The herald and news. (Newberry S.C.) 1903-1937, January 14, 1921, Image 1
VOLUME LVII., NUMBER 4. NEWBERRY, S. C., PXIDAY, JANUARY 14, 1821. TWICE A WEEK, $2.00 A YEAR
1 ' "" '
EYES OF PEOPLE
ON LEGISLATURE
SPEAKER COTHRAN TELLS Ol
NEEDED LAWS.
' '
Hold* Constitution Forbids. Makin;
Permanent improvement* by
i General Appropriations.
The State, 1 gth..
Calling: the attention of tjie mem
r - bers of the house of-representative
to the cry that is coming insistently
from the people for a reduction in o:
mow equitable distribution of taxes
Thomas P. Oothran, newly reelecte<
speaker of the house, yesterday ir
addressing: the members of the body
: . said that the people of the state hav<
their eye* on the members of fth?
house and that they will scrutinize
their actions closely. The people are
looking: to the hoQse for relief, h?
' t <-? _ i i.1 _ I l? - ?
saia, ana ne urgea x,nax tne question
fv ' of taxes be given the moat careful
consideration.
In the ,course of his remarks h
discussed the advisability of fixing 3
t maximum to the amount of money to
toe appropriated holding that such a
restriction would tend to insure a
xestfulness among the people, and
would prevent extravagant approTtrifl.ti?ns.
He als<5 condemned the
practice -which has grown up of ap,
propriating funds for permanent improvements,
holding thai the constitution
provides that the general aseembly
shall appropriate money only
for ordinary and current expenses of
the state, and he held that perma...
-v-JCr."Vx . u Jj. . 1
Bent improvements coin a not ue
classed as "ordinary" and "current"
. expenses../He also referred, in passing,
to source^ q| jpgyenne for
the state: speech was listc led
to with closest attention and was accorded
generous applause, at its conf^loss^iy^fe
a copy cifciiit speech:
r YV*
? ' * S" rnmmmmm,
I appreciate very deeply the high
honor which you haVfe. conferred upon
inland I trust that my earnest
v efforts to discharge, the -duties of
that position, which I sincerely
pledge to .you, will be supported py
the same kindly consideration.
^ K
"Be to my faults a little blind
And to ,<by virtues very kind."
I have never known the light to
beat #iore fiercely upon you than it
i - does at this particular time. The
eyes of tie whole .state are upon
you.
It is true, even though unfortunt
ate, that in discordant times, in the
discontent and cttfcffession of circumstances,
due w causes which you
can not control, the people turn to
ifche lawmaking power for relief, at
least for exemption from increased
burdens.
Theje is little of . relief that we
/*? n trive litiip we can do to restore
&* "? -- --tiie
era of prosperity inv which we
basked only a fe* inonths ago, and
whose blessings we Huilg away as a
spendthrift would; there is much that
we can do in preserving the state
from greater Jbu^dens.
Many New Men.
" The great majority of this house
are new men, wiiose conception of
the difficulties that lie ahead of them
_ is necessarily immature and which
* ?:n -' "t" o+ronofolv
the retrospect Wlti 2>U\J W
* - inadequate.
The roost serious problem that -will
arise will be to decide jbetween the
logically unanswerable demands of
the state's educational and charitable
activities and the ability of the
people to respond to those calls. No
one wants to cripple them; every
one recognizes the reasonableness of
their requests; we are drawn by the
conflicting emotions of responding
to them and the expediency under
present conditions of doing so.
We can run the state upon less
money if*we are satisfied with the
/ condition which will result thereby.
If we adopt the ni jgardly policy
of appropriating just as little as
these- institutions can subsist upon,
we very, very naturally reduce the
present appropriations, but there will
i e no progress, and if no progress
there will foe decadence.
If we adopt the more liberal policy
of advancement, of improvements, of
progress, we can not hope to accomplish
a sensible reduction.
If we adopt a policy of preserving
! the status quo, of marking time for!
a period, we still can not hope to a- '
' ccxmplish much in the way of reduction.
