The Anderson daily intelligencer. (Anderson, S.C.) 1914-1915, February 05, 1915, Page PAGE SEVEN, Image 7
WITH PEEPLE
(CONTINUED FRO?a PAGE ONE.)
tion I phoned you asking for an ap
pointment with you fer five o'clock
that afternoon in my room at the Je
rome Hotel. At the outset of my ad
ministration I was in urgent nerd of
legal advice on a number of matters,
including the pending Asylum investi
gation, the order to disband the mili
tia and other questions. You came to
my room at the Jerome Hotel at five
o'clock that afternoon and again dis
cussed the matter with me in the pres
ence of Mr. Benet, who had been pres
ent et the former conversation. At
that time you stated to us that to
your great embarrassment you were
not able to get Mr. Dominick to re
sign; that you had asked him to re
sign last summer and again since the
campaign; that you had had mutual
friends to go to him and state that
he was embarrassing you and your
conduct of the office by insisting on re
taining his position as youl assistant;
that you bsd not been able to make
bim consent to give up the office, al
though you still hoped that he would
do so. You stated that Mr. Dominick's
work wgs not satisfactory; that he
bad been absent from the office with
out your consent or even knowledge;
that he bad on occasions left the of
fice on Friday morning and stayed
away until Tuesday night; that this
was hot satisfactory to you nor to the
conduct of the business of the office,
but that you were powerless In the
matter. You stated that when tho cam
paign began last summe, you had gone
to him and asked fer his resignation
on the ground that you were in the,
campe ign yourself, that he was a can
didate tor Congress and dat Inas
much as you had to maka the State
tour with the campaign pirty, the of
fice of the Attorney General would
be closed unless your Assistant were
there; that he had declined to resign,
which had caused you great embar
rassment and had forced you to leave
the State campaign party a number
of times to attend to matters in the
office which absolutely required at
tention. *
? You again stated that you personal
ly were snxloua to work in harmony
with my administration, but that you
could not get rid of Mr. Dominick;
that you regretted this, and that you
still boped the matter would work It
self out.
i." I have never Intimated to you or to
anyone e se that I wanted you to
appoint any particular man, nor do 1
v now do so. You'havo an absolute right,
legal and otherwise, to appoint whom
you please; but in view of thevolun-.
tary statements and assurances you
had made me, I was glad to discuss
Ute appointment with you: while in
view of the peculiar unsultableness
of the appointment of Mr. Dominick,
X have a right to protest, not because
of any personal feeling against him,
but upon the grounds that Mr. Domin
ick, having been the law partner of
the former Governor, his campaign
manager and his close confident and
partisan, political and Otherwise,
would be opposed to the carrying out
of the changes in our government
which the people by their vote, bist
August, ordered done. In considering
appointments distinction must be
made between thoso twp offices where
the duties are of an administrative
character and those where the duties
are advisory. In the one case, difieren-1
ees as to political association are not
especially important; In the other,
lack of sympathy and conviction
necessarily prohibit co-operation.
I am disappointed that you do not
' seem to realise the absolute necessity
of every branch of the government
co-operating fully with complete con
fidence, in order to put into effect the
expressed mandates of the people. .
In frankness, I can but feel that you
could not be uninfluenced by the opln
- lots and association ot Mr. Dominick In
matters submitted to your office, when
yod have admitted to me that you had
asked him to resign, but were not
able to make him do so.
I am giving out the correspondence
for publication.
Yours truly,
RICHARD % MANNING.
Should Appoint Man la Sympathy
With Administration.
January 21. 1911?.
Hon. Thomas H.. Peoples, At t'y. Gen.,
Columbia, 8. C.
33o&r Sit* *
As I have said to you heretofore, I
was elected to the office of Governor
upon a platform In opposition to the
policies which have prevailed in this
S<D.CA for the last four years, and
lt, therefore, desirable that your assis
tant should be ? man tn sympathy
with my polic?as. You have seen flt
to appoint Mr. Fred H. Dominick your
assistant, who. waa a supporter of the
policies ot my oredecessor lu this of
fice.
in these circumstances i do not tees
that 1 can rely upon your office for
legal advt?*- I ?hall need legal advice
In the administration of my office, ai>d
therefore shall be compelled to cali
this matter to the attention of the leg
islature-for such action as they may
L-flt to take, If you Insist in making
this appointment.
