The Laurens advertiser. (Laurens, S.C.) 1885-1973, August 08, 1900, Image 1
?mvtimv
LAURENS S. C, WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 8, 1900.
GARY AND PATTERSON FIGHT
IW.OWS HIT AT liAllltKN?.
Two OMiiiintatL'ti Kor Governor Ifiii
)',hk'> I" a FiHilcuU on the Stand.
L'i ioo News und Courier, Auguut
Kohn write? of tho cannml^n meeting
at Laurorm on Saturday :
Tho ci-eivt e?ucatlouul campaign
ovolved Into a slugging match today.
It wan BOtuewhat tho unexpected which
happened. Prank Li. Gary und A. Linw
ard i'aitertton had a nun: h and lumhle
tight before a thousand I. *?11?. > people,
men and women. They fought with ilea
peration and determination until Jim
Tillman and others separated them,
and then they wanted to got tmck at
each other, Had the acckiunt occurred
years ago in this county, when ttiere
weroa cartload of platols a'.a mooting,
there would have been (uucralu tioro to
morrow, but now nil tbo feoiing aeoraa
to bo botwoon the candidates. Today
the roHull waa two budly hruiaed fucoa
and emphaaia on the 8 yle of campaign
ing going on, and If uthura allowed toe
8umo spirit thero would bd many muru
liatlcutTa from day to day. At touuy'a
meeting Mr. PaUoiaon in bla speech
attacked Mr. (Jury about bis Charlott
ton Hpuuuli, roading tbo clippinga aud
making the atatomout published. Mr.
(iary thought Uns normalem effort waa
tu make it appear, indirectly, that be
atraddled in Charleston, or favored a
local option wbilo in (Jnarloaton with
tho llcenae feature, which tiu inaislo?
was not tbo case, and I'uttoraou'a effort
by reading extracts waa to placo film
in a falau poaltiou aa to wbui ho aaid,
and his attibudo on tho liquor quea
tlon.
When Mr. Gary's turu came to speak
he Irnnn dlatoly replied that ho Old
not " straddle," ana that his position
then as now was plain. Mr. Patterson
was sitting about tivu feet beninci
where Mr. Gary was speaking, anU Mr.
1'attorson got up and he said : " Mr
Gary 1 want to exolain some! lung." Mr.
Gary turned squarely around and *au:
"Now, Mr. 1'atterson, 1 want to ask
you plainly is what 1 have said about
that Uharlestou mailer irue ?" Mr.
Patterson said ho would exnlaiu. Mr.
Gary replied that there was no use lo
explain, but insisted on ktiowiut; wheth
er what he had j ist saiu ahout the
whole matter wa? true or not. Mr.
Patterson went on to say tho candi
dates would not Hgreo with Gary, or
something on thau line, and saiu ho
dared to prove his statements hy any
of the candidates. Mr. Gary insisted
on a direct reply as to whether bis
Btatement about the Charleston speech
was true or uot. Uy tins time tue two
men wero within arm's length, looking
fiercely at each other and, no doubt
looking for a blow.
Mr. 1'atterson said that if he was not
allowed to explain be uiuot deny what
Mr. Gary had said was correct. Mr.
Gary then said : "If you say my state
ment Is uot correct you auy what is not
mi," The two men joincu. PatlorbOn
atruck out and claims to have hit first.
There was uot a second's Uilleronoe la
the passage of blows. Patiersnn struck
Gary an uphauded blow under the left
eye, which cut the sklu for half an
icon long. Gary bit Paltorson on tue
mouth and cut tue lip and struck him
under the eye. ll was uot a minuto bo
fore half a oi/, m men were around the
two combatants ; they wero up against
each ottier, cliuontd, ami ocvreai blows
were passed, but tbey w ei 0 pulled apart.
Gary was laKcu toward the front oi the
stand and Patterson to the rear. They
said nothing, hut were eager and
watching. Growds pressed up to the
stand, sumo yelling lor one candidate
and somu for anotlicr. Hy the aid of
two policemen, Sheriff McCravy, bona
tor Tlllmau anu Cnairman Smith,
those who belonged on the stand were
instructed to get back and sit down,
and thuso who did uot belong on the
stand to get oil. At this lime the can
didates had mopped their faces and
wiped the biood from their bruises.
When quiet was rostured Mr. Gary
faced the audience. Somewhat uis
hevelled and bruised, and quivering
all over and w'th clinched nauds, he
spoko out, and said when be left homo
be decided he would bo a gentlemun
and give no possible olTonce to any one,
In turn he would not take any insult
from any one. He bad treated Mr.
1'attersou as a gentleman and a friend,
tout be had gone too far, and he would
allow no man to insult him without
hitting him in the mouth. Mr. Gary
apologized with feeling and almost
tears for having fought before ladles,
and expressed nls deep regrets at the
Incident. Then be went on and con
cluded bis speech, cutting it hero and
there.
Mr. Patler bou was allowed to mako
a statoniunt and said hu wub vury
sorry fu<* the uceurence. 11 o did nut
llko such things, lie und Gary had
been warm friends and hu had been a
ataunch friend uf thu family, hub when
ever a man told him hu hud hu tried
to put hid dst in hid mouth and give
him thu beat hu had in his ahup.
When the two candidates had takoi.
their seats a poliueman, who luoks like
the picture* uf Mr. Dinkclspiol, good
naturudly hold uut hia hand and aaid
tuo disturbance would cost each of tho
combatants $0, or they would have to
go before thu mayor's court. Mr. Gary
paid his *<"> und Mr. 1'atteraon followed
suit.
The oilicur, when aakud about the
matter, said it always cost that amount
for a tight in town, hut thu combatants
cuuld go to cuurt if thoy wantud and
they might get back their inonuy, but
thoy bau unly ono rulu. Mr. Patterson
and Mr. Gary left the stand soon after
the speech uf Mr. Gary. It so happen
ed that they were guusts at thu samo
house, but onu uf thum has changed
his stopping place.
Through the etfirts of Glork of
Court Bolt Mr. Pattorson and Mr.
Gary met, shook hands and agreed to
be friends and comrades as when
they ontorod Laurens. Of course nob
thor of tbo contestants was hurt to any
extent.
