The Bamberg herald. (Bamberg, S.C.) 1891-1972, January 26, 1911, Page 4, Image 4
?tjr Bamberg ^eralb
ESTABLISHED APRIL. 1891.
A. W. KNIGHT. Editor.
Published every Thursday in The
Herald building, on Main street, in
the live and growing City of Bamberg,
being issued from a printing
office which is equipped with Mergenthaler
linotype machine, cylinder
press, folder, two jobbers, all run by
electric power, with other material
and machinery in keeping, the whole
equipment representing an invest
- .
ment of $10,000 ana upwards.
Subscriptions?By the year, $1.00,
or 10 cents a month for less than
one year. All subscriptions payable
strictly in advance.
Advertisements?$1.00 per inch
for first insertion, subsequent insertions
50 cents per inch. Legal advertisements
at the rates allowed by
law. Local reading notices 10 cents
a line each insertion. Wants and
other advertisements under special
head, 1 cent a word each insertion.
Liberal contracts made for three, six,
and twelve months. Write for rates.
Obituaries, tributes of respect, reso~
^ J -ii
lutions, cards or manas, anu ai> uv;
. *. tices of a personal or political character
are charged for as regular advertising.
Contracts for advertising
not subject to cancellation after first
t insertion.
Communications?We are always
glad to publish news letters of those
pertaining to matters of public interest.
We require the name and address
of the writer in every case.
No article which is defamatory or
'offensively personal can find place in
our columns at any price, and we are
not responsible for the opinions expressed
in any communication.
Thursday, Jan. 26,1911.
The State's temperate and fair discussion
of the inaugural address of
Mr. Blease is to be commended.
Is Governor Blease going to devote
himself to the task of reforming
Al? on/1 fho ministrv?
lUV lie v\ syayci o uuu nuv ? .
Well, the newspapers are in
mighty good company anyway, even
if they are under the ban of his excellency.
Too bad that new daily paper
"which is to be started in Columbia
. could not be issued in time to publish
Governor Blease's inaugutal address.
Governor Blease talks about economy
in public affairs and high taxes.
This is all right as far as it goes,
fe but the governor failed to mention
but one excessive appropriation?
that of the colleges. If he will specify
where taxes can be reduced his
jpr. -words would have some weight, but
thA neonle expect him to point a
!> > remedy and not merely criticise.
!In another column we publish Mr.
A. W. Brabham's letter to the Walterboro
Press and Standard, in which
he advises the people of Warren
township to stay out of Bamberg
county. Mr. Brabham says he paid
$20.00 taxes this year on 100 acres
of land. Wonder how much he
tfould take for this tract, or at least
what he values it at in case it was
v to be sold?
From the report of Solicitor Byrnes
we gather the facts that Bamberg
county only, had twelve criminal
cases last year, which is commented
*\n hv tho vnrimiR nanprs of the sec
ond circuit as being the best record
of any county. Crime cost us little
last year, and ff the absence of the
dispensary caused this better state
of affairs, we are willing to give the
credit where it belongs. Now if this
shipping of whiskey here from Augusta
and Jacksonville could be
stopped, we would be still better
pleased.
We all know that some mighty
fine boys grow up in Bamberg, and
the sad part of it is that too many
of them go away to make a living
and a consquent rise in the world. It
might as well be admitted that
there does not seem to be much fu- 1
ture for an ambitious young man in
Bamberg, and the trouble rests with
those who control the destinies of
the town. How many of the young
|;3;> : men in this town are getting a salary
which will warrant them in devoting
their life to the work they are doing,
and what chances are there for promotion
for young men in the various
v.. A ,
lines of business nere: minK over
these things for a little while, please,
and you will see that our business
men are holding down the young
men o? this community, and it is no
wonder that they go elsewhere in
order that they may do better. If
we want to keep the young men of
'Bamberg at home and encourage
them to do their part in the growth
of Bamberg, we must recognize
their ability and trust and pay them
accordingly. We do not like to make
personal allusions, but nevertheless
it is true that this newspaper is paying
more salary to its foreman, a
Bamberg boy, than nine-tenths of
the business houses of the town pay
to men who occupy positions of more
responsibility. Merit should be recarifi
thft bovs and voune
men of to-day are those who will
control the future of Bamberg. Keep
them at home and recognize their
merit.
