The Bamberg herald. (Bamberg, S.C.) 1891-1972, September 21, 1922, Image 1
% Hamtorg Ijcratt j
$2.00 Per Year in Advance. BAMBERG, S. 0., THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 21,1922. Established in 1891. f:||
Loyless
Guilty of
%
The jury at 7 o'clock last night re-11
turned a verdict of guilty of man- i
slaughter. Sentence was not passed. ]
,
The taking of the, evidence in the 1
Goodwin case began just before noon f
Monday, and at 5:30 Tuesday after- ?
noon the state rested its case. The j
testimony was long drawn out, and 1
the case was hard fought, every inch
of ground being keenly contested by (
the attorney for Go5dwin, R. M. Jeff- t
eries, of Walterboro. The prosecu- (
tion was conducted by. Solicitor Gun- t
with tho assistance of J. Wesley (
Crum, Jr. | (
Dr. Robert Black described the 1
wounds found on the body of the de- <
ceased, Jacob E. Carter, and a num- ]
ber of witnesses testified to the surroundings.
1
Vandy DuBois, a witness for the s
state, was the first person to reach c
the body after the killing. He stated
that he was employed at a saw mill s
and that he heard the two shots, c
being about five seconds apart, the i
contention of the state being that t
Carter was killed with a single barrel
shotgun, it being necessary to re- t
load the gun to fire the second shot, t
Shortly afterward, he said, he had 1
occasion to go to Carter's house on 1
an errand, going a near cut and com- i
ing suddenly on the body, which i
frightened him and he turned and J
went back until he found some other i
persons, and together they went to I
the body and found it still warm. t
Magistrate L. G. Yarley said that <
Carter had come to him in regard to <
a peace bond against Loyless Good- (
win, stating that Goodwin was going 1
to kill him. The warrant was not \
? ~ ? Vk/vAttnea Portpr i
issued, UUWevei, V ?
thought pfter Goodwin's trial on an- 1
other charge he would not press him i
for the money Goodwin alleged Car- i
ter ov^pd him. Most of the testimony i
of Mr. Yarley, however, was not al- 1
lowed to reach the jury, being re- <
lated subject to objection in the ab- '
sence of the jury. ?
'Mr. Yarley also'told of getting a 1
' single barrel shotgun from Goodwin's <
home the next day, which, according 1
to his knowledge of guns he w.ould i
say had been fired soon before. I
Miss Ella Goodwin, step-daughter- *
of Carter * who lived with the old <
gentleman, told of the events sur- 1
rounding the killing in considerable
detail. Much of this testimony was 1
ruled out as incompetent, but the I
, story as told was about as follows: <
Goodwin Vame to Cartel's some days 1
' * ? A1 and an era croH in fl ]
prior IU LUC JVi 111115 auu
rather animated conversation, as a 1
result of which Mr. Carter was quite ]
uneasy. In this conversation it ap
pears that Goodwin demanded pay- J
ment of certain money alleged to be i
due by Carter to Goodwin's wife, 1
which Carter alleged had been paid. <
He came again a few days later and <
1 hi^ attitude was very unfriendly. 1
Witness was not permitted to say 1
more than this. The night befora the
killing, the witness and Carter, she <
. testified, sat up all night with the ?
shot gun, evidently expecting trouble, '
but none came. ]
The next day after dinner she and (
Carter and the little girl whom wit
ness adopted went to the, house of 1
B. B. Goodwin, her brother, and after
about two hours Mr. Carter walk- (
ed home, sping the near way which
carried him through the lane. Wit- '
ness heard two shots in the direction 1
^ of her house, and she immediately
exclaimed that Goodwin had killed
her step-father, although this latter
statement was ruled out by the court
and the jury warned to disregard it.
She returned home soon after, and
failing to find her father in the house, 1
hnstiiv instituted a search, and found
him near the lot, lying on his right
side at, the woodpile. He V?s dead.