After the scrap It was up hill work
for all tho candidates untli Tillmun
was presentod and he was received
with onthusiasm. Ho whooped things
up and had tho boys hurrahing. Ho
took a pVimary, and called mo up to the
front to note tho vote. Not a dozen
voted for prohibition, but when It camo
to vote for tho dispensary pretty much
every one voted, and thoro was ono of
those old-tlrao dlspuosary holds of up
raised haDds. Tiilman was happy and
so did every ono else seem to bo, and
he remarked that thoro was nothing
muoh in tho talk of six hundrod tigers
In Charleston and two hundred In Co
lumbia, and ho put no faith in this talk,
and commented on tho evidences of
there being no tigers about Laurens,
and tbat there were not near as many
tigers as nomo triod to make out. The
orowd was quite largo and in tho best
humor.
OAflTOIlIA.
Boats th? _1 ?? Kind You Haw Always BoufiM
I MEETING AT GREENVIIJ,E.
nuail sj UROWU VKT.
Hoyt Woll lt( eel veil and Tlllmau
I'rli-K to MMr '1 hingt? op.
Pro DO The Daily News.
The ci osvil i hat greeted the State
campaigners, who ..puke hera yester
day from u stand erected In tho city
park at Hit- north end of Main Rtl'COI
was larger thun had gathered on nn,\
similar occasion in Urceiiville here
tofore and twice as largo as any cam
paign gathering so far in this State
this Hummer. Men were present not
only from this but from every neigh
boring county, some traveling; over
thirty miles in buggies to bear Sena
tor Tillman apeak, will n, oi eontr-.e,
was I he feature of the day.
Although there were a number of
(ireenvillu City people presen* the.se
for the most part did not take
part in the hand primaries uud other
demonstrations peculiar to a fi'liuun
campaign mooting'. Tho crowd was
made up to U decided degree vd*
bnstlc admirers <?t' their "oddest
only" Ueil and he voted thein will, bill
hand (tri ina lies in favor of what
ever be wanted. Throughout the
hand raising nil owed that the erowd
endorsed him by not less than 10 to 1.
Senator Tillinun estimated the
crowd of .">()(), which was probably
at least 500 above the number ac
t-ally present. Jle voted the crowd
almost, solidly for the dispensary tcs
it gains! prohibition ami in t li>- name
wtiy be made them endorse lcs pe
sition that "the preachers are in an
unholy alliance with the wh:d;ey
men led by Col. Iloyt," although the
same crowd a short time before that
shouted almost with unanimity for
lloyt, and this county will give him
a handsome majority in spite of the
way the crowd yesterday exhibited
its feelings and sentiments by means
of 1 he hand pri ma l ies.
Tlllinnn was bis fiercest und he
made Iiis most, ugly faoos in express*
ing contempt, for those opposing him
ami Iiis "God child." I he dlspem^ry
law, which he dramatically dcelnred
was a legitimate olVspring of a mar
riage between Itenson and Prohibition
and uol a cheat lor prohibition as
had been charged. Prohibition., bo
said, wanted to marry that old hag,
runalaclsm, but he prevented this,
which was his duly I" do as governor
in the interests of the people, over
211,000 of whom I he ret urns showed
had not voted on the question. A
majority of the people, therefore, li'iti
not voted for prohibition.
He characterized as sneaking n?v.l
cowardly shirking tho elVorts nun In
on the part of certain politicians In
have the liquor question voted 0p<?n
separately. P.y a peculiar coinci
dence I his scheme w as adopted ill
Greenville county ;il the suggestion
of one of Senator Tillmnn's staunch
est friends, ( apt. A. Mythe.
Senator Till ma ti handled the He.V.
Dr. ('. S. Gardner roughly und said
that his attack in n recent sermon oil
the dispensary law was false. lb
was interrupted with hurrahs for Dr.
liurdncr. lie spoke with fine scorn
and contempt of priest, craft, and
quoted scripture to show that, there
was no foundation there for prohibi
tion, but, thai drunkenness was con
demned.
The campaigners speak today ill
Pittkens. A majority of them left
yesterday for that town. The others
get out of Greenville this morning nt
l> o'clock on a freight train.
Colonel lloyt opened the speaking
by pleasantly introducing his oppo
nents to the pep pie of his home coun
ty and concluded bis reinarkes by
saying:
"Give them all an attentive and res
pectful hearing and be sure to vote
for lloyt."
"This met with cheers and applause
and
"Sit down, Colonel I you're all right;
you needn't say a word we'll vote for
you anyway."
WOULD-BE COMPTROLLER GENER
ALS.
N. \Y. Krooker, for comptroller
general, said he was not unknown t<>
many of tile crowd, lit? volunteered
when 10 years old and spent, several
years in the Civil war, lit' served six
years as si director of the peniten
tiary, for live years he was ?in ex
pert, in the tax department. He re
viewed his work in the field. He
charged the incumbent with "vicious,
violent violations of the law." lie had
checked and stopped his (Brookcr's)
work. He charged that Mr. Derb am
passed $4,304.04 to the credit of the
sheriff of Clarendon county in (dear
violation of the law.
J, P. Derham, candidate for re
election as comptroller, said that his
statement as to Mr. .HrookerV. charge
was made l?y the gentleman
who made the settlement 111
question. It didn't do the speaker
tiny good to tell why Mr. Brooker
should not be elected. Mr. Derham
was vigorously applauded.
FOR SCHOOL SUPERINTENDENT.
Kllismi Capers, n fonnci' Crcenville
man, as a candidate for superintend
ent of education, was received with
hearty applause. It, was here that
he. got his first, business experience
as a clerk in a store in Main street
and his lirst. teaching experience ns
ti tutor in tin; White Horse school,
from here he went, to Columbia mid
graduated at the South Carolina
college. Ho presented his claims us u
practical man as against a theoreti
cal man. lie believed his opponent's
administration had not only
been a fail ore but that. two
years more of it would disrupt, the
winde school system. He attacked
Mr. McMahan for fathering the net.
to take the Choice of tllCO OUntV su
perintendents out of the hand's of
the people. This was ''ruthlessly
tramping on democracy." lie charg
ed that his opponent was endenvoring
to take the entire system under Iiis
own, one-man, control. Mr. Capers
concluded nmld hearty applause und
cries ?>f "you're nil right; we'll vote
for you."