GETTING RIGHT.
We cheerfully give our friend,
Mr. A. W. Brabham, some more
space this week. We note with much
pleasure that he has at last seen his
error in stating that taxes are six
times higher in Bamberg than in Colleton
this year, but, we say to him
in all kindness, that he should have
investigated this matter thoroughly
before making such a statement,
which did his county harm. He seems
to have been talking about taxes
paid in Colleton several years ago
and comparing them with the present
rate in Bamberg. Therefore we said
he was mistaken, which we knew
was the case, for the report of the
comptroller general for the past year
gives Colleton a higher levy than
P q rr? Knrty
Taxes are higher this year in
every county which voted out the
dispensary, and they are higher all
over the State, in fact they have
been increasing for several years.
While the levy has not increased in
some instances, the valuation of
property has been raised. Horses
and mules which cost $100 a few
years ago now cost $200 and more,
therefore they are returned higher
for taxation. Real estate has doubled
in valuation, both city and country
property, therefore the valuation has
been raised, and it makes taxes
higer. Farming lands which could
be bought for $10.00 an acre in
Bamberg a few years ago cannot
now be bought for $30 or $40 an
acre, and, as is well known, this increase
in values has been general,
except possibly in some counties like
Colleton where there is a large area
of low land, uncultivated and unimproved,
only good for pasturage, and
of course in a case like this there
a
has been no increase in values.
Mr. Brabham has been a reader
of The Herald for many years, and
he will no doubt remember that for
all this time we have persistently
begged our legislators to reduce appropriations
for State and county
purposes. New offices have been
created by the legislature, salaries
of county officers increased, and in
fact the appropriation bill of the general
assembly has been larger each
year for the past ten years. This Is
the reason for higher taxes. True,
the yearly expenses of Bamberg
county have gone from $12,000 to
$17,000 or more, but we are not
prepared to say there is any corruption
or extravagance in our county
affairs. We understand that the ex
penses for last year were less than
the year before, and we are glad to
hear it. But there seems to be a
general tendency to extravagance in
public affairs, and our present Senator
has been voting against these
excessive appropriations in the general
assembly for years. But we believe
Bamberg county is as economi
- * x? i_ xl
cany managed as any county in uie
State, and it is for this reason that
our tax rate is no higher than it is.
But we are with Mr. Brabham in a
fight for lower taxes, and we agree
with him that the burden is too
heavy, but high taxes are not confined
to Bamberg. It is a general
condition all over the State, and the
main reason for it is the excessive
appropriations and new offices and
new expenses created by the general
assembly.
Only one thing more, and then we
can drop this discussion of taxes in
Bamberg and Colleton. Will not
Mr. Brabham now write a letter to
the Press and Standard and say that
he has not paid taxes in Colleton in
several years, and that he was comparing
what he paid then in Colleton
to what he pays now in Bamberg?
All we want is the matter set
before the people in all its bearings.
We don't want to throw any dust in
the eys of the people of Warren
township. Let them have all the
information possible, but let it be
correct. There is no fairness in
comparing taxes in Colleton several
years ago with this year in Bamberg.
Take the year 1910 for Colleton and
Bamberg and see if there is any difference.
That is the only fair way,
for the people of Warren township
are not concerned in what was done
years ago. They are interested in
what is being done now and what is
likely to be the case in the future.
Frankly, Mr. Brabham has not been
exactly fair to his own county in
his comparison, but if he will now
explain to those good people, why it
will be all right. We'll drop this
discusion and do all we can to aid
Mr. Brabham in bringing about lower
taxes for Bamberg county.
The Orangeburg Times and Democrat,
in a long editorial explains what
was meant in the paragraph referring
to the Jones case, and it says
in effect that the verdict was a proper
one. We hardly thought our usually
level-headed contemporary
meant to condone the conviction of
Jones, and we are glad that the verdict
meets with its approval. Fact
of the matter is, from the evidence^
the case came very close to being
downright murder, and Mr. Jones
should and no doubt does feel that
he got off mighty light.
The members of the dispensary
winding-up commission say they will
welcome an investigation.
I
TAXES TOO HIGH.
Something is Wrong Somewhere,
Says Mr. Brabham.
Editor The Bamberg Herald:?I
have read with much interest your
reply to my article on high taxes.
You contend that taxes are as high
in Colleton and Barnwell as in Bamberg.
