The herald and news. (Newberry S.C.) 1903-1937, October 06, 1908, Page TWO, Image 2
GARRISON GUILTY
OF INSLAlUGIITE
SENTENCED TO TWO YEARS Il
THE PENITENTIARY.
Judge Refuses New Trial-Convicte
by Laurens Jury After Long
Deliberation.
The State.
Laurens, Oct. 2.-J. Henry Garr
son of Gray Court, who was th:
morning convicted of manslaughte:
was this afternoon sentenced to tw
years at hard labor in the State per
itentiary, >the motion for a new tria
being overruled by Judge Memmin
ger. The attorneys for the defens
will carry the mattter to the suprem
edurt and in all likelihood it wi
come up in January. Garrison is or
on the same bond of $500 that wa
given August 1, when he was release
.pending the trial held yesterday.
Laurens, Oct. 2.-"Guilty of mar
slaughter with a recommendation t
the mercy of the court," was the ver
diet written and handed in at 1
o'clock this morning by the jury ii
the Garison munrder eases, whereupo:
Mr. Featherstone at once gave notic
of a motion for a new trial, whie
will doubtless be heard at some tim
during the day. After styaing in thi
jury room all night, at 9.30 this morn
ing the jury came out and announce<
that they could not agree. Judg
Memminger admonished them to usi
every effort to reach an agreement
that the county was at great expens(
in the trying of such cases, and tha
a jury had no right to try to shif
the responsibility of a decision upow
another jury. He recharged them oi
the poin.ts of law involved and sen
them back to find a verdict.
At 11 o'clock they announced tha
en agreement had been reached, an<
the verdict of guilty of manslaugh
ter with recommendation to the
mercy of the court was read- by thi
clerk.
It is understood that on the firs
ballot last night that two of the jur
ors stood for acquittal, some for man
slaughter, and some for murder. Thi
morning, when sent back to the jur:
-room, the same two stood for ac
quittal -and the others for man
slaughter; finally the verdiet render
ed was reached -and the jg~ry had end
ed its work.
It is a matter worthy of note tha
Judge Memminger has the fewes
* number of mistrials to occur unde
his presiding; he urges. the necessit;
of a jury reaching some kind o:
agreement, in fact, he all but tell
them that they must agree. Hi
* charge this morning was even strong
er -than that of last night, and ni
doubt the clearness and strength o:
it caused the verdict to be reached.
* TESTIMONY IN DETAIL.
Miss Garrison's Testimony-Defend
ant on Stand-Judge Memnin
ger's Charge.
The State.
Laurens, Oct. 1.-At 12 o'clock t<
night the jury in tha Garrison mur
der trial had not reached a verdic
and Judge Memminger ordered then
locked up until morning.
Laure,s, Oct. 1.-J. Henry Garri
son was tried today in the court o
general sessions for the killing of 3
Louis Williamson.
All da.x was consumed in hearin
* the testimnoy, the arguments of coun
* sel and the judge's charge. Messrs
Richey and Featherstone addresse<
The jury in behalf of the defendant
while Messrs. Cooper and Nelso2
spoke for the State.
On the witness stand today, fo
the first time, were declared the de
tails of the tragedy, which occurre<
near Gray Court at about 11 o 'clod]
on the night of July 31, and in whic)
Mr. Louis Williamson of Bethesda
York county, lost his life. Mis
Mary Garrison and her father wer
'the principal witnesses, Miss Garri
son for the State and the defendan
zfor himself. Although summoned b;
the State. Miss Garrison 's testimon.
was decidedly in favor of her fathex
:a fact impossible to be concealed.
The prosecution sought to shoi
;that Mr. Williamson was not takin:
:advantage of Miss Garrison; that hi
conduct was but the legitimate cares
ses of a lover a.nd a future husbani
The defense endeavored to show tha
these acts were not within th
bounds permissible and that the
were committed against the will o
Miss Garrison, who protested agains
them, and endeavored to free herseli
It was testified that Williamson ha
been drinking, was intoxicated whe
he arrived at Gray Court, but it wa
acot proved that he had had an
whiskey after 'his arrival and th
State contended that he had time +
:oher up before the shooting t<
place.
The defense held that Garrison
not know that his daughter was
gaged to Williamson. The prose
tion contended that no harm or inji
was committed, while the defe:
took the position that the indicati<
were sufficient to convince the fa
er that harm was attempted.
