The herald and news. (Newberry S.C.) 1903-1937, November 13, 1908, Image 1
VNBCYE8A1tro.50A
VO'L XLV. NO, 91 NEWBERRY, S. C.. FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 13, 1908. TIEAWE.$.0AYA
IRBY'S SENTENCE
THIRTY YEARS
MISS DEMPSEY'S ASSAILANT
GETS LIMIT OF LAW.
Spartanburg Court Room Jammed
With Spectators Anxious to
Hear Proceedings.
The State.
Spartanburg, Nov. 11.-John Irby,
colored, was convicted in the special
term of court this morning on the
charge of assault with intent to ra
vish upon the person of Miss Leila
Dempsey and was sentenced by Judge
Schumpert to 30 years at hard labor
in the State penitentiary. Irby was
carried to Columbia this afternoon by
Deputy Sheriff Becknell, who was es
corted as far as Laurens by the
Tranyham Guards, returning home
after spending 24 hours in Spartan
burg helping the Hampton Guards
keep the peace and protect the negro
Irby from mob violence.
The trial passed off quietly and
there was no sign of trouble at any
time during the day. Irby was ar
raigned at 11.45 and at 1.12 p. m.
Judge Schumpert passed sentence on
him.
Long before the appointed time of
the opening of court a large crowd
gathered about the court house and
the court yard. - The corridors and
hallways on the first and second
floors of the court house were pack
ed with men eager to see Irby and
hear the trial. Shortly before 10
o'clock a guard composed of five
soldiers marched into the hallway on
the second floor and began forcing
the crowd down stairs. Only the
jurymen and court officials were al
lowed in the court room. The squad
of soldiers stood at the foot of the
stairs with crossed bayonets and no
one was allowed to pass.
Organizing the Court.
While the crowd remained dowt,
stairs watching the gates of the jail
yard for a first glimpse of the negro.
Judge Schumpert and Solicitor Seast
were in the court room uipstairs or
ganizing the court. The grand jury
was got together and Judge Schum
pert gave them a short talk as to
their duties. The petit jurors were
got together and all the machinery ot.
the court put in good runing ordei.
All this took up considerable time.
Meanwhile the crowd down stairs be
gan to get restless and on every side
one could hear men talking of the
neonle being robbed of their rights
by being kept out of the court room,
a thing never heard of before.
From sullenness and restlessness
the crowd changed to good humot
and had quite a lot of fun jeering at
the soldiers and making all mannet
of comment in a jaeose way of the
boys in uniform. At 10.30 the doors
of the court room were opened and
there was a migh.ty rush for the stair
way leading up stairs. The soldiers
stood with crossed bayonets and triea
to keep the crowd passing up the
steps single file. But it was no use.
Hundreds of strong, easer a-nd deter
mined men. pushing with might and
main, were too much for five young
men in uniform. The steps were
jammed. and men were niashed up in1
the press till they called out foi
mercy, laugh-ing in frenzied delight.
*Scuffling to keep their feet. and
pushing the men ahead, the crowad
wvent up the steps.
Court Room Filled.
When the court room was filled to
its capacity, Sheriff Nicholls ordered
the soldiers at the door to let no more
pass in. All who could not find
seats on the inside were asked to
move out. Seats wer:- at a premiuni
and it was surprising to see how
small a surface big-bodied men coula
find a resting place. There were more
people left on the outside of the court
room than there were on the inside.
It was a most curious crowd. Every
body wanted the trial to begin.
When the crowd rushed into the
court room the grand jury was out
with the indictment of Irby for as
sault with intetnt to ravish and the
indictment of murder against Elmore
Wright the young nian who is charg
ed with having shot and killed A. (*.
Kirkendall at Moores some weeks
ago In a few minutes the grand
jury marched in. For each of the i
dietients they had found a true bi
They were handed two other indic
ments in smaller charges and aga
retired to the room. The judge o
dered that Irbv and Wright I
brought into the court.