Not having paid in Colleton
for four or five years, what you say
I do not gainsay or dispute, for you
should know. Now, I must infer
that the whole State is paying high
er taxes than ever known, and you
say the voting out of the dispensary
is the cause in all counties where
it was voted out, of higher taxes.
Granted, but there must be something
radically wrong somewhere,
and I am in the field to fight to a
finish to know where the trouble
comes in.
High and burdensome taxes
brought out Wade Hampton, and
taxes were not as high during Radical
times as they now are. \ve all
know that Hampton entered upon his
duties with the State bankrupt, no
means to carry on the ship of State,
yet the entire government was carried
on in such a business-like manner
that no one felt the small amount
demanded to carry on the affairs of
State, yet no State institution suffered
for money. For years the State
went on with a lower rate of taxes
than almost any State in the Union,
and no one missed the money paid
for taxes.
For several years Barnwell county,
including what is now Bamberg
county, did not get a cent revenue
from the sale of whiskey for we
had prohibition then as now, and
there was no increase in taxes. If
we could carry on the county's affairs
at one time without the aid of whiskey
money and no raise in taxes,
surely we can do the same thing
now.
I know there is something wrong
somewhere and somehow, and I
shall, as time permits, ascertain
where the trouble lies.
I cannot pass what you say about
not seeing my name connected with
anything that helps or has aided the
county, but that I am trying to tear
it down. .1 ; i
I have never entered politics, because
I abhor them. I have led a
quiet life on my farm, and if you
will nardon this little piece of self
upraise, few farmers in South Carolina
have ever made a name as farreaching
as I have done. Years of
study and toil with nature enabled
me to give to the world, or the South
at least, the greatest forage plant
known to man to-day. Farmers from
Maryland to the Canal Zone, are
sending me letters of praise which
are too flattering for the public eye.
And the highest authority on fine
cotton, living, says the day is near
at hand when my breeding of cotton
is going to revolutionize the cotton
world.
The department of agriculture for
V> n n rvoi'd mo fnr oooH nf
S1A y ^(11D IDCIO paiu uiu JLvi wvvu vfc
my own breeding the highest price
ever known for the same class of
seed. Their expert breeders, under
my directions, are making experiments,
and I am the only farmer in
Bamberg county who has ever had
an official visit from one of Uncle
Sam's most expert scientists.
"Done nothing for Bamberg county!"
Ask many poor people around
me, when last fall, with no crops and
no means to supply the wants -of ap|
proaching winter, what I did. Many
families here owe it to me and my
methods of business the money they
spent on themselves and their families.
Out of these poor people I
could have made a nice sum for myself
,but had I done so my conscience
would have gnawed a hole
in my nearc.
"Done nothing for Bamberg county!"
Years ago I favored long cotton
for the uplands. Everybody deemed
me crazy. I lost money on the
venture, but I held on somehow, and
now, to-day, thank God! I am proud
of my humble part. Upland long
cotton is here to stay.
"Done nothing for Bamberg counj
ty!" Ask the bankers in the lower
part of the county how I aid and assist
my fellow-man each year when
they (the people, not the bankers)
need help. Ask the unfortunate
who apply to me as such if I do not
"treat each son of Adam as a brother
of the dust!"
A. W. BRABHAM,
Olar, S. C., January 21, 1911.
When a newspaper speaks it is the
voice and thought of an individual,
and therefore the writer of an editorial
is very careful in what he says.
In the first place he tries to be ab
solutely sure of facts and in the second
place-that his remarks are worth
making and they are always meant
to bring about good in the county.
?
South Carolina could not do a better
thing than spend a little money
in co-operating with the railroads in
bringing good people from the West
to occupy our idle lands. Thousands
of them are ready to come if they
only knew where to come. The State
is the proper party to furnish this
information, and it should do it.
- " v: -_.W. / * ~. ,
"STAY OUT OF BAMBERG."
Mr. Brabham's Advice to People of
Warren Township.
Editor Press and Standard: ?
Please allow me once more to warn
the Warren township people to stay
out of Bamberg county. When I
paid taxes in Barnwell county, it
cost me $4.00 on 100 acres of land.
On the same land now in Bamberg
county I am paying $20.00 for 100
acres, or five times as much.
Warren township contains 100
square miles equal to 64,000 acres
and would pay $12,800.00.
