The ledger. [volume] (Gaffney City, S.C.) 1896-1907, April 22, 1902, Image 1
£
THE LARGEST
/
Circulation of An/ Ne^snaps
• in the Fifth Congressional
District of S. C.
The Ledger
SEMI-WEEKLY—PUBLISHED TUESDAY AND FRIDAY.
WE GUARANTEE
The Reliability of Every Adver
tiser Who Uses the Col-
umns of This Paper.
A Newspaper in ail that the Word Implies and Devoted to the Best Interests of the People of Cherokee County.
ESTABLISHED FEB. 10 t 1804.
GAFFNEY. S. C., TUifiSBAY, A1MUL 1004
81.00 A YKAIL
THROUGHOUT THE
PALMETTO STATE.
Items of Interest of Passing
Events.
ALL OVER THE STATE.
Event* that Have Taken Place from One
Eml of the State to the OtherCulled rrom
Exchanges for <Julck Kt-aiilng by Scores
of Busy People.
Representatives of mill supplies
and machinery dealers from five
southern states met in Charleston
Tuesday and effected an organization.
The 315th session of the South Caro
lina Presbytery closed at Abbeville
Monday. Richland church. Oconee
county was chosen as the next place
of meeting.
A petition signed by a majority of
the voters of Lee County has teen
filed with the the county board of
ntrol asking for the establishment
'f a diepensary at Scranton.
Fo*r something over two years
Sheriff Buford of Newberry has had a
warrant for Dennis Limi-ay. a negro
charged with riot and o* 1 r thine*,
and has been searching him. On
Wedne-day he cantured I. ..usay at
Bartow, in Barnwell county, and has
him safely lodged in jaii.
Thurs lay Andrew Cosby, a colored
boy living in Columbia, who was ar
rested a few weeks ago on tne charge
of trying to kill his father, was taken
before an t xtunining board and ad
judged insane. The judge of probate
made out the necessary papers for
his commitment to tne asylum.
Wallace Williams, a negro boy
about 12 years old of Union, was run
over by a freight train on the South
ern a few days ago and lost his foot.
It is said he attempted to cross the
track, and being half blind he stum
bled and fell on the tra> k but man
aged to get off all except the foot.
A. P. Aldrich, a machinist working
in the Grendell cotton mill, Green
wood, had a spell of tvpho’d fever.
He brought suit against the company
for $10, 000 damages on account of
loss of time, pain, mental anguish
and all that sort of thing. After a
trial lasting two days, the jury
rendered a verdict in favor of the cot
ton mill.
The entire faculty of Converse Col
lege in Spartanburg has been re-elec
ted with the exception of the follow
ing, who have resigned: Prof. J. F.
Brown, Miss Nina Horner, Miss Lil
lian Luitweiler and Miss Anna An-
nable. Two of these positions, so
far, have been filled. Mr. M. R.
Hamer, of Dillon, has been selected
as secretary of the college.
The governor Thursday reappointed
Maj. W. H. Gooding, of Hampton
county, to be a member of the board
of regents of the State hospital for
the insane for the term of six years
dating from April 10. Maj Gooding
is one of the oldest members of the
board in point of service, having been
-originail.v appointed by Gov Hugh 8.
Thompson in the early ’80s and hav
ing served continually since. He is
also one of the most painstaking and
valuable members.
A warrant was sworn out Thurs
day morning before Magistrate Garris
of Spartanburg, for Geo. Bowen for
larceny. It is charged that on Tues
day night Bowen entered the bouse
of C. F. Felmet, who runs a boarding
house at Converse, and stole $125 70
in cash, a watch and a pair of brass
Jcnucks. Most of the money belong
ed to E. B. Farmer, a boarder there,
and the rest, $5 20, was the property
of other parties. The watch and
part of the money were found on
Bowens person and be was locked up.
Tuesday was the 533 anniversary of
what is known as the “April snow.”
On the 15th of April, 1849. snow fell
throughout the upper part of the
State, covering the ground to a depth
of eeveral inches. The weather that
year had been balmy and vegetation
was far advanced. All the fruit was
killed, and the wheat and oat crops
were badly damaged. Corn was spring
ing up and was all killed, but was re
planted. The cold was very intense
and a great many grown trees were
killed, as they bad commenced put
ting out foliage.
