The Horry herald. (Conway, S.C.) 1886-1923, April 04, 1912, Image 12
I
?i-.
1
g?,' "
PROTECTION OF PROFITS, ]
THE INIQUITOUS POLICY OF THE
REPUBLICANS FOR HALF A CENTURY i
The One Question Eternally Present is the Most Effective, the
Most Efficient and the Fairest Way of Equalizing
tho Rurrlono nF To\/n+!
tlit? UUIUDUO Ul I aAaLIUli
Mr. Underwood Would Have the Question Solved with the
Determination to do the Right, Safe and
Reasonable Thing
Speech Before the New York Southern Society Dec. 16, 1911
The kaleidoscope of political issues must and will continually change with
the changing conditions of our Republic, but there is one question that was '
with us in the beginning and will be in the end, and that is the most effective,
efficient and fairest way of equalizing the burdens of taxation that are levied by 1
the National Government. Of all the great powers that were yielded to the
Federal Government by the States when they adopted the Constitution of our
country, the one indispensable to the administration of public affairs is the
right to levy and collect taxes. Without the exercise of that power we could i
not maintain an army and navy; we could not establish the courts of the land; <
the government would fail to perform its function if the power to tax were
taken away from it. The power to tax carries with it the power to destroy,
and it is, therefore, a most dangerous governmental power as well as a most
necessary one.
There is a very clear and marked distinction between the position of the :
two great political parties of America as to how power to tax should be
exercised in the levying of revenue at the custom houses.
Republicans Have Always Stood for Protection.
The Republican party has maintained the doctrine that taxes should not
only be levied for the purpose of revenue, but also for the purpose of protecting
the home manufacturer from foreign competition. Of necessity protection
from competition carries with it a guarantee of profits. In the last Republican
platform this position of the party was distinctly recognized when they declared
that they were not only in favor of the protection of the difference in
COSt at home and ahrrmrl hut slcr. o A
_ ? ? ??vMk u ivojuiiaui^ yi uuu iu rvmcrican maustnes. I
Democratic Party for Tariff for Revenue Only.
The Democratic party favors the policy of raising its taxes at the custom
house by a tariff that is levied for revenue only, which clearly excludes the
idea of protecting the manufacturer's profits. In my opinion, the dividing 1
line between the positions of the two great parties on this question is very
clear and easily ascertained in theory. Where the tariff rates balance the ]
difference in cost at home and abroad, including an allowance for the difference
in freight rates, the tariff must be competitive, and from that point ,
downward to the lowest tariff that can be levied it will continue to be com
petitive to a greater or less extent. Where competition is not interfered with
by levying the tax above the highest competitive point, the profits of the 1
manufacturer are not protected. On the other hand, when the duties levied
at the custom house equalizes the difference in cost at home and abroad and
in addition thereto they are high enough to allow the American manufacturer
to make a profit before his competitor can enter the field, we have invaded ,
the domain of the protection of profits. Some men assert that the protection
of reasonable profits to the home manufacturer should be commended instead !
of being condemned, but in my judgment, the protection of any profit must
of necessity have a tendency to destroy competition and create monopoly, I
whether the profit protected is reasonable or unreasonable.
Unfairness of Protection.
You should bear in mind that to establish a business in a foreign country .
requires a vast outlay both in time and capital. Should the foreign manufacturer
attempt to establish himself in this country he must advertise his
goods, establish selling agencies and points of distribution before he can sue- ,
cessfully conduct his business. After he has done so, if the home producer is
protected by a law ^iat not only equals the difference in cost at home and
abroad, but also protects a. reasonable or unreasonable profit, it is only neces
sary for him to drop his prices slightly below the point that tjjr* .aw has '
^pMPi^orbercotne' a%EankruptTkcause*fte tf&HTa''img
and not a profit if he continued to compete. The foreign competi^f having
retired, the home proikicer could raise his prices to any level that home competition
would allow him and it is not probable that the foreigner who had
already been driven out of the country would again return no matter how
inviting the field as long as the law remained on the Statute Books that would
enable his competitor to again put him out of business.
Iniquity of the Protection of Profits.
