The herald and news. (Newberry S.C.) 1903-1937, January 31, 1908, Image 1
VOL XLV NO 9 NEWBERRY) S. C., IFPIDAY, JANUARY 31. 1908. TIEAWE.$.0AYA
DISPEN~SARY AFFAIRS
IN THE LEGISLATURE
SENATOR BLEASE WINS FIGHT
AGAINST ADMINISTRATION.
Railro,ad Measures Considered-Pro
hibition Bill In The House-Oth
er Matters.
Special to The Herald and News.
Columbia. Jan. 30.-The feature of
the legislative proceedings this week
so far is the senate's refusal to pass
the resolution asked for by Gov. An
sel, on the suggestion of Attorney
General Lyon. in regard to the status
of the dispensary funds. Senator
Blease. who opposed Gcv. Ansel last
summer led the fight against this res
olution in the senate, and he had the
support of other senators. who made
legai arguments against the measure.
The governor on Tuesday sent in a
special message suggesting the pas
'sage of a resolution declaring that in
providing for the commission to wind
up the state dispensary the general
assembly did not intend to create a
trust fund but that the commission is
the agent of the State, and also ap
proving the course the commission
has pursued in looking into the claims
against the dispensary. The house at
once. upon explanation that the reso
lution was desired to assist the attor
ney general in proceedings pending in
the federal court at Asheville, passed
the resolution asked for by the gov
ernor, but in the senate the objection.
of Senator Blease to immediate -con
sideration was under the rules suf
ficient to carry it vore for one day
-and on Wednesday the Newberry sen
ator renewed the fight. The resolu
tion was by consent amended so as to
-ut out the 'endorsement of the com
mission and then it was thought it
would pass but the motion to table
was carried by a vote of 19 to 1S. Fol
lowing is the report of .Senator
Blease'.; speech taken from the Co
- umbia State:
"Senator Blease was recognized by
the chair and made a lengthy speech
in opposition to the measure. He had
before him a number of newspaper
clippings and other papers and an
nounced that he was prepared to make
some very interesting showings and
hoped the senators would pay special
attention to the reading of tihe news
paper cilppings.
"He stated. however, before begin
ning his argument against the resolu
tion that he would be glad to have it
go over as he felt that there were oth
er mat ters of importance on the cal
endar which siould be disposed of.
and be warned the senate that no lit
tie t'me wonld be co'nsumred in consid
ering this resolution. This suggestion
was not acceptable. and the senator
from Newberry proceeded.
"He said that 'he was opposed to
resolution on a number of grounds.
In the first place he considered it an
:attempt to whitewash the disepnsary
commission; there had been charges
madie against the commission and it
ill-'behoored the general assembly at
t.his time to pass a resolution comn
mending the commission in everything
they had done; as for himself he was
not willing to commend the commis
sion and he thought that if the senate
investigated matters some they would
oppose this resolution.
"He said that Governor Ansel 'had
turned out of office the members of
the former board of directors-Raw
linson. Black and Wylie-and now
the lea'islature is asked to set its seal
of approval upon the members of the!
State dispensary commission for do
ing what the directors were condemn
ed for doing. referring to the accep
tance of the Clark-c pure-hase of liquor
Tt was charged that the board had
pur'?hased these licuors from Clarke
Bros. & Co.- illegally and the general
assembly passed a resolution asking
the g'overnor to take some action. and
as a result the governor turned the
members of the 'board out of office.
The commission later accepted these
same goods which th.e lezislature hadI
decided were purehased illegally and
no0w it is .p)roposed to en iorse the ac
tion of the commission. He declared
that it was not right-that if the
mis' Iia .1dc '' ila w 'i 2.1 li .:2 v 'el
amii y :t :efud: the hands1t11 1
'f the e:mmisi1. were deposited in
a t lun1 l1 a baik, of which 1r. Mur- i+
ray. clairnian of the colnussion, is a e,
directo;r. Thiere had been other chiarg- t!I
es against the commission and he t
thought a mistake would be made in 1b
passing such a resolution as is propos- a
ed. He said that the adoption of this $
resolution would be nothing less than e,
a slap in the face of Judge, Pritchard, e:
and would undoubtedly be so con- it
slreed by him.
"He said that a governor, with a ti
'hackbone. having removed one set of o
offieers for doing a thin- declared to ii
be ille nl. would have removel an
other set of men for Committing the
same oilense.