Thursday the supreme court
banded down a decision in the case
of Kirby vs. Southern Railway Co.,
in which the judgment of the lower
court was affirmed. By this decision
the family of the late Ison Kirby, of
Clifton, who was killed about three
years ago by a moving train on the
Southern railway at Ciifton, will re
cover $5.(KX) damages and interest.
The attorneys in the case were C. 1‘
Sanders, Esq., for the Southern rail
way and Hon. Stanyarne Wilson and
Hon. D. E. Hydrick for the plaintiff,
•11 of Spartanburg.
There was a small wreck on the
Southern at Spartanburg Junction
Wednesday. The dining'car of No. 35
which ie left in Spartanburg for the
mbrning train, was being pushed
up to rheJunotion by the shifting
engine in order to have it reversed,
A freight train from Asheville was
standing on the track The engineer
of the shifting engine did not know
this and pushed the dinning car into
the freight train. One end of the car
was badiy broken in and the front of
the engine somewhat icj red. Con
ductor Logan was bruised, but not
seriously. »
Thursday Capt. James Mike!!, an
engineer on the government dam and
locks at Granby near Columbia met
with an accident which happily
was not serious. Capt Miaell while
crossing the S. A. L. bridge was over
taken by an express train from the
south. He attempted to reach a side
platform, but the distance was too
great and so to avoid the imminent
danger of being run down he lay
down on the outer edge f the cross
ties. As the train was passing some
hanging chain or car step struck him
in the h<^d inflicting a painful scalp
wound. Thursday night lie was
resting easliy and it i» expected that
he will sjon be out again.
The B B. Evans case, which was
to have come up in Columbia last
wvek. has been continued until next
term of court, on motion of George
Johnstone, attorney for defendant
Mr. Johnstone presented an affidavit
setting forth that a most important
witness, the defendant’s brother, was
in Waterbury, Cone where his wife
whs dangerously ill on account oi the
death of her mother. This week Mr
Johnstone has an important engage
ment elsewhere. The affidavits also
stated that Mr. Johnstone had hoped
to have the witness on hand M ed-
nesday. but the above stated facts
prevented. Solcitor 3 liurmond an
nounced that the state was ready to
try the case. Judge Buchanan gran
ted a continuance of the case on the
grounds set out in the affidavit.
CORINTH CHRONICLES.
Farmers t’lantiiiK Cotton-A Flourishing
Sunday School—Other NotdS*
(Correspondence of The Ledger.)
Corinth, April 21.—Farmers are
getting a move on themselves now.
Many of them ere planting cotton
seed, and th „ who are not ready are
preparing for it. Farmers, let me
give you a piece of advice : If you will
plant a little more of what you need,
such as corn, peas, potatoes, wheat,
oats, etc., you are sure to escape the
sheriff (as our Cowpens correspondent
says). Let us live like our friend 8
over the line in the Tar Heel State.
Mr. F. C. Hobbs, of Knoxville,
Tenn., is in our community repre
senting the Treeville Nursery Com
pany.
We hear that our friend, Mr. W.
D. Kirby, will be in the race for the
legislature, and if what we hear is
correct, bis platform is to let the
white educate the white and the cpl-
ored educate the colored. We can
agree with Mr. Kirby in this, as we
think that as much or more money is
going to the colored public schools.
We don’t mean to speak anything
against our honorable superintendent
of education, Mr. W. F. McArthur,
but we do hope that in the future our
public schools will be in a better con
dition So, let us support Mr. Kirby
and some other good man of the same
platform, as we think it would be an
advantage to our county and State.
We agree with our friend, “Oc-
tavus,” as to the men who voted in
the legislature for the eight-day road
law. Just think o'a man working at
12.J cents a day in the long summer
days! We think that we, the voters,
should pull against all such men as
that. Of course we do not mind pay
ing $1.00 road tax, but we do oppose
pauper labor. We need men to rep
resent us in the legislature who will
oppose all such laws as that. We
hope that our present members of the
bouse wont think hard of us for these
few dots that we have written, for we
think they should run for the State
senate.
Messrs. Collis Kirby and Dock
Clary, of Gaffney, poked their feet
under Mr. and Mrs. J. S. Littlejohn’s
table last Sunday.
