The Marlboro democrat. (Bennettsville, S.C.) 1882-1908, February 27, 1903, Image 1
'DO THOU LIBERTY GREAT. INSPIRE OUR SOULS AND MAKE OUR LIVES IN THY POSSESSION HAPPY, OB OUR DEATHS GLORIOUS IN THY CAUSE."
wm
BENNETTSVII?L?E, S. C., JFRIDAY, FEBRUARY 27, 1903.
NO. 16.
BAIL REFUSED
J. H, Ti lman by Chief Justice Pope
on the Evidence
SUBMITTED BY HIS ATTORNEYS
Some Scraps of Arciimont Atado by
tho Lawyers on Both"Sides. Tho
Ohler Justice- Makes a
Statement.
Ah half-past four o'clock on Thurs
day afternoon Chief Justice Pope re
fused the application for bail of James
II. Tillman, charged with the murder
ot N. G. Gonzales and now confined
in the Illchland county jail. The
hearing was resumed in the Supreme
(Joiirt room in Columbia, having been
adjourned Trom Newberry on the 12th
inst., at 10 o'clock and cont inued un
til nearly 5 with an intermission
from 1.35 until 2.40 p. m. The pros
ecution was represented by S li;itor
J. W. Thurmond, ex-Attorney Gener
al G. D. Bellinger and Judge Andrew
Crawford.
The defense was represented hy
Congressman-elect G. W. Croft of
Aiken and ex-Solicitor P. ?T. Nelson
of Columbia. Ex-Judge O. W. Bu
chanan, Messrs. C. L. Blease of New
berry and G. It. Uembert of Richland,
of counsel for the defense, were also
present but not actively participat
ing. During most of the day about
100 spectators were In thcroom, the
number at times inore'"dng. Mr. B.
R. Tillman, Jr., a ti?h of Senator
Tillman was a spectator.
At the opening Col. Cruft read a
waiver of his legal right to bo present
by thc defendant, Col. Tillman, who
did not tn person appear. Tue read
ing of the allldavlts con. urned -one
hour a nd a half, Mr. Crawford read
ing tbose of the prosecution and Mr.
Nelson those of the defense.
MU. NKLSON OMENS.
At 11.30 the argument was opened
by Mr. Nelson for the defense. Ile j
was followed hy Messrs. Crawford,
Thurmond and Bellinger for the
State. After the recess Mr. Croft
closed thc case for thc defense. .
Mr. Nelson clearly and rapidly dis
cussed the evidence, taking up atilda
s vtlyS seriatim and disposing of their
hearing from the point of view of the
" defense. He stressed the reply of the
.defense in thc large number of atllda
-%-vits sustaining the character of the
?ffffl?ht Holsonbacke against fie elfort
. ?of the State to impeach it. Reaching
the affidavit or the aillant A'in le, lie
Ej was interrupted by Justice Rope, who
;wit, as co' that affida
vit was not necessary. Ile then pro
ceeded to analyze the State's a tilda -
-vit, pointing out what he regarded
. their discrepancies and weaknesses
and arguing self-defense based on the
affidavits of the State. He then took
up the legal aspect of the application.
Mr. Nelson's case was a brief, concise
and lucid exposition of the case for
the detense, without especial chort at
oratorical effect.
von THE PROSECUTION.
Judge Crawford drew the court's
attention to the alleged threat: "1
have made him show the white feath
er several times already and if he
crosses my path I will make him do it
again." He argued forcibly that this
in connection with the previous con
duct of Mr. Gonzales constituted no
threat whatever. Mr. Gonzales had
never attacked Tillman, had never
drawn a weapon upon him, had never
made any Demonstration of violence
towards him-"hid never made him
show the white feather," and so had
given Mr. Tillman no cause to fear
bodily harm from him. Having never
"made him show the white feather"
thc language even if true incant noth
'""-UrgT'As Tillman's life and limb liad
been safe under the so-called "white
feather" performance of the pist,
why did Tillman kill Gonzales for
simply doing that which caused h'm
the humiliation of "showing the
white feathery" There had been no
personal encounter and the "white
feather" must have been only in a po
litical sense, the result of the editori
al attacks which ended last Septem
ber. Mr. Crawford then argued that
having assisted materially In defeat
ing Mr. Tillman for governor, Gon
zales had no motive to threaten Till
man as to try to take his life. Till
man was the vanquished; Gonzales
thc victor. Ile could understand why
Tillman should desire revenge and so
could understand his declaring, :ie
cordlng to the atilda vit of O. I).
Black: "My God, I am going to kill
him!" and the intimation contained
in his language to Hon. W. B. Ganse.
Tillman made threats; Gonzales made
none. Tillman wanted blood; Gon
zales did not. Tillman armed him
self for the purpose, and Gonzales did
not.
THE SOLICITOR.
Solicitor Thurmond followed in an
argument covering the law and facts.
No threat had been made by Mr. Gon
zales. What he had said, admitting
thc truth of the alleged threats for
the sake of argument, was no stronger
than criticisms. if such language
could be construed as threats then
every candidate, for example, that ap
peared on the hustings would have a
right to assume that his lifo was. in
peril. "Any one who has had experi
ence in the court house" knows how
easy it is to pie vail upon many people
to make ,illida vi ts as to character.
Mr. Thurmond eomprehensi vcly ar
gued the law of the case, citing with
eirtphatis the rule laid down in a
Texas case as to thc meaning or the
phrase "proof is evident" in the con
stitutional provision as to bail in cap
ital cases, lie maintained that ball
should not he granted merely because
the case mighu contain conflicting
affidavits, hut that if the court wore
convinced that the evidence of guilt
substantially preponderated so as to
make a reasonably convincing case
the ball should be refused. As for the
newspaper attacks, public men must
expect, their records to bc attacked
and exploited by the press. These
atti.cks had been made long before
and Mr. Tillman had submitted to
them.
