The Barnwell people. (Barnwell, S.C.) 1884-1925, June 18, 1914, Image 3
/
KICKED IDEM OUT
. * ' . i
, >
rO NOTARIES PUBLIC IN SMALL
TOWN LOSE COMMISSIONS
ram AGAINST BtEASE
w
Goveraor Refuses to Give Reasons for
Action Saying Cause was Known—
Refuses to Answer Whether Vote
for Barnwell as Chairman Caused
His Displeasure.
The Charleston Post, of Saturday
printed the following self explanatory
correspondence:
McClellanville, S. C., June 4, 1914.
Editor Evening Post, Sir. Will you
please publish the enclosed corre
spondence between Goveruo’’ Cole L.
Blease, myself and others? I have
received no reply to my letter of May
6 requesting his reasons for my re
moval.
Yours truly,
H. T. Morrison.
Columbia, S. C. f May 14, 1914.
Mr. Henry T. Morrison, McClellan
ville, S. C.
Dear Sir: You are hereby notified
that the commission issued to you as
notary public for the State of South
Carolina, during the pleasure of the
governor, has this day been revoked,
and any further act or acts performed
you as such officer will be illegal
nd in violation of law.
Copy of this letter has been filed
with the secretary .of State and with
clerk of court of your county, who
ha.ve been requested to cancel the
record of said^commlssion upon their
books. Very respectiirMy,'
Cole L. Blease, Governor.'
, Copy to secretary of state, clerk of
court. Charleston county:
You will please be governed in ac
cordance with the above.
WILL SEND DELEGATES
CARRANZA SAYS HE HAS AN-
SWERED MEDIATORS’ NOTE.
McClellanville, S. C., May- 18. 1914.
Governor Cole L. Blease, Columbia,
S. C.
Bear Sir: Your fetter of May 14 re
voking my commission as notary pub
lic received. I was of course sur
prised at same. While I admit your
legal right to revoke my commission,
I think it due me as well as yourself
to give your reasons for taking this
step. Hoping to hear from you at
your convenience, I remain,
Yours truly,
H. T. Morrison.
(Copy.)
Columbia, May 19, 1914.
Mr. Henry T. Morrison, McClellan
ville, S. C.
Dear Sir: Your letter of May 18
has been received.
If you will notice section 73, Vol.
1, Code of Laws of S. C., 1912., you
will see that the governor is author
ized to appoint as many notaries pub
lic throughout the State as the pub
lic good shall require, to hold their
offices during the pleasure of the gov
ernor. You were commissioned un
der this law; and, it was the pleas
ure of the governor to revoke your
commission, and it was done. I ex
pect you know why it was done about
as well as he does.
Very respectfully,
Cole L. Blease, Bovernor.
Although Conditions Are Not Named
Constitutionalist Chief Says He
Will be Represented.
■r—^ • —
Gen. Carranza announced Thurs
day night that he had returned an
answer to the note of the Niagara
Falls mediators stating that he would
appoint representatives to the con
ference at Niagara Falls.
The names of the representatives,
were not made pub)ic. The note gave
simply the assurance that the Con
stitutionalists would be repre?ented
and did not mention conditions on
which the Constitutionalists would
take part. It was announced, how
ever, that the agreement to attend
the conferences would not serve to
check the campaign now being waged
against the Federals.
The Federajs attempted Thursday
to escape from Mazatlan through .he
Constitutionalist forces, but were
driven back with heavy loss. Two
thousand citizens of Maxatlan, who
were destitute and without food,
came into the Constitutionalist camp
and were fed by Iturbe, although the
latter had to take the food from his
own soldiers to do so. Gen. Carran
za has sent 100,000 pesos to purchase
food for these people.
Fighting Thursday between the
rebels and Federals continued at Zac
atecas when Gen. Natera began an
assault with his 12,000 Constitution
alist troops. Gen. Natera has drawn
a clese line around the town and is
determined that he will not allow the
Federal garrison under Medina Dar-
ron to escape. No details of the cas
ualties of the present battle have
been received:
Gen. Carr:.nza has issued an order
to obviate the confusion caused by
refusal of persons in some States to
accept as legal tender money issued
In other States. The order provides
that money issued in any State must
be accepted ii every other State un
der Constitutionalist control.
