The times and democrat. (Orangeburg, S.C.) 1881-current, February 24, 1904, Supplement The Times and Democrat, Image 11
It out. From its appearance it looked
to me as it* some one had used some
kind of bar to prize it loose. The work
had the appearance of being well done.
I remain, Yours, very truly,
Columbia Plumbing and Cornice
Works,
H. B. Chapman, Manager.
Telegram:
Columbia. S. C. Feb. 18,1904.
A. C. Dover. Ocala, F1&.
Did the State house roof show flash
ings wert; torn out when you examined
it?
(Signed) Frank P. Milburn.
Telegram:
Ocala, Fla.. Feb. 18,1904.
Frank P. Milburn. Architect.
Yes, some half dozen places absolute
ly pulled away from wall.
(Signed) A. C. Dover.
Columbia. S. C, Feb. 15, 1904.
Mr. Frank P. Milburn.
Dear Sir: 1 am a native of Georgia,
but now a resident of Charlotte. N. C.
I am a practical cornice and metal and
sheet worker, with '12 years actual ex
perience.
i did a great deal of work on the
State capitol at Columbia: had charge
of the sheet metal work of the inner
dome and the outer dome, and also
the guttering, and the same was put In
according to the plans and details for
the same, by experienced workmen, in
a good, workmanlike manner. I have
read the published testimony of Mr.
Hunt relating to my work, and the
same is In the main not true.
I have this day been on the roof and
examined the dome and gutters. The
Hour of the lantern of the dome has
been badly abused since the work was
completed and accepted. There have
been holes made in the copper, which
cause leaks in the inner dome. There
is now a piece of timber there with
nails in it, which might cause some of
the holes noted.
As to the guttering, the statement of
Mr. Hunt is generally not true. They
are made of Merchant's old method IX
tin, which is the standard of America,
and proper material for that particular
work. It rests on a granite foundation
and has all the protection necessary.
After three years use it is in perfect
condition.
I have had large experience with
roofs, and have been familiar with this
roof, off and on. since It was put on.
In this matter, again the testimony of;
Mr. Hunt is largely untrue, it is as-,
phalt and gravel, and not tar and
gravel. None of the stone used in Its 1
construction were one and a half or I
two inches, and the little slipping noted
is only some slight excess of material,
as is common to such roofs.
The cost of metal ceilings in 1901 and
1902 was very much less than it was
in 18S9, because of progressive ideas
and methods in this kind of business
and prices of material. Al hough I had
no interest in the ceiling of the main
lobby or elsewhere, my work was near
it. and I had conversation with Mr.
Unkefer about same, and'I know that
the new ceiling cost more than it would
have cost to repair the old one, but to
fix the old one would require the im
portation of special expert metal work- i
ers, and a great deal of time, which
would have resulted in inconvenience
to the legislature.
Yours truly.
(Signed) G. G. Ray.
?To Whom it May Concern:
Gentlemen: I have read with sur
price Capt Hunt's testimony in re
?gard to the roofing applied to the S*ate ;
house, and have the following to - ib
mit: i
The roofing on -this building is what I
is known as "Warren's Anchor Brand, i
Natural Asphalt Roofing," and was ap- '
plied by the "Charlotte Roof and Pav- ''?
ing company" of Charlotte, N. C, ac
cording to the plans and specifications
adopted by the Warren Chemical and |
Manufacturing company of New York
city. This roof is what is known as !
our "Standard Anchor Brand Asphalt
Roofing." and has- been applied accord- I
ing to our plans and specifications. It |
contains no coal tar, or coal tar prod
Ucts, and is composed out of asphalt
throughout. In reference to Capt. ?
Hunt's assertion that the roof is of lit- !
tie or no value, i might state that |
while there are some leaks in the roof, I
these leaks arc occasioned, not through -
the fault of the rooting, but for other
reasons not in the rooting contract.
