The Marlboro democrat. (Bennettsville, S.C.) 1882-1908, March 06, 1903, Image 1
DO THOU LIBERTY GREAT. INSPIRE OUR SOULS AND M?^pjO|jR LIVES IN THY POSSESSION HAPPY, OR OUR DEATHS GLORIOUS,IN THY CAUSE."
BENNETTSYILLE, S. C., ?tDAY, MARCH 6, 1903.
NO. 17.
TILLMAN SPEAKS.
He Criticises the President's Door of
Hope Policy in
CONNECTION WITH THE NEGRO.
Ho Says thc Ballot ol' tho Negro In
- tito South lu Always n
Monaco to Good
Government..
Senator Tillman opened his batte
ries in the United States Senate 1 ist
week on the negro question. Ile was
discussing the Indi,mola po^tulllce
trouble. In his introduction he said
he proposed to surprise his friends
and astonish Ids enemies, if lie has
any, by being very mild and temper
ate in what he would say: "If we had
known at the beginning of the civil
war," said he "what we know now
there would have been no war." lie
inquired why the large majority of
thc law abiding people or ludlanola
should bc punished because there was
a small lawless and brutal i lenient.
It was contrary, he said, tn the fun
damental principles of Anjrlo-Saxon
jurisprudence.
? Replying to some remark ; made by
Senator Spooner in his spece i, Senator
Tillman said: "It is not the dream of
the wildest ass that roams over the
Southern States with a wax skin on
him that the Federal Government is
not supreme," but,he said, there were
some cognate propositions which have
been ignored.
Ile said that in thc South people
have a constant reminder that their
ancestors thirty-five years ago were
conquered. "We are perpcotually re
minded," he said, accentu iting his
words, "that we are in tee union, but
not in it, except to pay taxes.
The poison in the race condition in
the South, he declared, lay in thc ref
eree system which had been adopted.
Thc balance of power, he said, in the
National Republican Conventions, was
held by thc machine of the South,and
that machine was composed of ne
groes. When the people of the South,
said he, lose patience and do "cruel,
bitter, fearful, tiendisli and savage
things, there is a howl from men who
know nothing and have never been
South of the i'otoinae, but have theo
rized."
Continuing, and addressing the Re
publican side, he said that if this pol
icy of negro equality is carried out,
and if some of them could be given
places in the cabinet he would vote
? for them. "I will vote to confirm
Booker Washington as secretary of
anything. Let us have a negro, a
?rje_U?irr.o. iuiL--a_mulaltu or hy.
fiji; Then let tis make them officers
in the army and navy. Let us give
them prorata share of all the good
jobs, wherever they exist, without re
gard to local conditions." He said
that nothing of the sort would bc
done.
Mr. Tillman said that in 'dealing
with tile Indiauola postollice the pres
ident and postmaster general trans
cended their authority in resorting
method which were both tyranical
and unconstitutional, ile wanted to
know if in figuring up the purpose of
their new born zeal "this cold blood
ed, calculative, advisedly-taken ac
tion" was not prompted by a low mo
tive. Ile charged that 800,000 ne
groes arc coercing 50,000,000 of white
people in the Is'orth to deal with 17,
000,000 white men in thc South in the
interest of 8,000,000 ignorant negroes
in that section.
Ile referred to thc cost in lives and
money on account of the race problem
in this country and addressing the
Republican side, called on them to
meet him "upon the same plane of
patriotism of race pride and civiliza
tion and not to fall into the pit!rill
"^cesspool bf partiRatr?sities.'! JTc read
extracts from the letter of the""pro
dent written some time since covering
his views with respect to appointments
of negroes to ollice. lie wanted lo lie
just lo tile president, he said, but the
views were superficial. "How little
and small and infinitesimal," he said,
"is the knowledge behind such a
view."
lie added that the people of the
North have no more use for thc negro
at close quarters than he had. Ile
cited instances of assaults by negroes
on white women and declared that the
more the Northern people lind out
about the negro thc less use they have
for him. Thc ballot of the negro, he
maintained, was a menace to good
government and the people of the
North are coining to realize t hat thc
.enfranchisement of him bordered on
ii crime.
Reverting to the president's utte.r
?ances that he was unwilling to shut
.the door of hope and opportunity in
?thc case of a worthy and competent
.colored man, Mr. Tillman said at first
'blush there is not a man alive who
would not agree, with that sentiment,
but he inquired if it ever occurred to
-any one that in opening that door of
hope it might not be to shut it in the
face of the white man. The door o?
hope in South Carolina, he said, at
?one Unie lind been closed by bayonets
to the whites for eight years while
rapine, murder and misgovernment
ran riot with an abomination in the
sight of man.
He declared that he did not hate
thc negro and that all negroes are
not bad. Only a small percentage are
bad and these, he said,arc leading the
rest and being patted on the hack by
politicians. He regarded it as his
duty, he said, to his State to stand
forever opposed to any idea of politi
cal or social equality on the part ot
the negro with the whiles. Continu
ing, he referred to the adoption of Hie
I8tii amendment to the constitution.
When you remorselessly stand hy that,
said he, "and say it is sacred, you
force us to face the alternative ol' a
conllict of races."
The purpose of those who endorse
the president's door of hope policy, he
declared, is that in time South Caro
Una should become a State of ?nula
toes, and in this even he predicted
there would be more bloodshed than
was ever shed before. ''I lieg you, foi
Cod's sake," facing thc Republican
side, "not, to reproduce an acute stage
of hatred which will bring the two
races together with tho resolve of thc
whites to die lu order to retain their
supremacy."
Mr. Tillman said his newspaper
friends always took great pains to
quote anything he had said that was
hot," leaving out everything that
was rational, decent and sane in their
pursuit of sensations, and in this re
spect a great wrong had been done
him. "A lie," he said, "never had
any particular truth," and he would
not attempt to make even a start to
run down those that have been told
on him.
