and it was decided that the
motion will be heard on Monday morn
ing. In the meanwhile Noal is under
bond and was not deprived of his
liberty. If the DOW trial is not allowed
it is generally thought that an appeal
to the supreme court will he. taken. It
may be noted that in the Assman case,
which is the only other case of convic
tion under the same statute as Noal,
the offender was sentenced to I lu ce
mouths in the county jail.
Mr. 1'. II. Nelson opened for the de
fense. He declined (hat the. jury be
fore, convicting Ins client should he.
I satisfied that Meal had in his posses
sion ?not indefinite amounts?hut the
particular sums named in the Indict
ment. He cited supremo court decis
ions showing that it must be moved
Hint all ami not part of thu money was
not turned over. Ilo contended that
Ihe monoy was legally disbursed as
shown hy the evidence of Col. Jonen
in connection with that of Noal. Tliis
indictment makes four specific charges:
That Noal failed to turn over to bis
successors $1,000 between N- vetubor
22nd and Decembor 10th, lau?, and
$544 belweon February 24tb to 27111,
1807.
Mr. Nelson went on to say that from
j the period November 22nd lo Decem
ber 0th, lH'.i.?, Noal deposited over
Uf.7,U(K). This was the tune wboh Neal
was accused ol making away with
I$1,000. In February, IK;.?, 24 It lo
JTlh, Col. Neal deposited over $000.
This was at (he time the $54'1 is charg
ed against him in Ihe indictment. Not
only did he (lop ?Sit these amounts,
hut he checked them out as supcrin
tendon t.
The superinlendunl is allowed in the
absence of the hoard of directors lo
pay out any money necOflsary in the
running expenses. Col. .Jones tCSlilh d
that Meal's checks as superintendent
showed where, that money was dis
burse 1. Neal is not culled upon t"
prove his innocence. The ."Stute must
prove bim guilty. Hut not one. suhl*
titln of evident o hu* been produced to
aliow whore the money wont to, The
defense has produced evidence thai
th.it money deposited hy Neat was lhal
j which was collected from Fowler and
i Hammond. Nonl had himself mo testi
fied and no evidence liad J>ccn pro
duced to refuto it.
Mr. Nehon then came to the Inves
tigation of the pcaitcutiaiy iu 1800 hy
I tho committee of "live astute lawyers."
' Hu (Iceland I ho outcome of the in von*
tlgnlioti was im?' t?t tin- greatest farces
! over perpetrated in (his Slate. These
j live astute officers nt tin- Si i'e drew
their per diom and mileage und en joy e I
! themselves lluriiug oul where -i dltle
butiormllk, or a row sinwberrios or
h ?me cabbages went. They wound u:>
b"y accoptiug Neat's own statement as
to Ins indobtcducss, uiul aelu ills de
ducted uu Item ol -T.!J which Noal
acknowl ulyod be owed. They never
failod to (ir.i v (bi ir p< r diem und
mileage, tbo Legislature having appro
priated SM,00U for their pay.
He pictured the change in Neat's
condition. In Is'.i.", Meal eaine It re in
power and honored by many Iii ml*.
Then when this matter eutne up poll
licinns were arraigned ngdust Noal
and he was desei ted by nun who b ??
lore would have been glad lo lie hi^
shoestrings. There A-a one man who
?tood by him vVi.i< .1 lies. l>o yon
think Wilie Jo'ne.s wo lid a> i ei it ? with
a dishonest man ? Would he be in
timate with a man, who,as it lias b > n
intimnlod by tbu state, bus e si the
batfk s-j jino ?
Mr. Nelson then emphasise d the fact
Hint Superintendent (irillilh had tesli
llod that he would noi have accept I i
payment and have given a receipt in
lull to Neal when UrdUlh took charge
i>l the ofll !o. The l> ?oks and accounts
of tlio penitentiary might not have
beon kept ship shape, hut No i! to he
made a scapegoat ? He iuilined on Ilm
penitentiary board lor being lax and
careless in the discharge <>i' u> duty.
