The Marlboro democrat. (Bennettsville, S.C.) 1882-1908, August 25, 1905, Image 1
I ne
PITT
"PO THOU, fl H10 AT LIBERTY, INHI'IRB OUR SOULS AN!) MAKE OUlt LIVES IS tgal IOSSESB?ON BAOT OH OUR DEATHS GLORIOUS IN THY OAUSE."
VOL. XX^
BENNETTS VILLE, S. C., Elli DAY,! AU GUST 25, 1905.
AN OPEN LETTER
From Hon. George B. Cromer to
Senator B. R. Tillman
ON THE DISPENSARY
Air. Cromer Appeals io Senator Tillman
to Leave Out Factional Politics
When lie Discuses the Whiskey
Question, Which Ile Claims
ls a Moral Issue.
Tho lion. George B. Cromer, former
president of tho Newberry College, bas
addressed the following open letter to
Senator 1!. R, Tillman:
The Hon. B. li. Tillman.-Dear
Sir: I protest against the introduction
of the tom-tom and Hie spirit of fac
tion into tho movement by which the
merits of tho di;-p nsary are to bo test
ed. Tnc tom-tom ls tho instrument o?
the Juggler and factionalism ls tho re
Bort of the politician. Tue pi opie of
this State havo the right to expect
something higher and better from yi u.
Your recent loiter to Mr. Higgins was
a calm, sane and judioal statement of
your attitude on the dispensary quea
sier but for this very reason it was
dlstaaeful in certain qoartors, and you
wero accused ( f straddling You gave
that letter out as an expression o?
your views, and, my name having been
kindly suggested by you. l was asked
to answer lt in the New Voice. I de
clined to do so for tho sim?le reason
that in this county wo wi: h to ti.st
the dispon-ary <i icslion cn its merits,
and, therefore, ueslre to exclude every
possible phase of ''Til m uism,"
In the Higgins h ttei y< u recogni*/,
ed the widespread and v/ell founded
hollef that the dispensary is comipt
in its administration, and that toe
present agitation is an expression o'
popular dissatisfaction. But In your
Edgellold speech you chitted your
ground, and took the position that
tho movement ls p tlltlcal In .si^nili?
canoe and ls a covert attack upon you.
lu tho Higgins lotter you said that
the remedy for the corruption resi.s
with the Legislature; that in the last
Legislature tho friends and enemies of
the dispensary got together and did
nothing hut appoint a committee ; that
ever since you were Governor you nave
given advice and made suggestions, but
that your opini?n has Lad no weigh;
with tbe Legislator?.?.; and that li tte
next Legislature does not apply the
remedy, you will help to kill the dis
pensary.
?Y IMPLICATION.
In your Edgelield speech you said
that if thc next Legislature dons not
adopt certain suggesth ns that you in
tend to make, yen will help to elco!, a
Legislature thal will. And you said,
by implication at lc:'.sfc, that you will
go to the lloformcrs for that Legis'a
ture.
I appeal from Philip drunk to Phil
ip sober-from thc temper cf thc
Edgelield speech to the tono of the
Higgins letter. lu Newberry there ls
no disposition to make an attack upon
you undercover of a movement ?gal nat
the dispensary. It is not a political
movement, lt was begun in an dT
year in. order that lt might ho a test
of a great moral q test! i, unclouded
by personal and politic) ei?shlur?,
tiona, lt is not a mo\,.:> ni t i I tin
politician?, but a novement <f the
people. You ha^e doubtless not-ccd
that the counties that wore ?.!;.
"Conservative" arc not? io tho nu ve?
merit.
.7? do not question j wx rtoht to Ka!?
P&rt in the discussion, indnij nlentij
of the fact that y m ?ro L u'hor
the system in this M. , ii ..^1 ! he
strange if you wero to roi dn Klient,
By virtue of your bi fi ?iii 5 and of
your gn at ii.ll unen i , 1. vour duty to
speak-but to sp:4, k ?.anely and tem
perately as you did 1 t. ie Higgins h t
ter. "You owe a g rt at deal io the
youth of this state; \<.u owe thc o bhe
best that you have, tc t'ive. Wbei the
dispensary was tin t ; ut on trial thero
may havo been gotd reason f r an au?
peal to a faction, hut that r :a 0 1 no
longer exis'.s. The syat m h. bee;
on trial more than tw< )v > yt tn 1. 1 ?
will soon bo vot ?(I on by thou abd ? of
men who wert) only ? Igh* or n!no \ e . rs
old when lt waa adopted. Winn \ou
speak now, we aro en tl lied to have
you speak from th ; p. Int bf view of
statesmanship and nob of paitism po
litics.
NO DANOIfilt TO TILLMAN.
liefiides, you have too much sagaci
ty to fiar that rhla m >vumcnt against
the dispensary CAU endang ry ui po
litlcal future. You oe npy a larg
place in the history of South Carollua
for tho lost fifteen years, and fur a
numhor of years no rival bi H C allong
?e! your primacy am ug tho political
leaders of the State, B nT Imap,-l 1
Sonator represe 1 ting S u .li Oar lina,
can well alford to discard th 1 mi thoth
of Ben Tillman the partis ui poll i .1
leador. I do not 1 om tb bo elf naive.
You-know of my appreciation of tho
distinguished sorvh bl ab you have
rendered this S lato kn a 11 imb r of di
rections. But 1 earnestly protest thal
you have no right to befog this quos
tion by lowering lt to tho p'ano of
partisan politics.
That tho adtnjnlnl ration of the dis
pensary system ls corrupt any fool e m
BOO as bo runs. But I go farther than
that, even at tho risk of having y u
charge me wloh cant and hypocrisy.