Mr. Tillman said he did not want
to see the African driven to the wall,
and he did not want to shut the door
of hope in his face, but he could not
consent to the dominance of that peo
ple over thc whites. He then poked
fun at Mr. Hanna and read the title
(?f the hill he recently introduced to
pension ex-sl?ves. "Oh, my God!"
said he, "did Mr. Hanna mean that
or is it a political dodge?" The effect
of the bill was, he declared, to give
opportunity to unscrupulous negroes
to bamboozle and deceive their people
hy securing subscriptions ostensibly to
further tho Interests of the bill. He
concluded by saying that "in propor
tion as you arouse false hope in the
minds of these" people you are only
sowing the wind which will Hame up
into a whirlwind later on."
Mr. Tillman spoke for three hours.
He was followed by Mr. Carmack of
Tennessee, who said the action of the
president in the Indianola case was
not in accordance with reason, justice
or Lue constitution.
A DEPLORABLE AFFAIR.
A School Teacher Shoots Ooo of Iii H
liarger l*upilH.
A very deplorable affair took place
at Inman in S partan burg County the
Urst of last week, in which Mr. Reu
ben B: Pitts, the principal ol the In
man' school, shot and dangerously
wounded one. of his larger pupils by
the name of Ed. Foster, lt seems
that on Monday Pitts had ordered
Foster to stay in after .school was dis
missed, but Foster did not regard the
teacher's words. Tuesday afternoon
the request was repeated, and along
with Foster three other of the oldest
pupils were kept in. Thc teacher
j and Foster went into thu room adjoin
ing, where thc three remaining pupils
sat, and after closing the door Mr.
Pitts stated to Poster that he would
have to whip him. Foster said noth
ing. Pitts secured a switch and be
gan to strike the student, who was!
larger and heavier in weight than lie.
About this time the door was shoved
open and the three male pupils sur
rounded thc teacher. Pitts changed
his hickory from his right hand to thc
left, reached with his right hand into
his hip pocket and produced a.,,32
calibre pistol. As he brough thc tire
arrh in front Foster struck forward
with Iiis hand, hitting the pistol and
causing the weapon and the arm of
thc teacher to fall, and the gun was
discharged. The bullet entered Fos
ter's stomach. The wounded boy was
carried to the. home of Mrs. R. F.
Brown, near the school house, where
an operation was performed. Pitts
surrendered to the sherill and is now
in jail. Foster is laying at thc point
of death and is not expected to re
cover.
FOSTEIt IS DEAD.
Foster died on Friday morning. Be
fore dieing lie made the following
statement.
The anlc-mdrtcra statement of Fos
ter was read as follows:
State of South Carolina, Spartanburg
County.
Personally came E. L. Foster before
me and made oath that he is a resi
dent of this county, and, being badly
wounded by a pistol in the hands of
one Reuben Pitts on Feb. 24, 11)03,
and realizing that his wound is con
sidered dangerous and might prove fa;
tal makes Lin's his an tc-mortem decla
ration: First, that Reuben Fitts is
principal of Inman graded school and
that oh the afternoon of February
24, Ilion, the said Reuben Pitts caused
mc to stay in after school was dis
missed: after words he called mc up
to him and said he was going to
whip me. Ile sent three other
boys out of the room, lie asked
me why I did not stay in on the day
before. 1 said 1 did not miss but one
word and would not take a whipping.
Ile then ordered me to get up and said
he was going to whip me: brought two
switches from rostrum and laid one on
bench; he gave mc two licks 1 then
grabbed the switch and told him 1 was
not going to take it. lie changed
switch from right to left hand and put
his hand on hip pocket and (liewa
pistol threw it up in my fae;.'. I then
grabbed pistol and tried to knock it
off; he then (ired it. 11 did not weaken
me at lirst. I did not know that 1 was
shot and I caught him hy the hair he
again threw pistol up. I then began to
get weak and fell hack on the rostrum.
Fred Rallonger, Jessie Pallengcr and
Raymond Wolfe who were also kept
In, who were in an adjoining room,
come in when the pistol H red. Pitts
saidas I fell down "Just as 1 expected,
you are all on inc." He jumped up
two or three limes saying he was aw
fully sorry about it. About that time
.lessie Pallengcr had my clothes un
fastened. Pitts came up and wanted
to know where I was shot, ile then
left the room saying he was going to
give up. There was no one in thc
struggle with Pitts but myself.
(Signed) "Ed. Foster."
Sworn to before me this February
24th. 1003. G. ii. Camp, V. P.
OppOHKtl by FanatlcH.
The Washington correspondent of
the Richmond Times-Dispatch tells
lils paper that "tremendous opposi
! tiori is developing to tho proposition
to place a statue of General Pee In
Statuary Hall. Republican members
of congress, from States of thc north
and west are hoing overwhelmed with
protests. These come from Grand
: Army of the Uepubllc organizations
and from individual.-. A member told
me he had no idea that sentiment
against the proposition was so strong.
Ohio, Indiana, illinois, Kansas, Iowa
and one or two of thc New England
States seem most strongly opposed.
Sentiment against it is not nearly so
strong in New England as would bc
i supposed. New York is paying no
attention to the matter, and but Tew
protests have come up from Pennsyl
vania."
THE OTHER SIDE.
Tillman Gives His Version ol the
Terrible Tragedy.
HIS STATEMENT GIVEN IN FULL.
The Other Testimony Oft'orcd In Ite
huttnl to that Offered, by tho
State in Opposition to
Allowine Bail.
Last week we published the testi
mony offered by the State before
Chief Justice Pope in opposing the
application of James H. Tillman for
bail. Below we publish Tillman's
statement in full and other testimony
offered by him in rebuttal. Read it
and draw your own conclusions:
Jumes II. Tillman being duly sworn
says:
That in addition to thc atlldavit
heretofore made by him, he submits
thc following:
That ho has read the atlldavits of
Joseph R. Allen and Policeman Ro
land, and says iu reply thereto, that
he did walk towards the city hall, all
the while, at least for some distance,
obliquing to the left, with his pistol
down to his side. That as well as he
recollects, he bowed to a man on the
platform of a street car, whom he took
to bc either the conductor or motor
man.