Mit. lt IC L I.. INO Ell 81'BAKB.
Mr. Bellinger made the closing ar
gument for the State. It was an
easy matter to obtain affidavits to
sustain a man's character. If per
chance that man had a local reputa
tion as a "bad man," in thc western
sense, as a dangerous man, lt was not
difficult to find those who, desirous of
not offending him, would sign testi
monials in his favor; but to tell the
plain truth about him required moral
and physical courage. Hence the in
ference was fair that in a case like
tbls the a nhl a vi ts attacking a man's
reputation for veracity came from sub
stantial men representative of thc
best classes in tho community. Re
ferring to the expression," "made to
say," applied to thc affidavit of Mrs.
Melton, Mr. . Bellinger observed that
the affidavit of Holsonbaeko was
signed "Richard Holsonbacke, his
mark.'' Nevertheless, it wascouched
willi an elegance of diction and accu
racy of rhetoric surprising to say the
least in a man unable to write his
name. In striking contrast was the
! allldavit of Mrs. Melton, clearly stat
ing the facts sbe knew in her own
handwritings, submitted to thc
State's attorneys at their request.
Mr. Bellinger summed up the testi
mony of tlie State's affidavits, forcibly
presenting it. "If the dying declara
tion of N. G. Gonzales, the statement
or Senator Talbird and the allldavit
of Mrs. Melton be true, Mien it was a
deliberate, schemed and premeditated
assassination.
COI.. CROFT CLOSES.
Cul. Croft made first a strong argu
ment on the law of bail. The rule ls
not, be s ild, as tho State would have
it, that )mil should be refused in cases
where a verdict of guilty is probable
that will not be.set aside-this with
out conceding at all that this case is
or that character. Where a doubt
may be entertained by the court Its
duly is mandatory. ?he court is nol
tu determine guilt or Innocence ii:
this proceeding. The credibility ol
witnesses Is not to be passed upon.
The presumption ot innocence tbi
law gives to thc defendant and bili
true mle is that if testimony is sub
raiued that presents a defense am
allows ul the. admission of a doub
of guilt the court must grant bail.
Mr. Croft then referred to thc news
paper and personal attacks ntl Mr
Tillman's public and private cbarac
ter, beginning, be said, as far back a
181)0. They had no parallel for unie
laming vindictiveness in South Car.)
lina. Mr. Tillman's good name bai
been torn to tatters and besmeared
liven In bis family life, in thc sacre
marriage tie he bad been attacke
and only bis life bad been left. Whit
words did not justify the taking u
human life -the defendant bad tb
right to infer from the unceasing per
sedition of Mr. Gonzales the bent o
bis mind towards him, and to belicv
that Mr. Gonzales intended to tak
Ids life as he bad taken hisgoud name
Mr. Gonzales' honesty of couvictio
bc did not impugn, but bis hatred c
Tillman became an absorbing passior
Ile was relentless towards enemic
and it was not in bis nature to brou
opposition.
Gol; Croft strongly argued the test
indny of Senator Talbird that he 01
eil pied the outside position on tbesld
position on the sidewalk with Tillma
between him and Brown, accentua
ing thc point that, such being tl:
positions, Mr. Gonzalo's turn toward
the Inside was a direct approach ti
wards Tillman.
THE DECISION.
As Col. Croft was concluding Chic
Justice l'ope requested bim to expiai
bbc course of thc ball as shown by tl
autopsy, and the testimony of D
Knowlton was read.
Then while the spectators listone
with breathless attention the cbli
justice, announced bis decision. "Tbei
are always two sides to a homicide
be said, "and even with thc mat
that have taken place in this State i
late years, there is in most of tbei
some provocation-that is, there is
defendant's side to it. It seems fro
the testimony that the defendant h;
been tho object of newspapers attacl
for ll years perhaps without a paral 1
I in this State. The liberty of ti
! press dues not permit the license
I the press. Dr. Franklin said tl
! liberty of thc press would often I
followed by thc liberty of the eudgi
In this case no cudgel, though, w
used, hub a deadly weapon. One cou
hardly believe that a man could be
thc long continued ordeal of the abu
that the defendant underwent wit
Out having malice in bis heart. T
rule was long ago adopted in tl
cou rb nob td give the reasoning lea
ing to our conclusions in bail a
plications. The law ls that thc fakii
of human life with malice premed!;
ed constitutes murder. Painful as
is, under my oath of office, so rece ni
fresh on my lips, I must do my du
and decline the application."
Thc following is the order deny!
the application:
St ?tc of South Carolina County
Richland.
The State vs. .Jas. ll. Tillman.
This was au application for ut
and after bearing the a Hid ay i ls bi
of thc State and tho petitioner a
after argument pro and con it
ordered that ball is hereby refus
however without prejudice to I
petitioner lo apply to some obi
judge if he should ba so advised.
Y. J. I'ope, Chief Justice
Million Dollar Hitchins !>ost.
