The Manning times. (Manning, Clarendon County, S.C.) 1884-current, January 25, 1922, Section One Pages 1 to 8, Page Page Five, Image 5
[DOEShNOT BELIEVE IN
CO-OPERATIVE MARKETING
Several of our subscribers have
asked us to publish some anti-co
operative tobacco marketing news.
We have clipped two items from The
Southern Tobacco Journal which may
be of considerable, interest. One is
by the 'editor of the above journal
and .the other one by a tobacco man
who is now located in Belgium.
The Southern Tobacco Journal of
-.fers no 'apology for the position it is
taking in the matte: of the Co-opera
'tive Market, as' apphed to leaf tobac
e We- believe 'that we are doing the
tobacco farmer a favor in warning.
him against a proposed plan that we
'honestly believe will if put into opera
tion of work to his disadvantage. Not
only this, but if the proposed plan
should be put into operation, the en
tire business interest of the tobacco
centers of the country would be em
barrassed. It is a matter of surprise
to us that bankers and other business
concerns do not realize the serious
"ness of the pt. .osed proposition.
Since announcing our position in this
matter, and stating our objection to
the plan as affecting the tobacco in
tprest we have received many letters
of endorsement of our position-and
"hundreds of tobacco farmers have
talked the matter over, with us. We
find also that bankers and others who
are interested are anxious for all the
information they can get. In our is
sue of week before last, we endeavor
ed to present facts in connection with
the propbsition. Our editorials were
'extensively copied and we were-forced
to issue several hundred copies ex~*
tra, which were promptly taken by
those seeking information. We have
rece.. ly come into contact with hund
reds of tobacco farmers who are anx
ious to know what all this thing of the
tobacco Co-operative Marketing: Plan
means. We believe that we are stat
ing the truth when we say that not
more than 10 per cent of those with
'-vhom we have come into contact are
in favor of the plan. In fact many
with whom we have talked, who have
signed the five year contract, are -an
xious to be released from the obliga
tion.
We want to say again, and we want
to say it iwth all the emphasis at our
ccommand, that, we are not influenced
in our position on account of any per
sonal. interest. Those who know us
best know that we have nothing to
.'ose ,nor nothing to gain. Now let
us address a few remarks to our far
mer friends as well as others who
should be interested in their welfare.
You are called upon, gentlemen, to
enter into an agreement with some
one (God knows who). This agree
ment is supposed to bind you for 5
years. In this agreement you agree
to pool your tobacco. That is you
place your tobacco in classes with
'hundreds of others. This tobacco is
then prepared for market, re-dried,
etc. It is then stored and buyers in
vited to inspect, etc. Then you deliver
your tobacco to be classed. You are
told that you are to receive 60 per I
cent of the value of your tobacco, and
the remainder, or what, is left after
it is sold and delivered. Of course
yuo know that out of the tobacco that
is sold yo uare to pay your propor
tional part of the cost.of grading, re
drying, packing, insurance, taxes, etc.
They tell you that expert men will at
tend to classification, valuation, etc.
Well now stop just one minute and
estimate what all this will cost. The1
-expert grader, the expert appraiser,
the expert re-dryer-the expert this
and expert that. With a complicated
system of bookkeeping-and then a
great loss in weight. You know that
there 'will be a bill of charges that
will stagger you. Now think again:
What manner of man is he, who can
p~ossibly place a value on tobacco in
advance ? Did you ever think of this ?
If not think of it seriously now. No
human being can tell ijvhat the prices
of tobacco will be from one season to
the other-and in the face of this
fact, these piromoter's tell you that.
you will receive 60 per cent of the
value of your tobacco.
Now comes the proposition of fin
ancing the proposi tion. Naturally
those who can furnish the money will
want to know howv it is going to be
applied-and believe us-they are
surely going to know. D~o you believe
for one minute that banks or the Gov
ernment will loan money to pay for
tobacco on a valuation that would in
all probability he out of reason. And
then again-it is going to take mil
lions of dollars to pay other' expenses.