These three causes are open tp
you; personally I do not .believe that
we will or should take a backward
steD. I
i A"
Contrary to Constitution,
In my opinion the state has continued
for years a policy that is condemned
by the constitution and has
provoked much of the evil of an excessive
appropriation bill, and that
! is,^ to pay for permanent improveriment
sout of the current taxes. Year
j after year vast sums of money have
|: been appropriated for new buildings
t at the hospital, Winthrop college,
the university, the Citadel, the insfci[
tution3 for the blind, the feeble
> minded institutions, De la Howe &i.d
' 1 ^ V - i-_i.
, j otners. inuring tne iast uvc ^cais
\ j the appropriations for permanent ira,
j provements, paid out of current tax11
es, approximate $2,000,000.
t The constitution - provides, in ,my
opinion, the general assembly to ap(
propriate money only for the ordi\
nary current expenses of the state. I
! have more than once called; a.ttenj
tion to this and at the last session
' | prepared a resolution providing for
the submission of a proposition to
issue'$3,000,000 of bonds to provide
-v * x_ ? .Ko
for seen improvement:*, eta u115.ui/ wv 1
necessary, for a period of ten years;
it was defeated by a large majority
in this house. I still think that this
should be done. t,
\ Hears Many Complaints.
It' is) unfortunate, perhaps unmerited,
but I state what I believe to be
a fact, that the jpeopJe are distruSt!
ing these representatives in the matter
of appropriations. I have never
j heard as great complaints in my life,
from the people upon this subject as
are now coming up from all parts of j
the state, and while I speak, .a meet-j
ing of taxpayers is being held in this p
? J-~ fnrf.Vipr in- i
j City UJ 'piUlCJt
I crease.
j It seerhs like a dream to recall the j
j fact that in 1908 I introduced 4. reso- '
lution providing for a constitutional
limit of the amount of appropriations '
to $1,250,000, which sum at- that
j time had not been exceeded. It died
| in the committee. In 1920 the ap-1
I propriations amounted .to over $6,000,000;
and requests are now in for
over $9,000,000.
It is not too late now to put a
check upon this outlay, and if the
; limit should he placed at '$5,000,000
| for the next ten years, we could live
within it and restore a feeling of
confidence and restfulness.
" At to Taxation.
I believe too that such a cause
would secure a fairer and more equitable
return and assessment of prop!
erty for taxation. The real under1
% H .1
flying reason why men do not return
their property at full value is the
fear that with a full assessment, the
" l ????? rronPrill i
j psycnoiogicai cuetv u^ua ? .
j assembly would .be to increase appropriations
and it seems reasonable .
i that if these appropriations continue
j.to pile up as they have done upon
a scant assessment the result would
| be appalling upon a full one, unless
j there were a constitutional . limit.
I Any plan that will secure equality in j
I^the burden of taxation will be wel-l
corned, and the natural and logical
{.basis of -this equality is the actual
J valuation of the objects of taxation;
| that therefore which tends to secure
j this valuation necessarily leads to
equality. ' N
-I believe further that the matter
j of valuation of property for assess- '
ment is essentially a local one, wnere
it can be accomplished by those who 1
are not only familiar with the propj
erty but directly intrusted in its
j bearing a just proportion of the buri
den. Should I be assessed at $100
j far property worth $1,000, and my
i neighbor at $500 for similar proper|
ty, the deficiency in my taxes would
! be made up by the entire state, notj
i'by my neighbor; hence his interest in <
forcing me to come up to his stand-1
ard would be so remote as to be ig-j
nored by him. But if the township,!
school district or ward in which we J
both live was required to raise a certain
amount of money as its fair proportion
of the state appropriations,
; my neighbor's interest in my delinquency
would be immediate and sub
j stantial to the extent 01 enlisting ms j
| active vigilance in bringing me up
. to his standard.
| I believe therefore that the entire
j amount appropriated for state"ex
I REIGN OF TERROR IN FLAME
i
r v V ' ' - * ':
L, -S.; 'xoJK-:' >r> x ' ' x- <" ' ' % ' J-':
fg- ?> . .
& "vSv'Jv1 >><> ' : ' v
& r >'l>; ' : :<<.
