The Horry herald. (Conway, S.C.) 1886-1923, February 15, 1912, Image 6
STATE HOUSE AFFAIR
TO FIX RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE
PLACING OF CONTRACTS
INVESTIGATION ORDERED
+.
Resolution Providing for Immediate
Inquiry, by Special Committee, of
Conduct of Committee on State
House aud (.'rounds and Others Involved.
* - * ? n*l..i...,1ov li or] fin
M lie i louse on j hui ?...
<*thcr decided llurrv over the matter
of the contract for (lie plans for the
extension of tlio State House, for
which a bill of $13,f>00 lias been submitted
in connection with plaster
models. Wednesday two resolutions,
looking to straightening the record,
were presented, and Thursday morning
Mr. Rembert suggested another
plan of investigation, and the House,
finally, after a "merry-go-round,"
adopted the suggestion of Mr. Stevenson
relative to the inquiry as to
how, when, and where the contract
that has been so much discussed was
really arranged. The resolution, as
adopted, and as indicative of the
view of the majority of the House,
reads as follows:
1. Resolved, by the House of Representatives,
That a committee of
three members of the House be forthwith
appointed by the Speaker and
when appointed, shall constitute a
commission whose duty it shall be to
investigate and report to this House
with all convenient speed the facts
as to the conduct and action of the
committee on State House and
grounds, and its sub-committees, and
all other persons and oliicers connected
therewith or alleged to have
been connected therewith or to have
had anything to do with the same
as to the plans undertaken and contracts
entered Into to carry out the
terms of a concurrent resolution, the
object of which was to carry out the
suggestions of the Governor in his
Message No. 5 in relation to the State
House.
2. That said commission shall
have the power and authority to
swear witnesses, send for and compel
the attendance of witnesses and
production of papers; employ a stenographer
whose uuty it shall be to
take and transcribe all testimony;
preserve order, and shall report the
testimony with their conclusions
thereon back to this House with all
conventnient speed at this session.
That the sergeant-at-arms of this
House is directed tc serve all process
issued by said commission,
signed by its chairman, and obey
the orders 01 said commission.
The following resolution was introduced
by Mr. Rembert;
Members of certain newspapers in
this State are attempting to fix the
responsibility with reference to the
State House contract upon the Governor.
Now, therefore, that justice
may be done to all parties, be it
Resolved, That the committee on
ways and means be instructed to
thoroughly investigate the entire
matter, summon and swear such witnesses
as may be necessary and re
port to this body, fixing the responsibility
where it belongs, together
with all testimony taken in such
hearing, and that saul report be made
at the present session.
Mr. Rembert vigorously defended
bis resolution and be insisted that
he had the utmost confidence in
Messrs. Todd, Rryan and the members
of the committee making the
contract. 'Mr. Cary urged that it
was time to stop talking so much politics.
It did not set m to him that it
was a legislative function to try newspapers
or bother with what this or
that newspaper suggested. He believed
the ways and means conjmittee
had better l>e excused, as that
committee had already reported
against the claim.
Mr. Stevenson offered a substitute
for the entire inattei. This he held
was not a political matter, as Dr.
Sawyer had charged, was be'ng made
of the matter. Dr. Sawyer suggested
that ho only referred to the newspapers
trying to make the whole matter
a political affair. Mr. Stevenson
said ho wanted prompt action, s
quick report, and ;m-tice to everyone
Mr. Stevenson said Govern >r Please
denied nothing and never said he
was not present when the contract
was signed.
Mr. Pry an said he was misquoted
He said more than v. as quoted in tin
State.
Mr. Stevenson said lie had no pur
pose to inject politico into the whol
Inquiry. If members talked abou
politics he would like them to rea<
the Governor's reply for facts as t*
the alleged mill merger and his repl
that he would use what facts he hai
on the stump. That looked like pol
Itlcs!
Mr. Browning said in the heat o
argument he had used the word
"bribe and debauch," and apologize*
for using such language. Tie did no
mean to use such language am
should not have done so, for he di<
not believe it possible to "bribe am
debauch" members.