We will leave it to you to tell us
where it is coming from. Another
thing gentlemen, and that is, if this
great scheme should he put into op
cration-those who are stock holders
(and every man who stores tobacco
is a stock holder) become speculators
or dealers in leaf tobacco. Suppose
the concern has several million pounds
on han (dto be sold. There are only a
fewv buyers who cut a big figure. The
tobacco that is for sale is of course
put up in hogsheads, redlried, etc. One
of these big concerns wants the to
bacco handled and re-driedl in its owri
way-andl so do the others-andi the
result is that in all probability none
of the tobacco is handled to the sat
isfaction of a possible piurchaser.
Going back to the grading proposi
tion where several hundred farmers
pool their tobacco to be classed. Now
gentlemen, honestly9 do you for a mo
meat believe that there are a set of
men on earth that can classify tobac
co to the satisfaction of all concern
ed.
These are only a few of the diffeul
ties, but there are others. Farmiers as
a cl'ass are no different from all oth
era in that they need their money
when they earn it. It will be a sad
day fo r'many poor farmers who work
hard all the year, who goes in debt
for his fertilizers and other supiplies,
when he Is forced to wait indleflnitely
for a big part of his tobacco money.
Now come on gentlemen, and think
of this matter seriously, Did it ever
occur to you that it would have b~een
fairer to the farmer if this contract
had been for one year Instead of five.
Why is this five year business'? Think
of ite-investigate thoroughly-and
Swhen you do, you will discover "tbe
nigger in'the wood-pile."
Do yan believe for a mnInuto that
BACK GIVES OUT
Plenty of Manning Readers Have Ths
Experience.
You tax the kidneys-overworl
them-.
They can't keep up the continua
strain.
The back may give out-it ma'
ache and pain;
Urinary troubles may set in.
Don't wait lonFr-take Doan':
Kidney Pills.
Manning people tell you how they
act. Ask your neighbor!
Mrs. C. M. Taylor S. Boundry. St.
Manning, says: "About a year age
I wss troubled with kidney com
blaints. I had terrible backaches anc
Ifeadaches. Nervous spells upset m(
and my nerves were just a wreck. ]
felt tired and languid and I sufferet
from dizziness. Finally I heard aboul
Doan's Kidney Pills and bought som<
at Arant's Drug Store. I can cer.
tainly say Doan's did me a wonder.
ful lot of good and quickly relieve(
me."
Price 60c, at all dealers. Don't
simply ask for a kidney remedy-gel
Doan's Kidney Pills-the same thal
Mrs. Taiylor liad. I Foster-Milbur'r
Co., Mfrs., Buffalo, N. Y.
a man will come from his home it
galifornia to help the tobacco farmer
unless he expects big pay? Do you be
lieve that, men who are active in th
business are working for nothing
You are not fools and you know bet
ter.
We are frank to say that we believ<
the Co-operative Market Plan 'as ap
plied'to nearly all farm products is a
good thing. We believe that the plat
is a good one, when applied to suel
things as farmers' produce, for imme
diate and *direct consumption, bu
when it comes to leaf tobacco, all fair
minded men must agree that th
Auction System of selling leaf tobac
co is the best way.
The fact is gentlemen, the bes
friend the tobacco farmer has is thi
Warehouseman. The tobacco ware
houseman stands between the buye:
and the sellor, and as he gets his pa,
from the farmer, it is his duty-to se
that his patrons receive the best mar
ket prices. The . tobacco farme
makes his crop, gets it in good shape
takes it to the market, places it o
the warehouse floor, where all buyer;
can see it-and when he is suppose<
to receive the highest market prices
The farmer gets the market price fo
his tobacco for which he receives cast
on the spot. This system is all tha
can be desired--and the very best an<
fairest way of selling leaf tobacco
Now gentlemen, listen to us; Just a
certain as any thing can be, the pres
ent system of selling tobacco will con
tinue. For. a while there may be a de
parture on the part of some from th<
Auction System. Those who enter in
to the five year agreement will regre
their action and those who refuse t<
be led into a departure from the oh
way of selling tobacco, will certaitl:;
be glad of their, action.
