The Manning times. (Manning, Clarendon County, S.C.) 1884-current, September 23, 1908, Image 1
VOL. XXIII MANNING, S. C. WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 23, 1908 NO.5
FORAKERTREED.
Seems to be a Tool Of Standard
Oil Co.
HE GOT CHECKS.
One Letter from Archbold Speaks
of a Deposit of Fifty Thousand
Dollars to the Senator's Credit.
What- Foraker Says.
In a speech at Columbus, Ohio.
Hearst charged the Republican party
with being the beneficiary of the
trust corruption. He said he had
legal evidence and documentary
proof. Hearst then read four letters
from Archbold. John D. Rockefeller's
right-hand man, to Senator Foraker,
of Ohio, who is now a member of
the United States Senate. The first
letter refers to two bills, one men
tioned,as house bill niimber 500. in
.relation to foreign corporations
against which he desired a demon
stration made. Following it, 17 days
later, the second letter refers to the
senator's favor for $15,000. The
third refers to "Another very objec
tionable bill," which he hopea there
would be no difficulty in killing.
The fourth is as follows:
"Twenty-six Broadway. April 17.
1900.
"My Dear Senator: I enclose you
certificate of deposit to your favor
of $14,500. We are greatly at a loss
In -the matter, but I send you this,
and will be glad to have a frank
ta& with you when opportunity of
fers, it you so desire.
"I need scarcely again express
or great gratifica!ton over the fav
omabe outcome of affairs.
"Very truly yours,
JOHN D. ARCHBOLD.
"on. J. B. Foraker, 1500 Sixteenthl
Street, Washngton, D. C." h
That Foraker Says. . I
United States Sena-tor Foraker
Friday issued the following state- 1
ment in reply to the charges made
Thursday night at Columbus' by W. I
R. Hearst.
"I don't know whether the letters I
given out by Mr. Hearst are true I
or not, but I assume they. are, for
I was then engaged in the practice of it
law and was employed by the Stan-1
ard 11 Company as one of its coun
sel In connection with its affairs in
oio, where it was attacked in the t
courts and in the legislature.
-While I don't now recall the de
tails, remember that I rendered the
company such service as I could and
harged for it and was paid.
"The employment had no refer
ence whatsoever to anything pending
in congress or to anything in which
the Federal Government had the
sightest interest,
"That 1 was so employed and
presumably compensated for my ser
ices, was common knowledge at the
time; at least I never made any ef
fort to conceal the fact; on the con
'trary, I was pleased to have people
know that I had such clients.
"It had not then become discred
itable, but was considered just the
reerse to be employed by such cor
poratons."
Hearst BePIl .
At St. Louis, Mr., Hearst on Fri- I
day night in n speech said:
"Mr. Foraker replies in charac
teistic Republican manner. He ad
mits that he did serve the Standard
Oil and is proud of it. His state
ment Is based on letters I read las:
night. If he had seen the letter 1
m going to read tonight, he would
have denied the whole matter.
The first letter follows:
"2$ Broadway, New York, Januasy
27, 1902.
"My Dear Senator: Respondiag
to your favor of the 25th, Itgie
me pleasure to hand you herewith
certficate3 of deposit for $50,000 inm
accordance with our understanding.
Your letterstates the conditions cor
'etly, and I trust the transacion Will
be successfully consumated. V~~ery
truly yours,
"JOHNZ 0. ARCHBOLD.
"Hon. J. B. Foraker, Washington,
D. C.'
The second letter as read by Mr.
Hearst was as follows:
2$ Broadway, New York.
February 25, 190.
'hy Dear Senator: I venture to
write you a word re the bill intro
duced by Senator Jones, of Arkan-'
sas, known as S. 649, intended to
amend the Act 'To protect trade an~c
commerce against unlawful re-'
straints and monopolies,' etc. m
trdced by him December 4.
It really seems as though this bill
is very unnecessarily severe, and
even vicious. Is it not much better
to test the application of the Sher
man Act before resorting to a meas
re of this kind? I hope you will
feel so about it and I will be greatly
pleased to have a word fromi you on
the subject. The hill is. I believe,
still in committee.
"With kind regards, yours very
truly.
JOHN D. ARCHBOLD.
"on. J. ID. Foraker. Washing
ton, D). C."
"The bill referred to in t'ns letter
is the one introduced by Senator
Jones, of Arkansas, in the united
States Senate. Consedquently' Mr.
Foraker's statement does not say
when he had anything to do in Con
gress.
"There is n'o greater danger to
this Republi' than this Power 01
money emple-red for '-:il.. There
ar no ::reatr crimujinals than3 thne
trusts that crrupt the rpubli" srn
"Th Republcan party has long
-~ --NIGHT RlIDERS
Waru Farmners Not to Raul Cott
to the Ginls.