No mattor ho n h gb your pm > ose may
have been In adopting I he sysb m, in
its origin lt seems to bav 1 ti cn ai eua
nlrigly-d?vised sch mg bo obi ?r?form
the publio eonsolcnoo, No .Teni 1 tina!
attempt to debauch m inis hy using
the cud tn justify the menus could
have been moro successful if the sys
tem had been honestly administered.
The ooriupt administration will save
us from thc system Itself.
Governor Hoch, of Kansas, tells us:
"Wo are rearing a new civilization
here: I believe there are more than
a quarter of a million young people
who have never Seen a saloon. Probt
cition ls the only logical attitude of
law toward tho liquor traillo, and the
whole country will some day recognize
tho fact." What sort of civilization
aro we rearing lu South Carolina? Our
Supremo Court, in Its famous deolslou
upholding the Constitutionality of the
dispensary law, laid down the follow
ing as a fundt mental proposition and
said that If this proposition ls not true
tho lav/ls unconstitutional: "That
liquor, in its naturo, ls dangerous to
the morals, good order, health and
safety of the people, and ls not to bo
placed on the same footing with tho
ordinary comme dit les of lifo, such as
corn, wheat, cotton, tobacco, potatoes,
eto. Kansas says to hor children:
"Tho liquor traillo ls dangerous and
ought to be prohibited." South Car
olina says to her thousands of tohool
children: "The liquor traillo Is dan
gerous to tho morals, good order,
health and safety of the people, and
therefore we will sell liquor and get
all tho money we can for tho schools."
You may call it cant If you will, but
in ilTect here h an insidious attempt
co wed public education to tho liquor
tr?, ill J. It ls an unholy alllanco aud
Got! will put them a- under. Wc can
not i> flo d to lower the Ideals of our
BOhools. We must not poison the foun
tain that ooo visl H\s the heart and brain
of our people.
WAS BECOMING DISREPUTABLE.
Tlie business of tho saloon ktoper
was becoming disreputable lu this
State, aud saloon keepers were begin
nlrg to find it d.tlioalt to justify the
business in the eyes of their children.
The dispensary system attempts to
make tho traillo respectable and repu
table. How can t?ie children In our
sehe Ol S answer the sophistry of thc
argument that whatever contributes
to the support of the school ls good
and wiseV 1 lav it down as little short
of an axiom that a ny restrictive scheme
Unit takes control ( f ?a tr>llli that is
dangore Ul to bite morals of thc people,
and controls lt in such a way as to
make it reputable, ls a vicious and
dangerous schomc.
L'it me suggest an historical paral
lel. A great leader was commanded to
go down against thc Amalakites,
standing fer immorality, and destroy
them and theirs utterly. When lie was
called to account by t ho old prophet
and asked what meant the lowing of
cuttle and tho bleating of sheep, his
lanie excuse was that the people had
kept tho best of the sheep and oxen to
sacrifice to tho Lord. The prophet's
answer was ?as swift and withering ?as
lightning: 'Behold, toohey is better
than Baerl flee." Saerllico is good, but
there are bettor tiling \ than a -esac
rllicj. Tho Government ot great
State was commanded by tho moral
sense of the people, expressed at tho
ballot box, to go down ?and destroy
r,he liquor traillo. And when called to
account it makes the pitiful plea that
Ahilo it has not destroyed tho traille
it has managed lt so as to get money
for tho. taxpayers. Mopey for tho
schools ls good, bot there are batter
tilings than money for the schools.
The blight of God's curse falls upon
thc people that resort to methods that
dull the public conscience and lower
the tone of public morals.
IT CANNOT UELP YOU.
Senator Tillman, the dispensary sys
tem cannot help you, and you can help
it only temporarily, lt ls wrong in
principle and corrupt in practice, and
its doom has bien written. By throw
ing your powerful Influence against
che present agitation you may save
the dispensai y for a while, but lt ls
tottering and must fall, lt is fortu
nate for yon that your reputation restb
upon achievements that will endure.
YUH recall, do you not, tho desire ol
Jefferson that lils epitaph should re
mind posterity that ho was the authoi
of tho Declaration of independence,
nd >.f the bill of religious liberty, anti
the father of tho University of Vir
guda. And so his name is handed
clown, riveted to civil llhorty, and re
liglou? liberty end higher education,
loree tilings that can never depart
from the earth or from the 1 >vo ol
oem And you, what would you be rc
membered by? There ls Winthrop and
there is Clemson; well may your heart
?well with honorable pride. And there
i , I will not name the third thing.
VVbat true friend w-.it'd link youi
mune with the dispensary? What bit
ter enemy could desire a worso fate
for you iban to hive you raised tc
that bad rminene? ? A wisc solutlot
of thc liquor problem is ono tiring; tin
dispensary is another.
1 have vory little political ambition
and no taste for public controversy
Y u need not remind me that lt 1
nono of my business to take care o
your reputation. 1 know that. Hu
in a quiet way I have for many yoar
bien doing my best, little as lt rn-;
nave been, to dov ?lop strong, clean
bravo manhood lu rbis State, and i
,i d ns me to feel that you are abou
LO let pride of opinion and tho fervo
f debato stand in the way of a fal
u d open test of a groat moral epics
?.on. The poople do nut need advice
i they need free opoortunity to vote
Respectfully, GICOBGK B. CKOMEK.
Newberry, August ll, 1006,
Start With New York hlfO,
insurance Commissioner ll. I<
Kohr., of Tennessee, announced Sal
urday that the Interstate examinatio
f life Insurance companies wool
in men ce on Ootobor I. The Nie
Y rk hi'o Insurance Company will h
. x ? in i ned ilrnt. This an-.ouncemen
.v.ui m ; le af tor a c ?nforence bctweo
tho Insurance commissioners of Ku
Lucky, Minnesota, and WlSOonsll
Nebraska, Louisiana and Tenne, s.:
iud President John A McCall, cf til
Nev/ York Lifo Insurance Compati]
A Good Gift.