Soon after Constable Carter,- who
in company with Mr. Ehrhardt and
DuBois, who previously visited the
body but who had left to go to Good- (
win's house to serve a warrant on
him, returned with Goodwin. Goodwin
went into the house with them, <
and the witness exclaimed "Take the
dirty rascal out of my house; kill
him and burn him. He has killed
my papa." This statement, made in
the hearing of the defendant, was allowed
to go to the jury. Goodwin
heard the statement, but made no reply,
according to other witnesses, i
Witness is a first cousin of Loyless
Goodwin. <
H. M. Carter testified to seeing
tracks in the lot, but it rained soon
after and he was unable to follow
them. J. E. Fender corroborated the
/ '
r. i -
In Found
Manslaughter
estimony in regard to the tracks, and
>aid they appeared to have been
nade by a No. 7 or 8 shoe. Attorney
Fefferies at this point had the defendant
take off his shoe and it was.
found to be a No. 10, and on cross
wn rvn !*, n + fVltt rrrif r> Odd QHmittPf?
/AaiUiiiatlUU IUU nn/uvkju ???
shoe might have made the tracks; he
vas no expert on tracks.
B. B. Goodwin, a cousin of Loyless
joodwin, and step-son of J. E. Carer,
testified that the surroundings iniicated
there had been no struggle
vhen Carter was killed.? Tracing the
lirectioiv of the shots indicated by
)bjects struck, indications were that
he person firing the shots was located
about the center of the lot gate
L6 1-2 feet distant from the body.
At the conclusion of the state's
:estimony, Mr. Jefferies moved to
strike out several parts of the evilence,
which was overruled.
The defence closed its testimony
ihortly before noon Wednesday. The
. nly important witnesses for the de'ence
were the defendant and the de'endant's
wife, Mrs. Vena Goodwin.
Mrs. Goodwin testified that on the
ifternoon of, the killing of Mr. Car;er
her husband wras at home: that
le came home after a visit to Vandy
OuBois at the log camp about 11:30
tor dinner; that they ate dinner
ibout twelve, and that he did not
eave the premises again until he was
arrested some time after Mr. Carter's
bod^ was found. She heard
vo shots fired about 2 or 2*30 o'?!ock^but
she could not tell in which
lirection they were; that when the
)fficers came to arrest Mr. Goodwin
tor alleged violation of the state
automobile license law, he was at
;ne barn feeding his stock, and that
;hp officers arrested him at the iot.
She *as positive that Mr. Goodwin
.vas not off the premises. The witless
testified that ther$ were no ill
Vielings between her family and that
it Mr. Carter, and denied tha: thert
;vas ever any trouble with Mr Carer
concerning any money alleged to
>e due her by Carter. She denied
Mnveying any threats to the Carter
'amily. She admitted that she did
not gc to Carter's home after the
filing, explaining that it rained all
:he afternoon, but did go to the home
if defendant's brother, Phil Goodwin,
-where she spent the night.
The defendant, E. Loyless Goodwin,
denied in the first question that
le killed Mr. Carter. He corroborated
the testimony of his wife in practically
every detail, stating there had
never been anything but the best of
feelings between him and Carter, and
tie also denied that he even knew
Mr. Carter had sought a peace bond
against him, or that Carter had visited
either the sheriff or the magistrate
in this connection. He explain
3d his failure to meet the magistrate
court at Ehrhardt the afternoon of
the kiljing by saying that he thought
the trial was set for the next day.
He declared that he was at home
all the afternoon until the officers
came. He saV Mr. Carter'and his
step-daughter, Miss Ella Goodwin-,
pass going to B. B. Goodwin's, but
denied that he saw Carter \return
h6me later in the afternoon. At the
time of his arrest he had gone to the
barn to give his stock some mutton
corn he had cut earlier in the day.
Defendant said he heard two shots
about 2 or 2:30 in the afternoon in
quick succession; sufficient time did
not elapse, he said, between shots
to permit reloading a gun. He said
that when he stopped at Carter's
house after he was arrested and was
accused by Miss Goodwin with the
killing, he was immediately carried
out and that he did not have time
in the confusion at the time to make
any denial, but that he did deny the
accusation to the officers later. Asked
if he saw Dr. S. P. Rentz that afi.
a /^Ani if a KoaIii IaItt T-T a
leruuuu, 110 ucuicu it auouiuicij. xi.w
denied making "any threats against
barter at any time and said they were
the best of friends.
