The Manning times. (Manning, Clarendon County, S.C.) 1884-current, April 15, 1891, Image 1
VOL. vII. MANNING, S. C., WEDNESDAY, APRIL 15, 1891. NO. 17.
STORY OF THE COOSAW.
THE FIGHT NOW ON IN THE FEDE
RAL COURT.
Unexpected Appearance of the Attorney
General--La3ing Out the Lines of Bat
tle-The Argument of the Counsel Pro
and Con.
CARLEsTON, S. C., April 8.-Par
suant to the order issued by Judge
Simonton in the United States Circuit
Court on Tuesday, the proceedings on
the order to the Coosaw Company to
show cause why the receivership cre
ated by the State should not be made
permanent were begun yesterday morn
ing at 11 o'clock.
The Court was opened for the ordin
ary business of the term at 10 o'clock,
but little was done, as e, erybody was
waiting expectantly for the arrival of
the hour when the cause now so famous
in the judicial annals of South Caro
lina, should be argued. The opposing
counsel appeared in Court a few mm
utes before 11, and taking their seats
at the long table just in front of the
clerk's desk quietly awaited the hour.
When the portly form of Attorney Gen
eral Pope appeared in the Court room
there was some surprise evinced by
many persons present, as it had been
thought that he would not have been
able to leave Aiken, where similar pro
ceedings are in progress before Judge
Aldrich in the State Court. By travell
ing in the night, however, Mr. Pope,
and Mr. I. A. M. Smith, of counsel,
reached the city, and, accompanied by
Major Julian Mitchell, appeared in
Court before the appointed hour. They
looked as fresh and ready for another
hard day's work as if they had been on
a week's holhday, instead of being en
gaged in burning the midnight oil over
musty law tomes, studying up the
merits of their position.
IN BATTLE ARRAY.
These gentlemen occupied seats near
the door, while at the other end (f the
table sat the Hon.Augustine T. Smythe,
Mr. Louis DeB. McCrady and Mr. T.
W. Bacot, counsel for the Coosaw Mi
ing Company. The tables were crowd
ed with law books, and a half dozen in
evitable "green-bags," crammed with
heavy volumes, peeped out from under
the seats of the opposing lawyers. The
counsel on both sides were evidently
ready for heavy work,- and each was
prepared to meet promptly any point
that might be raised by the opposing
attorneys.
There was no crowd in the Court
room. The arguments were supposed
to be dry and technical, and the general
public took but little interest in them.
There were, however, several members
of the Charleston Bar present. who
listened with great interest to the ar
guments as they were presented.
OPENING FIRE.
Judge Simonton was en the Bench
before 11 o'clock, and as the hands of
the big Court clock crept around to the
appointed hour Mr. Smythe, leading
counsel for the Coosaw Company, arose
and informed the Court that, in ooe
dience to the order of the previous day,
the defendants were present and ready
to proceed.
Attomey General Pope read the fol
lowing, which was fiied with the clerk:
A PLEA TO THE JURISDICTION.
"And now comes the State of South
Carolina, plaintiff above named, by the
Hon. Y. J. Pope, Attorney eneral of
the said State, and appear herein for
the purpose only of contesting the
jurisdiction of this Court over the
above mentioned cause, and the legality
of the attempted removal of the same
from the Court of Common Pleas for
Beaufort County. and for no other pur
pose whatsoever. Y.- J. Pope.
"Attorney General, State of S. C.'
)FUTUAL ENP'LANATIONS.
Mr. Pope then called attention to the
remarts of Mr. Smythe on Tuesday, in
which a reflection had been thrown on
him for not replying to a letter which
it was said had been written to him in
his official capacity. He disclaimed
ever having received such a letter,
either individually or as Attorney Gen
eral. After mutual satisfactory ex
planations between Mr' Pope and Mr.
Smythe, the latter gentleman called at
tention to the fact that the paper intro
duced by Mr. Pope raised immediately
the question of jurisdiction, and re
quested Mr. McCrady to present the
argument of the defendants.
liR. LOUIS DE B. M'CRADY.
Mr. McCr'ady began his argument
promptly and applied himself to the
points in issue without any introduc
tory fiourish of trumpets or rhetorical
effort.
There were, he said, three iconstitu
tional questions involved in the cause.
The tenth section of Article IV of the
Constitution of the United States pro-,
vided that no State could by any legis
-lative act impair the obligation of its
contracts. Under an Act of the South
Carolina Legislature a grant had been
made to the Coosaw Mining Company.
nder which it claimed an indefinite
and exclusive license, on certain condi
tions, to mine rock from the Coosaw
River, opposite to and south of Chis
ol's Island. By another Act passed
on December 23,1l890, a board of phos
phate commissioners was created, and
the Act provided that the board should,
on and after March 1, 1891. take pos
session of the Coosaw territory, and
further authorized the uoard to issue
licenses to other parties to milne in this
rive.- On the 21st of March the State
of South Carolina filed a complaint in
the Court of Common Pleas of Beaufort
County. askIng for an injunction re
straining the Coosaw Company from
asserting its rights to the territory and
from mining rock within it. There is
no reference in the complaint of the
Act of 18910. but without the Act the
board would have had no existence.
The wrongs charged 'against the Coo
saw Company are the wrongs set forth
in this Act, and nowhere else. In this
suit the Coosaw Company has tilled a
petition for a removal to the United
States Court, and in regard to jurisdic
tion it must be shown by the defen
dants that there is a Pederal question
involved. Is the petition for removal
a pleading, and can a Federal question
be set forth in that petition ?~
In support of his position M1r. Alc
rady quoted numerous authiorities,
among them the Gold Washing atnd
Water Company vs Keys, 96 U. S., page
202, which he referred to several times
in the course of his argument and read
from at some length. In 121 U. S., page
42, in the case of Carson vs Dunham,
it was held that where the petition was
defective it might even be amended to
make more plain the point of jurisdic
tion. He quoted further from 122 U.
S., page 517; Mayer vs Cooper, 6 WVal
lace, ge 252; Railroad vs Mississippi,
102 L. S., page 140, and a further
lengthy list of authorities.
