The Manning times. (Manning, Clarendon County, S.C.) 1884-current, September 16, 1891, Image 1
Vi)L VII. ________ ___ MAN N ING, S. C., WED)NESDAY, SEPTEMBER 16. 1891. NO. 39.
DMNVLS AT "HIE WEILl.
SERMON PR~ACHEJ AT ELMIRA, N. Y.,
BY REV. DR. TLMAGE.
'ib. sciJa.ct U. Lrttr*r .ibppriate by
theFactTn it *hley Are Holding an In
ter.tate Fair There-Text of the Ser
InoD, GeUC4 ?, xaxx. S.
ELI1mA, Sep:. 6.-The Rev. Dr. Tal
mage preachd here today to the im
mense ultituat who have come to at
tend the New York and Pennsylvania
expositi. n. wuich is being held here
Sept. 1 to SLpt. t). It is a combimed
expositi..n o' cattle, sheep. horses and
valuable ztock of all kinds from the two
states. Tne sermon was preached on
the fair grounds to a great audience of
farmers. horsemen, drovers and stock
raisers fAom :;car and far, as well as citi
zen from the adjacent cities. Secretary
Stanley, of !he Young Men's Christian
Assoeia ou of Elmira. piesided. Dr.
Talmag. s text was Genesis xxix, S.
"And they said, we cannot, uatil all the
flocks be gathered, and till they roll the
stone frm the well's mouth; then we
water the shtep."
THE 1-i:OUE TE KING OF LEASTS.
There are some reasons why it is ap
propriate that I should accept the invita
tion to preach at this great interstate
fair. and to :hese throngs of country
men and citi: ens-horsemen just come
from thtdr ine chargers, the king of
beasts, or 1 take the crown from the
lion and out it on the brow of toe horse,
which is in every way nobler-and speak
to these 4herherds just come from their
floes-the Lord himself in one place
calltd a She.herd and in anotner place
called a Laiob, and all the good are
sheep-aod preach to you cattlemen
come up from the herds, your occupa
tion honored by the fact that God him
self thiLks It worthy of immortal record
that he owns "the cattle on a thousand
hills."
It is ap.propriate that I came, because
I was a farmer's boy, and never saw a
city until I was nearly grown, and, hav
ina been born in the country, I never
gt o rer it, and would not dwell in cities
a day if my work was not appointed
there. -,y k ve to you now, aud when
1 get hrsugh I will give you my hand,
for though I have this summer shaken
bands with perhaps forty thousand peo
ple in twenty-one states of the Union,
all the way through to Colorado and
north and south, I will not conclude my
summer vacaUton till I have shaken
hands with you. You old farmer out
there! P1ow you make me think of my
father! You elderly woman out there
with cap ana spectacleq! How you
make me think of my mother!
And row. while the air of these fair
grounds is filled with the bleating of
sheep, an.] the neiabing of horses, and
the lowing of :attle. Icannot find a more
appropriate text than the ode I read. It
is a scen" m Mesopotamia, beautifully
pastoral. A well of water of great
value in that region. The fields around
about it v hite with three flocks of sheep
lying down waiting for the watering. I
hear thtir bleating coming on the briaht
air, and the laughter of young men and
maidens indulging in rustic repartee. I
look off, -nd 1 see other flocks of sheep
coming. Meanwhile, Jacob, a stranger,
on the mI:erestinaz errand of looking for
a wife, comes to the well. A beautiful
sheperdess comes to the same well. I
see~ har approachiig, followed by her
lahte~r's tiock of sheep. It was a mem
orable rieetime. Jacob married that
shepherdess. ~The Bible account of it
is, "Jacob ktssed Rachei, and lifted up
his voice and wept."
It has always been a mystery to me
what he found t ocry about! But before
that scene occurred Jacob occosts the
shepherds and asks them why the y post
pone the slaking of the thirst of these
sheep, and why they did not immediately
proceed to water them. The shepherds
5reply to :.he etfect: "We are all good
~neighbrs, and as a matter of courtesy
we wait until all the sheep of the neigh
borhood come up. Besides that, this
stone on the well's mouth is so-uewhat
heavy, and several of us take hold of it
and push it aside, and then the buckets
and the troughs are filled and the sheep
are staistied. We cannot, until all the
flocks are athered together, and till
they roll the stone from the well's
mouth; then we water the sheep."
A THIRSTY WORtLD.
Oh, this is a thirsty world! Hlot for
the head, and tlistering for the feet, and
parching for the tongue. The world's
great want is a cool, refreshing, satisfy
ing draft. We wander around and find
the cistern edipty. Long and tedious
drouaht has dried up the world's foun
tains, but nearly nineteen centuries ago
a Shephered, with crook in the shape of
a cross, and feet cut to the bleeding, ex
plored the desert passages of this world,
and one day came across a well a~thous
and feet deep, bubbling and bright, and
looked the north, ar d the south, and the
east, and the west, and cried out with a
voice strong and musical that rang
throuah the aces: "Ho, every one that
thiirsteth. conme ve to the waters!"
Now, agreat flock: of sheep today
gather around this Gospel well. There
are a great many thirsty souls. I won
der why the tlocks of all nations do not
gather-v, by so many stay thirsts; and
while I am wondering about it, my text
breaks forth in the explanation, saying:
"We canmot until all these 11ocks be
gathered together, and till they roll the
intone fromi the well's mouth I then we
water the sheep."
THE GENTrLENESS OF sHtEEP.
If a herd of swine come to a well they
angrily j. stle each other for the prece
dence; it a drove of cattle come to a
well, they hook echcl other lack from
the water, but whetn the ilock of sheep
come, thou~gh a hundred of them shall be
disappointed, they only express it by
sad bleating-they come together peace
fully. We want a great muluitude to
come around the Gospel well. I know
there are those who do not hrke a crowd
--they think a crowd is vulgar, If they
are oppressed for room in church it
makes them 1-ositively impatient and
belligerent. Not so did these oriental
shepherds. They waited until all the
flocks were kathered, and the more
flocks that came the better they liked it.
And so :we ought to be axious that
all the pec ule should come. Go out into
the highways and the hedges and compel
them to come in. Go to the rich and
tell them thiey arc indigent without the
Gospel Qi Jesus. Go to the poor and
tell them :he aflluence there is in Christ.
Go to the blind and tell them of the
touch that aires eternal illumination.
Go to the lame and tell them of the joy
that will zjake the lame man leap like a
hart. Ga:.her all the sheen oir of all
the mou::tain~. None so .torn of the
dogs, imone so sick, none
so worriedi, nonme so dying as to be omit
ted.J WhezatbefItl eleetions e'ome& the.
whole lnd is scoured for voters, and if
a man is too weak or sick to walk to the
poils a carriage is snt ir him; I:ut
w% hen the question is whether Christ or
the devil shall rule this worle, how te-w
there are to come out and3 seek the sick,
and the lost. and the sullering, and the
hereit, and the lame and miduce their
suifrages for the Lord Jesus. Why not
gather a great fiock? All America in a
Iflock; all the world in a flock.