Now. the pitch of this root, as nearly
as I can ascertain, is about four inches;
to the foot, and the rooting is well j
adapted to this class of construction: '
in fact we do nut hesitate to advocate,
and furthermore to apply this roof- ?
ing on buildings whose roofs have a
pitch of (6) six inches and upwards to
the foot. The crushed quartz used for
the graveling surface is such as wi!J)
pass through a mesh from 5-16 inch to ?
l-'l inch in size, and I am at a loss to
understand how Capt. Hunt can say 1
that he was able to find stones as big,'
as pigeon's eggs, or the size of a man's
hand. 1 submit the above testimony in;
defense of the Anchor Brand Rooting,;
which has been a Hacked by Capt.
Hunt, and trust it will be accepted as
such.
(Signed) Walter If. Harris. ,
Representing Warren chemical and i
Manufacturing company, 17 Battery
Place. N<yv York city.
I notified the Charlotte Roof and
Taving company repeatedly to send
men to repair this roof. They sent j
men more than once, but finally Mr. j
Inner, the manager, told me that some;
one was- tampering with the roof and 1
that be thought that water was run
ning through the copper work and
around the windows. It is a fact that 1
some of the frames and sash were i
blown in during a severe windstorm
last summer, and uore than likely this
accounts for sou;- of the leaking com
plained of. Mr. Ray informed me that ,
holes had been punched in the cupped
dome. I cannot say ;is to this, but;
J do know that people wen- permitted !
to go and conn- at will.
On t\\:i or more occasions I sen; my
men to inspect tie- roof after it was
reported t. that it had leaked. They
reported that a scuttle, which is about
three or four feet square, was left off:
and one time both scuttles were off.
I required that the roofing contract
ors give a guarantee for Hi years,
vhicb fully protected tie- State's in
terests. !
The committee say that a fine slate
roof wa.-- torn off' which cost the State
a great amount of money, and they
further say thai it afforded perfect pro
tection. Rut tle-y did liol produce a
single witness to prove these assertions.
Who told them? The absurdity of the.
statement is proved by the fact that
the principal argument used in gel
ting the appropriation for the improve
ments v as thai "the roof was full of
holes and leaked like a seive." Resides
being old an-! worthless as a roof, there
was a very ?mall portion of the slate
on ib.- roof, only thai -'it that could
be seen from tie- ground?thai is. tie
Steep maiiK.-ird-- th.- rest was of copper
and ?.is sold f(M" junk.
Wighth. Numerous objections to the
dome which are so disconnected as to
necessitate somewhat of a genera! re
ply.
Ii should be clearly understood that
1 originally planned for the construc
tion of this dome of cast steel, just 'il>e
th' mate!;,:! a.-- d for th.- dome of t.'ic
capitol Washington. r0|. Marshall
obji-etc,| -,<? tiii-.. and the commission,
as I believe, largely influenced by its
desire t.> satisfy him. directed tie
chance i,i granite. This ?hange noces
? si tute ?! ., greatly increased load, and I
not only carefully considered the
?"'.renath of th-- main building to sup
T'Oi-.t it but. al my own exuense. had
the j? >t expert in this lino t" make an
exam\jiiaU,,n ami calculation of the
ju??m-'V.i,. ,,,, [j,,. masonry, of the pro
j.os.-,i i ..... .... i flu? proposed
change-a V\as feasible, but instead
of snp's.ii t h:.; i(ie dome OH two
St<>vt to--, .is titsi designed. i
bad K. ( ,.: f...-- :.ug-- box M-..|
gii iers. .\:,| i?< n used the thick
ness of al.'. that metal. The expert
I
referred to said, "We jw-e satisfied that I
I there is no question as to the strength
j of this revised design." With this
change it became necessary to give
greater pitch to the roof than origi
nally intended, and to make numerous
modifications and changes in the spec
ifications and detail drawings for the
work. For instance, the change in
pitch of the roof obviated the necessity
for the ventilators shown in the orig
inal plans, which would have been un
sightly thereon. The modified and re
vised drawings for this portion of the
work are still on file in my office and
1 could have been seen by "the investi
gating committee and their "expert"J
j ha?? they so desired.
