The Manning times. (Manning, Clarendon County, S.C.) 1884-current, April 04, 1894, Image 1
VOL. IX. MANNING, S. C., WEDNESDAY, APRIL 4, 1894. NO. 36.
THE BLAUND BILL V ETOED
TEXT OF PRESIDENT CLEVELAND'S
MESSAGE ON THE SUBJECT.
He Reviews the Finarcial Condition of
the Country at Length-ThinkS the
Measure 11l-ads i ed and Dangerous-The
B; Faulty in Coustr actlon.
WASHINGTON, March 29.-The ol
lowing is the text of the President's
message vetoing the seiguiorage bill:
To the House of Representatives: I
return without my approval Heuee bill
numbered 4956, entitled "An Act direct
ing the coinage of the silver bullion
held in the Treasury and for other pur
poses."
My strong desire to avoid disagree
ment with those in both houses of Con
gress who have supported this bill,
would lead me to approve it if I could
believe that the public good would not
be thereby endangered and that such
action on my part would be a proper
discharge of official duty. Inasmuch.
however, as I am unable to satisfy my
self that the proposed legislation is
either wise or opportune, my concep
tion of the obligations and responsibil
ities attacied to the great office I hold
forbids the indulgence of my personal
desire, and Inexorably confines me to
that course which is dictated by my
reason and judgment and pointed out
by a sin.ere purpose to protect and pro
mote the general interest of our people
The financial disturbance which
swept over the country during the last
year was unparalleled in its severity
and disastrous in its - consequences.
There seemed to be almost an entire
displacement of faith in our financial
ability and a loss of confidence in our
fiscal policy. Among those who at
tempted to assign causes for our dis
tress it was very generally conceded
that the operation of a provision of law
then in force which required the gov
emnment to pur chae monthly a large
amount of silver bullion. and issue its
notes in payment therefar, was either
entirely, or to a large extent, responsi
ble for- eur trouble. This led to the
re on the 1st day of November,
19 of this statutory provision We
had, iowever, not fallen so low In the
depths of depression and timiditv, and
apprehension had so cowpletely gained
control in financial circles, that our
rapid recuperation could not be rearon
ably expected. Our recovery has, nev
ertbelesi, ,,eadily progress-d, and
though less than five mont6s have
elapsed since the repleal of the mis
chievous silver purchase requirement,
a wholesome improvement Is unmis
takably apparent. Confidence in our
absolute solvency is to such an extent
reinstated and faith in our disposition
to adhere to sound financial methods is
so far restored as to produce the moat
encouraging results, both home and
abroad. The wheels of domestic in
dustry have been slowly set in motion,
and the tide of foreign investment has
tgamn started in our direction. Our
?ecovery being so well under way noth
ing should be done to check our con
valescence, nor should we forget that a
relapse at this time would almost sure
ly reduce us to a lower stage of finan
cial distress than that from which we
are just emerging.
J. believe that if the bill under consid
eration should become a law, it would
be regarded as a -retrogression from
the financial intentions indicated by
our recent repeal of the provisions
forcing silver bullion purchases that it
would weaken if it did not destroy re
turning faith and. confidence in our
sund financial tendencies and that as a
consequence our progress would be un
fortunately checked and a return to
our recent distressing plight seriously
threatened.
This proposed legislation is so relat
ed to the currency conditions growing
out of the law compelling the purchase
of silver by the government, that a
gace at such conditions and a partial
reiwof the law referred to may not
Between the 14th day of August, 1890.
when the law became operative, and
the 1st day of November, 1893, when
the clause in it directing the purchase
of silver was repealed, there were pur
chased by the Secretary of the Treas
ury more than 168.000,000 ounces of
silver bullion. In payment for this
bullion the government issued its
Treasury notes of various denomina
tlons,amounlting to nearly $156,000,000,
which notes were immediately added
to the carrency in circuli'tion among
our people. Such notes were, by the
law, made legal tender in payment of
all debts, public and private, except
when otherwise expressly stipulated
and were made receivable for customs,
taxes and all public dues, and when so
received might be reissued. They were
allowed to be held by banking associa
tions as a part of their lawful reserves.
On the demand of the holders, these
treasury notes were to be redeemed in
gd or silver coin in the discretion of
the Secretary of the Treasury, but it
was declared as a part of this redemp
tion provision "that It was the estab
lished policy of the United States to
maintain the two metals on a parity
with each other upon the present legal
ratio or such ratio as may ne provided
by law. The money coined fromn such
bullion was to be standard silver dollars
and after directing the immediate coin
age of a little less than 28,000,000
ounces, the law providedL that as much
of the remiaiig bullion should be
thereafter omnea as might be necessary
to have for theredemptioni of the Trea
sury notes on Its purchase, and that
"any gain or seigniorage arising from
coinage shall be accounted for and paid
into the Treasury." This gain or seign
orage evidently indicates so much of
the bullion owned by the government
as should remain after th" usng of a
sufficient amneunt to coin as .e s at -
dard silver dolla's as shou1l
equal in number the dollars represent
en by the Treasury nott s issued ini pay
ment of the et ire quantA~y of buhiO.
Tese Treasury notes now outsrantio~
ard in circt:latIOn emount to $152951,
280, ar-a ala bough tub re has tteeo anus
fr but c' e.a.parativesy smautll amount
of this builion coine' yet. the so-cdll- --
g in or seignierage, as above de fiaed,
which would arise from the coibge ot
the entire mass, has been eaesily ascer
taned to be a quantity of bullion suffi
cent to make vhen coit.pa 55,156.6h1
standard silver dollars.