Senator Blease followed up his sig- S
:l victory over the administration
by a ie''Ution ea!'if* for all pa
,,er1s ad .I1 ":;e< ondonee l i .:r1 111 :th mat
t ' t ; i: )tanc. 1 :he m mis- .8
si+n ot the (elebrat.'d larke Brose
I -.V ' will be reea0 1':' 1 la.t
s in ?:, :en:eral a":.a.:1b- ly '> .is re o ;
it:1.a i1r:tl led that the worsa e
jiot he:i theal State.board of control *
for their action in purchain, a lar'O "
t1. [t. wi.k , it was c'lain.o ilI gal
lv. from Clarke Bros. & Co., of 1
Peoria, Ill.. and that subs. nuentlv tih" 1
ComI1lssit'n to wind up the dispen- tl
sarv acce'ied the whis.key in ques- '
tiol, which had been pronounced unlfit. tl
Senator Blease now wants to have tire
correspondence a:bouf this matter ti
placed before the senate. It was stat
ed in the senate that the commission's
action was taken because of the pro- P
mise of the Clarke concern to give t
what evidence it mi!rht have as to
g.,aft in the State dispensary's con
duct and Senator Blease said this was t
bribery. Following is th resolution
by Senator Blease: a
u:
"Be it resolved. by the senate of
South Ciarolina. the house of repres
entatives concurring:
"-That the commission appointed to
wind up the affairs of the State dis
pensary be and they are hereby re
quested to furnish to this general as
-embly a report of all of their deal
ingis with the Clarke purchase of
whiskey and that they furnish copies
of their correspondence with Messrs.
Hull and Dudley of the Clarke conm
pany. especia lly the correspon.:deuce
and tranlsactions between the chair
man of said board and Mr. Dudley.'' bi
Prhibition is theC pending issue be
fore tile house. Tihe Xash bill may
be voted on today, as it was under dis
o.nesion when the hour arrived yes-n
terdav for the memorial exercises inE
'onor1 of the late MessrS. J. M. Epting..
of Lexingttoin. and W. F. McArthur of
Cherokee. both of whom have died
sh:ee the last sessioPn. Mr. Nash made 5,
a strong argumenlt for prohibition e
yesterday when his bill was brought a
up. and he was support by Mr. D. I..
Smith, of Colleton: Mr. Morrell, of ~
m
Another of Mr. Nash's bills, to es- - b(
tablish the department of insurance Iar
with a commissioner has been k-illed h<i
by the house, the vote being 48 to 33. e
Practically the same bill has 'been fa
aain introduced. jre
The bill of Mr. Hydrick, to require~ pc
the existence of crops to make a mort- Ito
age thereon va.lid, was passed by a ju
vote of 57 to 45. This is intended lu
o supplement the repeal of the lien
law, for which the house has voted.
Tihe bill of Mr. Gyles, of Aiken, to
nermit an election in Aiken on the Pi
dispensary in April passed the house,I
after a discussion of the conditions
in that county by members of the Aik
en del'egation. Mr'. Croft wanted the Si
election in August but the bill as
drawn passed. being amended so as re
to include Colleton also. to
The senate has considered several
rairoad measures this week. Senator Itr;
Graydon' b 1ill to prohibit th e runnIinUe
of doule hleaders was passed. by a fu
vote of 19 to 10, and his bill to extend an
the law as to contributory negligence s.n'
was naseed, after being anmended so
as to apply only to common car
ier:s. The bill by Mr. Kershar;. which or
passed the house last year. to estab- i
lish a State board of examination fors<
railroad telegraphi operators was kill- la~
ed by the senate, tihe vote being 15 1)0
to 14. th
11 ' f* o' l( j no r lIrmnlers. '.'(e resEnlltin:.
,t1s co:t:idet th" 'talte 11nd. solic"it
I lrdler= i:1 this State. er lted( 1
t deal of discussion. It war
im:ht on the ground thAt it was un
ustitillonal and also that it was
k entering wedge for a license svs
~.. It was however finally passed.
v a vote of 21 to 11. being first
nended so as to make the license
.000 instead of .$1.000, as propos
I by Mr. Appelt. and also so as to
cem)t Marlboro and Lancaster from
s provisions. The license is to be
sued by the county treasurer, and
eo prpose of the bill is to stop the
rations of the whiskey drummers
this State.
DENOUNCED AS LIE.
enator Blease On Floor of Senate
Calls Attention to Inaccuracy of
Augusta Chronicle.
pecial to The Herald and News.