This man has done nothing more lor
Which he iuu.-1 he held lO-fpoilSlhlc
ih in have the 25 or .'50 uthei ? >Hi? i.i1 -
<? inueclcd with the insitluli >n while Im
was there. Mr. Nelson called litten.
Ii hi to the fact that Noal hail he, n
I.icd and acquitted on one of thu Items
of the indictment, ahhoti/h on a diffor
eut charge. Can Neal !? held guilty
of not turning over this money V II?'
says (hat ho dep isited the mom v " hen
he received it, The State lias not dis
proved it,
Tlie chairman of the investigating
committee has said thai there was con
fusion in the accounts, tilth aigh Iho
management of the farms waiall right!"
The chairman ol the committee did not
testify that Ncai had purposely held
hack anything
Suppose Neal had been unfortunate
in lhose times. II.is ho no) paid i vety
cent ho owes? lia> i hu State loal a
cent by him ? If anything has gone
wrong in this institulii n, wh ?so fauli
is .i ? Is it Ne d s laud ? lias Ni al
tooled the public '.' Il l- Nl III lo .led
the general i.sscnibl\ ? Shall the I ?
islutu committees be without blame ?
/Vre the penitentiary direct ?ri of thai
period blameless? If they had dolU
their duly and have made monthly ex
aminations of Hu l> ?oks llieso derolic
lions would hav e he: ii stoppe I al one .
If ihn board ol directors knew of h\i
physical condition, i-houhl fh v no
have been more ^tiaxled ? What has
been Ne.tl's conducl ? Di l he tml oi
ler to pay the Mali- every cent as s um
as he knew how much he was due ?
And did he not pay if ?
I lie hue and cry ol the populace IUI I
the [ins.- is hard lo withstand. This
man wie denonilliali d the kitig-m ik
or " of the State, ami hut for ids prom
inence as a public ollicei hi' wiaihl
never have been prosecuted. If he,
had been a private party, and an em
ploye of a corporation, nothing would
ever have hccti heard ol it. This he
said with the giealesl respect lor the
prosecuting officers who are trying to
do their duly.
Mr. Nelson con lined himself princi
pally loa discussion ol the evidence.
He spoke, with his usual earnestness
ami directness, and handled his cause
in a most creditable nianiii r.
M It. o. nUNOA.N HI.1.1.1 N'OKII,
the attorney general, made the closing '
argument in the case. Ho had shown
considerable vigor in cross-examining
the witnesses of the defense, and hi
spirited argument was not a surprise
He began by saying that it is an in
correct statoment of facts for Mr. Nel
son to argue that had YV. A. Neal
been a private eiligen there would havi
been no prosecution. On the central')
had Ntal been nil ordinary priv He
c.ti/.en, no hope of acquittal would
have entered the breasts of the deft nsu.
This case is being tried under the law
Of South Carolina, not under the public
opinion or of newspaper criticism. In
reply to Mr. Nelson he asked where '
is there a newspaper hounding Neal
down?
He said that out of his public career
of twenty years, nearly h df has b< > i
spent in an ill'ue do vo! olio the on
forcoment of tho criminal laws ami a -
signed to the proscculii ii of criminals.
Within that lime and under stich cir
cumstauccs there is apt lo bo impress
ed upon the mind ami he.nl of ally
man a n veicnce for law ami a respect
for its true, representatives. Li is hut
human thai in such a Hold thorc
should be found Rccii and bitter dis
appointments, hut one. can make light
of failure, who does his own duty and
leaves the result With bun who read
all loans.
Tins trial presents n question and II
lesi of good cmiixi-11 111]i h ims been
truly said the' UO law can he etifoi't
oppo-cd by public opinion and it may
1)0 unfoi tunalcl\ true thai juries loo
often represent public opinion. I'd Iho
serious mind, liighor than iho question
of cilizonahip as involved in casos like
this, is that of manhood and illdividu il
honor and as Uiliplioil id' dlltv. A man
who Hilda il hard lo pert' im n simple
duty 11(1(1 CA8J 10 slin k il 111 UlO lure ol
popular clumor, is n moral coward and
lie, who willingly silling in judgment
would screoti t he guilty by violniiiiji hia
plighted word has sacrlfied llifl man
ly honor. It has been his puinftll
duty in Ins Ii Coli mo io prosccu 0 some
ot ins don rest friends.
