The herald and news. (Newberry S.C.) 1903-1937, April 14, 1908, Page THREE, Image 3
1 t6e trouble at olemson
reviewed by mr. hoyt
Mr. James A. lloyt, the Co'lumbii
correspondent of the Charleston New
and Courier, spent several days a
Olemson college last week and sen
* his paper a very interesting and in
* Utructive article on the recen't trou
ble at the coillege. The article is ra
tlier lengthy but is well worth read
in g:
Clemson College, April 8.? '4 Wlia
is the matter at Olemson?"
This is the question which sine
the lirst day of this month the peo
pie of South Carolina, whose institu
tion Clemson college is, have beei
asking. It is a question that the;
have asked before, more than onci
And it is asked not with any forget
'j fulness of the great work for oducn
\ tion that Clemson is doing and ha
done, not with any disposition to dis
^ count the influence for progress ii
[ agriculture and the mechanic art
that the institution is exerting in th
commonwealth ^nd the south, but th
question is asked because there is re
gret that any trouble at Clemsoi
should impede this work.
Instructed to find out what is th
matter at Clemson, this correspond
ent came here and gave the president
commandant and others, in and out o
authority, to understand that what h
wanted to teU the people of the Stat
was the truth, the whole truth an
I nothing but the truth. It may not b
possible to tell the whole truth, it i
difficult still to get at 'the causes o
the recent trouble, but what is tol
, is related with the desire to tell notl
ing but the truth.
Tho Man of the Hour.
The principal trouble at Clemso
at present is the new commaiulai
and the boys have found that on
"When it comes to break inn' rules an
disregarding discipline they ha\
found that ('apt. >T. C. Minus is
very serious trouble. Tie is new f
the .job, but he is not new at this gam
r at all. In the first place Minus :
I a soldier. He is .just a soldier. 11
ought h> be a soldier, lie was c'duca
ed at the South Carolina Militai
^ Academy, then at "West Point, the
saw service in the Philippines and i
posts in the west. He applied for tl
position of commandant at Clemso
last, spring because, like every lovi
South Carolinian, he wanted to con
back to South Carolina. lie did n<
know what conditions here were, an
if he had perhaps he would not ha\
come, but having come he has done h
duty and he has bad really the chant
to serve his State. Because conditioi
at Clemson were serious. That avj
realized last June, if not before, ax
the retirement of Capt. ('lay brougl
it before the public. The farnoi
* 'shirt-tail" parade of last commenc
ment is not yet forgotten.
On the walls of the barra'cks as oi
strolls through lie can see this inscri
tion scribbled:
"."Who ran 01 ay? Class of 1907.'
And on April 1. 190S, the questit
[ may have been asked in the barrack
"Who will help run Minus?''' But tl
boys have discovered, if they did n
jU suspect it bofore, that Minus is n
r the running sort. He is still gtandii
bis ground and if he has to retreat
will be by the orders of his superioi
not of his own vi.lli'.oti.
The boys ai Clemson, loose iuvolvi
in (he April fool trouble as well
^ others, seem stunned and they do n
f talk much, even among ihemselv
about thai trouble. But since the lir
announcement from Uie disciplii
committee there has been a firm co
viction for the youthful soldier if the
was violation <*f rules he would' ;
home. F.ven before their cases we
passed on many of the boys pack*
their trunks and some went so far i
to openly apply for money to go horn
The effort to conquer Minns, if sin
an effort it was, has Turned into
victory for the youthful soldier of IT
cle Sam.
While the origin and purpose, if
had a purpose, of the outbreak is n
vet fathomed, there can be lititle don
that it was primarily intended lo te
Capt. Minus; t<> s,-e whether ho won
insist on punishment for violation
p rules and to see whether, if he. d
insist, tho president and authoriti
of the college would stand by hit
Other presidents and comman.lan
| have been sacrificed to the sluden
at Clemson in its brief history, and
now remains to be seen whether Pre
idenl Mell and Capt. Minus will 1
.offered up. The discipline committi
has stood firm, as have the preside!
and the commandant, but, of conrs
1 the board of trustees may yet have, r
opportunity to undo what is beii
H done. If tlrey do reverse the disr
WL piino committee conditions at Clci
mgS~ son will be worse than they have ovi
m been. Any one can sec thai an
K.' hence il is to be presumed that tl
Y trustees will not interfere.