Judge Memminger made a bi
but unusually strong charge to
jury on the points of law involv
s showing under what circumstan
, an act like Garrison's would con
0 tute a defense of a female member
- his family and at 8.15 o'clock
jury retired to find a verdict.
Composition of Jury.
e Something over an hour was c
e sumed this morning in the select
Ll of a jury to try Mr. J. Henry Ga
t son for the murder of Louis Willih
s son of York county. Ten farm(
I one clerk and a merchant compo
the panel.
The State opened its case by
- testimony of Dr. C. E. Rogers
' Gray Court, who was called in to
tend the deceased. Dr. Rodgers I
1 tified that he was called by Mr. G
' rison at about 11.30 to come to
2 house to see a "man he had shot.'
Attende4 the wounded man and
certained that there was no hope
recovery. Death caused by inter
hemorrhage. Some gunshot a
wadding in the wound. Shot entei
1 to left of abdomen.
Miss Mary Garrison was next 1
upon the stand. Had been teachi
in the Bethesade high school, n<
Rock Hill and in two miles of I
Williamson home. Met Mr. J. Lo
Williamson and later became engag
to him. Returned home May 2
this year and Williamson came to
her in June. Upon question fr4
counsel she stated that she had r
told her mother of the engageme
but her mother knew it after tl
first visit. Williamson's conduct q
proper and becoming a gentleman
this first visit. On July 31 Willia
son arrived at her home at about
o'clock in the afternoon with J.
Garrison, her father, who had goi
upon her request, to meet him
station. They went walking in t
afternoon, had supper together a
sat for a while on defendant's pori
together with members of fami
Later-at about 9:30-she and M
-liamson went into parlor together a
the family retired to their roomsJ
b the night, she supposed, for ti:
were not on the porch.
Just Prior to Shooting.
TRelating the circumstances ji
Sprior to the shooting, Miss Garris
Ssaid that Mr. Williamson acted iri
a manner unbecoming a gentlem;
- went too far, took undue liberti
> She was begging him to desist
Etones loud enough to be heard o
side. Then she'saw the barrel of
gun stuck into the window from i
outside, heard her father's vo
calling out something. Did not ku
- what. She got ula and ran. Will'a
son also got up and in just a momne
she heard the shot. After the sI
.she, with her sister, Fannie, andi
mother entered the parn ,r. WillEs
> mn sat down. but later walked wi
- out assistance into the bed room, ji
t back of the parlor, w1.ere he pul]
c ff his coat and with hes- (Miss G:
rison 's) assistance pulled off his e"
iar. .%'e fanned him ,.,2 staye.i
- hde:il of bed most of the time. S1h
a little while on sofa next u:or:::i
-Ila-1 n-nt some flowe14 :along w:
'L' .c boy next day and identified 1
e ar.I on the flowers. A's - identi5
- ai !etter of sympathy she ha~d writt
. frs "i'ame on afte- the t.-aret
i This i:tter was not adtI.tted as e
.dence. When Mr.'NelsoA banded I
l'etter :a Miss Garrison she lboked
it a moment ard then to~ j l' ut
e throwing it on the floor. At the e<
. clusion of her testimony Mr. Feath
i stone apologized for the act, sayi
e that under the severe strain Miss G:
a rison wag not herself.
,Jud-ge Memminger stated th!at he
a preciated the situation and the
a would not be deemed contempt
. court.
t On cross-examination by .
Featherstone Miss Garrison said ti
she knew by his general 'demear
that Mr. Williamson had been dri]
ing. She gave Mr. Williamson's<
e ing statement to her. It was th
,"I know I am going to die and
s was to blame for the shooting a
- not your father, and I don 't wi
.your father hurt for it.''
t Reexamined by Mr. Nelson, M1
e Garrison said that after the shoot!
Mr. Williamson asked her to get
f suit er She did so, an.i he go1
t bottle of whiskey out of it. Some
.the whiskey had been taken from
j bottle.
a Mr. T. L. Shell and Mr. W.
Blythe were put up by the State,
y first testifying that lie was notif
e ,of the shooting and went to the G
SiMsan honse at aout 12 o'clok e
)Ok
did
en- u
iry g
ase
yns
he
the A. HATted,
ces a NE WH 1K YS
3ti- W jIKL S
of 1
the
on
ion
rs, Ta xoe is our hpphg
Sed best adr. quizL.et shippi:Lfl'% ,citia
HATKE'S VIRGINIA Mf 'IJT
the i PRIVATE STOCK CO :N-'Ti
of " HOLLAN D GIN-Dest Gin sold
at- APPLE BRANDY-This years
PEACH BRANDY-Made esp
es- ''ADD 1
ar
his We prepay express Charges z
as
of
aal S(80-8(2-8(M4-80w .