If everybody in Bamberg county
nn tr? ap taiiaIi nn T A A 4^ a lonrl to vac
i'aJ,0 0-0 iUUV/U M A uu luc iauu laaoa
alone would amount to $51,200.00.
Let each and every farmer in Warren
township count what he now
pays to Colleton, then figure $20.00
for each hundred acres of land he
owns, and see what the move would
cost him. For a year or two, I own,
the Bamberg people would be very
easy on the Warren people, charging
even less than they now pay, but in
a few years they would find the
Bamberg people "a relentless foe,
with no pity for its victims."
Friend Knight of The Bamberg
Herald said I was mistaken in my
first letter. I was not mistaken then,
and am not mistaken now. I have
kinpcople in Warren township and
some good friends there, and'I know
that they know I would not misrepresent
facts in a newspaper.
Every day some tax payer is complaining
to me, they all say that
their taxes are out of all reason,
from 100 to 150 per cent, higher
than last year, and want to know if
any redress can be had. My answer
to each and all is, "God alone knows
where this extortion will stop, fiach
year sees the taxes higher, and we
cannot see where they are being
used. There is something 'rotten in
the State of Denmark,' and we must
kpp whp.rp it. is."
There are to-day more dissatisfied
taxpayers in Bamberg county than
any county in the State.
And I take this method to warn
ray Colleton friends to stay in Colleton.
The taxes are lighter there,
for I have paid taxes there, and God
knows I could not, and would not
lie when the records are behind me
?I cannot afford to He about any
matter. A. W BRABHAM.
Olar, January 11.
CONVICTS WHO MADE GOOD.
As a Railroad Man Once Notorious
Burglar Earns $12,000 a Year.
Two interesting things are shown
hv tho ror?nrda nn file with the Dardon
I clerlj at the State capitol. One is
that there are many men in the great
State of New York going through
life with sinister past known neither
to their^ wives nor children. The
other is that men sent to prison for
penal offenses can live down their
evil ways and become useful and respected
citizens.
Most remarkable cases of this kind
came to the attention of the officials
during the closing days of the administration
of Governor White.
Names are not made public. It has
[ always been the custom to shield
j from publicity such persons as sought
to have their citizenship restored, on
the theory that publication might do
them much harm by branding them
as convicts.
i
Scores of applications for restoration
were made to Governor White,
and quite a few of them were granted.
The most remarkable came from
a man who is now a prominent railway
man in the employ of the Pennsylvania
railroad. He earns a salary
of $12,000 a year and lives in fine
style with his family. His petition to
be restored to the full rights of citizenship
was endorsed by a lawyer of
prominence, who declared that he
and the petitioner himself were the
only living persons who knew that
"the petitioner was at one time a
burglar of considerable reputation."
In the papers it was explained that
the man served a term in prison for
burglary, but that after getting out
he resolved to "brace up and be a
man." He went to a part of the
country where he was not known
and studied engineering. None of
Ma aoanHatec nnH nr? member of his
family knew anything concerning
his dark past. Like practically all
others who seek citizenship years
j after being deprived of it, this man
grew tired of making excuses to his
wife and children for not voting.
Another case which attracted considerable
attention was that of a
Brooklyn business man who was sent
to prison for robbery in 1872. He
reformed, married, and now has a
family of grown-up children. His
sons last fall expressed surprise that
their father did not vote, and his
explanation was a lame one. To the
nfflniolo Viora Vi a cairl that hjjfl pl_
ViUViaiO UVA V UV WMAVfc VUMW MV aavwv* M?
ways feared to swear in his vote lest
some one who remembered the 1872
case would challenge him and expose
his dark secret, which has always
been kept from his wife and
chlidren. His application to be restored
to the rights of an American
citizen was granted, as was that of
the Pennsylvania railway man.?
New York Herald.
/ " ' . . <" '* " ... . } '''
HUNTING IN THE PHILIPPINES.
Sportsmen Shoot Where Ducks Have
Not Heard Sound of Gnn.
Not long ago, while stationed in
the Province of Albay, P. I., Capt.
Burt, 18th Infantry, and myself decided
to take a trip to Lake Bato, |
some forty miles inland. We packed
all our duffle into an army wagon,
and with four sturdy mules to draw
it started early one morning for our
long drive, arriving at the lake that
night. The next morning we hired
two cantamarans, threw our baggage
aboard and crossed the lake. Then
we made camp and cooked chow.