Mr. Bryan said in view of Mr
Browning's statement he would with
AIKEN OFFICER KILLED
?
DEPUTY SHOT DOWN WHILE
SERVING A WARRANT.
shooting Don? by m Court Witness
for Whom a Reiicli Warrant Had
liccn Issued.
Fuller Gregory, an ex-policeman
of Aiken, was shot and instantly
killed Wednesday night by Tom Liptord
at Lipford's home at Warrenville
in Aiken County, while Gregory
was acting as a special deputy. Hoth
(iregory and Lipford lived at Warrenville,
and both are well known.
Lipford was arrested by Maxy Craig
and carried to Aiken and lodged in
jail.
Lipford had been subpoenead as a
witness in the case of John Ware,
who is charged with burning Green's
store at Warrenvllle some timo ago.
He was relied upon by tho State as
one of the main witnesses against
Ware; and when, Wednesday afternoon,
the case was called in the special
term of general sessions court
.here, he was not present.
Judge Copes issued a bench warrant
for Lipford and Gregory was
deputized to go to Warrenville, arrest
Lipford, and bring him to Aiken.
Armed with the warrant, Gregory
went to Warrenville lato Wednesday
afternoon.
Reports as to tho killing are conflicting.
It is staged that Gregory
knocked on Lipford's door and Liplord's
wife opened it for him, but
that as he stepped inside to serve the
warrant on Lipford, Lipford fired
upon him with a shotgun, the entiro
load entering Gregory's right
side. lie fell dead outside oil the
porch.
Lipford's friends claim that Gregory
was drinking and that when lie
wont with the warrant to Llpforcl's
homo lie was staggering and that
when Mrs. LipforJ opened the door
he fell over her as he entered the
house and that it was then that Liplord
shot hi in.
Lipford is about 4 0 years of age.
Gregory leaves a family. lie was for
a long time 011 the police force in
Aiken and was weil thought of. As
the grand jury is still in session it is
probable that action will be taken at
once.
draw his remarks made last night.
Mr. Ashley said he never in his
life saw such efforts being made to
make politics out of everything.
There had been no such feeling since
1892-1 89 4. He had been a member
for sixteen years and be had never
seen such ail effort to try to hurt
the Governor. It seemed to bo an effort
to get the Governor in a hole.
He referred to the guano bill for the
State House grounds by a former
commission. He vent back to Tom
Polder, and said he never ought to
have been allowed to take $170,000
in commissions. That money would
build a State House. He talked
lieved there was ever a hook coming
from Tom Felder." May be they are
waiting for the campaign. He said
Mr. Gonzales had used $12,000 or
more for guano and a little coed and
ditching on the State House grounds.
Mr. Meares tried to got Mr. Ashley
on the record as to how the money
was spent 011 the Srate House grounds
hv the commission, of which Mr.
Gonzales was a member. The record
showed that $1,11>4 was spent in
1910, (not $ 11,000.) and it was spent
for fertilizers, labor, plants. This,
lie said, was quoting rrum inumuir,
Mr. Ashley sai l Mr. Meares did
not know what lie was talking about,
and that he was tired of sonic people
trying to run the State. He knew
the whole tight was on the Governor,
and lie was sick of the whole thing.
Mr. Ashley made a red hot talk
against what ho regarded as attacks
on Governor Hlease.
Dr. Wyche made an lmpassionate
speech, eloquently saying the legislative
hall was not the proper place for
political stump speeches, and he did
not want to hear so much about politics.
He would ''C opposed to any
investigation o* further ado, except
that the members of the sub-committee
asked for it.
Mr. Rembert insisted that he
would raise his feeble voice for Governor
Hlease whenever he saw fit, and
that Judge Jones bad regular lioadq
n,-triers.
{ Mr. Wyche said he meant no reflection
on Mr. Rouibert or anyone
, else; his only desire was to have the
^ 1 louse get to work.
I Mr. Stevenson's substitute resolution
was adopted bv an overwhelming
vote. Mr. Humbert's resolution
^ was defeated. Ho said he wanted
"the other side" ro table his resolu.