Considerixng the present ijdrinsic re
lation betwee. gol ; andl siver thte
maitena-nce of the parity between the
tw o mer.als. as medtioned In this law,
can mean nothing else thar thy main
tenance of sneh a 1parity in the .r ima
tion and confidence of the peop e- ho
use our money ini their daily trax.sac
tions. Manifestly the maintena: ce' of
this parity can only be accoemplihed so
faras it is affected by tnese Treasury
notes, and in the estimation of the
holdeis of the same by giving to such
holders, onl their redeu..p ion, the coin,
web;:-r it is gold or silver, wbich they
prefer. It follows that while in terws
the 1la' leaves the choice of comr to be
pid on such redemption to the discre.
ton of the Secretary of the Treasury.
the exercise of this discretion, it op-'
posed to the demands of the holders, is
en~tirely inconsistent with the effective'
and ber delcal maintenance of the part
tyeha'=:.n tha two metals- If both
gold and silver are to serve us as money s
and if they together are to supply to i
our people a safe ani stable currency, I
tMe necessity of preserving this parity E
is obvious. Such necessity has been re- ]
pettedly conceded in the platf irms of s
both political parties and in our Feder
al statutes. It is now here no more E
emphatically recognized than in tbe re- I
cent law which repealed the provision t
under which the bullion now on hand i
was pureased. This law insists upon c
the "maintenance of the parity in value i
of the coins of the two metals and the i
equal power of every dollar at all times E
in the markets and in the payment E
of debts."
The Secretary of the Treasary has i
therefore for the best reasons, not only
promptly complied with every demand
for the redemption of the Treasury
notes in gold, but the present situation
as well as the latter and spirit of the
law, appear plainly to justify, if they do
not ernjoin upon him, a continuation of
such redemption. The conditions I
have endeavored to present may be t
thus summarizsd:
First. The government has pur
chased and now has on hand sufficient
silver bullion to permit the coinage of
all the silver dollars necessary to re- t
deem, in such dolsars, the Treasury 4
notes issued for the purchase of said t
silver bullion and enough besides to t
coin, as gain or seigniorage. 55,156,681 t
additional standard silver dollars.
Second. There are outstanding and I
now in circulation TTeasury notes is- s
sued on the payment of the bullion I
purchased amounting to 8152,951,280. c
1-hese notes are legal tender in pay- r
ment of all debts, puDlic and private, -I
except when otherwise expressly stipu- r
lated, they are receivable for customs, c
taxes and all public dues, when held by t
banking associations, they may be t
counted as part of their lawful reserves t
and they are redeemed by the govern- t
ment iii gold at the option of the hold- I
era. Ttese advantageous attributes t
were deliberately attached to these r
notes at the time of their issue, they E
are fully understood by our people to
whom such notes have been distributed
as currency and have inspired confi- a
dence in their satety and value and I
have undoubtedly thus induced their t
continued and contented use as monoy i
instead of anxiety for their redemp
tion.
Having referred to some incidents s
whict I deem relevant to the subject, I
it remains for me to submit a scientific t
statement of my objections to the bill o
under cnsideration. 0
This bill consists of two sections, ex. t
cluding o-te which merely appropriates t
a sum sufficient to carry toe Act into s
teff.ci.. The first section provides for
the' immediate coinage of the silver g
bullion in the Treasury, which repre- u
sents the so-called gain or seigniorage :
r which would arise from the coinag.- v
of all the bullion on hand, which gain a
or seianiorage this section declares to
be $55,156,681. It directs that the
money so coined or the certificates is
sued thereon shall be used In the pay- j
ment of public expenditures and pro f,
ides that if the needs of the Treasury g
demand it the Secretary of the Treas- 0
ury may in his discretion issue silver t:
certificates in excess of such coinage v
not exceeding the amourt of seignior p
ag in said sction autnorized to be e
coined.
The second section directs that as p
oon as possible atter the coinage of t
this seigniorage the remainder of the p
bulion held py the government shalt t
be coined ~to legal tender standard a
,ilver doll and that they shall be c
held in the Treasury for the redemp ti
ion of the Treasury notes issued in the &
urchase ot said bullion. It provides ti
hat as fast as the bullion shall be 1:
oined the redemption of said notes
shall not be reissued, but shall be can- i,
elled and destroyed in amounts equal o
o the coin held at any time in the 1F
reasury derive~ from the coinage a
provided for, and that silver certificates u
shall be Issued on such coin in the i4
anner now provided by law, it is, si
owever, especially declared in sala b
lid section that the "Act shall not be ti
onstrued to change existing laws re
ating to the legal tender character or t
mde of redemption of the Treasury ~
otes issued for the purcniase of the b
silver bullion to be coined.
The entire bill is most unfortunately
onstructed. Nearly every sentencea
resents uncertainty and invites con-a
roversy as to its meaning and intent.
he first section is ep ly faulty in
this respect, and it Is emely doubt! d
ful whether its language will permit c
the consummation of its supposed pur
oses. I am led to believe that the pro
oters of the bill intended in this sec
ion to provide for the coinage of stan-.
ard silver dollars, and yet there is pos
itively nothing in the section to pre
ent its coinage in any description of as
silver coins now authorized under any di
xisting law. I suppose this section
was also intended, in case the needs of
he Treasury called for money faster di
than the seigniorage bullon could act- t
ually be coined to permit -the issue of t
fiver certificates in advance of such q
oinage, but its language would seem I
o permit the issuance of such certifi- l
cates to double the amount of seignior al
age as stated, one-half of which would pl
not represent an ounce of silver in the y
reasury. The debate upon this sec- it
ion in the Congress deveceped ani ear- T
nest and positive difference of opinion ~
as to its object and meaning- In my
t-vent, I am clear that the present per- ul
plexitl' and emb. r-assments of tue
Secretary ot the Treasury ought not to
e augmenkted by devolving upon Dim
the execution of a law so uncertain
nd confused.
1 am not wililag, however, to rest
y objection to this section solely on
hese grounds; in my judgment sound ~
finnte domes nout commend a furt her iu- ci
u en of silver into our currency at ~
ths lime unaccompanied by furtber
oequate provision~ for the maintain- P
mee our Trens'ary of a safe gold r'-- C.