This well of the Gosi'el is deep enougi
to put out the buraing thirst of the tour
teen hundred million of the race. Do
not let the cnurch by a spirit of exclusive
ness keep the world out. Let down all
the bars, swing open all the gates, scat
ter all the invitations, .W hosoever will,
let him come." Come, white and black.
Come, red men of the forest. Come,
Laplander, out of the snow. Come,
Patagonian, out of the heat. Come in
furs. Come, panting un der palm leaves.
Come one. Come all. Come now.
As at this well of Mesopotamia Jocob
and Rachel were betrothed. so now, at
this well of salvation Christ our Shep
herd will meet you coming up with your
long tiocks of cares and anxieties, and
he wil stretch out his hand in pledge of
his atiiction, while all heaven will cry
out, -Behold the bridegroom cometh, go
ye out to meet him."
THE WELL OF SALVATION.
You notice that this well of Mesopn
tamia had a stone on it, which must be
removed before the sLeep could be wa
tered; and I find on the well of salvation
today imi ediments and obstacles, which
must be removed in order that you may
obtnam the refreshment and life of this
Gospel. in your case the impedunent
is pride of heart. You cannot bear to
come to so democratic a fountain; you
do not want to come with so many oth
ers. It is to you like when you are dry,
coming to a town pump, as compared
to sitting in a parlor sipping out of a
chased chalice which has just been lifted
from a silver salver. Not so many pub
hcans and sinners. You want to get to
heaven, but it must be in a special car,
with your feet on a Turkish ottoman
and a band of music on board the train.
You do not wat t to be in company
with rustic Jacob and Rachel, aud to be
drinking out of the fountain where ten
thousand sheep have been drinking be
fore you. You will have to remove the
obstacle of pride, or never find your way
to the well. You will have to come as
we came, willin- to take the water of
eternal life in any way and at any hand,
and in any kind of pitcher, crying oat:
"0 Lord Jesus, I am dyin of thirst.
Give me the water of eternal life, wheth
er in trough or goblet. Give me the
water of life; I care not in what it comes
to me." Away with all your hindran
ces of pride from the well's mouth.
Here is another man who is kept back
from the water of life by the stone of an
obdurate heart, whici lies over the
mouth of the well. You have no more
feeling upon this subject than if God had
yet to do you the first kindness, or you
had to do Gol the first wrong. Seated
on his lap all these years, his everlast
ing arms sheltering you, where is your
ratitude? Where is your morning and
evening prayer? Where ore your conse
crated lives? I say to you, as Danicl
said to lashazzar, "The God in whose
hand thy breath Is, and all thy way,
thou hast not glorified."
If you treated anybody as badly as
you have treated God, you would have
made five hundred apologies-yea. your
whole life would have been an apology.
Three times a day you have been seated
at God's table. Sprinz, summer, au
tumn and winter he has appropriately
appareled you. Your health from him,
y our companion from him, your children
from him, your home from him. All
the bright surroundings ofyour life from
him. Oh, man, what dost thou with
that hard heart? Canst thou not feel
one throb of gratitude toward the God
who made you, and the Christ who came
to redeem you, and the Holy Ghost who
has all these years been importuning
you? If you could sit down five minu
tes under the tree of a Saviour's martyr
dom, and feel his warm li.e trickling on
your forehead and :heek and hands, me
thinks you would get some appreciation
of what you owe to a crucitied Jesus.
Heart of stone, relent, telent,
Tfouebed by Jesus' cross subdued;
See his body, mangled, rent.
Covered with a gore of blood.
Sinful soul, what hast thou done'?
Crucified the Eternal Son.
TAKE THE STONE FRoM THlE AELL.
Jatcob, with a good deal 01f tug and
push, took the stone from the well's
mouth, so that the flocks might be wa
tered. And I would that to-day my
word, blessed of God, might remove the
hindrances to y our getting up to the Gos
pel well. Yea, I take it for tranted
that the work is done, and now, like
oriental shepherds, I proceed to water
the sheep.
Come. all ye thirsty! You have at
undefined longing iu your soul. You
tried money making; that did not satisiv
von. You tried ocli:e under govern
ment; that did not satisfy you. You
tried pictures and sculptures, but works
of art did not satisfy y ou. You are as
much discontented with this life as the
celebrated French author who felt that
he could not any longer endure the mis
fortunes of the world, and who saId:
"At 4 o'clock this afternoon I shall put
an end tno my own existence. Mean
while, I must toil on up~ to) that time for
the sustenance of my family." And he
wrote on his book until the clock struels
4. when he folded up his manuscript and,
byv his own haud, concluded his earthly
life.
There arc men here who are perfectly
discontented. Unhappy in the past, un
happy today, to be unhappy forever, un
less y ou comce to this Gospel well. This
satisfies the soul with a high, deep all
absorbing and ete-rnal satisfaction. 1!
comes and it offers the most unfortu
ate man so much of this world as is best
for him, and throws al! heaven into the
bargain. The wealth of Croesus and oj
all of the Rothschilds is only a poor,
miserable shilling compared with the
eternal fortunes that Christ offers yot
today. In the far east there was a kink
who used once a year to get on a scales,
while on the other side~ of the scales
were placed gold and silver and ,zems:
indeed, enough were placed there te
balance the kin; then, at the close o1
the weighing, all those treasures were
thrown among the populace. But Christ
today steps on one side the scales, and
on the other side are all the treasures o!
the universe, and he says: '-All ar'
yours-all beight. all depth, all length
all breadth, all eternity; all are yours.'
We don't appreciate the promises of thc
Gosel.
When an aged clergyran was dying
-a man very eminent in the church-i
young theological student stood by his
side, and the aged man looked up and
said to him: -Can't you give me some
comfort in my dying hour?" "No,'
said the young man; "I can't talk tc
Lyou on this subject; you know.- all aib-u
it. and haveknown it so long.'.' "Well,'
said the dying man, "lust recite to me
some prouises." The younlz man
thought-a mioment, and he came to this i
promise. "Tie blood of .iesus Christ
Ileansetl from all sin;" and the old nu
Clapped his hands and in his dying nio
ment said: "That's just the prouise I
have been waiting for. 'The blood of
Jesus Christ cleanseth from all sin.
Oh. the warmth, the zrandeur. the niag
tiliceuce of the promises!
COME ALL YE TROUBLED.
Come, also, to this Gospel well, all
ve troubled. I do not suppose you
have escaped. Compare your view of :
this life at fifteen years of age with what t
your view of it is at forty, or sixty, or t
seventy. What a great contrast of i
opinion! Were you right then, or are
you right now? Two cups placed in
your hands, the one a sweet cup. the
other a sour cup. A cup of joy and a
cup ot grief. Which has been the near
est to being full, and out of which have
you the more frequently partaken?