It is charged that the window frames I
of the dome do not fit. This appear-j
ante is no doubt caused by the fact j
that some of them were blown in dur
ing a severe storm last summer.
Again, that there are kinks and
crimps in the galvanized iron of the
inner dome. Hut these are no doubt
due to natural expansion ami contrac-'
tion.
Again that some stones on the out-1
side of the dome are too short, and the
contractors filled up the spaces. Now, i
the fact is, you cannot keep the water
out of a close joint of stones: there!
must be space enough to calk and ce
ment, and it is necessary at that point.
It must be understood that the little
water oozing past the cement swells
the oakum and this makes the joint
water proof.
t:ut the great bulk of criticism I
of tha work on the dome is that j
b Is not according to plans and;
specifications, and that the ohms!
actually used are not what they
should be. It is true that much of it|
Is not according to the drawings and]
specifications seen by the committee j
and their expert, but are a substantial]
complance with the modified drawings]
and detailed working plans. As to the i
criticism by Mr. Hunt and the commit-1
tee of the plans as changed and actu- ;
ally carried out. I insist that neither
this contractor nor this committee are i
competent judges. Surely the members
of the committee art- no better able to
judge of the work, at this time, than
were the members of the capitol com
mission, who saw the work as it pro
gressed and when it was completed and
accepted.
Ninth. That the wood truss under
the portico roof, culled for by the draw
ings. is absent.
After the commission decided to!
omit the two columns before referred
to, the wood truss was no longer prop
er, the drawings were changed and
steel trussed perl Ins substituted, span
ning the portico the shortest way.
And here again the committee under
takes to criticise the use of built up
sections, as called for by the draw' gs,
instead of expensive solid stones, in
deed, they criticise everything except t
the contract price, which every body
knows was very low.
Ten'h. That a sheet of galvanized
iron 1-32 of an inch thick is all there
is between the interior of the building
and the "wide, wide world."
These gutters are not galvanized iron,
but the best quality of IX tin. which is
the best gutter lining that can be used.
Copper lasts longer, but the expansion
is too great. These gutters, which are
of the usual thickness .for ths class of,
work, are painted on the under side,
caulked with lead in the ston;> and the
gutter bed lays flat on the stone cor
nice.
Eleventh. That one of the large lin
tel stones in the rear portico Is cracked,
this being the last of the specific
charges which is numbered.
This stone showed no defect when
the work was accepted, but has bro
ken since then I do not believe it is
likely to "give away." Apparently per
fect stones will sometimes crack in a^
building and cannot be guarded!
against. The committee could have]
easily found evidence of this fact, had .
they desired it. in several large stone,
on the east side of the building, which'
are cracked and broken, as is also a I
very large stone on the south side
near tin; west corner.
Next: That the contractors did not]
protect the interior of the building dur- ;
Ing tb.e work.
Ii is almost impossible tu fully pro-,
tect a building during repairs and
changes and lei the occupants remain'
inside- its is not like an unoccupied j
building. I could not. and did not.
undertake to prescribe just how the
contractors should protect the old
work, ami they claimed 10 the commis- i
slon that they had done all they could j
do to that end.
In this connection it must be remem
bered that many of the stains from;
leaks in different parts of the buUdlug j
were there before the work under in-;
vestfgation begun.
Next: As to the cement floors and,
water leaking from above.
Only one day last month I was sur
prised to see so much water in the
passageway under the front portico,
as it had not rain<-d for several days.:
and I called the attention of Mr. Wil
liam Hanks of The State to the condi- ]
tions. Careful examination showed
the.! the walls of the building were!
sweating all around, but where the dirt j
was against the building it absorbed
the water, while it was not so absorbed
where the cement Moors joined tin
walls. The walls sweat regularly.
This would not have been the eise had
they been built hollow in the outset?
they had enough thickness for air
space in the centre. This is one of the;
most serious defects in any part of the
State house. I had nothing to do with I
it. !
Next: As to the defective water clos
eta and plumbing.