('oltunbia. Jan. 30.-The Augusta
b1roniele of Wednesdav. in speakinu
the resolution, referred to in an
her column of The Herald and News,
endorsing the work of the winding
ci:immission and its efforts to have
w liquor houses produce their books
order to aid the commission in
obing 'for graft. and saying that
e funds of the commission are held
the commission as the property of
e State, and tha:t it was not intend
t that the State should be sued
rough the commission". said:
"Tlie resolution passed the house
ithout a dissenting voice. but its
ssage was blocked in the senate by
e objection of Senator Blease, of
ewberry, the law partner of ex-Di
etor Hub Evans. Mr. Blease saying
at the commission itself should be
vestigated as to certain charges
"ainst it. The resolution went over
ider the rules till tomorrow. Friends
the reselation say it will pass the
nate tomorrow by an overwhelming
ajority. When it is passed its text
ill probalbly be wired to Asheville.'
This article appeared under the
me of W. T. McCaw, manager
ironiele Bureaa at Columbia.
In the senate today senator Blease
a1 the above extract from the Co
nhia correzpondeuce of the Augusta
1roniele, and said:
'"Now.- Mr. President, if I were
eaking of this report off of this
>or I would denounce it differently,
heiie - I am reminded th:..t J can use
mvsuch lancguaiie as I could in the
nreh. So TF will say the report is
absolute lie: that the only busi
~ss connection I ever h-ad with M-r.
~aus was attending to a law suit
~d ie p)aid me my fee. I have only
id one other t ransaction in which
was interested, and that is defend
ghis urother-in-law, who is charg
with murder, and Mr. Evans did
t pay me a cent of that fee, but it
~s paid by his brother-in-law. I do
~t presenit Mr. Evans or any other
an connee;ted now, or who has ever
en connected with th~e dispensary,
d do not represent any whiskey
use in any manner or form whatso
er, but I am' doing what I do here
r the interest of th-e people I rep
sent, and I can not see why this re
rt was sent out, except to attempt
do me a political and personal in
ry. And it is, as I said, an abso
te lie. '.'
NASH BILL KTTJLJD.
-ohibition Measure Dies in House
Labor Contract Law Passes
House.
eial to The Herald and News.
Columbia, Jan. 20.-The house of
presentatives today, by a vote of 61
52, killed the Nash prohibition bill.
The house pase the labor con
it liw rec-ommnended by the judi
try committee which is printed in
11 in another column of The Herald
d Naws today. This bill will now
to the senate.
Thei Naeie Maniufaeturing Co.,
>re all next week who w'll show vou
w to bake ''iseuits. brown top and
ttom. in three minutes. Don't miss
s ehance of seeing the g-reat cook
SROFT ENDORSED.
Resolution Unanimously Adopted by
Aiken Board of Trade.
At a me:ting of the Aiken board
of t ra(i the following resolution en
df)rsing Mr. T. G. Croft's actions hi
the North, Augusta dispensary mat
ter was unanimously adopted:
"'That the thanks of the people of
Aiken and the board of trade be ex
tended to Hon. T. G. Croft for the
eredita'ble position he has taken in
1 the defen., (f the people of Aiken
crunty and in resenting tir.2 imper
tinent interference of the petoi. .;"l
eity of Augus.a in the affais f th
people of iSouth Carolina.'
CROFT DENIES ALLEGATIONS
The di-. tehes froi, A nu-t 4 pub
lished in the South Carolina papers
on the dispensary in North Augusta
caused Representative Croft to rise
to a question of personal privileg2
and vi2orously to denounce certain
reflections which he said had been
easteupon him.
Last week'when Mr. Lane of Marl
boro had iassed a resolution con
demning the action of the Aiken
county hnard. in -etablishing the
dispensary at North Augusta, as un
democratie, Mr. 'Croft. who was out
of the house at the time, had the
resolution recalled later and taken
from the record. In the course of
his remarks Mr. :Croflt said that he
had as attorney represented to the
Aiken, found that the dispensary
should be established and that cer
eain ministers had state- that while
\they were willing for a dispensary
to be established at Hampton Ter
race hotel they were not willing for
it to 'be established in the town of
North Augusta.
It was this statement that caused
a. dispatch to be sent out from Au
zusta stating that the ministers of
Augusta. were indignant and would
send a conmmitteee to Columbia, at
the same time charging that Mr.
Croft was a representative of liquor
interests.