Hon, and this was done on motion of
Mr. Stevenson.
e - - ?
. Speaker Smith appointed on the
i eonnnittoe Messrs. Casque, Millor,
j ftolser, lloyd and Connor. This comv
mittee Is to report during the pres'j
ent session.
4..?
Negroes Lynclu'd n Negro,
f TTomor Stewart, a negro, was
a lynched hy members of his own race
d Tuesday at Cedar Crossing, C,a. Stewt
nrt is alleged to nave killed another
d negro and fatally wounded two oth1
ers at a negro festival. Stewart was
j' arrested soon after the killing, it Is
p.ated, and was ?u f:ig taken hy an
ofhcer to the Toombs county Jail
- when they wero overtaken by a mob
HOT TALK IN HOUSE'
PLANS TO REMODEL THE STATE '
HOUSE IS CONSIDERED
AT COST OF $1,000,000
?
Coventor Illoase Sends Mcsmko on
the Subject, Cause of Sub-Committee
Who Made Contract ami Ari
chltect Tocl<l is Uevievred, All of
Whom Try to Explain.
There was an nnoxnected flurry
in tho llouse Wednesday over the
special message of the Governor with
reference to the contract for plans 1
for the development and improvement
of the Sta'e House, by Messrs (
Todd & Benson. The special message
from the governor, in which F. M.
Bryan and C. D. Lee, with A. W. 1
Todd concurring, deny that the con- (
tract for enlarging the State House (
was signed in the governor's pres- 4
once, and further states that the ;
chief executive, as far as they know '
know nothing of it until the general
assembly met.
Appended to the message was an '
editorial from The State containing *
the charges denied. The minutes of (
tho meeting of rhe committee that
awarded the contract show that the
committee met in the Governor's of- '
fice on Wednesday, September 2 7, '
19 LI, with tho Governor reported <
present. The contract between F. 1
M. Bryan, W. W. Dixson, and Todd '
and Benson was dated on the same
day the meeting was held in the ]
Governor's office, when his Excellency
was reported present. Rising to ?
a question of personal privilege, 1
Lowdnes J. Browning of Union called
i snnrlft n sii.'idn i .1 snpflldfli? of the
matter.
Mr. Browning stated that Todd
liad repeatedly told the ways and 1
means committee at Its meeting that
the matter between himself and the
sub-committee had been gone into (
in the Governor's office when the
Governor was present. In referring 1
to the $1,000 traveling expenses
which tho Dixon- Bryan-Lee. subcommittee
from the committee on
State house and grounds had allowed
Todd, who is a member of the house,
for visiting "as many members as
possible," and for using "any means
in his power to acquaint them of the
contemplated work," Mr. Browning
said:
"So far as I know, this is the
first instance in American history
where a subcommittee has attempted
to appropriate State funds for in- '
(luencing members of a general assembly.
Speaking even plainer, the
subcommittee has made an effort to
use State funds to bribe and debauch
tho members of the general assembly
into adopting the plans which
they approved, and they placed these
funds In the hands of the architect."
Mr. Todd also spoke on a question
of personal privilege. Ho said that
Mr. Browning's statement as to bribery
was false so far as he vsas personally
concerned. As an introduction
to his question of personal privilege,
Mr. Browning read from the
report on the sub-committee of State
House an.l Grounds in House journal
of February 1, which F. M. Bryan
transmitted. The section of the re- 1
port which Mr. Browning read was
the minutes of the meeting in the
Governor's office. It follows:
"Pursuant to a call of Chairman
of (he Connnitto on State House and
Grounds, tho committee mot at Co
lumbia, in 11?o office of His Mxcclleney,
(ho Governor, on Wednesday,
September i27lh, !J)1 I, at which were
present His Kvcclloncy, the (lovernor;
Chairman F. M. iiryan, Secretary W.
\V. Dixon, Clarence I). Lee, composing
the subcommittee; a full quorum
of the committee and Architect A.
W. Todd.
"The committee was called to order
by the Chairman, and the report
of the architect to the subcommltie,
was read, which, after due discussion
the two reports were unanimously
adopted.