The profound linporlnnca of this
Irml in shown by the. fact I bill this is
the llrst time since ibo diiya ol '7i'? that
S State olliccr has heen brought to the
bar of justice to answer for bis pecu
lations. In ftOtna things it recalls to
the student of history the great trial of
the grout viceroy of India in ihe <??,?? n
ing ycurs ?'t' ? lu; last ccntur. within
Westminister's historic walls. Win
n-n Hastings Im I added an einpire lo
Ihe lioiiiinioiia of Iiis kinsr, imi ti.'1
pump ami eiretiniatniieo ol Ins royal
?position, surrounded by Ihu iiiirvai
lug splendor ttnil Inviab wodthof Ilm
orient, warmed into life Mir cupidity "t
tin- runed busii oss man and lulled lo
slumbi r Ihu drowsy conscience of ibo
trusted solvent, Tin1 mighty fell, nod
was brotiglil lu answer charges before
an oui iugcil pe< p o
Less than a decode ago the man who
sits li> lore you today was elected, by
the assembled representatives of the
people, to our oi ihe niosl coveted and
cap usihle p >sit ons within lh? u'i^fi ?f
the Stu ??. Absolute master of a thou
sand slaves, uulrammelcd lord ovor
ustalcs baronial in extent, his edict
employed lie1 man to administer cor
poral punishment to iboc.onvlcl, up
politic I the physician - to heal his
WOUIlds, Ml 1 called Ihe priest to till'
minister lo his spiritual needs; a ct u
lurinn with cnplaius and sergeants
and corp ?ralfi ami guards under him.
ii" s.iith unto '.Ins man go, and he
?_""ih and lo another coilli ami he
? o,De h."
I CiUISC for grout w onder that lie
reai I, I. nh for greater power and
assumed to he the political dictator of a
commonweallh of tree nun? Willi
nllC-l nih of l 10 gross revenues of the
>; lo pu.?si ig yearly through his hands.
?\ i Ii &ul> superintendents and Blowards
and cashiers mill bookkeepers the
creatures of his own despotic win,
growing temptation anil unsy oppoi'
I unity undermine Ihu imposing odillcu
ami what once stood for chnrnctur falls
a shapeless muss of ruins, lint hero
tlio analogy ends and the contrast be
gins.
Continuing, ho said: ?? No tilled
lord sji^ upon the hunch, bul a man
who lias sprung from tin- people, with
like passions and sympathies, knowing
his du'.v only us hi- oath and llio laws
proscribe. No lliirko or Sheridan in
words oi Tu ry indignation an I burning
eloquence cty lor vangeunco, only iwe
pi dn men charged by our fellow ciii
/.oils with the woil- in blind, conn: be
fore you bvgging for tbo vindication of
a Violated I.UV tilld justicu lor an out
rage ? Siah:. .\s triers of tin- fact, you
sii 1.0! iburo as lords "i ihe realm, by
tbo grace of a monarch or by Inheri
tance of a lony line of noble ancestors,
inn only as * moo, high-inii.de I nu ?>.'
His honor ui Hm heiich, the solicitor
und I are hen: because it is our duly,
nol because we voluntarily assume
ibis particular n sp< nsibiliiy. Hut you
a- good und lawful in. 11 when asked if
you won!,1 give both sides juslice, an
swered yes, ami willingly uiidertoook
the Imidin, and staled your com pad
Wil Ii \ oil- 0:0 Iis "
The Indictment in ilii- enac has boon
passed upon by tin supreme court and
Um In ii declared valid. Neal was
elect' <i in I80JI and on Iii-; own tosti
in ii v admits that ho did uoi havo a
-1 Ith in in with iIn' in-iiiuli 'ii until
1800. N Ii it is tin- di reuse ? I n it
"iruiltA except for the reason of insan
ity v" I - n that he has sotth d with
tin- .Van a- sooi] a- In kill w how UUtch
he owed V Is it thai In- nevei made
misuse of ihe funds at ail ? Docs any
bod) know what tin' defense renlly is?