Gen. Villareal, governor of Nuevo
Leon, has issued an order in Mon
terey that no one shall be allowed to
hold corn for high prices or store it,
and also that no price greater than
five cents a liter shall be charged for
It. It is believed this order will hhve
the effect of relieving the food scarc
ity in that State.
A statement that the family of
Gustav Bauch, killed in Chihuahua,
would receive |25,0d0 from the Con
stitutionalists was denied by officials.
The commission headed by Gen.
Fraustro appointed to investigate the
Benton and Bauch cases, will go im
mediately to Chihuahua and Juarez
to take evidence and has been in
structed to expedite the examination.
Killed by Son-In-Law.
R. H. McDaniel, a well-to-do farm
er of Forsythe, Ga., was shot and
killed early Friday morning by Thos.
Meek, his son-in-law, in a quarrel
over domestic affairs.
Aproprlates Money to Aid Survivors.
The Canadian government has ap
propriated $50,000 to aid the survi
vors of the Empress of Ireland disas
ter. Also $10,000 for the inquiry
about to be held.
McClellanville, S. C.. May 25, 1914.
Governor Cole L. Blease, Columbia,
S. C.-
Dear Si»: Your letter of May 19
received, in which you recite the law
giving you the power, as governor, to
revoke my commission as notary pub
lic. This far I admit that you are
entirely within your rights, but you
failed to give your reasons for so do
ing, closing your letter with these
words: “I expect you know why it
was done as well- as he (the gov
ernor) does.” I anl not asking you
Jor a. reappointment, nor will I accept
one from you, but I do request that
you give me your reasons for my re-
-mnval. Was it because, as a dele-
gate to the Charleston county con
vention, I voted for J. W. Barnwell
as chairman? Has any one from this
place written you- or the attorney
general requesting my removal? Or
was It for misconduct in office?
Hoping you will favor me with an
early reply, I am,
Your respectfully,
H. T. Morrison.
Spends Much Time in Prison.
Annie Alexander of Pittsburg, Pa.,
who has spent 26 of her thirty-six
years in prison was convicted Tues
day of another theft and received a
new sentence.
Four Killed in Auto Accident.
Four men were killed at Goldfield,
Nev., in an automobile accident Tues
day afternoon.
ning Co.—their removal has serious
ly inconvenienced the community at
large as well as thfeiUSelves. We, the
citizens of McClellanville, feel that
you must have been misinformed as
to the standing of these two gentle-
men. as we do not think you would
have taken this step without feeling
you had just cause.
We think it, therefore, due to your
self as well as the gentlemen, that
you give us your reasons for their re
moval.
An early reply will be much ap-
p reclamed.
OIVEN TO rilBlIC
MEDIATORS GIVE OUT CORRES
PONDENCE WITH CARRANZA. .
■w
WAITED WEEK FOR REPLY
Hawing Received No Answer They
Publish First Letter of Invitation
to Rebel Chief, His Reply Object
ing to Mediation Without His Be
ing Represented, and Answer.
The. correspondence made public
Thursday between the Argentine,
Brazil and Chile mediators and the
Mexican Constitutionalists is compos
ed of only three letters. The first,
dated Washington, May 3, Is the tele
gram in which the mediators with
drew their invitation for C.arranza to
send a representative to the media
tion because he refused to declare an
armistice. Its text was published at
the time. - .
TH3 second communication, dated
May 28, was signed by Rafael Zuba-
ran, special representative in Wash
ington of Gen. Carranza. This letter
said Carranza considered that the
conflict in Mexico should not be the
subject of negotiations at the media
tion conferences in the absence of
representatives of the first chiet of
the Constitutionalist army.
The mediators replied to this note
on June 2, commenting on the fore
going portion of Mr. Zubaran's note
by asking if they were authorized to
Interpret the suggestion as an expres
sion on the part of Gen. Carranza of
an adhesion to the terms set forth in
.the telegraphic communication of
May 3. These terms were a declara-
tlon of an armistice and a-readiness
to discuss all questions Internal and
international. This letter concfhdes
as follows: * *..
“If this were so we would take the
liberty of suggesting through you to
the first chief of the Constitutionalist
army that he hasten the appointment
of his representatives to the confer
ence In which we are now engaged.”
To this answer nothing has been re
ceived and the mediators have fre
quently said that they considered It
beneath their dignity to wait any
longer^ for Gen. Carranza to define
his attitude, having given him more
than a week.