Sunday school has again opened at
this place, and we have a good at
tendance. Mothers and fathers,
bring your children to Sunday school
every Sunday and let us have a good
school. I am sure that it will be a
help to them and probably it would
teach you something.
Messrs. Forest Petty and Fred Tur
ner were in our community last Sun
day What’s up boys? Come again
We are glad to have “Flaw” with
us again; so we can expect to hear
from the “Coalin’ Grounds” now.
Give us some good ones, “Flaw,” and
tell us how you and old “Banjo Lu”
are getting along.
There was a big hail storm in the
Goucher neighborhood last Saturday
which did a good deal of damage,
i Billie.
UNCLE SAM'S BUYS
IN THE PHILIPPINES,
Strenuous Methods Used to
Make the Natives “Talk.*’
THE WATER TREATMENT
DEBATING SOCIETY
ilEAl! ETTA JANE
Treatment of V.' a . Indian and
Negro Discussed.
The Boy*‘‘(.ettlngr Even” for the Way the
Ninth Infantry wa* Butchered at Samar—
Native* a Tieaclw rou* and Iteeeitfnl I’eo-
plewlih a LauKtiaK* Worse than ”Monkey
Talk”—••>• Non Hitcir'aud Water Treat
ment" T*ed.
(Corre^nondonee of The I.edger.)
In; an a avitk Pkov , March 11 —
Since n .• Ib>t writing <>ur “Co.” has
been n.,'Vrd to this piace. thirty miles
south f F. De MalabLD, the place
I !>*«' dirte from, but sti'l in the
'Him- 'ovir;c r ' (Cavite). And now we
are to be moved to Batangas City,
Bata? _as province about sixty miles
aout i rf here and still closer to that
dreadful place. Samar, where bolus
are used at any old time and when
you least expect them. All will re
member Samar, the place where the
galianl Ninth were butchered oniy a
few months ago. There also a few of
our boys got a slight dig soon after
thr-y arrived in connection with the
17th Infantry, when six were killed
a id fourteen wounded. But we have
< tie consolation—we have a comman
der who hates a Goo Goo worse than
any officer I know, and when he starts
after tnem is one of the fiercest horn-
bres after niggers there is in the is
lands. He believes in the water cure
for niggers that will not oblou (talk).
Now, a great many of you do not
Know what the water treatment is, so
I will try and explain it.
Well, a company is out after nig
gers, and in passing along the trail
will suddenly come to a small clear
ing and will see an hombre, or maybe
several, working for all they are
worth, as though they never did a
mean act in their lives. Still their
guns are hid in some batr/boo pole or
in the brush not far off. As the
Americans have gotten on to this
method of fooling people, we just ar
rest these honest, peaceable, hard
working nigger^, who in reality are
the ones who are causing all the
trouble over here. We try by fair
means and gentle persuasion to get
them to oblou (talk) and as they are
very true to their cause, they will not
do so. If they do not we send them
to a place nearby where water can be
found and make them drink till they
can’t drink, then pour it down them
till they have all they can hold, then
stand on their middle or stomach and
continue this till they oblou. If this
fails, which it sometimes does, we
next tie the “Nelson” hitch; grasp
them around the neck with the left
arm (standing behind them), throw
your right foot to their right and
your front, catch their right wrist and
then bring your knee in under tha
shoulder and press upward and back
at same time, which will, as you will
find, give a very nice feeling to the
entire right side of the person from
the hip up the spinal column out tha
entire arm; also, at the same time,
you want to press with all your might
against the windpipe with your left
forearm, your shoulder and body act
ing as a brace for his bead and shoul
ders, which thus adds force to your
(left) arm pressure on throat. This
generally gets the desired informa
tion, though we have failed on one so
far. But there is one less (hombre)
now. Just try the water cure, or at
least, try the “Nelson hitch” and
some time it may be of service. Of
course these methods are not allowed,
but still they are used, just as other
things that are not allowed are used.
Take Samar island ; we cannot hear
any official reports to amount to any
thing, but now and again some one
comes up from there and you can rest
assured that the boys are getting
even for the way the Ninth was butch
ered. Still it is not officially reported
for lack of means of communication
—I mean convenient.
I guess a blind man can under
stand what I mean, and who can
blame them when they think how the
Ninth was treated?