Mr. Croft~ said that he l?ad been
grossly misrepresented in these dis
patehes, and he would have liked
very much to have faved this Au
gusta committee, which at the last
moment failed to turn up. He wish
ed to say that he represented no
liquor interests, that he had appeared
befo:e the 'board without even ac
cepti:ng a fee, although he would
have been justified in taking one for
his legal work, and any
statement to the contrary could be
nothing but a adliberate lie. The
Auznsta interests had. shown them
selves decidedly lacking in courtesy.
to say the least, in the statements
they have sent out to prejudice the
zeneral assembly.
Mr. Croft th m read statements
form the :Aiken papers, avhich he
said ha.d been written by a prohibi
tionist, which substantiate his posi
tion and he presented affidavits along
the same~ line.
Afterwards the house.passed a res
olution endorsing the statement made
by the Aiken representative and ex
onerating him..
GOV. GLBNN "MAR.K'' MAN.
Roanoke. Va.. Jan. 27.--Much -ex
eilent nt was create-d in a hotel at
Bluefield last night when a man from
Ohio offered to bet $1,000 to $10 that
(Tov. Glenn of North 'Carolina would
he,~ assassinated before next Christ
mas hecanse of the stand he has ta
ken in thes (fiht against the rail
oadsL-. There were no takers. Tire
man claims that he had no informa
tion tha.t would lead him to believe
that a plot had been laid to kill
Gov. Glenn. Gov. Glenn has been
notified of the man's -bet that the
executi,vei swould .not Sive till next'
Christmas.
NOT A CANDIDATE FOR SENATE
Atlanta. fla.. Jan. 2.-Gov. Hoke
Smth issued a formal statement late
t'rv. announeing that he would not
: a cand:(date for- the Unitedi Statas
se -te to succeed Senator A. S. Clav.
His statement also de.lar?d ihat he
would run for a second term for
ovrnor in order to finish the work
whi.he pledg-ed in his platfor.m.
1PRITCHARD REFUSES
TO NAME RECEIVER
DENIES PETITION OF FLEISCH
MANN & CO.
The Question of Jurisdiction the On
ly Matter Considered In Dis
pensary Matter.
-Columbia State.
Asheville, N. C., -Jan. 29.-Judge
Pritchard in the United States circuit
court today denied the petition of
Fleischmann & Co. of New York and
refused to appoint a receiver for the
South Carolina dispensary fund of
$800,000, against which there are al
leged to be claims aggregating $600,
000.
The judge made his announcement
during the afternoon session, after at
torneys for the dispensary commis
sion had presented their bill in an
swer to the sensational charges made
in the Fleischmann petition, which
was filed in this court a short time
ago.
The answer alleges tha. the claim
of Fleischmann & Co. is unjust and
invalid and that there was collusion
and conspiracy between the plaintiff
an anotier firm to defraud the State
and that the State was cheated out
I of a large sum of money in each of
the claims made by the plaintiff; it
also alleges that Fleischmann & Co.
sold to the State a concoction with a
mere trace of whiskey.
The answer declared false the al
legation by Fleischmann & Co. that
the commissioners were wrongfully
withholding the money for their own
individual interests. The answer de
nied as false and malicious the al
legation in the complainr which re
ferred to a conspiracy between Attor
ney General Lyon and the dispensary
commission and demanded proof.
Affidavits Read and Filed.
At the conclusion of the reading of
the bill, a number of affidavits. on be
half of the defendants, were read and
filed.
Shortly after the court convened for
the afternoon session Jud:;e Pritchard
announced from the bench that lie
would not appoint a receiver for the
dispensary. as he felt that the funds
are now. fully pre'teeted. He directed
the attorneys to confine their argu
mients to the question as to -sheiher
this court could assume jurisdiction,
the point being whethe.r t.r not this
is a suit against the State. Mr. D. L.
Rountree of At.lanta, for the commis
sion, consumed the remainder of the
Iaft'rnooni session in argzamenit t4 es
tablish the fact t'ha' the Stat~e is an
indiepensable party to th'e suit.
Ben.re the liill ofI the dlefen1dauts
was read. Attorney General Lyon of
South Carolina resplied to the alle
gations made by Fleischmnann & Co.,
relative to the transfer of funds from
the jurisdiction of the court, saying
that the State of South Carolina was
not running away, that the allega
tion was false. He read a concurrent
resolution adopted by the house of
representatives of South Carolina yes
terday. In the course of the resolu
tion it was stated that the legislatuire
of South Carolina, in creating the dis
pensary comission did not consent to
suits against the State for claims
as a result of the dispensary muddle.
Lyon and Lester Clash.
Just befr.re Judge Pritehard an
nounced his daeision there was a sharp
colloquy between Attorney General
Lyon of South Carolina and George
B. Lester of New York and Alf. S.
Barnard. who .represent Fleischmann
& Co. Mr. Barnard asked for time to
prepare answers to lie dffidavits of
the commissioni.