The first of the three communica
tions that comprise the correspon
dence Is the telegram ■ scot by the
mediators on May 3 to Gen. Carranza,
then at Chihuahua, withdrawing their
invitation to ths Constitutionalist
chief to send delegates because of his
refusal to declare an armistice. It
follows:
“We have received your courteous
telegraphic message of yesterday In
which you inform us that you deem
It Inadvisable for the Constitutional
ist cause to suspend hostilities
against Gen. Huerta because such sus
pension would benefit the latter only
and in which you state that the in
ternational conflict between Mexico
and the United States, for the solu
tion of which you accepted our good
offices, is independent of the inter
nal strife In that country.
‘*We consider this unexpected dec
laration incompatible with the pur
pose which prompted our tender of
good offices. We believe as a matter
of fact that all difficulties which have
contributed to bring about the pres
ent situation of Mexico directly or
indirectly affect the solution of the
conflict pending between Mexico and
the United States and consequently
we understand 14 that they must be
made the subject matter of consider
ation in the settlement negotations
for the full success of which we have
deemed the suspension of hostilities
to be indispensable.
^f you should not so understand,
we would-be compelled to withdraw
as inofficious our invitation to appoint
representatives of the constitution
alist party to attend the negotations.
We greet you with all our considera-
tlon.”
No reply to this telegram was
made by Gen. Carranza, but on May
28 he protested through Rafel Zub-
aran.hls Washington representative,
against the Mexican conflict being
made the subject of negotiations in
the absence of representatives of the
tlnent, accepted the tender In prin
ciple,. and, owing to the complicated
character of the situation In Mexico,
he deemed It necessary to request
your excellencies to define the scope
of the proposed mediation to the end
that he may appoint duly authorized
representative!.
“Without having received a speci
fic reply to this inquiry, the chief of
the constitutionalist government was
notified If hostilities against Huerta
sere not suspended—which proposed
suspension he deemed to lie Inconsis
tent with his duties to the people of
Mexico—your excellencies would be
compelled to withdraw the Invitation
to him to^ippoint representatives.
“He is now informed that the
mediation conferences have been tak
ing place for some time with repre-
scntetlves of the Huerta government
participating in the deliberations, and
he regrets that efforts should have
been made and continue to be made
to solve the conflict between the Unit
ed States and Mexico without taking
into consideration the fact that the
constitutionalist cause, which he rep
resents, has the support of a major
ity of the inhabitants of Mexico and
has the largest armed forces within
the republic, and that the forces, act
ing under his command, have been
able to recover from the power of
Huerta, since the first action of med
iation, the cities of Monterey, Tam
pico and Satlllo with the adjoining
territory and the territory of Tepic.
“Under these circumstances, the
chief of the constitutionalist govern
ment finds himself compelled to state
to your excellencies with all the re
spect and consideration due your
high offices that he considers that
said conict should not be^made the
sugject of negotations at the media
tion conferences in the absence of re
presentatives of the first chief of the
constitutionalist army.
“The undersigned avails himself of
this opportunity to express to your
excellencies, the plenipotentaries of
time, the
surances of his most distinguished
consideration.”
The mediators on June 2 replied
to the foregoing communication as
follows: “We haye had the pleasure
of receiving your courteous commu
nication of the 28th of May, last,
which we have noted very carefully.
“We must in the first place ac
knowledge the recognition by the
Arts chelf of the constitutionalist
army of the wishes and sympathies
which prom ted the tender of our
good offices towards the settlement
of the ronfllct pending between Mex
ico and the United States, a tender
inspired by the declared purpose of
further ing the interests of peace
and civilization on your continent
and the earnest desire of avoiding
frrther bloodshed to the Impairment
of the cordiality and union which
have alwayc gaverned the develop
ment of the relations of the govern
ments and peoples of America.*
“In carrying out these purposes,
we could not but welcome the advent
to onr confercences of representa
tives of all parties Interested, provid
ed they agree to submit to the consi
deration and counsel of the medltion
and differences which now divide
them, In order that a peaceful settle
ment thereof may be sought In an
atmosphere of tranquility and concil
iation.
“Hence It would be a source of
great satisfaction to us to know that
we are authorized to Interpret the
suggestion in the last paragraph of
one of your communications as an
expreslon on the part of the first chief
of the contstitutionallst army of that
spirit of compromise which In our
judgments should prevail at the con
ferences of the mediation, and as an
adhesion to the terms set forth in
our last telegraphic communiciation
of the 3rd of May, last.