Prisoners Enter Court.
Exactly at 11.30 o'clock Irby al
Wright were brought in betwe
files of soldiers. The entire compar
of the Hampton Guards and tl
Travnham Guards accompanied ther
Irby was placed at the desk next i
the one occupied by Solicitor Seas
He did not seem disconcerted
frightened in the least. The soldie:
stood up around the railing whi(
enclosed the bar. It was an imposi
sight to see so many uniformed m
in the court room with weapons j
their hands ready for service but
was a necessary precaution.
Judge Schumpert made a sho:
talk before arraigning Irby. He sai
that he knew nothing of the presen<
of the militia until upon his arriva
that they were not there by his o:
ders, but by .the order of the gove:
nor that the majesty of the law migl
be upheld. He said that he had n<
regarded it necessary to have th
militia. "'And I do not now so ri
gard it as a necessary precaution,
said the judge. "These soldiers ai
of our own flesh and blood and tli
Itask they are called upon to perfori
is an unpleasant one to them.
"When an appeal is made froi
this bench.'' he continued, "I kno
that it will be respected. I have cor
fidence in the law-abiding citizens c
Spartanburg county, and Mr. Sherif
I wish you would have the soldiei
dismissed from the court room."
Judge Schumpert Cheered.
The crowd cheer'ed Judge Schun
pert vociferously. Helcalled for oi
der and said that he had not intenc
ed to make a political speech. but wa
simply appealing to the patriotisr
and courage of the people of Spai
tanbuig county. He said the soldier
had sacrificed much to answer th
call of duty and he felt for them. R
remarked that he haC heard of som
of them even losing their position
because they defended the negro,i
by. and passed it ip by saying tha
if he had to deal with the men wh
discharged them they would be give
their deserts.
A t 11.45 Irby was arraigned. Mar
Irby, his wife, stood beside the pri~
oner 's dock. When Clerk Trin
mier read the indictment and th
question was put. "Are you guilty?~
Irbv answvered: "Not guilty.'' R
said he was ready for trial. Whe
asked if he wanted an attorney, h
replied that he did not know wha
that was. When asked if he wante,
to see any one he said: "I want t
see my daddy.'' Peter Irby, the fatt
er of the prisoner, was called and i
a few minutes a respectable lookin
old colored man appeared beside th
prisoner's dock.' A close consults
tion ensued between fa.ther and sor
Lawyer Named for Irby.
Judge Schumpert said that th
court had no power in such cases t
appoint an attorney to defend th
prisoner, but that owing to the pr
railing excitement he would ask tha
Capt. Win. McGowan and Mr. L. IV
Cantrell act as counsel for Irby an
see that he gzot a fair trial. Mr. Car
trell was absent and Capt. McGowa
asked to be excused. He said that h
had been brought up on such case
andi that he thought he had done hi
full share along that line. He sai
that he felt so strongly in the matte
that he was sure he could not d
justice by the negro. He said tha
in this he was not influenced by who
had been .said in the newspapers
been scat.tered about in printed forn
on the streets. Judge Schumpert rn
called an exoerienee in which he we~
put very much in th'e same fix as Ml
MGowan. He said that he had bee
called on to defend a p)arty when lh
had exnressed himself strong]
agninst him and had even been intei
viewed by a newspalper reporter .th2
day bhefore. With this and like pe
suasives. Capt. McGowan gracefull
acceded1 and promised to aet as cour
sel for the defendant.
IAt this point Elmore W\right we
arraigned for thle murder of A. (
(tnued on page three).
a- THE NEWS OF PROSPERITY.
The Lutheran Synod Adjourns
in Death of Mr. Monroe Wick
t- fer-Personal.
