The Manning times. (Manning, Clarendon County, S.C.) 1884-current, June 27, 1894, Image 1
VL MW7
VOL. IX. - -- MANNSC.WENSAJN ,__O 4.
BUTLER AND TILLMAN.
THE GREAT SENATORIAL RACE BE
GUN AT ROZK HILL.
Senator Evans Made a Speech and Had
Some Passes with the Crowd-Pope and
TIndel Do Their Devoir-The O) her
Candidates 11 Not Spsak.
RoCK HILL, June 18.-The great
Senatorial cntest has begun. During
the early hours et the (lay hundreds of
people were congregated around Turn
er's Hotel, where both Butler and Till
man were quartered, and it was a Butler
crowd, the followers of the G overnor
not coming up into town in large rum
bers.
Two hundred Butlerites arrived yes
terday. Fifty of them came from Edge
field and the remainder from Greenville.
At 6:30 this morning the train from Col
umbia brought 450 more, all wool-hat,
hardy looking fellows, from Union,
Fairfield and stations aloag the C. C.
& A. road. A good many others came
in about 10:30 from the direction of
Charlotte. The audience at the meeting
numbered about 2,000.* Oae of the not
able passengers from Columbia was
Newbold, the dispensary detective. He
had to stand some mild guyig from the
country boys.
Shortly atter 10 o'clock this morning
Senator Butler made a ten minutes talk
to 250 of his supporters in Armory aall.
He started that a rumor had been cir
culated and telegraphed that Governor
Tilman was to be assassinated prompt
ly at noon by a prearranged plan. He
destred to state that so far as he knew,
therumor was unqualifiedly false. He
had never, he said. done or said a word
to cause a breach among the white
people, nor -would he. He hoped his
fiends would scatter themselves at this
meeting as they would at any other
meeting. He thanked them for their
presence and hoped they would go to
Yorkville tomorrow. He had no fear
for himself, and he did not see any rea
son why anybody should wish to kill
him, but he supposed he could as well
afford to die now as ever.
-The Senator -remarked that the
State executive committee had passed a
rule requirmg candidates to announce
themselves by June 17, and that in com
pliance he had written the following let
ter:
Edgefield, S. C., June 16, 1894.
To- Mr. D. H. Tom pkins, Secretary of
Democratic Exactive Committee,
Columbia, S. C.:
Dear Sir: I hereby announce myself
as a candidate for the United States
Senate for the term beginning March 4,
1895.
I presume the canditates for the
States Senator, will abide the result of
the primaries set for the 30th of August
next.
I hereby request that a seiarate box
1p provided by the State executive com
mittee at each and every voting precinct
m the State, in which each ioter may
express by his ballot his prefirence for
United States Senator, said iseparate
boxes to be managed uncer the same
rule as other ballot boxes in the prima
ries, and I hereby pledge myseli to abide
the result ol the vote thus cast at the
said primary. An early reply will oblige.
Very truly, M. C BUTLER.
The Senator said that it he could.
get afair primnary he would atide by it,
and not whine at the result if the people
preferred1 the other man. He could re
turn to Edgefield and fish for the remain
der of his life and spend it free etpublic
cares. What he wished was to get the
people to listen to argument.
THE EGULAB MEETING.
The speaking was at M'cres~ grtve.
hait a mile north of the centre of the
city. Congressman Strait war given
thirty mmnutes, the senatorial candidates
one hour each and ten minutes bar reply
and the candidates for Governor thirty
m-mnes each. At precisely twonminutes
past eleven, Senator Butler ani Con
gressman Strait arrived on the ground.
The stand is an ordinary woods plat
form, bilt against a majestic- white
oak. It stands in the midst ot a splendid
grove.
A the Senator steps upon thestand,
attired in bluish cambric neelireeishirt,
scarf- and black clothes,~ ~onis one
shoas, "Hurrah for Butler," anii con
siderable cheering follows. One voice
shouts for Tmlman.
.In a moment Governor Tilman, wear
ing a white helmet and black alpaca
coat, low quartered shoes and, greenish
yellow socks, follows, and cheers, scarce
ly so general as Butler's, greet him. He
takes a seat at the rear of the stand and
leans against the oak. John Gary Evars
-seats himsell at his right elbo N' and Tin
dal directly behind. Samps Pope, El
lerbe, Buchanan, Watts, John Walter
Gray and Mayfisld seated themselves
around the stand, with Butler holding
the left flanking seat.
President White of the Rock Hill
Democratic Club called the meeting to
order. Bev. W. G. White prajed and
the band played.
President White intrcduced Congress
man Strait as the first speaker. Ho
body cheer ed as he faced the crowd. It
began to sprinkle rain gently, damper
ing the spirits of the assemblage, and the
Congressman's remarks appeared to
have a similar effect.
GOV. TILLMAN SPEAKS.
At the conclusion of Congressman
Strait's speech President White, after
cautioning the crowd not to interrupt
the speakers, Introduced Governor
Tillmnan.
The cro wd had waited patiently for
the Senatorial guns to fire and broke
into applause when Chairman White
introduced Governor Tillman and an
nounced the order of the remainder of
the spaking. The Governor advanced
in the cool, deliberate manner usual to
him. He said he was the only mnan in
Houth Carolina who had tried to canvass
the tstate three times, county by county.
He brought applause and loud laughter
when he said he was glad to meet the
audience face to face even though many
of them came from North Carolina and
all over the globe. He was accused of
having a bitter tongue, but he stood
here and said he was not resp~nsible
for all the bitterness. He had been
more persecuted and maligned than
any other man. The people, Tillmn
said, had elected him tO office before
and were going to send him to the
Senate sure as a gun's iron. (Loud ap
plause.)