Can you imagine a lake fifteen
miles in diameter and literally covered
with fowl? The report of a gun
was unknown in the vicinity, and of
course the fowl were not gun shy. i
We took life easy until 2 o'clock the
following morning, when our guides
awakened us. Creeping out of our
blankets we got into our baucas, or
boats, and started down the lake
shore. About three o'clock we
reached a rushing stream some forty
feet wide, and I can safely swear
that each and every mosquito from
tip to tip measured the same. Wow!
We plunged into the marsh, sinking
to our knees in many places, and
waded some three miles. It was still
dark and I had visions of horrible
snakes and mammoth lizzards, in
which this country abounds. After
an hour of this "sort of travel we arrived
at the edge of a little mud
pond some hundred yards in diameter.
One of the guides motioned for
the captain to remain with him, and
my guide, beckoning to me to follow,
jumped into the water to his waist.
In I jumped. Ugh! I'll never forget
it as. long as I live; soft, slimy mud
for the bottom and now and then a
snake gliding silently along the water
in front of me.
We reached the other side and entered
a little inlet. Passing throughthis
we came out into another pond
exactly like the first. The guide took
me to a little clump of partly submerged
alders, and we waded in and
got among them as best we could.
I was sitting in mud and water up to
my waist. But the air was simply
alive with ducks, as we knew from
the whir of their wings.
Daylight came, and I shall never
forget the sight. Flock after flock
came dropping down into the pond.
I heard the captain's rifle and knew
the shooting was on. It seemed like
deliberate murder. Flocks of ducks
numbering 500 would fly within
twenty yards, and after being shot
at would circle and come right back.
At about 9 o'clock, gathering our
kill, we went Dack to tne nrst yuuu.
Between us we had ducks enough to
give the battalion a Thanksgiving
dinner. We shot them all with our
rifles.
Since leaving that station my field
of labor has been changed to Allindanao,
and while stationed on a hill
on the shores,of Lake Lanoa I have
been able to shoot wtild hogs by
moonlight from the guard house.
One night while returning from a
11 ?Ut. iU- 4,, +V,
small scrap WILU trie iuuius, m tut
Taraca valley, I shot several ducks,
feeding in the rice paddies, the full
tropical moon making it as light as
day. At my present station, Misamis,
I have good snipe shooting.
There are monkeys everywhere, but
they are too human to kill. If they are
wounded they cry and sob like small
children. The natives eat them and
use their hides to make drum heads.
For the big game we have the water
buffalo, which, if wounded, will
put up a pretty stiff fight, and in a
good many cases it is the hunter
hunted if he is not an excellent shot.
The woods are full of deer, but they
are very small, being about the size
of a hound or shepherd dog. They
are easily tamed and almost every
American in the province keeps one
or two tame deer.?Recreation.
BOOZE SHOPS PAID WELL.
Big Dividends on Aiken Dispensaries
for Last Quarter.
Aiken, Jan. 18.?The (report of the
Aiken county dispensaries for the
last quarter, which is the largest in
the year, was issued yesterday afternoon,
and shows the receipts from
the dispensaries to be tremendous.
The total net profits of the six dis-v
pensaries in this county amounted
to $27,026.10, $9,008.10 of which
went to the schools of the county;
county of Aiken for ordinary purposes,
$1,008.70; town- of north
Augusta, $1,210.68; town of Wagener,
$1,310.70; town of Salley, $1,870;
city of Aiken, $4617.32.
This is an unsually large amount
of revenue to come from the dispensaries,
which will help the city and
county wonderfully. It appears that
the dispensaries are well managed,
and in the dispensaries Aiken county
has a well paying institution.
The presidents of Converse college
and the Greenville Female college in
Greenville have had to appeal to the
police of their cities to protect the
young ladies from heing annoyed by
rude and impolite young men of the
town and the male colleges.
r
'jy ' '' ' r
:
CLOSET HAS SKELTON.
Startling Reports on North Carotin* ;
Withheld.
Washington, Jan. 19.?That Charles
Nagel, secretary of the department
of commerce and labor, has
suppressed much of the reports of
agents of the labor bureau because of
their revelations concerning the pri- ?
vate lives of people in North Carolina
and other Southern States was assert
ed in the senate to-day by Senator
Overman.