J. R. Posten of Bath, N. Y., bas
front ot" bis bouse what lie calls a r
lion dollar bitching post. It i
while oak post, and was removed fi
a Held near Can isleo. Steuben com
N. Y., and is believed to be tile 1
of thousands ol posts that were ri ri
for a distance of inore than one h
died miles on thc route of thc ?1
York & Eric railroad when il was
lng constructed tb rough Susti
banna, Caiiisteo and Allegheny val
sixty-two years ago. Lt was Inten
to elevate Hie rails tor thc rail rout
these posts instead of laying theil
a solid roadbed. This plan of i
road building was abandoned belo
rail was put down. The money sj
in the useless work amounted to u
than one million dollars arid drove
Hrle into Its first bankruptcy i
owner of this relic of thc old pile ri
bed of the ?ric obtained it last
while visiting relatives In the vlei
of where lb stood, a lone moimmcii
thc costly folly that placed it tl
two generations ago.
{
THE TESTIMONY
Presented by the State in the Case
ot J. H. Tillman
BEFORE CHIEF JUSTICE POPE,
Ami Upon .Which Ho Refused to
Allow tlio Defendant to lie
Released from Jail by
Glvlnf- Bail.
Last week we published the entire
testimony presented by J, IL Tillman
in his application for bail. Below we
present about one-half of the testi
mony presented by-thc State iu oppo
sition to tho granting of bail to .1. H.
Tillman, and upon which bail was re
fused tlie defendant. The testimony
speaks for itself, and every one can
read it and draw their own conclu
sions. The testimony is ?as follows:
Personally comes Robert Lathan,
who says on oath: That he was stenog
rapher and secretary to thc late N. G.
Gonzales and occupied such a position
at tlie time of the shooting of said N.
G. Gonzales; that on the afternoon of
the shooting, and just after the said
N". G. Gonzales had been brought into
Tlie ?State newspaper olliee, on Main
street, some 50 yards north of the
point of the said slanting, M. G. Gon
zales told deponent that he, the said
Ni G. Gonzales, knew the result of
such a shot as he had received, and
more than once while in said olllcc,
suffering from said wound, intimated
in plain language that he knew his
wound was mortal; that thereafter;
and in a couple of hours thereafter
when said N. G. Gonzales had been
conveyed to tlie Columbia hospital, lo
be there operated upon, lie repealed
said intimation of the result of lits
wound to deponent; that while in this
state of mind he said the following
words, or of like import, to deponent,
to wit: "I started out o? Tlie State of
liee walking as usual on the right hand
side of the'pavement, going towards
thc State house, and as I got close to
the corner, the intersection of Main
and Gervais streets, where 1 bad to
turn to the left into Gervais street on
my way home, I observed Tillman.
Two men were with bim, Senator Tal
birti of Beaufort and another man,
whose face E did not observe. Tal bird
was next to Tillman, and this other
man was on the inside. Tillman was
on the outside. Knowing that if I kept
straight on 1 would collide with him.
because tlie three men were walking
abreast and Tillman was on the out
side, 1 also being on the outside; I cut
diagonally to the left, intending to
furn into Gervais street, as I could
have done without touching tlie mau
of the three who was on the inside.
As 1 got (I had just merely glanced at
his face) on the turu, not more than
t.wo or three feet from thc exact cor
ncr.Tillman suddenly pulled Iiis pistol,
or perhaps he had it in his hand, pos
sibly up his sleeve (I did not notice,)
presented it and tired, making some
exclamation which I have forgotten.
The shock almost threw me off m?
feet. 1 swerved around and feFt very
weak. I threw my back up against the
corner on thc Main street side, so as to
support myself, and faced bini. Ile
bad Iiis pistol pointed at me, and I
said to liim, 'Fire, you coward: you
have already killed mc, you know
it. Shoot again.' Tillman said sonic
i Hiing about ?I took your advice," t lien
I looked -at my face, dropped his hand
holding the pistol and sauntered out
into the middle of tlie street." Reply
ing to some question, Mr. Gonzales
continued, "I bad no idea whatever of
meeting him. 1 had seen him two days
before in thc lobby of Hie house. Ile
saw mc and was talking to someone,
while I was walking around. He did
not say anything. I did nob say any
thing. The tiling was finished as far
as I was concerned." Mr. Gonzales was
Mien asked whether Tillman said tiny
thing when he Hied on him. He re
plied that lie did say something. Be
ing further questioned, whether lie
had sent Tillman any message, Mr.
Gonzales answered, "Never sent him
a word of message by any one." Then
thc question was asked, .Did you hear
liim say you had sent him a message
by any one?" Mr. Gonzales answered,
"No. he said something like 'I have
taken you at your word,' or somet hing
like that. 1 sent bim no message, so
kelp me God." Mr. Gonzales further
said Tillman used the expression '1
have taken you at your word.' or some
thing of similar import, after he tired.
On the lirst day of I he present session
of the general assembly, or t he day
thereafter, I was in the lobby of the
State house on the side next the ball
of the house of representatives. While
there I saw Mr. N. G. Gonzales stand
ing just at the door of the committee
room to the left as you enter the hall
of the bouse of repr?sent ai i ves. He
was talking willi a gentleman. While
lie stood there 1 saw Mr. .lames ll.
Tillman standing in Hie lobby wit hin
a few feet of tlie said N. G. Gonzales.
He, thc said Tillman, was speaking
with some one when'I saw him, anti
he passed into the committee room
opposite that one near flic door of
willoh Mr. Gonxales was standing.
Said James II. Tillman was obliged to
have seen N. G. Gonzales,as there was
nothing interposing between them.
Robert Lat han.
Pcrsoi ally appears before mc E. J.
Watson, who being duly sworn says:
That on thc 2Sth day of November,
1002, tue day that thc-fl nit I meei ingot'
the hoard of canvassers was held to de
clare the result of t he general election
held earlier in the month, deponent
saw Lieut. Gov. Tillman. Ile was wit h
several others chatting in t he (?thee of
the attorney general. Filially those
present, among whom was Mr. Till
man, began to leave Hie room. As de
ponent, started to go out also Mr. Till
man detained him a few minutes, and
si anding engaged him in convers?t ion,
which led io a statement from Mr.