He said he had been Governor four
years and stood ready to defend his
every act. He made an appeal foi
brotherly love In the coming campaign
and paid an eulogy to the farmers al
the backbone of the country. He said
he was proud of being a farmer Gov
ernn.He had never run for office til
cver 38 years of age. Taen he had gone
for the biggest plum on the tree and g
shook it down. le was now after a
bigger plum and i-tended to get it. a
(Applause.) b
His friend Butler had been in ofcice n
eighteen years. The office belonged to d
the people not to any man, u
The Governor next said he supposed a
the candidates for the Senate must dis- n
cuss nationai issues. He would simply c;
take a bird's eye view of the situation. I
There were only two big questions-the v
tariff and finanxe. He wouldn't touch 1,
on the tariff to day and would discuss a.
finances to some extent. He jumped el
into the question by showing the great fh
contraction of the money of the court- si
try. In 1865,he said, there was $2.000,- G
000,000 of mmey in circulation; now 1h
there is only-S1,000,000,000. Tuat was n
tte reason the poor farmers of the b
country wer not getting a reward for h
their labor. He charged all this to Il
Wall street. Shylocks, backed by Lom- C
bard street.London. These Shylocks t<
had caused his contraction by putting
the issue pcer in national banks. The I
people wercontinually getting poorer
and all the 'ealth of the country is in cl
the hands o a few thousand million- t<
aires. il
The Govelor jumped on the national C
bank quesbn and defended green
backs. He rplained the difference be- n
tween them. Money sharks said green- s1
backs weri fiat money. That fiat tl
money, hoever, had whipped the -
South in theate war. Purchased Con- 12
gressmen ad Senators yelled "Fiat e2
money" becise they had been bought. h
The spear then began the discus- OJ
sion of thesilver question. le said ca
gold and ster had been on a parity ti
since the da) of Abraham and ought t
to be now. 'he Democratic platform W
adopted at icago had said they were gi
equal, but Oveland hadn't carried out t(
the plank. leveland was a confessed
perjurer andesponsible for the present r
deplorable ctdition of the Democratic G
party. He crged Cleveland and Car- h:
lisle with hacs-pocus game in issuing oJ
$50,000,000 c bonds to replenish the u]
gold reservewhich is again down to 01
65,000,000. lie charged a lot of thiev
ing and rotbry in Washington, but si
said some da the people will get to
gether and fere will be a big shaking P4
up. (Laught.) a
He attacki Cleveland as an old bag g
of beef who'be could not find words .
to describe. lie said John Sherman s1
the people's eimy, was now the trusted w
advisor of Cleland, who has betrayed w
every trust. he country is in its pres- pi
ent conditionerough the treachery of i1
a Democraticresident.
The Goverir reviewed in a clear
manner the imonetization of silver
and the bad cdition of the country. ni
He said there'e millions of starving st
workngmeB. Uoney sharks, he said, f
have grown ) outrageous in their
treatment analk as to wish a stand -
ig army to k a few starving men
off the grass. ie alluded to Coxy and
his ragged meland said poor Coxy had
had his heatracked. There might di
not be any Co~ites in the South, but
the people hei sympathize with the
demands of lair.
Resuming scussion of the silver
question, the ivernor said the people
the dragon etircling them. They W
would do it witiheir votes and could
hot be boughtwith money or free w:
passes. This wahis first direct allusion
to tne free passree excursion of But- cc
lerites and brccit loud applause from a,
his supporters. fa
The fight. he aid, must be for free a
silver and maore treenbacks. The Gov- pl
ernor said the euth and West must vi
get together and nake a fight for liberty ti
and bread. He oncluded by telling a is
story of big JohnJones anid his ox, a a
story about an ox's tail being tied I
though the dastboard of a vehicle. bi
Ihe Governor sail if sent to the Senate fr
e woul-l promise tot to be bribed and lil
not to sell out. He~ would chunk rocks tc
for the people's irterest as long as he B
ould use his tongte and would do all ha
e could. b
Just as the Governor was concluding,
some man in the audience remarked
that Tillman would not get to the si
Senate to chunk rocks. T
Turning toward the speaker and G
waving his hand, the Governor said w
Ihat sixty-tive taiousand white men had
elected him to his oflice and would send E
him to the Senate. This elicited loud al
md prolonged applause. b
SENATOII BUTLER sPEAKS. si
At the conclusion of Gov. Tillman'sp
speech he was heartily cheered and the ti
and played. As the last note of mu- t
sic died away there was a cry for But- P
[er, who was then introduced by the
~hairman. Hie said: g
"I'm mighty glad to see you. I am
ad to see you in a good humor. I'm
lad that Governior Tillmani was in a
;ood humor. I shall meet him with
hhe same respectful bearing. The
Lovernor says he has been eccused of
Liaving a bitter toingue. Well, a fishP
woman can wield a bitter tongue, but
it requires courage to speak to an in-e
eligent and well informed audience "
ike this before me.h
"I have a proposition to make to the h
lioveror. If he will agree to have a l
separate ballot box at each voting pre
inct in which the people, I mean the
white people, in the primary in Septenx-I
ber may register their choice for Sen
itor, without the interference of ringsb
mud caucusses, I shall agree to abide by b
Lt. 'Will he do that ?" -0
Voices-No, ne, no."h
"Ob.~ I think he will," said the Senia- P
tor. "Will he agree to submit to the
people whether he or I should repre
sent them in the Senate ? I will aoide
by it." (Cheers.) i
"The Governor says that the Senate le
desn't belong to me; I didn't ask to go V
tere. I did not asar for the privilege '
of accepting the volume of abuse P
which the Republicans hurled upon me .
when I was fighting for my seat. Men
who rode by me in camp and bivouac 1
called on me for what seemed a for- e
lon hope, and I would not refuse, be
ause I felt it was my duty. I would '
not go through that experience agamnl
for any office.
"If we are to judge gf the Governor
n the Senate by the speech he has
made, what a spectacle be would be, t
driving an ox cart with the ox tail in 0
the dashboard; flinging rocks from the c
mountain top. What could he accom- f
lih in the Senate making such a veri- t:
table spectacle ofhimself ? s
"We have heard a good deal said g
about finance, Clevreiandi being bought I
Iand free passes. I submit that that is t
a delicate question for the Governor, a
(Cheers.) 1 think he had better let the bi
subject drop. Has it come to this that I
a man in South Carolina can't ride on j
a train without asking Marse Ben ? I Li
have asked for passes for poor men 's
out of a job. Has the Governor everi
asked a pass for a poor man? (Wild t
cheering.)
Voice--He asked for one for him- a
self." "-Fierce cheering, which Butler (
had to quiet.)
Some voices shouted for Tillman.