M uvc inusl enter ii>i<> the n ml of
ibis ??st- as throwing light upon the
question al bsuo. lb- handled tin'
business reckless!) in i rder to tlil his
pockets with ?jam. Fowlnr furnishes
proof nl an (-x press od design on Neal's
jairi lo deceive tin- Legislature ami to
Um? iii-nii' ins re-election. While bo
for four years forg t all about this one
thousand dollar-*, which he said had
been spent <>n traveling expenses, he
novi rthelei'S remembered lo render an
aceouul lor traveling expenses aggre
gating SUM) from August, 1805, t<>
.1 muary, 1800, and In- collected this,
tie reporied the accounts ol Fowler
ami Ilauuiioud outstanding although
he. had months before collected these
amount-- ami had purposely failed to
credit the sann'.
Ilr charged thai Neal was a hypo
crite. Ilf referred i-areaslically to
Neal's report lo Ihe Legislature that
the spiritual condition of the convicts
was gratifying lo the superintendent
Col, .loins did not sav what money
Neal hid deposited. Of course Ncul
had drawn it out as superintendent,
P i In had deposited it as superintend
ent. Nei - Ultornuyp had vaunted the
fact that in he indictment for breach
ol trust Neal had not a witness lo tcs
tif) in hi- hchall ami yet he was ac
quitted. Pel haps Neal lloW feels like
kick! g h m ed ail over the com (house
tor lestilyhlg in this case, for he has
so opcid) conti tdlcied his leslimony
hoforo H e legislative investigating
coiumitti e.
in hchall oi ihe invest nutting com
mitteo, he sai I in reply to .Mr. Nelson
ih it (ho M ite might have spent *1 ,<inn
lo coitduc (he impdry into Neal's ad
nnnistral on. but h wan worth $20,000
to have unearthed all this rascality. In
passing ho r< marked upon the ease
j widi winch people obtain pardons these
(III) s.
I Why did Neal never rcporl from
I |H05 until 1800 a dollar of this mono)?
Why did he not know how much he
owed? With thai mind saturated with
opium, (I'd llC Hot keep these, item- in
Ins head lor |\ nr lollg ycni'd ? Ca pi.
liriiliih showed his good judgment
when he refllSi d lo give a l'( ? eipt for III
dehtcdliess when Neal shoved a chick
for Sl7J at him a- settlement of hi
ncCOlint. W hile it i expressly laid
down as lawih.it the motives ol the
d 'fundaiil are immaterial to tin- issue,
the arguing of the facts In prove Iho
charge will Btlggost the motives ami
demonstrate the muht fhh of tin
transactions. Ilowdid ho perform the
plain diitn - imposed upon him? Can
icssiy, rccroauuy, nisrcgardrul ??i in
trust and with :i viru to IUI hl* pockets
?villi (lisIlOIH'Sl L'iilliH. Ho fllllod l6
lake bonds, as require^ by law, ii ho
thought if pnrtioa good. Collected
largo IUUOUIU?, some "I which Iii' ic
orted und tinned in und muuu bo kept
I und 8iiid n tiling. Deceived tbo board
oi di cciius and Iba I.ogislnturo by re
porting Hammond and Fowler as ow
ing $1,000, when ho know tbov owed
nothing, as ho hftd collected $600 from
each of them and Bp< i i the last dollar.
W< purled a large imaginary sum as
prOll B for the pcnilcnii r.y, in order,
I y ihl* apparently splendid linancial
' success, to sccuro, undor falso pre
ROVAL powder
Absolutely Pure
Makes the food more delicious and wholesome
teiiccs, Ins re-election to further his
In i irious designs. Forgot four years
etui until ro molded by the invesiignt
lug couimitteu to have the bookkeeper
cuter up ins collections for travoiing
expenses for 181)5, but icmcnibcicd to
il nur from him si. i over and above
\hut in luul take...