According to the report of tho cx<
outovs of the will of tho late W. Vt
Franklin, of Columbus, Ohio, ti
Children's hospital and tho Homo fi
tho Aged of that city will got$60,0(
aoh ar wollan the residue left af h
a $70,000 estate Is settled. Tho ex
cut os say that tho residue will be tv
or three times greater than the spec
fie beq (eats Of $60,000 each, and th
will oe evenly divided between ti
two Institutions, lt ls thought cai
Institution will rccelvo $100,000 ;
least. _
Voted lt Out,
Tho dispensary was voted out
Union C ninty Tuesday by a vote
t wont j-two to one. Tuc vote ea
was very light, showing that mai
Of tho citizens of that county can
very little which way tho clcoth
wcut.
HE DENIES IT
Senator B. R. Tillman Replies to
Or. ti. B. Croiner's Letter.
DEFINES POSITION.
Says He Has Not Nor Does He Intend to
Appeal to Factionalism, but Asserts
that thc Leaders Are right
ing Him While Fighting the
Dispensary.
Thc Hon. George B. Cromor.-My
Dear Slr: As your "opon letter" ap
pealed in The Sunday Nows and In to
day's State 1 presume you exptct an
answer through tho same medium.
I desire, in the beginning, to ex
proas my appreciation of your kindly
and complimentary allusions to my
self. 1 value them moro highly be
cause In tlie past you have not been
my political friend.
.1 have road your lotter carefully
and have endeavored to judge your ar
guments and weigh the points you
presont as sanely as may bc. It ls
not always possible for men to agree,
even though both aro actuated by the
nighest and purest motives, and it is
therefore natural that you should
misjudge me in some things and disa
gree witli me In others.
Now shout tlie appeal to factional
ism; 1 deny absolutely that I have
made such an appeal or intend to
make such an appeal, and in just!Ilea
tlon of the truthfulness of this state
ment let me remind you of what 1
said at Edge?eld. To quote: "I do
not wish to revive factionalism and 1
ara sorry to have the appearance of
doing so." "1 am aware that many
of tho strongest, s apporte rs o? the dis
ponsary now are men who were and
are yet probably Conservati ves, while
some of Its most bitter antagnlsts are
former Ref ot mers. lt, thercf re, can
not bc charged that 1 am codea vorlog
to draw tho cid lines which rent tho
State in twain." Again, "1 want
this matter settled entlroly apart
from my perscnal and political for
tunes, lt is a much groator question
for thc people of South Carolina .is to
how they shall wisely and best gov
om the sale of liquor than as to
whether I or somo one else represents
them in the Si-nato. 1 know there
are many, m m who will vote for me
regardless of their former poll ties 1 af
dilations and of tholr present attitude
oil tills question', and it ls probable' "
that there will be many who will be
aggrieved at my activity lu dealing
with tlie question."
ONI.Y A CASK OK SKI-K DBFBNOB.
When a public man is viciously at
tacked with slander and abuse
and there is every indication of
a purpose to press that attack In tho
next Democratic primary with a view
to his overthrow, it seems to mc lt ls
perfectly legitimate for bim to give
notice to his frlc -ds and his one m'es
alike of what ls going on, and let all
understand that he is prepared to
tight. This is all I have done and st?
far from expecting to maleo a plea to
the Reformers as )0u charge to bo my
purpose by "Implication," 1 have ex
prcssly said that tlie old lines could
cot be drawu and 1 want the Issue
settled entirely apart fro;?', my per >
sonal and political for;unes.
When 1 wrote my loiter to Mr.
Higgins 1 merely alluded to the "true
Inwardness" of this movement, which
I then real!/.'d was liebig engineered
by my inveterate political enemies.
You seem to be aggrieved because I
have shifted position from tho "sane
and judicial attitude of the Higgins
lettor," and now take tho ground that
tho movement ls political and a covert
attack up.m me. Your assertion is
too sweeping, my dear Doctor. The
"movement" against the dispensary
among the peoplo arises from thc dis
satisfaction witli the management
and strong belief In corruption willoh
exists, 1 Ut whilo tlie people are light
ing tho dispensary either to purify tr
destroy lt, the loaders are lighting me.
Von may not be. In fact I know you
aro not, and probably there are many
others who bavo not such feeling or
purpose, but look at thc numerous
evidences of tho p ill bical purpose and
significance of the movement in the
minds of tho leaders. One of those
who attended the Prohibition Con for
enc, in Columbia declared lt to be the
Intention to "tilt the State up on
edge and spill out not only thc dis
pensary, b it tho existing political
status." Toe Darlington News de
olared that the "dispensary was so
intimately interwoven with Senator
Tillman's polltlcil fortunes that fur
destruction of the one meant tho do
struothul of tho other."
The mass meeting bold at Yorkville
on the 7 h of this m '?nth, under the
leadership of tho author of tim Brice
hill, d.scussed and abused me a great
deal moro than they di ^cussed the dis
pensar y or prohibition, and each and
every speaker opened ids m. u h in
many respects to mo in thc harshest
and most insulting manner. Since lt
Will not bo (billed that tho anti dis
ponsary forres aro au Incongruous and
In m< ii, respects an tag nlstlo aggro
gath n, ml Isters of tho Gospel, d >c?
tors of divinity, advocates of high
license, the old bar room system In Its
ossencj blind tlgOi'S) who want free
liquor for tho money they can make
nub of lt, and yet with this army In
molloy, lcd by men with all manner
of opinions, and marshalling its forces
for my destruction, you. ray (?oar
Doctor, tell me that I must remain
quiet, continue tho Ramo "calm, ju
dlelal, sane attitude assumed in thc
Higgin?'? letter" and not lot thc peo
pie know what ls going on.
THAT "OIIANOK OK POSITION."