The solicitor brought out in the
cross examination the fact that Dr.
Rentz, who has tragically met his
death since the last continuation of
the case, made an affidavit that he
was passing that way that afternoon
and that he saw Goodwin coming
from the direction of Carter's home
with a shotgun in his hand. The
court rules however would not permit
the offering of the affidavit in
evidence.
The case was given |o the jury
yesterday afternoon, and at the time
of The Herald going to press no verdict
had been reached.
. *
McLEOD TO THE PEOPLE.
Governor-Elect Issues Statement of
Conduct and Policy.
Thomas G. McLeod, nominated for
governor of South Carolina in Tuesday's
Democratic primary, issued the
following statement, immediately following
assurance of his majority.
"My first impression is a feeling of!
profound gratitude to the men and I
women of South Carolina for their
zealous and unselfish support during
the campaign.
"To the people of South Carolina,
I desire to say that the deep interest
shown in the issues of the campaign
makes the ' result an endorsement
more ofy the principles that I advocated
thfen of myself
*1 shall endeavor, as far as witfcin
me lies, to see that the affairs of the
state are economically managed. We
arp living in times of deDression and
the hand of adversity falls heavily
upon many. There must, therefore,
be a fair and just discrimination of
taxation. We must not take a hackward
step and a fair and just distribution
of the burden /means the
maintenance of efficiency.
"South Carolina has no foreign
element, our white citizenship are all
one people with the same traditions,
hopes and aspirations, and I sincerely
trust that there will be no lines^of
division, but that together we may
work out the destiny of a vigorous
and valorous commonwealth.
"I realize the great responsibility
that I wiir*assume as governor and
must earnestly beg the cooperation
of all citizens, their sympathy and
their prayers in my efforts to impartially
administer the affairs of this
state.
"In the campaign I made no personal
attack upon anyone. I am
leaving it as I entered it?without;
malice. I have no bitterness and
covet the good will and sympathy of
everyone. It is my purpose to work
out our problems for the best good of
all. I will b* the governor of all the
people."
HARDA\TCK-BLEASE-V A RKVIAN.
i ??? ? <
The South is Congratulated on Recent
"House Cleaning."
* # %
Thomas W. Hardwick's service as
governor of Georgia is to terminate
in the same way as his service as
United States senator was enSed in
1919, through the refusal of the Democratic
voters of his state to grant
him a renomination. In the primary
thi^ week he was overwhelmingly
hv Clifford L. Walker. That
*" ~ I
the Ku Kliyc Klan and Senator Tom
Wiatson, with whom he was previously
in alliance, had a hand in his defeat
does not detract from Georgia's
good fortune in being rid of Hardwick.
For after being repudiated so
decisively his chances of returning
to the senate, on which he had set
his hopes, are slight.
In shelving Hardwick, Georgia has
closely followed the recent example
of other southern states. In the last
few weeks the sojuth has profited by
the opportunity to eliminate three
politicians of the worst type it has
produced.
Yardman, of Mississippi, Cole
Blease, of South Carolina, and Hardwick,
of Georgia, are all of the same
category of demagogues. Their capacity
for working mischief in politics
and in public office has been so often
demonstrated that their states are to
be heartily congratulated on having
disowned them. The south is cleaning
house, and in doing so it deserves
well of the country.?New
York World.
In Bad Company.
;When a vote is to be taken on some
important measure, a congressman
who can not he present "pairs" himself
with some representative who
would vote "aye"".to the congressman
"nay" or vice versa. Once a Democratic
member of the house received
a letter from an active politician of
that party ih his district, calling attention
to the fact that he was reported
in Congressional Record almost
every day as being "paired"
with a republican. "I don't doubt
your loyalty to the party," read the
letter, "but I think the boys would j
like it a good deal better if you pair- j
ed with democrats instead of repub- j
licans."?Harper's Magazine.
m i?> ?