Please let me have your reply.
Very respectfully,
RICHARD I. MANNING.
Governor.
Attorney General Terns Governor's
Letter Bess** for Dismissal of
Assistant.
Columbia. 8. C., Jan. 23, 1?16.
Hon. Richard L Manning.
Governor of South Carolina,
Columbia, fl. ?.
Slr:
I am tn receipt of your letter ot the
Slat last, wherein you sabstaniisUy.
if not expressly, demand that I shaU
rescind the appointment made by me
of. Mr. Dominick aa my. assistant, and
tn the event I do not, you practically
threaten to call my refusal to rescind
anet: order, and appel?t such person
I NOT INTERFERE
|j|?g|Nj
that will be satisfactory to what vou
term your ''policies." to the attention
of the legislature for such action ns
they may see flt to take.
I shall endeavor to answer younlct
ter, so surprising in its character and
so disagreeable in its tone, ss cour
teously as my feelings will penni..
I haft occasion to reply to a letter
of yours, inquiring as to what recom
mendations I would make In my re
port, so that you might incorporate
them in some message designed by
you to be sent to the Legislature. In
doing so, I expressly declared to you,
with great sincerity and candor the
following sentiments: "I shall be glad
at any time to confer with you upon
any of these subjects (alluded to in
my letter) and shall always be pleased
to carry out any of the directions that
you, as Governor, shall make within
t'.e powers conferred upon you by the
constitution and statute laws of our
State. With much regard and with a
sense of duty towardB you, as the leg
al adviser of the officers of the State
and tho head of the Department ot
Justice of such State, and as that head
to serve you as thc Chief Executive
officer of the State, I remain, etc.
This statement then expressed, I
still entertain and there will bc no
effort lacking upon my part lo per
form my duties and to cooperate, as to
the duties devolved upon hie, with you
in any matter becoming our duty- to
discuss or to take action upon.
By the constitution of this state,
Article IV, Section 24, it is declared
that "there shalt be elected by the
qualified voters of the State .'?**"-)'.
an Attorney General (and other offi
cers therein mentioned) . . . . .
who Shall hold their respective offices
for a term of years and until their
several successors have been chosen
and qualified; and whose duties and
compensations shall be prescribed by
law."
It is again, by Article V, Section 28,
declared: "There shall be an Attorney
General for tho State, who shall per
form such duties as may be prescribed
by law. He shall be elected by the
qualified electors of the State for the
term of two years, and shall receive
for his services euch compensation as
shall be fixed by law."
By the Code of the Laws of 1912,
Vol, 1, Section 710, the Legislature,
in pursuance of the terms of the con
stitution, enacted: "The Attorney
General shall receive a salary at thc
r.ite of nineteen hundred dollars pei
'annum and the Assistant Attorney
General, who shall be appointed by
the Attorney General, shall receive a
salary of thirteen hundred and fifty
dollars per annum." <slnce increased.)
The powers and duties of the At
torney General aro further provided
for in subsequent sections, to whict
reference is asked to enable you tc
have a clc%r comprehension of thc
powers, duties and limitations of thc
office. I now hold and especial attcn
tion Is Invited io Beetioh. ?17: "I!*
(Attorney General) shall, when re
quired by the Secretary of State
Treasurer. Adjutant a.id Inspectai
G?n?ral. Comptroller General. Rail
road Commissioner,: or other State of
fleer, consult and advise with them
respectively, on questions of law, re
latlng to their official business."