To the business men of the tobacc<
centers of the tobacco producing sec
tions we suggest, that they look int:
the proposition which is pending.
few men are putting forth every of
fort to destroy a system of sellin,
leaf tobacco which would if auccessfu
work a serious injury to some of the
most pPogressive towns and cities o
the country, and at the same tim
would hurt the farmer, whq want:
ill he can get for his tobacco, 'im(
needs it when his crops is cured.
- In conclusion gentlemen, what is al
of' this thing about any way? Her(
comes a man from California-ross
ing the continent, 3,000 miles, and a:
he comes he could find in some sec
tions through which he came, cort
being used for fuel, oat meal sellin
for 25 cents per bushel, potatoes rot
ting in the fields and farming condi
tions generally bad. He leaves all o
this and conmes to wvhere grazing i:
good. Hie lands in the tobaceo prio
ducing sections and proceeds to or
ganize tobacco farmers, when in fac
tobacco is selling, and has for som<
time been selling for good prices
Taking the quality of the crop int<
considleration, tobacco is selling thi
year for big prices. Whenever a far
mer offers any thing that is at all (Ie
sirable he is satisfied. Then why al
of this muss about the tobacco farm
er. Now you can find "the nigger ii
the wvood-pile."
Mr. Poe, editor of the Progressiv<
Farmer, tells you about what they
are doing in Canada and Maryland
D~oes lhe knowv that Canada produce:
but little more tobacco than Stoke:
and Rockingham counties combined
and that the Canadian tobacco is en
tirely different from our tobacco. An
so in the Maryland tobacco, the larg
or propoi~tion of which is taken b)
foreign markets.
As we close this article we are re.
ceiving letters and telegrams from al
set ions endorsing our position.--Th<
Southern Tobacco .Journal.
ANVERS, BELGIUM, LETT1ER
By Edward Nyssens
In Western Tobacco .Journal
I enclose herewith my letter in parn
to one of my good friends aind custo
mers I nthe Stahtes, which might be 01
interest to your readlers.
From your letter and~ from other in.
formation I see that the Pool is going
to be a success-in so far that 75 pei
cent of the crops will most likely be
p ledge-but when this is (lone th<
ardl ask is only going to begin.
Tro make ca pool that is surc to win
is to make money-it must have th<
entire control of the crops and b<
strong enough to hold them until th<
buyers are forced to pay their prices
Will te Pool be strong enough t(
(10 this?
As far as the finer grades of to.
baccos are concerned; bright and dIarl
Plug wrappers, bright Burleys, frag.
rant bright tobacco for Cigarettes of
the best brands, good spinners and
perhaps a few other specialties; thor
is a possibility that they mayr succeed
and they can only! succeed if they arc
wise enough to fx reasonable prices
For these grades of tobaccos
tha'ugh, there is no needl to make
Pool for', actually the- demand ii
strong enough to comamand higi
prices, I dare Bay even highe prlcci
than they could reasonably expect to
bake.
It is simply a question of offer and
demand and when the demand is
strong and the available quantity
small, as it is the case just now, the
open competition is far better than
the strongest Pool.
When it comes to common tobaccos
though, the question is very different,
because the manufacturers of com
mon tobaccos will use any grade, as
long as it is cheap; and the quantity
in sight of common tobaccos is that
large that I don't see the possibility
of any concern, whetler it be a Pool,
Trust or corporation of any kind to
control it 6ntirely.
Your people lose out of sight that
the bulk. of common tobaccos has to
be exported and they don't realize
that, in that respect, they have to
compete with the common tobaccos
grown all over the world. My exper
ience of the tobacco business is that
the Worlds trade will work the com
mon American tobacco if t.hqy are to
be had the same price as the "home
grown tobaccos" an dthose that they
can get from the different producing
centers. In other words, the export
trade is not bound to buy the Ameri
can tobaccos, but contrary to what is
the case to the highly protected
American tobacco trade that forces
the American manufacturers to work
only American tobacco; the export
trade has at its disposal the tobacco
produced in the whole world and it
dos and will always buy and work
the cheapest first. Besides the stocks
of common tobaccos held in the U. S.
you have little or no idea of the im
mense stocks of common tobaccos still
held in the Filippines where the bulk
of the last two crops is unsod yet,
of the stocks of South America to
baccos, Paraguy, Rio Grande, Brazil,
the Domingo tobaccos, the Javas,
British India, South Africa, Algeria,
Chinese and Oriental tobaccos, etc.,
not to forget the Home grown tobac
cos of Germany, Austria, Italy,
Switzerland, Belgium, Holland,
France and even Spain.