I am under the impression that I
walked across .the street car track at
thc end of a car which was standing
on it. Directly after I crossed the
track on Main street, Policeman Bo
land came up to me. I still had my
pistol down at my side. I do not re
collect all that was said by Mr. Boland
or hy me, hut I think his statement as
to what occurred is near about right.
I recollect Policeman Boland asking
for my pistol, but did not wish to give
it up until he assured me that I should
be protected, as 1 staled to him, 1 did
not wish to he butchered up.
I think 1 was about midway, oppo
site the city hall, when this occurred.
1 then turned togo with Policeman
Boland to the station house, and after
turning the city hall corner, going
down Gervais street, my brother-in
.aw Judge Buchanan came rushing up
and asked what was the matter. 1 said
to the policeman that he was my
brother-in-law, and he then accompa
nied us to the police station.
The magazine of my pistol had been
broken for some time, and as I was de
sirous of having it repaired before re
turning home, Tasked Mr. Fred. Dom
inick on "Wednesday to take it to Mr.
W. P. Stieglitz's gun shop and have lt
fixed for me-being then engaged in
my otliclal duties at the State house,
and did not have Cline to go to the
gunsmith's. He said nothing to me
about the magazine until the next
morning, when he asked me for the
pistol, saying he had to take It to
Stieglitz to put the magazine in. I do
not know at what, time he took the
pistol to Stieglitz nor when he brought
it to my room afc the State house. He
told me Some time during the morn
ing that he had left the pistol in my
room.
I do not own a Prince Albert frock
coat, nor have I worn one since my
arrival in the City of Columbia. 1
neither had on a Prince Albert coat on
Tuesday, Jan. Kl, ???3j nor did I have
a pistol in my hip pocket, nor did 1
stop on Main street near the steel
bunding and "look up and down the
street as if expecting some one to
pass." I was not looking for any one
in whom 1 was interested to pass me.
The aillant P. W. Smith I am inform
ed is a hoy 12 years old, and Yedder
Zimmerman about thc same age.
I do not recall meeting Mr.'S. T. D.
Lancaster on the 14th day of January,
1903; but if he did see me, lie could not
have seen a pistol ''sticking out from
the (my) rear coat pocket," as 1 did
not have a pistol with me-thc only
pistol I had in Columbia hoing broken
as above stated.
That Mr. S. J. Young may bc correct
when he states he saw me "about 12
feet from the inside of the pavement",
and 1 may have had my pistol eleva
ted. 1 know I did not haye it pointed
at N. G. Gonzales, hut I was looking
at him, momentarily expecting him to
tire upon mc, and when he diu not do
so 1 lowered it to my side.
In reference to the statement of Ar
ledge Ly les who, I have been informed
is a boy about 12 or M years of age, 1
do know that after having li red and
the lire not being returned, 1 lowered
my pistol, as hy that time Senator
Tal bi rd got between me and Mr. Gon
zales. I do not remember saying: " You
will let me alone now." 1 do know
that 1 did go as Arledge Lyles says
across the street, obliquing, looking in
the direction where thc clilllciilly oc
curred and at Mr. (??nzales, until I
got to the street car track and crossed
it, and it was about this time that
Policeman Boland came up.
I do not know Mr. C. M. Lide, who
slates he was walking behind Mr. Gon
zales and in the same direction Mr.
Lido states: "That he (referring to
inc) maintained that position with his
hands in In's overcoat pockets until
just before he had tired the shot herc
inaftcrwards described." Ile also
slates: "When just as he (Gonzales)
was going around the three, on the in
side of the pavcment,Tillman being on
the outside of the three, and near the
outer edge of the pavement and hav
ing both his hands In his overcoat
pockets, thc latter (that is Tillman)
suddenly Hied his pistol." My over
coat has no front side pockets, and it
was therefore a physical impossibility
for me to have my hands in my over
coat pockets-the only pockets in my
said overcoat being in each tall of the
rear of said coat, and 1 had a pair ol'
gloves in my left hand, both hands be
ing hy my side. This statement. I beg
lo verily hy the coat which is in thc
possession of thc sherill'.
As to thc atlldavits of Abram Brown
(a colored man) and of August Schied
eman, thc same are not true in so far
as they conflict with thc statement
now made and heretofore made, and
which is corroborated by the affidavits
of Melton C. L?rick, and W. IL Halli
and that of Richard ll. Ilolsonbacke.
1 have only to say in reference to the
atilda vit of Mrs. Minina C. Melton that
the lady is mistaken In thc position in
which she places me on thc sidewalk.
I know not hing, of course, neit her had
I any knowledge up to that, lime, and
none now, save as is stated In Mrs.
Melton's affidavit and those of some
others, I hat it was Mr. Gonzalo's hab
it to walk with his hands in his pock
ets. When ho obliqued across, coming
towards me, I again repeat he glared
at me, pushing his entire right hand
in Iiis overcoat pocket, and giving mc
every indication and grounds lo be
lieve, as I nave heretofore stated, that
he intended to assault me with a pis
tol. To show that Mrs. Melton is mis
taken when she says: "lie (Gonzales)
did not look in the direction of Mr.
Tillman; he was looking directly at
the opening between thc inside gentle
man (Senator Brown) and the tnois
ier station, to willoh he was walking,
and through which I had slowed up
to let him pass " attention is called to
the allldavit of Mr. Robert Lathan,
wherein he states that Mr. Gonzales
told him that he had glanced at ray
face.