An examination of all> of the Statu
tes and law relating to my office wil
shew, (aside from the duties devolved
upon the Attorney General a J ex-of
flclo member of certain boards, which
ho can exercise not by assistants hut
personally) that it was never In con
templation nor within the purview of
tho Constitution or of any of the Acts
of the General Assembly to make the
office of Attorney General as legal ad
visor of the different departments, a
political one in the sense of haviug the
oolnlons, which lt ls the duty of the
Attorney General to render biased by
what yod may term, or have termed,
yorr "policies." or that of any oftlcer
of the State t'? whom it is my duty to
give a legal opinion. It would he clear
ly an anomlnaly of law and good sense
to uttempt to blas or prejudice the
view of the law in Its construction
of the statute hy the attorney general
because of the political party or pnrty
factlon to which the Governor or any
officer of the State may for the time
helm: belong. I must, therefore, insist,
and UH long as 1 am Attorney General
will insist, upon giving my opinions
as to what I conceive to be the law,
whether it is in sympathy with this,
that or any other narty or partisan. I
would he unworthy of the position,
and so would any other man, who
considers himself In the position ol
having to render opinions and adrice
to officers of the State except as he
conscientiously believes the law tc
be, Irrespective of all political poli
cies or other views.
It IK quite true that you have taken
occasion to state to me. heretofore
that you had been elected to the of
fice of Governor upon a platform lr
opposition to the policies which hav<
prevailed in the office of Governor Poi
tho last four years. This was a mattel
of which I had no concern and ha vi
novdr entertained any. Tl J?, ad-vio
given from this office, whether b;
myself or assistant, bears no color o
faction or of party. My personal pref
crences. as to who should hold ollie
in South Carolina, has never in ll ur-n
ced or swayed tho construction of an;
Statute, or constitutional provisto]
which has been submitted to me, no
has the prescribed duties made ' b
Statute been view hy me, when askc
as to their menning and-as to what ac
tlon should bc taken under the, eve
been rendered in view of any polic
which <waB thought best by the Exe
cutlvo Officer.
It is further known to me that you
views, or at least your exprcssloni
have been in accord with your preeh
cessor's In office, to whom you aliud*
and that your election may be cor
strued as an endorsement of this b
the majority of the people voting t
the primaries.'and that you will I
held responsible for carrying out sue
views, whatever they may be. I do n<
profess to have made any carefi
study of your platform or of yoi
spf eches. While you may thus prope
ly indulge.In (Ike idea, I must cn
your attention to the fact, that, ha'
lng served two years as Attorm
General, that 1 was oleted to my o
flee by a-majority of the votes of tl
qualified electors of thc people, pro
ably by ns many as' you received; ai
I Indulugo. the presumption that ll
conduct of my office, for tho two yea
in which I have held lt, has been e
dorsod by tho majority of the pe
plc of Sooth Carolina, and that th
will hold.me responsible for the pr
por conduct, of my office. I am tht
servant. I certainly am not the at
vant of the Governor of tho Sta
whoever he may he.
. For nearly fifty years, the Assli
ant In the office of the Attorney Gc
eral-one time designated as Clerk,
now as Assistant Attorney Gcner
has > been considered a personal a
confidential appointment-tbe Atti
ney General being entirely rcspon
ble for everything occuring in his i
IF SKIN BREAKS
OUT AND ITCHES
APPLY SULPHUR
Uso it like a cold cream and
dry Eczema eruptions
right np.
Tho moment you apply bold-sulphur
to au Itching or broken*out skin, the
itching stop? and healing beginn, saya
a renowned dermatologist.
'1 los remarkable sulphur maiio into a
thick cream effeet? mich prompt relief,
even in Aggravated Eczema, that ft 5??
a never-ending source of atuateinent to
physicians.
For many year? hold-Milphur has oc
cupied a secure position in the treat
ment of cutaneous eruptions ,by reason
of it* ooolim?, paraaite-destroying prop
erties and nothing liait ever been lound
to take its place in relieving Irritable
and inflammatory affections <>, tho akin.
While not always establish ir. ? a perma
nent eure, yet -in .-very instance, it
iinmeHiivtoly "subdues the itching irrita
tion and heals the Eczema right up and
it is often year? later liefore any erup
tion again manifests itself.