All of these tobaccos are on the
)open European markets and even
worse; large quantities of these to
baccos are still in the hands of the
banks who are eager to sell them at
any sacrifice.
It is certainly very natural and very
respectable for your farmers to love
and look out for their interests, but
I fear that when it comes to Pool their
crops and impose their prices, they
are and will make a mistake.
Your farmers ought to be better
educated as to the quantities that the
world really needs. I mean what are
the quantities that the world legiti
mately needs or demands.
You have behind you two bumper
crops of about 1,500,000,000 pounds
each these two crops were even too
large to fill the empty warehouses of
Europe4 for notwitstanding the large
exports of 1919 and 1920 and the de
creased exports of 1921 there is quite
a surplus left in the States and all
European warehousese are full, I dare
say more than full. England has now
a stock of 376,000,000 pounds of raw
tobacco in its bonded warehouses,
whereas in 1918 htere was only 115,
000,000 left. This means that in two
years England has imported 260,000,
006 pounds of tobacco in excess of
its ' onsumption and its actual stock
represents a quantity large enough to
cover the whole consumption of Ewig
land for three years.
The stock in other European coun
tries are perhaps not so large, still,
it is a certain fact that all of the
bonded -warehouses of Belgium, Hol
land, Germany and other European
I countries are full of tobacco and that,
at the same time, the crops of most
of the European and Oriental coun
tries are large and are steadily in
creasing.
If your farmers, or better said the
Pool knewv this, and if they were wise
enouigh to use for manure all of their
common stuff that sells .after all 'be
low the cost of production: and spoils
the market of honest ,tobacco, they
. would conme to the natural result to
have a fair sized crop of only clean
goodl tobacco that wvould be sure to
find its place at fair prices.
This year's crop is again of *some
1,000,000,000, pounds. 'rhis quantity is
more than suflicient to cover the needl
of the Americani factory, say about
600,000,000 pounds and leave a good
Isurplus of some 400,000,000 for export
which is more than sufmcient also.
If this surplus is going fo be com
mon stuff, thmen the Pool may and I
dlare say wvill, find itself at the head
of an immense stock of common stuff
for which there is no market any
where.
If the big four go against the Pool,
and it seems to be their intention to
doC so--they are in a finer po(sition
than they ever were. They certainly
have on hand a stock of 01(d tobacco
to last them easy twvo years, they will
alwvays be able to get quite a quantity
from the mndependent planter so that
they wvill be able to hold out for
qluite a length of time and leave the
bulk of the crop) on the shoulders of
the Pool.
The Marylandl people had quite an
exp~erience of it and if my informa
tion is correct, they have to sell now
at some 7 to 8 cents, tobacco that they
could have sold1 at 25 to 30 cents sonme
fifteen months ago. At the same time
the Marylands of last years crop now
in the hands of the indlependlent trade
sell at fancy prices; because they arc
the gradle of tobacco for which there
is a dlemand.
My sympathies always go for the
farmer and I really wlsh and like to
see him make good prices-which is
no more than well (deserved returns
for his hard and steady labor-and I
always pity the poor fellow that gets
Iless money for a crop that takes fully
a year of expense, hard work andl
tioub~le (I mean manuring and culti
vating the soil, sowving, lalnting, hoe
ing, suckering, topping, cutting, haul
ing in the barn, dIrying, striking it
(down, sorting, tying, taking goodl
care of it at all the time lhe brmngs it
to market) thain for common hay that
is cut down by machines, dIried in the
sun and sold on the meadow or
brought to market with no more
trouble than to pres sit down in bales.