<;* ' *& : *;\. ;:>< >; J-sSXi' fP'-y \? !}"'
'?4-' SS'V: : : * / "' ' '
A view of St. Patrick's street, t'he
swept the business section of Cork it
flames. The flames are said to have
ries loaded with special constables an
of the ibuildings. I
penses should be apportioned to 1
each county, requiring it to raise a j
certain amount of money as its just?
share of the iburden; then of each j 1
county's proportion let each town-!
ship be required to raise a fixed J t
amount. Localize the assessment?^
and localize the interest of each tax j r
payer in what oiher tax payers in his;
district pay. % f 11
For Survey of State. ' - p
In 1917 with the assistance of Co!, j1
Johnson of Marion, I prepared a bill is
Crs.tn n vwrott a P C"f 0"f n 6
liXOViUJiiJJ JLV1 <* S>ui\\zy Ui 1.11= |
It does seem to me simply an act off*
business judgment to ascertain the! *
assets of any business in which you;1
may be intrusted. .The greatest as-:c
set of the state from an income pro- j
ducing standpoint is ths power of j ?
taxation. It has some property,!c
most of which is a liability rather! *
1 i
than an asset. Its income must come j*
fi'om taxes, and the amount of these j t
i * : i.i. j- ?i 4.1,^ I t
taxes is governea oy xae vaiuu uj. mc; property
to be taxed. Hence an in- j t
ventory of this property, .the source j i
of its income, appears to me simply a : 1
v/ork of plain .'business judgment, j
not only for the purpose of knowing i t
what we now have but of assuring us j ^
that it will continue to be placed on *
the books as an asset, annually to be '?
drawn upon. I had at the time the 1
assurance of competent engineers j ?
that they would do the work for anyj t
county, platting county, township,, ?
school district and private property j <
lines at six cents per acre ana that, i
they would take their pay only out;
of the taxes which by their efforts! ?
were placed on the tax books; not a, {
cent of cost to the state, not a cent j i
of cost.to the county, net a cent to j i
the property owner. In the language! <
of a former representative from J j
Greenville county the bill "went: S
down under the bloody tomahawk of ?
legislative warfare.*' The trouble1 e
with all tax reforms is that we i j
flinch, and propose to abolish the j (
wrlrnlo evefum iiist. stp. ?nr.ri as it ]>e-, T
g-ins to accomplish something. 11
, i
VITAL STATISTICS FOR
THE CITY FOR 19201
Births. * j ?
White melase 70
White females .. 53 j j
Total whites ?123 i
Bfeck males 39
Black females 27 . j
Total .black ? G-G j
Total births 189 ( ^
Deaths.
i c
White males 18
White females 17
m . j. l 1. ' jjx i
Total wnixes ? o<j
Black mslss 25
Black females 24
Total blacks ? 49 j
Total deaths * 84 J ?
S. S. Cunningham, j a
Local Registrar, jt
SWEPT CORK AS MACHINE
I.J'n Jj*?Wwi-A'Jull- I
' f' '
!',; ',- v $v?
principal thoroughfare of Cork,
is estimated that $15,000,000 c
been set tfcy the -British forces i
d auxiliaries. It is believed thai
::
*7 i- ^: i.
:XTRA SESSION ' iJ;
LATEVIN MAP
Phe State. ..
Washington, Jain. 11.?Infoi
ion from 3Iaricn'indicates that i
riess wiil be called into extrac
:av.y session March 2S.
__Th'e principal business with w
he new oner 3 "3 will concern ii
vill be the preparation and en
nent of a-tariff bill. Such work <
mmes six months, as an average,
i result, it will be October when
>511 is law, ar.d congress given an
jortu.iity to adjourn pending
egular session, the following
:emfcer.
The business of the present
rress consists solely in the enactn
)f pay bills which are necessary
;he transaction of the governni
jusiness. There will (be no e.nerg*
arii? legislation, as hitherto state
his correspondence. Since Peni
he Republican "boss" of Peni
rania, fooled the country by sta
lis intention to support the
vhich previously he had anathe
;ized, there has been feeble h
But Penrose was joking. He sai
effect that he would support
)ill, but would amend it?and
le hoped the house would ac;
1 1? XTri l-n r.irt +.Vif
>UCfl 3.meiiu'juciibd. ub
he bill is amended following
;ime -consumed in its consideratio
committee and on the floor, it
lot be enacted prior to March 4.