A dispatch from Sandersvil
Miss., says night riders have a
pe~red in Jones county. and thr
prominent farmers received not
es Monday night to haul no mo
'cotton to gin. or else they wou
"get paid" as they returned hon
A general notice was also placed <
the pub:-c roads warning all fa
miers to cease hauling cotton aft
September 14. Considerable e
citement prevails and farmers ne:
town are rushing their cotton
while those farther away have cea
ed hauling to the gins.
Ginmers Also. Warned.
A dispatch from Laurencevill
Ga., says night riders have poste
written notices. painted with rt
hands on them in several gins
this county warning the proprietoi
that their gins will be burned to tlb
ground should a boll of cotton t
ginned before the price of cotto
reached 12 cents. It is reporte
that similar warnings have bee
posted on many gins and oil mill
over the county.
Gin Insurance Cancelled.
A special from Quitman. Miss
says people in this section are ver
much wrought up over the allege,
night riders who have been operat
-ng in the southern part of thi
county. The matter became seriou
today when it was learned that som
of the insurance companies had no
tified their agents to cancel thei
policies on cotton gins in this dis
trict.
FLYING MACHINE WRECKED.
One of the Occupants Killed an(
One Hurt.
After having drawn the attentiot
f the world to his aeroplane flighTu
at Fort Myers, near Washington.,
and having established new worl.
records for heavier-than-air flying
machines, Orvtlle Wright Thursday
met with a tragical mishap while
making.a two-man flight. The aero
planist was accompanid by Lieut.
Thos. E. Selfridge of the signal
:orps of the army.
Lieut. Selfridge was fatally in.
jured and died at 8:1t o'clock
rhursday night. Mr. Wright was
iriously iniured, but is expected to
-ecover.
While the machine was encirclin'
he drill grounds a propeller bladde
mapped oi and hitting somue other
7art of the intricate mechanism.
:aused it to overturn in the air. and
all to the ground. enevloping the
wo occupants in the debris.
Both men received'tdeep cuts about
he head. Mr. Wright regained con
ciousness at the hospital and dic
ated a cablegram to his brother
Lt Lemans. France, and requested
hat the same message be sent to
is -sister and father at Dayton, Ohio.
ssuring them that he was all right.
PREACHER HORSEWHIPPED.
Ey a Woman He Had Scored in a
-Sermon.
Mrs. Bonita Schwartzenberg, a
landsome young woman, has been
ned $1 anid cost in the miayor's
ourt at Pineville. 1a.. for horse
vhipping the Rev. H. C. Worten,
tyoung Baptist preacher of that
:own.
Mr. Worten stood calmrly in the
aain street of the town and received
:he whipping without a murmur.
Els wife stood near hini and when
~rs. Schwartzenberg had exhausted
terself applying a .large buggy whip,
he minister and his wife proceeded
n their way.
Mrs. Schwartzenberg says she
hipped Mr. Worten because he had
cored her in a sermon. The min
ster denIes that any part of his
sermon ha~n reference to the
oug widow. He declined to appear
gainst her in court.
BRTAN-TAFt' MEETING OFF.
Republicant Nominee Will Not Attend
Chicago ranquet.
The conttemplated mein:1 01
Judge Taft and W. J1. Bryan at
banquet in Chicago October 7 has
fallen through, according to a state
ment by Chairman Dixon. of tht
speakers' bureau.
"Judge Taft on September 2:3 wil
address the lndependenlt Rtailwa)
Men's Taft Club ini Chicago, sai
Mr. Dixon. "but his itinerary wil
not allow of his speakting at Chicagt
October l
It is said~ that it was .Judge Taft'
wish to speak at the banquet. h~u
that th.e speakers' hureau wa no
consulted offcially in mahing th
engagmlent.
Mr. Bryan. however, will atten<
the banquet whichl will be given b:
th' Chicagio A\ssoc~ition of (Cm
merce.
WILl~ Ti! HUNG.
For the Murder Which Led to th~
Springlield Rioting.
Joe .James, the negro slayer C
Cergy A. Ualiard. of Springfielt
llinois. must pa ythe penalty c
death upon the.- gallows for hi
crime. The fixing of punishmett
death was returned at (6:1 0 o'cloc
last at-ternconi. after the jury ha
deliberated since 10:45 ini the mooi
ig. The prisoner was in the coul
room and heard the verdict of rI:
jury. He could not u-ter- a sour
and took tihe report of the tweb
men without a :remor. Cle-r-g'
Ballard, the ruine - eninmeer. w;
killed on the night of' July 4t
Blanche Ballard. 24 years old. we
awakened late at night by the ueg:
in her hed room. Her screams a
rcted her: foher, who rushed
-'r reistance. Ballard in his nig
c~h.hn wa Unarme2d. helplest am
wa ,3'ahbed mo death. The remnov
of Jaaes and the negro Ric-hardst
from the jail by Sheriff Werner pr
.i'toeam the bloorh- rini: in wvhi
!HELD FOR CONSPIRACM
jALLEGED PLOT AGAINST WHITE
P- DISCOVEIEI) AT GREENWOO).
Ee
c -
re
ld Blacks at Ninety-Six Said to Hay,
Conspired to Kill Four Prominen
White Citizens.