Thirty or forty years ago when we had numbers of small manufacturers,
when there was honest competition without an attempt being made to restrict
trade and the home market was more than able to consume the production
of our mills and factories, the danger and the injury to the consumer of the
country was not so great or apparent as it is today when the control of
many great industries has been concentrated in the hands of a few men or a
few corporations, because domestic competition was prohibited. When we
cease to have competition at home and the law prohibits competition from
afernad hv nrntertintr nrnfits. there is no relief for the consumer excent to crv
out for government regulation. To my mind, there is no more reason or
justice in the government attempting to protect the profits of the manufacturers
and producers of this country than there would be to protect the profits
of the merchant or the lawyer, the banker or the farmer, or the wages of the
laboring man. In almost every line of industry in the United States we have
as great natural resources to develop as that of any country in the world. It
is admitted by all that our machinery and methods of doing business are in
advance of the other nations. By reason of the efficient use of American
machinery by American labor, in most of the manufactures of this country,
the labor cost per unit of production is no greater here than abroad.
It is admitted, of course, that the actual wage of the American laborer
is in excess of European countries, but as to most articles we manufacture
the labor cost in this country is not more than double the labor cost abroad.
When we consider that the average ad valorem rate of duty levied at the
custom house on manufactures of cotton goods is 53% of the value of the
article imported and the total labor cost of the production of cotton goods
in this country is only 21% of the factory value of the product, that the difference
in labor cost at home and abroad is only about as one is to two and
that ten or eleven per cent of the value of the product levied at the custom
house would equal the difference in the labor wage, it is apparent that our
present tariff laws exceed the point where they equalize the difference in cost
at home and abroad, and we realize how far they have entered into the
domain of protecting profits for the home manufacturer. This is not only
true of the manufacture of cotton goods, but of almost every schedule in
the tariff bill.
To protect profits of necessity means to protect inefficiency. It does not
stimulate industry because a manufacturer standing behind a tariff wall that
is protecting his profits is not driven to develop his business along the lines
of greatest efficiency and greatest economy.
Wool, Iron and Steel Industries.
This is clearlv illustrated in a comparison of the wool and the iron and
steel industries. Wool has had a specific duty that when worked out to an
ad valorem basis amounts to a tax of about 90% of the average value of all
woolen goods imported into the United States, and the duties imposed have
remained practically unchanged for forty years. During that time the wool
industry has made comparatively little progress in cheapening the cost of its
product and improving its business methods. On the other hand, in the iron
and steel industry the tariff rate has been cut every time a tariff bill has been
written. Forty years ago the tax on steel rails amounted to $17.50 a ton,
today it amounts to $3.92. Forty years ago the tax on pig iron was $13.60 a
ton, today it is $2.50. The same is true of most of the other articles in the
iron and steel schedule, and yet the iron and steel industry has not languished;
it has not been destroyed and it has not gone to the wall. It is the most
compact, virile, fighting force of all the industries of America today. It has
long ago expanded its productive capacity beyond the power of the American
people to consume its output and is today facing out towards the markets of
the world, battling for a part of the trade of foreign lands where it must
meet free competition or as is often the case, pay adverse tariff rates to enter
the industrial fields of its competitor.
Duty of Our Government?Genuine Tariff Reduction to a Revenue
Producing Basis Only.
Which course is the wiser for our government to take? The one that
demands the protection of profits, the continued policy of hot-house growth
for our industries? The stagnation of development that follows where competition
ceases, or on the other hand, the gradual and insistent reduction of
our tariff laws to a basis where the American manufacturer must meet honest
competition, where he must develop his business along the best and most
economic lines, where when he fights at home to control his market he is
forging the way in the economic development of his business to extend his
trade in the markets of the world. In my judgment, the future growth of
our great industries lies beyond the seas. A just equalization of the burdens
of taxation and honest competition, in my judgment, are economic truths;
they are not permitted today by the laws of our country, we must face toward
them and not away from them.
What I have said docs not mean that I am in favor of going to free trade
conditions cr of being so radical in our legislation as to injure legitimate
business, but I do mean that the period of exclusion has passed and the era
of honest competition is here.
Let us approach the solution of the problem involved with the determination
to do what is right, what is safe and what is reasonable.