The tariff bill of the extraordi:
session may bring on a clash 'betv
.he new president and some of
nembers of the senate?that is
ess President-elect Harding a!
Ions his present intention of st;
ng only for a "reasonable"
Senator Penrose, Senator Sm
Senator Watson and others w<
srect a tariff wall a.bout the coin
n that domestic manufacturing
lustrles might flourish without c
jetition. The excuse they offer
hat the tiiii es are unusual, abnoi
md so direful that they require
isual treatment.
A few Republican senators ?
.-aution against such abuse of j:
:r. They fear that Penrose w<
-.tt o for the election <
t*jr W x-r.ww
>emGcr?jt.;c president four y
lence. Such a possibility is
:cnsidered bv Mr. Harding.
" ?
Chapter Meeting.
The Dickert-Sehumpert chap
daughters of the Confederacy,
r.cet on Saturday, January 15, s
('clock with Mrs. Harry II. Blea
Boyd Wheeler,
Presiden
Abbie Gaillard,
kJ t'li V C-C* i. J .
Lots of money was spent for
^orks and there was a big trave]
ill the roads, still ,-folks say "Y
imes."?Tugaloo Tribune.
GUNS IN STREETS SPIT DEATH.
!if i
As the result of 'a great fire which
lanwges has followed in the wake of the
n reprisal for the ambushing of two lor;
many bodies are in the charred rains
v '
|CENSUS RECORDS
JCH.J ? LU5i IJN VL.A!?U
| Washington, Jan. 10.?Priceless
:ma-? census records, dating back to 17S0,
con-j when the first enumeration of the
>rdi-1 Uni-ted States was takeri. were destroyed
tonight in a fire of unknown
hlchj origin at the. department ,o?^ comis&Jf
j merce. The records also include figaot
j ures from every census up to the
con-j present one, and officials said that it
. As: would .be. days before even an esiithe'
mate of the'damage could be given,
op- i The blaze originated in the basethe:
ment of the commerce building and
Be-; five alarms quickly* brought every
i piece cf apparatus in downtown
con-' Washington to the scene and more
lent; than 20 lines of hose completed ths
fori damage done to the records by pour>nt's:ing
tons of water through windows
jncy: into vauits where the records were
J 4 ! 1" r?r\4
a in .
"ose, j During ,the two and a half hours
isyi-; which firemen fought the blaze three
; firemen were overcome by smoke and
'bill j taken to the hospital. Among them
:ma-iwas Frank Newman, recipient of the
ope.! 1920 bravery, medal.
^ *nj T. J. Fitzgerald, chief yclerk of the
i census bureau, said that the actual
| fire loss was very slight, ibut "the
i records destroyed could not be reu.,fi
placed if we had the entire wealth od
t"e' the United States at our disposal
n *n-j There are no duplicates."
j Officials said that it v/as jjfobably
! the most disastrous loss Of records
iary! the government -had ever sustained.
raen |
the J ' *
un_ News of Excelsior.
ban- Excelsior, Jan. 13.?Mr. and Mrs,
W. E. Cook have moved in their nice
bill.' new home here. They have a warm
;COt,' welcome and may their sojourn to>uld^eth?r
be 'on? anc* pleasant.
itry! Mrs. Rhoda Watts is visiting retain.
tives in Greenville.
;oni. J Mr. Rc'bert Shealy and wife have
is | moved in the J. D. Stone home.
mal I A little early but some of oui
un_ i gardeners have Florida peas up and
| cabbage plants growing. Qther
jl: plants will grow besides cotton
! plants.
(OW- ix__ __ ?
mlcfi J-1*1'- -Monroe JLester ana iamny ana
? a!Mrs. J. S. Werts of Saluda county
ears: sPcnt Friday with Mr. and Mrs. H.