Prosperity, Nov. 12.-Rev. and
Mrs. Caldwell, of Woodruff, were the
4 guests of Rev. Ira Caldwell on their I
III return from the A. R. P. synod at
SNewberry.
ie ! [ichm:ni Wis- has elcsed his I
i. cotton season at Swansea and will
: sepnd the month of Novemhr i
e.home.1
h Miss Lizzie Dieher, of Irmo, has i
'- been on a visit to Miss Della Bowers.
ll Dr. Hunter went. up to Clemson
40 college Sunday. He was accompan
! ied home by his father.
i Shss Rosa Crosson an4 Mi s Vi c
it toria are with Mr. John Crosson's
family.
t Dr. and Mrs. Hallman returned to I
a Spartanburg Monday, after a very
e happy week spent among their
1, friends and former parishoners.
- Mrs. Kohn and Mrs. Lizzie Young
e- went to Columbia to see Mrs. Wise L
it this week. Mrs. Wise is improving i
o. a-d vill be home before long. C
e The announcement early Sunday
- moniing -of the death of Mr. Monroe
Wicker, one of our suburban resi- t
e dents was an entire shock to his
e friends. On Saturday afternoon he i
h was on the streets seemingly enjoyirg I
bis wonted health. Mr. Wicker was e
h possessed of many noble qualities,
x and he will be greatly 'missed, for I
truly "An honest mav is -the noblest f
t work of God." He was an aggres- t
t, ive, progressive farmer, and one y
s who knew how 'to make two blades of t
grass grow where only one grew It
before.' In his early manhood he i
%was happily married to Miss Sallie
Cook. He is survived by his wife and
two brothers, Messrs. Jefferson ani
Pickney Wicker.
ML7. John Pat Wise spent Sunday
at hom-e.
Miss Mrie Lathan visited Mr
, Harmon over Sunday.
- Miss Dolly Davis, of St. Luke's, s
ei visiting Mrs. A. H. Hawkins. r1
Messrs. Young, Younce. Kester and n
Lown. of Newberry college. visited v
Messrs. Kohn last week. t
- Miss Minnie Hussuy, who has been p
at Mr. E. 0. Counts', has returned t
to Columbia.
Mr. Young Brown, of Erskine col- b
lege, spent several days of last week s
-with his parents.
SThe graded school enjoyed a rare e
-treat Thursday morning when they y
a were i.ddressed by Rev. E. C. Welt- e
:i ner. This genial man is a noble ob- t
e jeet lessen to children, for he hasf r
i been blind ever since his youing man
1 hood, but despite this deprivation, Jt
L' he is entertaining, witty, humorous, t
-- and in addition is an impersonate1 n
a and minic of unusual ability. The s
Schildren and friends present were so
e elated over his laughabIe sayings, o
-his ludierous motions. and rare imita
tions of musical instruments than
they begged is speedy return. We~ t
are glad to announce that in the near 3
future lie will give a humorous lee -t
ture at the auditorium under the aus-I
piees of ''Grace (i!eaners.''"
S Rev. J. B. Bass, of New Brook- h
land, delivered a foreeful sermon at 3
the Baptist' chureh on Monday even-b
-ing. On Tuesday at 11 a. m. a fine iJ
talk on Sunday school work in its y
e manifold phases was given by Rev. 2
J. D. Moore, of Columbia. It wast
Sannounced that Rev. Mr. Fowler, of a
SClinton will begin an evangelistie f
series of meetings here on Monday a
night Nov. 17. All dIen.ominations
.a~re invited to participate with the -
Baptist in these services and the piub- p
lie ia c ordially invited. I
S Mr's. Barret. of Augusta, Ga., is e
visiting Rev. Mr. Krep's family. t
*Mr. Leonard Senise, of the county, r
.spent last week witai his daughiten
1 Mrs. Stoudemire.I
e Misses Clara Gibson and Willie I
v May~ Wise are home from Winthrop
-college.K
e Mr. S. S. Birgte and Master George, t
. Wis spen1t several days in Columbi:t
v this week.I
i M. Joe Carmichael, of Cavuta.
a., spent last week in Prosperity
-and vicinity, with re'latives 11nd
. friends.I
.. Rev. Mr. Kreps and Dr. Hunter at
tended the nenctie committee mee.-v
BX-SENATOR CORMACK
SLAIN IN THE STREET
KILLED BY ROBIN COOPER, SON
OF .A POLITICAL ADVERSARY
3ditorial Attacks Cause of Shooting
-Brilliant Tennesseean Perishes
in Pistol Battle on Seventh
Avenue, Nashville.