Birmingham News I
Supports Underwood
In many quarters there has arisen a
demand that Oscar \V. Underwood be "<
named the standard bearer of the Demo- ti
cratic party in the campaign that will 01
be waged for the presidency in 1912. w
It is the earnest hope of The Binning- S
ham News that this may come about, tr
Should the banner be entrusted to the sc
keeping of Oscar W. Underwood, The cz
Birmingham News thoroughly believes a(
that by him it will be carried to glo- p<
rious victory, and that it will never be ai
stained by compromise with wrong or bi
sullied by collusion with privilege.?The oi
Birmingham News, Thursday, November b<
23, 1911. D
A NATIONAL REPU1
WITI
T Jc nrnVo VJ v crrpatPQf i r>1
^ HUV.1 ?. to ' ? ? authority
on the tariff in the House of
Representatives, or, for that matter, in 11
Congress. fc
"What do you think of Underwood?" a:
I asked Senator Bailey. p(
"Underwood," said Bailey, "is the only cr
man in cither house of Congress who in
could be locked in a hermetically sealed fr
room for a week and emerge from it ai
with a perfectly good tariff bill." bi
Underwood is the strongest example w
in modern times of a thoroughly modest fu
man getting a reputation without going n<
after it. Politics is a noisy game; you li
have to have a trumpet and a bugle in B
WHY I AM FOR
OSCA
(1) Because he is the strongest all- cl
round man in the field; r<
(2) Because he is old enough to have 11
learned a great deal, and young enough 111
to learn more;
(3) Because he is a constructive, j1,
practical statesman;
(4) Because he fathered the Farmers'
Free List Bill, which was an im- ^
mense stride toward free trade, and a
measure that would have been magically
beneficial to our over-taxed people; ST
(5) Because he proposed and put tf
a v. ? a ? c ? r
LilJUUJJll <X UldMll I C1UI 111 U1 111
the infamous woolen tariff; and also a
sweeping reduction in the cotton goods n;
schedule; c:
(6) Because he had the manhood to C
defy the Birmingham Board of Trade, le
when it tried to intimidate him as to in
tariff reduction; sc
(7) Because he has introduced a bill Ii
to cut the steel and iron schedule g]
from 30 to 50 per cent;
(8) Because he had the courage to n;
oppose the Sherwood pension grab, ai
which the shirkers and skulkers, and S
deserters, and bounty-jumpers demand.
^hamp Clark voted for the grab: w
Bryan has not had the pluck to say a pi
word against it, nor has Wlodrow v;
' "flggafiM," ul ^fiu i> JI
the spunk to tell the people tha^ll this o
talk about the initiative, referendum g
*1 recall, in national politics, is d
tommy-rot. Everybody should know tl
that the Constitution of the United 1
States would have to be radically 1
UNDERWOOD AS
In Mf. Underwood's candidacy the t
South for the first time in 60 years t
comes forward with a man with a rea- i:
son?a man with a valid claim on c
Democracy for signal recognition. If a
unselfish devotion, high performance, \
Nation-wide breadth of view, and rare g
qualities for leadership entitle a man g
to sympathy and support in his aspir- \
ations, the nomination of Mr. Under- c
wood would be a testimonial logically f
bestowed. F
The Southern Democracy never c
wants, in or out of Congress^ for t
powerful champions of party politics, c
men who come in for honorable men- r
tion when the Presidential year rolls 1
round, but in Mr. Underwood's case i
A SOUTHERNER I
Oscar W. Underwood of Alabama is J
unquestionably of presidential size. His <
leadership of the Democratic majority 1
on the floor of the House has never been ]
excelled for skill, force and definite di- i
rection. It is a respectful hearing from ]
all over the country which Senator I
Bankhead of the same State will have ]
in naming him for the Democratic nom- 1
ination.
Has the time come when it is expe- ]
dient for the Democracy to nominate a j
Southerner living in the South for the
presidency? It has not been thought so <
since the civil war. It has not even :
been thought expedient to give the South 1
second place on the ticket. The nearest <
approach to this was the naming on the
WIDE APPEAL OF UND!