'r,.. Dour-ts also arise as to the e,
n-miag ad construction of the ee- er
>ad seetita of the bili. if the silve-r j
oiars therein directed to be coined a
.re, as tL-. sectioni provioes, -
o e! neld in theITre isuir for rei- -f
ion of Tre-asury notes it is sugg'-sted
not ije i-sue-d ou such coin -in -ne m>tn
aer rso- provIded by law," be'cause ~
these doll ars are monley hield i;- '
iresury for the express purpos.- of re
deemtcg Treasury nottes ou emnd
,ihien would ordinarily mean '.flat
:ey were set apai:. for the purpose of tU
substituting them for tae's Tresury s>
n-rs. Tni y are not, therefore, hel in E
suha way as to forniisf a basis for g
e-it.f,-.ates accoramng io an~y pro~v1ion
f elist.ig saw. 1t, bewever, -siveI t4
ertiicates can properly be issued1 apon
these doli-ers, taere is nothing in Ide I
ction to i:.dlcate the ci rracteristics I
md functions of these certfi,ates. 1 b
t~hey were to 'e from the same charac- f
ter as silver certieaces int-irculation i
urder existi'. ls 'tiay would at. bes' 0:
be receivable only tor customs, texes d
nd all public duts; aid under the laa- Iti
guage of tnis sectlin i. is, to say the i
ieas, extremely do :tf ul whether the Ii
:eicates it contemplates would be a
a-ully receivea even for such pur- c
poses. c
Watever else m ty bs said of the un- t<
eertainties of expression in this bill, ,
'hey certainly ought not to be found f
in legislation affecting subjects so im-lu
pm.rantoan a r.eaning a our financae
6nd currency. in statinz cther and
nore important reasons for my disap
iroval of this section, I shall however,
issume that under its provisions these
Creasury notes issued in payment for
ilver bullion will continue to be re
leemed as herete, fore in silver or gold
t the option of the tlders; and that
f when they aie presented for redemp
ion or reach the Treasury in any oth
nanner, there are in the Treasury
-ined silver jollars -qual in nominal
raiue to such Treasury notes, then and
a that case, the notss will be destroyed
nd silver certificates to an equal
6mount be sutstituted.
I am convinced that this scheme is
Ul-advised and dangerous. As an ulti
nate result of its operatiOn Treasury
Lots which are legal tender for all
ebts public and private, and which
re redeemable in gold or silver, at the
ption of the holder, was replaced by
iver certificat_-,whicb, whatever may
ie their character and description will
iave none of these qualities. In an
icipation of these results, and as an
mmediate effect, the Treasury .notes
vill naturally appreciate in value and
tesirability. The fact that gold
an e realized upon them and
te further fact that their
estruction has been decreed whe:L
hey reach the Treasury must tend to
heir withdrawal from general circula
ion to be immediately presented for
old redemption or to be hoarded for
resentation at a more convenient sea
on. The- sequel of both operations
vill be a large addition to the silver
arrency in our circulation and a cor
esponding reduction of gold in the
reasurv. The argument has been
aade that things will not occur at
ce because a long time must elapse
efore the coinage of anything bitt
he seigniorage can be entered upon. If
he physical effecTs of the execution of
he second section of this bill are
iot to be realized until far in
be future, thbi may furnish a strong
eason why it should not be passed so
auch in advance; but the postpone
aent of its actual operation cannot
trevent the fear and loss of confidence
nd nervous precaution which would
mmediately follow its passage and
'ring about its worst consequences.
regard this section of the bill as em
odying a plan by which the gover'
ient will be obliged to pay out 4.s
canty store of gold for no other pur
ose than to force an unnatnral addi
ion of silver money into the hards of
ur people. This is an exact reversal
f.the policy which safe financ- dic
ates if we are to preserve paity be
ween gild and silver and maintain
esible bimetallism.
We havs- now outstanding more than
338.000,00 in silver cprtificates issued
naer exibring laws. They are serving
he purp 'se of money usefully anid
rithout question. Our eold reserve,
rununting to only a Jit'e more thAn
100,000.000. is direcs !!aei with
2e redemption of $346.6000.0 -) U sited
-ates notes. When t. :- n->csed to
ifate our silver currency it is a time
)r strengthe.'ning our g.ild reserve in
ead of depb-ting it. I cannot conceive
f alonger stet to silver monometallism
aan when ve sm-nd our gold to buy sil
er certificat' s for circulAtion, an 1
ecially in view of the fac- of -he difli
ulties surrounoing the replenishmer.,t
f our gold. Tnis leads me to earnestly
resent the desirability of ranting to
ie Secretary of the Trea.surr a better
ower than now exists to issue bonds
) protect our gold reserve when for
y reason it should be necessary. Our
arrency is in such a confused condi
ton, and our financial affairs are apt t'o
ssume at any time so critical a posi
on that it seems to me such a course
idictated by ordinary prudence
I am notinsensible to the arguments
favor of coining the bullion seigni
rage now in the treausry, and I be
eve it could be done safely and with
dvantage if the Secretary of the Tre es
ry han the power to issue bonds at a
iw rate of intet est under authority in
ibstitution of that now existing and
etter suited to the protec tion of the
~easury..
I holre a way will present itself in
is aear futura for the ad justment of
ar monetary affairs in such a compre
ensive and conservative manner as
rill accoid to silver its proper place in
ar currency; but in the meantime, I
m extremely solicitous that whatever
tion we take on this subject may be
ich as to prevent loss and discourage
ent to our people at home, and the
strnction of confidence in -our finan
al management abroad.
GROCVER CLEVELAN.
Executive Manasion, March 29,189k.
Porced to Resign.