J. .f. McMahan, for rc?c1cotlon as
superintendent of education, suhl ho
came In on nn aggressive pint
form, lie denied Mint, he hod failed
to consult the stuto board. As to
the charge that he was trying to take
tho choice of the county superintend*
cuts out of the hands of the people
he said he wanted competent men for
that place, lie wanted the position
taken out of polities as much ns pos
sible, wanted to see the superintend
ents with good salaries chosen by
a board as the city superintendents
ore s > ns to elevate and improve tho
county schools. Mr. McMahan wns
also applauded.
POll ADJUTANT OENEHAL.
George 1). House, for adjutant gen
oral, was uhseut and ChairiUttU Austin
read n letter of regret from htm.
Mis opponent, J. NV. I'loyd, referred
pleasantly to Muj. 1?. M. Mythe, of
this city, his opponent two years ago,
and to Major lilythe's company, the
Greenville Light infantry, and then
spoke of how the militia system had
recently been improved. Colonel
Floyd made a good impression und
was heartily applauded.
FOR RAILROAD COM MI SSI ON Bit.
I'>. 11. Evans for railroad commis
sion, reviewed the situation as to
discrimination against, this section re
garding the high local tariffs. The
present commissioners are "either
ignorant of the conditions or they arc
subsidized." "Unless you elect, men
of honor, integrity, intelligence and
backbone you will continue to suffer
in the future as you have in tho
past. The people of South Carolina
are being robbed by the railroads of
$t,'.'?o.ooo annually on account, of this
discrimination. Me attacked the ex
press company and said it was the
fault, of the p sent subsidized
board that the express rates in North
Carolina ami Georgia were from 30
to 70 per cent lower than in this
State, lie was warmly applauded.
T. N. B?rry, also for railroad com
missioner, was a prohibitionist, lie
was running as a clean honest man.
He was cheered.
J. K. Pettigrew, for the same of
llee, said he was attached to Green
villi* on uc^i'nt of having two brav:
(irecnville hoys wn, fell in his com
pany and were buried together. He
advocated and promised lower local
rates.
\V. I). May field, for the same posi
tion, said that this State paid higher
local freight rates than any otllCI
Stale, with the single exception of
Florida. Consequently South Carol inn
manufacturing enterprises cnnnol
compete with those of other Slates.
Atlanta can ship Hour to every point
in South Carolina cheaper than the
Hi'CCIl vi lie roller mills can. Wholesale
merchants in every surrounding mid
neighboring Stale can ship cheaper
into this State than the merchants
of this Slate itself.
.1. II. Whnrton, for the same place,
said he had educated four daughters
ai Greenville Female College ami a
sou at Fitrinnn university. He also
reviewed the discrimination situation.
W. I>. Kvans, candidate tor re-clee
tion as railroad commissioner, was
absent
AND DEN T1LLMAN Sl'OKK.
Senator Tillmuu Ktiicl:
"Mi*, chairman, ladies and fellow
citi/.cns: It. is six years since 1 had
I he pleasure of addressing I he Dem
ocracy of < i reen ville, ami after I his
long absence il is a source of great
gi'ai itieat ion to look you in the face
once more ami hear your lirill greet
ing ringing in my cars. I will remark
in passing before I forget, it, that
from, the hearing of this platform
? Ins morning, there must he some
thing Weak and shaky in the knees
here. I don't know whether it is the
leadership in the Democratic party
in this county, prohibition or what,
Im! I do know whatever it may he,
(he opinions, wishes, feelings and
courage of the men who arc to lead
(ireenville in rank are true as steel,
ami will vote as they please in spile
of jurisdiction to the contrary. Now
they have changed the program for
the first time in t his canvass. Owing
lo my absence to speak in Dakota
for I'.ryan, which 1 agreed to do he
fore congress adjourned, I had lo
miss a good many counties, and when
I returned and went into the State
campaign at Itenneltsvile immediate
ly a great howl arose from some peo
ple who have not. loved me in the
oast, ami don't love me now, that I
was meddling, doing what 1 had ac
etified Senator Hampton of doing in
18U0, and that 1 ought not to do
what. I objected to, pretending to be
lieve it. contrary to the voice of t he
people of the State, and that I had
no right, to do it. The idea was ad
vanced that, because of the fact thai
I have no opposition as senator, that
I ought, to content, myself with dis
cussing national issues and leave the
issues and facts important in this
state strictly to the State campaign
ers. Now, they have changed the
program today, having heretofore
kept, me at. the tail, through at least,
six hours of sweat- to listen to a lot
of speeches which 1 almost know by
heart, i'nt today they have put me
before the candidates for governor.
I don't, know whether I am limited
or not.
Chairman Auatin?No, speak all
you want- l<>.
Well, fellow citizens, while I am
feeling a little under the weather, 1
propose to discuss at some length,
questions for your interest; but be
fore. J begin 1 want to set the mat
ter straight, why I am here, and
what, light I have here. Now, in the
first, place, under the constitution of
the Democratic party, tin' State Dem?
ocrntio committee is ordered to ap
point a meeting for the State of
ficers and United States senators
and congressmen where they shall
appear and address the people. 1
am here in obedience to the party
laws, because I am a candidate for
reelection, and the man wdio under
takes to say I am a candidate and
have no right to speak my views
freely I wish to assure him that. I
am going to speak without, fear or
favor to any. I am going to hew to
the line and let the chips fall where
they will, and if some lingers and
toes and necks got CUt off the fault
I is not. mine.
They say Ihn! I should not appear
at. the meetings and if I did I should
discuss national question; there is
no dispute upon national questions.
Suppose 1 had not. come what would
have been the iieeusntion; that. Ken
Tillinan cares no longer for Die one
gal I us und wool hut fellows; lu; has
gotten his fa) otllee ami goes about
his business. They would have
charged me with having gotten Die
swell head and growing too big for
my breeches. Then when I do come
into the campaign in obedience to
the. order of Die executive commit
tee they turn around und say he is
meddling in a fight that, he has no
concern in. Tho people of South
Carolina have enough of intelligence
to vote on tin' question without him.
it is nothing new. it. is tho Rome
old cry of '00 and '02 whan I hud
so many people on my book. It. did
not. mutter what I Bald or did, it was
I would ho damned if I did, and he
damned if I did not.