The speaker then compared Tillmjan
to a young mule, who, when working
in double harness, kicked and bit at 1
the other mule and did no pulling, lie
then ridiculed the Governor's love of
office.1
Man in the crowd-"Don't you love 1
oflice, too ?"
-Yes, I do, pretty w ell," responded
mknthe Seato, yeng the man coolly.
Lye God, I tell the truth; I haven't
one crazy about oflice. though."
The Governor is in nis "A, B, C'S"
bout finance. One of his friends calls
im a "genius of destruction." A com
ion tramp may blow up a house with
ynamite. The Governor talks about
tonopuies %nd robberies, but he sug
ests no remedy. He will get on a
ountain and throw rocks,drive an ox
trt with the ox's tail in the dashboard.
am under the impression that he
ent to cbicago a supporter of David
. Hill, whe at the beginning of his
treer, nps stabbed the party by de
aing against the income tax, the
drest clause in the tariff bill. That
iould teach you what to expect of the
overror. I am as far from Cleve
.nd as the poles from each other, and
D one is better aware of it than he,
at 1 take no stock in this abuse ot
im. The tariiY bill will be passed.
is the best tariff bill ever before
ongress, because it is not satisfactory
the extremes of each side.
Voice--It does not represent the
emocratic party."
Butler-"It is a bill which the Demo
atic party can stand on." The Sena
ir then defended the bill fully, assert
ig that its duties were f; per cent.
wer than the Mills bill.
"I predict that the next Republican
itionai convention will put in a free
Iver plank in their platform. I favor
Lat the Democrats of tbe South and
orth and West begin now and organ
e silver leagues. I believe the country
in sustain double the amount of green
Leks in circulation without one dollar
gold in the country. The Republi
n party is responsible for the condi
n of the South. I believe when the
riff bill is passed that the revenues
ill be ample for the support of the
>ernment. I am as much opposed
the bond issue as the Governor is.
To illustrate a Doint in silver de
onetization, the Senator said: "If the
overnor will lend me the dollar he
is, I'll show you; (smiling) he's better
f than I am." (The crowd laughed
>roariously.) I'll give it back to him
else play crack-loo for it."
The Governor came forward with a
ile and handed him the dollar. -
The Governor says greenbacks whip
d us. I was thar. It was muskets
Ld bayonets whipped us, or rather we
>t tired out whipping the Yankees.
Then the Senator explained the pen
?n infamy and said that the reason
by it was not checked was because
a hadn't the votes. He incidentally
did a tribute to the Confederates, say
g that there never were such soldiers
the soldiers of Lee and Jackson.
The Senator held up a large yellow
velope. "I have plenty of ammuni
yn here. I want the Governor to
iderstand that when I tackle the
ate administration I shall do it
ankly, though in perfect good hu
or. When I warm his back he must
ke it like a little man. He must
ke his punishment. I shall take
ine. I am used to it.
I know the farmers are poor. I un
rstood that the Governor promissd
hen elected that he would help the
rmers. Are they better off ? On the
her hand taxes have been increased.
hall stand side by side with my peo
al their struggle. I challenge Gov
2ere I have not done my duty. It is
-ong to turn a man out of the Senate
ly because he has done his duty. I
Juld lay down public life forever if I
uld thereby see my people united
Ad living as brothers as they were
ur years ago. I utter a warniug and
predictioD, that when the white peo
divide and appeal to the negro
ite we shall have a period of degrada
n worse than reconstruction. There
nothing for me in the Senate. I am
poorer man than when I went there.
have not learned to steal or accept
ibes, I can't be captured by gold or
ee asses. (Cheers.) It may be a
tle vain, but I believe I am the man
,bring the people together. Senator
atler was continually cheered, and
id often to stop and quiet his friends
'fore proceeding.
GOY. TILLMAN IN REFLY.
At the couclusion of Senator Butler's
eec, Col. Jones said that Governor
lilman was entitled to a re ply. When
overnor Tillman came to the front he
as loudly cheered.
The Governor began his closing re
arks by saying that he just wanted to
iswer a few little firecrackers shot off
his friend. In regard to the propo
ion, if Butler believed that the peo
e ought to have the right to elect
nators and if the Democratic Execu
ve Committee is willing t-> grant the
oposition he hadl no objection.
"Butler went on to talk about my
ftting among the plow boys. I1 want
ask you if the farmers did not put
e up to lead a forlorn hope.
'-Yes, they did and you won!" said
any voices.
"Since that time I have been more
aligned than any man in the State."
response to a question from a man
.the audience about his chances of
ection, the Governor said he had
Lone got the coon skin and was gone."
Abouit free passes, the Governor told.
>w he had accepted one and said But
r 'had ridden on one all his life. He
ten showed up how many in the crowd
id come here on free passes.
These men didn't come here from
orth Carolina and all over the State
r nothing. They could veil, he said,
it couldn't vote in York County. He
iused great cheering when he said he
4 York County and would thank the
ople in advance for the vote of
e county. The Governor told
hat he bad done since he had been the
hief Executive and said he had noth
to shield. in his life. About But
r's story of the old mule and C~he
>ung mule, he asked the farmers
hich they bad rather have, a young
ancng mule or an old flop eared,
orn-Out animal.
"We'll take you:" shouted many amid
ughter at Butler's expense as a ilop
ired animal.
The Governor said he had not voted
r Hill but for Boles at Chicago, But
r having charged him with being a
ipporter of the former.
SENATOR BUTLER IN REPLY.
When Senator Butler came for ward
reply, both factions cheered vocifer
usly tor some minutes. The Sena':or
baracterized the Governor as an art
1 dodger in fleeing behind the execu
.e committee in the proposition for a
parate box. He bad asked for a cate
orical answer and had ex pected one.
the charge of ringism he was sus
ried by the high authority of no less
personage than John L. M. Irby, who
ad charged that there was a State
[ouse ring. If the Governor had
iven the peorle the primary, why did
e now permit it to be violated ? Why
ras a convention to be held in August ?
Vhy were not all men allowed to go to
oe polls andl vote?
The Senator clcsed by sayicg that the
ssessment on the railroads, which
overnor Tillmen "had throttled, had
eenreduced." There was again long
ot mued cheering.