In the WdidS of ?.' great lawyer,
1'surely such uu Invention of liuauco
n iver was. beard of?an exchequer
win n iii extortion was tlio assessor,
frau 1 the cashier, confusion the ac
countant, concealment ihe reporter
and oblivion tin* remembrancer ; in
?bort, such as no man, but one driven
into frcn/.y by guilt, could ever have
dreamed of."
II is not 'he servant of the beard
of directors. Tlie superintendent is
co-ordinate with the hoard ami neither
a servant exceptio the Stale. Neal
madu Iiis icport to the board and I bo
hoard made n> n port on this showing.
\s ibo reports show Neal deceived
the hoard tune and nuaiu. How Iben
i couui iho board have known liow the
, affairs worn when be reportod it a- un
paid and in v I cicdilod il? n I hu books?
He obtained Iiis election twice under
fal-e pretonscs.
Mr. Hol linger read Iiis receipt to
Neal n> winch il spcciiics that Neal
owed 11 ii- Star the amounts named in
thi> indictment. Wh) did W i11 it- Jones
pay this mono) ? Ikceuse he had it to
110 ? When did Neal pay Willie Jones?
In i Ictobei, 18P9.
A> to (hi; acquittal under Ihe other
indictment, that of In each of trust, it
?mist h>' shown that a m m intends lo
steal money froin tin* luoiueul ii is |>nt
into In- hands.
BILL ARP TALKS ON vSUICIDIv
One to Unhealthy Condition of
Mind?Chopping Wood n Sine
Cure.
Atlanta Constitution:
l he increasing prevail nee of >m<ad< s
ludieidcs an in liculih\ eouditiou ol
lllind and body, and I have thought
thai d the man would quit thinking
about his troubles ami go to chopping
wood or digging in thu garden, <> < m n
go hunting ami got up a good circuit!
inui he would ni l bet ei ami conclude
to live t o a whin- longer. The bod)
affects the mind und when the blood
111 the veins gets thick ami slu. gi-h
ami the secretions become siauuaui,
ihe miud gots diseased ami morbid,
the t motions me out of iutic ami the
man uclutlll) belie c- he would lind
resl and peace in death. Ii i- strung)
that mi) mar id education or roll lie*
mem would entertain such an unreason
uhlo hope. What tlid the schoolte ichei
ot Dalian accomplish hy killing In.
McNeil ami himself? Where is the
ecli loitcuchcr how? When two ?. n
euiies light a duel ami both tue killed,
how do i heir spit its meul in the other
wor'd? Do the) shake hands r renew
tl e'iuh.. for. of course, Ihe) an- not
ii. In aven? \\ hat does ti t young Man
accomplish hy killing his sweetheart
ami then himself? Are they not thou
forever separated? What .he- any.
bod) gain by suicide? A- Hamlet
say>: " la it not bolter to bear tin
iih we have than ils to others that wi
know not ol?" Why not run awn)
from yoursell? Iluii to the woo l ,
keop on running?jump ihe branches,1
swim the rivers, ;it wet, gel tired
word in the garden, tin.', hoe. i hop
wi>"k, mount a horse ami Mile furlousl)
tin)thing to divert the diseased mind
from its train ol thought.
M\ good old faihci was nllheled with
rhetimatitnn ami when he felt the acute,
agoui/.ing pains coming on he would
rouse up ami limp awa) ami make for
the farm, and won;.', walk faster and
faster as Iho pain- increased, ami
would actuall) make them uahamud
ami ihcv would h ave him lor a day or
two. To keep the miud in a good,
noiuial condition the body must he ex
ercised. Sedentary occupations are
not health) for nu n, ami t veil w men
should Hy HI und Ihe house with a
h room or wash the windows occasional
ly, or dig among Iho (lowers. It will
n,,l do lor then] lo -il ami sew all the
lime. I am sorry for these unmarried
girls who have io run ihe machine all
ihe llil) long and gel no healthy ex
ercise except for tin ankle bones.