The llrst. thing I want to point out
here and direct, your attention to
is a matter which I think is absolute
ly wrong. It is that your Democratic
executive Committee has given the
candidates a hole to hide in; baa
furnished a dodge, by giving a box
in which you shall decide whether
you want prohibition or not, instead
of having the men line up ami discuss
ihe question ami not. eleot men who
will lioneyfuggle to the interest of
the public without discussion along
the line whether you want prohibi
tion or not. In '02 it was not. wheth
er you wanted prohibition or wheth
er you elected Till man governor. The
only issue today is whether the dis
pensary law will stay or prohibition
take its plaee. 'Then we will have
free whiskey. (Yells for Uoyt).
You had better quit that holler
ing, now, if you get up that old game
you will get pretty hot. I say this
business is greatly in favor of the
candidates ami gives them this op
portunity to tlodge the issue, and 1
will say that you will he fools if you
don't make every candidate for the
legislature in this county come out
and say if lie is not going to vote for
the dispensary. If the majority have
this right to vote for it you have
the right, to have our Servituts to
vote for it. Von have U0 right to let
them bring these boxes among you
without, knowing how they stand,
if they don't like it let them lump
it.
The question which concerns you,
my friends, is one of vital impor
tance, it is out; which involves the
future welfare Ulld integrity of our
children and grand-children. It is
a question of vital importance and
therefore is not. to be lightly dis
cussed and whisked aside.
Another phase of the question as
far as I am concerned why 1 am in
(his light, making- (his issue, is he
cause I have Ih'cii attacked person
al)}', and win" men undertake (o
slap me in the face, OJlll iu question
lliy actions us governor, lind when
I get cowardly enough to keep silent
it will he. time to semi me hack.
Trenton to stay.
I doil't want to mention lloyt's
name iu any other than in a most
friendly way, and just way. I did not
come here to interfere as among men.
I did not come here to say for you
to vote for or against him. I am here
to discuss the issue between prohi
bition ami the dispensary and I don't
propose to treat lloyt unfairly, lie
is a high toned gentleman, but I warn
you now Iho more you holler that
way tho less you will like it before
you get 11)rough.
Col. lloyt declared In u speech that
the dispensary law is a bastard law
and the question is how (he dispen
sary has come into South Carolina.
I am here now to tell you, and it is
entirely proper for mo to discuss it
from the stump, but Die pulpit has
taken it up and sermons are being
preached Sunday alter Sunday on it
ami saying we asked for an egg and
they gave us a scorpion, WO asked
for bread ami (hey gave us a stone.
What, were the facts iu '02, after
years resulting in county after coun
ty going dry, and turning and going
wel until special boxes were provi
ded on one side to let those vote for
it or against it V The issue was not
against prohibition but it was against
Tillmttnism and untilsm or Shepherd
ism. Iu those boxes were till,(Hit)
votes, 35,000 of these were for pro
hihition. There were 02,000 Votes,
and Ihere were 33,000 not voting on
it. Prohibition never did have a ma
jority. Tho legislature eainc to in-'
lo get me to help I hem down on the
winning side, they bad said whatever
was voted in these UOVCS we will
stand by. Prohibition had failed
but they wonted to save the twenty
five or thirty thousand majority.
Well, at that time I had just* b?6U
elected governor. In '03 22,000 ma
jority, but iu spite of that, fact, they
said, ami you can hear it said now,
I hat it was a great political machine
to further my own ambitions. In the
name of common settee what more
machinery did I want than your votes,
1 had the biggest machinery organ
ized in this State or any other Stall'.
An overwhelming majority of your
votes, ami when they say I advanced
the dispensary to create a machine,
why, how contemptible it sounds to
U man who loves the truth.
When the issue had passed, prohi
bition failed, mainly and truly
through my efforts Who hail been
elected there and tho reformers with,
and without regard to who favored
prohibition and wanted to put the
people In better condition, prohibi
tion having' failed and believing from
my observation it was an impossibil
ity. However, in view of the object
lesson given from a State that had
it. that whiskey ran riot, 1 resolved as
a public man put in office that it.
would not be good for South Carolina
to have such al aw. It. would prove
a lesson which T did not want to sec,
therefore I went to work to institute
something better. I investigated the
dispensary at Athens, On. I found
that after the town was run by prohi
bition that drunkenness was on the
increase. The prohibitionists report
ed tins to the legislature and asked
to have n dispensary for Clark coun
ty and a man to sell it. 1 reported it
to this State and got. the Senate to
substitute the dispensary as enacted,
and then got. the house to accept
that. That is the straight, plain his
tory of how I enacted the dispen
sary.
i bad a conference with a Methodist,
minister In the conference who bad
charge of the prohibition affairs. We
made several alterations in the bill
mainly at. my suggestions, some
amendments, etc. When he talked
to me he said this tight in South Car
olina was against the saloons. T be
lieve if is an iniquity and I will go
as far as any man to expell them
from the State and destroy thot
(dass of liquor selling,
When Colonel Ifoyt says it. is n
bastard law and I bad disowned my
bnhy I want, to call ins attention and
your assertion to tho absurdity of bis
remark. Here Is my version of the
story. old Prohibition, who had
been the pet of South Carolina, and
an old maid named fanaticism, lie
wanted to marry that old maid. He
t hought, he had nor. He actually had
the preacher ready when I found n
good looking young girl called Com
mon ,<;.<Mise. I said you want that old
maid but you can't, have her. Hut I
will marry you to this girl here. Af
ter persuading he agreed to many
Common Sense. The dispensary law
is the offspring of Prohibition and
Common Sense. Now, the old man
repudiates tho marriage ami s:.ys
that, he bad nothing' to do with it,
ami savs Iiis olT spring, the dispen
nary, is a bastard and he ask you
people to help him i<? get n divorce
so he cnn go to Iiis first I OVO, fanat
icism. Is tins u bastard? No, yon
know it. is not. It. If) the result, of a
legal marriage. I am the (lod-fatlier
of this baby ntid I propone to make
this old man stand up to his con
tract.
i come now to another of the at
tacks against, me. A man who goes
into the pulpit to make a political
speech nmi who-(Cheers for
fJardncr).