1 deny in toto the statement which
Mr. Robert Lathan says Mr. Gonzales
made to him in reference to how the
difficulty occurred. Mr. Gonzales never
said to me what Mr. Lathan says he
told him. If he did so state, I did not
hear him, and no allldavit has beon
submitted by any of the bystanders
that they heard him say it.
Deponent avers that lie has no re
collection of any acquaintance with
O. D. Black, who has made an alllda
vit herein, aud denies that he had any
conversation at the time referred to
on the railroad train, or in November
last at the Albion Hotel in Augusta,
Ga.
I do recollect having ? conversation
with Mr. 35. J. Watson, a reporter for
Thc State, but I deny the truth of the
convers?t ion as stated in his allldavit.
As early as 1800 thc sala N. G. Gon
zales commenced making misstate
ments in reference to mc in the public
prints of this State, and publicly
avowed and published the fact that lie
was instrumental in causing my appli
cation for membership in the South
Carolina club to be refused, referring
to me tis cowardly enough to slander
him anonymously, which was Utterly
untrue. Again in the year 1893, when
this deponent sent from Washington,
D. C. eertu'.n dispatches to the Colum
bia Evening Journal, the truth of
which he did not guarantee,but stated
them as rumor, Mr. Gonzales had him
self quoted in The State of April, 1803,
assaying that the statement was a
falsehood without a shadow of excuse,
and also referred to it in the editorial
columns of the said newspaper of
which he was the editor, on the 10th
day of April, 1803.
That the hatred of Mr. Gonzales to
wards deponent was personal. That
under the pretext of doing public good
he hardly attempted to cover his mal
ice and vindictiveness towards me.
From thc time of my entry into pub
lic life there has been an incessant,
coarse, brutal, and unreasoning ar
raignment of your deponent. Even so
late as July 31, 1002, there appeared in
The State an editorial of abuse, which
although headed "Partly Personal
Partly Public," was indeed albperson
al. An arraignment of your deponent
is made, beginning with the year 1800,
down through the service in the army,
and up to said date, Ulled with brutal
insinuations, coarse perversion of facts,
and false insinuations of thc .actings
and doings of your deponent. That m
the issue of The State of April 1,1002,
four colums of vituperation and abuse
were devoted to your deponent; on
I August 2, three columns on the edito
I rial page, of vi ll i Heat ion and abuse: on
August 8, one column: and almost
dally editorial comment from said
date up to and including August 20,
1002, and even after said time. In The
State's survey, editorial columns, Au
gust 20, 1002, he refers to your deno
nent as "reeling off miles of lies" and
"confessing to the. embezzlement of
money entrusted td him for thc erec
tion of monument to the Confeder
ate dead,'' And on August 20,-1902;
after the result of the elections had
been declared it is stated that your
deponent was not a gamecock, and
never "tit" in the pit, "and if he was
found dead there, -his remains must
have been thrown in after his demise
from excessive weeping." In the same
issue, referring to an occurrence at
Gaffney', S. C., he refers to your depo
nent as a braggart, and a spotted can
didate, and eulogizes E. E. DeCamp,
who had brought on the trouble, as
"one of thc first printers to stick type
for The State. Ile will permit us to
say t hat he has handsomely maintain
ed thc traditions of the paper."
That prior to deponent's candidacy
to thc olHce of governor, to wit: In the
issue of The State of June 2,1001, he
wrote a hitter,(?sarcastic editorial of
one and a half columns of your depo
nent, under the heading "We Plead
for a Sporting Statesman."
After all t his.dcponcnt submits that
he was justilled in believing, from t he
writings of the said N. G. Gonzales,
from the threats communicated to
him, and from his actions when they
met. that the said N. G. Gonzales in
tended to make an attack upon him,
and Iiis every movement os seen by
deponent so indicated, and would have
been so interpreted by any one possess
ed of ordinary firmness and reason,amt
deponent again reiterates that when
he left the State house to go to his
hotel, he did not know that he would
meet the said N. G. Gonzales. That
when deponent first saw him he was
glaring at him and continued to do so
until he, ('ronzales, was almost up to
him. That the said Gonzales then
obliqued across the pavement in the
direction of deponent. That when he
obliqued was the time when deponent
saw him thrust the thumb of his right
hand Into his overcoat pocket, and the
pocket was pushed backward. Thal
tlie said Gonzales glared viciously at
deponent at the time he did this, and
was cutting across, coining towards
him. That deponent ti rm ly believed
that the said N. G. Gonzales was
about to draw a pistol and lire upon
him. That lils manner, appearance,
and motions, were such as to justify
such a belief by deponent or by any
person of ordinary reason and firmness';
who had been slandered, villitied,
abused, and threatened, as deponent
had been. That deponent tired believ
ing his life was in danger, to save him
self. That he regrets the necessity of
being forced so to do, but fired upon
reasonable apprehension that his life
was about to be taken, or that he was
about to receive serious bodily harm,
and still so believes.
Deponent further says in reference
to seeing Mr. Gonzales near a commit
tee room in thc State house at thc
time mentioned in thc affidavits ol
Robert Lat han and E. J. Watson, it is
not true that deponent then saw Mr,
Gonzales, although he may have been
in the position that these gentlemen
say lie was.
Deponent further says that he ha?
ho recollect ion of seeing Mr. Gonzales
eil her In t he lobby of the State house
or in the senate chamber, as lt appears
from the affidavits of other parties he
may have been.
Personally appears John G. Rich
ards, Jr., who being duly sworn
deposes and says: That he ls a mem
ber of thc House from Kershaw; that
he was In conversation with Governor
Tillman and others on thc evening ol
January 12th last in tho cltyofColum
bia, and there was nothing said bj
Governor Tillman that he can now re
call with reference to Mr. Gonzales
blithe states confidently that Gover
nor Tillman did not on that occasioi
or other that he can now recall maki
any threat of any kind against tah
Gonzales. J. G. Richards, Jr.