Of course this would seem cruel,
and it would be if these people were
civilized, but they are—well, the
nearest things I can compare them to
(outside of monkeys) are Indians,
which they resemble in both color
and features. They are the most
treacherous, deceitful people living,
their language, even, is worse than
“monkey talk,” no heads nor tails to
it; it is far worse than the peon lingo
of Mexico. Of course a few speak
Spanish, but very few.
Now, the above may seem strange,
but if you were over here you would
soon be convinced that it was even
more than the truth.
Well, if I write all now I will not
have anything for next time, so I will
say adiot, my Ameticano amigos.
H. M.
NEGRO NOT MISTREATED.
The Soelety w»* Orgavu/.ed Three Week*
Aro and the Hoy* aro Taking Great In
terest in it—Mowel'.'.* Ferry Working Like
a Charm—Other Note*.
iCorresponnence of The Ledger.)
Etta Jane, April 18.—We are in
clined to think the outlook for our
country is more auspicious now than
it has been for sometime. Farmers
are cheerful. They have oorne the
disaster of consecutive crop failures
v ith commendable patience, and are
go»r:j to wo'k with renewed energy.
The i tat, we believe, will ^rove a
blessing in disguise. We never x-
pect to see the masses of them take
*o little iuterat in raising provision
crops ajjai’'. They who are teachable
have iearntu a it-ssoo they wiii hardis
ever forget. ‘ Hog and hominy” i a
the slang ot the tanning masses now
and forever hereafter, we hope.
As our problems have been the
means of bringing quite a number of
hoys and girls into the contest, we
propose hereafter to offer a three-
mo' (h’s sui -ci.ption to The Ledger
to me first on»j sending correct an
swers to any of them as they appear
in The Ledger from time to *
W ith the answer we we-'
testent lo give us his or ner metnud
of solution. We want the shortest,
easiest and plainest methods—not
for publication but for examination.
i‘he winner will always get the paper,
if the solver is already a subscriber
his time will be extended three
months, or he can have the paper
sent to some friend if he wishes, for
that time. Now who will get the
prize papers?
While only one can get the paper
we will be glad to have an honor roll
of those who solve the questions.
if five men can mow thirty-three
acres in five days, working eleven
hours a day, how many days would
it take four men to reap thirty-two
acres, working ten hours a day, pro
vided they can reap^five acres in the
time they can mow six acres?
Mr. J. Wesley Smith, of Georgia,
came down today to visit his niece,
Mrs. Laura T. Estes.
The first of this month the boys
organized a debating society at the
school house. It meets every two
weeks. Last Saturday night the
subject was: Who has been the
worst treated by our people, the In
dian or the negro? It was decided
in favor of the negro, after strong
arguments on both sides. Nearly
thirty years ago we bad the same
subject in the same house, but before
an entirely different set of speakers.
Then Messrs. Barnett Moss and
Hosea Webber were both on the side
of the Indian. It was a lively debate.
Barnett was left-handed, and a black
smith by trade, and in his gesticu
lations he hammered his arguments
out with his left band as if he was
laying plows. He said: “They talk
about the ‘nigger’ being mistreated
by being buck**d down and bit two
hundred and fifty lashes on the bare-
back with a cowhide, or a buggy
trace, when be should have had at
least ten thousand. What did be
care for two hundred and fifty or
three hundred lashes,—it only made
him sleep good at night and kept him
from wanting to run about.”
Hosea capped it by saying: “Gen
tlemen, we stand on stolen ground to
night. This school house is on stolen
tn keep back the crowd but were
powerless On they rush 'd cheering
the great statesman and the occasiou
which brought them together. Women
were screaming and children culling
for help. The commands, “stand back
gentleman. stand back,” was un
heeded; no one paid any attention to
it. At last the great statesman stop
ped short in his discourse and called
out: “Stand back gentlemen, stand
back ” “It cannot be done, they
shouted. “Stand back. I say, gentle
men,” he said without a change of
voice. “It s impossible. Mr. Web
ster,” they shouted.” “Impossible?”
repeated Webster. “Impossible?
Nothing is impossible for Americans
to do on Bunker Hill.” and the vast
crowd tolled back like a mighty
wave of t he ocean.
A few vears ago old fogies were
crying ou : ‘You can’t have a new
county. You can’t have an iron
bridge or a free ferry across Broad
river ” Yuu can’t have this, that and
the o'her improvements, that now
show what can be accomplish'd
when men set their minds and mu •
cles to woik.