Tillman? I would hnve thought na
few ns you arc you would have the
decency lo keep your mouths nhul.
(Cheers). Keep it up, the more you
blow that bellows the hotter the lire
grows, in ihis sermon or political
speech which this reverend gentle
man put forth from Iiis pulpit he
lakes positions Oil the several phases
of this subject, which 1 will read to
you and discuss as briefly as 1 can,
and explain them to you.
1 will say that, if he had not. taken
tlie liberty nmong other things to
mention me by name in an insulting
and outrageous manner, 1 would al
low him to preach what. In- pleases
and pass it, without, a word. Here
is ?nie clause in his sermon:
".Nothing can alter the fact that in
selling liquor as it beverage to its
citizens for a profit, the State is do
ing an immoral act, and no sort of
logical quibbling, and no sort of dem
agogic appeal to the prejudice or the
cupidity of the people can cover up
that, fact."
He. has no authority to ask me
that. If it. is immoral to Bell whiskey
as a beverage through Stale ofllcers,
then it is equally immoral for the
State to have whiskey sold under
license through these agents who pay
for the privilege. There is not the
scintila of difference between the
conditions the ground of this light
is that it. is ti sinful and immoral
use of whiskey is derived from a pas
sage in the Uible upon which I never
heard any sermon preached but a
prohibition sermon, in my life.
"Woe unto him that giveth his
neighbor drink," and right, there
to dispute with a min:ecdlbisETAIO
they st?>p; they don't go on and
give you the whole of it. They
take the liberty with this text
as they <io with others. Nobody
likes to dispute With a min
ister about his sermons, 1 don't
like '?. But as I say they stop right
there, old what is the balance of Iba
text, "That, put test the bottle to him,
ami makes! him uruilk," ami also
"that thou nutyest look upon his
nakedness." That, you may cheat
him or bamboozle him when you
make him drunk, 1 am going to give
you another text. Here is what Sol
omon says. Here is what the wisest
man that ever lived said, (read it).
So if the people can quote scripture
I can quote them. too. There is an
other text 1 happened to stumble
over, fell on it, and 1 added it. to my
others. There is one thing these men
are doing, if nothing else, they are
making me study my Bible. I will
show you where the prohibitionists
couple their text and leave ??IT the
tail, the essential sense. They preach
immorality lo drink and sell it as a
beverage. I contend, I take it there
is nothing in (he Bible which forbids
the use of whiskey. We, believing
yotl had the right to if you had the
money to pay for it and not. abuse
it, but to control it the dispensary
law was enacted. I did not want my
fellow citizens forced in order t<> get.
whiltskey, because t hoy lowed it, to
lie and play the hyproerite, lo get
sick every time they came to town
to get, a doctor's certificate, so I sub
stituted the. dispensary system. I
stood by the law in Columbia for a
year and a half at almost, the risk of
my life. The prohibitionists harp on
the fact that hey had a majority; I
would say they did not have u major
ity. I will point to the fact, that iu
'04 they went dispensary with an ov
erwhelming majority.
The House and the Senat?' in 1805
were in favor ?>f it. In ".Hi in
favor of it, '98 in favor of it
except a few friends of pro
hibition, and now they ciiihp to us
in this year of 1000 and swear they
wer?' cheated. They expect you to
right them, lo lake the scorpion and
bruise his head ami give them a nice
loaf of bread. Well, gentlemen, you
recollect in '04 under the supreme
court we bad prohibition for three
months. You know you got more
whiskey then. You knew from ob
servation that drunkenness is de
creased in Greenville under the dis
pensary, and you Know the people
have learned t?> control their appe
tites, because they cannot. g?>f it lo
drink as they did. Then you know
when the dispensary is closed up It
stays shut and you can't, get it out
of the back door.
It, has been charged that there is
an unholy alliance bet wen the whis
key men and the church. I charged
it, and I charge it here now again.
"That, charge is too absolutely false
to receive a moment's credence from
any human being who has the slight
est lingering regard for truth left
in him. Senator Tlllman, who made
that charge, knew to be false when
he made it. The charge cannot, be
interpreted ns anything else but a
mean and coi tomptible effort to
break the force of the almost, unan
imous advocacy of prohibition by the
preachers, and served its author
as a good occasion also to throw
contempt upon a class of men for
which he has in many other ways ex
pressed contempt."
He not only charges me With slan
der in uttering those words, know
ing them to be untrue, but he goes
further and declares I uttered them
to express contempt, for men for
whom I have contempt, f stiy here
in this presence, among the people
who listen to (iardner, that. Gardner
owes it. to himself to prove it by
bringing certificates, or he owes me
an apology, 1 pronounced It a false
hood when my religion was brought
into question in '00 and '02 and they
charged me with infidelity, 1 said
then that f was a. poor fallen sinner
going from the cradle to the grave,
admitting my weaknesses and trying
<<> force!, them, but I swear no
preacher con say that I ever treated
ilim except with respect; but it is al
ways the bit. dog that howls; he al
ways howls. Is it. an alliance with
the preachers and barkeepers or
not ? Is it. true or not? (Voice Yes).
Very well. 1 will vote you on it. All
you who believe, it. not. true hold up
your right hand. Now, all you who
believe they are in an alliance writ
ten or otherwise, hold up your hand.
One more word and I am done, I am
sorry I had to bring this matter up
here, but I believe always in coming
to a man's house, face to face, teeth
to teeth, if I have a controversy to
settle, and therefore had very little
to say until 1 eanie here and I am
sorry he is not here, but his friends
will tell what I have said when he
coincs, nnil let Ii im write ay. apology
ami publish it. F believe lie is an
honorable man and that he. will do
it. One more phase of tho. ques
tion mid I am done. An effort, is being
made by the ministers of the gospel
but. f don't know whether by the ma
jority, to use the pulpit to take
charge of the polities of South Caro
lina. Not preaching the word of Cod,
an ordered by the divine minister, but.
preaching politics. In conclusion I
am going to sec tho sense here iih to
prohibition or no prohibition, on leg
islative candidates, Col. Hoyt would
tnko the constablea away, lie hopes in
some way to enforce the law, but he
cannot do it, but if you semi down to
the legislature to Columbia you will
protect tin* law, the policy ?>f the
state. Now, as I have i>?>t
had any other opportunity
, 1 wish to sco how you are
going to vote on the legislature.