Any good druggist will supply an
ounce of bold-sulphur, which should be
applied to the affected parta like the
Ordinary com creams It isn't unpleas
ant anil the prompt relief afforded is
'.cry welcome, particularly when the Ec
zema ia accompanied willi torturous itch
lng,
flee. Tho legal, personal and other
oualificallons ot such Assistant ls a
matter entirely that has heretofore,
under all conditions and changes, been
considered to be tHe peculiar affair of
the Attorney General in making his
selection.
Mr. Dominick has been my assist
ant for nearly thc entiro period that
I have been attorney general. Tho
people In electing me, as I have a
right to presume, endorsed him also
as an of tidal In my office and certainly
I heard throughout the entire cam
paign no objection made to bim.
You practically request me to
surrem .? the right and the duty of
selecting auch assistant, given mo
by the General Assembly, and to re
strict lt to such person as may be in
"full symnathy with my (your) per
sonal policies."
Admitting for a moment this claim
of yours, no office in any department.
I Judicial, legislative or otherwise, in
whom ibo Legislature bas vesteu the
right of anr.Mmmer.t of assistants,
could bold oft - 9 bave by your grace
and by your command. For example,
the Secretary vf State. Comptroller
General, and the State Treasurer, *nd
state BoardB which could bc men
tion- d.
As stated alcove, the express term of
the Statutes provides that I shall ren
der advice to the different officers of
the State and'take appropriate action^
In the premised'I should not have con
sidered it toomuch of an encroach
ment of. my rights if, on account of
personal feelings which you .may have
towards Mr. Dominick, you had re
question that all communications be
twoen you and myself should be taken
up by me Individually, and that Mr.
Dominick should not 'ie brought Into
contract with* ? your office, but the
slightest reflection upon your part, lt
seems to me, would show you that the
terms of your, letter ls doing Mr.
SPEAKS HERE SUNDAY
I
IL' .. .. .
. |B3
Rev. Millard A. Jenkins, D, D.
Whennen i ///////c ?>
Thinks af'
GOOD Clot
j Parker 6Bott
Dominick a personal injury, and mak
ing yourself the manager v>f my of
fice.
I do not recall any statute which
fixes a doltnlto period or term of of
fice of the assistant, but leave the at
torney general in position. If there be
objection made, or If he so desires, to
ask. at any time, for the (Hero follows ,
a line not legible-typewriter copy.) I
that would justify my asking for his |
resignation, to do BO, nnd have some
one else appointed, but upon such a ?
btatement-that he is hot in sympathy
wltu your "Policies." I cannot and !
will not undertake to act. It is too
lndrf.nlte, too unfair and unjust, for
me to treat any one. let alone a man
who has been faithful in his work, and
who. 1 am glad to say, has met with
the approval and good opinion of the
Judiciary of the State, and who I do
not believe can be called incompetent
or who would fall below the average
predecessors.
Besides, the solicitors of the State
arc a part of my deportment and act
under my instructions, and, I believe,
in some cases under yours directly.
They are elected by the people of
their several circuits. I do not say.
or undertake to say, that these gentle
men would not fulfill the duties of
their offices and respond to any call
that you might make upon them, or act
In full cooperation with me. The point ?
of your attack, however, seems only
to bc directed against an assistant in
w office, who has no Initiative what
ever and who is solely responsible to
me whose duties can be circumscribed
or limited by me or whose tenure of
office can be terminated at any time
by mc. I ara sure, upon reflection, that
you will find no precedent for the de
mand you make upon me, historically
or politically.
With regard to the threat that you
make of bringing the matter to the
?attention of he legislature-why you
I must take whatever course you see flt
about the matter; but I roust suggost
I to you that this method of expression
and tone of communication is not
pleasant and is not characteristic of
groper official communications.
I have endeavored, as stated, to
divest myself of any feeling on this
subject, in makins my reply to you. I
still desire to serve in t o best way
1 can, the people who have done rae
the honor to elect rae to thc ofllce of
attorney general. I shall not at any
one's suggestion, lay down those
duties voluntarily, but will endeavor
to maintain the rights of my office apd
to perform its duties.