Older members of the faculty thir
j that the present outbreak, if it ci
^
1)0 so called, is just a revival of the ]
. spirit which prompted the famous <
sophomore rebellion about eight years I
i ago, when the entire sophomore class ;
s declared it would leave it' one of its I
I members was disciplined for an alleg- <
c ed offense. By a close vote of the
- faculty the discipline was inflicted 1
- and the trustees on appeal reversed
- the faculty's action, reinstating the
- class. The merits of the original case j
were not clear and there were two
sides, but the ctTect of the trustees' '
action was to impair disciplin and th* (
influence of that action has been I
e henceforth feKt in the college. ]
Last year, when the commencement
- .parade was held and Capt. Clay as- !
I serted his authority, it was again felt '
y that discipline was not strictly en- I
!. 'forced by the higher authorities of the '
- college. While Capt. Clay is kindly
- referred to here by those who knew
s him, it is recognized that lie was not ?
- a consistent disciplinarian, that at
II times he was strict and at other times !
s lax, and the boys did not as a conse- '
e quence entertain for him the proper 1
e respect as commandant. When Capt. 1
Minus came here last L'all lie found i
ii himself the heir of the conditions 1
I which had grown up during a period
e oL years, but he also found a disposi|
tion ict give him a freer hand in tho ,
t, matter of discipline than his predecesf
sor liad had. The board of trustees
e passed a resolution declaring that thH
c commandant and discipline commitd
tee were to be the sole judges of mai*?
e ters of discipline , and that there
s would be no intereferenee J'rom thv?
f n't us tees. Of course, the adoption of
d this resolution is itself prima facie
i- "evidence thaft there had previously
been interference, and that the comman'dant
and faculty had not preu
viously had sufficient authority. At
lt the opening of school in the fall of
j 1007 Col. Alan Johnstone, president
of the board of trustees, came before
the new student body and in a speech
a characteristic of that forceful and
(t clear man told the students that this
resolution had been adopted and that
is they must expect to obey the orders
L'e of ilie faculty and commandant. Col.
(_ Johnstone in his expressive manner
y warned the boys tliat there was a
ii speed limit which must not be exit
('ceded. And in this present trouble
,e Col, Johnstone has lived up to his den
oalaration of last fall; lie has not by
nj even a word endeavored to interfere
ie with the faculty or commandant, or to
it otter a suggestion; he has not been
id here at all.
%
:e The discipline committee is eomposis
ed of the heads of the* different de?e
paiimcnts, the elder statesmen, as it.
is ~*vore, of the college empire. In thisis
matter they have been unanimous and1
id without any division have sustained >
i-t the commandant. Under live regal a-'
is tions matters of discipline art lePt ene
tirely with the commandant, mid it is
only when he decides to call in the
ve discipline committee that the commit p
tec passes on such matters.
f When the three hundred or more
boys left the campus on last Wedncs>n
day tlieir names were easily ascers
taineVl. In the first place, tjiey were
,e reported absent at morning drill, then
they were marked absent at fheir
classes "that day and were not 'to be
found at tliir rooms. It has been
asked why (he commandant did not
"s> refuse to let them enter the barracks
when the crowd returned from Pendiet
on last Wednesday afternoon. TTe
lls could have done so, hu'l did not for
at /east two reasons, In the first
OS
"t 1'^' 1,(1 dill not wish to deal with
i(i I he mob, but with individuals. Sec*
1 ond, he'wished to make a case against
each individual, so as to keep (he rec,.()
(l|'ds straight and have the evidence
*e in event of an appeal. Then he wcwita
?d to give every boy a fair show. So,
the matter was referred to (he disci-'
' pline co in mil tee and (lie commandant.'
i WMS IVildy to give the evidence against
I every boy whose name was called.
n_ livery "boy lias had an individual trial,
has had the chance (o say what Ire
.j. wished (o say in extenuation of his
. offense, and il lie desired, (o deny the
1^ whole filing, hut most of them have
sl owned up like men: in fact, all of
. . f iiem have done so, so far as is known,
nfj ' !,(> Juniors were examined and
id I ''''i'd first, and IS were dismissed last.