HON. JiOiN GARY EVANs SPEAKS.
Comptroller GeneraJ Ellerbe was in
roduced, but said he would not speak
is dinner time was -m hand and the
>eoole were tired; it they would come
o Yorkville tomorrow he would talk
o them, ie iinished amid applause.
Senator E-P.ans was next introdnced
md was warmly received, lie said he
tion, of which he was a part, agains
Senator Butler and if the Senatoi
spanked his (Evans') baby, he woul
put a mustard plaster under Butler':
shirt. (Laughter.) Senator Evan,
brought down the audience by sayinj
he was glad to see all the anti Tillman
ites of the State present. Every coun
t y was represented and a good deal o:
North Carolina was on hand. Touch
ing on National affairs. Evans sai(
Cleveland was a prostitution of Demo
cracy, and ir being a follower of Cleve
land was a Democrat, he (Evans) could
be called anything else.
"Didn't you vote for Hill?" a mat
asked.
"No, I did not," was the quick reply
"and the only ones I know who did ar
men now supporting Butler for Sena
tor. Ben Perry, for instance."
Evans made a good many pointed
jabs at Butler, tickling his friends im
menselv. He continued his attack o
Cleveland and defended the Democrac3
of the Reformers of the State. Senatoi
Evans said it was the old men who ha
been kicked out of office who were keep
ing the political ball open; it was noi
thevo ung men.
Evans parried in quick and neat man
ner a number of questions asked him,
He got in a blow on Butler whernsvez
he could and was asked by a young
man named Gus Aiken if he was run
ning for Senator or Governor. A col
loquy ensued between them.
Evans attacked Butler for his state
ment that State taxes have not beer
reduced and showed this was erroneous
He said if the Senator was as ignoran
on national affairs as on State, he wa.
in a bad fix.
Again defending the State adminis
tration, he upheld the Dispensary law
His declaration that it was the best las
for control of whiskey was hissed b3
several young men.
"I can tell that you fellows are from
North Carolina by the color of youi
noses," the speaker said to them. Ev
ans told how the Dispensary law had
been adopted and said it had reduced
crime and drunkenness to the minimum
In his own town only one arrest had
been made for drunkenness during the
Dispensary regime. The first night the
law was declared unconstitutional, thir
teen arrests were made. He gave fig
ures in favor of the Dispensary and
strongly defended it. He said lie will
advocate the Dispensary from every
stump in the State and if elected Gov
ernor will enforce the law to the letter.
"What about the Darlington affair?'
was asked.
"I am glad you mentioned that." he
said. "It was a premeditated affair,
brought on by the whiskey element."
He then told of the refusal of the
troops to go to Darlington and the of
fer of thousands of wool hat boys to
fight with shot guns and hickory sticks
South Carolina will never bow to the
whiskey element. The people will not
surrender to the little whiskey sellers
and grog shop aeepers.
"Why did you turn down Hampton?"
was asked.
"Because h's didn't represent us an
we will turn down anybody else who
does not."
"Why haven't you got a Governor
who knows the law?"
"We have a Governor who knows
together."
Evans concluded by saying that he
would continue his discourse at York
ville, where he would be glad to see all
North Carolinians and revenue offi.
cers." (Applause.)
MESSS. rOPE AND TINDAL SPEAKS.
Dr. Sampson Pope was introduced
and announced himself as a candidate
for Governor and said he would define
his principles, and declared that he
had always been a Reformer and
would continue one. The Reform
movement had done more good that
any administration. Taxes had not
been greatly reduced, because the .State
ad been forced into litigation at great
expense. Coosaw had been tnrottled
and the railroads had been made tc
come under the law. He showed thai
the railroads had not been paying at
equal proportion of taxation. Dr. P'opf
recited all things done by the adminis
tration. He also defended the Dispen
sary law and said it was the best lami
ever put on the statute books. If he
could not get the Dispensary he wai
for high license. Dr. Pope tavored al:
the Alliance demands within the Dem
ocratic party and said the sub-treasur3
was the best of all these demands. Hi
showed the great benefits of that plan
He also attacked Cleveland and saic
he stood in with Wall street. He saic
he despised Hill. He believed Tillmat
would be the next Democratic nominel
for President. Dr. Pope expressed th(
views on national politics enumeratec
by him before.
Secretary of State Tindal, the las1
candidate for Governor introduced
commended th3 Rock Hill people foi
their peaceable conduct. He told what
good the Reform movement had ac
complished. Things in the State be
fore the movement was successfuli
were stagnant. Governor Tillman wa
not responsible for the strife in th4
State. Turmoil was inevitable anc
would have resulted had any man beer
elected Governor. Tindal spoke foi
peace and unity. Both the minoritj
and the majority must use toleration
He wanted his Conservative friends t<
remember that the Reform movemen1
would never go backward. Tindal hai
no good. words for Cleveland. He spoki
some on national affairs. When hi
concluded he was applauded.
W. D. Mayfield was announced as
candidate for Superintendent of educn
tion; J. Gary Watts for Adjutant an<
Inspector General; 0. W. Buchanan, fo:
Attorney Generst and James Nortol
for Comptroller General. They mada
no speecnes.
At the close Col. Iredell Jones, pre
siding instead of Mr. White, who ha<
been forced to leave on account of sick
ness, dismissed the crowd which hai
already thinned to a few hundred, rap
idly dispersed.
Killed Before the Family.
JACKSONVILLE, Fla., June 18.-I
special to the Times-Union from Tamp
Fia., says: Tillett Whidden killed Ton
Swain yesterday at the dinner Table.
S wain was an escaped convict who hal
been sentenced for life for murder, an<
for whom a large reward was offered
Whidden met S wain, and protessin!
friendliness, invited him to his (Whid
den's) house a dinner. Swain accepted
and while eating Widden ordered him ti
throw up his hands. Swain reached foi
his gun and Whidden shot him dead
Mr. Whidden at d several child
ren were at the table when the traged
occurred. Whidden pu Swain's corps
in r. luggy and brought it to Tampa. H
drove ab:>ut lifteen miles overa lonel3
road with the body of his victim, reach
lg Tampa about midnight.