Please distinctly understand that ?
am, as such attorney general, ready to
confer with you and to communicate
with you upon my question relating
to my office ai. > the performance of
ita duties, as the law defines.
I have only one request to make of
you, which I have nb doubt you will
gladly grant, should you communicate
with the general assembly upon tho
subject matter of your letter, be kind
enough to incorporate a copy of your
letter to mc and my reply thereto.
I am,
Very respectfully,
(Signed) THOS. H. PEEPLES.
Attorney General.
Letter Was Not a Demand.
Columbia. 8. .C., January 28, 1915.
Hon. Thomas H. Pecples, Attorney
General, Columbia, S. C.
Dear Slr. I have your letter of
January 22nd. My lotter to you of the
21st inst., relating to the appointment
of the SBtdstant attorney general, was
not intended to be. and was not, a de
mand upon you; nor was it an at
tempt on my part to dictate whom you
should appoint as your assistant. My
letter was prompted and suggested by
the conversations which you and I
have had upon this subject, in which
yon assured me that you would make
no appointments to that office without
a conference with me, and would ap
point no one who would be embar
rassing to me, and, lastly, that lt was
your desire to appoint some one who
would be In harmony with ray admin
istration.
I have never questioned your legal
right to appoint whom you pleased as
your assistant, but In view of what
had heretofore passed between us, I
was justified In assuming that you
would make no appointment that
would embarrass me in my communi
cations and intercourse with your of
fice.
In your letter of the 2nd you make
statements in reference to Mr. Domi
nick which are In direct conflict with
those made by you in the conversa
tions which you have had with me in
regard to tho appointment of your as
8PECIALLT SELECTED Buff Rock
eggs for sale. $1.50 per ir.. W. H.
Milford, R. No. ?, Anderson, 8. C.
slstant. In Justice, to myself I will
be obliged to make a public statement
of a!! the fscts should occasion re
quire.
Very respectfully,
(8lgned) RICHARD I. MANN INO,
Governor.
Dominick His First Consideration.
Columbia 8, C., January 28, 1916.
Hon. Richard I. Manning. Governor of
South Carolina, Colombia, South
Carolina.
Dear Slr? I am in receipt of yours
of the SSth Inst, The position I hare
:aki n in the several conversation had
with you at your request in connection
with the appointment of the assistant
attorney general was that Mr. Domi
nick was my first consideration tn this
appointment, and that in tho event of
his refusal to accept the appointment
or of a vacancy I would he glad to
confer with you as to the appointment.
I assured you at the time that my
ofllce would work in ?hearty coopera
tion with yours, regardless of who
the assistant attorney general may be.
I still stand ready and willing aa the
legal adviser of the officers of the
Slate and the head of this department,
to serve you as the chief executive o'
th? Stat-i and to perform such ditt'.-s
aa arc ii icsod upon me nv tho coufctl
httion nnu laws of 'hi: Stat - m li?r
mor.v v Ith oil departments or th?
BtaU
'. have- ro*. the slightest mju'tlvu to
tito r?<:t4 lr connection wUb this mat
ter being -lade public.
Very rosepi-i/dily,
iSixncoj Tiios ti. I*K.: -i :.s.
Attorney General.
ooooooooooooooooo
o o
o WEST PELZER o
o o
ooooooooooooooooo
Miss J. Conway Carlington, tho
county agent for tomato club work,
visited our school luBt Friday. Jan
uary 22. She gave an interesting talk
on tomato growing. Sevorl girls Join
ed the club.
Mr. Lothrock also visited our school
last week and talked to the corn club
boys. We were very sorry to lenrn
that this was his laut visit to u \ as
he ls not going to hold the olllce an
other year.