This work was all done before the
city had plumbing rules, or an inspec
tor of sewers an,l plumbing, or even a
sewerage system. These rules vary in,
different cities, an,', in the ibsenee of
any prescribed rules each architect;
uses such plans and methods as seem
best, considering location and sur
roundings, general appearance and
sanitary rules. In all these matters]
there is constant improvement, just as
we have greatly improved on old clos
ets in the basement, which were in
stalled when c,|. Mai shall was on the!
commission in charge of the State
house improvements. I Must that the
State is able tu g.-t even more venti
lation, by electric fans, as suggested, ">?
Otherwise, as Ibe present location was,
not built '.er this purpose, or there
would hav*' been more ventilation. I
think tie- following letter v. ill enable
the public to form a correci estimate;
of the inclination of this investigating]
committee to condemn everything in
sight: i
Office of A. W. Edens. C. K.. Inspector
of Sewers and Plumbing, Koma
No. S. City Hall,
i 'olumbia, S. i'.. Feb. IWM.
Mr. Frank l\ Milbur'
Dear Sir: At yon. request I take
I lea mo" in slating that tic plumbing
i mi. i the two portlent? >>! the Suite
house will compare f.ivombly with any
plumbing ilial Mas conic under my ob
:? rvatio'i in this city which was in
stalled prior lo ihe passage of Hie
ixvpcnt ci y plumbing rules. The clos
ets und oth? r llxliues are of good ,,uai
ity. The principal >\> '- - i found was
the wani of proper vein i la tion.
yours respectfully.
ISi3.Ii A \V. Edens. C. IS.
Next.
it is charged that the contractors.
.?> "nuked trespassers." carried away
?.ml disposed o,' ,>'..] mat' rial, which
was valuable property of the Suite:
ami iho committee says they attempt
to justify i he ?ei b> an il< in of t ho
ppocificitimis. which docs n?i suppon
: In ? out, iiiioii.
This l.- another evidence thai the
i i.T.mit (??>? did not consider tie- reports
of ihe iMpitol commission, ns tie- legis
lature directed it to do: for it appears
in one "f those reports that under the
item of Ihe spe, in. mi ion* referred to.
tiie com rar tors, and oilm: bidders,
j w ci e told before bidding that they
would get all the old material, except
the marble: that the contractors al
lowed for the value of this old material
in their bid: that the commission Cully
investigated the matter: that the at
torney general gave his official opinion
that the general opinion had been that
the contractors owned the old mate
rial, and the commission could not
i claim it; th.u the opinion ot the attor
! ney general was approved by the com
I mission, excepting only Mr. .Marshall:
I and the commission referred Mr. Gar
i funkel's proposition to it to buy the
old material from the contractors.
I repeat that I cannot believe that
i this investigating committee consid
ered the report, or knew of these facts,
i If they did, I think a discriminating
I public can see that they are determined
'to uphold Col. Marshall's minority re
I port, even if a suppression of ? old
: facts is necessary.
Generally:
As an evident' hat 1 gave the State
good and honest ..crvice in the expend
iture of its money on the State house,
and in refutation of many charges
made, but not sustained, by the in- i
vestigatiug committee, 1 desire to sub- !
I mit the following statements of hon-j
orable, widely known contractors, not
j withstanding the chairman of that
committee, on the floor of the senate,
where he was .secure from reply, de
scended to the tactics of trying to be
smirch and impugn any of and all wit
nesses who dared to speak the truth,
if not in .support of his report:
Nicholas Ittr.cr, Contractor. P. 0. Box
GOG, Atlanta, Gu.
Atlanta. Gu., March 22,1901. 1
Mr. Prank P. Milburn, Columbia, S. C. I
Dear Sir: Your favor of the 20th to
hand. 1 examined the material and ?
workmanship at capitol building, and :
llnd it a first class job. 1 consider it a
good, substantial piece of work.
Yours truly,
(Signed) Nicholas Inner,
Contractor.
Savannah, Ga., Aug. 17, 1903.