, L'o repeal the dispensary law and
enact prohibition? I will ask you to
hold your right hand iu support of
the dispensary. KollII, you have
been fair and just; you have given
us a straight, report of the meetings,
hut you have been unjust, to suppress
things you should report, .Now, 1
ask you to report it as it is. Uivo
us a straight report its to the num
ber of people here. 1 would buy
twenty-live hundred in all. All you
who are going to vote for legislators
who will support the dispensary,
hold up your right hand. (Crowd for
dispensary).
THE OT11EK SPEAKERS.
At the conclusion of Senator Till
man's speech, the guberuatoriul can
didates were given an opportunity to
rid themselves of their usual speech
es.
Governor M. l>. McSweenoy, candi
date for re-election, was introduced,
lie said that he was not. here to sling
mud ami to run down his opponents
but, would make a clean speech lie
referred the voters to his record as
governor, lie said that during his
administration the dispensary law
had been rigidly enforced, that the
constabulary had done splendid
work .Mid that there had not been
any bloodshed by any of them
since he became governor. The en
forcement of a prohibition law, he
said, would be u farce and a great
harm to the people, that the law
would only move a mockerv if an
effort was made lo enforce it. lit; re
ferred to the utter failure of the pro
hibition law in Maine, Iowa and Kan
sas. After writing to the mayors of
the different cities of South Carolina.
he decided to out down the constabu
lary force und had thereby saved
the Stnte the amount, of $20,000, and
the dispensary law was now belter
enforced than it had ever been. Mr.
McSwccncy denied the charge of Mr.
Patterson that there were numerous
blind tigers in Charleston, and that
the people there well going lo vote
for McSweeney because he allowed
the tigers to exist. At. the conclu
sion of his speech Mr. McSweeney
wits presented with a beautiful bou
quet of flowers from Mrs. .1. .1. Co
wart.
Col. dames A. Hoyt was next in
troduced. He said that he did not
intend to make a speech, but felt,
called upon to answer some charges
made by Senator Tillmuu. Col. Hoys
said that he had nothing to do with
the establishment of separate boxes
for the prohibition ticket in tins
county, but that it was the work of
the majority of the county executive
committee. Tillmnn spoke of his
(Tiilmnn's) right, to be in the canvass
Col. Hoyt said that he had never ques
tioned Tiilmnn's right, to bo in tin1
State campaign and like any other
man lie had it right to be in the cam
paign if he so desired it. He said
that all the candidates would agree
with him that tho dispensary was n
machine used by politicians to gain
office, but denied tho charge that he
had said that Til I man was the con
structor of this machine. Tillman
has shown us Iiis familiarity with
the. Hilde. 1 am glad that lie has
been induced by some means to study
the Bible. In referring to a passage
in Hahnkuk which he said was the on
ly argument in the Bible for prohi
bition, Tillman said thai, Hnbakuk
was an obsolete book. Probably he
said that because be knew only until
recently that there was stich a book.
Habakuk is not an obsolete book and
furthermore there are other passages
in the Bible that, referred to Prohibi
tion.
Col. Hoyt in strong terms denounc
ed as utterly false Tiilmnn's state
ment that, the preachers were in nn
alliance with the barkeepers, lie ask
ed the question, "Who are the bar
keepers?" Don't, the blind tigers
here in Greenville g<? to the dispen
sary to buy their liquor? Are the
dispensaries in league with the
preachers? Col. Hoyt. said that it
was sinful or immoral to sell liquor,
the State of South Carolina was
then deep in sin. The condition of
Greenville and Greenville county is
now ten times worse than it. was dur
ing the ten years' enforcement, of the
local option law. At, the conculsioil
of Col. Hoyt's speech on,e of Green
ville's fairest maidens came upon the
platform and in a graceful manner
presented him with a lovely bouquet
of flowers.
O. Walt Whitman was next on iho
program. Mr. Whitman said that as
soon as he finished speaking lie would
be ready lo lake a drink. He began
by giving a history of himself and
ancestors. He said thai he was born
in Spnrtnnburg county, and that he
was proud of It. Mr. Whitman traced
his ancestry back to a rear admiral
in the ICnglish navy. He said that he
knew what it was to have a hard time
that, he had always been a bard work
ing man and could sympathize with
the poor farmers and laborers. He
said that Mr. Gary hud asked lor.
Where he was during the war, and
that, he had replied that, he was too
young to go to the war, but had
spent, flu? time behind the plow hand
les ami had lost, two brothers wdio
died lighting for their country. He
made an attack upon the State co -
leges, saying that he did not be'.'.CtO
in taxing the farmers in oredr to
run these State schools, lie asked
the voters to give him a vote and said
that if he didn't make a better gov
ernor than MeSweeney had made be
would kick himself.
Mr. Gary was introduced und began
by saying, "I contend that the bist
way to deal with the liquor question
is by the dispensary system. 1 e'nirn
that prohibition will not lead lo the
results claimed by its advocates." He
referred to a recent, visit of bis 4o the
Isle of Palms saying thai he
found numerous blind tigers there
and also in the city <>f Charleston. He
said that if Governor McSwccney
would go to Charleston and assert
his manhood instead of sending one
or tWO Constables, lie would bo able
to put a stop to the many blind ti
gers in Charleston.
Mr. Gary said that prohibition had
been tested ami proved a failure and
that the dispensary hurl proved a sue
C08S( itnt. until we can get something
better let. us keep it. lie wius oppos
ed to the high license system, but. be
lieved that each county had a right
to decide for it?plf whether it would
hnve a dispensary or not.
He advocated the establishment of
public schools, that the State could
not do better than foster the public
schools, but that he was not in favor
of pulling down the Stnte colleges.
The demand for educated men was
growing daily and if we do not fur
nish our boys with an education wo
would have to import educated men
from the north. In referring to the
old soldier he said that during his
term in the legislature he had altVHya
supported every meufsiire presented
that concerned the veterans. He
Buid he had represented his county
live limes iu tho legislature und once
in the constitutional conventiou, und
that during the last six yours he had
beeu speaker of tho House of Repre
sent at ives,
When Mr, Patterson was presented
he COUiplllined of the height of the
platform r?|ielf, ami said that he nev
er liked to have anything between
himself ami the people.