Section 10 of the 4th article of the
Constitution must be construed for the
purpoe of seeing if the act of D~ecem
er 3 1890, is embraced in its purview,
but a further constitutional question
than this is involved. The 5th article
Of the Constitution provides that no
person shall be deprived of his proper
tv without due process of law. The
oosaw Campany claims that it has an
indefinite grant under certain condi
tions, which it has fulfilled, but the
State notwithstanding this claim, has
passed an Act seeking to deprive the
company of its property without the
process of law. The "due process of
law," it has been decided, is a case in
which there is a plaintiff, a defendant,
a complaint, an answer and a trial, but
the Act of December 23, 1890, contem
plated nothing of this kind. In the
definition of due process Mr. McCrady
quoted Bump on Constitutional Decis
ions, page 35U0.
Under the Act of 1890, if any one at
tempted to mine in Coosaw River with
out a permit, his property was imme
diately forfeited to the State, and the
State was authorized to bring action
for claim and delivery, and in such case
was required to give no bond. If, after
several years' litigation, it was decided
that the Company was in the right, its
property would then h, I-st, a-d it
could get no redress since the Stata
could not be sued, and there would be
no bond on which to sue. Further
more, the Act of 1890 practically re
pealed the Act by March 20, 1876, by
which the grant was made, and the re
peal took place after the Coosaw Com
pany had spent vast sums of money on
its Iplant, and its great property was
thus to be swept away without any re
dress from the Courts of South Caro
lina.
On the subject of the State being a
plaintiff, Mr. McCrady cited the cases of
Railroad vs Mississippi, 102 U. S., page
140; Ames vs Kansas, 11 U. S., page
462; Tennessee vs Davis, 100 U. S. page
269; Stone vs South Carolina, 117 U. S.,
page 269; Stone vs South Carolina, 16
S. C., page 544; Barker vs Bowman, 8:h
S. C., page 388, and many other author
ities sustaining the same point.
ATTORNEY GENERAL POPE.
Mr. McCrady was followed by At
torney General Pope for the State. In
beginning Mr. Pope submitted the fol
lowing suggestion to the Court:
"And now comes State of South Car
olina by the Hon. Y. J. Pope, the At
torney General of said State. and gives
the Court to understand and- be in
formed that there is now pending and
being beard before the Court of Comnmon
Pleas for Beaufort County the question
of the ordering an inj unction and con
tinuing its receiver under the rule to
show case in said case in said Court
made and returnable on 7th April,
1891, and also on the question of juris
diction of such Court.
Y. J. POPE,
"Attorney General,
State of South Carolina."
Mr. Pop, after some introductory
remarks of a personal nature, said that
in the argument of opposing counsel
he had detected two errors, one of leg
islative history and one of State and
judicial history. It was news to the
State of South Coralina that the Coo
saw Company first saw the light in
1876 It was the child of an Act of the
28th of March, 1870, he said, and, con
tinuing, he gave what he claimed was
the history of the provisions of that
Act.
Mr. Pope's style 13 impassioned and
earnest, and he referred at some length
to the action of the Coosaw Company
in, as he expressed it, ungratefully dis -
avowing the State, its mother, and quo
ted Shakespeare and several other au
thorities to sustain his position on this
point. He asserted with much warmth
the determination of the State to give
and to claim what was right, and asked
what the State had done that the de
fendant could come here with such
loud complaints. His remarks in this
part of his argument smacked strongly
of what hiight be termed sarcasm, and
his references to opposing counsel as
"these young men" causedtsome amuse
ment to those gentlemen. The State,
he said, had bowed her sovereign head
to come into a Court of justice, and the
people of South Carolinn felt it acute
ly that this mining company was not
satisfied with the righteous conduct of
the State and sought to inject delay in
the proceedings, and thereby induce a
compromise. He wanted to disabuse
counsel's mind of the idea that the
State would consent to anything like
this. Souil Carolina was neither poor,
nor wanting in spirit, and no concaten
ation of events could procure a com
promise. The State had been insulted,
and her laws shall be vindicated, and
this creature of hers(the Coosaw Com
pany) made to respect her. No power.
save that of the United States Courts
could stay her right to make this crea
ture bow in submission to her righte
ous will. He here paid a lengthy trib
ute to South Carolina, the United States
and Chief Justice Marshall, and the
Federal Courts.
The filing of a petition and bond does
not constitute a transfer of a case, he
said, It is the duty cf a suitor who
wishes a transfer to appear in the State
Court and settle the matter there, and
any othet course indicated a lack of
courtesy toward the State Court. On
the point of the United States jurisdic
tion being purely statutory, he read the
Act of Congress of 1887 amendatory to
the Act of 1875, which latter Act, lie
said, was fraught with great mischief
and arrogance to the States. Every
case cited, he said, by the opposing
counsel had been decided under the old
mischievous Act, and not one under
the ne w Act of 1887. Under the law of
1887 the Court was compelled to con
fine itself In such cases to the com
plaint filed in the State Court. This
was not true under the old law, and it
was there that the difference between
the Acts of 1875 and 1887 appeared.
The petition to this Court states no
facts which raises a Federal question.
From the beginning of this case the
great cry on the part of the defendants
had bee-n the great amount of money
that the-y had paid to the State, but
they said nothing abdut the money the!
had made out of the Coosaw River.
The amount they paid to the State was
only a part of the value of the State's
property.
lHe asserted that the State could not
grant in perpetulty to a few persons
the exercise of rights which belonged to
all her citizens. Any such Act of the
Legislature is repealabie. On the prin
cipal of eminent domain, the State can
take the property of private citizens
and appropriate it to rights of way for
corporations, such as railways, canals,
etc. But she holds navigable rivers
arid the soil beneath them in trust for
all her citizens. She holds them as a
sovereign, and any act which gives
them away can be undone by a subse
queut Legislature. .In support of tis
he quoted the final decision in the
famous Louisiana slaughter house case.
and argued that a Legislature could
not bind another Legislature to such
grants where the whole people were di
rectly interested. In reply to a ques
tion from the Court, Mr. P'ope ex
plained more explicitly that he held
that where an Act was passed by one
Legislature confining public rights to a
few individuals, a subsequent Legisla
tore could annul it.