Tillman that he would perhaps leave
the Stale sifter bis term of olllcc as
lieutenant governor bad expired. That
lie lia 1 received a good business oller
in another State. Then Mr. Tillman
referred to the way he had been perse
cuted by"that man over yonder,' poin
ting towards The Slate otllee, and re
marked that he had stood all he intend
ed to stand; that if he, Mr. Gonzales,
did not.quit hounding liim down and
continued to do bim so he would kill
him. Thinking a moment Mr. Till
man said. "You can take him I bat as
a message from me." That deponent
told him that the best thing he could
do (Mr. Tillman,) if bc really int ended
g^hig elsewhere would he lo avoid the
possioility of having any troulile; tba?
what had taken place and bad been
said was past and gone, and that so far
as taking a message lo Mr; Gonzales
was concerned he (deponent) certain
ly would not bear such a message from
him; that if he want0(1 lo send snell a
message thc proper way lo send lt was
to write it and address it to Mr. Gon
zales; that deponent could not allon!
and would not bc mixed up with such
a matter in any way; that Mr. Tillman
repeated what he had said, and said,
|""1 would bc glad if you would give
him that as a message from me"; that
deponent repeated he would not take
such a message, and Mr. Tillman being
called went out into the ollicc of the
secretary of state to attend the meet
ing of the board; that deponent later
m the presence of the members of tho
board saw Mr. Tillman in the office
of the secretary of state, but no further
reference was made to the conversa
tion above referred to; that deponent
have never seen Mr. Tillman to speak
lo him since: that deponent paid no
attention to the matterat thc time,
as he had heard Mr. Tillman make a
remark during tho summer that he
had stood all he intended to stand;
that deponent said nothing of thc
conversation to any one, and certainly
not to Mri Gonzales. Deponent never
at any time intimated to Mr. Gonzales
anything in regard to the matter; that
he"had no other reason for refusi.ig to
lake a message to Mr. Gonzales than
his determination, long formed, never
lo lake a message of such character,
knowing Mr. Gonzales' disregard of
any kind of a threat; he would not
have borne thc message feeling that
in so doing he would be in thc position
of being used simply to revive condi
tions that had long since ceased to ex
ist; that so far as- deponent is aware
nothing appeared lil the editorial
columns of Thc ?State in regard to
Tillman from the time of the con
versation with Mr. Tillman above re
ferred id; that thc condit ions of the
threat had never been fulfilled so far
tis d?ponent knows; that deponent
never saw Mr. Tillman after the day
in November until the opening of the
.session of flic general assembly, when
wliiie stat.Vding in the .lobby of the
hall of the house of representatives,
deponent, who was talking with Mr
Gonzales neurone of the committee
rooms, saw Mr. Tillman enter the lob
by and stand some feet away, engaging
in conversation with several gentle
men; that deponent and ?Mr. Gonzales
aller a short time passed out of thc
lobby and. went to thc senate chamber.
E. J. Watson.
Personally comes C. M. Llde, who
being duly sworn says: I am a broth
er-in-law of Pi of. Wardlaw of tile
South Carolina college, who lives on
South Sumter street, In the city of
Columbia, and there deponent lives
also: That on Thursday, January
loth, 1803, I was going down Main
street towards my home, which led
me past the transfer station of thc
street railway, at the northeast corn
er of Gervais and Main streets, city of
Columbia. Walking along some feet
In front of me was Mr. N. G. Gonza
les, editor of The State newspaper; 1
also noticed coining from the direction
of the State house, and meeting said
Gonzales, Lieut. Gov- Tillman with
two other men. I did not notice the
two men accompanying him at once to
recognize them, but I did observe that
Gov. Tillman was walking on tho out
side or the three au they came along
up Main street from across Gervais
street and that lie maintained that!
position with his hands in his over
coat pocket until just before he had
tired tile ?shut, hereinafter described.
1 was not close enough to hear any
thing that was said, either by Gov.
Tillman or by Mr. Gonzales, both of
whom I am informed invariably spoke
in a low voice. They (Gonzales and
Tillman) approached cadi other, Gon
zales going sou Ul, Tillman coming
north. Gonzales turned when about
20 feet in front of Tillman to the in
side of tlie pavement, Tillman being
on the outside, when just as lie was
going around the three, on the inside
of the pavement, Tillman being on
thc outside of thc three and near thc
oilier edge of Hie said pavement, and
having both hands In his overcoat
pooKOt, tlie latter, that is Tillman,
suddenly tired hts pistol. I just no
ticed that he threw up his pistol and
li red. I do not know where lie drew
his pistol from. 1 only know that he
drew it up and tired instantly. Gon
zales at th'c time had both hands in
his overcoat pockets. I could see that
much from Gie rear view I had. As
Tillman shot Gonzales turned immedi
ately and then I saw that his thumb
was projecting from Iiis overcoat pock
ets. I did not stop on my way and as
I advanced of course 1 camencarer to
thc parties. When Tillman fired the
muzzle of the pistol was several feet
from the body of his victim. I saw
Gonzales distinctly and 1 say that he
made no motion whatever or any d?m
onstration whatever up to the time
that Tillman tired upon him; and 1
say further that if the shot had been
delayed for another strip taken by Gon
zales. Tillman would lia ve shot him in
tho hack. As soon as Tillman fired
one of the men with Tillman threw
himself between Tillman and Gon
zales turned Square around and looked
Tillman in thu face. Ile then turned
towards the corner column' of the
transfer station and loaned his head
over. Tillman still had his pistol up
as if lie meant to take another shot:
he still held the pistol up over the
shoulder of tho man who got between
them. Mr. Gonzales then turned
again and faced Tillman. Mr. Sims
then went up to him. afterwards Mr.