Nashville, Tenn., Nov. 9.-As a se
jnel to the recent bitterly contested
)emocratic primary for the guberna
orial nomination in Tennessee, Hon.
dward Ward Carmack, former Unit
d States senator from Tennessee,
vas shot and killed in a street duel
ere this afternoon by Robin CoopeL,
yoting atturney. Young Cooper wab
vounded in the shoulder by a bullet
rom Carmack's revolver and is to
tight under police surveillance in a
ocal hospital. His condition is not
erions. -
Carmack was wounded three .times.
n the neck, the breast and the left
houlder. Col. Duncan B. Coopei,
'ather of the young man, was with
is son during the affray, but did-not
ire a shot. It is said he stood by
;i,th pistol in hand. He is detained
onight at police headquarters.
The direct cause of the killing is a
ecent series of editorials in the Ten
esseean. a daily paper of which Mr.
armack became editor after his de
eat for the nomination for governor.
he editorials in question had been
igorous in their comment on Col.
ooper and his alleged connection
rith what Mr. Carmack termed the
'Democratic machine" and its
ethods. CoI. Cooper, who is weli
nown in business, newspaper and
olitical circles in Tennessee, it is
aid ha-d notified Mr. Carmack that
he references to him must cease.
Mnother such editorial appeared this
iornnlz.
Close and Deadly Combat.
The men fought at close quarters
nd there were but few witnesses. It
as past 4 o'clock in the dusk of the
fternoon. They met on Seventh
venue, north, directly in front of
lie Polk flats. a faschionable depart
ient house. Mr. Carmack had just
fted his hat to Mrs. Charles R.
:stman, a friend, who was passing.
n a moment the firing began and
frs. Eastman was a horrified witness
t close range. So close was shre
h.at one of the Coopers is said to
ave charged Carmaek wit'h being a
rward and hiding' behind a womnat.
'oper 's friends charge that Car
ack fired the first shot, but the
end man's friend.s stoutly nrotest
bat, his opponent was 'the first to
boot.
The tragedy "breated the most ifl
anse excitement throughout the city
ndl within a short time the streets
1 the neighborhood were thronged.
A statement issued by friends ot
he Coopers tonight says that Cot.
ooper had recently talked with E.
eCraig of Chattanoga, a close
riend of Mr. Carmack, regarding
'he Tennesseeant editorials.. Col
'ooper had told Craig, t'he statemrent
ays, that lie wanted the references
r himself stopped, that he was a1
rivate citizen and Carmack had ma
ight to discuss his affairs in the
'tnner he had adopted. Mr. Craig.
:is said, saw Mr. Carmack aboiut the
atter and reported that Carmack
"ould consent to no relations with
'ooper. Mr. Craig, however, is said
a have e.xpressed the opinion that
be editorial references would cease.
'ooper had a letter which -he desired
>send Carmaek:. but friends advisea
gainst it and urged him to tatke no1
otice of the editorial this morning.
thortly after this conversano i of
ooper and his friends, the formet
as requested. the statement sayts,b
For. Patterson to come to the execn
ve mansion, whieh is on Seventh i
venne, north, for consoltntion on a1
ater not connected with ('armacki
nd to bring with him Austin Pea>.I
hairman of the Democratic State1
ommittee.
Advised to Avoid Meeting.