ps i Saturday. On Saturday the cases of
/ ? I'rc>hmcu were heard; on Mondav
jS their were 00 Sophomores and Kreshts
| men examined, ?no by one, and then
1*1 the rest of (lie oflending cadets were
s I before flic commit lev-, ffiargcs were
)0 | made against 1M0 Freshmen out of a
class of 2:t.S; -l.s out of 02 Juniors
|lt have been dismissed. None of the SO
Seniors look pari in fhe April Fool
in I1")' expedition. Tne tolal attendlsi.
ance at Hie college'at Ihis lime is 050,
half of which number arc implicated
n_ in I he f rouble.
er j Deliberate Judgment,
d To pass on all I hose cases has
)0 taken lime, but (Ik* delay does not
indicate nny disposition to waver or
>k any indecision whatever. Any boy
m who is dismiss^ has the right to ap
K'al t?.? tlie trustees and the ?Iisci|>1 i 11 o ly i
:*omini11has considered il advisable for
to make out each case fully, giving dun
it the same time a full opportunity tho
lo each accused hoy to answer in his, her
^>\\ n hehalt. There lias been no snap and
judgment; at the same time no weak- tori
less has been displayed. f,?x?
far as heard from the parents of wit
the dismissed hoys have taken the tie*
lotion af the authorities in fine spirit, a .p
just as the boys themselves have done, ed
There is no doubt in any mind on this dee
am pus that the display of firmness will
that has been given lias done the co'l- <xf
lege good'. On the other hand*, per- 1st
sons familiar with conditions at Clem- the
>011 do not /lesitate to say if linnness its
liad not been displayed at this crisis moi
the future of the college would h'ave thii
l)eon imperilled. tio:
An April fool lark is no serious tioi
ma titer ordinarily, brtt it is in this saf
?ase. There is no lasting disgrace at- the
I ached to it. nothing that carries a nil
sliirma of immorality through after- re a
lite. Hoys at oilier crtllcgcs have gon(l Ap
i)ll uii the first day uf April <md been tFon
none the worse for it. H?it conditions Ilia
:?l this college woiy -ucn on the llrsi: \v;i;
day of April. HlOS, (hal a violation of tim
I lie rules by a mob of the boys could
not be condoned. L:ist year practicalSTATEIV
OF
THE COMMERCIAL BANK
Under call of State Bank Exai
iness March 9
RESOURC
Loans and discounts
Overdrafts
Furniture and Fixtures
Cash
LI AB1L1T1I
Capital Stock
Undivided profits (less expenses p
Dividends (unpaid)
Cashier's Checks
Deposits, Banks """"""Ill
Deposits, Individual
JNO, M. KINARD', Pres.
J. Y, McFALL
4 per cent. Interest Paid in C
THE EXCHM
Newberr
In looking for a Bank tc
vou want to find a Safe
Bank, an Accommodatin
to consider this Bank ant
come in and open an acc
We Pay Interest or
J. D. Davenport.
President.
Edw. R. Hipp,
V. President.
G. B. Crom
We Lend
TC
Buy H
We provide easy terrny$
We enable borrowers??
in Monthly Installments,
allowed to meet obligatio
i It is cheaper than payin
to save money to buy a h
Contract.
If you want to save moi
take a Security Contract.
Call on A. J. Gibson, As
Treasurer, at office, corn
streets, next door to Oop
SECURITY LOAN AND
I lie vntire cadet corps cut classes 1
(he entire clay and nothing was
e. On previous April Tool days
usual pranks have been played
e with impunity. College banners
i" olass emblems have been mysously
allixcd to high places; a pro<or?s
staid cow has been saddled
h anoither professor's saddle and
I Id graze on the campus green;
rofessor's pony cart has been waftinto
his class room and used to
orate his classic desk. But boys
I be boys and the annual evidence
boyishness which is given on April
is no grave offence. But after
disorganization of lasft Juno and
"shirt-tail" parade any mob delist
rat ion at Clemson was a serious
ug. There was no definite indicaII
that an outbreak or demonstra1
would be made, buit to be on the
e side, and to prevent if possible
boys getting into trouble, the
i's forbidding such an cvodus were
d Io the corps the day before |1
ril Fool Day. This having been fj
ic, with I lie -express declaration H
it I he rule would be enforced, it L
squarely up lo the college anrities
when the exodus did take
(Continued on Page Six.) A
? I
1ENT
OF NEWBERRY, S. C.
niner at the close of bus- &
th, 1908. 5
ES H
$335,541 29 P
9,713 06 f
3,1 16 93
52,708 19
401,079 47 *
ss.