LaMoltc coming fruin lionel's bicycle
shop, and they almost simultaneously
tonk him hy his arm. Tiley asked if
Gonzales was shot and he replied, yes,
through the stomach, whereupon one
of them asked where he wished to be
carried: he answered, to Tho State
otilen and there tiley supported him.
As soon as Gonzales turned to walk
around the corner into Gervais street
going cast Tillman, sided oft' to his
left, and had gotten ti about the first
street car track on the brick crossing
towards thc opera house, with his eyes
still on Gonzales, when thc two gen
tlemen named turned towards The
State office supporting him. Tillman
still fa cd them, pistol lu hand, until
they had passed thc station going
north to The Slate office, and his left
baudin Iiis overcoat pocket certainly
some portion ol' the time. Then Till
man turned to his right, crossing
.Main street diagonally to thc pave
ment in front, of City Auditor Allen's
?lllcc, where lie met a man In citizen's
clothes, when Hie two turned and
walked along West Gervais street to
thc police station. Just at the mo
ment of the shot the man next to
Tillman, the mau being on linc with
Tillman, seemed to jump forward and
between them. I never saw Tillman
move his hands from his overcoat
pockets until he drew his pistol. I
was not near enough to hoar any
i [CONTINUKD ON PAQB 4.]
SWEPT BY STOEM.
Th?;.Details of the Fatal Disaster at
Honea Path.
- .
THREE LITTLE ONES CRUSHED
To Dcntli in Aiken County by
, Trees and Chimneys, Tho
Winds HtKh Ali Over
tho State.
Later details of the cyclone that
visited Honea Path on Monday of last
week shows that-it waa more disas
trous than ab first reporte.1. The
damages aa near as can be ascertained
are ?6 follows:
The large two-story double brick
store of Mr. W. A. Shirley was en
tirely destroyed and his stock of fur
niture and house furnishing goods
badly damaged.
Six young men on their way from
school dashed into this store to escape
thc wind and rain. They had just
reached one of the large double front
doors when they saw the front wall
was falling towards thc street. They
made an effort to escape from danger
hut tour of them were burled beneath
the wreck while two others rushed in
to tho front door and took refuge In?
the inside of the store.
WERE KILLED OUTRIGHT.
Earle McGee, son of Mr. W. J. Mc
Gee, and Bertie Austin, son of Mrs.
Thomas Austin of Greenville county,
were killed Instantly, and Edgar DOH
ald, son of Mr. J. lt. Donald, was seri
ously injured, both legs and arms be
ing broken and his spine injured. A. C.
Stone, son of Mr. J. T. Stone had one
leg broken and sustained other In
jurias about thc head and body.
Immediately after the destruction
or thc building Mr. P. W. Sullivan,
who was standing at one of the win
dowsin the hank building only ?1 short
distance away, saw thc hand of some
one shaking. He promptly called for
assistance and went to work to rescue
the victims. In a few minutes the
bodies of tim unfortunate young men
were extracted and carried to .nearby
buildings.
Medical assistance was summoned
and every thing possible was done for
the sufferers. The force of the storm
was terrille and tho building of Mr.
Shirley was torn to atoms in almost a
second. Large frames from the roor
were blown hundreds of yards and
brick were scattered in every direc
tion. .
STOKES UNROOFED.
In. addition to the above named
building, several stores were unroofed,
.ph?-- Syjjj blown down and trees up
ruuie rT?u a "piece of woodland a short
distando from here more than a hun
dred trees were felled.
Parties returning home, from town
were carried many yards by the force
of the winds. Telephone and tele
graph wires are down and communica
tions with other points was Impos
sible.
The graded school had just closed
its work for the day and lt is a miracle
that many of the children were not
killed. Many oj! them rushed into the
Baptist chnrch, although two of them
were carried across thc field and hurl
ed against a tree.
The damage to property here is con
siderable. Several firms suffered dam
age to their stocks of goods by water,
their storerooms being unroofed.
The los* to property in the sur
rounding country is not very great,
although many chimneys were blown
down.
Stock was killed and out buildings
damaged. Thc Chiquola mill suffered
considerable damage, several of the
tenant houses beingdemolised. Lights
were broken out of thc mill buildings
and waste house blown down.
MAIL CARRIER'S CLOSE CALL.
E. B. (Julbersoh mail carrier on one
of the free delivery routes, had a nar
row escape from death. He had taken
refuge in a covered bridge a few miles
from here. ?le realized thu I the bridge
would hot stand the force of the storm
and made an effort to get his team out
hilt before he 'could do so the struc
ture gave way. His horse was killed
and his buggy demolished. Ile saved
himself hy jumping into the open just
as tile illidge went down.
Tile citizens of Belton, a nearby
town, rendered valuable assistance,
several coming down on the lirst train.
Among them were two of the leading
physicians who very quickly offered
their services to the families of the
injured.
Thc work of removing the debris
from the streets was at once under
taken hy Mayor Milford and in a few
days tlie stores will be ready for busi
ness again.
It may bc well to state that no one
other than those mentioned aboved
sustained any injuries. The condition
of Edger Donald is critical but his
chances of recovery are' good unless
blood poisin dcvclopes. One leg will
will doubtless lia vc lo bc amputated.
TUE ?LOW AT ANDERSON.
An Anderson dispatch says the
storm was the most severe in years,
and it is a wonder that the loss of life
and property is not larger. Monday
was very warm for thc season and a
hard rain fell for several hours during
tlie day.