Personally appears Preston B. Calli
son, who, being duly sworn, depose!
and says: That he ls a member of tili
house from Greenwood county; that ht
recalls the conversation alluded ?o bj
Hon. John G. Richards, Jr., and here
by con linns thc statement of Mr
James II. Tillman.
Richards in every respect.
P. I
B?jp^-riie personally appears Dr. D. i
S.-P.ob?jAvho, being duly swcrn, says:
Tli?XKq? does not know Capt. J. A. <
WhUlpV and can give no opinion as Xo ?
bis 'mental condition; that in the atli- i
daviV?igned by him on the loth day
of Kdbruary, 1903, before William El
liotts Jr., notary public, he gave his
opini?n as to the effect of paralysis,
butipf course there-are many excep
tloria.to the rule, and it does not apply
in ?ttv cases; that nothing but a pcr
sonrn . examination-of one so alljlcted,
and'knowledge of his condition before
tlie-itrcke.of paralyisis, cou id enable
bini or any other physician to say
what tile elfect of such a stroke would
be on his memory or otherwise; that
in ?pd affidavit the word "apt" H used
whereas tho word "may" ls what d?
ponent meant to say. D. S. Pope.
Personally appeared Joseph P. Allen,
whcl, being duly sworn, says: I aih
city j auditor, and on the day Mr. N.
G. Ganzales was shot I was standing
at my desk facing east, looking direct
ly atiross Main street. In front of my
deslvand lu front of me was a copper
wlre'scrcen.the spaces-Inches, and tho
glass* of the window. Consequently I
saw Mr. Gonzales through the wire
screen and the glass of the windpw. 1
w?bV'ubout 110 feet from him, and he
was'about 80 feet from the door of thc
strebt railway transfer olllee. 1 did not
see the shooting and did not sec what
transpired immediately prior thereto.
Jos. Ri Allen.
Personally appeared bef?se me W.
H. Hall, who being duly sworn, says:
That he is a resident of the city of
Camden, S. C., and was in thc city of
Columbia on the loth day of January,
1003> That at the time of the shoot
ing bf "N. G. Gonzales he was standing
on the corner of Alain and Gervais
streets, and has read the affidavit of
Ii. H. iloisonbackc as to how the diffi
culty arose and he corroborates the
same is every particular. That dur
ing the evening of the 15th of January,
10u3, after the unfdrtuatc occurrence,
he, with the said R. II. Holsonbacke,
went to th? county jail and there saw
Lieutenant Governor James Hi Till
man, and told him that he had seen
the difliculty, and narrated to him
wiiat the said Holsonbacke stated hi
bis al?ida.vlt. W. H. Hall.
Before me personally appeared "?LC.
L?rick, who being duly sworn says:
That the day of thc difliculty between
Gov. Tillman and ?f. G. Gonzales he
was-standing on Main street of the
city of Co umbi a and saw the same
and was an eyewitness thereto; that
he has read the affidavits of Gov. Jas.
Hi Tillman stating how the difliculty
occurred and that his recollection coin
cides and agrees with that statement
in every particular, as it also docs willi
the statement of R. H. Iloisonbackc;
that ho recalls particularly thc atti
tude of N.G. Gonzales on that occasion
and fully expected to see him open
fire, upon Gov. Tillman,'as his every
movement and every appearance so
indicated, and from his actions at the
tlt?rt?g {relieved and believes now that
the said' GK' -Gonzales was armed
and-V/aV-intendlng to shoot Gov. Till
v,'*?s"t-lvre was- every..Indication
tha.t he (Gonzales) was about to draw
a p;istoi.' Mi C. L?rick.
Personally appeared before me Philip
Epstin who being duly sworn, says:
That he was in the hall of the house
of representatives on the day of the
election of speaker-thinks it was
Tuesday, January 13, 1?I03. That
James II. Tillman came into the hal.,
went upon the speaker's stand and
said a few words to the speaker. That
he tlier. came down from the stand on
the northeast side and wentout of the
hall. That "S.O. Gonzales was stand
ing a few feet from the reporters'
tables facing to thc southwest, his
back being to the passage hy which
Tillman must, pass to reach the door.
That Gonzales turned around as Till
man was passing and stared at Till
man with a sneering and bantering
smile of derision upon his face, and in
a taunting manner. That Tillman
apparently took no notice of Gonzales
or his bantering manner but passed on
by him willi a sad and rather sub
dued expression on lils face.
Phillip Epstin.
Personally appeared John E. Flana
gan, who being duly sworn, says: 1 got
olT the street car which was going ti
the river in front of the transfer sta
tion corner. I got off about opposite
thc southern corner of the trunsfei
station and the City Hall and about
In the middle of the street. My at
tention was attracted by a report
which I at first thought was a torpedo
I looked and saw Mrs. Emma Gi Mel
ton; she was very much excited, wai
moving her head and body in every di
rection, and jumping up and down-J
never seen anyone appear so excite*
in my life. Just as I looked and sav
her, 1 saw Mr. Gonzales; he took a ste]
or two, and seemed to lean against Hu
building, then he recovered himself
and he turned and walked back to
wards his olllee. Mr. James Sims am
Mr. A. G. LaMotte joined him wliei
he got at or near thc building occn
pied hy Mr. Way; each of them seem
lugly had him by the arms,and walkei
with him down to his ollice.
John E. '?'lanigan.
Personally appeared before inc Jame
\ T. Douglass, who being duly sworn
says: That he is State senator fron
Union county, and was in his scat ii
Hie senate chamber ii day or two be
fore the difficulty between James ll
Tillman and N. G Gonzales: that de
, ponent is not certain of thc day c
thc month, but feels confident it wa
Wed., thc 14th day o? January, lill):
: That Lieut. Gov. Tillman was presk
ing when N. G. Gonzales entered th
j senate chamber, t ook his stand ahou
. where the seats com mc nee on thc mai
i entrance of the senate chamber, an
for fully live minutes stood there loo!
j ing over the senate chamber. Tho
i his action was so strange, unusual ari
peculiar that he deponent , noticed i
j that he Inferred this from Mr. Goi
; zalcs' manner and actions.