' J. Kinard.
also |
Mr. lied WertS and family have
j moved in the J. D. Lorick home,
j The first Sunday in the new year
! was a good ,day for Excelsior. Rev.
tsr, j ]\jr- Anderson held two services here,
.*? I *
wlil j one In the afternoon and the other at
^ j night. At the night service his
se- j theme was: "Prepare to Meet Thy
! God, 0 Israel." The services were
t* ; interesting throughout.
| If the Southern railroad would
j just open the way under the trestle
inosf triii srhftol house we would hava
j a fine road from Prosperity to Little
fire- j Mountain. Of course the railroad
' on j people will do this some time but it
lard js needed now.
Owing to the mild winter grain is
?
/
jiMITTLE BEYOND
! BORDER OF STATE
MEDICAL CERTIFICATES PRESENTED
AT TRIAL.
| Case in Orangeburg?Trial of Carlos
Corbett Aha May Be Heard
At Present Tern.
The State.
Orangeburg, Jan. 10.?The court
of general sessions opened here today
with Judge S. W. G. Shipj) presiding.
The day was largely^ taken
, ud with* organization of the courr
! and charges to the grand jury. In*
the afternoon the case against Edward
N. Mittle, charged with the
murder of J. H. Patterson, was called.
Miittle did not appear, his attorneys
appearing for him offering
certificates from 'two doctors as to
his inability to be present. One was
a certificate from Dr. Clarence E.
Owen of Columbia. Dr. Owen stated
that Mittle had called upon him and
1 that Mittle was suffering from headaches
and from some wound in the
head, and as he would -be away and
could not, therefore^ diagnose the
case, suggested that Mittle go to
Jotins Hopkins hospital in Baltimore.
There was a certificate from Dr.
Barker of Baltimore stating that Mittle
was suffering from trouble of the j
miqd and that it would be necessary
for Mittle to remain up there about
ten days for observation. ' i
The prosecution endeavored to
show to the court the insufficiency
of the showing and that Mittle should
be brought to trial. There was no
I from anv doctor in Green
I ? ~ v
j vile, where Mittle resides. Mittle is,
| now beyond the state of South Caro-1
! lina, in some nursing home, although
' his case is set for trial at this term, i
Judge Shijvp wiil announce his - deci-!
sion in thecase tomorrow. If he decides
to order Mittle to trial, Gover;
7 .|
nor Cooper will "be asked for neces-1
sary extradition papers to brifig Mit-1
tie to trial. . j
Another case is that against Car- j
| j los Corbett, who is charged witn tne
murder of Hugh Fanning and- Jule
Cooper, he having been acquitted at
the September term of this cort of
the killing of Bryan Salley. Corbett's
case will be called the second
week of the court.
Other murder cases for the week
. are those against Bunch Gaillard, ne-1
gro, charged with the murder of. his.
wife;. Booker T. Johnson, negro,
charged with killing another negro J
x- - "C T. Rvrrl nPSTO of
at a nut , *j. u. this.,
town who- operate? a pressing j
club and tailor shop, chained with j
: the killing of Julius Robinson, and
murder cases are also held against!
1 the following negroes: Thomas Jam-j
J ison, Moss Hilliard and Lum Gads-I
den.
Mittle Trial Later.
\ Greenville, Jan. 11.?Continuance1
of in the case against Edward N. j
/-i-p rirPAnville. charged wlthj
lUlbliC Ui. V<> WW , __
the murder of J. H. Patterson near]
Rowesville, S. C., on the night ofj
November 14, was granted today tby
Judge S. W .G. Shipp, presiding at
the sessions court at Orangeburg,
following consideration of affidavits
presented by MittJe's lawyers pleading
physical disability.
Mrs. Fracea Workman Davis.
The State.
Newberry, Jan. i2.?Mrs. Frances
Workman Davis, daughter of the late'
| Madison F. Workman and widow of
i Joshua T. Davis of Floyd township,'
died yesterday at the home of her
son, Thomas P. Davis, with whom
she had made her home recently and
was buried in the cemetery of BushRiver
church at noon today in the,'
I presence of many'sorrowing friends
! and relatives, the funeral service beI
ing conducted by the Rev. E. L. Long,
of Clinton in the absence of her pas- J
: tor, the Rev. R. II. Burriss, who had j
{gone to Anderson to be present at J
| the funeral of his brother. Mrs..
j Davis is survived by two sons, Thorn'
as P. Davis of Clinton and Asa Davis,
j of Kinards, and one daughter, Mrs.!