That Representative Oscar W. Underwood
is rapidly crowding to the wall
all other aspirants for the Democratic
presidential nomination, is ,fche information
that comes from sources close to
the Alabama leader to-day. In fact, it
is now a subject of open gossip about
the House that New York State is veer- 1
ing toward the Alabama member and
that Clark, Wilson and Harmon are los- <
incr crround in the chief pivotal State of 1
the Union. i
A member of the New York delega- 1
tion in the House, who is not person- i
ally an advocate of the candidacy of i
Mr. Underwood, admitted in confidence i
to-day" that the trend of sentiment in
New York city and New York State
now favors the Alabama leader. From
Representative Henry D. Clayton, of
O'SHAUNESSY BOC
Mr. O'ShaunessUs declaration followed
the Underwood demonstration in
the House. Mr. C'Shaunessy said:
"I believe Mr. Underwood is the right
man for the presidency. He has wonderful
executive ability, as shown by his j
[ management of the House at this ses-1
'he South and
the Presidency
This constant reference to an alleged
lead line" when it comes to the selecon
of a candidate for the presidency, is
ut of place. It is a peculiar fact that
e hear more of it right here in the
outh than anywhere else in the coun y.
We are getting to be painfully
df-conscious about this supposed politiil
bar sinister. Not only that, but we 1
:t on the assumption that it would be
olitically inexpedient for us to support
ty man who is Southern born and 1
red. It is folly of the worst kind and 1
nly serves to keep alive the dying em- 1
irs of sectionalism.?Shrcueport Times, :
ecember, 1911. (
(
: :
rATION :
I0UT SEEKING IT!
1
rder to make anybody hear your name. {
: is a rule to which there is no excep- '
r\r% fhof T r\( AVAAnf T T r% rl a ?-? ?/% r\ A 1
uii tiiai x ui liviti vvuuu.
lie sat back there quietly in Congress :
ir sixteen years doing splendid work 1
id never getting his name into the pa- (
rs. Finally the crash came, the Demo- (
ats carried the House, and from sheer ^
lerit and nothing else the quiet man
om Alabama was made floor leader
id put in charge of the party's tariff
11. And he so acquitted himself that
ithin a month he became a national
?ure, and now he is quite likely to be
Dminated for President.?Charles Wils
Thompson, in The Sunday Herald, '
oston, October 22, 1911. i
i
' 1
R UNDERWOOD j
langcd, before the present system of ;
*presentative government and legisla- ,
on could be changed for direct law- }
laking.
When, do you suppose, we could elect
Congress that would give the people
le opportunity to vote away the pre)gatives
of Congress?
When, do you suppose, there would
: 34 States ready to adopt the new
rstem?
When, do you suppose, would the
nail States be willing to surrender
leir equality, in the Federal Govern- t
lent ? *
When Wilson and Bryan prate of a .
ational initiative, referendum and reill,
they make themselves demagogues. '
1 t-i nitViAr nf tViom f#?11 tic Knur O J ror-t
UI1 vimv* v/A kiiviii kvii w j iiv n JL/11 vv.w
gislation can be applied, nationally,
i such a manner as to preserve the
ivereign equality of the small States?
f either of them can, I should be i
lad to publish their plan. <
It will be time enough to talk about <
ational Direct legislation and the recall i
Fter we shall have tried it, in the J
tates. 1
(10) Lastly, I am for Oscar Underood
because his record, public and I
rivate* is unstained; his character elt- 1
ated and spotless; his leadership suppressed.
'Hi?1 Joesft^toSJTTo'TO^
ogy jo win popular applau%e; and he
oesnT cater to wealth and power, as
lie standpatters of both parties do.?
lorn Watson, in The Jeffersonian,
"homson, Ga., January 25, 1912.
A CANDIDATE
here is added a genius for organizaion
and command not often observable,
n party leaders of his section. For
andor compels a good word in
acknowledgment of what he did in the
ray of harmonizing and knitting together
the warring elements of his
larty in the House. Not in twenty
ears has there been in Democratic
ouncils a leader who proved successul
in uniting all shades of opinion and
>resenting a solid front on practically
very issue that came to a vote. For
hat reason, if for no other, Mr. Unlerwood's
availability would seem to
nerit careful consideration at the
lands of the Democratic party.?Washngton
Post, October 3, 1911.