When they gel married and ihe babies
come idoiig they me prett) sate, for
little children givo a mother diversion
enough. A motlu i w ith a babe in hei
arms never thinks of suicido, Kven il
her husbnnd Is ciuol lo her or is a
drunkard, she will live on and t>n for
the sake of the child.
We ii dice that most of (ho suicides
occur among the youtij inch and are
caused loan iiilemperaiue or disap
pointed love or failure to make money
last, or laing caught In emhe/./.lemetii
(dnis stealing) Othello killed bun
:.e|| 111 e 111 e he folltl 1 ? lit ill it lie bad
ivro" gfullv kille I hi. wife, and shake
spearc snys he was gieu ol heart.1
I reckon ho was, considering that In
wa- a Mo ?r and -!i 1 IIol bolleVC in m
hcrea'tor. It w s ihe host thhig and
ihe most heroic thing that lie could do.
It w.i- ihe vet) nitcu-ii\ of grief and
ivpeliinnrc ami has no parallel in
Illodt in UlleidO", for most all of them I
arc a lllsh of ruViMigi lul. It was liki
the linriktri of .Sau , or of the ancient
IHM ah W III 11 ilcfoaii <i 111 I? it! If.
Tlio most nl inning fonlin e nboul
ihc?c suicides of our young nu n is tin
Indication (hut llioy are not t?f i i--\? 1 -
in the Christian religion. No ^.m,
in.in w ill t ikcliis own life if hi' believe!'
in benvon nud lu ll .o il a future state
of n wards nud |itinisbinenl . Ilu wil
bo afraid to. 'l ue Itiilueuee of inodori
llcliou on Ibo V' uiliiul mind litis muri'
j to do With it, fo( a great deal of it i
tainted with athoism and llilidelily
liven smile of Ihe stand.nil writers,
BUCb an Hume ami Disraeli hid lei
their had impression. Tbo latter threw
u dark shadow ever lifo und aays thai
" youth is a blunder, manhood a strug
glo and old ago a regret."
I- it not tai botlor to take a m ?ro
hopeful view ol* life and say like tbo
' poet, Horace Smith :
? [It 6 world is very lovely! Oh. my God,
1 thank thee that I live.'
Or to say like Longfellow ?
" late is roal?lifo >s oarnost,
A nd the fjrave is nut its final."
Il is easy to diagnose a poet's ?6tU
I pcramont or a philosopher's by his
wiitings?some are gloomy au i some
uro blight and cbcerlul, I was mini
uating about tboso young men who
have just graduated at my alma mater
and the other home colleges, and won
dering bow many of them would prove
a success in life and twenty j ears hence
exclaim with the poet, u Ob, nty God,
I thank Thee that I live." Fifty-four
years ago 1 was at Athens, in the class
of ' IT, and of the forty-two then living
there are now hut half a dozen loft.
Many of them lived and died and uiado
no siyiis. Some of them saw trouble
ami some made good citizens, good
husbands and fathers; and just so his
tory repeats itself all along the genera
tions.
H grieved mo that I could n >t nttetid
Iho centennial und commune with the
alumni und rcjoico with Ihe young und
feel lonsly with the old. Thou there
is old college and new college, and the
chapel and the campus and the two
halls that are still unchanged. I
wonder how many boys have occ upied
the old room thai Hriscoo and 1 lived
in for two long years'. I saw it in the
picture and fell like it was still my
room, lite ailaulhus Ircos (by a mis
nomer called the tree of heaven) grew
(dose to our win.lows und extended
Ik ir nauseating odors to ihe dormi
tory where WO slept, and the hoys all
along the liuo complained, hut the
faculty said Ml would soon pass away,
I and tbo tri es were imported from
China, the Celestial Kmpiro, and they
were called the tries of heaven. So
<"ie dark nigh! the boys (not I) got axes
and girdled them and they .lud and
went lo heaven in China, whore they
came from.