Misused Figure of Speech.
j
A young writer, not much given to
revision, recently sent out a' story
" "
wherein the loiiowing oauncu.
"He called his son a spendthrift,
and did not fail, as he had done before,
to cast his recently purchased
motorcar, a 160-horse-power touring
machine in his teeth."
j 5
1
FLAMES DESTROY HOUSE.
W. M. Ritter, of Xear Cope, Suffers
Heavy Loss.
Cope, Sept. 13.?Wm. Ritter lost
his dwelling and contents Monday
night by fire. Mr. Ritter lives about
one and three-quarter miles west of ,
Cope, near the A. C. L. railway, and ,
was awakened from his sleep by the
roar of the flames just after 2 o'clock.
He called his little son Henry, ran
out into the yard and fired his pistol ,
to arouse the neighbors, and dashed ,
into the house to try to save some- j
thing. His first thought was to get
the piano out if possible, but upon .
nnenin? the door saw the flames Com- ,
ing through the ceiling, he turned
his attention to other things and j
grabbed a trunk, and as he turned to .
enter, the rafters fell, breaking in (
the burning ceiling. One trunk was .
all he saved, everything else being a {
total loss. The only theory so far, is
that rats caused, the firdv
Mr. Ritter had a little insurance
but that will not replace his loss. (
One night last week a rogue broke ,
into a tenement house on W1 M. .
Hughes's place, and robbed one roos- .
ter of all of his wearing apparej, and
upon leaving set fire to the bed. The
bed being of iron, the bed clothes ;
weVe consumed, the ashes falling on
the floor, but not heat enough to .
catch the flooring. The thief took (
that plan to hide his deviltry. He ]
was tracked by his bare-foot tracks (
near to Binnaker's bridge towards ,
Denmark, but has. not yet been ap- .
prehended. Two parties were missing
from their work the next morning. ,
and it lies between one or tne otner {
or both. ^
COPE GRADED SCHOOL.
John P. Cattrette Will Again Have j
Charge.
!
Cope," Sept. 17.?The Cope graded j
school will open tomorrow morning :
for the 1-922-1923 session, John
P. fcartrette, of Conway, who was
principal last year, tfill again be in
charge, and he will have as his as- 1
sistants four new teachers, as follows:
Miss Beulah Johnson, of Lowryville;
Miss Elizabeth Darby, of i
Chester; Miss Elizabeth Kirkland, of
Bamberg, and Miss Black, of Millets- i
ville. j
A new school building for which
bonds were voted some three weeks ;
ago will soon be begun and will no
doubt be in use before the close of
this session. - 1
The following young women of
Cope left recently to teach: Miss ?
Mayy Thomas, at McColl; Miss Elise
Gray, at Brevard, N., C.; and Misses
Lucille and Lillian Tatum, at Bessimer
City, N. C.
The following left recently for col*
- - "* *" * /''l A/ilrlAtr P Vi ? _ j
lege: '.viiss iviargautt? vynTvxvioj, vm
cora College, Columbia; Miss Evelyn
Henerey and Miss Rita Barton, Brenau
College Conservatory, Gainesville,
Ga.; Carlton Thomas, Bailey
Military Institute, and Murray Tatum,
for the Citadel, at Charleston.
SCHOOL YEAR BEGINS.
?
Encouraging Outlook in Olar for
Session.
Olar. Sept. 16.?The Olar high
school reopened Monday morning and ,
considerable enthusiasm was manifested
over the encouraging outlook
for a very successful year.
After singing "America," invocation
was offered by the Rev. C. M.
Peeler, pastor of Bethel MethocUst
church. W. L. Brannon, the newly
elected superintendent was then introduced.
Mr. Brannon was well received.
He madd a very inspiring
address and made a favorable impression
on his hearers.
Adresses were then made by the
Rev. Mr. Peeler and C. F. Rizer, Mr.
Rizer being a member of the board of
trustees. ' These gentlemen gave
some very wholsome advice.