, .lames T. Douglass.
, Personally appears Tillman Bund
who being duly sworn, deposes an
says: That he was told by Gov. Til
manto take a certain pistol, a Colt
. 38 calibre weapon, from his room an
carry or return to its supposed ow m
! at another hotel. After alleinptk
to do so he had to return the won poi
. being unable to lind any owner for tl
[ same, and h I nisei f carried the san
. down to thc president's room and le
- lt there, where it was when Gov. Tl!
. man began to remove his'effects. Tlii
he did not tell Gov. Tillman he hr
! left lt In the president's room. Th!
i he did not know who was the owner
. the weapon, and does not now know
? Tillman Bunch.
Personally appeared before me B.
. Lewis, who being duly sworn, sai
j That he has been acquainted wfl
? Richard H. Holsonbaek for a numb
? of years and that he bears a reputatk
} of being a truthful, upright and re
. able man. B. p. Lewis.
Personally appeared before me )
H. Tlmmerinan, who being du
?worn saya: That he has known
Richard H. Hoisonbacke for a number
if years; that he had worked for him
ana that he had always done Iiis work
faithfully; that he bears the name of
paying ids debts and rents on lands
leased for cultivation.
W. II. Timmerman.
Personally appeared before me P. P>.
Mayson, who being duly swori , says:
That he hud known R. II. Hoison
backe for a number of years and that
his general reputation for truthful
ness and veracity is. good; that he is
known to pay his debts, and that de
ponent would believe him on oath.
P. li. Mayson.
Personally appeared before me (de
ponents stated below) ard bein? duly
sworn said that they know Richard
II; Holsonbacke's general reputation
for truth and veracity and that his
reputation is good and that they would
believe him on oath:
A. P. Lott, C. A. Austin, J. W,
Hester, J. P. Odom, Samuel Hyatt,
Jas. G. Mobley, J. Goldberg, Tlios.
Holmes, J. P. Fulraan, W. II. nail,
W. E. La Grove, A. C. Mayer. J. F.
Murrel, A. E. Carpenter, M. G. Car
penter, J. S. Bush, Malcolm Jackson,
J. W. Hardy, Willie Cogburn, Jas.
Temples, E. L. Sawyer, C. W. Wil
liams, G. W. Williams, P. A. John
son, J. A. Lott, W. ll. Lott, J. E.
Lott, J. S. Culbrcath, lt. M. Powell,
J. C. Workman, M. O. Norris, Hon.
J. G. Edmunds, W, T. Walton, J. N.
Carpenter, N. II. Jackson,M. H. Cuur
scy, W. II. Carpenter, lt. II. Carpen
ter, lt. O. Car pouter, C. B. Carpen
ter.
A similar certlticate as to Holson
backe's character was signed hy citi
zens of Aiken county, as followh:
M. C. Whitlock, John lt. Edison,
H. A. Turner, J. M. Paul, P. L. Bn>n
don, J. G. Hoard, J. T. Mayer, II. W.
Hester, Samuel Hyatt, J. G. Mobley,
J. B. Odam, P. L. lirotfdon, J. G.
Hand, J. T. Mayer, J. Goldberg, B.
Flinn, W. L. La Grove.
Before me personally appeared B.
R. Tillman, who being duly sworn
says: That he is a resident of the
county of Edgc?ield, South Carolina;
that he knows the reputation and
character or Capt. J. A. White of the
town nf Erlgetteld in said county and
State; that his reputation for truth
and veracity is high, and he (d?pon
ent) would believe any statement he
made. B. R. Tillman.
Personally appeared before me (de
ponents stated below) and being duly
sworn, says: That they are well ac
quainted with J. A. White and know
his general reputation for truth and
veracity and honesty and fair dealing
to be excellent, and that'they would
believe him on oath. That Captain
White is in full possession pf his men
tal faculties and consequently kuowg
what lie says and does."
W. G. Ouzts, deputy sheriff. P. B.
Mayson, C. W. Odom, J. G. Faulkner,
M. L. Brunson, magistrate; ?i. G.
Evans, J. T. Patterson, M. D.; C. M.
Williams, county treasurer; W. A.
Bird, county superintendent of educa
tion; W. ll. Timmerman.
Personally appeared before me ?V.
IL Timmerman, who being duly sworn,
oays: That he has known J. A.
White for a number of years and that
his reputation and character have
always been excellent for truth.
W. H. Timmerman.
Personally appeared before me R.
H. Ilolsonback, who being duly sworn
says: That bc did make a statement
that he had something else in view
when he came to columbia besides a
position as doorkeeper to the senate
and that the business to which he re
ferred was to secure a position as spe
cial constable on the dispensary force:
that he was also trying to get a posi
tion as doorkeeper to the house of
representatives; that he attaches to
this affidavit letters from Hon. L. J.
Williams and Maj. G. W. Croft, which
letters have reference to the above
statement.
his
Richard H. (x) nolsonbacke,
mark.
Olllce State Board of Directors of thc
South Carolina Dispensary.
Columbia, S. C., Jan. ?, l!)0:i.
Mr. lt. ll. Hoisonbacke,
Johnson, S. C.
Dear Sir: 1 have again seen UH
governor in your behalf and heassurci
me that he will have the status ol
blind tigerism in Johnston investigat
ed and if he concludes it will be ad
vantagcous to appoint a resident coi.
stable he will try and help you,
Yours very truly,
L. J. Williams.
G. W. Croft & Son, Attorneys anc
Counsellors.
Aiken. S. C., Dec. 20, 11)02.
Mr. R. H. Hoisonbacke.
Johnston, S. C.
My Dear Sir: Your favor of Dec.