Du1iuso a thunderstorm last Wed
nesday afternoon th~e lightning struc
the signal pole of the weather obsers
er's office int W ilmington, N. C, whic
was raised on the top of the Goverr
ment building. The pole was ehat
tered and the~ halliards parted whe:
the flags came down with a run. Th
building was not damaged at all, a]
though the shock was felt all over i1
espeially on the upper floor occupie
by the weather observer and the Unit
te ta esa engineer officials.
THE YORK MLEETIMt.
I GREATEST iNTEREST IN THE FIGHT
FOR THE SENATE.
The Crowd Lar gly in Fayor of TI1lm-n
Butler Makes a Good Speech-Ssn-psfi
of the t'peechm Mad-, by it-e Diftfrent
Caudidatep.
YORKVILLE, S. C., June 19.-Tning
warmed up a little at today's campaigi
meeting. The crowd got somewhat
enthusiastic. The best of bumor.how
ever, prevailed. Everyone went away
happy and contented, and no anger
was shown. Today's meeting empha
sized one thing strikingly, the audi
ences do not care three snaps for any
thing except the Senatorial debate.
The enthusiasm was below zero until
the central figuies, Butler and Till
man appeared. Then the voters braced
tremselv up, and were all interest and
showed their feelings They listened
to the others, they laughed and noted
the argument, but when General But
ler was announced there was a decided
change in the atmosphere. A complete
change had come over the scene.
Chairman J. Steele Brice, in opening
the meeting, begged that this be made
a repetition of the model meeting held
here two years ago. The Rev. Mr. W.
G. Neville made the opening prayer.
JOHN GARY EVANS
was introduced as "from Edgefield,'
but he promptly corrected the state
ment that he was from Aiken.
He continued: Whether we be Re
formers,Independents or Conservatives
or Republicans our interests are one.
That banner can go with the one un
der which we have won, "Equal rights
to all and special privileges to none.'
We are not Populists or Communists,
but are working for one interest. We
now have a ring of entirely new peo
ple. See to it that you are not dicta
ted to by the bosses. No man has the
right to fear for the interests of his
State, of the people. Nearly all of the
measures advocated in our platform
have been enacted into law. There is a
demand for a constitutional conven
tion and that'has not been acted on.
The Constitution you live under was
made by a people who had no interest
in you; yet we are told to keep this
dangerous Constitution. I tried to
amend it and was voted down. We
pay too much to tbe classes whose in.
terests are not ours in proportion to
the taxes paid. That means if this
country ever gets into the hands of the
carpet-baggers the negro has equal
rights in all your schools. There is
great danger in this provision. The
schools should be put under the people
through the Legislature. Vote for a
constitutional convention. New York
has outgrown her Constitution. and
oars was modelled after theirs. Every
Confederate soldier is* stigmatized in
y:>ur own Constitution as a rebel.
We "Reformers" have started out on
the platform of the Alliance. Those
demands are today the only true De
mocracy. We have been called all
g -p ca1ege j -ehad
to old Jeffersonian Democracy. We
are fighting for principle and if we
keep it up we are bound to win. I
stand upod every demand in there. It
is claimed that we have done nothing
for the peopie. We refunded your debt
with an annual saving of $80,000 a
year. We actually had men go to New
York and say the debt would be repu
diated. They ran Dr. Bites and Gov.
Tillman out of New York by their ma.
licious reports. They even wanted to
continue the debt at 6 per cent. when
they knew negotiations were pending
for the settlement of the bonds. The
next year the bill was telegraphed to
New York. Why was it done? For
political purposes. They were trying
to fly-blow the whole debt. We went
over to Baltimore and placed the
whole thing and they went away like
they had their tail cut. [H-urrabs.] A
patriot of South Carolina wantea the
State to fail in placing the bonds.
They are all coming over, but we
must not baptize too many at .one
time. Don't let them all in at one time.
They may break the plank. We have
even converted the State. The scales
on his back are too thick to let him in
with one scraping. We have to mark
him with a red star and anoint himi
and baptize him before we let him in.
About this time a train passed by
and Evans said: 'Let her roll!" and i'll
wait. The dlspensary law is the best
tfing you have ever had. We found
South Carolina drunk as a lord. We
could not take avnay the liquor at once,
we took It away gradually. We tooE
temptation away from the boys. P
dacreased drunkenness oyer '5 per
cent.
The audience did not seem to be in
the humor to applaud, and only did so
wen he made a good point or a laugh
able suggestion.
[COMPTROLLER GEN'ERAL ELLERBEE
was in good trim. He said that, al
though he had been cussed and dis
cussed, he had no intention of apolo
gizing for anything he had done. My
couiD, for he is my cousin, is some
what ashamed of me because as a plsir
farmer I can't speak like he does.
SWhen I am elected he will call me
S"cousin.', and then i'll give him a trial
justiceship. [Laughter.j
SWhen I went into office I found thi
-property not fully assessed. I sent out
circulars to my auditors to increasi
assessments to the full value of th4
property. We have increased the val
ation of the railroad property tc
a~out $7,000,000 as it now stands to
- day. We raised the South Caroline
I and Georgia road to S16,000 per milb
and that was when the bonds wern
I worth on the market about $7,000,000
-It's t~he same thing with the othae:
roads. The Columbia and Greenvll4
bonds were worth on the market $17,
000 and we assessed it at $10,500. Yet
they cried we were trying to ruin ths
state.
Recently we got over S200,000 thal
escaped taxation, and yet this property
is no higher than any other. You ai.
remember the bank cases. I only or
dered the auditors to tax the propert:
according to law, in the Newberr:
Bank case the bank showed S300J.000 ir
- stock and surplus. The auditor as
,sessed them at $230,000, but the Couri
)fixtd that at $150,000, which is lesa
than 50 per cent. I am sorry to sa)
when I came in I founc. shortages.J
told the sheriffs to enforce executione
v and we are making better collection!
than tbey ever did.
, Mr. Ellerbee told a very laughable
story of how a young lady tried to havy
him stop a tax execution, which occa
sioned considerable merriment.
ie continued: We defeated Coosaw
We refunded the State debt, whici
saves you S50,000 a year. We buill
i Clemson College for your sons, wher'
- we mossbacks can be educated. Oui
i Penitentiary is now managed as wel
-as any in the country, while now Col
-Neal is turning money over to thi
treasury. Yet w'e are asked what wt
e have done. Yet we have done all this
- without increasing your taxes, a]
;, though when we went in we xounc
i $50,000 debt. We had to raise taxec
-last year because we had money tieC
up by the railroads. Then look at th4
litigation they forced us into. Then
we are building your colleges.