.nd
-ed
>ut stayed until nearly morning. William- si
ng son made a statement to him, but it U
1 was not admitted as testimony at t(
;he first. Court heard statement while w
ais jury retired which was: "I don't see k
ed 'why that man shot me." c
of Proper legal foundation for the in- h,
;e troduction of this had not been laid, vn
m hence it was ruled out, but later from
tot another witness it was introduced. '
at, W- :.. was ti'-. U' :a: 21 0 al
tat embalmed the body. f]
ras Besides numerous witnesses who rE
on testified as to seeinP Mr Williamson w
m- on the afternoon of July 31, and that h,
4 he was in an intoxicated condition, w
H. the defense put up Mrs. Garrison, tl
ae, wife of the defendant, J. H. y
at Mrs. Garrison heard the dying state
he ment of Williamson. Went to the t]
nd parlor when she heard shot after ,,
sh, leaving the porch. Went to her room h
ly. and retired, but did not know wheVh- h
!il- er or not she had been asleep. Heardu
nd Mary's voice in the parlor directly I
~or under her bed room. "Heard enough
ey to know that Mary had no business ina
there, so I got up to go down and call
her out. Didn't know where Mr.2
1st Garrison Was. Had left him down
on stairs. Just had got into the back
a hall when I heard the shot."
, The Defendant's Testimony. C
es. Mr. J. Henry Garrison sworn, testi
in fied that he was .the defendant, agedd
at 57 and a half years, the father ofd
a Miss Mary Garrison. Had gone ton
he the station the afternoon of July 31,
ce distance of about half a mile, to get
shoes for mule and had been asked
m. by Miss Mary to meet and bring out
mnt Mr. Williamson. Saw Williamson t<
of when he got off train. Thought he S
er was a little dazed from riding but B
.did not approach him at once, as bi
Lh- some one called him. Later passed e<
ist him in the postoffice, told him to wait f:
ed a minute for the mail, then they w
ir- would go home. Had not up to this V
ol. time noticed that he was intoxicated.
at Did notice later when he went to
~pt get in buggy. Drove home and work- 2
g. ed in field until sundown. Ate sup- L
thi per with Williamson, who appeared ,
~er to be still intoxicated, but did not say e
ed anything out of the way. After the
en couple went into the parlor he went d
y,* up stairs and. sat in a window direct
-i ly' above the parlor. Was suspicious
he of Williamson in his then condition. 0
at About 10 he went to his room up
,stairs and stayed until nearly 11G
>n o'clock. Heard a scraping noise as a
er- chair dragged across the room. Wenta
ne down stairs. Half way down heard a
ar- his daughter say: ''Please don't."
Heard it again. ''As I reached the i
-bottom of the stairs I thought of my
ict gun in the passage way just outside, *
of picked it up, walked out the backA
way around the house to the window 0
4r. on side, saw Williamson with his
iat arms around her. Put the gun into ~
ior window and hollowed: ''Move,'' for t
ik- he didn't want to shoot the man in 0
.the back, whereupon Miss Mary ran d
is: and Williamson exclaimed: ''Mr.
I Garrison, Mr. Garrison.'' Shot wast
nd fired almost immediately after Gar- e
int rison hollowed ''move.'' After being Ce
shot Williamson said, ''I intended to a,
iss marry your daughter and you have 0
ing killed me.'' to which Garrison re- b
his plied, ''May be you did and may be e
a you didn't.''
of *Williamson asked not to be shot P
the again and Garrison said he would not a
and upon request of deceased went
B. for Dr. Rodgers. Mr. Nelson in the
the cross examination asked Garrison
ied why he did not go directly into the r
ar- parlor from the hallway instead of
nd sneaking around on the outside and
E&CO
dED 1867
DISTI LLERr AND SHi
?~ErAILD~WIOLE5ALE 1
ousar where we have been doing businea
_U' orders :.re sent out same day re
AIN PYE-A whiskey we have beei
a mild and mellow, try it once,
at this low price - -
crop, but it is PURE BRANDY
ecially for us in Maryland. -
C ENTS EXTRA PER GALLON FOR ANI
24 Plata or 48 Half-Pints of Any Al
t these prices and guarantee safe deliver;
Send Money Order or Reg
A. HATKE &
CARY ST., BOX :
>ying on his own daughter, to which
a. ison r2:>lied that he did not .vant
give them warning, that if there
as anything wrong he wanted to
now it. Asked why he shot the de
ased, he said, "Because I thought
a was trying to take improper ad
mntage of my daughter."