2;i received and hasten to reply and
to enclose a letter to Mr. M. L. Smith
recommending you, which you car
present to him when tiie legislature
opens, and 1 will also do what 1 cat
with him personally. I lind that ni)
court meets hereat Aiken on Januar}
12th, extra court session, and it maj
interfere with my getting dowr
promptly, so 1 give you a letter willer
you can show Mr. Smith yourself.
With best wishes for yourself billi
season, believe me,
Your friend,
G. W. Croft.
Tile statement made by Governoi
Tillman on the relation mentioned by
mc was looked upon by me as a mat
ter of pleasantry and wa? not consld
orcd by me at tiie time as a matter ol
threat at all. Thc allusion was madi
also to editorials in The State news
paper in which newspaper there liac
been an accusation against Governoi
Tillman of a rogue, etc. -
W. B. Gausc.
Want the I>lni>onsnry.
Thc governor lias received a request
from several members of the S tat?
legislature of New Hampshire asking
for full Information about the opera
tion of the South Carolina dispensar:
law, their purpose being to Introduci
a like measure In the Nev Humpshirt
general assembly. The governor wll
forward a copy of tho law and copia
of the olllclal reports of the operation!
of thc dispensary.
FERTILIZER TAG TAX
Is Greatly Increased This Year Over
Last Year.
The Columbia State says there bas
been a remarkable spurt in the re?
eelpts of "tag tax," or fertilizer tax.
Up to the 1st of March the receipts :
will be $22,000 more than for the
same period last year, or n gain of 50
per cent. Whether this stride.- will
keep up or not caunot be foretold.
There are three possible causes for
the heavy pu rebases of fertilizers. One
is that the farmers are making their
purchases earlier than usual because
money d'cs not appear to bo as tight
tliis year s is customary. Another is
that the acreage in crops requiring
fertilizers will be materially increased,
and another possible reasou ls that the
fertilizers w?ll be used more intensive'
ly or more thoroughly.
It may be that this rush of orders
will soon be over and that thc sales of
the entire year will aggregate little
more than in other years, but the
amount of tax received so far is ? rec-,
ord breaker and there are two months
yet before the sales of fertilizers for
tiie year will practically bc over.
A comparative table of the sales in
different years might be of interest at
this time. Thc receipts to date in
1903 are 501.991.55; same time last
year $40.030.55, and for the year be
fore 857,097.03. Following are the
totals for the several years slncq?thc.
inauguration of the "tag" tax systemVli,
Year. Amount.
1890-91.... $53,285.85
1892.?. 30,108.98
1893. .;.. 50,243.95
1894. . 43,423.88
1895./... 30,135.93
1890.Six..'_ 54,524.37
18117. 59,352.33
1898. 05,494.33
1S9?). 02,123.88
19U0. 75,214.34
1901 . 84,073.43
19?2. 81,744.94
All of the receipts from this fund
go to Clemson College-avowedly for
thc purpose of paying for the inspec
tion of the commercial fertilizers to 1
protect the farmers from being im
pused upon. Really less than $10,000
a year is spent upon the analysis of
commercial fertilizers. Clemson thus
gets for operating expenses from the
privilege tax more than thc co'i?iblned;.
appropriations to the South Carolina;
College, thc Citadel and th?i^ta?e i
Colored College. In addition tcV*thi8';
Clemson gets revenue from other
sources. There is $15,000 from the
Hatch fund; $3,000 from thc interest
on Mr. Clemson's bequest; $0,000 from
the land scrip fund, and about 350,000
from the "cadet fund," which, as
slided in tiie annual report of, the ,
legSaidtlvc-lnspectirrg ' cqinmlttepi^-is
exuended on board, laundry, etc*., for
thc cadets. Clemson has indeed - a
princely income, just how much can
not be told from the annual reports,
and is doing a superb work. Out of ;
the Income the permanent improve- i
ments are made. Last year nearly
$50,000 was paid out for new build
ings. Tiie question arises: "When
Clemson gets through putting up
buildings and adding to thc equip
ment, will there not be an annual res- :
idue from thc tag tax receipts.'-'
That question has worried the gen- ;
eral assembly for several years-but
was not touched upon at the session
just ended, although there wefe sev
eral bills to reduce thc tag tax from
25 cen Ls a ton to 15 cents, to raise it
to Ito cents, etc. Hut the proposition
which has ever attracted thc greatest
attention is to have Clemson divide
the privilege tax with Winthrop.
This has been opposed on the ground
that the State has no right to levy a
special tax and that this "inspection"
tax is but a subterfuge for a special
tax on a commodity. Should the in
come be diverted from the inspecting
agency of the government, then the
whole scheme might be declared un
constitutional and Clemson suffer a
serious loss. If Clemson continues to
develop and extend her magnificent
plant, it is probable that? ail of this
inspection tax may bu required for op
crating expenses and that there would
be no residue.
Judge Lyon, who attends to the fer
tilizer tax books in the State treasur
er's otlice, Stated Friday that there
is little or no chance for the fertilizer
!, companies to defraud the State gov
l eminent. The companies arc liable to
heavy penalty if they omit from thc
sacks of fertilizers the tags showing
the authority of the State govern
ment. Thc consumer may be defraud
ed, because every sack is not tested
and its contents analyzed, but the
payment of the tax cannot be escaped.
I When a fertilizer company makes a
requisition for tags, thc check ls sent
to thc State treasurer's otlice and
thence forwarded to the State chom
ist at Clemson. The latter sends the
plljcial tags to the company. The Vlr
. ginia-Caiolina Chemical Company
pays Hie greater part or the privilege
1 tax, although some members of the
J legislature are impressed with the
s fact that tiie people themselves pay
1 this tax and that if it were removed
tiie price, of fertilizers would not be
' reduced correspondingly. Friday
.ludjre Lyon received a check for $2,
1 500 from the Virginia-Carolina Chcm
' ?cal Company accompanying an order
; for tags.