GOING INTO ANCIENT HISTORY.
This company may tiourish, he said,
but in the end it would be overtaken.
Charges had been made, though they
may ne ut!ue, that the inception of
these matters in the Legislature were
not handsome-I will use no stronger
term.
Mr. Smythe: "Now, if he wants to re
fer to those things, let him put them
in the pleadings, and we will meet him
now."
Mr. Pope: "I will not refer to these
mtters if the company behaves in a
seemly manner, but if it does not the
strong arm of the law will catch it by
the nape of the neck and swing it clean
out. We will try to avoid it. but if
necessary will do it."-News and Cou
rier.
Argument at Aiken.
AIKEN, S. C., April 8.-Judge Al
drich, in chambers, continued the hear
ing of the argument to-day on the peti
tion of the Phosphate Commission
that the adpointment of a temporary
receiver and the temporary injunction
of the Coosaw Company be made per
manent. The State was represented by
Col. Robert Aldrich and Mr. G. S.
Mower, and the Coosaw Company by
Gen. Edward McCrady and Mr. A. M.
Lee. The hearing commenced at 10
a. m. and continued until 2 p. m. A
recess was tnen taken until 3.30 p. m.,
when the hearing was resumed. It
was concluded at 4.30 p. m. Messrs.
Mower, McCrady and Lee left for
Charleston on the night train and Col.
Aldrich returned to Barnwell.
The matter is inL Judge Aldrich's
hands, and his decision as to whether
he, sitting in chambers, had jurisdic
tion in the case, and as to whether the
appointment of a receiver and the
granting of a permanent injunction
may be expected in a few days.
Mr. Mower, in opening the argument,
addressed himself to the task of proy
ing that Judge Aldrich had jurisdic
tion in the case. In support of his
views he quoted liberally from law
and precedent.
Col. Aldrich followed for the State
and Gen. McCrady and Mr. Lee for
Coosaw. The time before dinner was
taken up in arguing the question of
jurisdiction. After dinner the argu
ments were on the appointment of a
receiver. Col. Aldrich said it seemed
that the rock was owned by the State,
which is not disputed, and when the
Coosaw Company ceases work the State
is deprived of its revenue, adding bur
dens to the taxpayers. It appeared that
his Honor should issue the usual order,
confirming the order issued appointing
a temporary receiver, and continuing
him until further action of the court.
He thought there is no reason why
Mr. Brooks should not be appointed
receiver because he is a clerk in the of
lice of the Secretary of State.
Gen. McCrady-" Would you think it
proper to appoint a Coosaw oflicial re
ceiver ?"
Col. Aldrich-"Yes, if it pleased the
court."
Gen. McCrady then suggested Mr.
Moses E. Lopez for the position. Ile
knows more about phosphates than
any other man in this State.-The
State.
Italy's Bluster.
RoME, April 2.-In a long interview
with Marquis di Rudui, Minister Porter
stated that the United States govern
ment is willing to materially compensate
the families of the New Orleans victims,
but that it is impossible for the Wash
ington government to place the lynchers
on '.rial, that being a matter for the
grand jury in New Orleans to decide.
The Premier insisted that Italy's dignity
demanded that~ the culprits should be
punished.
All endeavors to obtain the opinion
upon the present crisis between the
United States and Italy of Hon. A. J.
Porter, United States Minister here,
have proved futile. Porter declares that
the rules of international comity pre
clude an expression of opinion by a
Minister placed in the position that
he (Porter) is now placed in. It is learn
ed, however, from reliable sources that
the United States Minister has done
much to pacify the Italian government
and that he has won over to his way of
thinking other Ministers, several of
whom have been trying to induce the
Italian Premier, Marquis di Rudini, to
be less hasty. The idea of war is scout
ed here in diplon~atic and government
circles. Even Baron Fava's final with
drawal is not pefinitely decided upon. It
is said that even if Baron Fava is with
drawn it will be done only as the most
forcible protest known in diplomacy ,and
not as a forerunner of a conflict between
the United States and Italy. The Ital
ian Cabinet Ministers are in receipt of a
large number of cablegrams and letters
from prominent Italianis in other cities
urging moderation upon the Italhon gov
ernmont in its treatment of the New Or
leans troubles.
School Examiners' Recom ndationl.
CoLUr1BIA. S. C., April 8.--The offi
cial report of the proceedings of the
meeting of the State board of examin
ers Saturday is given to the press this
evening, it was decided that all man
uscript histories of the State to be sub
mitted must be presented in type writ
ten copy, and that the manuscript will
be accompanied wvith some indication
of thesproposed arrangement of the
text, the style and cost of the book.
The board 'decided that the form of
county teachers' certiticates shall be
changed by the addition of imatter
showing the holder's experience as a
teacher, and attendance on the teach
ers' institute, proper credlit being
for them. The board decided to have
the State divided into suitable districts
for the holding of teachers' institutes
this summer. The detailed work for
arrangement was left to State Superin
tendenit Maytield. A resolution was
passed urging the county boatrds to re
district their counties in suitable
school distriots and press the levying
of a special school tax under the pro
vision of the school act of 1888 in all
proper cases. __
Revengeinat Ita~lians.
PARKEIISBURG, WV. a., April 3.
There is considerable commotion
among the railroad lines in this State,
and there are indications that the Ital
ians are avenging their countrymien by
the destruction of property. Iwo at
tempts to wreck a fact express on the
Baltimore and Ohio Railroad were de
t ected in time to prevent the ioss of
life. A few minutes before the New
York express passed a narro w cut near
Graf ton the track walker discovered
several heavy pieces of iron wedged
tightly between the rails. An hour
later the Chicago express barely escaped
a disastrous wreck near the same point
by a similiar obstruction. A large de
p~ot and store building on the Balti more
and Ohio at Constitution was blown up
with .dynamite, completely wrecking
the building and causing a heavy loss.
All the contents were destroyed. All
these crimes are charged t~o the ital
ians in the neighborh ood where they
happened.__
Italy's Next Move.