Counsel had defendant admit that
iilliamson was not doing anything
the time he was shot. On question
-om counsel, Garrison stated as his
.ason for bringingeWilliamson home
ith him in a drunken condition that
a wanted to get him away from
here the neighbors would see him, as
ere was already talk about the
>ung man being drunk.
A number of witnesses testified
iat Williamson was intoxicated on
_e afternoon of the 31st. None,
>wever, that he took a drink alter
is arrival at Gray Court at 3 o'clock
p to the time he was shot at about
L o'elock.
The defense in a nutshell was
cound this point, that young Wil
amson was under the influence of
hsikey and acted in such a manner
>warrant the girl's father in 1kfend
g her. The State had a number of
iaracter witnesses here, among them
[ayor John T. Roddey of Roch Hill,
Stestify to the good character of the
sceased, but because the defense did
>t assail his general good character
iat testimony was not taken.
Best the World. Affords.
"It gives me unbounded pleasure
>recommend Bucklen 's Arnica
alve,'' says J. W. Jenkin;, of Chapel
:ill, N.' C. "I am convinced it 'e the
est salve the world affords. It ear
I a felon on my thumb, and it never
tils to heal every sore, burn or
ound to which it is applied. 2'i-. at
r. E. Pelham and Son's durg st3re.
500 .il'e State Family Tickets $11.
5.-Good over the Atlantic Coast
ine in teach State for the head or de
andent memibers of a. family. Limit
I to ope year from date of sale.
1000 Mile Interchangeable Indivi
aal Ticket $20.00.-Good over the
Sthe Southeast aggregating 30,000
iles. Limited to one year from date
i sale.
2000 Mile Firm Ticket $40.00.
ood over the Atlantic Coast Line
ad 30 other lines'-in th-e Southeast
rgregating 30,000 miles; for a man
~er or head of firm and employes li
nes in the Southeast aggregating 41,
ited to five, but good for only one
Ssuch persons at a time. Limited to
tlantie Coast Line and 30 other lines
ae year from date of sale.
1000 Mile Southern Interehangeablh
idividual Ticket $25.00.-Good over
ie Atlantic Coast Line and 75 other
)0 miles. Limited to one year from
tat a'f sale.
All mileage tickets sold on and af
er April 1st, 1908, will not b'e honor
: for passage on trains, nor in
1eeking baggage (except from non
gency stations and stations Dot
pen for the sal eof tickets) but muist
a presented at ticket offices and there
changed for continuous tickets.
15 cents saved in passage fare by
rchasing loeal 'ticket from our
gents.
Atlantic Coast Line.
T. C. White,
Gaeneral Passenger Agent.
'. J1. Craig,
Pasenger Traffic Manager,,
Wilminstton, N. C.
LOCATED tfN
RICHr
ND C rP- y
III RUNt
PPERS FF1N WM I KE'S
PROMP'
s for more than forty years. Being nex1
reived. We make losses and breakage g
1 Gt
i selling for forty years - $2 5
then always - - - - 2.5
- - - - - 2.5
- - - - 2.5
- - - - - - 2.5
F OF THE ABOVE BRANDS IN FULL Qf
bove Brands In Plain Case $7.50.
y. Write for complete price list, as I
istered Letter with order.
C.OMPANY,
371,
AN ORDINANCE.
Fixing the rate and prescribing the
time for the payment of town taxes
for the year 1908.
BE IT ORDAINED by the mayox
and aldermen of the Town of New
berry, S. C., in council assembled and
by authority of the same:
That for the purpose of raising a
revenue and in the exercise of the
taxing power of said town, the fol
lowing taxes are hereby levied foi
the fiscal year ending December 31st,
1908, upon all real and personal pro
perty within the corporate limits of
said Town (except such as is exempi
from taxation under the constitution
and laws of this State) upon the
valuation thereof as assessed for tax
ation for county and State purposes;
viz:
Section 1. That atax of sixty eentE
on each one hundred dollary of real
and personal property within the cor
porate limits of the Town of New
berry in the State of South .Caro
lina (except such as is exempt fromr
taxation under the constitution and
laws of this State) is hereby levied
for the purpose of raising a revenue
to defray the ordinary expenses of
said Town for the fiscal year end
ing December 31st, 1908.