I joined the Alliance when it was
frst organized, and I believe in it. I
believe it will do us good. It is an or
ganization to help the agricultural
classes. They tell you our demands
are unconstitutional, and they would
not know the Constitution coming
down the road. [Laughter.] Anything
would do better than what we have. It
is time to do something for the people.
He touched lightly on the banks.pro
tection. free silver, national aid to the
railroads and the Alliance demands.
le favored national control of the
railroads, especially those rFded by the
Government. The roads can be re
produced for three billion dollars and
they are trying to pay interest on nine
billion dollars. Ie favored an income
tax. He wanted some way to send tax
perjurers to the Penitentiary. I am in
favor of peace and unity myself, but
there is one thing our people will have
to understand, and that is the minority
cannot dictate to the majority. Repub
licanism would be a cruel fallacy it
this was the case.
There was not a flatter or a word of
applause as Mr. Ellerbee finished, al
though his speech took very well with
the audience.
CANDIATE TINDAL.
opened by saying that for eight years
he had been working to build up the
"Reform" party. He did not feel like
a stranger.
He continued: You were in bygone
days suffering from political lethargy.
You felt an oppression and a wrong,
but you did not know the cause. I
then tried to tell you what was your
trouble and that is why you are here.
What you want to kno w is what you
are voting for. Tcday I am a candi
date, not of my own choice, but be
cause my friends want me to run. The
great acts of the "Reformers" are the
building of Clemson College, the Win
throp College and the railroad tax
figrht, which really meant that they
niust pay the same taxes as others, and
I venture to say the roads and the peo
ple hereafter will be on more friendly
terms.
You have today an honest and effi
cient Government-. It is a Govern
ment of white people. No one denies
that. Why can't we have peace in
South Carolina? Nothing we have
done is disputed. Why not come to
gether? All of our people speak for
Deace. I never have been able to be
lieve that any portion of our people
can be enemies to the State. Nearly
all we suffered during Radical days
was brought about to perpetuate the
party. All we want is a Democratic
party in this State. We want one uni
ted force to accomplish our work in
Washington.
The "Reform" party has never de
prived anyone of his rights. If I can
remove any prejudices against the Al
liance 1 would be glad to do so. The
politics of the Alliance are as open and
as broad as the noonday. It has no se
crets except those connected with its
business, like a merchant's private
mark, of which none complain. When
the Alliance went in it went to fight
trusts and extortions. The farmers
found they must work together, and
when they opened their eyes they
giving $18,000,000 to sugar growers as
a bounty; it found farmers almost de
prived ot the use of money with which
to raise crops. Thea the Aliance got
up its demands in order to get you to
direct your attention to the questions.
It binds no man's conscience. In
Ziarcb, 1890, I introduced the platform,
from which I will read extracts.
Mr. Tindall made a good, clear, forci
ble speech.
DR SA31PsON POPE
made an exceedingly clear cut, open,
plain speech. lHe wanted the Constitu
tion overthrown so as to insure white
supremacy. Vote for it, he said, and
there willibe no danger of the white
people separating. He favored pro
tetion and said: You have not suffer
ed by the sugar bountry. You have
betn benefited more than hurt, getting
five cents sugar. E verything is cheap
as dirt. We only need more money.
The rariff does not hurt you. I would
have voted for high license, but after I
saw the operations of the dispensary I
ow favor the law. If unconstitutional,
then as alast resort i'd go for high
license. Prohibition does not prohibit.
If thelaw is passed there ought to be
a State board of police commissioners.
There never was and would never have
been an innocent man's house searched
I would not be a Prohibitionist. The
bitterness was not due to "Reformers,'
but to the ne wspapers.
He charged that all the newspapers
except the Greenville News and the
Register had worked against the State
refunding its debt. The Greenville
News, he said, did not even spell reform
correctly. Mr Smythe and others had
gotten $15,000 for defending the rights
of the Coosaw Company, from which
the State got no money, and it was
said he was also paid by thie company,
and the old Administrations thought
Coosaw could not be made to joosen
its grips.
Tne announcement of
D. E. FINLEY
as candidate for Congress brought
aboui; considerable applause. lie said,
in opening, that he had always been a
consistent "Reformer." He was bound
by their platform. For the last four
years he had always advocated every
measure looking to the curtailment of
expenses. He thought he had done as
much as anyone in this line. He _in~
trouced the bill for the reorganmzation
of the University and the salary re
duction bill. The delay in passing
this bill was not on his account. He
had no apologies to make. He was
equally frank to say some measures
passed did not meet with ;his opproba
tion. He did not vote for the dispen
sary law because he did not think it
wise. He did not vote for the "Biack
district" bill.
Continuing he said: I am here as a
candidate because1I want office. The
inancial question deserves attention.
The pension law has greatly
inj urea the South. Ten per cent
of all money incirculation~ is paid
Ithee pensioners. It amounts to rob~
bery. Our Representatives have not
fought this as they should. A tight
must be made. I believe in the free
coinage of gold and silver. I do not
believe that the repeal of the State
bank tax would relieve the situation.
Dr. Strait has made no fight for Daper
money to be issued direct by tbe United
States Government. I will go to Wash
ington representing you all, not to
make a fight for oflices. Mr. Bissell
will never have any opportunity of
passing on my Democracy. I won't
let him do so. [Ilurrahs for Finley.]
- CONGREsSSAN STRAIT
started out tby talking of the snakes
.and devils and treacherv and horrors of
Wall street. The tariff bill is a poor
thing without a daddy. It puts intc
the hands of the Sugar Trust over
$100,000,000 by its provisions.
Col Talbert is our leader on pensions.
.e voted for the unconditional repeal
of the State bank tax. If the people
don't want State banks they need not.
state banks would be an experiment.
- I begged nlo man for a recognition 01
I my Democracy.
sFinley: I did not say that, and meant
I no re flection on you..