Eleven negroes were brought t<
Greenwood Saturday, September 12
nI
about noon. from Ninety-Six, in th<
! custody of Sheriff McMillan and De
1puty Sheriff Charles Dukes, under z
6 warrant charging !hem with con
d 1
dspiracy. The arrest of these negroe
was the outcome of an investigatior
son the part of the local authorities
e and certain citizens in Greenwood.
e Very little was known in Ninety-Six
d up to Saturday morning of the pro
1 posed arrest or the cause therefor,
s but several of 'the leading citizens
of Ninety-Six were fully aware of
the situation, and the bringing of
the negroes to Greenwood was de
cided upon as the best method to
proceed in a lawful and orderly man
ner. Saturday evening ynother
negro was arrested and brought there
on the same charge. The negroes
Jfirst arrested are: P. B. Dean, S.
T. Jackson. a preacher. Jas. Step
hens, Anderson Stephens. Ed Har
ris, Tom Bishop, Davego Williams,
'Wayman Jackson, John Calhoun,
Zeke Chappell, another preacher, and
Wade Williams. The negro brought
Saturday night was :Press Goodwin.
The investigation, which led up to
the arrest of these iiegroes. started
in Greenwood on Tuesday, Septem
ber 8. On that day a certain negro
in Greenwood received by mistak-e a
letter addressed to another negro in
Greenwood, and thA letter, upon
which the whole ca-se hangs, as it
were. is the most important docu
ment and development in the whole
affair. The great question is. is the
letter genuine or a fake? This Is the
letter:
"Ninety-Six, September 7, 1908.
"Mr. H1artie Harris, Greenwood, S.
C.: We want- you not to give us
away in this me an Tom Bishop and
Rev. Zeke Chappell is a committee
to get up men to buy Winchesters, to
fix for white folks in a few days.
We are going from house to house at
night and shoot in, and they will
think it is Tolbert. Now, we want
you to see flow many at Greenwood
will hel.p. All of us who come up
there to Tolbert Convention is in it,
but Joe. Don't know anything about
this. It is us. who is S. T. Jackson
there. We will be ready by Sunday
night to start if our men get back.
Don't jell anybody of this. and burn
this letter up. Let me know who
will come from there by Tuesday.
Signed) Wade Williams."
. As stated above, this letter by mis
take was received by another party
than the one to whom it was address
ed. This party, a negro, states that
he started to put the leter back in
the postoffice, but reaiizing the seri
ous natture of its contents. lie turn
ed it over to Chief of Police Mc
C.ombs. The chief of poje imme
diately consulted with Sheriff McMu
Ian n these two with se%'eral other
representative citizens began the in
vestigationl.
The negro who had received the
letter, having himself been arei
dent of Ninety-Six was most closely
Questioned. He let it be known that
he knew something of what was or
~had been going oh aniong the color
ed peopie at Ninety-Six. Expressing
'ear- for his own safe.-~ he avas reluo~
tant to divulge adythiiig. Reneateri
questionihg finally brought out the
:flatm'ent that two negoe societies at
Ninety-Six had been indviging in in
denciary talk against the whites in
their secret 'orders for some time.
These talks had been more frequent
and more violent since the recent
trouble at Ninety-Six, as the result
of the local election on the matter of
isuing bonds to build a school house.
The negro did not connect any white
person at all with these talks, but
stated that the talks were original.
with the negroes and coniined ex-,
clusively to their own secret o~rde-rs.
He stated that the negro Odd Fel
os Lodge at Ninety-Six was talk
ngfl an tive interest in the matter,
as were the members of another se
cret society among the negroes,
nuown. as the "Nniights of the Guid
~ng Star of the East." He stated that
1committee from each of these'
odges had been appointed to have a
conference with each other as to the
purchase o[ gtuns, and to do certain
oter things, so he had been inform
ed.
After consideralie parleying he
consented to go to Ninety-Six and
attend the meeting of the negro Old
Fellows on Thursday night, this br
ing their regular meetinlg to-night.
He stated before going that he did
not know' whether he wouai be allow
ed to get in the lodge or niot. as he
w'as behind in his dues. .1Iney was
- gien him to pay up his dues and he
flet Greenwood for Ninety-Six. On
sFriday he returned and as proof of the
at 'hat b!- had been to Ninety-Six
kand hadd attended the meet
d ing. he brought hack with him his
- membership) ead on which the PaY
ient of his dues had heen receipted
e and dated at Ninety-Six the night h
d fore. and counte-rsignedl by the re
gular offcers of rle lodge, who wot
residents of Ninety-Six.