I stated in that letter If the Legis
laturc did not apply tlie remedy for
tho existing evils in tlie dispensary
management that I would help kill
the dispensary, More mature thought
and a bettor understanding of the
purpose of thc anti-dispensary leaders
led mo to givo notice that if that Leg
lslaturc did not apply tho remedy 1
would appoal to tho people to oleot a
Legislature that would.
Is thcro anything wrong In that?
Anything Immoral, or unst&tesuian
like? If I had remained steadfast' in
that position would not all the ILIIU
euces that are pe-sslblo bo brought to
bear to keep the Legislature from
doing anything, especially doing
things whloh I suggest? If tho Legis
lature now in oilloo could te thus In
lluenced, oajjled aud coerced to resist
reformation under tho speolous ploa
that lt was at my diotation and I had
quietly fallon in ranks to help kill the
dispensary without first appealing
from the Legislature to the pecplo, do
you not see that I would have tied
my own hands and surrendered at dis
cret on to my worst cncm'es?
1 hud to deal with ono "driftwood"
Legislature once, and 1 appealed to
tho people to riifoim It, which they
did most elli Coally by retiring most
of those win? had proven false to their
professions and pledges, to private
life. Tho present Legislature was
not elcoted on tho dispensary IHKUO,
and ls a very conservative body of
men, and with so much political elec
tricity In the atmosphere and so much
thundering against the dispensary, it
may wall pause ere it takes tiny action.
Tho disclosures at Spartanburg will
undoubtedly cause lt to do something,
but whether lt will do anything effec
tuai or not remains to be seen.
I wish to say hore and now, as
though in parenthesis, the result of
this light, as far as 1 am personally
concerned, gives mo no uneasiness
whatever. The olllce of Senator does
not. belong to mc, but lt belongs to
.?he pcoplo and they will have tho
right next year to choose my succes
sor, and I will bow to their will, what
ever lt may he, without a muriner. 1
rio not believe that the fall of the dis
pensary neoessarlally means my fall.
1 do not see what association there is
or could possibly be between the dis
pensary question and the position
which I have taken upon lt and my fit
ness fur tho high ollie) which 1 hold.
If my health continuos gool I shill
ask the pi opie to continue me in the
place, not because I am tho father of
the dispensary, but because of my ser
vico In Washington, 1 am not un
easy 1 I the least. So much for that
branch of your letter.
Ll QUO lt DK1NKINQ NOT IMMOUAL.
Wow let us como to the dispensary
sary question and vour treatment of
lt. You quoto, with great unotlon,
from tho decision of our Supreme
Court,, ''That liquor In its nature ls
dangerous to the morals, good order,
health and safety of the people, and
is not to be pl deed on the same foot
lng with tho ordinary commodities of
life, such as corn, wheat, cotton, to
bacon, potatoes, etc. " I wish I had
that decision before mo so that I could
tilve its cssoncn in lylef form rather
than take au Isolated sentence;' You*
aro too good a lawyer not to know
Uiat thc State could have nothing to
do with the liquor trafile were lt not
for the exercise of tho police power
which rests upon thc right of the
Slate Government to control or forbid
any and every thing which concerns
the mora's at,cl health of thc people;
and right hero Ls where we part com
pany in dealing with thc question.
The prohibitionists in general, and
you, my dear Dootor, as ono of their
leaders, tire thoroughly Imbued with
the bell? f that liquor drinking ls dan*
goren s to tho morals, good order,
health and safety of tito people, and
you would therefore forbid its sale In
any way a.s a beverage and would lirall
itsu-e Lo medicinal, pharmaceutic a
and mechanical purposes. South Car
olina declares In the dispensary law
li self:
"The manu facture, sale, barter or
exchange, receipt, or acceptance for
unlawful use, delivery, storing and
keeping in possession within this Statt,
of any spirituous, malt, vinous, fer
mented, browed, (whethor lager or
rice boer,) or other liq Jors; any com
pound or mixture thereof, hy what
ever nama called or known, which
contains alcohol and Is used as a bever
age, oxoept as ls hereafter provided,
ls hereby prohibited under a penalty
of not less than three nor more than
t welve months at hard labor In tho
State Penitentiary, or pay a lino of
not loss than $100 nor more than $500,
or both line and Imprisonment, In tho
discretion of the Court, for each of
tense. All alcoholic liquors in this
State, whether manufactured within
this Stato or-.{elsewhere, not having
be? n tested by thc chemist of the
South Carolina College and found to
bc pur:1 and free from poisonous, hurt
ful and deleterious matters, are here
by declared to be of a detrimental
character, and their use and consump
tion are against tho morals, go id
health and safety of tho State, etc."
[u thc j idgment of tho Legislature,
which enacted tho law as a oorapro?
mise, the dispensary system would
bring about the best results. You
and your friends nuke of thL ques
ton a religious Issue, while tho sup
p irtcrs of the dispensary law consider
lt a political Issue, and tho people of
tho State have six tinvs by ovar
whelming m-j uitics sustained such
view. Y< u and your friends h,\v.>
time and time agata presented >our
Idoas and pressed them wlth-vigor and
ability, but tuc voters have not seen
lt as you did.
M(?UOU MON IGY IN TUM SCHOOLS.
l vfculd Wo the l&st man to lower
tho Ideals of our schools. I would be
tho last n an to throw temptation In
tue way of any one, young or old. 1
.vonld bj tho last man to teach any
child to il, liquor ls not dangerous;
but is it tho outy of a statesman to
hobble the devil, so lo speak, when
ho oan't bi chained, or is lt his duty
lo ?Imply say he wants to soo him
hobbled or Ohftlncd and then tot him
?008C? Tho dispensary law properly
administered does reduce drunken
ness. It does c.'mince to tamporiMice
and good morals, and ti aches men thc
uses of llqu ir rather than tho aboso.':
of it. Tnat tho Stato board of con
trol IR now under suspicion of corrup
tion, with many things pointing to
th?' belief that the suspicion is well
grounded, and that tho local dispon
sers have I ?eon debauched, because of
tho lax administration or maladminis
tration of tho law, proves nothing.