SDr. Strait: it looked to me that way.
I have not gotten any offices. I Voice:
What adout Hemphill?l
Strait: He got his package marked
patronage and not marked "Corigres
sional." [ urrahs for Strait and "Say !"j
DR TIMMERAN
was introduced as a candidate
for Lieutenant . Governor. As
he got up there was a titter, and a
few said, "Oh, my, look there!" dS they
looked at the man with the harelip
nose. He said what he wanted about
politics and announced that his chief
claim for the nomination was his good
looks. (rbis was a joke on its face
The crowd yelled and whooped. but Dr
Timmerman went on and said that
about his only rival on looks was Nor
man Elder, of York, and they kept on
laughing. The woman, he said, must
see something in his looks as he had
been mirried twice. (Laughter and
hurrabs.]
SENATOR BUTLER
was greeted with applause as he walk
ed straight up to the end of the plat
form. He spoke right out and was
given close attention. He said an of
fice holder was responsible to the peo
ple and the officers were not the masters
The people here are the rulers and the
sovereings. It is not osly your right but
your duty to demand of every man in
office an account of the trust. Just
here I wpuld like to make a personal
explanation. Messrs Shell and Mc
Laurin have requested me to say
something about an alleged political
combine with them, and a statement
thatthey had been traitors to the Reform
Movement. There never was any
foundation for the report, and I should
not have noticed it except for their re
quests. 1 have always tried to treat the
"Reform" Congressmen with respect.
[Just at this jucture two men got into
a personal fight, but Gen Butler and
Chairman Brice quieted the crowd.]
Continuing Gen Butler said he would
criticise Governor Tillman's public re
cord as much as he wanted to and he
did not want Governor tillman to get
mad about it. Is there any objection
to asking far an explaration from
Governor Tillman? FLfteen years
ago I said we ought to have jost such
a college as Clemson and I have al ways
favored such colleges. They talk of
baptizing me when ,I advocated
measures they are talking of before they
were born. In 18801 voted for the free
coinage of silver and have voted for it
ever since.
He went on briefly to explain what
there was in free coinage and said that
the Government could not, unless it
increased its mint capacity, give more
than one dollar pen capita per year.
Continuing he said: I never owned
a dollar's worth of stock or bonds in
railroads or banks, but Iam in favor of
protecting their interests. The fight
began twenty years ago. When it comes
to pensions the soldier vote is so strong
that neither side will fight it in the
North or East. It does look alarming
to see the pensions steadily increasing
and we, my old soldiers, we, who fought
for four years, have contributed over
$300,000,000 towards it. I would stand
that without a murmur if they did us
justice in other respects. When the
Democratic Convention met it agreed
first to repeal the election law, second
to change the tariff law, and third to
as c ,
pending. That tariff bill is not s ithat
I would like; there were compTUCW
yet I believe it the best tariff bill almost
ever passed, in the bill is a tax on in
come, and it is the first opportunity to
reach the bondholders, It is fair, it is
Democratic. I regret to say that the
third most vital and more important
demand has not been granted, and I
fear will not be as long as Mr. Cleve
land Is our President. You and I voted
for him. Although the people knew
Mr. Cleveland was opposed to free sil
ver the people voted for him. He was
the choice of the Democrats. I don't
believe him a thief or scoundrel, yet the
masses and not the leaders wanted and
elected him. My judgment is that the
fight against corp .rations has been en
couraged by the Republicans. It will
be a death struggle in the next election.
It will be a triumph for Republican in
stitutions or it will be the beginning of
the end of popular government. We
ought now to organize silver leagues on
which to build a financial system on
which to give relief to the people. I am
not a pessimist, but my experience is
that the struggle must come and will
come bet ween the money interests and
tne masses. They have found men to
shoot down citizens. There are four
teen States in insurrection. There is
dynamite, death, destruction in the air.
I advised to let Coxey alone; that is a
mere symptom of the disease that Re
publican legislationi has brought about
He referred to Governor Tillman's
throwing rocks jokingly and tieing ox
tails up in Washington. I should go to
the West for our next President. H~e is
with us and I have my eye on him. If
Governor Tillman has gotten any more
abuse than I have, Lord help him. I
don't mind that, it is the right of the
newspapers to comment on my record
but I don't get mad about-it like he does
I don't think the newespapers mean
much by abusing us. They have a right
to criticise. They talk about my fami
ly holding office. The fact is 1 am the
only man in my family who has had an
office in the forty years. I went
through the storm of abuse in 1876, I
stood it for your sake. Everyone
thought I was a fool to make the fight,
but I did get my seat.
What have I done? Among my first
acts was to get $200,000 for Charleston
harbor; that was the first of a $5,000,000
appropriation. I got the first appropria
tion for Winyah Bay; I helped get a sur
vey of the rivers of the State; I got an
appropriation of half a million for the
dry docks at Port RIayel; I got the di
rect taxes reimbursed to the State; I
had $500,000 paid them for their lands;
L have participated in alt the debates
to my best ability; I helped make the
agricultural department what it Is. I
do not feel 1 have neglected my duty.
It is not common sense to turn a man
down because he has done his duty.
The secret of New England's influence
is that she keeps her good men in Wash
ington. If I had devoted the same time
ani devotion to any other business I
would have made my fortune.
I do not agree with Mr. Tmndal that
the office holders have never until now
addressed you. We have always done
so since 1874. I have begged
for a constitutional convention.
We ought to have called a con
vention in 1880. 1 am, however
somewhat afraid our people might get
ito a fight and not get the best men at
the convention. 1 nave always been
in favor of such a convention. I want
the people to vote at a directi primary for
the United States Senator and I will
abide the result. if the Governor will
agree, and get the executive committee
to let the people say who they want,.I
abide the result. All I want is a fair
fight in an open tield. If they want to
jump on me. let them do so one at a
time. As a taxpayer and candidate I
have a right to criticise what public
acts I want, and 1 will exercise that
right.
Gen. Butler was given great applause
on concludinlg.
OYERNORi TtLLMAN
was given greater applause than the
Iother speakers. He said he did not
know where to start, as everythiug bas
A radyr ben very fully and ably coy
ered. I presume you have staid here to
bear me.
Voices: "That's right."