What a different place the cemetery 1t
trom what it used to be! Once it was to
you a grand city improvement, and you
went out on the pleasure excursion. and
ran laughing up the mound, and you
criticised in a light way the epitaph.
But sivce the day when you heard the
bell toll at the gate as you went mn vith
the procession, it is a sad place, and
there is a flood of rushing memories that
suffuse the eye and overmaster the heart.
Oh, you have had trouble, trouble, trou
ble. God only knows how much you
have had. It is a wonder you have been
able to live through it. It is a wonder
your nervous system has not been
shattered and your brain has not reeled
Trouble, trouble. If I could gather all
the griefs of all sorts from this great au
dience and could put them in onie scroll,
neither man nor angel could endure the
recitation. Well, what do you want?
Would you like to have your property
back again? "No," you say, as a Chris
tian man: "I was becoming arrogant ,
and I think that is why the Lord took it
away. I don't want to have my pro
perty back." Well, would you have .
your departed friends back again? "No,"
you say; "I couldn't take the responsi
bihty of bringing them from a tearless
realm to a realm of tears. I couldn't
do it." Well, then, what do you want?
A thousand voices in the audience cry
out, "Comfort, give us comfort." For
that reason I have rolled away the stone
from the well's mouth. Come, all ye
wounded of the flock, pursued of the
wolves, come to the fountain where the
Lord's sick and bereft ones have come.
DESOLATION OF THE BEREAVED. t
"Ali," says some one, "you are not f
old enaugh to uederstand my sorrows. t
You have not been in the world as long
as I have, and you can talk to me about
my misfortunes in the time ,f old age."
Well, I have been a great deal among c
old people, and I know how they feel
about their failing health, and about I
their departed friends, and about the
loneliness that sometimes strikes t
through their soul. After two persons
have lived together for forty or fifty
years and one o1 them is taken away,
what desolation!
I shall not for.:et the cry of tile late
Rev. Dr. De Witt, of Yew York, when
he stood by the open grave of his be
loved wife, and, after the obsequies had i
ended, he looked down into the open
place and said: "Fafewell, my hon
ored, faithful and beloved wife. The
bond thac bound us is severed. Thou I
art in glory, and I am here on earth. I
We shall meet again. Farewell! Fare- I
well!" To lean on a prop for fifty years,
and then have it break under you!
There were only two years' diff'erence 1
between the deaths of' my father andt
mother. Atter my mother's deceaseu
my father used to go around as though
looking for something; and he would of-a
ten get up from one room without anya
seeming reason and go to another room; a
and then he would take his cane and i
start out and some oneo would say,v
'Father, where are you going?" and lie 1:
would answer, "I don't know exactlyt
where I am going." Always looking i
for something. Though he was a ten-I
der hearted man. I never saw him crya
but once, and that was at the burial of f
my mother. After sixty years living e
together, it was hard to part.t
And there are aged people today who
are feeling just such a pang as that. Ia
want to tell them there is perfect en- I
chantment in the premises of this Gos
pel; and I come to them and I offer -
them my arm, or I take their arm and (
I bring them to this Gospel well. Sit
down, f'ather or mother, sit down. Seee
if there is anything at the well for vou.
Come, David, the psalmist, have you e
anything encouraging to offer them?
-'Yes," says the nsalmist: "They shall a
still bring forth fruit in old age, they I
shall be fat and flourishing, to show thata
the Lord is upright; he is my rock, andr
there is no unrighteousness in me."t
Come, Isaiah, have you anything to say
out of your prophecies for these aged I
people? "Yes,"! says Isaiah: "Downa
to old age I am with thee. and to hoary I
hairs will I carry thee."
Well, if the Lord is going to carry
you, you ought not to worry much about
your aingeyesight and failing limbs.
Yuetalittle worried for fear some
time you will (ome to want, do
you? Your children and grandchildren
sometimes speak a little sharp at yoc
because ot your ailments. The Lord1
will not speak sharp. Do you think you
will come to wanty Who do you think
the Lord is? Are his granaries empty?
WVill he feed the raven and the rabbit,
and the lion in the desert, and fbrget
you? Why, naturalists tell us that the
porpoise will not forsake its wounded
and sick mate. And do you suppose
the Lord of heaven and earth has not as
much sympathy as the fish of the sea?
But you say: "I am so near wornout,
and I am of no use to God any more."
I think the Lord knows whether you I
are of any more use or not; if you were (
of no more use he would have taken yon
before this. Do you think God has for-t
gotton you because lie has taken care oft
you seventy or eighty years? ie thinks
more of you today than he ever did, be
cause you think more of him. May th~e
God ot Abraham and Isaac and Jacob
and Paul the aged be your God for ever!
GETHER YOURi FLOCKS.
But 1 gattier all the promises today in1
a croup. and I ask the shephierds to drive
heir flocks of lambs and sheep up to
the sparking supply. "Behold, happy
s the man whom God correcteth."c
"Though he cause grief, yet will he havet
compassion." "Many are the aillictions
of th;e righteous, but the Lord deliverethlI
him out of them all." "Weeping may
endure for a night. but joy comneth in
te morning." I am determined today t
that no one shall go away uncomfortced. j
Yonder is a tanid and shrinking soul
who seems to hide away from the con
solations I am uttering, as a child with
a sore hand hides away from the physi
cian lest lie touch the wound too roughily.
and the mother has to gto and compel
the little patient to come out and see the
hysician. I!
So 1 come to your imP' anu zhrink
og soul tcoday. :.ud conn' out in the
resence o1 te Divine I'lh l.m He
ull not hurt you. Ile lat been heai i
vounds for many N ears. and w! -,i.-t
.ou gentle and omi upo tent me.he amcat.
IUt pCOp le. whlei they hav 0 t'roub1Ile. !'(t
mvwhere rallier tum to I. De '
..uincy took pitun to get rid of hir
roubles. Charles Latmb took to punch.
l'heodore Iook itook to sf)etlhin,
trouigcr. E. vin Forrest too' to the
artical dissination. Aud men have runr
Ill around the earth. hopiug in the quick
ransit to get away froi their misfor- I
unes. It has been a dead failure. There r
s only one iell that can slake the thirst s
>f an aillicted spirit. iid that is the d-op Y
md inexhausIale well l the Gospel. t
TIE T1OUI IT oF IIEAVEN.
But somie one ia-s. iI the a;Wielnce.