Pope long slnco epitomized this whole
I subject In that woll known couplet!
(Continued on fourth pago.)
A Preac?i?jr Calls a Dispensary
Adv?cate a Liar and
MAKES A SENSATION.
Thc Rev. P. A. E. Derrick Charges Sena
tor Bleaeje, of Newberry County,
With Insulting and Impugning
thc Ministry, and Lying
If He DenledCharge.
A special dispatoh to tho Columbia
State from. Newberry says an unex
pected and'sousatloual dispensary de
bate took placo at Young's Grove in
that county on Tuesday of last week,
when ltov.^C. M. Byod of Prosperity,
?utraged at statements made by Mr.
?. L. Bl?iise who ls Stato Senator
from Newberry concerning tho Chris
tian ohuroh and ministry, protested
eloquently.
Following this and at the close of
tho speak lng Mr. Please was halted by
the Rev. P. H. E. Derrick, a Lutheran
preacher who chargod him with in
sulting and impugning thc Ohtistian
ministry. Mr. Derrick seemed to be
very mad, whon he began talking to
Mr. Bleas?.
On Mr. Btease's denial that he had
made certain remarks in his speech,
Rev. Mr. Derrick threateningly and
llatly contradicted him, renewing the
accusation. Mr. Please' turned to
walk away but before he had taken
twenty steps Rev. Mr. Derrick shouted
after him'tiie words, "and If you deny
lt you are aliar." Mr. Please took
no notice of the words.
Willie denouncing general hypocrisy
and corruption in bis speech. Mr
Please said that if all tho rascals were
turned out of tho churches there
would not be a quorum left next Sun
day, and that he had never known a
preacher , who would not tako a gam
bier's money.
The whole affair created intonse
feeling. ; Mr. A. 0. Jones also inter
rupted Mr. Please to express his in
dlgnatlon. Ahlde from the above in
oident l<lie day was without marked
features: All of tire speakers ac
quitted ^themselves well and wore lis
tened tu with attention but at no
time was there groat enthusiasm.
Mr. .I.-.bn C. Goggans presided, in
.ryrtiyM - Mr. Arthur Klblor as the
r.it in. jr. Dr. Geo. u. Oromor and
Mr. A. Cajones followed. A lotter
was read from Rev. J A. Sllgh, re
gretting bis Inability to bc present on
account of sickness.
Mr. Pleaso's speech followed, being
the only ono on the dispensary side
After the incident between Mr. Bisase
and R iv. Mr. Derrick tlie cro wd called
for Rev. Mr. Boyd on the platform
Ile responded eloquently for prohib?
uion. Thc crowd was estimated a?,
about 800.
ANOT1IICH ACCOUNT.
In speaking of the occurrences nar
rated above The News and Courier
says: Q lite a sensation developed at
Young's Grove Tuesday afternooon at
a dispensary discussion. In his speech
Senator Blease referred to some pro
hlbitionlsts as hypocrites, and said:
"If you are going to kill tho dispen
sary because lt is rotten, why not kill
tho Church? If you turn out every
rascal In tlie Church you would not
have a quorum Sunday."
Hore A. C. Jones interrupted, say
ing that Blosse had no right to slan
der the Church. Argument followed,
the crowd upholding Mr. Jones.
Then Blease repeated lt, whereupon
some one said: "Talk to us like de
cent men or quit."
Blease resumed his speech, but the
Rev. C. M. Boyd, the Associate Re
formed minister here, said:
'Mr. Blease, just now you told a
lady how to raise BODS, not drunk
ards." Now tell us about the Spar
tanburg Investigation, when you said
on thc stand, "I wvuld like to have a
drink now."
Mr. Blease replied: "Yes, I said
it. You look like a man who would
take a bottle of beer on the sly. When
we got up town we will take one to
gether. I can generally read any
man."
When Blcaso was noll li sd that Mr.
lloyd was a minister, lie apologized.
Col. Please tried to continue, but
tlie audience yelled, "Boyd! Boydl
Boyd!"' and Pleaso's voice was drowned
when he was not half through speak
ing.
Thc Rev. Mr. Pojd came on the
stand. Please asked bl rn not to bo
personal, as he had been promised the
last speech. Then Mr. Boyd said he
would not speak, but the crowd yelled
for him. Ho said that what he would
!\:>.vo to be personal, when a man said
at an Investigation that he wanted a
drink and hero teaches a woman how
i.o raiso anon, not a drunkard, ?lan
dor Churches and virtually blasphemes
God. Ile conk! not help from speak
ing. Mr. Boyd's speech was a master
ful oral! in, to winch nosynopsh herc
car do justice. Iludid not want Lo
say anything today, but had to
When he carno here there was no dis
uins.vry, no policeman, no jill. Now
all these ai o hero, and the ol tizona
know the stato of affaalrs. He ap0!
pealed to thinking men to rid the
conn ty i f a curs;.
When Col. BlcaSO left the stand lie
was confronted by the Rev. P. H, G
Derrick, tlie Lutheran minister, who
challenged the statement made In the
speech that no minister ever refused
blood money to build a church, Col.
Please said he referrod to Newberry
and seemingly showed the white,
feather, walking off. Derrick said:
"And you are a liar, "
Tr At rt mt xiii-m.
Four young men who reside In
Charlotto, N. C., sat on the Southern
railway track near Greenville Tuesday
night foll asleep. Tlie outgoing Go
? lumbla brain in passing killed c.
Williams Instantly and seriously in
Ju rod Paul Fowlor and Henry Holley,
l?dward Kills oscapod unhurt*
FELL F?OM A POLE.