ON THE TICKET
Parker ticket in 1904 of Henry G. Davis
?f West Virginia. But that is essen:ially
a Northern State. Carlisle of
Kentucky had a few votes for President
n the conventions of 1SS4 and 1892;
Blackburn of Kentucky and Tillman of
South Carolina in 1896; Williams of
Mississippi in 1904. But they were
merely complimentary.
Yet the war is over. A Southern
Democrat and a former Confederate
soldier is Chief Justice of the United
States Supreme Court by appointment
of a Republican President. The day
may not be so far off when the last
traces of the sectional line will be obliterated
in American politics.?The New I
York World, October 24, 1911.
ERWOOD'S CANDIDACY
Alabama, also, comes confirmation of
the fact that the Underwood boomers
are receiving most encouraging reports
from New York. These reports go so
far as to say that if the South will keep
Representative Underwood's name before
the convention, New York State
may be counted on to fall into line after
the second or third ballot.
If the South can get over the ancient
obsession that a Southern man cannot
lie nominated for President and if the
South will keep the name of Underwood
before the convention, for a few ballots,
there are many wise political observers
in Washington and New York who are
confident that the New York delegation
will swing into line for Underwood.?
Washington correspondence of the
Noshville Tennesseean, December 31,
1911.
IMS UNDERWOOD
sion, and except for his residence so far
r* .? T r 1 . 1 _ A 1. . * _
boutn, l icci xnai ne is in every way
suitable for the place. I believe the
Democrats could not nominate a more
acceptable candidate."?Representative
O'Shaunessy, of Rhode Island, in The
Providence Journal, August, 1911.
UNDERWOOD SOUNI
VIEWS ON RECIP
MERCHANT M
RECIPROCITY i
(In the U. S. House of Representatives, 1
April 21, 1911.)
Our agricultural implements supply r
the farmers' wants beyond the seas, c
Our boots and shoes are worn by peo- 2
pie who speak many foreign languages jand
who tread the highways of the j
Occident and the Orient. The looms of t
our factories clothe the people of dis- t
tant lands. The freight of our foreign x
rivals is carried to market on American [
rails, drawn by American engines, across s
chasms spanned by American-built ^
bridges. [Applause.] The harvests of t
Dur farmers feed the toiling masses of ^
Europe. We would be the unrivaled t
masters of production and industry in f
every land where free competition can t
oe obtained if we would but strike off [
:he shackles that bind us to the dead c
ind unnecessary economic system main- v
:ained by the Republican Party, that ,
creates false standards and wasteful ]
conditions at home. [Applause on the ^
Democratic ?iHe 1
<
ANTI-TRU5T LEGISLATION
(In Speech Before Pennsylvania Society
of New York, Dec. 9, 1911.)
"Is it not proper for all of us, irrespective
of party, to insist that the
:ime has come for us to join together c
in putting an end to this profitless agi- c
tation and proposals for tinkering with c
the (Sherman) law? As the necessity *
arises, we can from time to time enforce .
the act, without fear or favor, but with- 1
out any disposition to get political cap- J
ital out of what we may be called upon
to do. Let our pilot be experience and c
accurate knowledge and high resolve, 1
and not party expediency or misdi- j
rected energy, whether proceeding from
ood or bad motives, and above all this J
let us not proceed upon a crude guess." c
]
AMERICAN MERCHANT \
MARINE <
<
(In the U. S. House of Representa- \
tives, Feb. 26, 1910.) (
It is clear that there are no treaties i
:hat stand in our way to prevent us from f
enacting a discriminating tariff duty \
UNDERWOOD THE MAN I
OF THE HOUR
But Mr. Underwood's rise in public
favor has not been spectacular. His
is not the kind of popularity that will
Tf J* A ...jJ?i.. u.... 1
xt uamicu duuucmy uui lis
dawning was rather the awakening of
recognition than the discovery of a new
star. Mr. Underwood and his ability
had been there all the time, but they
had not been called into action. Opportunity
revealed the man and the
leader.
His leadership and his qualifies* are
his party, but his usefulness to the party ,
and to th^people will not be destroyed.
He is hanging no hopes on the reward
that may come to him from the party.