LoNDON, April 2.-A dispatch from
Rome says that the next move on the
part of thie Italian Government, should
satisfaction not be gilven for the New
Orleans tragedy, will be to place an em
bargo on American goods, and prohibit
their importation into italy.
Much indignation exists in Rome
aganst the Vatician party for the ut
terances of the Papal organ to the ef
fet that the government was influ
enced by secret societies. The clerics
are said to be doing everything possi
ble to weaken the prestige which the
government has gained with the peo
ple by its action. With the exception
of the clerics, the newspapers, without
regard to party, support the govern
ment in its course.
TILLMAN AND NOBLE.
THE AGRICULTURAL COLLEGE FUND
TIED UP STILL.
Further Correspondence Between Gov
ernor Tilman and the Department of
th'e Interior-Congresu Will Have to de
cide the Matter.
COLxMBIA, S. C., April 7.-The fol
lowing is the last letter from the Depart
ment of the Interior to Governor Till
man in regard to the equ-itable distribu
tion of the fund last year given by Con
gress to be divided between the white
and the colored agricultural colleges of
the State. As will be seen by it the De
partment of the Interior adheres to its
idea of what is an "equitable" distribu
tion. "Governor Tillman's reply was
mailed yesterday, and a copy of it will
also be found below. He, too, adheres
to his previously stated views, and so
the whole matter lies over for the con
sideration of Congress at its next ses
sion unless the Secretary of the Interior
should in the meantime conclude to ac
cept the basis of distribution provided
for by our Legislature at its last session:
DEPANITMENT OF THE INTERIOR,
WASHINGTON, March 21st, 1891.
Hon. B. R. Tillinan, Governor of South
Carolina.
Sir.: I have the honor to acknowledge
the receipt of your letter of the 16th
instant stating that your Legislature
having acted and adjourned until No
vember the question of the equitable
division of the funds appropriated for
agricultural colleges by the Act of Con
gress, approved August 31, 1890, is no
longer an open one so far as the State of
South Carolina is concerned, and en
quiring whether the Secretary "refuses
to pay South Carolina her quota upon
the basis proposed by the General As
sembly, and if so, whether he insists
that the school population, as shown by
the census of 1880 instead of 1890, shall
govern ?"
In answer to the first part of the in
quiry I have the honor to call your at
tention to the provisions of the statue.
It provided in the first section:
"That in any State in which there has
been one college established in pursu
ance of the Act of July 2, 1862, and also
in which an educational institution of
like character has been established or
may be hereafter established, and is now
aided by such State from its own reve
nue for the education of colored stu
dents in agriculture and the mechanic
arts, howeyer named or styled, or
whether or not it has received money
heretofore under the Act to which this
Act is an amendment, theLegislature of
such State may prepare and report to
the Secretary of the Interior a just and
equitable division of the fund to be re
ceived under this Act between one col
lege for white students and one institu
tiop for colored students established as
aforesaid, which shall be divided into
two parts and paid accordidgly."
Section 4 provides:
"That on or before the first day of July
in each year, after the passage of this
Act, the Secretary of the Interior shall
ascertain and testify to the Secretary of
the Treasury as to each State and Ter
ritory, whether it is entitled to receive
its share of the annual appropriation
for colleges, or of institutions for col
ored students under this Act, and the
amount which thereupon each is enti
tled respectively to receive. If the
Secretary of the Interior shall withhold
a certificate from any State or Territory
of its appropriation, the facts and rea
sons therefore shall be reported to the
President and the amount involved
shall be kept separate in the Treasury
until the close of the next Congress in
order that the State or Territory may,
if it should so desire, appeal to Congress
from the determination of the Secretary
of the Interior. If the next Congress
shall not direct such sum to be paid, it
shall be turned into the Treasuary, and
the Secretary of the interior is hereby
charged with the proper administration
of this law."
It seems evident that while the Leg'
lature may propose a division of te
fund between the two institutions, it Is
made the duty of the Secretary to pass
upon the equitableness of the proposed
division. In all but a very few instances
where a slight variance was admitted
the Secretary has insisted upon a divis
ion on the ratio of the school population,
and this seems to be the most equitable
and uniform basis that can be adopted
In this case he sees no reason to recede
from his convictions that equity de
mands a division into the ratio of the
school population.
In answer to the second part of the
inquiry, I have to state that when you
were written to on the subject, Jannary
31, 1891, the school census for State of
South Carolina for the year 1890 was
not available, and the census of 1880,
white 35.9 per cent., colored 64.1 per
cent., was suggested as an equitable
basis of division. The department is
now in possession of the school census
for 1890. (Whites 36.7 per cent., colored
63.3 per cent.,) and it is-considered that
the division should be based upon the
latter enumeration. Very respectfully,
GEo. CILANDLER,
Acting Secretary.
GOVEnNOR TIL31AN'S REPLY.
Ho'n. (ieo. Chanler, Acting SecretarU
In terior, W ash ingto n, D, C.
Smn: I have the honor to acknowledge
receipt of your letter of MIarch 21st, in
reply to my letter to ion. John W. No
ble,~dated February 16th. As I wrote
to Mlr. Noble. our General Assembly has
proosed an'equal division of the fund
donated by Congress last year "for the
further endowment and support of col
leges for the benefit of agriculture and
the mechanic arts," between Clemson
A gricultural College (white) and Clain
College (colored). W~hether such divis
ion is equitable or not as provided by
the statute and whether the Secretary
of the Interior has the right to refuse
South Carolina her quota because he
thinks it is not equitable is for you or
him to decide until Congress meets.
South Carolina has dealt liberally
with its colored college in the past and
I am sorry to see it crippled by a refusal
on your part to accept the apportion
ment proposed by the State. As Gov
ernor I have no authority to do more,
and if I had, I would refuse to accept
the money on such terms as you offer.
Very respectfully,
B. Rl. T'ILLMus, Governor.
"A Pure Matter of Health."
WVasJINGTo, April 8.-Senator Ed
munds, who sent his resignation to the
Governor of Vermont a few days ago,
when asked for a statement of the rea
sons for his resignation, said: "1 have
resigned from personal considerations
soley. It is a pure matter of health.