The faculty is composed of the following:
Supt. W. L. Brannon, of
^Smyrna; Misses Maggie Milhous and
Mary Neely, of Olar; Miss Mary Bufort,
of Xewberry; Miss Charlotte
Rivins. of Haddock. Ga., Misses Cor
! nelia and Kathleen Sanders, of
Greens-Westminster.
^
Not So Bad.
j "This is a good place to summer,"
remarked the boarder in a cultivated
tone, "but it must be quite deadly to
winter here."
"Well,"drawled the native. "I'm
pretty lively still and I not only summered
and wintered in this town for
seventy years, but I sprang and fell
here too." s
. / x ftfii
General Sessioi
Convened M
The court of general sessions convened
in Bamberg Monday morning.
On account of illness, Judge Geo. E.
Prince could not be present to fill
his regular schedule, and Robert
Lide, Esq., of the Orangeburg bar,
was appointed special judge to preside
in his stead. Mr. Lide is well
tnown in Bamberg, having frequently
practiced in this court, and he is
presiding with the air of an experienced
jurist.
The preliminaries were gore
through with rapidly, and before
noon the court was busy on the trial
of Loyless Goodwin, charged with tlje
murder of Jacob E. Carter, an aged
citizen of the Little Swamp section of
Bamberg county, more than a year
ago.
Judge Lide delivered a strong
charge to the grand jury, and the
solicitor had a large number of bills
to hand to the grand jury early in
the day. The grand jury expedited
its duties, and before night a mass of
indictments were in the solicitor's
hands.
The court lasts only through this
week, and as the court docket is one
of the largest in some years, it is not
likely that anything like a clearing
of the docket can be accomplished in
these few days. In addition to the
regular schedule of liquor violations
and other lesser crimes, there are
several murder trials of more than
*
ordinary interest.
The Goodwin case has been hanging
in the court for a good while. It
will be recalled that Mr. Carter was
eJ J J A nk lirno
LU Ullll UbdU ILL ills y CLL U. a OUUl (, '? nir.
kfter he was shot to d?ath. When
found, his body was still warm. TJie
surroundings indicated that the old
gentleman, a highly respected citizen,
had been cutting wood in his
yard. The axe was lying near his
body. A load of sbot had entered thfc
body from an apparently close range,
as a gun wad was stuck in his body.
Loyless Goodwin was arrested
about the time the body was found on
a charge of operating an automobile
without a state highway license. He
vas at his house near the Carter home
at the time of his arrest. He denied
any connection whatever with the
homicide. '
\
The following jurors/were selected
to try the Goodwin case: F. W. Free,
ORANGEBURG HAS PISTOL DUEL.
Policeman - and John Lloyd Wound
Each Other.
Orangfeburg, Sept. 16.?A shooting
scrape here this afternoon near the
corner of Middleton and Amelia
streets about a block from the heart
Of the pity, resulted in the serious
wounding of Policeman F. G. Cannon
and John Lloyd. Both parties
are white and well known in this city.
The shooting took place about 6:45
p. m. A large crowd gathered at
once and the bodies of both men were
rushed to the Orangeburg hospital.
The cause of the shooting is not
known exactly, but it is reported
on the streets Mr. Cannon sought to
arrest Lloyd. When Mr. Cannon approached
him, he told Cannon not tc
put his hands on him, and drew his
pistol, it is alleged. About this time
Mr. Cannon grabbed his pistol and
both parties began shooting. It was
reported that .both participants were
shot six times but this couldn't be
verified. It seems that Mr. Cannon is
the more serious shot at this writing
and it can't be told now whether
either or both will recover. Mr. Cannon
was shot once in the chest while
Lloyd was shot in the'face and arpis.
Mr. Cannon is well known locally and
has a family and has served the city
efficiently as an officer. Llyod has
been in trouble before.
BLACKVILLE MAN IS SHOT.
y ^
Belton Fannftng Reported to be in
Serious Condition.
Blackville, Setp. 18.?Belton Fanning
a young man here, was shot and
nerhaDs fatally injured Saturday
about midnight, by his brother-inlaw,
A. V. Collum. Very little has
been learned about what caused the
shooting. It occurred in the lunch
room of Fortesque's, an ex-policeman
of Charleston, and who served as policeman
here recently.