He said that he fori" the dispensary
law was adopted his OOUUty seat,
Uarnweil, at Christmas time was a
scene of debauchery and riotous coil
dtiet. Christmas, now, he said, was
like Sunday, lie said that, the prohi
bition party were not- advocating to
tal prohibition, but, wauled the sale
of liquor continued for medicinal pur
poses.
Mr. Patterson said that it was gen
erally conceded all over tho State
I that Governor McSwccney had nr.I
enforced the dispensary law. Ho said
that there were at least six hundred
blind tigers in Charleston, ami about
two hundred iu Columbia, ami that
they lltlVC been turned over to ihe
watchful cure of the police Who wt.ii
in cahoot with the tigers.
hail read Commissioner \V. I>. ICv
ans was next introduced, having been
absent when his turn came, lie said
he had tried to do his duty in his
otlicc. 'The rate on fertilizers, on
wood and other commodities, includ
ing cotton, had been reduced. As a
result the low country had shipped
its cotton to Ihe mills up here. Ihc\
had been told that the hoard hail
done nothing, thai the factories had
been driven from I he Stale, but yet
cotton mills had sorunir no all over
this country It hud been said thai
be was subsidized; that ,':is, I,. Orr
said SO. 11* Mr. Orr thinks so he has
never made any complaint to the
board. His family was as honorable
US Oil's He detailed his political
record and (old of the honors bis
home county had given him. He was
on the steering committee of the
constitutional convention ami had
been elected first vice-president of
the national association of railroad
commissioners, lie would never be
guilty of doing anything that would
bring dishonor on his wife and ten
children and promised lo serve ilie
people ill the future as in the past.
Col. .lames 11. Tillman, candidate
for lieilf cnuilt-governor, was next in
troduced, iic had heard so much
speaking that In dreamed of it at
night and lie. knew MlC 1.pie were
tired. lie was a CUUdida'C for lieu
tenant-governor and foil.- honorable
men opposed him. They had all held
oflicc before and he never had. lie
could not. refer tbeni to any ollicial
record, but there were boys in ibis
county who served under him in the
Spanish-American war. lie referred
to Col. .lohn T Sloan and bis war
record. Then to Senator Knox Liv
ingston, whom In- said lie couldn't
get. on tiny plai form. Livingston
claimed to he from the grand old
prohibition county of Marlboro.
This gave occasion for Col. Tilllliau's
snake joke, and also his roon joke.
Col. Tillman then referred to Mr.
Winkler, who, be said, was one of
l lie most ai l fill dodgers be ever saw,
Itlcasc had been as consistent as he
could, but he had one objection to
Itlcasc. When his regiment was mus
tered out, the. privates hail given him
a medal and I5lca.se presented it, sav
ing that, they hoped to sec him climb
the ladder of fame, but lilease is try
ing lo push him off the ladder now.
lie Iben briefly outlined his platform,
lie was squarely for the dispensary.
Temperance is a moral question, not
a political one. It. should be taught
al home. He was a t iod-l ea ring man
and a member of the church, but
didn't want Iiis church dragged into
politics. In every Slate prohibition
Iltis beeil a failure. Time was called
.hi him. In reply to a question, he
didn't favor pulling down any State
college.
Senator Knox Livingston said he
had heard Col. Tiilmnn's speech for
the nineteenth time and his joke had
been borrowed from a congressman
in t he Sixt h dist riet.
Col. Tillman -The congressman
borrowed it. from me.
Livingston No, sir; 1 beard hint
tell if two years ago and ho said you
borrowed it from him.
He did no! wish to be the funny
man of the campaign, but stated his
claims for the high and distinguished
olllce. From 187(1 he had endeavored
to uphold the banner of Democracy,
not onlv in the da.VS when it caught
every breeze but when liiere were
storms ami lightning1. His people
bad advanced Iii III lo bis present po
sition, and nol only bis own county
hut those nround it bad greeted him
with loild acclaim. He did hold an
Otllcc Senntor from Marlboro but
ho didn't ask the. people to jump him
from the position of private lo the
presiding oilieo of the senate, lie
asked for their suffrnge on his mer
its.
Ifo had devoted a good deal of at
tention lo the public roads. lie
wanted convicts used on the public
roads and had introduced a hill on
thill line in the senate.
He. had stood for prohibition when
public sentiment would sustain it.
if the representatives from any coun
ty wished to be exempted from the
dispensary, he would cast, his Vole
for prohibition. (Applause).
Col. Tillmnn Didn't, you vote for
Ihe Appclt bill, a local option bill'.'
Livingston A cs; it gave the people
the rieht to vote whiskey out of any
county.
His record on education was clean
and lie had ever Voted to advance
the interests of the schools. He
made no promises, btlt wanted the
oiTice on his qualifications.
Cole I.. Itlen.SC was the next can
didate for lieu I ena nt -governor. He
favored a. good school and a. good
teacher in every community and the
liberal but. not. extravagant support
of the higher colleges. He opposed
the white man's IllXC.i going to edu
cate the negro children. The pooi
man's children are paying for the
schools from which they (hi not get
the. Willie good Iis the rich people's
children who have better chance lo
secure the scholarships under the
present, system.
He favored hi-cnulnl schbIohs and
had introduced a hill for Hint pur*
pose at. tin*, last- session. There are
too many laws. [Ovcil the best law
yers cannot understand the laws.
There is no man in South Coro?
Una he honors more than Col. Hoyt,
but. when he says the people ask for
bread and they give them a slone.
lie replied that, the prohibitionists
enacted the dispensary law. They
had a majority in the legislature, but
they voted for the dispensary. Their
leader had said in the house that he
had had a. talk with that great, and
good man, Gov. Tillman, and asked
the prohibitionists to vote for the
dispensary.
As i<> the. Bible and prohibition,
you can take the Bible and prove
anything. He told a joke to illustrate
the point. Time was called on him
at this point.
C. h. Winkler, representative from
Kershuw, und ti candidate for lleuteu
nnt-governor, was n?'xt. 11?* was
making (he race <>n his record und
hud said nothing unkind of any of
his competitors. ll?* had served his
county for six years iu the legisla
t ure.