When you look at it in this light,
It stands to reason that sound clean
tobacco ought always to bring a fair
price, but when It comes to common
musty, sandy and damaged stuff, It
-"" ---rage i1we
C. L. Strauss Company,
9 Dugan St., Sumter, S. C.
MR. FARMER:
We handle all your Farm Products,
such as
POTATOES TURKEYS
CUCUMBERS HAY
TOMATOES CORN
BEANS OATS
CHICKENS . PEAS
EGGS VELVET BEANS
And in fact anything that the farm produces. This
is your headquarters and you will be welcome.
In a short time we will have for sale SEED OATS,
MIXED FEEDS, and other commodities that you'
purchase.
Phone or write us for market quotations and get
our prices before you buy or sell.
"A word to the wise"---Do business with
C. L. Strauss Company,
Phone No. 693, Sumter, S. C.
ought to be looked at and treated as work. lie said that he probably would ment in such a manner as it
manure. and should never be allowed use them to reach the North Pole (eem best. We will be Pleased, there
to spoil the floor of a decent Tobacco should his plan to drift past the pole fore, if you will kindly furnish us
Warehouse. with the ice pack prove not feasible, not later than February 28, 1922, ad
This is what the "Pool" ought to A wireless equipment installed aboard dressed franks for the 900 quart pack
understand and if he does he may be the Maud will be used to broadcast a ages of cotton seed made available
sure that real success is in the end. message when he eaches the top of for your constituents.
I see that I have just written you the world.
quite a letter and hope I am not Captain Amundsen expects to strike Respectfully,
taking too much of your time to read immediately into the outward or Chief of Bureau.
it. northern drift of the ice as it leaves
I see that Cincinnati has opened Bering Sen next spring, and to swing
again; when a boy in 1876, I was a with the northeasterly current early NOTICE OF ELECTION
clerk in the office of A. C. Lamotte, in the summer.
Ne York, and in those days Cincin- With the explore . v. he C.pt s
nati was the Trobaceco market and wve a Witnsiig m tewoSte fSuhCrli,
did quite ap1, extensive business there sol thssle"n h ot ee onyo ilasug
through W. G. Morris, Auetioneer aindlC lniegne' r I .Se-I eKns e wm ~ang
tobacco b)uyer. In those days also thedusiettofhe xeiin;wo Istit
"Western Tobacco Journal" was start'- Nreinaitr n r~ fsxNTC SI RI GVN
ed under the management of Majot'br ia aie h ondteMu hi rt'i o re indb
Manson. i 90 h lcrbe..1.Bitn lr f
In those (lays also the buyers on the ~Cuto'Cono la o ilas
breaks in Louisville took their free AAINT IJALlII(E br (hmyonte 0hdyofa
lunch in "Fourteen D~rops" and Stone Orn bug -Jn .-ectr . "'Y12.ArEhdinwlhe ed
Face, which was Whiskey and Crab-A.Iuto il rbayitod eainth Ki:'tee wap laing
aipple Cider.bili th Seae ti ek t (I)Iit t : aIudute4t dy'o
These are old recollections of the aa vt h ony rrl pli' "lri,', 12, a Jh oe'
time when the "Galt House" was the sse.I o ot h onysoeada 1 on' ~r
Louisville Ihotel, and the pigs wVere mr hn$400frterrl~-S~(,t lc he ~ang on
running loose in the streets.lieaditisteiIao th ne bil I5oii orh addrnae is
Very truly yours,to uralepne. he ew lil ii.