$ 50,000 00
aid) 48,958 32
1,2.47 00 1
1,236 24 s
...$ 1,202 71 I
. 298,435 20?299,637 91 1
$401,079 47 j
O. B. MAYER, Vice-Pres. c
, Cashier.
>ur Savings Department.
<6E BANK" i
y, S. C.
) receive your money,
Bank, a Convenient
g Bank* we want you
d satisfy yourself and
;ount with us.
i TTme Deposits.
M. L. Spearman,
Cashier.
W. B. Wallace,
Ass't Cashier.
er, Atty.
>
omesl
kgf payment, J
6 accumulate a fund j<
! 1
on which interest isj j
>ns at maturity. A
g rent. If you want j r
ome take a Security j *
ney for any purpose c
It pays,
>stant Secretary and
er Boyce and Adams
eland Brothers.
INVESTMENT 89, L
omrtiix, a.o. 11
9
| ABO
With a Bank A
And that account drawing in
bigger all the time, feels inor<
the boy who spends every nie
jfts it comes to him. The I
money when other boys are
(Strengthening that will powe
I'liini as a man to be a sober, st
'l
'while others become drunkan
i On Savings Depositsw
!' Semi-Annin
Tile Bank of \
Pi osperit}
DR. GKO. V. IIUNTKR, V
President.
J. K. RROWNlv, J
Cashier.
NATIONAL BANK OF
11 I 1 g
"AIN'T NO USE, HILL, IT':
A repository in which yoi
>osited, and maybe your vah
trong enough to resist the
Entrust them to us. They 1
With an account opened wi
:heck, thereby insuring accui
nethods of keeping account!
:onvenience and safeguard fo
DIRECT!
. A. Carlisle. H. C. Moi
F. A. Blackwelder. Robt. No
3. C. Matthews. S. B, Aull
YOUR BA
THE NEWOEIIRY 5
Capital $50,000
No Matter How Small,
The Newberry S
will give it caroful aUor
applies to the men and th
JAS. MciNTOSH.
President,
w.r??>^cv^.>T?TTMrTTI |||W||,|n ||H| |||||MB fm m
rtTo. eo
Tlie People's i
Prosperitv
3aid Up Capita?
Surplus and individual P*
Stockhol rJersp Li abilit.ies
-or protection of depof-i'<
-I. C. Moseley. President. V.
V. W. Wheeler, Cashier. Geo
Better a conservative interest
eturn when v/anted, than a high xt
ibout the principal.
A National Bank. Is a snfe Deposl
nakes it so. Likewise our Board
>f prudent conservative manageme
DI RECTO
G. W. Bowers. \
J. A. C. Klbler. v
R. L. Luther. ^
M. A. Carlisle. (
J. H. Hunter. 1
J. P. Bov
Ne allow 4 per cent, per a
Department, interest pa>
:sb3W??*
\
Y
ccount,
tercst and getting '
; like a man than
kel he gets as soon
loy who can save
spending theirs is
r which will enable
eady, business man,
Is and spendthrifts.
re pay 4 pr. ct.
illy.
Prosperity,
S. C. a
>R. J. 8. WIIKKIJCR, ' I
\'. President. M
. A. COUNTS. I'
Assistant Cashier. |]
NEWBERRY S. C
fO g
S BURGLAR PROOF."
i have your money deux
bles stored, should he
attacks of the burglar.
will be absolutely safe,
th us you can pay by
racy and system in your
5. There is no greater
r handling money than
^OOTTHSTT.
3RS:
seley. T. B. Carlisle.
rris. Geo. Johnstone.
I. Jos. II. Hunter.
L.NKING!
SAVINGS BANK.
Surplus $30,000
Matter How Large,,
Savings Bank
ition. This message
ie women alike,
J. B. NORWOOD,
Carrier.
mma I
uiiono! Oaiik
8. C.
- T??!V100 OO
'ofits T-G,000 OO
. $25,000 00
>?s.
A. Cap.! ir;t r?, Vice-President
>. >ni-, Attorney.
o:i your deposit with Its safe
ile and <) leellng of doubt
It. Government supervision
of Directors Is a guarantee
nt.
RS:
V. P. Pugh.
Jno. B. ellers.
vV. A. Moseley.
jeo, Johnstone,
C. Moseley.
for s.
nnum In our Savings
able semi-annually