Nothwitltaaudnuz al you imve said r
his morun,! I find no aLLieva lon for t
ny troubles.'" Weil. I am 1ot through V
-et. I have lett. the zuOL 3'otent !In
ideration f'or the last. I am i I t
othe you with the tiought ot heaven.]
lowever taikative we way be, there will
omwe a time when the stoutest n1lud m)'st
p11t)hatic ieterrogauion will evoke from
Is no ans - er. As soon as we have
losed our lips for tihe final sileuce uo
ower can break that taciturity. bat
vhere, oh. Christian, will be your- spit ? l
.n a scene of innite ;;!aness The i
pring uorimuar of heaveni wavfn its
>lossoms in the bri::h. a'r. Vitors t
l'esh from battle sh'owir their bcars. a
he rain or earthly sorrow struck .u
hiough with the rainbov o eteralJ joy.
n one urouD. God and angels aud the 4
edeemed-Paul and Silas. Latiner and
tidlev, Isaiah and Jeremiah, Pa son
ud John Milton. Gabriel and Michael 1
he arch angel. Long iue of choristers
eaching across th; bills. Seas o0J.1y
lashing to the white beach. Couluerors o
arching from ga-e to gate. You aiong
hem.
Oh, what a great flock of sheep God a
vill gather around the celestial well. t
wo stone on the well's mouth while the
hepherd water the sheep. There Ja
:ob will recognize Rachel the shepher
less. And stanling on one side of the
ell of eternal rapture your childre.n.
Ind standing on the other side of the I a
VC-l of eternal iapture your Christiau
ocestry, you will be bounded on all
ides by a joy so keen and grandl that t
1o other world has ever been peruitted
o experience it.
Out of that one (eep well of heaven 1
he Shepherd will dip reunion for th e I
ereaved, wealth for the poor. heahh
r the sick. rest tor the wav. Aad
heu all the lock of the Lord's sheep
Vil lie down in the green pastuirs. and
Vorld without end we will praise the
ord that on this C::st autumnal Sabbnth
f 1S91 we were permitted to study
mong the bleating dleks and lowmI -
erds of this fair ground t.he story o f
acob and R-chel the shepherdles, at a
he well in Mesopotamia. Oh, plunge
our buckets into this great Gospel A!Liv
nd let them come up dripping w:th that y
vater of which it a man drink lie never \
ain shall thir.t.
. t
,HE SOUTH ENTERS ON A NEW ERA.S
3usless and Farini;;g Interers on a
Sau1d nais
BALTIMORE, Sept. 3.-The hanu
cturers' Record, of this werk, pub
ishes six pages of speclal letters from I
eading bankers in all parts of the South o
s to the financial couditiou and pros- C
-ees of general business and armingl b
aterests. These re ports uuiformily show
hat immediately after the Baring fail
r, Southern bankera and merchants
ursued a very conservative pIohCY and1
t once commenced to ':urtail all their
perations and to make 1preparations fort
long period of monetary stringeney,.
it should come. The etfeet of thli. 1,
een the reduction of indebtedness andr
he placing of all business anud banking~
aterests on a very solid financial basis.
t also resulted in the borrowing of lessi
dvance money by cottoa planters thau
>r many years. and' hecnce~ the l'rCeeent
rop has less indebtedness azainst. it
han the crops of th rmuer yeari. In all
arts of the South thrmerS are reporitedj
.s less in debt than for years, many re
orts saying that their :ndlebteduess is
maler than at any time sine the war
-due, in part, to the enforced economy u
account of the monetary stringenc~y a
ince last fill, and ini part to the~ large i:
rops of the last few years. d
The low price of cotion in the spring r
aused the planters tO pay more atten- V
ion to raising their OWn 1)sod suplies, t
id the South will probably be lecas de- e
endant upon other sections ker corn
d wheat than ever bc-tore. It issi
ated that tile graia crop of the South
his year will aggregate nearly 100i,000,.- t
'00 bushels more thau n 18 I90, and
hs, added to tle larger ) ields or fruils t
nd vegetables, will keep at home at c
east 75,000,000 that last year went e
orth and West ihr tnood.tudl.. Tis t
rill tally ebfect the low price u; cot ton- e
d if cotton shouhdI advance by reaison e
*f a decrease in yield there wouid he at e
lear gain to S muthern farmuing itrsts.i
ie yield of sueer, rice ad tohacco
romise to exceedi the cromps of 1890I and!
o add argely to the general su~ply o'
he uth.
The bankers in all sections oh the i r
oth report that with husmuen on at e
ohdJ basis, with le-, indebtedneuss in
he part ot the farmers and mo taniec
han for many years, an-! with eropls y
sred. lrospects for the fai1 and wmn- u
er huave never been m re favor.ible.
periodl of great activ ty in oldi.1, sub-'
tantial dev'elopiunn is uiversally pre
.ieted.
(Oet Euough of laberma.
NEW YORK, Sept. U.-Geornr I.
?arks. a mulatto ueionging to Autanta. I
sa., and his family. cousmstinag of his
rife and seven children,. arrived he:e
-day on the Soriento. Parks :san in
elgent man :.[,d a carpe-nter. O()
ay 22, lured by tho prommes':i lhe
eciety for the IPriniation eb ('oonla
ion in Liberia, he set hail wi:h his
arily for that place. lHe lonedi ii j
oraia, and found the counltry in aI
nost primitive anud debaue:aMi coni- -
ition. The. Ameri:mi negroes who
a already emuigratedb there lhad as
umed most tyraninicaul rule ove~r the
.atives. No part of the trround is un
.er tltivastion. Parks huas b~eeni a slave
a the South, but he says the cu'1dution
*f slavery in Liueria i, muichi worse
han that in Georgia ubefore the war.
Thildren offer themselves for sale.
'arks was ostracize-d by the other ex
oericain negroes because he would "
tot buy slaves. After spen~dolg twe
y-one days thiere hr sauntd on a st'-amer '
or Hamburg, and fronm that p~aet for
ere. It cost him S~bo to bring htunei
d famaily out. Whena be left Gear-gi:
me had $1,~250; he has n~ow $L60 which P
nil pay lis way liack to Atlanta
WUi 5unIS to bie b.img in E mrope.
Vihen it comes it wvi l te a ueatnl :truug- t
1e, as all the great power.s will be Ull- t
wral.
A GREAT DEBUTE.
HE ;SUB-TREAStRY DISCUSSED BY15
TWO STRONG DEBAT ORC.
. the Clo of the b1scuselom : Vote
showed tie Andit nce Sirougiy i 1avor
ofn Watnatte mid ith~-1ieD-~ m sf tL--Or::ta.
Piatrorimi.
BrAEsnT RG, S. C; Sept. 9.-: enator
itler and Coiigressman Watsoa have ;
let, and the debate between Candina's il
,urdy, magnetic senator and th- virile i]
mung Ceorgian is over. TIh sub-li
-easury was the stated issue on which
iiev ciashed swords, but. measi:red by
ie exoress judgment of the ot ht r. each t
ilew tie track." ,ome very fine thinus 1
arding that ev(r present tone of con- I
-tion were said on each side. Mr. n
Vtson inadei many friends, and it is P
ut thc truth to say he had the (demon- t
r-t* ive portion ot trie crowd wi: h him. 1
e intest.ered lis discu--sion of the r
atrer with some line Ilights of (lo- 1
uenee, and with apt anecdote. On the I
:i r hand. SenatOr Butler's brave s
ords .nd stendy talk brought tinging r
ei rs from all sides.