Thc Episcopal church at Calhoun
Falls was also destroyed. A severe
wind storm set in here just after dark
and continued with more or less se
verity until midnight.
l.igon & Led better's largewholesale
grocery store and the Anderson Cash
Grocery store were unroofed. A large
plate glass in B. ?. Evans & Co.'s
show window was destroyed, the slate
roof of tlie court house badly dam
aged, and telephone and electric light
wires blown down, and much other
damage was done of more or less Im
portance.
About ? o'clock a team of horses be
longing to Dobbins' stable ran Into a
live electric light wire on East Boun
dary street and one of the horses was
electrocuted.
On thc account of the broken wires
the electric lights were shut off and
soon after this the Ure alarm rang,
hut luckily lt was only a foul chimney
burning, and no damage-was doue.
About 10 o'clock all communication
, with the outer world was cut off by
telegraph and telephono, all tho wires
being down in every direction. After
the storm it turned bitter cold, and
continued so all day.
CAR BARN BLOWN DOWN.
At Spartanburg the storm, which
lasted an hour and a half, and which,
blew down the car barn of the Spar
tanburg Railway, Gas and Electric
company, situated about one and one
half miles from the city in the north
eastern portion of the city. Numer
ous trees were also uprooted in the
suburbs and fell on the lines of the
electric and telephone lines. The
roof of the Southern Cotton' OH mill
here was blown off, many glasses and
windows to store rooms' on the square
and on various streets were ; shivered
by the force of thc Wind and the ob
stacles it swept in its path'.
The storm, unaccompanied by rain,
hail, thunder or lightning, raged un
der a sky covered with stars and a full
moon. On account of the storm, the
power house of the Spartanburg Rail
way, Gas and Electric compuny was
shut down, and transportation trolley
cars abandoned, the lights of all kinds
were shut out and darkness was every
where. The lighting of the city was
shut down the earlier part of the night
in order that the lives, of .travelers
and pedestrians on the soreets should
not be jeopardized by contact with
live wires, dangling on the streets,
where they were forced by trees fall
ing on them. Telegraph and tele
phone work was out of the question.
A cirrjRcn DESTROYED.
At Abbeville about dark the mer
cury began to drop rapidly, and as
thc mercury fell tho wind-rose, so
that by 9 o'clock a howling, shrieking
gale was blowing, making sleep al
most out of the question. By some
persons it is said that the wind reach
ed a higher velocity Monday night
than in thc storm of the afternoon.
At any rate the damage done was
greater. The Methodist church at
the cotton mill is a complete wreck,
os is Hammond's tan-yard, both build
ings being flat cn the ground. Tele
phone poles, -trees, shrubbery and
chimneys again suffered. No news
has been received from the surround
ing country as tu damage done. The
wrecked Methodist church is a new
frame building and its destruction
will be greatly felt by the * congrega
tion, as it was by hard work that
funds were secured to erect the build
ing.
SEVERAL HOUSES BLOWN DOWN.
The storm struck Laurens about
half-past four o'clock, and for 10
minutes it was terrille. Trees were
uprooted everywhere, the plastering
loosened In residences and more or
less damage done to light outbuild
ings, kitchens, etc. The telephone
and electric light systems probably
suffered the greatest damage. Poles
were llattoned right and left and the
wires aro down in every direction.
For several hours the service of
both were badly Interrupted. On
Wm. Brown's place a cabin was blown
down and a negro child had its skull
crushed and a negro woman was In
jured by falling timbers. Thc child
will probably die. At Owingc'
Station Mr. Jno. Campbell's ' house
was wrecked and a negro house on
Will Powers' place nearby was blown
down. Two miles above there Mr.
Robert Stoddard's residence, a new
building was demolished. No one is
reported to have been injured.
At night the wind continued fu
rious, and it was past midnight before
many people slept comfortably.
Tuesday it is biting cold and extreme-1
ly disagreeable ""for outdoor work or
travel.
TUREE KILLED IN AIKEN COUNTY.
Loss of life followed in the wake of
the storm which passed over Aiken
county Monday night. Two children
of Mr. Jas. Davis, who lives at Ergles
Bridge about 12 miles from Aiken,
were killed by a falling tree. At
Lake View the roof of a tenement
house was blown off and tho family
ran out and escaped-without injury,
but the child of Moses Dorkins, about
0 years old, was struck by thc falling
chimney and killed. While the wind
was very hard in Aiken no material
damage was done.
INSURANCE FRAUDS.
Several Murders Done to Aid a
Gljtuiitic Swindle.
Assistant District Attorney Krotel
said Wednesday that the insurance
fraud cause now under investigation
in New York promised to develop into
one of the most startling ever known
In the criminal history or the city.
"Before the district attorney's of
fice has finished its Investigation of
the astounding and extraordinary
New York insurance frauds," he said,
"I should not be surprised if it were
proved that the conspirators even
went so far as to murder in cold blood
to get bodies for the purpose of col
lecting policies. We have found that
2a substitute bodies were passed off on
the Haneok Insurance company alone,
and as soon as the plotters are indict
ed these will be exhumed. The in
vestigation into the remarkable pict
has hardly begun."
Thc fate of Sarah Weber, who it is
alleged, died from thc effects of brutal
treatment, which, it ls charged, she
received at thc hands of thc conspira
tors, Mr. Krotel said, was but a single
instance.
According to stories told by her rela
tives Sarah Webber was tortured In
order to compel her to aid in the in
surance frauds.