I cannot -live in Washington during
the winter. I ruffer from throat trouble
and the climate is too severe. I hold
that a senator should attend to his du
ties, and if I cannot remain in Wash
ington constantly, I prefer to resign.
shall spend the winters in Aiken, S.
C., visiting Washington occasionally
to attend the sessions of the Supreme
Court when I have busiess before it."
Mius. SARAr B. COOPER condensed
a great truth into a sentence when she
remarked to the Pacific Coast Women's
Press Association that the greatest
blessing a community can enjoy is a
od newspaper.
GIRLS SAVED THE TRAIN.
But they Planned the Wreck Themselves
-Bogus Heroines.
FREEHOLD, N. J., April 12.-Ano
ther chapter was added to the story of
Laura and Flora Woolley yesterday.
These girls are the twin sisters who
piled ties on a rail road track near Farm
Ingdale last week, and then flagged the
train. hoping to get a large reward.
Their ruse was discovered.
Laura has been greatly agitated ever
since the matter became public, and yes
terday she went to her bed-room and
prepared to end her life. She tied one
end of a stout rope to a hook in the wall.
- d with the other end she made a noose.
Then she mounted a chair, -placed the
noose around her neck, and prepared to
swing herself off into eternity. She
sprang from the chair, and was strang
ling when her sister Flora rushed in at
the door and rescued her. The girl is
apparently not much the worse for her
experiment, and her frieuds and rela
tives wi' try to persuade her that there
is no reason why she should not con
tinue to live.
The attempt to wreck the train oc
curred on Monday of last week. As the
4.30 p. m. express train from New York
to Lakewood, on the New Jersey South
ern rail road, neared a deep cut at Hen
drickson's switch, five miles from Lake
wood, a young girl ran down the track
frantically waving a red flag. Engineer
William Narison put on the brakes, and
the train stopped but a few feet from a
heap of ties that had been piled across
the track.
"I saw two men put them there and
run into the woods," the girl said, appa
rently in great excitement, "and ran
down to stop you."
Grateful passengers took up a c ollec
tion that was reported at the time to
amount to $105, and the maiden iound
herself a heroine.
Gecrge Fitzgeiald, the station boss,
could not quite see how such a scheme
could be planned in that vicinity.
Tramps vrere not numerous, and the few
families living in the vicinity were well
known and above suspicion. A little.
investigation convinced him that the ties
were not placed there to wreck the train.
These suspicions were confirmed by a
fellow employee, Levi Buidge, a cousin
of the "heroine of a day," who obtained
from her a confession that she and her
sister had planned and carried out the
scheme to enrich a slender purse, and
incidentally to win a little fleeting re
nown. The girl whQ had waved the
flag was one of the twin sisters, Flora
and Laura, daughters of George Wool
ley.
The Misses Woolley were in a sad pre
dicarent at the discovery of their plot.
Thei had heard their father read in the
newspapers, they said, of a girl who had
saved a tram for glory, and the idea
suggested itself to them that the same
thing could be done for money. They
had carried the ties to the track and
sent their younger brother, "Bud," to
the house for a signal flag. The story
about the men making for the woods
was persisted in until Mr. Burdge wrung
a confession trem them.
A11iances in Every State.
WASHINGTON, April 8.-Represen
tative Jerry Simpson left the city yester
day for Olean, N. Y., to spend the next
ten days in the work of proselyting the
farmers -of Western New York. The
national lecturer of the Alliance, Mr.
Willitts, also left yesterday afternoon
for New Jersey, where he hopes to
awaken considerable interest in the Al
liance cause. He has already made a
journey out to Ohio and sown the seed
from which he hopes a large crop of Al
liances will grow. This activity on the
part of the Alliance leaders, according
toSenator Peffer's statement toa Uniired
Press reporter, is due to the fact that a
movemnent is on foot to carry the Alli
ance ideas into every State of the Union
before the next campaign. Senator Pef
fer also spoke hopefully of the confer
ence to be held in Cincinnati on the 19th
of May, and said that it was the forerun
ner of the organization of a new party.
The effect of the recent visit of Repre
sentative Simpson to New England is
viewed with some alarm by t'he mem
bers of both the Republican and Demo
cratic parties in New Hampshire.
Both parties there have discovered how
equally divided the vote is, and it would
not take many converts to the Alliance
ideas to give the third party the balance
of power. ________
P. T. Barnum Dies.
BRIDGEPORT, Conn., April 7.-The
great showman, P. T. Barnum, passed
away at 6:22 o'clock this evening in the
resence of his grief stricken family.
During the period of Barnum's invali
dism and confinement to the house
which began twenty-one weeks ago last
Friday, there have been frequent fluc
tuations in his condition from each of
which he rallied. although in each in
stance with a slightiy lowered vitality.
The change for the worse, which oc
curred last ~night was so much more pro
nouncedi than the previous attacks had
been that it convinced the physicians that
their patient had not many more hours
to 1 ye. At 3:30 o'clock this afternoon
Barnum sank io a comatose condition,
from which it was evident that there
would be little hope of his again return
ing to consciousness. When the end
iia lly came, it was peaceful and to all
appearances, painless. The physicians
say that Barnum had no orame disease
whatever, enfeebled heart action, which
had been apparent for the past few
months being due to the gradual failure
of his general mental powers, resulting
from old age. He was about 80.
Counterfeit Currency.
WASIIINGTON, April 8.-Assistant
United States Treasurer Whelpley
stated this morning that there was no
doubt that a counterfeit of the $2 sil
ver certificate was in circulation. As
fast as the $2 silver certificates was
receifed at the Treasury Department
they were destroyed, but no order had
yet been issued calling them in. The
printing of $2 silver certificates from
the old plate had been suspended. The
new design will bear the portrait of
Secretary Windom, instead of that of
Gen. Hancock. It is said that the ne w
Issue of $2 silver certificates will not
be printed until Secretary Foster de
cides upon a distinctive paper upon
which to print all treasury notes, bonds
and securities.
Ready to shoot Italians.