* * * * * * 1
Mr. Underwood's public record is unusual
for its clean brilliancy. It stands
without a flaw. Critics may search it
through and through and Mr. Underwood's
smile would never waver. His
party record is just as clear. His private
life is without a blemish.
He is peculiarly fitted by nature and
training for the leadership of men and
the administration of executive functions.
He comes of good stock, if that
means anything in this people's republic.
His education was thoroughly
rounded. His character well poised.
His training has been broad and wise.
He is thoroughly practical. His academic
education has been broadened by
well directed experience and constant
application to useful research.?Walter
Harper in the Birmingham Age-Herald,
January 7, 1912.
L
UNDERWOOD OVER AGAIN
The rapid rise of Oscar W. Underwood
in the discussion of Presidential
possibilities is full of significance, and
may well cause consternation in the
Wilson, Clark and Harmon camps. As
a distinctive Southerner, his boom especially
is a menace to Wilson, who appealed
strongly to the sentiment of that
section, in which he was born and spent
his early years. In the soundness of
his Democracy, the statesmanlike judg
ment and moderation he displays in
j dealing with the issues of the hour,
Mr. Underwood has no superior among
his rivals. He avoids indorsing very
questionable issues to which Wilson
committed himself somewhat incontinently.?The
Troy Press, New York,
November 28, 1911.
THE HAN TO WIN
The Mobile Register declares that
the relief of ninety millions of people
from tax extortion is the issue, and the
issue is personified in Oscar W. Underwood.
What more "fitting, therefore,
asks this paper, than that the man who
is the personification of the issue should
stand before the President who vetoed
the bills drawn by Mr. Underwood seeking
to give relief to the American people?
What more fitting that the candidate
should be Mr. Underwood, standing
for tariff reduction as against Mr.
Taft standing in defense of present tariff j
laws? What more fitting for the Democratic
party to nominate a man who can
win?for this is the time Democracy can
win. Powerful political leaders of
thought and those journalistic exponents
of Democracy throughout the country
should take note of Mr. Underwood.
They should investigate; and with party
firm?with c^rtinn^l nr^iiidipp
It. M a 1 L V 111 ill Mini >M.Vllu.n.. ^ - ~J ?
eliminated, learn to know the man and
the principles for which he stands. The
1 Southern press, especially, should rally
with unhesitating vigor to support and
use their influence for the man who has
done more than any living Democrat to
reunite Democracy, and who can, as a
Southern Democrat in the White House,
establish forever a reunited country.?
Richmond Journal, reproduced in the
Advertiser, Montgomery, Ala., January
I 20, 1912.
#
D ON ALL PUBLIC Q
ROCITY, ANTI-TRUS
ARINE, PUBLIC SEF
n favor of American ships. It was the
)olicy of the fathers; it built up our <
nerchant marine from a point where
t was carrying 17 per cent of our com- 1
nerce to a point where it was carrying ;
'0 per cent of American commerce in
i period of seven years. It does not 1
dace additional burdens on the people; :
t is not a policy of doubtful constitu- ;
ionality; it is a policy that has been i
ried and proven effective. It is a pol- i
cy oy wnicft we can restore the Amer- J
can flag to the seas and the American 1
hips to our commercial trade. It is a
>olicy that will enable us to build up
he export trade of the American peo>le.
It is a policy that will enable us
o find foreign markets for our surplus
iroducts in agriculture and manufacure.