The statement was elicited in connection
with an inquiry from Sena- as
tor Beveridge as to the publication
of the results of the investigation into
the employment of women and
children, made a few years ago by ^ 3
the bureau of labor. %
Report Over I* ng. J/m
Responding, Senator Smoot, chairman
of the committee on printing,
sad that owing to the. extended '.-II
length of the report, publication
would necessarily be postponed until
the middle of the summer. . ~
Mr. Beveridge expressed impati- '
ence over the delay and, and while
he was engaged in colloquy with
the Utah senator, Mr. Bailey interrupted
with the observation that if
the information coming to his ears . ^1
was correct the report should never *
be published.
It was at this juncture that Mr.
Overman made his statement concerning
the course of Secretary Na- ..jl
Had to Suppress Them.
"I heard of the vile character of
some of these reports," he said,
"and went to Mr. Nagel about them.
He told me that the revelations were
such that he had felt called upon to
suppress them. It would seem that ^
some of the agents had gone into ;
the mountains and had taken it upon
themselves to investigate the private
affairs of the people when the law
authorized an inquiry only into labor
conditions." -"^38
"Just so," commented Mr. Bailey. 3
"Whenever we allow one of these
meddlesome officers to get their noses
into the front doors of the homes of
the people, they are liable to go far ther
than they should."
The inquiry in question was made
of o nt~ia+ nf 4 5 00 000
U V U wov V& y w v v I v v v ^ ^ 7^-jraQ
Bits of Philosophy.
Man shows his good behavior and , ;|p|
gets his good loo?s by the sunshine
ho scatters along the pathway of the
sorrowing; man approaches perfection
by giving peace and not pain. k
Troubles always grow if much ado
is made of them when coming, when
here or when gone; troubles are lim- y^jWI
ited in force and number by curtailing
the number of people we tell
them to.
Man's mind is modeled after Godfe /V ^
and made subject to his laws;
body is made to look as his mind "'SMM
thinks and is therefore subject unto
Man to be happy in his work, must
do the kind of work that does not
worry him; that man's soul doesn't
sing while his hands and head work, : ^
somebody or something in out of
tune.
Your excuse for your failure will
never make it anything else, than
what it is?failure; your excuse for ,
yesterday, lost, is>an abuse of to-day's
opportunity. , ,
Idleness must be the great curse,
if work be the greatest blessing of "v ?
life; there is nothing noble or divine
in the wasting of the golden
minutes which make up time.
When you return evil for evil you
must expect to get back for yourself ':
a fuller measure than you give; you
will get your own downfall when you .
attemp to taae a ian oui 01 your
enemy. 1
Flowery speech and saintly look
may cover up the show of error and
change the color of vice to that df
virtue; seeming truth is a sham that
good men will not believe in long.
PUBLIC NOTICE. ?
I positively forbid anybody huntor
trespassing in any way on my land, h
If any one should be caught doing
what is hereby forbidden, he will be
punished by the full extent of the
law. MRS. P. W. SANDIFER.
MASTERS' SALE.
Pursuant to a decree of the court
of common pleas made in the case
of Edward R. Fishburne et al., vs.
Claude C. Fishburne et al., dated November
23, 1910, I, H. C. Folk, Master,
will resell at the risk of the
former purchasers, at public auction,
in front of the court house at
Bamberg, S. C., during the legal
hours for sale, on February 6, 1911,
the same being sales day, the following
described land to wit: ?
All that tract of land, situated in
Bamberg county, S. C., containing
three hundred and sixty-five (365)
acres, more or less, and having the
following boundaries: On tbe Nortn 3
by Lemon Swamp; on the East by estate
of R. W. Sandifer, L. N. Bellinger
and W. H. Morris; on the
South by D. D. Utsey; and on the
hv lands of C. C. Fishburne,
Mrs. Eliza Fishbuirne, and estate of
E. H. Dowling. The said sale to be
for cash, and purchaser to pay for
papers. All bidders required to place
in the Master's hands a cash deposit
before bids will be considered.
Witness my hand and seal this
18 th day of January, 1911. *3$
H. C. FOLK, (L. S.) i*
Master for Bamberg County.
WYMAN & HENDERSON,
Plaintiffs' Attorneys. J?