DODGE CITY, Kansas, April 2.-The
following message was sent to N~ew
Orleans to-night: To the Mayor and
citizens of New Orleans: The people
of Dodge City, Kansas, in mass conven
tion assembled, resolved, that: this
meeting express the sentiment of this
city and county, and say to the people
of the Crescent City, that 1,000 able
bodied men, spoken for by this resolu
tion, are ready to go to Louisiana and
shoot, and they' will shoot, if ealled
upon by our G.overnmenlt and Italy's
hostile attitude demands it.
B. W. Kvm' Mayor.
UNDER BONDS.
THE SHERIFF PUTS A STOP TO AN AN
TICIPATED ENCOUNTER.
Colonel Talbert Arrested and Put Under
Peace Bonds--Mr. N. G. Gonzales Tem
porarily Bound Over-His Case to be
Heard this Afternoon.
COLUMIA, S. C., April 10.-For the
past day or two there has been some ap
prehension of a personal difficulty oc
curring between Colonel W. J. Talbert
Superintendent of the South Carolina
Penitentiary, and Mr. N. G. Gonzales,
editor of the State, on account of re
cent publications reflecting severely on
each other, and on yesterday from in
formation given to him, Sheriff Rowan
was led to believe that there was some
grounds for these apprehensions, and
accordingly he took cut warrants for
the arrest of both of these parties in
order to have Ithem put under peace
bonds. The warrants -were issued by
Trial Justice Muller and placed in the
hands of Constable Pollock. Colonel.
Talbert was found about two o'clock
and at once proceeded to the Trial Jus
tice's cffice, where he gave the required
bond for $500, with Mr. W. T. Martin
as surety. He stated to the Trial Jus
tice that he did not object to giving
the bond if it was required of him, but
that at the same time he wanted it un
derstood that he % as thirsting for no
man's blood, and further, that as a law
abiding citizen, he considered himself
to be always bound to keep the peace,
although always ready to protect him
self when necessary. He said also that
he did not want any one put under
peace bond for his protection. le
asked the Trial Justice if any one had
requested that he should be put under
bond, to which the Sheriff replied that
he had taken out the warrants on his
own responsibility.
The warrant against Mr. Gonzales
was served later in the afternoon, and
he appeared at the Trial Justice's office
about 5 o'clock in the afternoon.
Mr. Gonzales was accompanied by
Mr. F. H. Weston as his attorney, and
demanded a trial on the ground that he
had made no threats against any one,
and could therefore see no reason why
he should be required to give a peace
bond.
Sheriff Rowan made a statement to
the effect that he had made inquiries
of parties ,who he thought were in a
position to know as to whether there
was any likelihood of a difficulty occur
ring between Messrs. Talbert and Gon
zales. and that he had been informed
by them that there was. Mr. E. J.
Watson of the State being one of those
who, so informed him in response to his
inquiries. The Sheriff further stated
that Col. Geo. K. Wright had notified
him in the morning that a difficulty
was pending, and that thereupon he
considered it his duty as a peace officer,
to take the course he had taken.
Mr. Gonzales said that the course of
the Sheriff was unwarranted by the
facts and that if he was put under bond
Mr. Calvo of The Register ought also
to be put under bond as he had pub
lished in his paper an article writtan
by Colonel Talbert that might have
provoked bloodshed.
THE SHERIFF's sWORN STATEMENT.
After making an unsworn statement
as above, counsel for Mr. Gonzales re
quired the Sheriff's testimony to be re
duced to writing, it being as follows:
S. W. Rowan, being duly sworn. says:
"My attention was called to the proba
bility of a difficulty between Mr. N. G.
Gonzales and Mr. W. J. Talbert. I was
informed that policemen were sta
tioned near The State office and that
the citizens along the street were an
ticipating a difficulty. I made inquiry
last night to get something definite, but
the parties gave me evasive answers.
I have not seen Mr. Gonzales for three
or four days. When I read the paper
(The State of the 9th) I read an article
that made me suspicious of trouble. I
went on the street this morning and
a gentleman informed me that trouble
Tas expected s between Mr. Gonzales
and Mr. Talbert, and that he thought
that they ought to be placed under
bond. I requested my informant to
make his affidavit and told him if I
made it I could not make the arrest.
He declined, giving no reason, and I
then came round and made the affidavit.
I had been told if these two parties met
on the street there would be trouble.
Mr. Geo. K. Wright came to me and
stated that Mr. Condit was alarmed
and so told him."
Cross-examined-"I saw the police
men standing near the State office; I
have frequently seen them standing on
the corner of the Opera House and
at the Opera House steps. There
is one store between the Opera
House and the State office. I did not
approach either Mr. Gonzales or Mr.
Talbert, I was suspicious of trouble last
night, and from the time of the appear
ance of the first article in The Regis
ter, knowing Mr. Gonzales not to be a
man who take insults. I think, but do
not state positively, that both Mr. Wat
son and Mr. Reynolds told me that if
Mr. Gonzales and Mr. Talbert met there
would be trouble. Mr. Watson and
Mr. Reynolds both are employed in the
State oili ce; Mr. Watson as local editor
and Mr. Reynolds as business mana
ger.
"Signed) S. W. RowAN."
Mr. Gonzales was then required to
give bond until 4 o'clock this afternoon,
at which time the examination will be
continued.
Colonel Talbert stated at the time that
he was in the Trial Justice's office that
he regarded the whole trouble as hav
ing been purposely brought about by a
"Radical sheet," as previous to its at
tacks upon him there was no cause for
any trouble.
The Evening Record, commenting
upon the arrest, says:
"Since the publication of Mr. W. J.
Talbert's letter in The Register yester
day morning in which the following
reference to the editor of the State ap
peared: 'I denounce his insinuations
against my good name as contemptible
lies and slanders,' the public generally
have felt that bloodshed was imminent.
All day yesterday every one was on the
qu vive of expectancy-"
This statement, taken in connection
with the sworn stateznient of the Sheriff,
goes to show that there was some pub
lic apprehension of an impending difi
culty.-Register.
Holocaust in Pennsylvania.
PIT TsBUROi. Pa., April .-A special
from Rochester, Pa., says: "in a fire
last night a large frame structure on
N~ew TYork street, belonging to John F.
Smith, in which was located the tea
and coffee store of Geo. Edwards, the
millinery store of Mrs. Hall, the shoe
shops and residence of E. .J. Keene was
destroyed. A number of Italians lived
over the millinery store and all were
burned to death. There have been nine
bodies found.