WAsHINGTON, Mach 28.---This official
mouncement was made at the Treasury
s afternoon:
"Mr. J. B. Brawley, Sixth auditor of
e5 Treasury Department, todJay ten
rEd his resifnation to the l'cesident,
take effect upon the apnointment and
lificatiorA of hia tuccessor. Mr. Braw
y is a citizen of Meadvilie, Pa.. is a
wyer by protession, and was appointed
ditor April 19. 1893. The position
sys 3 600 per annum. No action hag
it been takea on his resianation, and
is not known when it will be accepted.
bis is the first. promineeit official ap
>inted by the present administration
ho has resigxned. His renignation is
aderstood to have been f~rced. For
>me time past the relations ot thbe sixt.h
iditor and Sscretary Carlie have not
sen pleasant, and s x weks ago, there
'as quite a scene in Secretary Carlisle's
>om between the s~x;.n auditor a.d. tue
creary. S-cretarv Csriiste has no
s'n impressed with Mr. Brawleg a exe
Itive capacity. The work o1 tbe sixth
door's iflice is tar behin'; methods
nployed were not businessi'e, and
'tmaster Genera! B sel, 8:-cret-r\
arl and tie Pre d-at, six w -ek
r, came to the conclusiu L:a.
>ange was neces=ary is !e oilic" Mr
rnee7 called at the Trotir Dw.ar:
tent \'.,er11 and k~r l1 --1r
s resia aion. Tei- ah Ii
r-as -be em*ira~ ALieh L. Depmi
Rn-zta zno Muw-.e-.
JACKsoNviLLE, \l tn f7 --i. e: cial
r~e: i'here is grea. ex m- r
lavilL', a fei uil .-1 -< Whis
tace, over the mxura r -' I.,i- ,
aged tooian, an i-.- ,a fij
initl mal:,ue i( *fh home Iu ri~.t L
le rodl in roux t f h- houise withl ne~r
rs b- .-a . Oal Mrs Turter wa~s
an c aa :j re ouse, her htead ha
g as> beeti oraten to a j y- Au ax'
Sa natenxt !ad bee u-ced ny th-- *ur
erer. An ex-amiuationl of the- body of
i girl sho ws that snie had bUen rav
tied. ji is supposed ''.at ,.'er t'u
ed had stteli '4id ni t, e slew the
ir and tne oid wnman, to ~ rev~ent ni.
rime being aiscovered. T here is no
!-ae to the murderer. but It is supp ised
have been the work ot a negro tra..p
rho was seen near the house at nighi t
ll. Tne people are terribly wrougnt
p and if the murderer can be disc-ov
deJudg mincne .a il dispose of him.
TAKE YOUR CHOICE!
WE ARE BOUND TO HAVE FREE SIL
VER OR FREE BAN'KS.
An Argunment in Favor ot State Banks of
Issue-If the Pef, pie are not Given Free
Batkithey wilt a the End have Free
SiLver.
To the Editor of The News and Cou
rier: For several years I have given
careful thought to the financial prob
lem, and have read the best arguments
on all sides of the subject. I have giv
en no less attention to existing politi
ical conditions, since in matters of ad
ministration it is necessary to study
not only abstract questions, but modi
fications rendered necessary by the
fact that government is a compromise.
and that the wise statesman must con
tent himself with doing not what is
best, but what is best under the cir- 1
cumstances. "Abstract ideas, when
true render Governments impractica
ble, and when false *tend to destroy
them."
The abstract question of money is in
itself a difficult one. Money has sever
al functions to perform, and for each
there are requisites sometimes opposed
to one another. To be a perfect medi
um of exchange money must :e in
great demand, to be in great demand it
must be comparatively scarce. But
when too scarce it does not afford a
sufficient supply for loans. In attempt
ing to secure a volume sufficient to
meet this demand for loans, the requ- I
sites of i perfect medium may be sacri
ticed. Money must also be elastic in
volume, varying directly with the
wants of trade in ordar to become a
perfect standard of value for different
times. A government currency, while
it may be a perfectly safe medium of
exchange, cannot possess sufficieht elas- c
ticity of volume. Rigidity gives rise to
alternate plethora and scarcity in busi- .
ness centres and disturbs the market I
for prices and loans. As most of the
traffi of the world is based on credit. 0
any considerable fluctuation of prices r
of commodities works serious injury.
Even in a steady general rise of prices
creditors are swindled. while through a 1
steady decline debtors may be ruined.
Ail economists concur in the truth 0
that the standard of values should be
set by commodities, and that money is .
m-rely a measure of that standard. t
Wnen it fails to perform this duty it 1
becomes a national nuisance. The ex
ising long continued decline of aver
age prices, measured in gold, uncontest c
able proof that, gold is not following the
1aw of average value, and that unless
supplemented in volume it cannot be
takeh as the standard. A silvet stand
ard is still more unreliable. At present
neither the goll dollar nor the silver
dollar is a representative of average
values. If all prices nave fallen 25 per
cent in the past few years It can be 0
seen that the voluime of mcn
ey should be increased, both for reasons S
of honesty as of politics. This truth ti
may as well be accepted.
Taose who compare merely the vol n
ume of money ior different times Re- -
glect a great factor in the problem. The b
irade or the cou.-t.ry is based on one
part money and nine parts confidence. f
Each may fluctuate - independently. 0
When there is a loss in the stock ofi
confidence an additional demand is cre- a
ated for maney. A dimunition of 10
per cent in confidence calls for a tre
mendous proportional increase in cur
rency. But this increase may be need- P
ed only until confidence is restored, y
when it ought to be withdrawn. Gov- t.
einent cannot secure elasticity with
out resort to tha Ocala sub-treasury
plan, which has so many other bad fea
ture as to render of no accoust this s
good one.P
The problem Is how best to inzcrease ~
the currency and make it elastic, and
et pr.eserve its true money character.