The candidates yesterday told us that
we ought to revise the order, so I made
this suggestion to let us come last.
While my friend has not pitched rocks
today he threatenedto tnrow some. He
is holding it possibly for Charieston, for
I see he has a bundle of papers. When
he shoots you will just hear me limber
up. Everybody ackuo wledges his ability
and his character If I have been on
any bed of roses I am sorry. for my suc
cessor. I want to go to Washington
because you want me to go there.
Voice: "hiat's so!" "Hurrah for
Tillman!"
Tillman: The General has told you
about G.oxey's army being out to re
press disorder among the laboring
classes. Yesterday we saw a spectacle
that was a disgrace to anyone.
To Gen. Butler: Are you or are you
not conducting your campaign ? I see
by the papers you are. I mean are you
bossing it?
Gen. Butler: I don't boss anybody. I
leave that to you.
Tillman: Now what did yousee yes
terday in Rock Hill? When I got to
Rock Hill I saw a crowd of strangers.
There were at least eight hundred who
were brought there on free passes
["Hurrah for Tillman! Put it to him,"
from the crowd.]
Now you have heard Gen. Butler say
that he is running his own campaign,
yet out of the 1.500 people here 800 were
hauled on free passes to hurrah for
Butler. LHurrahs.] Keep quiet gen
tleman, 1 don't want to arouse your
passions. It was a kind of Corey's
army that Is to be feared. I shall not
attempt to locate the responsibility.
They did not holler mucb, I tell you.
[Hurrahs for Tilman. "We'll vote for
you."] I have been through a good
many hillsand I- have always counted
on the freemen to help me. I know
where you are. I know how you look
upon Ben Tillman. Possibly some of
Gen. Butler's over-zealous friends may
have engineered this. If Bunch Mc
Bee, as superintendent of the Blchmond
and Danville Railioad, is prostituting
his authority by hauling people free,
we ought to know it. If there is a
corruption fund raised in New York
then we ought to know it, for it is
talked about.
"4No, no." Hurrahs for Butler and
Tillman.
We can't be bought. Mr. McBee and
I are good personal friends. I took his
free pass and rode on it. It was mighty
nice riding. I have never been picay
unish about each things. Several of
those "boomers" came to my room and
told me they came on free passes and
were for me. When I went on to
Washington I even slept in one of Mr.
McBee's berths, although I had one in
the sleeping car. I have taken all the
cussing, and if there is anyone entitled
to a soft place I ought to get it, but I
expect to work. If I went to the Sean
ate, though, I would be the first Simon
pure farmer there..
Then Tillman reviewed the railroad
tax cases and attacked J udge Simon
ton. We are still fighting the receiver
ships, and our bill to limit their au
thority was unanimously favorably re
ported by the committee and we will
et the redress for which
~-nd i nR m-M ongress
w~au IlUlT , said he had no right
SzQ ethe matter. I put dyna
outstretched fiisatal for he
Voice: "We North Carolinians e
Now I promisad not to talk long, as
every one else has covered the ground.
Voices: "Go on, let's talk."
Governor Tillman: What would I
do? Why I would vote against a
Judge that usurps his power. Gen.
Butler is not in smpathy with you. He
has been in Washington so long that
he has lost touch with the people
or he never would have had the Corey
army at Rock Hill. [aurrah.] You
never saw your candidates face to face
until you saw me. When the oldtime
leaders, Gen. Butler and Gen. Hampton
were asked to work for the regular
nominees in 1890, Gen. Butler gave out
an interview. I quote from The~ News
and Courier, ihich was his friend ani
I believe it is now. Look here, if it
comes over to me, dorn't think I've
changed. God knows I have not.
He read from the interview. In 1892
Butler said he thought Sheppard would
be elected, whiie today the Zionserva
tives are at outs with him because of
the patronage, and The News and Cou
rier and The State and the Greenville
News are indifferent; he is not with
you and never has been. You want
some one who will light for you and
work for you and that's my.
work. [laurrali for Tillman.] The
primary is none of my business. It is
the business of the Democratic execu
tive committee of the people. He
never had any belief la your capacity
to rule. I don't know what he wants
with the separate box. We have had
an experienee with the prohibition
boxes. What will become of that cor
ruption fund about which I hear?
Voices: "They can't buy me, and
me."
Till nan: "I want you to show him
where you stand."
Up to this time Governor T411man
had in his brief talk been working his
audience up to a good pitch of enthu
siasm. lie himself was much worked
up. Show him where you stand, he
cried out. Show him who has this
crowd. New, up with your hands, and
then up went about two thirds of the
hands in the audience, amidst wild
hurrahs for Tillman. Tillman had
the ciawd. lie saw it. His friends
saw that. Then to add to the victory
he said: Now those of you for Butler
raise your hands. A few did so, others
perhaps did not care to participate at
all, and others were not incllned to do
Governor Tillman's bidding.
That about broke up the meeting.
The candidates for other offices were
announced-for Attorney General, 0.
W. Buchanian; for Superintendent of
Education, WV. D. Mryfield and G.
Walt Whitman; tor railroad commis
sioner, J. C. Wilborn and J. Walter
Gray; Secretary of State, J. R. Harri
son. Abut half-past 3 o'clock every
one went to dinner.
Miurder in Darnlagton.
CHARLESTON, June 17.-A special
from Darllegton says: Au atrocious
murder was committed last night at
Mandville, on the Charleston, Sumter
and Northern roilroad, nineteen miles
from Darlingtot'. This morning the
body of Mr. J. P. Alderman, depot and
express agent at Maadville, was lying
on the track with his skull crushed in
and badly mnu.ilated. Mr. Alderman
was seen last night at 10 o'clock and
when his body was found he had a dif
ferent suit from the one he was last
seen in. Theory is that he beard rob
bers breaking in th~e depot. and they
murdered him when he came out. The
depot doors were broken in, but nothing
was missing except the dead man's
watch. Thbere is no clue to indicate who
commit'.ed the murder, oxept the fact
that a darkey was arrested at Gibson
today who said he was tuying cartridges
because the sherutf was after him. Mr.
Aldermac was a reliab e business man,
highly esteemed by his employers. He
was from North Corolina, was 30 years
'odand wa to have been married soon