IU* stood for Ihe dispensary as a
temperance measure, and if the g?>od
people would rally to its support
(hey would have the best liquor luw
ever enacted.
()n?* of the hest signs is the Inter
est the people are taking in educa
tion, and he had done all he could for
this cause. lie had also stood up
for the old Confederate soldier, und
this wits one of the most pleasant
recollections of his life.
He had had considerable experi
ence as a presiding otllcer, having
been frequently selected to preside
temporarily over the house, lie hud
been elected three times to tllU lumso
and to the constitutional convention,
tllwtl.VB at the head of the ticket.
Col. ilno. T. Sloan was the last,
speaker for lieutenant-governor. II?'
hoped to be first on August. 28th. He
was a Piedmontcr, having been born
iu I'endlcton, and was glad to meet
ihe people of (.Irccnvillc. At sixteen
years he entered the Confederate
army and served through two of the
bloodiest campaigns. Neither Col.
Tillmnn nor anyone else L'Otlld put u
blot on his war record, anil if Col.
Til I man bad gone through what be
endured he might have the reputa
tion of a dodger. No one would do
more for the old soldiers than the
speaker. He is from Ihe Piedmont,
and believed he would gel U good
vole here. He ha?l tin' experience
for the position, having been first
elected to Ihe house from Itichlnnd,
I hen served eight years in the sen
ule, had been elected l<> the constitu
tional convention.
Ills plat form mi ? In- liquor question
w as a constitutional one. Let tin*
people ni' cneh county say what they
wan'. That is true Democracy, anil
there will never he any rest until
it is left to the people.
lie detailed how many oft leer a the
oilier candidates' counties have, and
said it was time lor the Piedmont
lo conic forward.
lie had fought for Winthrop, had
supported the Citadel and the Sooth
Carolina college, hut the schools Io
was most interested in are the com
mon schools. lie would never he
Satisfied until he saw the light of a
school house on every mountain top,
in . '. '..^community.
The . 'ales for attorney gen
eral, ti. Dunent' ""cllinger, the In
cumbent, and .1. l! Moore, of
Charleston, were both an.sent.
Slate. Treasurer Tiinmcriuan had
been obliged to leave, and Clintn
Austin read a letter he had left.
The next, speaker was I!. II. Jen
nings, of fail field, candidate for
Stale treasurer, lie came before the
people on the recommendation of
the people of his county, one which
has not. bad a Statt- otliccr in many
years. He spoke of his war record
and referred lo several (ireenville
comrades. Il.mmCUtcd on Dr.
Timmcrmun's let i er.
("apt. .1. A. Mooiiey, candidate for
solicitor, was introduced. lie. said
that if made, no difference who was
elected or what the laws wore, so
the Slate's attorney's office was vidi
filled, lb- spoke lor only a. few min
utes, and in closing introduced in
glowing terms bis opponent, Mr.
? I ulius I-'.. IJog'gs.
Mr. Hoggs threw a few bouquets
al. the. crowd and Cap). Mooiiey. He
saiil be was glad that, so many good
people had come from Pieken* to
(Ireenville; he needed them in his
business.
lie spoke of I he courage, rectitude
and indifference to cavil necessary
for the incumbent of this office.
'flu- speaking" closed shortly be
fore. G o'clock. Mr. .1. T. Johnson,
candidate for congress, had to leave
the. grounds, ami neither he nor Wil
son was called.
Probably ?00 people, stayed to the
finish.
-Haron Klemens August Frieherr
von Kottolor, the murdored German
envoy extraordinary and minister
plenipotentiary to China, was a native
Prussian and but 17 years old. Vor
awhile ho was connected with the em
bassy at Washington and became min
ister to Mexico In 1800. At this time
ho married Miss Maud Ledyard, daugh
ter of the president of the Michigan
Central railroad. Last July he whh
sent to Pokln, where ho showed him
self to be a man of considerable ability.
?A person born In the United States,
of foreign paronts who have not taken
out naturali/utlon papors in this coun
try, is a natural-born citizen of the
Unitod States, having boon born with
in its territory, and is therefore, en
titled to all the rights of a citizen. He
Is a native-born cltl/.en, indopondent
of the citizenship of his parents.
?Pckln was made the capital of China
hy tho Kmporor Yung Loh, in 1411.
Previous to that, undor the Ming dy
nasty, Nankin was tho Imperial soat of
government The population of Pekia
now Is estimated at 2,000,000 persons.
Tho northeast gato commands the city
and it was by this gato that tho allied
troops entered Pokln in 18(10.
?Wo learn that a Western woman
wsH elected mayor of hor town, one In
which that olllclal tried offenders?**
against tho ordinances. The lirat vlc-i
titn brought boforo hor was her hus
band, whom she promptly fined $20 and
then, adjourning court, proceeded to
Invest in a silk dross with tho monoy.
?The apple crop this year will be
onorraous. All through tho apple belt
tho trees aro ioadod, and every in
dication points to an abundant harvost.
Tho crop may equal tho phenomenal
ono of I ??.id. Tho outlook for poaohes,
too, Is ?xcollent.
?Grout sections of Arizona are
drought-strickon. Gattlo are dying by
thousands, and forost fires are devasta
ting immenso aroas.
?Two bundrod tishing vessels are
caught In tho ice off the Labrador
coast, and It is fearod sotno of thom
will bo lost.
oil It GKKATK8T SPECIALIST.
For 20 ycarfl Dr. J. N >wton Hathaway
ban ro successfully treated obronio diseas
es tbatbe in acknowledged today to stand
at tbo bead of bis profession in this line.
His exclusive method of treatment for
Varlcoccle and Stricture, without tue aid
of Unite or cautery cures in IX) per cent, of
all cases. In the treatment of the loss of
I Vital Forces. Nervous Disorders, Kidney
and D rinary Complaints, Paralysis, Blood
Poisoning, Kheumatism, Catarrh, and dis
eases peculiar to women, he is equally
successful. Dr. Hathaway's practice is
more than double that of any otner spec
ialist. Pases pronounced helpless by Other
phyRinians readily yield to his treatment.
Write him today fully about your case.
He makes no charge for consultation n
advice, either at bis ottloe or by mail
J. Newton Hathaway, M. D? SB1'
Uroad street, Atlanta, (?a. ,.,(j r09,