Is This negro reported to tho'se wht
3 had sent him that he attended th<
tmeeting of the lodge and that aftel
Ithe regular business had been dir
tposed ot in the :odge an executim
0 seso was called. That he askac
1 to be alowed to remain 'o tha e
td eUtiveC es'ion~i. bht ther hr w grn
al aowecl Int rema!inl uiil lhe had mad
ma fierce denu~lnciatory speech agains.
e the w hitem. A fter 'That he was allow
' led to take part in the executiv s
'connected with the proposed beginn
ing of the fight were discussed ata
four white citizens of Ninety-Si:
were named as victims. As was sus
gested in the letter to Hertie Har
i ris, published above, it was state<
that the white people of Ninety-Si
would blame any shooting that migh
take place on the Tolberts, and tha
the negroes would not be suspected
The four men selected were wel
known citizens of Ninety-Six and il
was stated that others might be
chosen later, such developments de
pending on the outcome of the first
venture. It was also stated that the
Rev. Jackson. mentioned in the let
ter. had raised a fund of $70 to
wards buying a dozen Winchester
rifles in Savannah, Ga. The plan of
getting these rifles to Ninety-Six was
also discussed.
Some years ago somve little excite
meat was caused at Ninety-Six by the
fact that some eight or ten negroes
had ordered Winchester rifles.
These negroes stated that' they wished
them for protection against rowdy
members of their own race. They
readily gave them up when the white
people demanded them and thus the
matter ended. Having this episode
: fiind the negroes stated that it
would not be safe to have any guns
shipped to Ninety-Six, so It was pro
posed to have a young negro, named
Davega Williams. one of those now
in jail, and a son of Wade Williams.
the secretary of the Odd Fellows'
Lodgo go to Savannah to purchase
the guns. Ostensibly he would gz
to Claflin University, carrying a
trunk. Instead of going to Claflin he
would proceed to Savannah, buy the
guns and return as far as Dyson's,
which Is the next station below Nine
ty-Six *owards Columbia. He would
get off there with a trunk in which
the guns would have been safely
packed, and in this way the guns
cou'ld be distributed without any sus
picion being aroused. The floods in
tereferred with his going to Savannah
and back at the time first appointed.
Whether or not any other guns were
secured is not known.
However. according to the negre
informer, the first attack was to have
been made on Sunday night, Septem
ber 13, It being stated that the moon
would be about right so far as dark
ness was concerned at that time.
If all of this be true it seems pro
vidential that the letter adcressed tc
the Harris negro did not reach him,
but fell into the hands of the sherifi
through - e medium of another per
son, for Saturday morning Sheriff
IcMillan started out with warrants
for all of the ringleaders, and by
noon had them' safely lodged in the
ounty jail. As stated in the begin
ning only a few people at Ninety-Sih
knew anything about the matter
and it is possible that if all of th(
facts had been known the elever
negroes might never have been allow
d to leave the town. However, the
natter was well managed, and the
egroes were brought there and pu'
in jail without auy bodily harm be
ng done to them.
Saturday afternoon one of then
called to the sheriff and stated tha'
they did not want a preliminary hear
ng then. This procedure if adherer
to will mean that the whole dozer
will remain in jail there until th<
next term of Court of General Ses
sion. A large number of white peo
pe at Niuety Six tli-nk the whol'
thitig is a faite. They think the in
former is up to "spite work." and is
simply trying to get the white peopl'
worked up against certain negrr
enemies of his. There is ne
excitement either here or at Ninety
Six whatever, The affair has caus
ed considerable talk, of course, bu'
there is no excitement whatever.
ONLY T~WO.PFTHS~ CROP
That s tiie Estimate of Cottor
tzeoy by Farmers.
The gathering .of the gcecutivc
committee of the State Farners'
unon and county presidents con
eluded its session at Columnbir
Thursday afternoon. The followinf
information was given out from th<
meeting, which was held behind
closed doors:
From reports from each of the
twenty-five countes represented a'
the meeting the prtesent crop ws
estimated at fron .58 1-2 to 59 per
cent of normal, which means that
the State will produce about 800,000
bales this fill Encouraginlg reports
were lieai-d froml the State's dele
gates to the National Convention at
Fort Worth.'- Definite step~s we-re
raean to compel the orga:ization of
cot' Marion will be organized
next i day and Clarendonl, Marl
boro, Caihoun and Aiken counties
will fall into line soon after.
Secretary F. H. Weston. of the
Cotton Association, and President T.
B. Sckhouse. of the Ware House
Company, addressed the mecting on
the cotton movement and the im
portance of storing. A resolution
was unanimously adopted which re
nuires all members of the union te
sell not a bale until there is advance
from the present prices. The min
immis held secret.
Steps were taken to place the
F -arers' Union Sun on a fiurm fiuan
cial footing with $10.000~f capital
and a well eqnipped plant. the rais
in of stock t'eing pr-orated among
tihe several county organizations.
The dleterminnation is to make ther
Sun a strong agrieulturaIl paper.
second to none in the country, and
to this end a:-rangemenlts were masde
for various decpartnments of the pia
pe to be edited by emuinent agrien!1
rural sp'cilists.
P'ray for Rain.