The discussion cotiineiiced at 11 o
clock in the morning and lasted until I
te in the afternoon, with an hour's I
ispension for dinier. Mr. Watson t
pet-d the- debate, speaking for about t
vo hours. General Butler oc!upied
out the same time in reply, end in 0
Ao-ing Mr. Watson spoke for nearly
ree hiours. mAlny prominlent Alijince- n
i-n v1re present from all parts of the a
ate and tromn Georgia.
Tne meeting was called to ord-r and 0
resided over by Professor Nash. h
ravir was offered and Professoi Nash n
In read a letter from President Stokes !
f the State A)lliance regretting.. that l
her engagements prevented hiti from
tending. CPr ft ssor Nash thet made )
hort speech saying that people ate C
pt to read only on their own sice and r
ieir own papers and thus becone nar- T!
>wmindd in matters whiclh d-mand tj
e widest information. These meet- V
,s and discussions give us an *)ppor
inity to hear both sides of the ques- n
ors. "Georgia," he said." "has ;iinways V
ten kind to South Carolina at d has 1
Iways responded to her call. We are U
have the pl-asure to-day of ljs ening t
) one of Georgia's most eloque-t or- t
rs. Thomas Watson."
Mr. Watson was greeted with loud V
,iers ;s he stepped to the front of the a
atfurm. The sultance of his pet-ch n
given below. a
3tR. WATSON S SPEECII. n
Mr. Chairman and Fellow Cit:zens: b
realize the disadvantage under .vhich t
ilabor. I know t hat mndiscussingz with s5
e'ator Butler all the moral advantage b
on h:s side. You know and nonor a
io. I am unknmown to you and you are M
tikuown to tne. I am a stranger to 0
u and you are a stranger to a e. If b
nator Butler were a candida.e for c
nv rflice in your gift I Woule have u
iouegh sense not to oppose him. It c;
onu4t be a question of home ru4e for a
0oI'to settle. But that is not thf, case. 0
'hen Senat or Butler attacks the plat- "
rn on which th- farmers have taken 0
1-ir inopition, he attacks not only t
outh Carolina but her sister -tates V
-ho believe in that platform. V
We are discussing measures, not men; c
t the affairs of South Carolin::, but 1
tional affairs which affect the inter- 1
ts of South Carolina and Ge.'rgia. it
he contest is broader than on pe:sonal t
nes. I consider it an honor to meet 1.
enator Butler in debate. I hopi e;.ch I
f us may rise to the dignity of tie oc- fi
tsinn and treat the matter from a
road and logical :-tandpoint. I
The people o1 South Carolir'a are close i1
the heart of Georgia and Gieorgians. a
'ur best men are ktnown and honored b
our state and yours in ottrs. Sena- t
rButler is no less a historic cha rac-ter e
i te other side of the Savannah River t
a here. I say with the respect due o
elders. I fet-l it, an honor to meet tl
m in debate. [Cheers.] The old rebel 8
wind 1:4 just abrke on one side it the P
ver as on tihe other. a
Referring to the report of the Pros- 8
erity- uebate in the News and Ucutrier, b
-sami: '-We are o discuss the measure a
nil the principles which underlie it. c
(-ntor Butler at Prosperity diiscussed P
uce -ill and nrot the plan. Hie said there a
tat he wouild not discuss the vapor, tl
it w hat appeart d ott paip-r. So great di
star esman as Senator Butl'-r carl take a
d maintain no such position. He o
onnt contine himself to details. Every ti
nasure d'-pends utmun principles. No 1
leasure ever went through without p
ineiuen:s. First the plan Is ergan- V
-d, then the ligislators formxuilate the
etails. If you know a single right t<
esure that ever passed Congre-ss d
itout amendment you know more n
ian I di;. If the Lord's prayer we-re fI
nibodiedC in a bill and introduced in di
lgress soitebody would want to add a
mr take somiethin~g from it. In iegis- a
iion det-ails are thrownl into a legis- I
ttive hmth-potchi and harnmny colmes h:
Seaor But her must taike one --.f the
~V positiotns. Either the plati is rtwa t f
it is wrong. If it. is right an~d he t
iestlT tre'hii) wrong he shiould offe' u
aaen'd it. If the plan is wriug lie ti
ught ton he abtie to demonistratit. I Ie It
night to be al: to pmrohve i, wroing ac- hi
rdig tmo ihe Constti on~ti0im ecoI-omv. Vu
)precendent and to legislativye enaat- ti
teat. Wh ~en Senatmir Buitlmr haas to 1
s-uss the- pho bhe places himalf in ii
V a invrd position of .sayite the 0
an i r ght but 1 won't hlrp it: ir it is ii
ro - ad I ca't show it. Ie cau S
Re- -ithier hiortn in thi,- dilemntut me s
toses, b ut lhe wilh find it rough ri dintg 1:
-i voor owtn speecmh at PrVovlt4' t
m ul't discuiss thle plan;, but tmook
t it till; but whenr 'ou ailvo'-ed tI
ate banuks you disc-ussed the plait but I1
t te bill. * On what shall these '.mite n
rks i.su~e nonry y What assturance V
'al we havie-that theym will nt becomie al
ild cat schenm-s y llow sh~tll we ;.a:ke it
emt lmmatnuney on re-al estate y Ymmu ei
lk- abomL State tao ks tuow betmt out h.
your bihi. But I won't st.-p 'iere.
he uatoir has got to talk abou the pl
dl. and may God give the ' vitory to L
mi who is ini tihe right. Mir. W:.tmin .2
-Terr d to the reform miovement ini 1
n-ad, w hich was agitated by the ml
i amuI set led by them before- ani) U
!!wsfi-amed. T1uie tjplesttin of 'rishi y<
oir!ie ulon't stop for a bili, b.:t at
hen the: peopla pass on it a bil H 11tit h
amed. Gecnerazl, if o1ur platn is t-ight o
:in't you come and help us produmce a ti
ll? I will make this concesion. U
mut or Butle-r is honest in his op osi- cl
cat, and ini that spirit I am dtin . ttu a~
i e Smuthi . e have had tar iftr ar orn
tooted anddisiu,sd b'etore \I111s eve r ii
t ta-n to paper. Now help 's discuss hi
e sub-treasury plan, not the bt. ar
ears ago we talked secession aiiu di- h;
us-:ed the plan of see--ssion, but no hi..l 01
as ever m ramied. If the plain had II
ittmpheiid there would h ave been -:lu :- of0
uetionis to be settleci by bills. Now
thn help us debaute the plan an.t we w~
i t rmre the bili.'