t must be based on gold, the money of
the world. It cannot be exclusively
gold, for gold is scarce. It cannot be
basd on silver at the present ratio, for
silver Is dIscredited in the markets of S
the world, and the United States are not re
stronag enough to force the world to re- a1
:eive silver on the terms offered by the el
dvocates of free silver. The demand vi
that the United States should Issue pa- c<
per money would have been laughedot n
by all statesmen of all parties from the n
beginning of the Government till the E
remarkable decision of the Supreme w
ourt a few years ago, which in the ce
language of Hugh McCullough changed pl
his representative Government Into t<
an imperial sovreignty. No more than af
he States should Congress make "any- ci
hing but gold and silver a legal tender si
n payment of debts." -ai
There are six hundred million dollars e:
n silver in the United States today, and o1
his is enough in all conscience. Any y.
further issue of silver will tend still ci
further to deplete the treasury of the e:
old t hat is now the only means of pre- T1
serving the parity of all the silver and pi
all the paper currency of the Union. ni
The seigniorage bill Is but a further p.
issue of silver. Instead of preventing 54
run on the gold in the treasury it will ct
tend to aggravate It, and will have the el
endency to force either a new call for
gold loan or the appropriation of pl
gold to a premium, and its withdraw- la
l from circuiation.
If President Cleveland simply sign
bs bill he will be yielding to the cal A
for more slv-r. If he vetoes it wIth- A
u it dicating some other relief he will
still more surely strengthen the hands E
f tbe advocates of free silver or of un
imited greenbacks, and the irrepressi
:e conflict between good and bad mon c
a-v will ne on. Anyone who has paid C
attention to the signs of the- times will c
ee that only blind fatuity will prevent c
be erremist of the West and South r
i:ombining to sweep away "all the con
F
.xr Congress will be two-thirds in fa F
v r of frt-e coinag~e, or even free greene
ek', unlesas some step is taken to ob- c
~ae this danger. -
The third step is the repeal of the 10
per cent tax on private bank isui-s.g
n.trac-ly and politicilly this is tfle L
satst c zurse- L
I. may be admitted that for many ~
purpo~.-s a bank bi is not as good as aM
goa aallar. But if bas- d on gold itM
m.y for certain other purpa'ses be as N
t~e as a gold dollar. The principle o' c
-v ision of labor teaches that uuiver- c
sal money is not needed to pay local
d:ts. i
If a dolla~r wi11 cir calate freely where e
it is inieunded -to circulate, tohit is S
-'ougu. A mane is not needed to do U;
b I.1e werk. The cleari'g house cer V
rxtiec.te-, represe'etiug muoiicg but pri- Y
vite c:-eat, and even untier the ban of
(joverment so fair as it claimed to he
coey, WeDnt around the ittle tread
mill of its dluty and saved the Un!on,
whn t he st iver d ollar and the gold dol
lar and tree sovreign greenioack and the
-orfees." natuon-t b:rik bill were skulk- V
ug in~ corners. i2 this bank certificate ii
was so efiic cious mn time of panic, why hi
shoua not ctue bank's bill be good in of
time of conience-? c<
Te cry that bank issues must neces- st
sarily be dangerous is met by the teach- gi
ug of history showing what private et
Daoks of the Middle Ages did for h
sound money when Governments were e<
issuing clipped and debased coins and 1]
worthless paper. It was the banksathat p:
m.de umQor a honnet Thereai a
)o reason today why the bankers of
)harleston should not be as intelligent
md honest as their fathers or them
ielves were before the war.
This talk about wildcat currency is
ibsurd. So swift are methods of com
nunication today that a bank would be
:c.mpelled to redeem its issues or sus
)end in a montb. Nothing but a gocd
)ank bill would ever get out of sight
>f the bank.
The advantages of the private bank
ill are as follows:
It can be based on a gold reserve,
hereas the silver dollar will depend
in its on value.
It will diminish tne pressure on na
lonal money, and tb-reby permit the
iovernment to resist Government in
lation.
It will supply a local want within a
:ircle in which it performs every fanc
ion of money.
It will serve as a stock for local loans
on property that has no lending value
n the great centres, but is thoroughly
ood security.
It will not be congested in the great
noney centres, but will be confined
rithin the several States.
All objections to it as local money
an be met by State regulation, and
here is an abundance of national
noney to supply all the wants of na
onal exchange.
The system of State banks is opposed
iy theorists who endeavor to secure a
ierfect money in every respect regard
ess of political condition3 by those who
wish to control all loans and by those
rho believe that a national currency
ystem is the only safe one. It is op
osed no less by the silver kings and
ainers who see in it no opportunity to
ell their products at an inflAted value
y those who want paper fiat money,
nd by those who want the Government
o take all business into its hands
A word now of warning. There are
2any who wish to secure a safe finan
ial system and will join conservative
rees to obtain it. But thoy feel that
he-present condition of affairs is not
ast to the producers of the country.
nnominally low prices and the want
f a supply for loans have combined to -
un the farmers in the wall, along witb
2any others. They are determined to
ave more facilities of some gind for
)ans. They will take good money if 8
bey can get it, but bad money if they
Inst. If the question narrows itself
own to the issue lxtween the present
ystem and free silver the masses will
ake the latter every time. And the s
lasses have lots of votes.
The capitalists of the North have the
iatter.in their own hanas now. They
an eff-ct a compromise on free bank
ig. But if they blindly set themselves I
) work to thwart every enan.Ze they
rill find that they may be o ver whelm
cI in the deluge of wild financial
%hemes. If they refuse to accept bank
ills they will be forced pretty soon to
ke siomething they detest still more.
A recent writer in the Forum has
own that the silver agitation in Col
rado and other Western states has be
=me a craze. Tne necessity of the
outh are driving Its people to ally
emselves with the advocates of more
loney, whether paper or silver. In
oth Carolina thousands of rock-rib
d Demecrats who have no use for the 1
cala platform unite in its demand
)r siiver, because it seems to be the
nly practical way out of the deser t.
et them see that there is another and
better way.
A rw Congress will be elected this
l. Unless Mr. Cleveland and his
nmediate counsellors make some com
romise they will be powerless next
Bar by veto or any other way to con-,
:ol affairs.