He stated thiat the commission had
invited creditors to come to Colum
bia to prove their claims. But at the
sar.e time it was known that some 50
or (30 warrants were ready in the of
fi"e of the attorney 2'eneral on which
the representatives of the creditors
wuld b)e a :reted, and instareed the
e:: / th re'presenitative for Ull
mi 1 -> '.. who had been arrested,
e'1 ret(d Vi t h fraudl and r'e'uir'ed to
h'" I :v honid.
Judge Pritehard remar'ked that if
he took juri sdiction lie would appoint
a ma'ata' to sii: all c.harges of fraud
to the bottom.
The attorney general in reply to
Mr. Barnard said: "Of course we
hear this cry from those who have de
frauded the State. Naturally." When
I can catch any of these fellows in
South Carolina, I will arrest them. I
have no. warrant, however, for the
Fleisehmann representatives and I
will agree that they shail coma to
South Carolina to prove their claims
and depart unmolested." He added,
however, that there was a warrant
for the representatives of the Anheu
ser-Busch concern.
'IIr. Mordecai responded that Mr.
Farnum, the man referred to, had
left the State on business. But he
woald return and meet all charges.
Mr. Stevenson, counsel for the com
mission, stated there was ) intention
of inveighling men of South Carolina
for the purpose of prosecution.
No Receivership.
Judge Pritchard then announced
that no receiver would be appointed
and argument on jurisdiction was then
he.an 'by 'Mr. Rountree.
Among' the out-of-town attorneys
here interested in litigation now or
before Jud,e Pritchard are Attorney
General J. Fraser Lyon of South
Carolina. W. F. Stevenson of Cherar,
former speaker of the house of the
'South Carolina legislature; B. L. Ab
ney of Columbia, Mr. Rountree of At
lanta. Mr. A. L. Gaston of Chester,
Mr. W. T. Ayeoek of Columbia, T.
Moultrie '_ordecai of Charleston and
Mr. Geo. B. Lester. Dr. W. J. Mur
ray. chairman of the State dispen
sary commission, is also here.
NEXT PRESIDENT IS "BILL."
So it Was Whispered in the Nation
al Capitol.-Bryan and Taft
Present.
A special from Washington to the
Columbia State says:
"The next president of the United
States is nonw in the .dpitol," was
whispered about today.
"Who?"
"Well, his name is Bil!."
There were two Bills on the house -
side--Bill Taft and Bill -Bryan.
They did not meet, but ihey were
both jollying and being jollied. Mr.
Bryan spent a few moments in the
press gal'lery where the correspond
ents had a little seance with him.
He said he' would not go upon the
floor because the lobbies were ample
for. his purposes.
"Have you seen that commlitte'e
from New York who came down to
ask you :not to. run for the nomina
Ition?~" some one asked.
Mr. Bryan lau.thed..
.'"I have been siting up late at
ni'-hts, and 'knowing that the Wall
street mag'nates are accustomed to.
:ret up early I arose this morning at
I7 o 'clock and hurriedly dressed so as
to be ready to receive that commit
tee but they have not shown up."
The idea of any conference for th3
purpose of asking Bryan to withdraw
seems to be unanimously hooted at
today. A prominent Democrat told
me he did not believe there was 'a
man to be found aliout Washington
'who could 'be dragged to'Mr. Bryan
with a yoke of steers to tell him that
he should withdraw.
The Neraskan is triumphant and
dominant. He diied ' t'onight with
Senator Newlands and a numbar, of
senators and politics was tailked, but
no one 'here now h'as any serious no
tion of the Denver eohvention 's eon
sidering any one else- than Bryan.
There is talk of Harmon or Gray
for second place.
SERIOUS FIRE AT HAMPTON.
Hampton, Jan. 27.-One cf th'a
most disastrous fires that has 'ever
visited~ Hampton occurred last night
between 10 and 11 o'cloek, totally
destroying the tbuilding, presses and
nearly all of the material of th'e
Ha.mnion County Guardian, .own'ed
by 'Ex-Governor Myles B. MeSwee
nev. the omeies of Robert R. Sizer
&'co.. owned by Senator W. S.
L.h t wo small stores and two
small 'dwellings, on ILae avenue, the
principal street. 'The loss is estima
ted at $10,000. About half of this
is covered 'by insurance. 'The fire
originated in one of th'e small build
ings, and its origin is unknown.