Section 2. That a tax of three
fourths of a mill on each dollars
worth of real and personal property
within the corporate limits of the
Town of Newberry (except such as
is exempt from taxation under the
Constitution and laws of this State)
is hereby levied foiz the purpose of
raising a revenue to defray the bond
ed indebtedness of said Town for the
Opera House.
Section 3. That a tax of two and a
half mills on each dollar's worth of
real and personal property withir
the corporate limits of the Town of
Newberry (except such as is exempt
from taxation under the Constitutior
and laws of this State) is hereby le
vied for the purpose of raising a
revenue to pay the interest on and
create a sinking funK for the bonded
indebtedness of said Town for the
Water Works and Electric Light
Plant.
Section 4. That a tax of one mill
on each dollar's worth of real and
personal property within the corpor
ate limits of the Town of Newberry
(except such as is exempt from taxa
tion under the Constitutioh and law.
of this State) is hereby levied for the
pur'pose of raising a revenue to pay
the interest of the bonded indebted
ness of said Town for the Sewerage
System.
Section 5. That all taxes herein
imposed or levied shall be paid to
the said Town of Newberry in law
ful money of the United States, be.
tween the fifteenth day of October,
1908, and t' e fifteenth day of No.
vember, 190i8, and a penalty of ten
per cent is hereby imposed upon and
shall be added to all taxes in arrears.
Section 6. Tha.t execution issue ae
cording to law for the collection of
all taxes, fines or penalties past due
and unpaid for fifteen days, and the
cost of said execution.
Done a.nd ratified under the cor
porate seal of the Town of Newberry,
in the State of South Carolina, this
the second day of September, A. D.
1908.
.1. J. Langford,
Attest: Mayor.
Eug. S. Werts,
Clerk and Treasurer.
'THE:HEART OF
IOND, VA.
ADOAM5 TXPREsS
5OUTtERN EXP E5S
7 SHIPMENTS
to the express office gives us the
ood
iL 2 Gals. 3 eats. 4% Gals.
0 $4.50 $6.50 $9.00
0 4 50 6.50 9.00
0 4.50 6.50 9.00
0 4.50 6.50 9.00
0 4.60 6.60 9.00
ARTS."
hese are only a few brana.
RICHMOND, VA.
wrs. Alice Robertson,
TEACHER OF
Voice, Piano and Harmony.
Studio Over Mower's Store.
Open Mondays, Tuesdays, Thurs
days and Fridays. Wednesdays
and Saturdays by special appoint
ment.
VIOLIN MUSIC:
Miss Carrie Pool will give instruc
tion on the Violin, beginning
September the 14th.
Address: 1727 Harrington Street.
Phone: No. 78.
FOR SALE
113 Acres FineLand
One mIle of city limits of
Newberry, S. C. One-half of
lands in rrew grounds. 100
acres will make one bale of
cotton to the acre per year if
properly cultivated. Just two
miles from the City Graded
Schools and Newberry College.
Fine location for a home. Can
be purchased on reasonable
terms. Apply to
GEO, WE SUMER,
NEWOERRY, S. C.
WN. G. Houseal, M. D,
Office Hours - ( to 1a.m.
IL. A. Riser, M. D.
Office uwith Dr. Houseal.
{ 8to 9a. m.
Office Hours - 2 to 3p. m
6-30 to 7.30 p. m.
NOTICE or FINAL SETTTEMEN~T
AND DISCHARGE.
Notice is hereby given that I will
make a final settlement of the per
sonal estate of Benjamin F.'NPihoIs,
deceased. in the Probste Court for
Newberry county on O.ctober 12th,
1908, at 11 o'clock a. in., and im
mediately thereafter apply t>r let
ters dismissory. All creditors of
said estate will render their celsims
properly proven to the undersigned
on. or before said 12th day of (Oe
th.ber, 1908.
Laura C. Nichols,
Administratrix of the nersonal e.are
of Benjamin F. Nichols, decased.
4t-1taw.
POST CARDS that sold for 2 for 5
cents at 1 cent. Broaddus & Ruff.
SEE Broaddus & Ruff's Toilet Soap,
Box Paper. Talcum Powder, Dental
Powder. Tooth Brnshes. etc., be