Mr. Frank P. Milburn, Columbia, S.
C.
Dear Sir: In reply to your inquiry i
of .August 7th in regard to the work re
eently done on the State house, 1 will !
say that 1 have had considerable ex
perience in large work, and have had i
quite a number of contracts from the |
United Stales government. I was one .
of the firm of the Stewart Contracting
company, who bid for th" contract in
Columbia. 1 was in Columbia Aug. j
Nth, and while there inspected the.
Stoic house work. As a whole. 1 think
the work very satisfactory. There may
be some minor things that 1 would have
done different if I tool been award-.
ed the contract. Anyone looking to
llnd fault can always lind it. There is
one thing certain, the Slate of South |
Carolina, in my estimation, has re
ceived full value for the money ex
pended, and now has a capltol thai I
any Stale might well be proud of.
This is my honest and unprejudiced i
opinion. Yours truly, j
(Signed)
J. E. Burgess. Manager,
Savannah Contracting Company.
Note. Mr. Bulges remodeled interior
of postollice building in Columbia, in
'1)03.
Augusta, Ga., SepL2, 1903.
Mr. Frank P. Milburn, Columbia, S. 1
C.
Dear Sir: In reply to your favor of
Aug. 25th, wanting an opinion from us
on the new Stale capltol in your city, j
we beg to say the writer has frequent-'
ly gone over this building during con-j
struction and since it was finished, and j
consider it as good a job as it is pos- ?
sible to make oul of a remodeling job,
and being familiar with the price paid
for the work, I consider the State se- j
cured a regular excursion price on that
building.
We have had considerable experience j
in remodeling work, and know how I
difficult it is to make everything per- '
fectly satisfactory, as there is some- j
thing always in the way that cannot
be moved, i'ou would have no trouble
to prove up values if the matter was
investigated, as you know from ex-'
perlt nee that ii is much easier to crit
icise than it is to execute.
Yours very truly.
(Signed) .1. Ii. McKenzie & Sons.
(inner? I ("ontruciors.
IJy i 'hal ies F. McKenzie, j
Johnson city. Term., Sept. 26. 1903.
Mr. Frank 1'. .Milburn. Columbia, S.
C.
Dear Sir: Replying to youi inquiry i
of Aug. 25th, asking my opinion of the j
work recently done on the South Caro- i
lina Slate bouse. I will say thai i con- :
sidered t'- ;am>- well executed and fill- \
ly up to tne slandaid for such work. I|
have had experience in remodeling old |
capitols, and have found it hard to I
please every one, as they do not un- !
derstand the many troubles that we
have to contend with. I am surprised
that any objections are raised in re
gard to the job. as 1 thought the qual
ity of the work done, considering the I
quantity, was well worth the price
paid for it. 1 should think it would be
worth fully ?200,0(io to duplicate the |
sane- work now under the present con
ditions of markets, etc.
i'ours truly.
Signed) .1. IS. I'arrish.
Contractor and Builder, Lynchburg,
Vn.
Columbia, S. ?'. Feb. 3. 1901. j
Mr-. Frank P. Milburn, Columbia, S.
c. I
Dear Sir: Replving to your favor of!
recent date, in which y<>u request us to
inspect the work done <m the Stale
capitol building at Columbia, s. C, we
beg to advise as follows:
After a careful Inspection of the I
work, we are prepared to say that in
our opinion, that the work seems to
have been performed in a substantial |
and workmanlike manner. In our opin
ion, the appropriation was entirely too
small for ;h.- amount "i work under
taken. Very truly yours,
(Signed) \\\ T. IIa,lloW I'm.,
By G. II. Madlow,
General Com factors, Jacksonville,
Fla.
i 'olumbin, S. i'.. Feb. ir,. iaw.
Mr. Frank 1?. Milburn. 1
Dear Sir: 1 have this day been
through th- capitol building at Co
lumbia. S. <'.. aid alter looking over
tic wmk I am satisfied that the work
don- |?y the contractor is a faithful
performance of the spirit and 1111-111
oi the plans and : peejfications, as the
work don,- i.- Worth a great ,1-al tic ie
than bis contract price.