Coirg down to the sutb-tre:snaryw
an, r. Watson spoke of tnhe tend.-ncy I:
citg to ohd ideas aimi method, re- se
rir.g t >the prisoners who shed 'ears o
hen libe-ratt d from tl.e hastile ac.d tm d
e eppsitionl to any imiprovemeent in si
i postal s'istemi. "Now is it a good hi
ation. What is the evil compiaue
f ? 1 po General Butler: I don't undei
l:nu this report of your speech whirr
ays t hat the iational baiks do not ge
o per cent. more. but 11) rer cent. les
han they pay for. Is that correct
enator Butler: Why, of course
i arguing to show that that positiol
5 not corr-et. If I buy a norse of yoi
h- horse is mir.e and the money 1
ours. I hat is payiog for a thin(,
iational 1-arks siantly deposit thei
onds and draw Interest on then re
eiving for their bonds 90 per cent. il
auney. Senator Butler said the bank
og system was a war measure. I den
'.he fitst bank charter was grantel
a F- bruary, 1863. The first bank not
,as issued December 21, 1663, and a
h- banks did not get into proper work
ig order the bill reallirming the na
ional banking Act was passed, bu
ot until 1664. when the war was prat
ir-aily ended. I his was not a wa
weasure. The greenbacks took th
eople through the war, and this sys
em was est abiisheu to get the mone
ato the banks of the plutocrats. Th
ational banking system was a Rr-put
can institution. Wouldn't you tiii
strange that a man who opposes th
ub-troasury would vote to recharte
ational bznks? But Call of Florida
orman of Maryland and Hlampton o:
out h Carolna did so. National bank
ave bad your money and have beef
nrding it to you. The protits accruin
) them are estimated by financial au
ao rit y at from a25,000,00 to $50,000,00
year. They have been growing riel
a what they owe. Infainy of infanie
would like the firc. (-f national indig
ation to rise and swet them from th
arth.
:iator Butler wants the system at)
lished. If that is done what shall w
Lve in its place? The issuance o
ioney is a sovtrteign right. low n il
re people get it, except by loaning
'armers and frited. of labor deman<
bat a svstemn of loans on land and non
erisihatile products shall take the plac
f the national banks. Yet our oppo
ents fall to pieces if we mention sut
reasury. They "cuss" in all colors o
ie rainbow .ud go home and spani
de bab3 over it.
New idLeas nave to spring tip lik'
ew scions from the roots ot decayint
rees. Yet this is not an entirely nes
lea. The bank of Amsterdam. th
est of the present system, is the sub
reasury pure ana simple. You tak
aere y our gold and silver and deposi
. You receive certificates of deposi
hich immediately become currenc:
nd circulate throughout Europe. YoL
eed not take coin, but old metal o
ny kind. That was the sub-treasur
early three hundred years ago. Th
ank of Hamburg saw the results o
us policy and adopted it with th
ime beneficial results. In Sweden th
anks base their currency not on silve
ud gold but, on land, the idea whict
re have now got. Triey loan mone:
n lan' to two-thirds of the valuatioi
und on the tax books at four pe
ent. In towns the valuation is base<
n the amount for which the p:opert:
n be insured. They loan the mone;
t four per cent., which Senator Butle
isapproved in his Prosperity speecL
,o doubt if they had knowa the Poo
pinion the Senator would have o
em some hundred years later the:
ould have demanded, and the peapl
rould have paid, the rate of seven pe
i-nt. n hich lie thinks is the proper rate
Iou will find, my friends, that the mat
,ho wants to borrow at a low rate o
iterest is the man who intends to re
urn the loan, while the man who neve
itends to pay is williiig to take th
yan at any rate at which it may be oi
:red.
They had tied it in Norway, and th
:icyclopedia Brittanica, which is no
a polities, is not a demagogue and no
crank, says it has been of incalcula bi
enefit to the people. Why not trn,
3m here ? Frederick the great adopt
the plan to build up his counrtry af
?r seven years' war by establishing th
ilesian Bank, which loaned money t
ne farmers at four per cent. If ou
overnmenit can borrow money at tw
er cent. why can't the people ? Whi
Sit that borrows 'out the people ? Wh3
enator, you yourself, who denounc
orrowing at less than seven per cent
re a party to borrowing at two pe
nt. I have shown you the plan ar
led to land, let us see how it work
pplied to cotton and wheat. It take
ree times as munch catton to paty
ebt ol 8100 as it did t wenty years agt
nd your debts has e not decrease d
omebody then, has robb-d you of tw.
:urids of your cotton. What ha~s dont
Ly Contraction of the currenicy. Sup
ose I had 8100.000 whbich w as all ther
ras or could be in Lexington County
'he division of thai ainount accordini
athe amount or yotur products woul<
etermmfe the price of them. Suppost
o w, Ihhouild burn half of that money
'he value or your products would b
ecreas:'d jusit one-half, f or the smalle
mount of money must be divided jos
s the larger amount would have been
'o must pay your debts just as yet
a:I to tefore but the debts have no
ecreased in proportion to the decreas
t he moelimt with which you have tU
v hem. That is just th~e way con
rietioni of the currency has robbed yoi
f two-:hirds of ycur cotton. Contrac
on or the cirrency in En land rnobbe<
ur-liths of the farmers or thel
oes and great dituress p'revaile
util Lord tastlerragh inmroduce<
i bills in one day pirovidinlg
)r an increase mt the <:lrculatin1
ledt rn. The-n a da:. o*f prosperit;:
a'sneci and the farmiers :.egan to re
eem their ho.iws. O, citizens of tan
outhi, mtay the time cotme whten on
atsmenCI iay hecar anid see, wvhen thi:
ill shall set in flow a tidr of actiot
n on: people anall bt'gmi to redeent
eir homes.
I have shtown you the a rgtument fo
we hai.1 baa. What good will it do
Swil! betnellt the mn who has tot
miuc Iard w.hich is deipreciatitig it
lue e-' cry year. because he can sell
nd use tne proceeds to imuprove tha
aliuce-. It ill benteit the tenan t by
:abling htuu to purchase land ata
ae a ilome ol his own.
No w when they Iti a that our peoS
i arc exuravagant and laizy I point tt
e tact that a f ew years a g,> they sai.
a were not ilUng cottont en~ough
ou turned to, ran the plow poisn
ay-etr. andt this y ar yon raised 5000X.
ij ii-. Nowv Senaaor Bum ier telh
> u tht if you will only plant tes
re to lhe tile that Eden i: here ac
rgates are wide opeu. If there i
or ~rodtuctioon of cotton, why is il
tat ao nany ot our Soulth Carolhna anc
eorgia girls and boys are so pocri3
Oted that they cannot go to Sunday
hool? There is a butg tn the butter
.1k somewhere-. Suppose a man starty
with a debt, as you did after the war
w is he ever goinig to pay it ? There
*c nien here over w hose dimmed eyes
igs the same-debt as~ when they canm
it ot the war stalwart and' vigt.rouis
ur peo'ple noght ho alie to keep out
debt li thev didn't st'rt in debt.