'There will be either free banking or
ee silver In the near future. Let cap- 2
ilists take their choice. The political
.tuation grettly modifies the financial
roblem. It is wise to da~ the cest one
n, and to do it when one can.
1R. biEANS DAVIs.
Suth Carolina College, Columbia S.C..
[arch 24, 1894.
The5tate's Pensioners.
COLrMtmA, S. C., March 28.-The
ate pensioners will, in a short time, ~
~ceive the annual quota of the pensica
ppropriation. For the past week the
erk of the pension board has been re
sing the rolls sent in by the various
)nty pension boards,and the work is
early completed. There are only three
ore counties-Fairfield, Marion and
ershaw-in which a further revisionC
ill have to be made before the board
m take final a:tion and order the
reparation of the warrants to be sent
each penaioner. From the returns
imade up there has been a total in
ease since last year of only ten pen
oners. The~ number this year is 2,265,
Sagainst 2,255 last year. The ordinari
cpenses,etc., for this year will be paid
it of the amount held over from last
ar's appropriation. This wiil in
ude about $1,100, the amount of the c
:penses of the several ccunty boards.
he per capita payment which each,
ansoner will receive for the year will
yt be less than $22, and it is all to be
aid at once. The warrants are to be
nt to the several count~y clerks of ,
mrt for distribution to thle pension- c
-5. - C
The following shows the number of a
masoners in each county for this and c
at year:
1894. 1893 t
.bbeville................ 6 70 d
iken..... .... ..... .... 58 53 1
nderson.............. 148 151 t
ar wel-... .... ........ 52 56; u
eaufort...... ..... ..... 1 1 d
erkley..................
arleston.................
ester...................
estrfield................
laredon.............. 67 6
erinto------ 1-8 69
dg~ed------- 415 45S
airied------ 46-~ 49 1
lorence...... ...... ..... 32 3
e orgetown....... ....... 2 2
reenville..... ......... 164 159 b
mpton........... ..... 42 4') d
orry...... ...... ..... . 35 37 1
erhaw...............-5- 4
arcaster............... 4 66
aurens.................
ezington................
[arboro.................
ewerry.................la
eoe...............
rangeburg...............
ichianid..... ..... .....
trEanurg..........,S & uC.,
eln................AILERIS..
(ilamsburg...
Total.......EISTRATION.
.ith Carolina,
s .CLARiENDON.
BIRMINGIAM, - WITH THE PRiOVIS
rilliaau lugratn, 0'the General Assembly,
g near Everrgeltar ouf February, 1882, I
.nigehds n Ort Lmo'se ini lanning. in
.inedse the clerk of the court, the first
rmencse.- ch month, for the purpose of
rumens nscoming of age since the
ram ecamnflection to register, and to at
I an axe anther business pertaining to my
irled it int. S. P. HOLLADAY,
ige struct 4'Rtegistrationi Clarendon Co.
ixon and cess: Panola, S. C.
roducing de
ad s spend
A ROW IN DARLINGTON.
AN ARMED MOB WANTED TO ATTACK
STATE CONSTABLES.
rhe Gans of the Darlingtou Guards Taken
from the Armory to Xke the MiJitia
P- werlest-Tho Fall Story of the At
ftdr.
COLUMBIA, S. C., March 29.-There
:ame near being a big riot in Darling
:on yesterday over the raiding of biind
:igers by State constables. The matter
,ortunately passed over withou* ''.-.d
ihed, but the indications for some time
were for serious trouble.
The first known of the trouble here
was about 2 o'clock in the afternoon,
when Governor Tillman received a tel
!gram from Dispenser Floyd saying
;ttat raids were being made and that a
nob was on the streets armed with
inchesters. From then on until 9
)'clock last night the wires between
iere and Darlington were kept hot
with telegrams.
As will be seen from the story pub
Ished below the mob took the arms of
te Darlington Gaards,leaving no arm
d organization to uphold the law.
lovernor Tillman promptly provided i
or the maintainance of the law by tel- I
graphing to Sumter and putting the
;amter Light Infantry in readiness to
o to Darlington and by arranging for
special train to take the company to
)arlington.
The full story of the trouble is found
n the following telegrams. These are
Lil the telegrams which pasbed between
he Governor and Darlington and Sum
er and Charleston. The telegrams are
)ublished in the order in which they
vere sent and received and explain
hemselves:
DARLINGTON, S. C., March 28.
Constables raiding. Armed men
valking streets swearing they will
hoot. J. B. FLOYD.
[o Sheriff Sparborough, Darlington, S.
C.:
Columbia, S..C., March 28.
I expect you to preserve the peace
nd see that the law is upheld.
B. R. TILLMAN.
Darlington, March 28. 1
Fighting sure. Mens with guns
wear they are going to kill.
J. P. KIRVEN.
V. H. Lawrence, Darlington:
Wire me how many constables in
)arlington. Keep me posted.
B. R. Tillman.
,aotain Darlington Guards, Darling
too, S. C.:
Pat your command under orders of
iheriff and Dreserve the peace.
B. R. TILLXIAN Governor.
Darlington, March 28. 1
Gans taken away from )arligton
uards by mob. J. B. FLOYD.
Darlington, March 28.
Six constables here. Not enough to
told crowd down. Winchesters and
hot guns displayed. C. B. SWAN.
japtain Darlington Guards:
I hear yout arms have been taken by I
nob. Answer if this 18 true.
B. B. TILLMAN.
heriff Scarborough, Darlington, S. C.:
If you do not arrest those resisting
he law and assist constables in their
vork it will be the worse for you.
)ariington Guards -ordered to obey
our commands. Answer.
B. R. TILLMAN, Governor.
i. B.Swan, Darlington, S. C.:
Sheriff has been ordered to assist you
md Darlington Guards ordered to obey
lis orders. .Do your duty.3
B. R. TILLMIAN, Governor. I
Darlington, S. C., March 28.