? ---
Wiped Out. ttie Family.
Earl Wood, thc 17 year old son of a
prominent farmer seven miles west of
. Frankfort, Ind., Tuesday evening
, murdered lils father, shot and fatally
wounded his mother and sister and
then committed suicide. The mo
. tive for thc boy's bloody crime is not
, known. After the shooting the young
. man went to the home of a neighbor
j and said that robbers had entered his
f home and killed his father, mother
and sister and that be escaped after I
a running ba ttl o with thc desperadoes.
Ile apparently was greatly excited
and said he was organizing a posse to
j pursue his father's slayers. He stop
? ped at another house and told thc
t same, story. When he was questioned
- concerning the shooting he became
; confused and resented thc inqulsitlve
} ness of the man to whom he told thc
j story. He started away and dlsap
1 pcared behind a barn, when a shot
s was heard. An investigation dlscov
s ered the youthtul murdered dying
with a bullet through his breast.
CAUSE OF STAGGERS.
A Fatal Malady Now Prevalent
Among the Horses.
DISEASE OF NERVOUS SYSTEM.
Dr. Ncsom Says it is Always As
sociated With Mouldy Food,
Bad Water and Uncleanly
Surroundings.
Dr. Nesom, the State vetcrlnarium
at Clemson College, is receiving BO
many letters from various sections in
reference to staggers that he has [
found it impossible to anBwer them
all. The following letter^will be of
interest to many throughout the
State.
As it is quite out of the question
to give personal answers to all of thc
letters received from citizens of South
Carolina and Georgia regarding a
horse disease commonly referred to as
staggers, I take this method of say
ing to those concerned that more and
more cases appear every week, and :
just at a season when horses and
mules are so much in demand for farm
work it becomes a serious question.
The lasses in South Carolina from this
disease during the past year are esti
mated at about $10,000, abd it is
prevalent in Maryland, Virginia,
Njurth Carolina and Kansas. I baa
diagnosed the disease as cerebro-spl
nal mcningetis nearly a year ago, but
many of the diseases did not seem
typical of tibin idease. I have recent
ly forwarded to the bur eau of'animal
industry at Washington six of''the si
brains taken from bourses that had
died of this disease. A partial report ^
has been received and the disease
proves to be cerebro-spinal meningetis,
or leucoencephalitls.
This is a disease of the nervous sysl
tem, affecting chiefly the brain and
its covering membranes. Most of the
brains taken out recently have been
congejted, some blood serum around
the brain, and in either the right or
left half . of the upper portion of thc
brain (cerebrum) there has been found
a large area of degeneration. This
cannot be seen on thc surface, but if
the brain be cut open what appearer,
jfco be a large ulcer is found in the
substance.: of the.brain. This ls the
principal losion and is responsible for
most of the ill symptoms.
The symptoms are those of nearly
all the other forms of so-called "stag
gers," and death generally follows in
one or two daye If not very soon after
the disease is noticed. .The cause of
the disease is not well understood, but'
iayalways . associ?t
fdoq,. bad .water and u u'clean fe wr^?hd>ifr
hags.
Thc remedy is to''?*?oid the causes,
use only the best food, pure water ;
and keep the animals under the best
of conditions as to cleanliness. In ;
one case I saw where a number of
mules died, the only bad environment
I could lind was that a lot of rank
weeds had been mowed down'around
the barn and left there to decay dur
Ing a rainy spell of weather.
Medical treatment ls almost useless*]
as the losious of the brain have al
ready occurred when the symptoms
are noticed and cure is generally out
of thc question when so much of the
brain has become decayed. Cold
shower baths to head, doses of one
ounce of chloral hydrate, one ounce
aloes, or for ounces of whiskey, may
relieve the symptoms for a while.
When the disease appears clean, dis
infect and whitewash the barn, and
do not usc a stall where a horse has
died. If possible abandon lots and
barns for two or three months and
provide quarters elsewhere for all
horses kept on the place.
G. E. Nesom,
State Vetcrlnarium.
Things to Forget.
If you would increase your hap
piness and prolong your life forget
your neighbors faults. Forget the
slander you have heard. Forget the
temptation. Forget the faultfind
ing and give a little thought to
the cause which provoked it. For
get the peculiarities of your friends
and only remember the good points
which make you fond of them. For
get all personal quarrels or histories
you may have heard by accident, and
which' if repeated would seem a thous
and times worse than they are. Blot
out as far as possible all the disagree
ables of life; they will come, but they
will grow larger when you remember
them, and the constant thought of tho
acts of meanness are worse still,
malice, will only tend to make you
more familiar with them. Obliterate
everything disagreeable from yester
day, start out witli a clean sheet for
today, and write upon it for sweet
memory's sake only those things which
are lovely and lovable.
A Destructive.
At three o'clock Thursday morning
thc town of iJeak was aroused by thc
alarm of Ure at thc Southern railroad
depot. Forty-four bales of cotton were
on lire- The depot and nine store
houses and warehouses were burned to
thc ground. As all were wooden build
ings very little was saved. Mr. W.
H. Suber lost two stores and two
warehouses. Mr. S. T. Swygert,
stock of goods valued at $5,000; insur
ance, $2,000, and $500 on house. Mr.
II. W. White's store was occupied by
J. H. Bushard as postolllce and mer
ehantilc business, was destroyed. Tho
contents were partially saved. No in
surance.
Thomm? Jcfl'crson.
A letter has been received by Gov
ernor Hey ward from tho Thomas Jef
ferson association of the United States,
asking his cooperation and endorse
ment of a project to erect in thc city
of Washington a suitable memorial to
the man who wrote the Declaration
of Independence. The letter calls par
ticular attention that thore has never
been provided such a memorial in any
city of the United States. Thc asso
ciation wishes the endorsement of the
plan by the governors of all the States.
Capt. F. W. Wagoner of Charleston
ls the South Carolina member of the
board of governors of the association.