What a great “bugaboo” that
word “impossibility” is?
William Pitts Chatham, who was
*ii k with gout when he received a
message iroui Lord Anson that it was
impost.'We for him to tit out a fleet
within a limited rime, lock'd at the
messenger in surprise, as well as
disgust, and said: “Impossible?
Who dare talk to me of impossibility ?”
Then springing to his feet while great
drops of agonizing sweat stood upon
his brow, he said : “Tell Lord Anson
that he serves under a minister who
treads on impossibilities.”
When Nupolion was told by his
engineers that it would be impossi
ble for him to take his artillery and
cavalry across the Alps, he replied:
‘ There shall be no Alps,” and at the
head of 30,0OU men he ordered the
advance with his horses and artillery :
he overcame the apparent difficui-
ties and like an Alpine eagle eager
for its prey he swooped do«vn upon
Italy.
What a forceful declaration is
that of tfc* Apostle Paul who says :
“If God be for us who can be against
us.”
Etta Jane April 19 —Mr. Ekitor :
The answer to J. N. Swafford’s ques
tion is three and one-half hours after
the candles are lighted. His answer
to the question of a few weeks ago
was given correctly by Mr. Carr, of
Gaffney,—it is 40,9*50 acres.
The answer to “Meno’s” question
in yesterday’s paper is six and one
thousand seven hundred and eighty-
seven ten thousandths of a foot.
Were it not that “Meno” gives “J.
L. S.” a special invitation to answer
this question we would let it pass for
a few days in order to give the boys
and girls a chance at the three
months subscription to your paper.
It will be remembered that about
two years ago “J. L. S.” gave the
rule for working this special class of
problems and therefore we don’t
think it fair for him to enter the con
test in competition with deserving
boys and girls who are much our
juniors in years, at least.
Let the first one of those who sends
you a correct answer have the paper
with our best wishes. J. L s.
THROUGHOUT THE
TAR HEEL STATE.
t
From the Mountains to The
Sea.
NORTH CAROLINA NEWS.
ground Squire ’s
stolen ground, Mr.
on stolen ground, the
bouse is on
-’s house is
railroad up
here at Gaffney’s old field is on stolen
ground and the town and city that is
seen to grow up there some day will
be on stolen ground. It by right
belongs to the Indians and we have
no right to it.” It will be remem
bered that at that time the place
where the city of Gaffney now stands
was known as “Gaffney’s old field.”
The subject however was decided in
favor of the Indians.
The subject for Saturday night
2(>tbinst., is: ’“Resolved, that the
art.of man is more attractive to the
eye than the works of nature.
Come down, Mr. Editor, and hear the
boys and take part with them. They
make things lively when they get
stirred up.
The rigging of the ferryboat at
Howell’s ferry works like a charm.
When two such counties as Cherokee
%nd York undertake a work it is to
accomplish it. This remark recalls
an incident which took place when
Daniel Webster delivered his memor
able oration at the dedication of the
Bunker Hill monument. The crowd
pressed forward to and around the
stand until women, children a^nd old
men were fainting from heat and
suffocation. The officers were trying
,.a»hed Between Cara.
IaC. Hugh A.Stead, a car coupler on
the Salisbury yard of the Southern,
was caght between two cars and crush
ed to death about 8 o’clock Saturday
morning, near the freight transfer
shed in Salisbury. The cars were
equipped with the automatic couplers
required by law and it was not in the
act of makiog a coupling that the
accident occurred. He was trying to
pass between the two disconnected
sections of the train as they were
being brought together, probably
preferring to make the coupling from
the other side, but misjudged the
distance and the cars closed on his
body at the waist. The unfortunate
man’s injuries were too horrible to
be described A pistol in a hip pock
et was twisted like wire and forced
through the flesh He was taken,
still living, to the Whitebead-Stokes
Sanitarium, where be lingered two
hours. Mr. Stead was 25 years of
age and had been in the employ of
the Southern for four years.
/ A Gentle Hint.