A sensation in Abbeville.
CHARLESTON, April 7.-It was diS~
covered Saturday that the grave oi
Judge Wardlaw, who was buried neai
Abbeville eighteen years ago, had beer
opened and the coffin broken. Ti
body was undisturbed. His wife's
grave had also been opened. The Ino
tie is not known.
EDMUNDS EXPLAINS.
The Farmers' Alliance Makes the Situa
tion Inreresting.
WASHINGTox, April 12.-The Star re
cently published a two column interview
with Senator Edmunds upon the present
political situation and outlook. As be
tween the two great parties the Senator
does not see any great difference be
tween the situation now and what it has
been for several years, but as to the
Farmers' Alliance the situation is one of
extraordinary interest and importance
because of its possible effect upon the
next national election. The reporter
asked: "What dangers to both parties
and to the country are there in the
situation ?"
"I do not-think there is any danger
to the Democratic party," the Senator
replied with a faint smile. "For in this
respect all is fish that comes to its net,
or indeed goes into the net of the
Farmers' Alliance, for the next Presi
dental election if the Farmers' Alliance
should carry many States without hav
ing a majority of the whole electoral
college the simple result would be
that there would be no election by the
people, as it is called, and the present
House ot Representatives, having a
verylarge Denocratic majority of States
as well as members, would elect a Dem
ocratic candidete in a Constitutional
and regular way, although he may have
carried the smallest number of States.
As to the danger of the Republican
party, it is that the Farmers' Alliance
may carry in the next Presidential elec
tion some States that would otherwise
vote for a Republican candidate, and
thus in effect, if there should be no elec
tion by the people, give the election to
the Democratic candidate by the House
of Representatives."
"What do you think will be the issue
of the Presidential campaign parties ?"
"The Republicans will doubtless stand
by the same ground for justice and
equality of rights among the citizens of
the United States and fair elections and
for the protection of American labor and
industries that it has maintained hith
erto."
"Do you think silver will be an issue
in the next election?'
"I don't think it will be an issue be
tween the Republicans and Democrats,
for I think that the Democratic party
will hardly wish to make the silver ques
tion an issue to the extent of running
any considerable risk of separating silver
and gold as coiu money for the country,
and certainly the great body of the
Republican party I am sure will not up
to the point of safety. I have no doubt
but that the Republicans will be in favor
of using silver as money as it always has
done. What the Farmers' Alliance plat
form, if it should nominate a cahdidate
for President, will be I am quite unable
to say."
"H1ow is the feeling of the union
among certain classes to be met?"
"I think it is to be met as every other
disturbance in society ought to be, by a
candid consideration, by correct infor
mation, just reasoning and the enact
ment of such laws as may fairly appear
to be for the promotion of the general
public good. It is upon such considera
tions that every government of the
people must be carried on."
"is the third party movement likely,
and if so, what might it lead to? Is
communism at the bottom of it?"
"A third party movement," replied
the Senator, "does not exist inthe Farm
ers' Alliance enterprise. If succeessful
to the extent of having a President and
both houses of Congress, it would doubt
less lead to the enactment of the mea
sures they have already indicated, and
then in a very short time whether those
measures were good for the farmers or
extremely bad for them would mani
festly appear. I do not think that
communism is at the bottom of the
Farmers' Alliance movement. The per
centage of communism in this country
is, I believe, almost infinitesimally
small. The great body of the labor
ing people of the country, which taking
all the departments of human activity,
embraces probably Dinety-five one hun
dredths of the whole number of grown
up people who are altogether too intelli
gent and honest to think that commun
ism will be of any benefit tothem or their
families, but they believe that it is des
tructive of private rights, of personal
prosperity and personal happiness, and
if carried into practice would effect the
maintenance of the vicious and lazy
and ignorant out of the toil of intelli
gent and industrious people."
"How might the finances of the coun
try be affected by this movement?"
"The finances of the country always
depend very largely upon the confidence
that people engaged in business and
people having capital have in the ad
minstration of its government. If any
of the movements of which we have
been speaking should appear so formi
dable as to make unsound legislation at
all probable, tue finances of the country
would be very greatly disturbed, and
that, of course, would disturb every
branch of labor and business. This
every body perfectly understands."
Fifty Liyes Lost.
ST. Lorrs, April 6.-Mr. John T
Farish, a well known mining expert'
who has returned to this city from Col'
orado, s'iys that never in all his exper
ience in the mountains has he witnessed
anything like the snow storms of the
past six weeks. For eighteen days he
says he was snow bot nd in the Red
mountains, near Rico, Col., and during
that period was literally cut off from
the world. The snow storm, which
raged for weeks, started in about the
15th of February, an'1 since that time
the trails to the mines have been cover
ed up and fully fifty lives lost by the
disastrous sra'w slides that were of al
most daily occurrence, making it dan
gerous for a man or beast to venture
away from shelter. IHe reports that the
reat producing mines were completely
shut off, and that thousands of tons of
ore are awaiting the reopening of the
trails.
The Death of Gor. Fowle
RALEIGH, H. C., April 8.-Governor
Daniel G. Fowle, who died suddenly
last night, had been slightly indisposed
for two days, but was not supposed to
be seriously ill. Shortly after 11 o'clock
he called to his daughter Mary and said
that he was not feeling well, and ex
pected she wonld have to sit up with
him. His daughter, Miss Helen, then
went into his room, and in a few min
utes he said, "I am fainting." She has
tened to his side, but he almost instant
ly expired. His death was probably
from apoplexy. He was sixty years of
age. The capital, public buildings and
the executive mansion will be draped
in mourning. Raleigh is a city of sad
ness. Lieutenant Governor Holt has
been telegraphed for and will be here
to-day. ________
Italians Flocking to America.
NEW YoRK, April 2--Superinten
dent of Immigration WXeber says immi
gration from italy is rapidly increasing
-in fact,1leading that of all other coun
tries. The figures of March are: Italy,
7,869; Germany, 7,087; Great Britian and
Ireland, 4.386; Hungary, 3,589; Austria,
3.84; Russia, .,925; total 29,338. Sixteen
hundred and seven Itanians were landed
at+te+are ofice to-day.