Collum immediately went to Barnwell
and gave bond. He is the man
who shot and killed Frank Walker,
city marshal here, recently.
: : . . . . .V.:. ; \
ns Courl \ i
onday Monring J
. 0. Fining, F. B. Adams, R. A.
Easterling, H. L. Kearse, Paul Whitaker,
G. W. Freeman, J. B. Brickie, G,
Laurie Sandifer, W. H. Carroll, A. P,
Freeman, R. R. Kearse.
The following extra jurors were
drawn Morfday morning from the five
mile box: H. L. Kearse, W. D Rhoad,
Jr., J. E. Zeigler, C. E. Priester, Sidney
Hutto, C. W: Rentz, Jr., W. A.
Dickinson, J. L. Wilkinson.
The grand jury found true bills in
the following cases:
Curtis Hutto, murder.
John Dowling, rape.
Nathan Washington, murder.
Carrie Stevens, alias Whitmorer
murder. . ' ?^9
Frank Johnson, murder. i
Mincer Moye, assault and battery
with intent to kill, carrying conceal- \ S -M
ed weapon. V ^3
Lalla Esther Washington, housebreaking
and larceny. * _,
Seabrook Brown, housebreaking
and larceny. >
B. B. Williams, two cases, drawing
checks without funds.1
Sheppard Sheldon, housebreakings '
1 and larceny. \ 7
'B. D. Donald, violation of prohibition
law.
Monnie Kelley, Jeremiah Henderson
and Clinton Stone, housebreaking
and larceny.
Judge Johnson, obtaining goods'
under false pretence. *
Peter Murray, violation of the pro- v fi
hibition law. .
John Fewell, violation of the prohibition
law. .
TTTilljA. nMlliomo Trlnlotfon ftf t.hft
??line TI luiaiun, ..v.*.*..'..
. prohibition law.
Fred Carter, /wo cases, burglary
and larceny.
Isahc Way, rape.
H. G. Delk, drawing check without
funds.
John Busby, violation of prohibition
law.
Seabrook 'Brown, who is a young j
negro boy, pleaded guilty to housebreaking
and larceny, and was sentenced
to serve eighteen months on
the chain gang. Judge Dide first
sentenced him to the reformatory, but
later changed it to the chain gang,
with instructions to give him such,
light work as he can perform.
FORD PLANT CLOSES DOWN.
About 80,000 Men Thrown Out of
Employment.
Detroit, ,Sept. 16.?'Henry Ford's
industrial strike against what he
charges as excessive coal prices was
in full swing tonight and approximately
73,000 of his workmen in the
Detroit district were out of jobs for
an indefinite period. Thousands of
others in assembling plants throughout
the country alse were erdered to
lay down their tools. I,n.addition, a *
1 score oi? more of small industrial *
concerns here dependent upon the
Ford Motor Company for orders were
^preparing to close. These employ
' uDwards of 30,000 men.
The Highland Park and River
1 Rouge plants of the Ford Motor Com1
pany, employing about 60,000 men
! were deserted tonight save for a com
parative small force that will be retained
to keep cook ovens warm.
Although many of them were smil!iing,
the majority of the Ford works
ers who passed through the gates of
the Highland Park plant after turning
in their tools today, expressed
' concern over the shutdown. Their
foreman had handed down to them
advice from Mr. Ford to buy as little
coal as possible and cut their living"
expenses to a minimum. Many of
1 the workers were met by wives and
children, eager to learn how long the
hea'ds of families would be unem- x
ployed.
Jogging His Memory.
j It was a thrilling story that Mc- *
| Gregor had to telfc
! "I had abandoned all hope," he
! said. "As I sunk for thetthird time
i my past life seemed to rise before me
! in a - series of grim, realistic pici
tures." >
iA murmur of sympathy rolled
from the lips of listening friends;
hut in?t as McGregor was preparing
. to resume, McTavish interrupted him.
I sharply and hopefully.
.! "And did you happen to notice,"
he asked, "a picture of me lending
you a fiver in the autumn of 1919 V*
The Continent (Chicago).