In our style of climate, with its
sudden changes of temperature—rain,
wind and sunshine often intermingled
in a single day—it is no wonder that
our children, friends and relatives are
so frequently taken from us by neg
lected colds, half the deaths resulting
directly from this cause. A bottle of
Boschee’s German Syrup kept about
your home for immediate use will pre
vent serious sickness, a large doctor’s
bill, and perhaps death by the use of
three or four doses. For curing Con
sumption, Hemorrhages, Pneumonia,
Severe Coughs. Croup or any disease
of the Throat or Lungs, its success is
simply wonderful, as your druggist
will tell you Get a sample bottle
free from Cherokee Drug Co. Regu
lar size. 75 cts. Get Green’s Special
Almanac.
lutereNting Item* Concerning Our Neigh
bor* Deyoud the Line Which May Prur*
Entertaining Reading for Hundreds ol
Ledger Readers.
Anoth'-r silk mill is soon to be
erected at Fayetteville.
It is rti:iiored that the Southern
Railway will locate large repair shops
at Char!' ' te soon.
David C. Lnughlin, of Henderson,
known formerlj in circus life us Cas
te.le, the rider, haff both feet cut off
while tryinir to board a moving train
ui Hamlet Saturday.
The wife of R v. H. M. Blair, edi
tor of the North Carolina Christian
A vocate of Greensboro, died sudden
ly at her home in that city Friday
evering after an illness of only a few
hours.
Frank Shaw, colored, was hung at
Lumberton Tuesday for the murder
of his sweetheart. Mary Ferguson,
last November. He was tried and
convicted at the F-bruary term of
court and was tbiice given a respite
by the governor.
Henry StO'k ; i fanner l ; v ty near
Snow Hill, is c r.fined in ti ■ Greene
county j ti! charged with l ie killing
of IDnry Weber, a young man who
was in his employ. Stocks and Web
er had quarreled, the result of a mia-
uinjersiaudicg about some work,
being done.
Allen Cogsdell, an aged farmer of
means in Rutherford county, has pre-
nared to commit suicide in a spectac
ular manner. He has issued invita
tions to bis friends to a dinner to be
given on June 10th. At 11 o’clock
that day he will give his friends an
opportunity of seeing him commit
suicide by shooting himself.
Some Syrians who keep a taffy
store in Concord, were badly Imposed
on Friday night by a negro who went
in to trade and passed a $20Confeder
ate bill over the counter, receiving
$13 in good money as change coming
to him. After finding out how they
had been cheated search was made
for the offender but without coming
anywhere within sight of him.
The sensational case of Flauner vs.
Butler was decided in the Superior
Court in Wilmington Friday in favor
of the plaintiff, who is awarded a val
uable store on Front street, valued
at $7,000. The plaintiff, however,
contended for other residence proper
ty in the city valued at about the
same amount, and both sides took ao
appeal to the Supreme Court.
Thursday afternoon George, the
four-year-old son of J. L. Wilson, of
Begonia, in Gaston county, got hold
of a bottle of arsenic which was being
prescribed for Blanche, his older sla
ter, who is sick. He drank the con
tents. It was soon discovered and
Dr. G. R. Patrick at once summoned.
Timely medical attention averted the
danger and the boy was getting along
well at last reports.
W. W. Hunter, brakeraan on south
bound through freight No. 63 on the
Southern, while cutting off the cab
at the water tank in Gastonia
Wednesday afternoon to leave a car,
lost bis footing and fell. His left
heel was caught under the wheel and
smashed very badly. He will be con
fined for some weeks. His home ia
in Charlotte but be is staying at the
Gastonia Inn till he gets better.
A little boy in Monroe, two aod a
half years old, found some matches
at bis aunt’s home and struck a num
ber of them, setting fire to his clothes.
He ran into the streets screaming and
a colored boy came to his aid and ex
tinguished the flames. His outer
garments were almost completely
burned off, but the child’s injuries
are not serious. Pass it to the col
ored boy’s credit that be saved tha
child from being burned to death
A man named John Berry or John
Beattie, going by both names, waa
struck by a train one mile from
Cberryville Friday while intoxicated,
in a most unusual manner. The fel
low was sitting on the end of a cross
tie but seeing the train coming ha
staggered away a short distance, bat
just as thd engine came past him ha
gave a sudden dive as intoxicated
men will do, apparently aiming his
head at the engine wheels. He fell
but escaped the wheels and waa
struck by the steps of the baggage
car and was knocked around in a cir
cle. The train was halted and invea-
tigation made. The man had tha
clothing of the right shoulder knock
ed off but little damage was suffered
by him.