It is a policy that will restore the
lalance of commerce as well as trade to 1
)ur Nation. It is a policy that will J
lltimately overcome the necessity of our ]
>aying a foreign balance in gold to
European nations and will bring pros- <
>erity to all lines of industry. i
<
rONVICTIONS HORE POWERFUL
THAN LOCAL PRESSURE j
[In the U. S. House of Representatives, :
April 21, 1911.) I
Two years ago, when the proposition 1
rame before the House to cut the tariff ]
m iron and steel products, in many ;
:ases about half, I favored the proposi- ;
ion because I thought it was just and ;
air, but some of the protected interests
n my district met and passed rcsoluions,
and resolved that they would re)uke
me if I voted to reduce the tax
)n iron and steel. I voted to make the
eduction [applause on the Democratic
iide], but they did not turn me out of
Congress [applause on the Democratic (
side], and they will not turn you out '
)f Congress if you stand true to the
people you represent. [Applause on the
Democratic side.] The distinguished
gentleman from Illinois [Mr. Cannon],
ivhen he addressed the House several ]
lays ago, stated that the United States ,
Steel Corporation was in favor of this
jill and asked if I did not know it,
>r if that was not the reason why I
iavored it As I then stated to the
gentleman from Illinois, I was not iniormed
as to the wishes of the United
UNDERWOOD'S RISE NO
SURPRISE TO THOSE
WHO KNOW Hill
For years Oscar Underwood has been
"ecognized in his district as a man of
narked ability.^ His broad knowledge
}f the tariff displayed time and again
)n the floor of Congress and in public 1
utterances on the stump; his far-reachng
insight into large public questions
rnder consideration in the national lawnaking
body; his skill in debate; his
romplete mastery of himself in times
)f political turbulence on the floor of
. wdLas. Jhis.
ment long before he became Chairman
of the Ways and Means Committee with
a tremendous task to perform.?Birmingham
Ledger, 1912.
ALABAMA AND
ITR. UNDERWOOD
But the present leader of the House
is not impulsive. In truth, that fact
explains his leadership. He is a man
of calculation. Had he not been, he
could never have piloted his party
through the difficulties of the extra session.
His task then called for a calm
vision and a single purpose. Had he
been a spellbinder and a scatterer he
would have wasted his opportunity.
Were Mr. Underwood to set his heart
on the White House and maneuver for
a stay under that famous roof he would
play hobs with all the reputation he has
just acquired. His vision would become
confused, and everything would go
by the board. He could not serve two
masters, and his work in the House has
the first and highest claim on his attention.
This does not mean that Mr. Underwood's
name will, as the result of his
reply to his House colleagues, disappear
from the Presidential speculation.
Of course, it will not. It is there to
stay, with the other names now on
many pens and tongues. The matter of
the nominee is in the lap of fate, and
we shall all have to wait for the decision.?The
Washington Sunday Star,
December, 1911.
UNDERWOOD
Even* public speech that Oscar \V.
Underwood. Democratic leader of the
House of Representatives, makes brings
him closer to the people as a presidential
possibility. What Congressman
Longworth, a Republican, said of him
at the dinner of the Pennsylvania Society
in New York on Saturday night
is coming to be generally felt by the
public.
"Not for many years," said Colonel
Roosevelt's son-in-law, "has so forceful
a personality come to the front of his
party as the present leader of the House.
Not in my time, certainly, and not, as I
believe, in modern times, has the Democratic
party developed a man possessing
in so full degree the qualifications for
real leadership as it has this year in the
person of Oscar Underwood."?The Jersey
Journal, Jersey City, N. J., December
11, 1911.
SOUTH ELECTED CLEVELAND
"It was due to the South that Grover
Cleveland was nominated and elected,"
said Judge Parker. "It was due to the
South that William J. Bryan was twice
* J 1-1 _ _ ^1. _ c ?1_
nominated, ana m line manner me ouuin
was responsible for the nomination of
a New Yorker, who speaks to you now.
I still believe that the South is the section
of our country from which a presidential
nominee could be chosen who
could quell the voices of all the Democratic
factions and heal all breaches.
When the Democratic National Convention
sees fit to nominate a Southerner,
I believe that the Northern Democrats
will supnort him with their ballots.?
Judge Alton B. Parker, in The State,
Columbia, S. C., January 25, 1912.
luestioms
;t legislation
'.vice, the tariff
States Steel Corporation. As a matter
of fact, I am interested in the iron and
steel business myself. Everything I
have in the world is in the iron and
steel business except my home, but not
with the United States Steel Corporation.
My people are independent manufacturers.
We meet the United States
Steel Corporation every day of our existence
in a competitive battle on the
industrial fields of America. My peopleliave
not asked me to vote for a protective
tariff on iron and steel.
PPOTPrTtnM'Q IWim TiTinc
- .tv.Mvasvti KJ li 1 ly C/l 1 rl1
(In the U. S. House of Representatives,
April 21, 1911.)