For some months 1 roomed in new
college, and so did our tutor, who wart
cross and never smiled, for he was an
old bachelor peace to his ashes. He
wouldeiit hi mo nor Chess Howard
play on the Mute utter study hours at.
night, nor let lien Moscly and Dick
Farmer play on the fiddle. Said it an
noyed Inni, and so some ol the boys
(not I) got some old cannon halls from
the urinory and awav in the dead hour
<>l night, when deep sleep fillIctil upon
a man or a tutor, they rolled a six
founder along the lo:.ur bail 200 feet
light by his door, which was about
midway. When it got l" tie: other
?. ml another hoy slipped out ami lolled
it Lack again, and this rolling nud runi
blinjj w as kept up for a i me' until there
Itappi lud just What they thought A'Ould
happen. The tutor ha I opened a CM k
in Ins do ?r, and w hen he heard ilie
hall coming lor the fifth lime he slipped
out suddenly ami slopped il wtlh Ilia
loo*, am! picked il up and look if in his
room.
Thai was just what the hoys (not I)
wanted, foi they had another one i-i
ihe lire giltlng hoi. in due lime they
look it in the shovel and sent n slo \ly
? I iwn the hallway, and it stopped not
fur from his door. (,?uick!> he stopp? d
out and ihe light from hi* room showed
him ihe hall. He sci/.cd it with his
right hand ami straightway dropped it
ami used sonn- language that was un
becoming, ami retreated to his r mm,
i he next day Ins hand Was tied Up in
i while handkerchief, which was v
kilid ol ling of truce, for he was much
more considerate lo us ami sunned to
liku music. I never perpetrated much
mischief while in college, hut i .v;.s an
ipt scholar lo look on and enjoy all
ihe lun.
( lies- Howard was an export, and
could play bolter than anybody, cspu
ci illy a hot cannon hall. Chess Came to
c us sonic lime ngo ami nftor while.
asked im and my wife lo give them
sonio music. And so she seated her
self at Ihe piano and I look my lluto
and asked what he would like. And
lie said play that good old piece that we
used to call u .Salbu Haxler " when we
went serenading in Athens. So wo
played it, and before we were aware of
'. i hi ss had slipped his ow n lllltC out
of his pocket and was tooting along
h hind nie. Sallio was our college
sweetheart, bill we dideut get her, for
Hird Hew lh< e and she followed him
dV io liiilliln to, and is living there
yet. Hut m ? 1 sver thought of suicide.
Hui I fothcal. Iii- sweet and it's
sad to h i all the memories of'i?, '46
lilld 'IV. am! I Would have felt lost and
l.uicly in Athens, Ii was college then,
11 is a great university now, and many
hanges h ivc come over it, and wc old
.? lerans have to Keep up with the
i occasion ? bother wo like the modern
incthads or not. They have got inter*
. oil. guile ha-eh dl in the curriculum
now and I reckon u is lo keep the hoys
I from committing suicide. It diverts
ibeir minds from the strain of trigono
nulry and calculus and conic, sections.
Progress is ihe order of the. day in col
us in ovorylhinu else. On ?
i und red ami llfty years ago old I).-.
I >lnis.tii sai'l lo Moswi ll, "lo our great
- Iio ?Ii ihoru is es< flogging ihnti for*
in t \. Consequently, Ioh9 is loarned
here, s.i whai the boya got fit ono
o . i ihoy lose at the othor." Now
ih -re [a no Hogging anywhorc, and Iho
LtM Iteis ami juolussors are. thiiiikful il
they i'scapo il fioill IllO hoys.
Irl II, Am?.
'I'Iki ii vorn go in in il can't need x poul
ii m ik ? u woiuan ovo him; all ho
lliaal.i l a -welled loud.
OASTOHIA.
Beats tho si NU KllWl YOU llavB AliMjfS ?0U?ht
Bi8T" <Z*0&?%t