"They thou authorized the Chairman
and Secretary to enter into contract
with the architect, and to formulate
a run to present to the next
session of the Legislature.
Mr. Todd suggested that we have
a plaster cast ma le of tho building
as it will appear when completed, and
exhibited a proposal from a modeler
to make the model for the sum of
nine hundred dollars ($000). After
some discussion Mr. Todd was
I authorized to have tho model made
at a coat not to exceed that amount,
and liavo the model on exhibition at
the State Capitol at tho meeting of
the Ceneral Assembly,
"Mr. Dixon then moved that Mr.
Todd visit aa many of the members
as possible, and use any means in
his power to acquaint them of the
contemplated work, at a cost not to
exceed one thousand dollars ($ 1 .000).
After some discussion this motion
was adopted.
"There being n) further business
before tho committee, they adjourned.
(Signed) "W. W. Dixon,
"Secretary.".
Mr. Drowning declared that A. W.
i Todd had told tho ways and means
committee that the matter had been
entered into in the Governor's pros- '
HOST SERVE SENTENCE
H. A. CARLISLE, OP NEWBERRY,
REFUSED A NEW TRIAL.
Sentenced to Five Years on Indictment
Charging Misapplication of
Funds of National Dank.
A prison sentence of five years foi
Milton A. Carlisle, president of the
National Hank of Newberry, S. C.,
will stand so far as the United States
iicuit court of appeals is concerned,
according lo an opinion handed down
;t Richmond, Va., on Wednesday, the
: pinion being read by Judge Colt
Fliis case was argued several months
go, Gov. HIeaso of South Carolina
ippearing as ono of counsel for the
convicted banker. It came up on appeal
from the district court at
Ureenville, S. C.
Milton Anderson Carlisle was convicted
October 20, 1910, in the federal
court at Greenville on live counts
jf an indictment containing 1(52
counts. Carlisle's conviction came
if tor a trial which lasted several days
ind aroused much interest in South
Carolina.
The counts of tho Indictment on
which Carlisle was convicted were
hose charging misapplication of the
unds of the Newberry National bank,
)f which he was the president from
L899 until 1909.
Tho specific charge in three of
hose was based on drafts by the Cold
Point Granite Company, of which
Carlisle was president and treasurer,
which were paid by the hank but refused
by the parties upon whom they
were drawn, the bank not being rembu
rsed.
The other two counts charged misipplication
of funds paid by a farmer
ipon notes due the bank. Carlisle
was alleged to have put these sums
:o his own uses. The total amount
involved in the transactions for
which Carlisle was convicted was less
ban $500.
The bulk of the Indictment, upon
which Carlisle was found not guilty,
barged overdrafts of his personal
iccount and of the account of the
Gold Point Granite Company for considerable
sums when "ho had no
reasonable grounds to believe that
these funds would be repaid," as
both Carlisle and the company were
hopelessly involved.
Carlisle, who is 71 years of age.
was sentenced by Judge Brawley to
five years in the federal prison, a
motion for a new trial being denied.
His counsel took the case to tho circuit
court of appeals, where it was
argued some months ago. Gov.
Please was of counsel for the defense.
once. Mr. Todd had iterated his
statement that the Governor was
present. For this reason, Mr. Todd
had told the committee that he
thought he was buying a gold bond
when ho signed the contract.
"As for the actual signing of the
contract," continued Mr. Browning,
"this may not have been done either
in tho Governor's presence or in bis
office, but Mr. Todd did tell the ways
and means committee that the meeting
was held in the Governor's office.
And in tliia, I believe, .every
member of the ways and means committee
will bear me out.
"In addition," said Mr. Browning,
,1 ,1 f ^1 J thn eAuimlttnA tli n t t ho
1 (.Mill IIJ1U liiU /Uiu niiiivyu i/uut vtiv
plaster model had cost him $1,100."
Then, in conclusion, Mr. Browning
made the statement aa to the
unusual course of the subcommittee
of the committee on the State House
and Grounds in appropriating State
funds for the architect to use them
to Influence members of tho general
assembly to adopt hia plans.
In reply to Mr. Browning A. W.