“If this were so, we would take the
liberty of suggestiong through you ti
the first chief of he constitutionalist
army that he hasten, the appointment
of his representatives to the confer
ences in which we are now engaged,
“We avail ourselves of this oppor
tunity to extend to you the assur
ances of our distinguished considera
tion.”
It was because more than a week
had elapsed without an answer being
iceived that the correspondence was
made public.
FIRST TEST VOTE IN FREE TOLLS
FIGHT
60ME8
GANGS ROB AND PlUAGE
PIRATES PLY THEIR TRADE
SAN • FRANCISCO RAT
IN SENATE.
ESTIMATE TEN MAJORITY
Adoption of the Simmons-NorrUi
Amendment Which Passes 50 to
34 is First Test—Asserts Claim of
United States to All Rights Which
She May Have.
The Senate Wednesday night clear
ed away most of the legislative bar
riers In the way of a finaT vote ’bn
the canal tolls exemption repeal bill.
Votes taken on amendments design
ed to preserve any right the United
States possesses under the Hay-
Pauncefote treaty with Great Britain
to exempt American ships from toll
payment through the Panama Can
al indicated that the forces of repeal
will win by a substantial majority.
Senator Simmons, who led the
fight for repeal, has estimated that
the bill will carry by not less than
ten votes, and there was every pro
mise that his estimate will prove cor
rect.
There was no real test of strength
In the voting, but the repeal forces
won the first round of the fight when
they put through, by a vote of 50 to
24, the so called Simmons-Norris-a
mendment which declares the Unit
ed States does not waive or relin
quish any right to exempt Ameri
can ships from payment of tolls.
Although two subsequent attempts
to change the language of the amend
ment so that It would refer to a right
UuiUd States haa r instead, of anj
right it may have, were defeated,
neither vote was so decisive as that on
the Simmons amendment. One mod
ifying amendment by Senator Suth
erland was beaten, 49 to 33, and the
second proposed by Senator Cummins
suffered a like fate, 49 to 3 7.
There were several expressions
during the debate of a desire to sub
mit the dispute with Great Britain to
arbitration after the repeal bill Is
passed. It has been reported in the
Senate for several days that an arbl^
tration resolution will be pressed af
ter the passage of the bill. A so
rlous attempt to put through arbi
tration resolutions may be opposed
by Democratic leaden who are anx
ious to take up pending anti-trust
legislation.
The first vote came when the Sen
ate wap not looking for it and found
21 senators absent from the chamber
or out of town. The Senate adopted
the Simmons- i Norris amendment qual
ifying the canal exemption toll bill
by a vote of 50 to 24.
This waa the fint test vote after
six weeks of debate on the repeal bill.
The most optimistic senators who
favored repeal had not expected the
amendment to carry by so large a
majority. It is not believed, how
ever, the hill itself can be put
through by so great a margin.
Nine Democrat!# senators voted
^against the amendment. Several of
these, however, are expected to vote
for the repeal bill, while several Re
publicans who supported the amend
ment are expected to line up against
the bill. The Slmmons-Norrls amend
ment would provide that the passage
of the repeal shall not be construed
or held as a waiver or relinquish
ment of any rights the United States
may have under the Hay-Pauncefote
treaty with.Great Britain.
The vote on the Slmmons-Norrls
amendment was:
Ayes — Democrats, Bankhead,
Bryan, Chilton, Culberson, Fletcher,
Hitchcock, Hollis, Hughes, James,
Johnson, Kern, Lane, Lea, Lee,
Lewis, Martin, Myers, Newlands,
Overman, Owen, Pittman, Saulsbury,
Shafroth, Sheppard, Shively, Sim
mons, Smith (Arizona), Smith
Georgia), Smith (Maryland), Smith
(South Carolina), Stone, Swanson,
Thomas, Thompson, West, White—
Hindoos, Chinese, Pariah Whiles an#
Nondescripts Mingle Freely HnnnA
by Common Tie of Piracy.
The pirates of the San Joaquin,
long accepted as a traditten of thn
Pacific coast, for years have held un
disputed sway between salt water
and the fertile region of Califorttla’s <
great Inland delta district Hern;
are found the fertile river islaada,
100 in number, varying in size from
a sm^ll blot upon the surface of the
water to others many acres in extent. .'