After the appointment was made.
ontinues the statement, James C. 1
iradforil and Gen. Tilley Brown <
gain referred to the Carmack mat
- and navied Co. Conor not toi'
ng at Columbia.
Mrs. Samie Moore, of Zion, is at
\Ir. Roht.Puhs
The long-looked-forward-to con
rentions of Christian workers have
-onvened. and they have gone. But ]
n1 their wake linger many memories
md the waves of influence for good
:hey set in motion, we hope. will roll
mn and on and break only on the
hores of eternity. No town or city.
.specially our wide-awake. respoa
-ive Prosperity. could but feel that
t has been the recipient of a grea.t
avor. Nay evenbles,iig. disguised
md undisguised. We were ghd to
pen our homes to the consecrated.
-ltured flowers of the church, and
he kindness done is more than re
aid already by the val received
)f their enthusiasm and gioodwill.1
Ye congratulate Lexington upon the
,ood fortune of having synod withiin
ier gates in 1909.
We cannot refrain from adding a
Vord concerning the appreciation our
-hurch received. Some one aptly
alled it "a symphony in white and
old. And many have obtainedl i
deas here for their contemplated S
'hurches and memorial windows. The I
hoir. too. deserves a ward of praise, I
or its faithful attend.-nce and b-!a- I
iful renditions of anthems and oth- i
r music. To Mrs. Alice Robe-;on t
s due mf-hi of the credit for the
deasure the singring afforded. The i
loquent. masterly sermons to which i
ve gave undivided attention everN
ight must surely prove very help- I
ul to us in our moments of serious
hought and necessary trials. T'; i
leasure of entertaining the .oiven- (
ion and synod is exceeded only by
he rare good derived therefrom. It
s a good thing. r
MANY TAILORS DECEIVED. 1
fore Than One Thousand Exclusive t
Samples Get Into the Wrong
Hands. r
A piece of cardboard covered with
qu.are samples of woollen cloths for a
nen's and women 's suitings might ,
ot seem to the average man a very ,
aluable article, yet elaborate schemes a
o get hold of such sample cards are t
ilanned - and sometimes carried a
hrough.
A couple arrived recently at the I
est of the Philadelphia hotels and I
et out to visit all the leading tailors. 3
he man wanted a winter outfit of a a
omprehensive character,. while the t
oman was ,just as interested in ac- hi
umulating a winter wardrobe of the .e
ailor made variety. Occupying large (
oms in the hotel, there was no rea- r
on! to believe that the two were any- d1
hing other than they represented t
hemselves. So when they gave the s
umber of t' .eir suite in the hotel the
amples weie forthcoming. t
A fter several day~s had i.assed with- ai
ut the expected orders the tailors be- i:
an to send to the hotel for informa-t
ion. The answer returned was that t
bie two had given up their rooms and (
ft the day before. No samples were J
) h)e f6und.f
The number of inquiries became s'o '
ige that they were referred hy the (
otel clerk to police headquerters. s
ore than 1,000 samples of cloth had t
een sent by the t:iIlors to the couple. p
vestigation showed their p)urpose r
h. r in t"w Iro d - eet station n1
rere found two wooden paekages i:
b'ey had checked there. The pack- r
ges were filled with sample cards v
rm which the cloth had been torn (
way.t
The couple had succeeded in ae-- t
niring possession of the best sam- (
es of the firms that deal in the t
igh class exclusive patterns. Of a
ourse, they will sell their patterns to en
he cheaper firms that endeavor to S
eproduce them.(
Even a bolder effort to get the ex- v
lusive samples is reported from Chi- E
ago. There two men rented a store in t
hieh to open a tailoring business of Ia
,high priced character and sent to n
he manufacturers for their samples. a'
he samples were sent, but no orders
ver came in.
Later inquiry from the manufac
rers showed that the firm had got
n farther in its careecr thain taking e
he store for a month. Tts ob:ject was I
in wheni somei of th e bet designs1 a
-re tunedout bn the heaen mills. t,
1 on the streets in sth directions
as would make probable a meeting
with Mr. Carmack. To this Col.