No trouble here and no prospects of1
ny, but a good matured crowd in.
o-n. I can keep the peace.t
W. F. DAnGAN, Mayor. t
Darlington, S. C., March 28.
Telegram received, Have conferred r
'ith Sheriff who says there is no dan
'er of breach of the peace and no ne- C
essity for ordering out malitia. C
.-IiNRY T. THOMPSON, 5
Captain Darlington Guards. t
t
og gn March 28. r
All quiet. *D 'ate any t
ouble, If neces. Storg
GEORGE , H. p
o J. B. Floyd, Darliik.
Chief constable has b.. STATE AGE
Mrligton. Have warra .
gainst all persons who --alea,
unstables for riot, consp
sting an officer. AttC
rill come down tomori DIRECT IMO
til maae the arrests. B.
On receipt of your firs., -
rent to the court house
onsultation with officert LV.
iand concerning it, V
osence from the arrrh.arest
tizns went there ats.
f guns. On hearing
1em and de-mandedCI VA L
er them immediatel
now have all the gi_________
ken such precaut~ ~ A &
liv pr.-vent a re
ent. Eve-ythin
Capt
EVE~
At 9 o'c-loc~.,a
t a telega
ien quiet
Tte roll
r7 o'c)
4,'8 to 486 Meeting~ Stre
WETHER HORN
-.-MANU3FACTI
SASH. DOOE
7, 9, 11, 13 Smith Street,
LARGE
iSSORTMENT
Tinware,
No. 232 Meeting St.,
The following telegram was sent to
Dhief Constable Gaillard at 5 o'clock
.n the afternoon:
Take your entire force of constables, j
irmed with Winchesters to Darlington
;onight. B. R.TILLMAN, Governor.
A TRIHLE ALLIANCE.
DARLINGTON, S. C., March 29.- 1
Everything is perfectly quiet here now.
rhe Sumter Light Intantry are her*,
Lnd are quartered in the Guards' armory.
Lbere was real; y no occasion for their
)eing ordered out. Sumter, Florence
md Cheraw have all sent offers of assis- r
.ance in case of necessity. 1
A large meeting of the citizens of.Darl. r
ngton, Sumter and Florence was held t
it the court house this afternoon, at c
which the following resolutions were J
;assed, without a dissenting vote: d
ReslIved, That it is the sense of this s
neeting: I
First. That a man's house is his
instle, and that he is expec'.ed to defend
;be same against all anreasonable
warches.
Second. That in the counties cf Dar- h
ington. Florence and Sumter search t
)f ptivate residences, private rooms and t
,rivate apartments, used by their own- d
rs as dwellings and not as places of
,rade, shall be neither tolerated nor per. t
nitted. We hereby pledge ourselves o e
esnt all such unlawfal depredations. a
Third. That the citizens of Darling- k
on, Florence and Sumter hereby mu
ually pledge themselves to support each t
>ther in resistance to all such unlawful a
Lts, and we invite the co-operation of r
dl other law-abiding and liberty-lov!ng c
ivzens.
FLORENCE ALLIES.
FLORENCE, March 29.-The people j
f Flornce have.been in a state of excite- d
ent all day, waiting anxiously for news r
rom the "-seat of war." By 6 o'clock
his morning the notice was heard click- o
ag over the wires, warning Darliugton t
hat a reinforcement of twenty-five con- C
table would pay that town a visit to-day 8
Ater on taere came a telegram from t
)ariington, saying that they expected
rouble. Tnereupon a party of citizens d
bartered a special train, and reached
)arlington at 2:15 p. m. Immediately 11
ferwards a joint meeting of citizens of 1
)arlington, Sumter and Florence coun. e
ies was held in the court house. Ad- ii
Iresses were made and resolutions read S
and adopted. P
At 4 o'clock the Darlington Guards,
wenty-five- in number, marched down 1
o the deopt to meet the Sumter LIght 0
:nfantry; these latter arrived on a special t
rain at 5 o'clock, forty-three strong. d
,apt. Phelps in commond. The com
>aies then marched together to the
)arlington Guards' armory. a
The meeting of citizens had adjourned t
o witness the arrival of the military.
rhey resumed business at 5:15 p. m., f;
Ldopted further resolutions, listened to tj
Dirited addresses and adjurned at 6. f
o trouble is expected to occur just
iow. The constable have been refused 1
.ccommodation at any of the hotels P
here, and are staying closely cooped at 11
be sheriff's own house. They did not ap
>ear on the streets. There is no dis
>osition on the part of our citizens to a
esist.the majesty of the law, but they ,
>ropose maintaining the Constitutional t
xemption of private dwellings from ua- k
easonable searcbes. - p
MAYOR DARGAN TALKS. - n
DARLINGTON, March 29.-There is a
o mob in Darlington nor has there h
een any. No one has defied the law or ti
ny authawiity. The reports current and c
ent abroad are absolutely without faun
ation and have been originated and '
:romulgated by irresponsible and evil-u
inded persons from fear or malice. I b
esured the Governor by wire that there k
as no row or prospect of one and that I
could keep the peace of the town. The ta
eace has been kept and that, too, by is
he ordinary number of police on duty. n
During the constabulary raids which s
rere made without hindrance or moles- o:
ation, some one circulated the ,report si
bat raids would be made on private P
ouses, . Immediately some five or six,
r possibly eight, men got double-bar- ~
sled shot guns, and openly asserted ~
at resistance would be made. Theb
onstables were than in a difierent part i
f the town. I immediately went to the a
heriff,'who accompanied theralding par- d
7, and asked if there were warrants for s
ie search of private houses. He assured ii
re that there were none. I then went b;
ythe men who had she guns and told 3
2em there was no foundation for the re- 1E
ort and to put up their guns, which fi
~as Jmmediately done. Everything P
Sdown.c
) ~ort time afterwards a rumor was
~hat Mr. C. S. McCullough had
e constables to raid his home d
~ he constables had accepted his p
-jy Immediately McCullogh's
'~ushed for his residendence on &
S-eet. The constables were then se
-et, and perfectly ignoranL at
~~ejr ing on. On the way to o~
'use they met McCul- LI
his friends that there ca
)11, ~ - 0."or. Everybody P1
- again put O
M'FG. CO~
c
tAND : BLINDS.i
& USCER,
RERS OF
CHARLESTON, S. C.