The protected interests of this country
know well that this bill will make
a. break in the dike; that whenever theprotective
tariff is removed and the
Northern farmer stands out alone without
pretense of protection to his products
that he can no longer be counted
Dn to stand in the ranks of the monopolistic
interests of this country. That is
why they are afraid of it. It is not so
much what is in the bill, but they knowthat
the death knell of the protection
system will have sounded?that protection
that means the protection of enormous
profits and the creation of monopolies
in this country?when the
farmer understands and abandons the
Republican Party to those alone who
have fattened upon his hard-earned dollars.
They are using, my friends, every
effort in the districts on that side of the
House and in your district, my fellowDemocrat
and in my district to break
the column. I have protected interests
in my district, but I do not represent
them. I represent the great mass of my
:onstituency who want honest treatment
and fair play. ...
OSCAR UNDERWOOD
The appearance of Oscar Underwood
here last night, in advocacy of the Democratic
principles he has done so much
to advance, was an event not only highly
gratifying to his party associates in
Louisville, but of exceptional interest to
the community in general.
It is not often that a man returns to
the scenes of his youth to speak with
such authority, from so commandincr &
position, won on his own merit. It has
not been so long as the years ago?he is
not yet 50?since Oscar Underwood was
a schoolboy here; he comes back now
the recognized and applauded leader of
his party on the floor of the National
House of Representatives, the head of
the great committee which shapes the
fiscal legislation of the country; a new
chieftain of Democracy who has arisen
at a crisis when the old party seemed
all but leaderless.
Bravo, Oscar Underwood! It is a
bright day for Democrats when they are
fortunate to find and quick to acclaim
sis^i a leader^-?Louisville Courier-Jour- ^
nal, reprinte^ in Age-Herald, BinningSEETHING
OF ALABAfIA'5 PR
CANDIDATE FOR THE
PRESIDENCY
Whoever was floor leader of the Democracy
was good enough for Mr. Underwood
during all the long years that
party was in the minority, and day after
day, whether that leader was Joseph W.
Bailey, of Texas, John Sharp Williams*
of Mississippi, or Champ Clark, of Missouri,
the gentleman from Alabama was
always at his leader's elbow, ready and
eager to do anything he could to help.
Other statesmen might try to black their
party leader's eye, but Mr. Underwood
was never known to extend anything
but the helping hand.?George E. Miller,
Staff Correspondent, in the Detroit
News, October 24, 1911.
?*
WHOri SHALL THE
DEHOCRATS NOniNATE
Congressman Underwood, as house
leader of the Democrats and as chairman
of the Ways and Means Committee,
has measured up to the standard of
true statesmanship. He has rendered incalculable
service to the cause of honest
tariff revision, the one great issue in
the pending campaign, and by his splendid
poise and mastery ?f affairs he has
exalted his party's name in the minds of
thinking Americans.?Atlanta Journal,
January 7, 1912.
UNDERWOOD AS A CANDIDATE
If Oscar Underwood, when he was
made Chairman of the Ways and Means
Committee, had been as well known
throughout the country as Champ Clark
or Judson Harmon or Woodrow Wilson
he would have gone into the Democratic
convention far in the lead. He was at
that', time, however, little known and
this fact may give to the Speaker a part
of the prestige that Mr. Underwood
otherwise would have had.
Mr. Underwood is well known now,
however, and will be better known before
the convention meets or the States
elect delegates. Taking it for granted
that he will conduct the tariff fight as
well during the regular session as during
the extra session, Mr. Underwood
will be much stronger at the end of the
regular session than he is now. If we
judge by results we must conclude that
no Democratic leader has ever had his
forces so well in hand as My. Underwood
had during- the last session.?The
Florida Times-Union, Jacksonville, Fla.,
October 24, 1911.
AN EHINENT flAN
"The destiny of the American nation,
which I think is the most wonderful in
the whole history of the world, is perfectly
safe in the hands of such men
as your Underwood. It is a pity that
we cannot have more of his kind in
Washington. He is one of the most
eminent men that the South has produced,
and I look with vast satisfaction
upon the plans of his Alabama friends
to give him their unanimous indorsement
for that high office?the presidency.?Prof.
Willis L. Moore, Chief of
U. S. Weather Bureau, in the Birming,
ham, Ala., Age-Herald, Octr^?- 11,
1911.
y