A dispatch 'romn La Porte. Indl.
says the drouth conditions are so se
vere in K'ankakee county, where the
farmers maintain daily and nightly
vigil to preve~nt their homies and
farms from being swept away hpa
fire' that all drj srvie"- irr TNj
wre h'&l \wejusdla y in a r umer o
chlrr:Els. The' renditios arc s c'y
ious that the railroads 'nave men de
-tailed to wa-~tch tho bridg" to u'
t t ihem i nO c:-1 of Bre
LOCUST PLAGUE.
Wide Areas in South America
Made Desolate by It.
NO REMEDY IS FOUND
Five Governments Fighting the pest,
Which Is Yearly Getting Worse.
Swlarms of Loensts Sixty Miles
Long and Ten Miles Wide.
A cable dispatch a while ago de
seribed bow in Uie pronnee 01
Catamarra, Argentina. many women
bad fallen to the ground in convul
sions of weeping and for a time were
almost bereft of their senses, repeat
ing over and over only the words:
"The locusts. the locusfs?" It was
.he third successive session in which
they had seen the skies darkened
with clouds of locusts that. settled
down upon their fields and plains.
destroying the crops and evf-ry ves
tige of the vegetation on which theii
cattle and sheep subsist.
No other part of the world has ir
recent years suffered from such a
plague of locusts as the agricultura.
State of sub-tropical and teniperat
South America-Argentina. Bolivia
Southern Brazil, Paraguay ant
Uruguay share the affliction.
In these regions the swarms hav(
been steadily increasing for a num
ber of years. They are supposed t(
originate in the southerly part ol
the Amazon basin and in the Chaco
of Bolivia. and of Northern Argen
ina.
They come from the niorth ir
2louds that sometimes darken tht
3un and some of the swarms have
been estimated to be sixty milei
long and from twelve to fifteen mile:
wide. But these billions of flyint
nsects are only the forerurnners 01
:he greater mischief to come.
They make desolate the area ir.
which they settle, but often *jumi
wide areas in their flight. Befort
they take to the wing they lay bill
ions of eggs in the warm earth which
in a few weeks become hoppers
t is this young, voracious brood, be.
ore it can fly. that utterly strip.
he land of everyhing green a,
hough it had been burned over.
All the Governments are fighting
.he evil. Two years ago the Argen.
ine Government organized a burear
mnder the name of defensa genera
tgricola para for the destruction O
he locust. Last year the Argentint
longress placed $4,500,000 at thi
11sposal of this commission.
Sub-committees represent the gen
ral commission in every departnien
posed to these invasions and the)
xteud from the northern init c
griculture in the republic to th'
~eukuen River, almost to Patagonia
avevything possible is done to min
mize the damage.
A fine of 100 pesos is imposed up
n any settler failing to report t'
he sub-committee in his distric
he presence of locust swarms or hop
~er eggs on his land. An organizet
ervice embracing 4thousands of me:
:in readiness at any moment tr
end a force to any place where
anger is reported. The most ef
ective war is wagedi' aga'.inst th:
oung hoppers.
The official report is that as many
s 52,000 hopper eggs have beer
ounted in a space less thaln thre
nd a half feet square. A prodigioti'
umber of the young insects ar,
estroyed soon after -hatching b
eans of sprinkling carts filled witl
iquids. Still many of themo escap
nd the country they cover is to
ast to be entirely treated with th
sprinkling process. Fortunately rh
oung hoppers have a habit that fn
ilitates the destruction of mi!lion
>f them.
By the time they are two weei
>ld they have developed an e'ln'omou
tppetite. But they do not set on
to eat up the world in thin array o
'tathered detachments.
They collect here and there i:
eompact masses t'o move forward o:
the food, and when an army-. of' hot
pr's advances from OU(e sace t
another there is nothing left t
rt OU tihe gr'ound they have deser't
ed. They cannot fly. they move for
ward oinly from 400 to tiu0 feet:
day. Now is the time to trap them
In front of them a' trench is d u:
about six feet deep andi wid"- an.
100 to 2')) feet long. F'romt eat'l
end of the trench peaces of shee
tin about seventy-five feet long an'
a foot and a half high are stuel
into the ground. forming two line
of fence spreading fanlike from the
ends of the trench. These fene~
are etended till their outer ends ar
hundreds of feet apart. w-ide enoudg
to enclose the flanks of the invad
ing armlfy. Then all is readly for' ihr
drive.
It is hot work. beginninig a 51:n
Irise, and all the settler's andi th.
Government men senlt to their alt
take part in it with weapons tha
sre eff.ectiv'O- thiough they are onh'
piee of cloth, with which they Cla:
the ground and urge the hopper'
forward. \-ery oftenl dari--ess fall
and the rear' guard of t~he hoppr.
has not yet reached the brink ovr
which they tumble to their fate. 't'n
~hopers W' 1 t 11051'. IlI sttrs
and then the flapping of the cloth b
resumred till ths part it'r In rnty 1.
enguled. 'The crp and zra .ns
ahead are safe tot' a while.
B3ut such 1 work as this st readt ivE~:
evera cou ties(' is enormousfly~ ('N
pensive and is only a pailiative of.
the terrtible evil, not a renmdey fo:
itc emedy' ha~s not y-et heer
fouind. Can the plagule ot' locusti
re uenched if attacked 'at its head
sor~e7 Is ther"' an ta raite 01
van hea introducerl to qulenchu the.