Jesse W. Boyd of Spartanburg.
| j
looking- nicely. Our people are prom-,
ising themselves to plant less cotton j
acreage and try to raise more to eat. i
1 Rpff-pr would do it. J
i . ;
*?
HEARINGS OVER
M i MM V
UN TAKlt* BILL
SENATE FINANCE COMMITTEE
SPENDS BUSY DAY.
' Opponents Believe Amendments
Will Work H&yoc With Fordo#j *
Emergency Plan.
! Washington, Jan. 11.?Hearings
, on the Fordney emergency tariff biil
| were concluded by the senate finance
j committee tonight after another day
: of appeals,.. either to be excluded or jjjjj
| included, had opened up what supi
porters of the measure; feared and
| opponents hoped wouM be the means
' of adding amendments to the bill *as
; it passed the house.
j Senators McCumber, North Dako- %
; ta, and La rouette, Wisconsin, nepublican
members of the committee,
, at the conclusion of the hearings, announced
they had statements to make
relative to the subject matter of the
tariff. These will ;be read at a 'se^^HB
sion Thursday, when it was mddcaJ^Hj^H
several other members would also^^^H^H
clare their attitude; Mr. B
ber's statement will concer^flH^^H
wheat duty, he said, and
lette said his would i>e with
to cheese, on which the bill provides
no additional protection.
i The close of the hearings brought
indications of a concentration of effort
among opponents of the bill and
the turbulence with which some of
them discussed the question was accepted
to mean they would go far m ~ ' I
+v?pir fifrht against nassage of the
measure, which is designated as an
aid to farmers.
) Many Amendment* F finding J
! Already a do|ejl amendments jffe
pending. Some amj
sors openly assert, are mtenWtobe
; facetious -but for the direct putpose
of taking up the timfc dfUtif Seifliftt,
and, if possible, of killing the bill
j OCiifiXUU1D i. ffyy
NHarrison, MiasisJij^l, Democrat*,
said today they would IMtefc Ito hart
the soldier (bonus and fminigratidflt
ibills tacked on to the tftrt'tf measure
i as amendments..
Another senator, it ir&& reported, f
was prepared to introduce ah amendment
which would ineludj the bill to
recodify the nation's laws kfcd to dej
mand that this amendn^pii be read.
It is of sufficient length to , keep
reading ciems uuay x*h. v?tw nww.
Sugar Grower* Active.
Efforts are being made on behalf ^
of sugar growers, dairy interests,
and other agricultural groups to
have the bill broadened to include
/
products omitted from the house bill.
Representatives of dairy interests,
numbering more than a icore, opposed
appearing ibefore the committee
to-day; asked for duties on im- ^
ported fresh and condensed milk and
- - 1 * -j-. j
butter. Growers of live block asjteu
that frozen meats of all kinds be
subjected fto an import levy and cane
scugar producers of Louisiana likewise
urged protection Vagiinst what
they feared would be roinous price
reductions in the future.
The appeals of representatives of
the dairy industry ibrougfcfc from several
members of the committee
statements indicating that some consideration
should be given this
branch of farm products. The dairy
men's representatives told the committee
that importations of Danish
* ii- - a
'butter were injuring tne AUlCllvait
dairy industry.
This and other incidents of the
final session it was asserted 'by several
senate leaders forecasts a bitter
fight behind the closed doors of
the committee room Friday when the
measure is to be considered.
Items From Various Point* in Salud*
Saluda Standard, 13th.
MVc R r. Schuranert of Pros
perity is visiting her daughter, Mrs.
J. A. Hunt.
Jonnie Robertson and Bennie Taylor
spent the week-end in Newberry
with relatives.
Attorney E. L. Asbill of Leesville
was in town Saturday afternoon
looking after the interests of his
clients.
Jilm Attaway spent last week-end
in Newberry with his sister.
John Cook was in Leesville Friday.
Harvey Kirkland was in Newberry
Fri-day.
Jim Attaway and W. E. Riser attended
a new year dance in Newberry
last Saturday. - :