The Hampton Literary Society
elected new olflcers at the last meet
ing-Ellison Padgett, proBldcnt; Mar
garet Welborn. vice president and
Mae Johnson, eecretary and treasur
er. Tho society voted to meet on
Thursday afternoon instead of Frl
day afternoon so those who have to
work on Friday can bo" present. The
following program was rendered at
the last meeting:
Janie Strickland, reader; Jack
Woodcock, declaimer. Tho debate.
"Resolved. That Monday would be a
better school holidays than Satur
day," was discussed by the following:
Affirmative, Lizzie Black, Ruth Dowls
and Harold Davenport; negative. Loyd
Whitton, Casper Caldwell and Mande
lino Holiday. Tho Judges decided in
favor of tho affirmative.
Two of the teachers. Misses Jessie
Norris and Margie West, returned to
Frankville alter a very pleasant vlBit
to their homo.
MAY JOHNSON.
MARGARET WELBORN.
THIRTEEN WAR DECLARA
TIONS.
Since Austria-Hungary first declar
ed war against Servio, on July 28, the
number of war declarations exchanged
'botwoo? the various ?.tatea has grown
to 13. viz:
1. Austria-Hungary against Servia,
July 28.
2. Germany against Russia, August
1. i
3. Germany against France, August
8.
4. Germany against Belgium. Au
I gust 4. j
b. England against Germany, Au
gust 6.
C. AuBtria-Hungary against Russia,
August 5.
7. Montenegro against Austria, Au
gust G.
8. Servia against Germany, Augusl
6.
0. Montenegro against Germany Au
gust ll.
10. France against 'Austria-Hun
gary, August ll.
11. England against Austria-Hun
gary, August 13.
12. Japan against Germany, August
23.
13. Austria against Belgium, August
29. V
0 ia. ?ail ri?i? ia wi un Sw s i on
All new. Military Tb Uber*. Famous Anioskeatr
ticking. O M yarta\otlcfc, iKmlilvoiy bimreat
and boat bod on marke Mung for loss tbnnxiz,
Sato delivery and ault ifucUon guaran iced or
money book. OrJor kuli y cr writ?? for catalog and
big spacial offer. Viral oplrr eninta on pr- minni.
JMITABY SMOIIQ COMPr'.f, But. SCO. Ourlet!?. S. C.
Something For Nothing
Younga Island, S. C., Nov. 23, Ult,
Tu get darted with you wo mateo
you tho following offer. Send CH $1.5?
for 1,000 Frost Proof Cabbage- Planta,
grown in the open air and will stand
freezing, grown from tho Celebrated
Seed of Dolgina & Son and TborboA
& Co., and I will send you 1.0)0 Cab*
bago Plants additional FREE, and yow
can rep-at the order as many time?
as you like. I will give you special
prices on Potato Seed and Potaba
Plants later. Wo want the accounts
oi close buyers, largo and small. We
r?& supply all.
Atlantic Coas*
Plant Co.
Lavalli?res
A lady came into my place a
few days ago and said that she
had heen all over town looking
for a LaValliere.
I felt a little bad as ? was the
last on the list. But when she
wrote a check for $50.00 and put
on one of the prettiest LaVallieres
I had, 1 felt better.
LaVallieres from $3.00
to $50.00.
Next Door NE^ STATION
Beautiful
Genere
Photos
ot your children made at your
home.
Keep a record o? your Child,
it wQl be a treasure in oki age.
Let us know when to call.
Greco's
Art Shop
On The Square.
with
? PITTSBURGH PERFECT n
Poultry and Garden Fence
Th? U the verdict of every man and woman whose noulity quarter? or gardens
are cncWd wah thu fence. What more than perfect s?'isfaction can one desire?
ll U th? W?h onatity Op.? Hearth wiro. Cl? old Um* Iron wire. p?rfoeUy S*tv*oi*?d
mmd mad? into (twi by {>u?pi?r?biy joinins ?Ur ?ad Unod witt* my ."MT*""*"*
ELECTRIC WELDING
EVERY ROD GUARANTEED PERFECT
m WELD
J? Sullivan Hardware Co.
^ggg Anderson. - - - Belton ^tfiflr