ITALIAN GASCONADE.
A LULL IN THE EXCITENENT AT THE
FEDERAL CAPITAL.
The Views of Senator Butler on the Course
of the Italian Government in Recalling
their Minister from the United States
No War Probable.
WASHINGToN, April 2.-All quiet on
the Potomac" sums up the situation at
the National Capital to-night. Sena
tors Butler, Ransom, Vance, Represen
tative Boatman and all the Southern
Congressmen now in Washington con
demn Italy's course. Senator Butler,
when asked if he regarded Italy's ac
tion in recalling Baron Fava as justifi
able under the circumstances, replied:
"I do not. Mr. Blaine and Governor
Nicholls have done all that their official
positions permitted them to do, all that
could reasonably be expected of them
and this action of the Italian Govern
ment has very much the appearance of
Italian gasconade. Of course every
law-abiding citizen deprecates the un
fortunate occurrence in New Orleans,
but the people of Louisiana are the
best judges of their own environments,
and can be trusted to deal properly with
them. Neither Mr. Blaine nor Govern
or Nicholls is a grand juryman or pros
ecutor, and they have properly left the'
affair in the hands of the law, where it
belongs."
"Do you think the Mafia will be again
heard from?"
"That I cannot tell. It appears to
be an Italian institution transplanted
to this country, but it does not flourish
here and will not be permitted to
spread. Whatever means are necessa
ry to eradicate it will be adopted
wherever it - shows iti head, and the
Italian Government may as well un
derstand, first as last, that if Italian
subjects come over and identify them
selves with the Mafia they must take
the consequences. How long do you
suppose an American White Cap, Ku
klux Klan or Mclly Maguire o
tion would be permitted to ply their
avocation in an Italian city on Italian
subjects? Just about as long as it
takes to get them to the nearest lam
post or nearest limb. One thing
think may be safely assured, that the
course of the Italian Goqernment is
not calculated to encourage the amia
ble side of the American character or
excite sympathy for Italian subjects
who use stilettos on the law oficers of
this country in revenge for enforcing
the law."
"Will the present complications lead
to war in your opinion?"
"I do not know. I trust not. There
is nothing in the conduct of our Gov
ernment to go to war about, but if
Italy is spoiling for a fight I expect she
can be accommodated. Nobody here
wants war, and nobody wants to be
dictated to or bullied by a foreign Gov
ernment. If the subjects of foreign
Governments are harshly treated by
our people the Governments ought to
do us the justice to give an opportuni
ty to make amends. That proper
amends would be made in due- time'
there can be no doubt, but when an ef
fort is made to drive us to a reckoning
with indecent haste we ought at least
to assert a becoming determination not
to be driven."
Senator Butler's utterances have the
proper ring, and he bat voices the sen
timents of his people in the Old Pal
mettt State as expressed in the News
and Courier.
There are no ncw developments in
the Italian flury. The next feature of
the controversy will be the reply from
Marquis Impeniali to the' Secretary's'
letter of last .night, which has not yet
arrived. On it will depend much of
the prospect. He may Indicate his In
ability to speak for his Government,
having been left only in chreof "cur
sent affairs' "In which event r.Blaine
will take itfor granted that diplomat
ic representation In this country from
Italy is at an end, and will probal
communicate with Marquis Di Rdn
through Minister Porter at Rome. The
note from Marquis Imperiali may be
delayed long enoug for a cable mes
sage to reach Rudin from here and for
a reply containing Instructions to
back. This mtay happen witi a
couple of hours or it may take two
days according to the temper of the
Italian Government.-News5 and Cour
ie . W recked on a Eeef.
NEW Yoi, Arl2.-The steamship
Aguan, of the duras Central Amen
can Canal Company left here two weeks
ao with Warner Miller,President of the
icaraugua Canal Company andpat
who were going tjset the works
On the morningoMac tl the
Aguan was wrecked onPaacore
reef 200 miles Northwest of Greytown.
No lives were lost so far as known. la
soon as the steamer struck the reef a
life boat was sent ashore. It reached
Gretwn on the 30th of MacAandoi
the day following the steamer Brazo 0?
the Moregan lfleft Greytown togoto
the rescue of the assengers and crew of
the Aguan. Te Braoisepcd
back at Gryown today. TeChief
Engineer of the Aguantegrpd
these facts to his company's ofieto
day. ________
The Plot MtscaZried.
WHEELING, W. Va., April 8.-Miss
Amy Morgan, daughter of a Wheeling
banker, was seized at her father's gate
by two masked men on Sunday night,
who thrust her into a carriage and
drove all night. At daylight thegil
who was blindfolded, heard one o h
men pounding at the door of a house.
He came back and said: "We are here.
The game is up." The two had a con
sultat'n as to whether to kill the girl
or let her go, and finally decided upon
the latter course. The girl ran and
walkedi ten miles, and then struck a
railroad at Kilsey, 25 miles from home.
She got back home at noon yesterday,
exhausted.
Jaggled Republican Victory.
PROVIDENCE, IL.IL, April 3.-The elec
tion returns available at 1 o'clock this
afternoon make it certain thatthere has
been no choice by the pepefor any
oficer upon the genea tce.The
republicans have carried a sufficient
number of towns to giethem the fifty
five votes necessary fra majort on
joint ballot. The total number ofvoe
for governor stands: Bur ,nationalist,
384: Davis, democrat, 22,24; Ladd, re
publican, 21,895; Larry, prohibitioniAt
1,829. The next general assembly stands;
Senate, repulicans; 21; democrats 9;.to
be chosen 6. House of representative,
republicans 34; democrats 23; to be
chosen 19.
severe Earthquake.
UETBEC, April 2.--Last ennga
ioln eatqaehere was fl l
along the North shore of St. Lawrence
and extended far into the back country
parishes. News fromiSt. Gabriel County,
at Quebec, and other stations confirm
the fact of a violent shock. Residents of
Bonaparte state that the earth and
dwellings there shook in that prs o
several seconds and caused teinhabit
nsurreat alarm.