It Is on these.Islands that the pirate
gangs make their abode, Hindoos,
Chinese, pariah whites and nonde
scripts of all classes mingling freely
in their various rendezvous and join
ed by the common tie of piracy which
unites them against all established
Institutions of the law. > t
For years property owners and of
ficers of the law have guarded
against these pirates. Scores of bat
tles have been fought. Many arrests
have been made and eases tried on
slim evidence. However, the pirates
are still as numerous and trouble
some as ever and just as daring.
From the many small islands in
the district where San Francisco bay
narrows the Charqulnez strait* and
the latter in turn, splits into two
great tributary rivers, the Sacramen
to and the San Joaquin, the pirates
operate in various gangs in the dead
of the night.
For the most part they travel t»
launches and scows,' without lights
and as quietly as possible. Pollsg
along In the shadows, they swoop
down upon the vegetable and mer-
ctranTHsr whlrrmettty- IHed along th<
levees awaiting transportation In tho ..
early morning on the river steamers
and transfer them to the bargee and
scows lying in mid-channel. '
Sacks of potatoes, beans, garde*
truck and other tide-land prodnes
stacked for transportation are spirit
ed away before dawn on the plrats
scows and disposed of by fences or
agents In Sacramento, Stockton and
San Francisco.
Owners, incensed st the contfnaed
depredations, have frequently stood
guard at night with shotguns sad
rifles. The authorities have started
investigations, working without el«*
or evidence, and accomplishing netfc-
ing but futile cruising up and down,
the various channels where ths pi
rates were known to be. Arrests,
have been few and convictions fewer,
although battles between ■hsrila''
posses and tbs pirate gang, contain
ing yeggs and ex-convicts, who find
water piracy an easy way of gaining
a livelihood, are not infrequent.
Gambling scows are an objection
able feature of the pirate settlement.
Frequent raids have been made dar
ing brawls on these scows but Inva
riably the polyplot gangs get warn
ing just In time to escape sad evade .,
arrest.
OPIUM SMUGGLERS ACTIVE.
I
McClellanville, S. C., May 19, 1914.
Hon. Cole L. Blease, Governor, Co
lumbia, S. C.
"“ Dear Sir: At a meeting of the
prominent citizens of McClellanville
May 18, 1914, the undersigned were
appointed as a committee to address
following communication to your
’honor, with reference to the bevoking
of the commission as notary public
of Mr. H. T. Morrison and D. M. Mac
intosh, these gentlemen being among
the leading and business men of the
town, the former being president of
McClellanville board <** trade.
♦ Via* -d . ^
■ .iPffcuftfcrr
State Farmers’ unfon,' president Sea
Island Cotton Growers' association,
and president McClellanville Anto Co.
and the latter manager McClellanville
Merc. Co.; president D. M. Mackin
tosh A Co., president Democratic dub
of McCMlaavtlin, secretary and
trsaaurer Ban Ihors Milling A Gin-
(Copy.)
Yours very truly,
J. B. Morrison, Jr.,
J. T. Hills.
S. A. Wrenn,
Committee.
^Columbia, May 2^, 1914.
Messrs. J. B. Morrison Jr., Jno. T.
Hills, S. A. Wrenn, McClellanville,
S. C.'
Gentlemen: Your letter of May 19
has been received.
Section 732, code of lawn; l'912r
provides:
‘The governor Is authorized to ap
point as many notaries public
throughout the State as the public
ahall-require.-to hold.Lheir. of-
pleasure of the gov
ernor, and wbose'"'JurlsUlcf 1OT Ififfll
ertend throughout the State.”