A Promising Young Man Meots With
a Fearful Peath.
itobort Haynewortti of donison, '02,
Dios From Injuries Ile oo iv oil
Whtlo PorformlnK His Duty.
A spcolal dispatch from Darlington
to Tho Stato says Mr. Itobort Hayns
worth, a ye ung man of much promise,
died there Thursday morning from
the effects of injuries he sustained in
falling from an oleotrio light pole
Wednesday night. The storm Wed
nesday afternoon had upset tho cloe
trio light wires and Wednesday night
it was discovered that sume of the
aro lights woro not burning. The
euginecr. Mr. Hatohell, at the power
plant apprised young Haynsworth of
this fact and tho latter started on his
round to remedy tho trouble
Ho was cautioned, howevor, bo
phono when ho found a wire that
needed tixlng so tire power could be
cut ott and he did so once or twice
but no message v/as received at the
tho point where the sad acoldent oc
curred. When fouud by the Coast
Line night watchman Mr. Haynsworth
was lying at the foot of an cleotric
light pole between tho depot and a
nearby shed.
II ls mangled limbs were across the
railroad track and his bady was drawn
as if he had suffered intense conges
tion. One leg v/as completely crushed,
causing tlie main bone to project
through the outer skin and clothing;
his forehoad also SUB tal ne 1 a seven
blow in which tho skull was slightly
fractured. Ile bled profusely and was
never conscious aftor the fall. Mr.
llatchell says that Mr. Haynsworth
left the power plant about 0 o'clock
and was not found until 10.15. Ith
probable that he lay there for over an
hour before any one saw bim.
Tncro arc numerous conjectures as
to how this accident occurred, but ll
ls generally believed that you np
Haynsworth ascended the pole ano
came in contact with a live Wirf
which caused him to lose iris grip arr
fal!. He must have ftdlen 25 or .'lo
feet. When fourni he was moved t
the home of his grandmother, M rs
H. E. P. Sanders, and a doctor wa
summoned but to no avail. He dior
Thursday morning at 8 o'clock ano
will probably be buried Friday at
Florence, where bis family reside.
He ls the son of Mr. and Mrs. Moo
ney Haynsworth of Florence and ii
nephew of that city. ' In 1002 h.
graduated at Clemson in the eleotrica
lepartment and came immediately t
Darlington, where ho accepted a pos)
oion with the Carolina Witter "?nd
Light company. He proved hlmsel'
in (.dictent electrician and ho advanoee
rapidly in this line of work. Only s
few months prior to his death he wa?
promoted to the position of genera
superintendent of the elcctrlct plain
there. He was a young mau with i
bright future and he had a host o'
friends in Darlington. His untimely
lea th has cast a gioom over the en
tire town.
Hungry l'oasants.
A dispatch from Madrid, Spain,
says the dlsordors in Andalusia as i
result of the famine aro growing
alarming. The sacking of farms ano
the slaughtering of sheep and cattli
continuo pratlcally unchecked. Thi
district-? around Carmona, Ouina.
Estepa, Utrlra, Marou and Jerez an
terrorized by hunger driven peasent:.
The wealthier resident.! are fleeing
and abandoning their homes taking
refuge in Seville, Cordova and otho'
large cities. The starving peasant*
continue to invado the towns, clamor
lng for f x>d and sometimes looting
It is stated that 1,000 are massed
outside Oiuna, thrcatnlng to storn.
tho houses of the rich. Aid from tho
go ver ment and public charity ls in.ade
q ti ate and distributed sbwly. Troops
aro protecting many towns, but tin
author!tCB hesitate to take seven I
mca-.ures, partly through sympathy
with tho distressed and partly
through fear lest a wave of vlolenoe
be provoked, lt ls est?mala 1 that
1,000,000 are desperately hungry, and
that 100,000 of those are actually
starving.
'Wounded hy ItnlHans,
A special dispatch from Anderson
to The S! te says Sheriff Nelson It
Green and his deputy, W. N. Scott,
receiver." .-dight wounds at the farmers'
barbecue Wednesday afternoon iti ar
resting four young men of the cou nt v
for disorderly conduct. The men an
A. L. Wi litton and three brothers
named Richey, lt seems that these
men were cursing and talking loudly
at tho table and when they were or
dered by tho sheriff to keep quiet one
of them resisted tito oilloor, who was
cut across the ab ?omen. His depu
ty was also slightly wounded. Thc
men were taken Into custody andar?
in the county jail.
Pearla Found lo ('ooonnutH,
"Pearls aro not found in oysters
alone." Sometimes, "said a lapidary,
thoy aro found In coeoanuts. 1 Otico
cut a cocoanut pearl. It was the si/.j
of a pea, and Its quality was good, lt
resembled an oysier pearl, only iu was
a little duller, Cocoanut pearls are
found in tlie heart of tho nut. It
ls thought that they aro formed by
tho hardening of tho nut's tl sh.
T.ioy aro, so to speak, a kind o*
oryslallzod tumor or wart. Thee
pearls aro. raro. They aro rarer i h ui
oyster pearls. They are also cheaper
than Oyster pearls, hoing less hard and
less transparent."
\ Minali Voto.
The Columbia Record says Union
county last week voted out thc dis
pensary hy 7(H to 410. In tho last
primary 2,(?75 votes wcro oast. In
tlie last general election, In which
there was no interest whatever, the
vote was 1,051 or 473 moro tiran were
oust In the dispensary election. Only
reglsterod voters aro allowed to voto.
We have no reason to bellovo that tho
result would have been different, but
ino faot is that ie&s than half of the
white mon of Union over twenty-one
years old expressed an opinion on this
most important question
S???H?M liUINJSD
By a Etrange Bug that Was First
Econ in Columbia.
Tho Nut mo ol tho New Par?sito ls as
Yot HomiwhRtUnknoAvn to tho
Department of Afcrtoulturo.