1'odd spoke on a question of personal
privilege. He sakl he wished to
state his position personally. It wars
false that there ha 1 been any scheme
to debauch tho members of the general
assembly, so f^r aa he was personally
concerned. Tie had entered
into a business transaction with the
subcommittee. There was no blot on
his character. lie had not "buttonholed"
members of tho general assembly
to get them to adopt Ills
plans. lie had been employed by the
subcommittee and had entered into
a written contract with them. The
whole meeting, except the subcommittee
meeting, had boon held In the
Governor's oflice. Not a member of
the committee had any idea of politics.
He was out of money for his
work and had thought he was buying
a gold bond when he signed the
con t ract.
Mr. P\ M. Bryan stated that he dosired
to speak of tho remarks made
on the floor of the House, that the
action of tho subcommitte appeared
to he an attempt at "debauching the
General Assembly." lie wished to
state, he said, in fairness to Governor
I dense, that when tne committee held |
this meeting referred to they met in
response ro letters sent out by him
(tilling the meeting. The Governor
was "in and out" of the office during
the meeting, said Mr. Bryan, and at
the c'ose of it, looking over the Todd
plans, he made the remark: "I
think it is very beautiful, and if the
hill passes tho General Assembly it
shall have my approval." The action
of the committee had been taken in
good la'ih, said Mr. Bryan, and, continuing,
he dee'ared that he wished
to pronounce not only to the General
Assembly, but to tho entire State,
BANK Of
Con wa
Ha> largest capital and surplus of i
tha i the combined capital and surf
CAPITAL STOCK. . . .
SURPLUS
LIABILITIES OF 8TOCF
SECURITY OF DEPOSIT
I)IKIi(
^hert B. Scarborough,
. L. Buck,
eorge J. Holiday,
We offer our customers every acc
will justify, and we
tOHEftT H. SCARBOROUGH, I
PRK8IDKNT.
We continue to pay 5 pe
&v<?> &&& -*^3 j
? FIRST NAIF
I
/fit CONW.1
r$\
Ir CAPITAL STOCK
<P SURPLUS PROFITS
/fit TOTAL ASSISTS
2k DIHKC
Hfr J. A. McDerinott, John t
/AK B. G. Collins, H. L. I
1 M. Burroughs, C. P. Qu
Successor to the Bank o
|ai Horry County, ami a pioneer
ly allied with the recent de\
^ Republic. Backed by the
United States Bonds, we are f
to in era any reasonable accoirn
js
& II. A. KI'IVHV,
Cnsliier.
FOLK AISK DOXM TO DKATII.
.Mysterious Quadruple? .Murder in a
Tenement House.
A mysterious quadruple murder,
in which two men and two women
were killed, was revealed by the discovery
of the bodies of the victims
in a tenement house in the heart of
Lawrence, .Mass. The dead are Mrs.
Annie Denis, aged 35 years; Mr. and
Mrs. Joseph Fa via?, aged 3 5 and 3 0
years, respectively, and an unknown
man.
A disturbance was heard in the
Favias' apartment about 3 o'clock
Saturday morning by the family
which lives downstairs, hut no investigation
was made. When no member
of the household appeared during
the day, however, the police were
called in.
The unidentified body was found
in. the kitchen with the throat cut.
In a corner were the bodies of Joseph
Favias and his wife, both of whom
evidently met death in a struggle.
In a bedroom adjoining was found
the body of Mrs. Denis. Her throat
had been cut
GAS (Ml SHI> I)HATII OF TIIItKK
Not Triple Murder, as Suspected.
OMirhil-i Decide.
Ilarvey Ilurst, his wife, and Elsie
Adams, sixteen yeais old, svho lived
with them, whose bodies were found
in the ruins of the Hurst l.ome, at
Delaware Okla., Saturday night, were
not murdered, according to Nowata
County officials but were the victims
of accidental asphyxiation. The presence
of a small wound in Mrs.