When the girl left home she had
rosy checks and was the picture of
health. When her family found her
she was a shadow-of herself. She
told her brother that she had been
beaten, starved and slashed with
knives to force her to help those en
gaged in the conspiracy.
Liven Loht.
At Port Huron, Mich., fireman Mil
ton Campbell, which was crushed un
der1 a falling wall at the Ure which
early Wednesday destroyed thc St.
Clair hotel and a number of business
houses, is dead. Yardman Albert
Worthing, of the hotel, has not yet
been found and lt is believed that he
was burned'to death in thc hotel. All
the guests have been accounted for.
The loss will reach between $75,000
and $100,000.
A HIDEOUS DISASTER.
Mino Guests Roosted. In a Hotel Pira.
Trap.
. At Cedar Rapids,.Ia., fire early Fri
day morning destroyed the Clifton
Hotel, cremating nine of the guests
and caused injuries to 42 persons,-who
were scorched or forced to jump to
the frozen street from second and
third Btory windows. vAfter ari all.day
search in the debris four bodies have
been recovered, lt is now- believed
that five bodies more remain, in the
ruins .of the. hotel, which j is said to
have been a flimsy structure and.Ulled
with delegates to the State - Young
Men's Christian Association. Conven
tion and the district conventioa of
the Knights of Pythias. The hotel
register was destroyed, thus making lt
di moult to ascertain, tho number of
missing persons. In an hour St.
Luke's Hospital contained 16.injured,
while many more, chiefly those who
had escaped with comparatively slight
hurts, were being care* :for in-huild
lngs near the scene of the tragedy.
Some who jumped owe their lives to
the fact that their falls were broken
by telegraph wires which Interposed
in their downward flight. A number
of the guests who were able to con
verse calmly following their escape
declared that they scumbled over
prostrate bodies as they rushed to the
windows. The flames literally were
! chasing them and the smoke made it
almost, impossible to breathe. The
proprietor of the hotel placed his esti
mate of the number of people in the
building when the alarm was raised
at between 70 and 80. Those who
were first to escape, where they were
not too severely injured, stood for.
some time barefooted in the snow,
chained to the spot and rendered un
conscious of the cold by the horror of
the scene. Many of them had to be
led away.
A DESECRATION.
A Historical Sideboard Now Adorns
a Liquor Saloon.'
An interesting story relating to the
sale of the sideboard presented to Mrs.
Hayes when she was mistress of the
White House is being sent out from
Washington. The story says the side
board, laden with wine glasses, decan
ters, siphons and even beer steins,now
graces a saloon in the capital city.
This sideboard was originally present
ed to Mrs. Hayes when her husband
was president in recognition of her re
fusal to allow liquors on the table at
the White House. It_was the gift of
numerous young women of Cincinnati,
among whom were Mrs. Bellamy Stor
er, wife of the ambassador to Austria,
and Mrs. Taft, wjfe ot-thc civil gaver-,
nor of the Philippines. The sideboard
shared the fate of many another piece
of White House furniture at the gen
eral clearing out auction last week.
It was knocked down to its present
owner for Ss85, nnd transferred from
the executive halls to a saloon, where
it has become not merely an article of
use, but has furnished to iconoclasts
the subject for many a bibulous jest.
No sooner did it become known that
the historic bit of furniture was being
thus desecrated than John R. Mc
! Lean offered S850, ten times the price
lt had been bought at, for the old !
sideboard. The new owner, realizing
thc advertising value of the sideboard
declined. Then Colonel Webb Hayes,
anxious to rescue the prized possession
of his mother from vandals, attempt
ed to purchase it, hut he was inform
ed that the price placed on it was
$3,000. So, surrounded by bacchana
lian insignia, in an atmosphere heavy
with the fumes ot alcohol, the old
sideboard, the gift of the Cincinnati
belles, the most cherished possession
of the white ribbon mistress of the
White House, stands while ribald
jests are abroad at the sad descent
from its former high estate.
Guilty of Manslaughter.
A i Chariottee, N. C. Sunday after
noon the Jury in the caseot Arthur L.
Bishop, the shoo drummer charged
with the murder of Thomas I. Wilson,
came into court and rendered a ver
dict of manslaughter. Bishop was in
court and his wife was by his side.
The court room was filled with people,
including about"50 commercial travel
ers who were in Charlotte to spend
Sunday. Immediately after the
rendering of the verdict Bishop was
remanded to Jail. Bishop, who travel
ed for a New England shoe factory,
killed Thomas 1. Wilson in this city
on December 9th, last. He had gone
to Wilson's home In company with
Miss Lena Schultz and Miss Ada Wil
son, daughter of the deceased. "Wil
son, discovered the three in his parlor
drinking wine and ordered Miss
Schultz and Bishop to leave. Bishop
wanted to parley and Wilson endeavor
ed to eject him, when he was shot
and killed by Bishop. The latter fled
and made his way to his home in
Petersburg, where he surrendered.
Hud No Coal.
At St. Louis owing to tho scarcity
of coal at the "Four Courts," which
contains the jail, police headquarters,
criminal court, etc., the building was
closed today. Not a pound of coal
could bc found in the engine room,
and the old floors are being torn up
to keep the j 250 prisoners in the Jail
warm. The grand jury Investigation
into Investment companies was sus
pended, and the two brandies of the
criminal court and thc court of
criminal correction adjourned for the
dny. This condition is the result of
negligence on . the part of tho con
tractor, who failed to deliver thc
coal already contracted for.. Other
city Institutions aro also short of fuel,
and an investigation will be held to
ascertain who is to blame.
Wages or Sin.