Tho State says there is a strange
bug on tho farm of tho State Ilospi
tal for the Insano, and oven the bu
reau of entomology of the department
of agriculture ls unable to ascertain,
fora time, tho ancestry ot thlsinseot.
Not long ago, it will bo remembered,
tho atteutlon of Mr. J. W. Bundi, su
perintendent of tho Stato hospital,
was oalled to the fact that sorghum
whloh was med to feed the cattle w<u>
dying rapidly. Investigation showeo
that a small post was preying on the
soi gluon and an export was askod foi
from tho government.
Mr. E. G. S. Titus, entomologist,
came to tho ol ty and inspected thc
damage done by tho pest, but eoulo
not tell what lt was. Ile left for Wash
ington with some of the "animals" in
lils valise and microscopical examina
tions have boon going on. Yesterday
Mr. hunch received tho following let
ter:
Mr. J. W. Bundi, Stato "Hospital foi
the l:mue, Oolumoia, S. 0.
Dear Mr. hunch: I am very muct
ludobced to you for your kindness te
Mr. Titus on his recent visit. Since
ois return ho has been very enthusi
astic regarding courtesies shown him.
1 have to thank you for tho arrauge
.neut to send us material at periods ol
ten days, in order to better euablo tu
to study tho habits of tho little pest
which seems to bo working so mool,
destruction In your sorghum. Uati.
wo can get au adult mojth wo shall Le
wholly lu the dark as to the Idontlt)
>f the depredator. As soon as wc sc
ouro a moth and lind out what lt is,
tt will throw a groat deal of light upon
the problem.
From the faot that lt appsrs t(
>rocd freely in crab grass, 1 am led
t-o believe that lt has attacked corn ie
.veil as sorghum, without having bea
detected by you. Whether its presen!
severity ls duo to your system of farm
ng, made necessary, as 1 understand,
by the rules of your Institution, ot
w he thor lt ls a periodical outbreak
such as WO nave witnessed lu the cast
if other Insects, I am absolutely un
ib!e to tell.
1 would judge If the crab grass was
ploughed ander this fall lt would great
y reduce the peat another year, but
rf course, crab grass grows on othci
premises besides your own, and unless
lt ls known to ocour In other premise.1
tbout you, 1 should bo very mue!) In
dined to urge rotation for a singh
/ear with some crop that would noe
issltate the destruction of this grass.
Some orup thit would require constant
cultivation until late in tho seasoi.
would seem to he preferable.
I wi uki like to ask If ordluaril)
.herc ls muoh of this crab grass witt
/our oats. If not, thou you shoul
bave to look elsewhere for relief. 1 an.
n hopes to be able to visit you during
Lhe next month, and probably soudai
vssistant your way later in the season
md he will endeavor to, If possible,
lind out some measure of relief.
Thanking you again for your oour
tesy, 1 am, yours truly,
E. M. WEBSTER.
In Charge of Eiold Crop Insect luves
g?tions.
It ls said that thc pest is making
itself known iii other vicinities, notai)
ly on the farm of Mr. 13. F. Taylor. It
is seldom that there ls an insect so
strange to tho bureau of entomology.
Had nu Kollow Kovor.
The desperate elTort3 of the health
authorities to prevent the spreading
if the typhoid fever epidemic pre
valent lu Brooklyn have not been sue
cessfulsof.tr and the situatlon ls be
?inning to be (falto ritlcal. lt seem
that Batch Beach, liensonhurst and
?lmor Park, situated on the lirooklyi
beach, extending from the Narrows
ro (Jolley Island, from the center or
heart of the disease d'strlot. There
are various theories concerning tin
causes of tho epidemic. The most
plausible ls that persons living In tin
icaoh 'district Insisted pu bathing at
the wrong side of the tide, when lin
water, backed up by the rising tide,
was strongly contaminated by the con
tents of the numerous sowers empty
ing Into the bay. The infected area
is constantly spreading and lt is feared
dist b fore long tho epidemic will
ga<n a foothold on thc Manhattan
side. Should that happen, the rosa I
?n the overcrowded and unsanitary
districts of the E ist and West sides
would be appalling. Up to the pres
nt time there have been nearly tw<
b usand O&ses of typhoid In Now
York and about four hundred deaths,
caused by that disease.
licHN Whtbkov Uaed.
Mr. .John 0. Watkins, Clerk of
Court of Anderson County, writes av
follows to Senator. Tinman;" Tho re
coups in tibs ollloe show that thc
curt of general sosslo.is for Aude r
son bounty during the years 18'Jl ano
18U1? there wi ro 108 trials and lhat
during,tho years 1903 and 1004 then
v.oro only 61. In this oonneoolon 1
will add an extract (rom presentment
of the grand Jury of Feburavy, 1904:
"Wc Ihluk lt is a matter worthy
of nbtico that notwithstanding the
rapid increase of population <>?
i ur county, tho influx of people from
other counties and other States, ai d
tho aggregation of so roany places of
the Industrial enterprises located In
our mid it, yot ci imo seems to bc do
creasing._
.Inul I.Ike Tin m.
"Reuben (fields, tho Johnson countj
mathematician, who ls oonelderod h>
many to bo an idiotic wonder, stopped
at a hotel lu a small t "WU in Hoary
county recently," says Thc Oak Grove
(Mn.) Banner. "As usual, In mich
places, there wore a number of drum
mers on hand; there was also a un Ot*
ing of some medical men at the placo,
who used tho hotel as headquarters
One of the doctors thought lt woulo
be q lite a Joke to toll Fields that so mu
of tno M. D.'s had concluded to kidnap
Ihm and take out his brains to learn
, how it was ho was so good In nutho
; mattes. He was th.cn asirnd by them
i what ho was going to do about it.
i Fields replied: I will go on without
brains Just like you doctors aro doing.