,lague or mitigate it? Such rgues
*tions as th1ese are no0W being anxiousr
1. dI. -.4' in south Am1ori"n.
AGAINST THE STATE
JUDGE PRlTCHARD'S DECISI(
UPHELD ON APPEAL. -
The Court Says the Dispensary Coi
inissioners Held Dispensary Fun
as Trustees for Creditors.
'1he United States Circuit Cou
of Atpeals ir a decision hando
down at Richmond. Va.. on Wedne
day sustained the opinion of Jud
J. C. Prichard, in the famous v4
of Fleischmann & Co., and othe
against the South Carolina dispe:
sary commission. The opinion w,
writtcn by Judge James E. Boyd. <
Greasboro, N. C., and was concu
red in by his associates, Judge E<
mund Waddill and Chief Justice Fu
er. The opinion consumes more the
forty pages of closely typewritte
matter, a - great part of which is d4
voted to a statement of the facts.
In the opinion, Judge Boyd states
'There are two main proposition!
the jurisdictional, which presents tb
question whether this a suit againm
the State of South Carolina, and ther(
fore forbidden by the elevent
amendment, and, second, whethe
he dispensary commission is a cour
incapable of having its proceeding
stayed by a writ of injunction, grant
d by a Federal court. Does thi
ase come within the limits present
ed? In this connection it is neces
ary to inquire if the State has an:
present interest in the fund in contro
ersy. which can be divested, by :
judicial determination of the amount
if any, justly due the complainant, o
has the State, by an act of legisla
ure, relinquished all right, if an:
existed, to ~enough of the fund t(
pay all just debts of the State dis
pensary. The fund being in thi
hands of the commission, charge
with the duty of abolishing the -dis
pensary, the State has no interest. ir
so much thereof as is necessary tc
pay tle just debts."
"In what capacity," asks th(
ourt, are the members of the com
mission acting? Are they officers of
the State of South Carolina or offi
-rs appointed under the act of the
Legislature empowered to take pos.
;ession of a certain fuNd and direct.
id to administer such fuLfd in a cer
tain manner?
"We are constrained to hold thai
;he funds in their hands are held in
-rust for payment of .the debts men
ioned, that the creditors of the dis
ensary have a property in the fund
n the. hands of the commission tc
lhe extent that the debts are shown
>o be just. and that a judicial deter
ination of the true amount of sucb
ebts can in no way effect the rights
ind interest of the State.
"Iaving therefore dete'rmined thle
elation of the appellants to the
iunds in controversy, we answer the
testion propounded in the outset.
hat this is not a suit against the
~ta't. and that the complaint is not
r~idden to maintain his action by
e eleventh amendment of the con
titution of the United States'. This
uit is not against the State, nor it
he State an indispensible party.
"Treating the fund in the hands ol
e appellants as a trust fund, and
he duties of the trustees being clear'
dfned, the trustees are not ever
necessary party to a sd:. ,jrought
> compel the trustees to discharge
*heir duties. Their position appears
y be that the agents and represen
tatives of the debtor should consti
ite a tribuinal absolute in its charac
er to arbitrarily pass5 up~on what.,i
tnyt hing, is due an alleged creditor
d. if a claim be adjudged invalid
-vithout further opportunity for re'
liess on the part of the creditor.
To uphold such a contention would
e to deprive such a creditor of hi!
property without due process 01
The court further announes tha,
n the conception and adoptioni of th<
eleventh amendment, it never en
ered the minds of the frm'cer's o
'hat amendment that a sov'ereig:
;tate could engage in the liQuo
usiess, and become a tradar b:
buying and selling an article of comn
on trailic, in comipetitioni with th
itizes' of the country. It may b.
1utioed therefore, whether th
State of South Carolina w~as exgerei
g a governmnental prerogative i
)erforming a functionl necessarily *o
o'eriy lincident to its aut~foomy, a
State...
In r'eferenee to the pr'ovisicuts a
the eleventh amenment. Judg
oyd uses the following: "Undoubi
dly. the~ elev'enth amendment wit
intended to prevent the Feder'
ourt, in suits prosecuted by the ce
ens of another State or citizens 0
mubjects of a fofeign Stat.'. f rot
interfering with a State in the pr'esei
ation of its autonomy, in minnitluf
its own sy'stem of self-governmen~l
So long as such system is in ha
o with the constitultionl of ti
Lnited States. To this end, the
fore. the funds of the Ststt. inj
~rauy or held by its ofticers
gets for use in the admistrariC
I he governmlflenltal affairs of ti
State are not to be affected by tI
procss of the Federal court. nor ce
sic court entertain .iurisdicril
ana'; jon which us f'or its iupo
the :;vasionl of tl'e r'izhts '
State to manage and control its
tern;'1 affairs. or of an action whi
will ohstruct the State authority I
impair the State instrumnentabitis
the dischare of legitimate en
tons in the muainlanaliwt of
;tate's integrity.