1ER.D & CO.
Goods, Etc.,
I' ~ ---AT
Send for circulars
and price lists.
CHA RESTON, S. C.
A SUMTER SENSATION.
UDGE BENET ACCUSED OF GAMBLING
WITH CARDS.
[e Indignantly Denies the Charge from
the Bereb, and Says He Was Orly En
gaging in a Sccle I Game of Whist With
Friends.
Week before last, the Sumter Free
ian, an Alliance paper that is very
inch opposed to Gov. Tilman, re
iarked editorially that Judge Benet of
bis circuit, who was then holding
urt in Sumter, was a prototype of
udge Mickey. The Manning Times
id not like this, and said some pretty
iarp tnings about the editor of the
'reeman, whereupova the Editor of the
tid paper had the following to say in
st week's paper:
"Since the Manning Times undertakes to
,port rumors about the favorable impres
on Judge Benet has made upon our people
ere we regard it as essential to truth and
> a future proper administration of jus
ce that we should publish the rumors o! a
ifferent character that are passing around
ilck and fast. $Ve hear that since Judge
lenet has been here presiding in the day
me in our Courts he nas been almost ev
ry nightpiaylng cards with persons known
s professionals. Of course everybody has
eard that Judge Benet before his election
ras a notorious gambler, but since his elec
,onit was hoped he would try to mend his
rays a little. It is distressing to thlinkhe
as not done so. We know that the fore
ian of the grand jury has had his attention
alled to this matter and we hope it will be
rell ventilated before we are through with
We want no gambling Judges."
Upon seeing &he aoove Jadge Baret
a open Court at Sumter last Wednes
sy morning made the following state
ient:
I wish the attention of the members
f the Bar and the jurospresent and
2e jurors and officers of the Court con
erning a matter which has arisen
mice the adjournment of Court yes
rday. It is a very painful matter,
;hich I cannot well pass over.
When I left the Court House yester
ay evening and got to my lodging I
>und in my mail a newspaper, pub
shed in this town, addressed to me and
arked in certain places, In that pap
r I was openly charged with consort
ig with professional gamblers of
amter and spending my nights card
laying and gambling.
The charge nas been made against
ie openly asa Judge. I have no means
f redress, except to answer it from
ae bench as a J udge. The office I hold
eprives me of the ordinary personal
eans of redress, and while it is true
iatoffice pats in my hands power by
thich such conduct might be justly
ad severely punished, I will not use
'is power in my own behalf.
I do say as a true man the charge is
se, absolutely false, without even
ie semblance of truth as a foundation
)r It.
Gentlemen, I feel I owe this state
ent to members of the Bar, of whose
rofession I am an humble memoer. I
el I owe it to the officers of the Court,
ho have been so kind and courteous
) myself. I owe it to the jurors who
te present and the grand jury who
re absent, especially in view of my
3arge to the grand jury concerning
ieir duty as officers of the law. I
now I owe it to the people, wnose re
resentatives elected me to the uffice I-'
ow hold. I o we it to the good men
ad women of Sumter, whose kuaid
Dspitality I have enjoyed. 1 owe it to
te office Inow hold, however ineffi
ently. I owe it to myself and to those
ho _ear my name to say that theman
ho wrote this charge wrote what was
tterly untrue, without excnee and
ithout foundation. I canndt compre
mnd what motive he had. I hardly
aow thle man. I never cross his path,
know no reason whatever for his at
ck. He must have been shamefully
uposed upon by his Informant, or he
nist have wilfully believed lies that
ere told him. [ therefore feel that the
ily way to meet the published accu
talon is to do so thus promptly and
alicly.
I cannot go. into the newspapers. I
ill not. My hands are tied. Men of
oper sentiments comprehend what I
tean by that. Good men know I mean
i that. The best way to meet a false
Jod is to confront it with the truth.
.nd this is the simple .truth: that
Iring the three weeks I have been in
imter my goings out and my comn
gs in have been seen and known
i all who cared to see and know.
othing I have said or done and no
here I have gote would I seek to hide
om the most t~umeless man and the
irest woman. to far as that Is con
~rned my conscience is clear.
Wnerever I enjoyed the hospitality
friends I met good men and good
omen, and while in their company I
d not see anything tnat had the ap
~arance of eyii or the suggestion of is.
What probably is the only foundation
r the charge is tis-although it
ems pitifui tnat I have to make the
stemients that follo w matters purely
private hie. On twojoccasions during
ese tlare e weeks, and only on two oc
slons, I have seen or handled cards. I
ayed wIist in company with three
her men wno are piayers ini the pre
nce of ladies for one and a half or
S- We engaged in
S. THOMAS, Ja. J. I]t.:hl&
~tephenThomas, Jr. & Bro.
EWELRY, SILVER & PLATED WARE,
Spectacles, Eye Glasses & Fancy Gonds,
*rwatches and Jewelry repaired by
nnpetent workmen.
257 KING STEET,
CHARLESTON, S. C.
save Your Eyes!
When you need a pair of spectacles don't
uy an inferior glass. You vwill find none
etter than
PERFECTED
CRYSTAL LENSES
Q uti n tAliva.
-on
THE CELEBRATED
i-ma' + Diamania + :- 6ctack
--EYE -:- GLASSES. -:
For sale by
DR. W. M. BROCKINTON,
Manning, S. C.
Parties desiring agricultural rent liens
Lnd supply liens can find them at The
tinning Times offie.