Hurst's head indicated that all three
might have been killed and the house
fired in an attempt to cover the
crinie. Monday evening county officials,
who viewed the bodnes and
the premises, concluded that flames
from an overturned gas stove had overcome
the family and that escaping
gas had subsequently been ignited by
a lamp and had paitk.ily destroyed
the dwelling. Officials say the wound
in Mrs. Hurst's head was caused by
a fall.
Five Lives I ost by (.'as.
At Philadelphia gas escaping from
a broken street main killed live persons
and overcame three others in a
house at 2 2nd and Carlton streets,
Tuesday. Three occupants of an adjoining
house wore overcome, but
were revived. The gas company discovered
that a mam had been broken
and that the gas had worke 1 its way
into a sewer and then into the house
?. ? ,?
Killed in Train Wreck.
Running at a high rate of speed
Tuesday morning, an electric cai
jumped the track near Coultersville
Pa., 20 miles from Pittsburg, and
went over a 200-1 oot embankment
Five men, three of whom were miners,
wore killed. The car contained
20 persons, miners on their way t(
fi-nm fJreenook to the mine!
near Scott Hoven.
Ken rat Buys Atlanta Paper*
The Atlanta Georgian, an after
noon paper of Atlanta, Ga., announc
on Monday afternoon that the papei
had been purchased by William Ran
dolph Hearst, front Fred L. Seeley
who established the paper six yeari
ago.
HOIiRY,
y. 8, C.
my bank in Horry county. More* \
)lus of all other banks in Ine county^ j
f&o.oe?
12,6?0
[HOLDERS .. .. 6?,000
ORS 11 <tf,600 /
:ioks
ARDSON I:
W. A. .foliuH Oil,
Will A. Freeman y
ommodation which their account*
solicit your business.
). V. Richardson, wili. a. frkkma*
VlCK I'KKHlDhNI
:r cent, on yearly deposits.
?&&&&'& rr '2$
ONAL BANK I
V, 8. o. A
$25,000.00 5
2,500.00 W
125,000.00 ill
? %
TOKH: 1
J. Spivey, I). T. McNeill, #
luck, VV. It. Lewis, L>. Jy ^
attlobaurn, i). A. Spivey. *
f Conway, uhe oldest Hank in Mji
in 10aet?rn Carolina. Close'elopnient
of the Independent \lf
(jovernuient and secured by |j.fa
>repared to extend to our cut- ^
moduMonu. Vflr
<V
li. (i. tXJI.I.I.VH, /ft
President. VV
t'HOKWSMKnN AL CAKOH
a. a. tvooDWAHi)
Attorney *nd Councelor At
CON WAY, M. C.
V
ft. U. nCAiUVKOUttli |
<JUi\ Wii, .s. (
Attorney At l>xv?.
#*. H. m hkogoh*
^'hyilctan And hnrKeo* r
(JONWAY, H. (1.
?. WOFFOIU* VVAJ't
\ttornrj Ml !?
M
Hank of Hurry lUiiidiHj*
CONWAY. H. C.
ItHNK IIAYK.MOli
Land Surveying
and
Drainage
Spivey Iiuildin^ Conway, S. C.
HE WORLDS GRtATtSf SEWING MACHINE
I ^ RUNN^
iQ?jprai wnnt etlherfi VlhrntingShuttle, Kntaffl
Shuttle or n Single Thread [ ('hain &/UcJi\
Sewing Machine write to
m ?EW HOME SEWINO MACHINE COMPAff
Ornnge, Mors.
fltonveewinc machine* are made to aelt retflrdiM#
I amauitv aut the Now Home t* made to
'Ju? (piaramy never runr out
flAW M ntliorlxrd dealer* 1
foa ?als *
1 BURHOlJuit *? v ? ui,hi>n tti.
Oonwny, H. C. ?
11
)
3 (*ns Hurts Rife of Three.
Throe vonng white men worn
found deal Tuesday night in a room
on the third floor of an apartment
- house in Raleigh, N. C. The gas
. from the jet and from a small gas
r heater was turned on. From cards
. in the mens' pockets, they are R. A.
t Johnson, aged 21 ; M. T. ITorter, aged
3 lfi, and Fred Jernigan, aged 23, all
of Renson, N. C.
I