As to whether the c-omuson
ourt is brictly consideredl. ]to
oyd. Citing the Constit.tiCU
at Carolina providing for theC
ablishment of the different ct-u
the eurt holding that while ihe cor
m issionrs were empowerd' to i
vestigate the transactions. ;* 'v "
not emnoweredl to determ;s :
irue of fact. enter any judgmec-n
onclude any party that might
,-nstla as to any right orine
- IJULX L' IJJI
Georgetown Boarding House Keel
Put Bullet Through His Brain.
A dispatch from Georgetown. s
Samuel M. Thompkins, 45 years
age, committed suicide Thursd
morning at 6:30 o'cloek by blowi
out his brains with a-.32 calibre i
n volver. Mr. Thompkins kept
boarding house on the corner
Prince and King -streets; he had
wife and two children, a&daughter
14 and a son 12 years of age.
rt Thompkins came to Georgetov
- about one year ago from Enterpri
a small village on the Waccamn
River, and previous to his residen
there he had worked very acceptab
in the store of Messrs. Burroug!
s & Collins, at Conway, and had maa
friends at that place, and in Hor:
S County. He was reared from a bN
d in Conway by Mr. W. R. Lewis, wl
married an elder sister, and wl
gave him the benefit of a good cor
I- mon school education. But untow
- circumstances followed the your
u man into later life, his health gal
n way and he has suffered recent
- from despondency. For the Dast s
months he has been out of steady <
remunerative employment, and th.
, fact seemed to prey upon his mind.
e After waiting upon his guests
t the table Thursday morning he stel
ped in an adjoining room, when tz
3 inmates of the house were startled b
r a pistol shot. Rushing to the apar
t ment from whence the sound pr<
s ceeded Thompkins was found lyin
- upon the floor with a bullet hole i
5 his head just above the right eai
- Physicians were immediately sun
- moned, but the unfor'unate . ma
breathed his last before their arriv
al.
KILLED FOR NOTHING.
Man Killed Over Last Drink of Wate
in Camp.
A dispatch from Bellefontaine, 0.
says fighting over the last drink o
water left in camp, the drought hav
ing dried up all thewells and spring,
in the vicinity, Frank Dadish wa!
shot. and killed by two men at tho
Ohio Electric Railway constructioz
camp Wednesday. Dadish wanted th1
water for his wife. in the last tw<
weeks it has become a serious propo
sition to supply the camp with water.
it being necessary to tramp threi
miles to'obtain a supply. Wednesda3
morning only enought water for g
drink was left. Rulu and Darrice
arrived, just as Dadish was pouring
the last bit of water -to carry to hi.
wife. The men demanded that h(
divide and when he refused, a fighi
ensued. During the scuffle the watei
was spilled on the ground.
CRUSHED TO DEATH.
Mob Pushes Young -Man in Front o1
Moving Train.
The wild rush of several hundred
men and women, most of them re
turning from a Sunday base bal:
game, to boabrd A train at Fair Hay
en, Pa., at 9.30 o'clock Wednesda:
night, caused the death of Wallac4
Wilson, aged 27. who was pushed ir
front of the train as it pulled int<
the station, by the crowding mass oj
people, endeavoring to -board thi
train.
The heroism of Miss McCleary. al
most saved Wilson's life, the gir
clinging .to him to the very last min
ute in an effort to save him fron
falling in front of -the train.
Stanley Dingo and Frank, Goarib
were also badly e'rushed by .being
pusied between two cars of the trait
by the excited crowd.
SPLIT IN HEARST PARTY.
Independenlce Candidate for Gover
nor of Georgia Is for Bryan.
An Atlanta dispatch says a seriou:
split developed in the Independenco
party of Georgia today, when Chair
man Sutler, of the State executiv
committee. annaunced that no elec
'oral ticket would be put in the field
At the same time National Chair
man Clapp, of the party. filed wit1
the Secretary of State a complete.li
of State electors.
Following a meeting of the Stat
executive committee an official state
-nment was given out by Chairma:
Berard Sutler, declaring that it wa
more imoprtanlt to wage a State can:
paign for Governor than to put a
electoral ticket in the field. Con:
menting on Tuesday's action, h
-said: "The action of our executiv
committee means that our candidal
Mr. Carter, will support Bryan an
Kern in the national election.
means further that Mr. Carter:
an independent Democratic candidat
for Governor."
involved. Judge Boyd then refersi
the opinion of the Supreme Court<
south Carolina deciding that a su
r against the dispensary commissi
n was a suit against the State. "TI
SSouth Carolina Supreme Court
a says the judge. "'is entitled to at
n has our most profound respect, b
.we do not feel entitled to adopt t1
construction given by that tribun
to the statute of South Carolina.
"It is our~ conclusion, therefor
h that the conclusion of the circ~
>r court for the district of South Car
lina, appealed from, should be affir
When Jurige Boyd finished rea
ing the opinion of the court. W.