At New Orleans Ella Atkins is dead
and Folger Green in the hospital with
titree wounds as t he result of a com
pact they entered into to end theil
lives. The woman died of morphine
poisoning. Thc man stabbed hlmsell
twice in thc neck and then slashed hi?
wrists. Tho tragedy occurred in o
room in the Victoria Hotel, on Bour
i hon street, where the couple passed as
man and wife.
MANY DROWNED.
The Passenger Steamer Olive Wreok-:
ed hy a Cyclone.
EIGHTEEN LIVES A EE LOST
And Eight Other Persons"Who Liort
in a Small Boat Aro Still
Unaccounted-for by
Friends. : .
1 A cyclone struck the passenger stea
. mer Olive which plies between Frank
lin, Va., and Eden?on, N. C., at 9:30
o'clock Monday night, Feb. .10, and .
sent her to the bottom of the river off..
Wooley's Pier^ between Mount Pleas
ant and Oliver's wharf, at Norfolk
Virginia.
The whirlwind when it struck the
Olive caused her to go over on her
beams' end and when she rifted it -
wasonly to sink on account 6f the
water Bhe had taken. A majority of
the passengers and crew were below"
at the time and had .ho ^opportunity
to reach the pilot house of the vessel.
This point was the only portion left
above water and in it standing waist
deep from the time of the accident
until 0 o'clock in the morning Capt.
George H. "Withy and five others were
saved.
According to the statement of Ca pt.
Withy to The Associated Press corre
spondent here Monday night 17 per
sons-are koowa to have beeu lost on
the sinking steamer and a..lifeboat
loaded with Engineer C."Li; Conway,
Assistant Engineer J. P. Murphy,
Purser J. N. Bell, one white and two
colored passengers unknown,.and two'
colored deck hands, which left the
steamer in hopes of reaching a vessel
whose lights could be-seen in-the dist
ance, is yet unheard from. If these
have been drowned the death list wlU
reach 25.
KNOWN TO BE DEAD.
Jake Lassiter, white, aged 25, home
Rich Square, N. C., salesman for Car
lin & Fulton, Baltimore hardware
dealers.
Mrs. Bennett, Franklin", Va.
Twelve year old daughter of Mrs.
Bennett.
Mrs. Vaughan, franklin, Va.
Frauk Hunter, George Butt, W. II.
Edwards and Andre Vaughan, colored _
deck hands. *
Abraham Cooper and Prescott Scott ,
colored firemen.
Esther Williams, colored cook.
John Cooper, colored porter.
John Cooper, colored preacher.
Four unknown colored passengers.
Capt. Withy reached Nortork-Taies-.
day afternoon in company with Mar
tha Barrett, colored stewardess of the
steamer. The Associated Press cor
respondent he made , the following
statement: - "
CAPTAIN'S STATEMENT.
"We left Franklin on our regular
trip at ll o'clock. A heavy southwest
wind was blowing, but along the Cho- q
j wau river we did not mind it much.
At 9 o'clock last Monday night we
passed Hollies' wharf and headed for
Edenton bay. The weather became so
heavy that I could not risk the open
water and I put the boat about to re
turn to the river for safety. It was
Just about 2 o'clock when everything
became inky black and a terrible roar
ing broke out of thc night. I was the
only one in the - pilot house and most
of those below had turned in. In a
second something struck the boat on
her port beam and turned her over on
her starboard side. J thought she
would never right herself and a mon
ster wave dashed over us. It flooded
the hold and smashed every window
around us. With thc rush of water
Into her hold the Olive slowly righted
and in less than two minutes after
having struck she was resting on the
bottom with only the pilot house
above the river.- Two lifeboats were
swept away and one was left. Into
this thc engineer, assistant engineer,
purser and one white and two colored
passengers climbed and put off with
the hnni? nf witching up with a tow
boat that could be seen ahead of us
I never saw them after they left our
side. Their going left the stewardess
and one white and two colored passen
gers on board with me. We stood in
water waist deep until 0 o'clock in the
morning when a Norfolk and South
ern steamer hove in sight, took us off
and landed us at Edenton, where we
took thc train for Norfolk. The boat
sunk so quickly after being struck
that none below had a chance to reach
the deck and all must have drowned
in berths."
lt was learned Monday night that
a white man named Wilder, of Coler
aine, N. C., is also among the drown
ed, making the eighteenth victim.
The work was started Wednesday to
recover the dead bodies and if possible
raise the steamer. Five years ago thc
Olive while running an excursion
sprang a leak and went down within
sight of Monday night's scene. At
that time no lives were lost.
. Thc-Olive was an Inland passenger
steamer hailing from Norfolk. She
was built in 18G9 and was of 287 tons
gross: 120.9 feet long, 20.4 feet beato
and seven feet depth of hold.
Tho Storm King.
A terrible wind storm and tidal
wave that swept across Mundcn's
Point, Va., Monday night destroyed
several houses, barns and the round
house of the Norfolk and Southern
railroad at Norfolk, Va., from which
several persons narrowly escaped with
their lives. The residence of Thos.
Morris was entirely destroyed. Mr.
Morris, his wife an? daughter were in
the house at thc time and narrowly
escaped being crushed to death. All
were injured. The house of Elijah
White also was entirely demolished,
the occupants narrowly escaping with
their lives, Mr. White being quite
badly injured. At high tide a tidal
wave came across thc land between
thc ocean and Pamlico sound which
washed away everything in its course.
Several people living in thc water
front were compelled to wade through
, water up to their waist in order to es
? cape from their homes which were be
; lng washed away by the j tide. Thc
. storm struck Moycock, N. C., on tho
Norfolk and Southern railroad last
Monday night. Two two-story dwell
ings were picked up and carried scv
oral feet.