Ederdslng my pleasure, as gover
nor, the commissions of the gentle
men mentioned by yon, were revoked,
and that la all there la to it
‘ Vary reepecthdlj; \ \ '.. ’
Cole L. Blease, Governor.
constitutionalist.,This letter to the
mediators at Niagara Falls, follows:
“The undersigned, the special rep
resentative of the first chief of the
constitutiomflist government of Mex
ico, Venustiano Carranza, following
express instructions, has the honor
to communicate to your excellency,
the Ambassador of Brazil, and your
excellencies, the ministers of Chile
an4 Argentina, the following:
“Prompted by a noble desire to
solve. In an amicable and peaceful
mamveT. tie conflict pending between
the United States and the Mexican
nation your excellencies , addresed
the government of the United States,
Gen. Huerta ancl the first chief of the
institutionalist— army, tendering
your good offices and inviting each
of tlie filferestea 1}i&rU*f*Xor AyJtuJ*
repdesentatlves for the purpose of
discussing the details of the negota
tions. y
‘‘The chief of the constitutionalist
government, greatly ■predating the
good wishes and sympathy of the sta
ir repwbHca of the American eon-
Republicaqs — Brandegee, Colt,
Crsq-ford, Gronna, Kenyon, Llppltt,
Lodge, MeCumber, McLean, Nelson,
Norris, Sterling, Weeks—13.
Progressive—Poindexter.
Nays—Democrats, Ashurst, Mar-
while the other eleven smoked. Nlc-[^ ne ’ O’Gorman, Pomerene, Ransdell,
otine poisoning caused his death. He'** ee
had never Smoked.
Dally Attempts to Bring Drag Across
Border From Mexico.
Opium smugglers are especially ac
tive along the Mexican boundary at
present and hardly a day passes that
the treasury department does not re
ceive reports of attempts to bring
opium from Mexico Into the United
States. The boundary line between
California and Mexico Is the most
popular place frith dealers in tba
contraband drug and the automobiW
has been adopted by smugglers as
the most successful means of eluding
inspectors.
Mexico is normally very slack in
regulating traffic across the border
and the war situation makes thn
work of the opium smugglers espec
ially easy insofar as Mexican officials
are concerned. United States inspec
tors, however, have landed scores of
smugglers behind the ban at greag
risk of life.
Killed by Tobacco Fumes.
Eli Sawden of Detroit, Mich., aged
•fifty-one, Is dead as a result of being
locked in a jury room two hours
Gives Them Summer Breathing Time.
President Wilson has signed an or
der directing that all government em
ployees wherever stationed be allow
ed to work only four hours each Sat
urday between June 15 and Septem
ber 15. .
Open Campaign Headquarters.
The Democrats, Progressives and
Republicans have opened headquar
ters in Chicago to direct the fight for
Congressional members this fall.
Liner Slips Through Locks.
The first passage through the Ga-
out Monday when the ocean liner
teed; Shields, WaTsh, Williams—9.
Republicans—Bristow, Burleigh,
Clark (Wyoming), Cummins, Gallin-
ger, Goff, Jones, Pa$e, Perkins. Smith
(Michigan), Smoot, Sutherland,
Townsend, Warren, Works—15.
The amendment reads: "Provid
ed. that the passage of this act shall
not be construed or -held as a waiver
or relinquishment of any right the
Unitetf States may have under the
treaty with Great Britain,« ratified
February 21, 1909, or the treaty with
the republic of Panama, ratified Fe6-
ruary 26, 1904, or otherwise to dis
criminate in favor of its vessels by
exempting the vessels of the United
States or its citizens from the pay
ment of tolls for passage through
said canal, or as any way waiving.
Inspector D. Evans at Tin
Juana, who has been one of the mask
active enemies of the opium trade. In
just recovering from a bullet wound
Inflicted by an opium smuggler who
resisted arrest. During a period of
five months Evans and his
at Tia Juana arrested fourteen smug
glers and seized 344 cans of opium.
New York Hotel Tragedy.
V. C. Steffano of New York is dead
and Mrs. Florence Boden of Allen
town, Pa., is beaten severely over thn
head as a result of a disturbance be
tween them while in a New Yorik
hotel. .
Went to Sleep on Track.
The bodies of J. W. Shackelford
and James Potter of Hickory, Miss.,
were found on a track near there.
Tuesday. It la believed they fen
asleep on the track.
lianca, 4.000 tons, passed throngh.
Demean In as Usual.
John T. Duncan has authorised the
announcement that he will be in the
race for gomaor again this
the United States under said treaty,
of otherwise, with respect to the sov
ereignty over. Uie ownership, control
and management of said canal and
> the regulation of the conditions, or
charges of traffic throngh the rfme.”
The Satherlaad amendment, pro
posed as a substitute for the- Sum-
tdT
ing In the remel act ahonld be
sldered as denying or abridging thn
right of the United Stntee <
mate in favor of
and added that, on fhe t
right in reesoortod.