SStevenlson, of Bennettsv~ille. ask
'that a reasonla')e stay be granted I
peparationl for an appeal in the ca:
He first asked for a stay of si~
days, but Judge Boyd suggested t~
t orty days would he ample time
n- whch to get ready for a writ of cC
rlorari to the Sup.reme Court oft
rUnied Stts. and an order ~
or tered directing that a stay of mn
bedae for that length of time be
tered.
IMMENSt UUWU
ts Hears Bryan in New York Cit
of
ay Friday Night .
e
a
* GREAT ENTHUSIASM.
of
,,n
e Shown on Al Sides as the Demo
ce cratic Candidate Opened the Cam.
paign in Greater Neiw York at
ly Carnegie Hall.
'y'
)y, Democratic presidential campaign
to in greater New York had its advent
1O Friday night when William J. Bryau
at a mass meeting under the auspi
ces of Tammany Hall spoke before
re enthusiastic thousands who ailled
y Canegie Hall and overflowed
into the streets. The ovation ac
corded to the'presidenta candidate
was a brilliant climax to. a day in
tt which a united party- paid Mr. Bryan
>- a conspicuous reception.
. Mr. Bryan spoke.for over an hour
y o
on "Republican Tendencies" at Car
negie Hall, and for over 10 minutes
g his audience a'pplauded his appear-,
arce on the platform.
Before the meeting the candidate
D spoke from a cart tail to an over
flowing gathering of New York's
thousands who stormed the line of
police to gain admission to the hall.
On his arrival in Now York Friday.
r Mr. Bryan spoke at a noonday meet
ing and during the afternoon held
constant levees at his hotel where
Democratic' leaders in the city and
r Stat'e .called upon him.
Previous to the Carnegie Hall
meeting Mr. Bryan was -entertained
at dinner at the home of Milbert E.
Cary. On approaching Carnegie Hall
a little later Mr. Bryan was given an
ovation by a crowd of 10,000 or
more persons who could not get in
the hall.
The candidate was taken to a flag
draped cart and from it he 'made
a brief speech. He was cheered re
peatedly, especially when a man in
the crowd tried to argue with him
and Bryan made a squelching reply..
"I- can speak to you only briefly,
as I have a long speech -to make
inside," said Mr. Bryan. "Let me
call your attention to the marked
difference between the Republican
platform and ours. The Republican
platform is different especially in not
outlining necessary legislation. Our
platform tells the public what we
think of what ought to be done. We
take the people, into our confidence
and thus we show not only our faith
in the merits of our policies but also
in the intelligence of tha. voters.
"No there are four propositions
as to labor fos whi'ch we stand. _
First, we believe that there should
be a department of labor with a cab
of the trust lagw..
"Second, we believe that labor
should be taken out of the operalon
of he rus law.
"Third, we believe that an induis
trial dispute should not be suffcient
cause for the Issuance of an infanc
tion.
"Fourth, we believe in trials by
jury in case of indirect contempt."
A man who claimed to be a union.
iron worker here attracted the atten
tion of Mr. Bryan and' asked him if
it were true that he had used the
expression that workmen were a lot
>f beggars when he was in congress:
"I speak as a representative of or
Janized labor." the man added.
"No, you do not," shouted Mr.
Bryan. "My record is will enough
known, so that no representative of.
organized labor would have to ask
me such a question."
"Did or did you not use that ex
pression?" insisted the man.
Bryan answered: "I shall not un
dertake now or at any other time to
-answer any and every statement that
may be made by those who are try
ing to help the Republican party
until they get an endorsement from
the Republican party or its repre
sentatives."
Mrr. Bryan then left the cart and
r., went into Carnegie Hall.
When Secretary Smith of Tamn
many Hall called the mass meeting
~to order every seat vwas taken and
every inch of space was filled. It
was an enthusiastic .audience and.
when Chairman Herman Ridder was
C introduced the crowd applaudod for
'several minutes. Mr. Ridder dwelt
on tariff reform.
While Congressman Sulzer war
speaking Mv. Bryan and his party
Sstepped f'rom an entrance upon the
stage. It was the Bryan demonstra
xtion of eight and twelve years ago
~that followed. Men leaped to their
ichairs and yelled and shouted while
n the band played lively tunes. Chair
iman Ridder's voice was lost as he
briefly introduced the Democratic
d candidate.
When quiet was restored, after a
~10-minute outburst s. enthusiasm.
SMr. Bryan began his speech. *
e* CARD GAME CAUSES KILLING.
- -One Negro Shoots Another in Woods
Near' Glenn Springs.
d- As the result of a quarrel over :a
game of cards Well Wofford is dead
or at his home near Glenn Springs, ha"
ing been shot by Jim West. Both
ti parties are colored. Last Sunday
,afternoon several negroes were en
rgaged in playing a game of cards in
e the woods. among thenm being Wof
*,ford and West: They fought as tq
who was winner, and West drew a
pistol and fired on' Wofford, shoot
jin hi thogh the stomach.