FIFTY KILLED
By Excursion Train Plunging
Twenty-five Feet in River.
BRAKE DIDN'f WOBK.
The Train Was from Klnston, N, C., on
the Atlantic Coast Line Railroad. ,
Ail, Except Two of the Un
fortunate Victims, Were
Colored People.
A dispatch frcm Norfolk, Va., says
jhat o*vlng to tlie Inability of Engi
neer D. l?. Ralg to ootroi bis air brakes,
an exoursiou train from Kinston, N.
C., bound to tbatoity, p'unged through
? n open draw in a bridge over the
western brai.ci of tho Elizabeth river
?.t Bruoo station, eight milos from
Norfolk, Tnursday afternoon, and 50
per jons, mostly negroes, were drown?
ed.
Up to a lato hour Thursday night
only so von bodies had been recovered
from the wreckage. The list of injur
ed so far as oan be ascertained, num
bars nearly 100, though most of these
*ro slightly hurt. A largo numer of
physicians from Norfolk and, nearby
ol ties went, to the scene.
Among tho victims, the only white
ones wero Edward J oliffe, manager of
oho excursion, aud Edward Forbes,
who assisted bira, both of Greenville,
N. G. Tue Merrit wrooking organizi
on Tnur&day night dispatches an ex
pedition from Norfolk to the soono
for the purpose of raising tho sunken
oars, which He In ab jut 25 feet Of
.vater. Until tho cars are ralsjd. no
icourato estimate nf thc number of
tho dead can be given.
Tue train WHS composed of aa en
gine and six passenger oars. Toe en
gine and two oars went through tho
haw, leaving tho four rear oars ? n
jiie traok. Ooo oar was comp^e^ely
iubmerged and tho other partly sub
nerged. Nothing ls visible of tho lo-.
I ;onoollvo not oven the smokestack. It
j s believed every occupant of tho llrst
jar perished. Tho dead can bo gjtton
jut ouly by diving under tho oar. The
some following tuc wreck was oae ot
indescribable horror, with the shrlek
0 g of men, women and children, who
meo drowning, struggling out of the
partly submerged coach and floating
.n the rlvor.
Tho passengers who were uninjured
immediately started to roscue thoso
inprlsoaed in tho oars. Norfolk and
Portsmouth wero communicated with
md physicians v/oro sent out on a
vrccklug train. Many people in tho
neighborhood went to the scono of the
vrcck and helped In the roscue. The
njured were taken to tho traok era
mnkmont and were attended thereby
1 ho physicians. Collins Ferguson, the
?olored bridge tender of tho Atlantlo
I Coast Hue, was knocked from the
iridge hy the Impact and killed. En
jlneor lldg and IPireman Alfred Coop
er, colored, escaped by jumping. The
vrecked train left Kidston, N. C., at
7 o'oioek Tnursday morning with 165
colored excursionists for Norfolk. It
vas due to arrive at Norfolk at 1
?'clock Thursday afternoon.
Following thia tialu was another ex
?ursion train over tho samo road bring
ing ?100 excursionists fron Rook7
Mount, N. C. Preceding tho wrecked
rain was still another excursion train
;arrylng some 300 merchants and
itiiers from Augusta, Qa., Cnarlcston,
.5. C., and J ackson v die, E.a., bound to
Baltimore, Philadelphia and New
York, for the pure^aso of fall good.
This Drat train arrived at Norfolk
it 8.;io o'olook Thursday morning
without accident and tho Augusta,
Jacksonville and Charleston merchants
ioft for tho north Tnursday night by
water. Tho Rocky Mount excursion
ists and thc survivors of the wreok
vere brought to Norfolk ovor tho Nor
folk and Western.
Cr ":linl Into Trolley.
At Cincinnati, Oolo, three m*n
.vere killed and ton wero Injured Wed
nesday night when a fast through ex
orcss from Nev/ York to Cincinnati
on the Haiti more and Oalo South
western crashed into a Winton Place
r,rolloy|car In Winton Placo a suburb.
VII tho killed lived in Winuon Place.
According to some witnesses of tho
wreck John Driscoll, gate tender,
hud let the gate down to allow a
'relght to pass. The locomotive of the
frelghtemltted heavy clouds of smoak,
preventing tiie tender from seeing the
passenger train bearing do vu at high
?peed and ho raia 'd tao gates, it ls
?aid. The locomotive striuk tho
n ick part of thc street car and lt
.vas tossed to pieces lu all directions.
A Voling .viiiilior.
Holen G itor, who would have boon
thlrtoen years old ou Novombor 5th
a xt, died In the Now York Post
Graduate hospital Saturday forty livo
minutes a'ter the surgeons performed
the Caes iran op: rai iou on hor. Tho
operation was the last retort to save
i he Uves of mother and baby, lt was
?moor s'u:, for, although Obiter causes
vere, it? ,al to the ohtld motlier, nor
baby survived and was cheerful and
m 1 ' ?,-, weighing so von pounds, The
Ohlld /as an illegitimate one.
'Mi ?O' Illili iltt.HMO.
At Baxley, Ga., A. J. Chestnut,
who a few days ago shot and killed
Marshall Mike. Asplnwall, and being
pursued hy the sheriff and a largo
number of Citizens was wounded, died
Wednesday evening. William Smith
.if Waycross, engaged at Baxley at
work on the school building, shot
Chi stunt with a rlilo and since has
become iu?-i?ic and Is now in tbs asy
lum. r
Another Polar KxnoiUtion,
A dispatch from Christina Norway,
says tho steamer Terrauova has boon
sighted off llonnlgsgaag, with Zolgler,
of thc north polo exploring exp?di
tion, hovllng by Anthony F?ala of
Brooklyn, aboard, Tho vessel had
got to 85 degrees i i minutes north
i latltu lo. All tho Amerioans in the
party aro well.