Edouard Nysse*ns. wudgv h ngsrt' o lh'f)l~tgai'tr'rlsud'
AM UNDSEN S11IIbeImun.Pil
ICEADY FOR)I TitllP- ~ ~laa oewoi ar
Earth's Northern Axis Is Goal; Ves- 10 El)S tlBIE Alcinilae mut ie thr
sel to Carry Airplanes and Radio peg ihteCek o'Cuto
Set--Forced lBack Last Year. IIn .''rnrlgn ~ himsui onv .Ca i
Sattle, ,Jan. 24t.--(Associated Press)Si:oftsewohntIiIthr hl s
-Final provisioning and equipp)ing of Wihavw t(iceangtIei- ytistim wllotepaed nth
the exploring ship Maudl, in whichteetine adiprvltye ofblts
Capt. Roald Amrundsen, noted Norwe-ispoodtofrihec Th plssal 1( ttil I(8
gian explorer and discoverer of the Snti n ersnaieu otn 'lc .o a~ ily 'hur
South Pole, will resume his interrupt- pouigtrioy~ih90 qatIt,12 n hl emi pt n
ed Arctic expedition in May, is beingpakis fsedtecmn sesnItito'(1)ookP. .onhe ad
c'ompletedl as the stout little ship lies Te'x fte~akg ssfiin a. Imida l l'efe h
in the land-locked wvaters of Lake t rbeafre omk ai-Imngr hl ~oe~ Ioe h
Union here. fcoyIrlmmr ra ftevr :Io oe alCutadthlt
A smashed propellor ulade, lost inieyicoprsnwt otrvait th Voercied yeihtiiilt.
the ice off the Northeastern Siberianisno grw inhslclt. tis Teruns fteeetinmste
2oast, last year forced Captain A mundthrfr demladial thtn fie vtbheCrkoCutofVi
sea to bi'ing the Maud to Seattle for idvda eev'mr hn oeIinsugCutS . it ae
repairs. When the journey is resumedIacgethn wlv (1) olck on t
the vessel will carry four extra blades Afe codcig tIists if heT say olwng he lcto.
so that a similar accidlent may causefamricovne thtte nw Teolwng reie irges f
anly a temporary halt to the expedi- t'in i ieie't th on hei ti' 5 il l(ti . Plig Pac
tioin. The Maud wvill carry provisionsaled gr ig, nIwilsbia.oh Cke' te,1.N (okr
for seven years, although tihe explorer dtielne~r I i eut i c 'aiir,..N cezear ir
loes not expect the trip to occupy crac ih isrcintgte miM~rze
mlol e than five years at the most. WihsmpIbolpodcd ron tie 1oirg la -- .(' oiislaim
Will Carry TWO AIrplanes qatpcae( ed h erit tre .A ic,(hin~rK i
The most important of the Maud's ma vl r~net uns i ~wsii~ I.M .Ckr
equip~menlt, in Captain Amundsen's etyz'wt n af uhlo 1 .BITN
apinion, will bec the two airplanes, pul'se o i-atia tr.wt il'Ceko or
ahased in Norway and shipped here nwvrit.Ti uniyi n'- o omnPesft iliiobr
recently, and which will be unsedl in flyhnldji~rfvrarecni ony .C
thle miaking of extensive geographie rm huderil nm t Ooncl iia '(,~C,1) 1 92 2
rind hrydrographic surveys for 1,000a dmaiktahl (n rtti )ils
miles on either s~ie of tile vessel's cr el upy sfti't fr
trac'k through the Northern seas. laeplnigtefloig ('51. N 'I(,0 il(H RG
Trho primary purpose oIf the expedli- Ec akg fse ilh c
tion, which Is operating under the auis cmaidb icli-gvn ul Iwl vt h Jde(fIro
pices of the Nprwegian Government, ifrainieadn h ait 111bt 4r lrero o vo h
is to stud~y the rmovemenit of the Arc-tie1e rte'sprifrassng2h lI (f Flram, 92at 1
Lie ice pack ,thec effect of ocean cur-th famriesalhig tonhsocckA .orLterof)ic rg
rents, magnetic influences arnd otherfa'.asg ilirfo ThmsMleo
p~henomena of the Polar regions. 'h lsrbtorwl ls nFb nrl io'
Willl Wireless Victorymay 8,92. Ay pcae e-ihrdG Mle,
The air planes ,Captain A mundseaannguclefoatrthtde dGadi.
xpecs, wll e cigrea vaue i th sholl behistriutpla todrfy p the Dpole MnigS . Jtl 3 02