Cooper assented. He and his son,
Robin. then left the office to go to the
governor's mansion. To avoid any
possible meeting with Mr. Carmack
they went through the Arcade and up
through Union street to Seventh ave
nue, north. Their purpose in taking
this route was -to avoid meeting on
the streets.
"Col. Cooper and his son went
through the Arcarde, through Sum
mer, then to Union, and up Union to
Seventh .avenue, north. Turning in
to Seventh avenue, Col. Cooper and
his son saw Mr. Carmack walking
up Seventh avenue, north, going
north on the west side of the street
and in the direction of CoJ. Cooper
and his son, though on the opposite
side of the street from them.
Col. Cooper thereupon said he
would go over and speak with Mr.
Carmack and see if -he would not
agree to stop making the annoying
newspaper attacks on him.
The. Fatal Shot.
"Col. Cooper walked across the
treet and a.m)roaij!ad ' Mr. Carmack.
who was coming facing him at the
time. Col. Cooper had just begun to
speak with Mr. Carmack when Mr.
Carmack drew his pistol and began
trVinz +'. fire it, whL,-3 a passir.g l:idy
was between Mr. Carmack and Col.
Cooper and his son, who had run over
when Mr. Carmack began to draw his
pistol. It is said that Col. Cooper
asked Mr. Carmack to come from be
hind . the lady, when Mr. Carmack
thereupon fired two shots, both
striking Robin Cooper, who had in
tervened in his father's protection.
Then it was, after being shot, that
Robin Cooper fired the fatal shot,
Col. Cooper never using a pistol at
all.
"Col. Cooper refused to consent to
any effort being made to secure his
release upon bond for the present.
He said, it is understood, that he de
zired the matter thoroughly investi
za-ted so that it might be seen that he
wa; entitled to bond before. he ap
plied for it."
Laps G. McCord. Jr., eitv editor
)f The Tennesseean. is .; 110- as :a
ins. "Several friends of the senator
had advised him to be careful and to
all of these admonitions the senator
repied that he did not intend to show
the 'white feather.'
Mr. McCord also said that in reply
ng to these admonitions Mr. Car
mack had remarked that he did not
think Col. Cooper intended to harm
uim.
As soon as Senator Carmack felt
m the edge of the street eurbing. Cot
Cooper put his arm around Robin
Cooper, and both walked a few feet
lown Seventh avenue to Dr. R. G.
P'ort 's offie, where the slight wound
n Robin 's shoulder was treated.
Carmack's Pistol Found.
An ambulance .earried the body of
sir. Carmack to an undertaking es
:ablishment. The pistol of Mr. Car
naek wa.s found lying at his side
with two ehambers empty and it was
turned over to an officer.
Toung Cooper was later carried tos
i hospital, and Col. Cooper is held at
rolice hegaduarters. Robin Cooper is
n attorney and unnmrriaT. lie is
?7 vears old.
Dr. McPheeters Glasgow. who ar
eived at the scene soon after the .trag
ady occurred, said tonight:
"I found the body of Mr. Carmack
Eving on the right side of Seventh av
nue. as one walks to Church street
from Union street. He was lying
with -his head facing north and with
his right arm under his head. His
sistol was lying just out of the reach
>f his right hand and the weapon was
pointing south. An evening paper
bas ling just out of his left hand
hhheld the stump of a eiga:,
whichu was crushed. I immediately
~nmmoned an ambulance and had the
vrl e:rried to the undertakingr es
ablishment of Finley M. Dorris. The
>ndy was without signs of life wheni
ond b-~ me aund anpeared to have
yeen so for about five minutes.
Three Wounds.
''There were three bullets in the
>ody of Mr. Carmack. One entered
mn the left side ahou't two e'nd one
alf inches below the left nipple and