I have told vou how the laud lo.n
ould work. Is there a slugle arg.
eit in favor of the land loan which
l1 not apply to cotton ? Land has a
edh value. Cotton and wheat repre
ut the product of labor, the true unit
raine. Economnists agree that the
iar is not the unit of value, bit the
vet of a mian's face. Mlr. Watson
re quoted f romn Adam Smith to sus
in uim srntenent. The suh..treasury
I plan, he said, recognizes this fact that w
- labor i. the true unit of value. This Y
i will give us a currency which will al- Y
t ways answer the demand and we shall
i have n-ither coul raction nor inlia- ti
Stiol. I
L Senator Butler says he don't want is
i warehouses. Then he ought to give us n
L the beneit of his suggestions by amend- t<
s ing the bill. We can use warehouses n
-. already erected and need not build a t<
r single one. Select a warehouse in each p
- district for the storage of your pro
i ducts and have the manager selected p(
- and bonded. You need not spend a ci
T dollar. Now let Senator Hutler show re
I that don't suit and we will try until he if
is satislied. The Senator says the ti
s money would go back into the Treasuiry yE
- at the time when it was most needed. it
- Ile allowed only six rhonths that the it
t products could remain in the ware- si
- house instead of twelve. Ile falls into jc
the error of supposing that we would p:
take our stock out the same dly w e put r
- it in. They say. too, that it will give d(
I speculators a chance to control i he crop.
It will des:roy speculation and give c<
every man an equal chance. Mr. Wat- a
son closed -his speech wizh a magnifi- tv
cent peroration, and his hopeful elo- T
r quence carried his audience by storm. di
, s t SENATORl BUTLER el
I was then introduced by the chairman, re
and was greeted with loud cheers. IHe st
i spoke substantially as follows: tr
Mr. Chairman and Fellow Citizens: e:
- My friend reproached me for not dii- n
3 eussin thesub-treasury bill at Prosper- ti
ity. I was invited to discuss the plan ta
upn its merits. The bill being the se
- only plan I had seen or heard of I ven- gi
a tured to discuss it. I have been de
fatted and derided because I exercised g(
the right of on American citizen to dis 1R
cuss any measure presented to the peo- te
ple. The bill was introduced and every h
I where hailed as the consumnation of all n;
the wisdom of American statesmen. I1
i Yet I s-eni to have committed a crime b;
- when I ventured to discuss it without a
the consent of the bosses who are try- n:
- ing to dominate all who do not je
- agree with them. 'the charge that I a1
said tiat those who wantid to borrow of
money at 2 per cent. never intended to tt
pay it is false; so too is the statement T
that I saia that no man ought to bor- id
row for less than 7 per cent. I have b<
stood by the side of too many people of tb
the State, in the times when their souls p:
- were tried, to say that 40,000 of them w
are scoundrels, and I brand the author 01
t of it as a liar. I have lived too long to ti
pander to demagogues and charlatans is
for the hignest office in the gift of the tb
L people of the State. c<
r Mly friend rebuked me because I had gi
r not amended the bill. I have those two ca
bills here and will submit them to any I
iEDtelligent and impartial man in the is
State and let him say whether in that fr
forw they were susceptible of amend- Pt
ment. The bills were introduced, went T
through the usuil course, were report- tI
r ed on favorably, and I had an oppor- 1)
L tunity to amend them if they had been tr
r susceptible of it. tb
i When my friend had tiislied 1 was fe
disposed to jump up and say: "The po- a
litical milleniumu and the political mes- 0
siah have come." He is a new man. Ii.
.1e is going to Congress. le's not only Of
going to smash the national banks and Of
pass the sub-treasury bill [a voice: ti
r "Tnat's what we want."] but he's going bt
to reduce the cotton tax and lie will fnd Sa
me right by his side. u
When I offered my bill to repeal the ti
10 per cent. tax on State banks my
f friend would not accept it. Now 1 P1
- would have the farmers go to the Leg- -(
r islature and get a bank charter. On tl
their deposits let them issue $2 for .1. ei
-The old State banks answered our pur- al
poses; they will again, because, as my ti
friend probably does not know, the. na- tb
tional banking Act was a copy of the In
banking Act of New York State. What W
harm can come from repealing that St
tax? If we had banks in Columbia, y1
- Charleston, Newberry or Batesburg, is- d
- sumng $2 for $1 deposited, it would Si
remedy the difficulties which I know to
>exist. [A voice: "lIow are we to get
rthe capital?" Work for it, sir. Ilow W
>did auybody ever get capital? It sE
>would take out of the hands of pluto. al
,crats the power to contract the curren- s<
Scy. It's his own remedy. It the farm- 11
,ers want to go into banking with their st
rcotton I want to see them in a position si
- to do it. Cotton is lust as good securi- fC
Sty for currency as silver. If they will ce
ihave the government buy cotton as it yt
Sbuys silver I will go as far as he will. irl
,But this is entirely different from his bi
.plan, which is to raise money direct to lti
- the people by advancing 80 per cent. ni
SThe Constitution prohibits this. This U]
- may seem old fogyish to those latter &
Sday statesmen who look upon that in- Ot
.strumwent as a dead letter. I regard it ti
eas a living, vital, powerful protection s<
to the peop~le, because the R~epublicans 91
have tL-e will to trample on it if they 15
lind it in the way of themselves or their a'
ends. ol
If the newspapers are to be believed 11
he has been doing some energetic work 2l
. in Georgia against the third party. As ni
tthe chairman has said, Georgia has of- EC
ten aided South Carolina in her politi- 15
Scal troubles. Distinguished men have bi
>given aid and moral support, but here- ti'
.tofore they came to aid in maintaining w
ithe honor and perpetuity of the Demo- er
cratic party. Now he has come to put
t in the entering wedge of its dlisruption. p:
lIe h-as auvocated the establishment of ni
a third party. [Mr. Watson: "'Are you fr
is('cussing thea plan or the bill now ?'] to
"Y ou havse attacked my record; now w
yours is open to mxe." '[Mr. Watson: -p<
-l"Ths wa s to be a sub-treasury discus- nm
sion. If you attack my record I must ra
hav e some time to reply. You may at- sa
-tack mie on any point you please, but I b3
cain deflend myself."} Then I say this, so
that I believe that toe doctrine asserted sa
by himi will iesult in a third party.
[A voice: "Where did it spring from la
-ast year ?"] I hope that will be a les
sou to us. There is no roomn for a third tli
party' in this country, al.
I believe the converting of the Alli
anice into a secret order was a great a.
mistake. If its princip~les had b,-en
adhered to it would have prevented the
oppression complained of. 'The farm
ers through the Alliance kn')cked out bL
theojutetrousthey were solid as ad
rockandbroghtthejute trust to isII
knmees. su
The tariff bili passed by the last Coin- fo
gress increased the price of c.ottonl ties. es
lhe tariff bill passed by the last Con- th
cress raised the rate on cotton ties from to
3~> to 1.02 per cent. I made the best hi
speech I knew how against it but they 1l0
passed the bill. The result was just sa
what I expected. Tlhe price was raised Dc
from $1.25 to $1.45 or $1.54). Some have w:
said they didn't feel the tariff, that it sti
was not a vital issue. There is the in- di
crease in cotton ties. See what that
amounts to in the aggregate, every dol- .tit
lar of which goes into the pockets of .an
the Pennsylvania manufacturers. If au
the Alliance will get together and say wi
to the manufacturers --we won't use lhi
your ties' there wvould be something| fo
practie.at which v~ ould relieve them of jfo
an enormous bumden. I presume that an
will rectify that too. (A voice: "That's vo
what he will.") If the Alliance wtill Ihi:
stick to the principles of Its organiza-.lte
tion it is supreme, but when they pro- 1e2
pose a plan which does not meet my Ct~
judgment I cannot endorse it. In~ my
judgment the Alliance is the blest anid.
most effective plan the farmer ever he
adopted to protect himself against op- wi
prsson When om, unite the tie trn d he
ill come to terms as the jute trust did.
on can use rope to bind your cotton.
our rathers did before the war.
My friend took up the proposition
at the currency (lid not affect prices.
said ir, should be increased, but I take
sue with him on that point. That is
>t the only trouble. I understood him
say that supply and demand had
thing to do with prices. I should like
say why, with the recent adverse re
)rte, the price of cotton has gone up?
he depreciation amounts to 20 or 30
,r cent. There is no more money in
rculation. Supply and demand have
gulated the price. Hence I say that
the farmers would plant ten acres to
e mule and more provisions, in three
ars they would be the richest people
the country. I would join the move
ent to plant only that amount if a
Xicient number of the farmers would
in with me. I am satisfied that sup
y and demand an.d not the need of
ore money is the controlling factor in
termining prices.
I can'L approve the bill because it en
urages Federal interference with the
fairs of the people. which we have for
renty-five years been trying to avoid.
his bill will put us, body and soul, un
the domination of the Federal gov
nment, and more than that it is in di
et violation of Article Iof the Con
itution. Not a dollar goes into the
easury except by taxation, with two
:ceptions. Where are you to get this
oney ? You can only get it by taxa
>n; I know of no other way. He says
ke care of the people in spite of them
Ives. I say leave them alone. The best
>verned people are the least governed.
My friend complains that I have sug
,sted no remedy. The Congressional
cord will show that I have been con
riding for a correction of the wrongs
laped upon the people. He wars on
ttional banks but he rejects my plan.
I could promulgate a plan inspired
7 heaven they would reject it. Under
State bank system we could borrow
oney easier than we can today. I ob
et to the national banks because they
e so eompletely under the domination
'the Federal government, and because
ey were adopted as a war measure.
he land loan system was tried in Flor
a some years ago and failed. I can
>rrow money on land in every Statein
.e Union now. There ought to be no
ovision of the national banking law
hich would prevent the loan of money
land. I am no apoligist for the na
>nal banking system, bat I can't abol-'
h the national oanks alone. I regret
at anything escaped me to offend the
urtesies of the occasion to our distin
iished guest. I referred to his politi
.1 record in Georgia in reply to what
thought a fling against myself. Here
the talk about 'a third party. My
lend asks me if there was not a third
rty in this State last year? I say no.
iere was an attempt at one which I
ought ill-advised. I voted thestraight
emocratic ticket and worked against
e third party. Life is too short and
.e world too large to quarrel about dif
rences of opinion. There is a talk of
third party in the West and in some
the Southern States, but when the
ies of battle are drawn the majority
our people will be found in the ranks
the Democratic and Republican par
s. Only the Hessians will be found
tween the lines. There.is, bautnon-;
fety for us in the South our constant,
idaunted and unhesitating support to
ie Democratic party.
My friend asks what the Democratic
rty has done for us in the last twenty
ars. Though in a small miaority
ey have resisted the attempt of radi
lism to put the chains of slavery
>out our necks. In the last Congress,
ough still in a minority they defeated
e iniquitous force bill, in a parlia
entiary struggle such as never before
as seen in the history of the Anglo.
,xon race. And now, ifter all our
ars of suffering, when the prospects
e so bright, are the beople of the
>uth to divide to give power to the
epublicans again ?
Whatever differances we may have
e must discuss and settle among our-.
ives. I have become accustomed to
use. Whenever my services shall be
uight for I shall not count the cost.
'when my term Is expired, the people
all send somebody else In my place I
all not complain. It might be better
r me personally, and if I am to advo
te measures which 1 do not approve
Li must seek another man. I am not
this controversy as Senator Butler.
it as plain M. C. Butler whom you
sve known all your lives. When Ilam
>t permitted to speak the truth as I
iderstand it let my friends lay me
ide, and if it is thou~ht that some
her man is better titte to represent
em let them say so. but let them say
honestly and boldly and not malign
defame me. Durng my incumbency
oflice I have never allo wed the honor
d interest of the people of South Car- -
ia to be assaulted without resenting
the best I conld. The benks which
r. Watson has mentioned are like our
trional banks. The money is not loan.
.by the government. Our Treasury
not a bank, it only receives and dis
rses taxes. Loans made to two na
mial expositions are no precedents on
bich to be found any system of gov
niment loans.
The speager here made a com
rison between a system of govern
ent loans and of borrowing money
:)m the State Treasurer, and referred
the position of some of his opponents
aio dleclare that the tariff Is an unim
rtant issue, showing that the cheap.
sa of some articles under a higher
te of taxation is the result of latK'r
ving nmachine-ry and is not affected
'the tariff. He closed by referring to
me of the advisers of the farmer and
ying:
If D~r. Stokes will give me the same
ad1 and the same mules, in five years
,vill be able to buy him out. I have
at mueh conlidence in my farming
ility, and that much distruct in his
ility, for I don't believe he ever struck
ick in his life.
MR1. WATSON'S REPLY.
[t would be impossible in anything
t a stenographic report to give aD
eq uate idea of Mr. Watson's reply.
met the Senator's criticisms on the
b-treasury plan, explained his grounds
objection to the proposition to
ablish State bank-s. and referring to
e position some Alliancemen are said
hold on the tariff question declared
uself in favor of absolute free trade.
gardinlg the third party matter he
d: --nl stanid by the Ocalagplatform,
matter where it leads. The man
to will vote for a thing and then not
ck to it involves himself in a contra
:tion."
[lls brilliant t-loquence, apt illustra
's and forcible arguments silenced
d convinced his questioners in the
dience, and carried the whole cro-wd
th him. They were asked to vote on
Sposition anO that of Senator Butler,
:and against the Ocala platform and
-and against the sulbtreasury plan,
d in each instance the vote was over
elmingly in his favor. The brilliant
ung Georgian completely captivated - -
audience and awakened a new in
'-est in the Ocala platform and its
ding feature, the sub-treaaury bill.
lumbila llegiscer.
X man may go to heaven without
tth, without riches without honors,
thout learning, without friends; but
can neve tet there without Chrst.