I also read Mr. Hunt's report as to
steel ceiling and lloor light and am
i satisfied ilia! he i< entirely loo high in
his valuation of the ceiling, and thai
the lloor light appears io have been
used 01 walked up,.11 liefore th- ceineni
sei, in which case the damages would
1101 appea r for some 1 imo.
And I would saj further, thai in re
pairing mi adding t-i buildings there
are a great many things which no
ability -11 ibu part of i!-,- architect can
f-i-e- .1:1,1 which have to |m> taken up
as they develop; so. : ft-r carefully
I looking over the matter. I am satisfied
that tu- criticism! upon yourself and
contractors ,.ic un< ,'ie.] for and u:i
I find thai th- granite use.; Is not as
hard as the original mantle, the
texture Indng eo-irscr. it would n<.t
take hi- same finish. I lind Iba' the
specific?tions provide thai each class
and style of work shall !?? so many
cuts and tie ..?d work would HO| be
tak'-ii by the eoinr.o tor as bis guide
in performing his werk, while the gen
eral style and 0t11lip.es would be the
same
I do :. : ? ? ? .'? r that the removal
of the ' ? ? 1 ? ? tiieulioiied oi M r.
Man.';- !?'??? : v 11 i weaken ;'>.? sirue
lu.-. I liii.-'.k the in uner in which you
provided i-i the change w as prop.-r. 1
find the ; hi- km-ss ??! the celling and
gutters arc su? h as are used on all
g.? buildings.
1; 1- my experience as a contraeinr
j for l'm years thai .< number of roofs
j leak fur iuine lime after the building
is completed, and to cover this a
guarantee is given for one year.
The copper and tile rout' on the gov
ernment building in Augusta leaked
from time to time and gave the officers
considerable trouble.
Respect fully.
(Signed) T. C. Brown & Son.
Per T. (.'. Brow n.
General Contractors, Augusta. Gu.
Tili': GOVERNMENT EXPERT.
Xo doubt the public is curious to
know something more of Mr. Hunt,
upon whom the committee seems con
lent to rest for the support or its nu
merous criticisms of designs, plans and
work, with the single exception or the
plumbing.
1 had undeistood, until last week,
that the name of this witness was H.
H. Hunt, and that he was a govern
ment architect, as Coinmitteeman Pat
terson announced In the house, and f
made diligent inquiry In Washington
as to identity and standing.
Ih the limited time at my disposal
since Thursday. I have inquired as to
the work, position, etc.. of Mr. S. S.
Hunt, resulting in the following in
formation: \
Before going to Washington, Mr.
Hunt enjoyed the reputation of being
a good mechanic.
The Washington city directory for
Hull! contains his name as a contractor.
The congressional directory does not
show any such oifice ns "superintend
ent of constructing of the United States
capitol." The last congressional direc
tory shows as connected with the office
superintendent of the capitol:
Superintendent, Elliott Woods, Con
gressional hotel.
Chief clerk. George H. Williams. 210
street.
Chief electrical engineer, Christian P.
Gilem, 6-12 Hast Capitol street.
Clerk, John Welch, 310 North Caro
lina avenue. S. E.
W. R. Kilpatrick wires:
"Architect says neither S. S. Hunt
nor H. H. Hunt, superintendent of con
struction capitol. Never heard of such
Hunt."
J. K. Taylor, the supervising archi
tect of the United States government,
wires:
"Office has no knowledge of S. S.
Hunt in 'connection with any of its
work."
Paul J. P< Iz of Washington, one of
the three architects (and the only sur
vivor) who designed the famous con
gressional library, says that his name
is not in the government Blue Hook:
that he neither knows S. S. Hunt as
a builder, contractor or architect, and
that if he had been of promin? u e in
either capacity, be would have ki.own
him.
Will South Carolinians endorse the
libelous report of this investigating
committee, confessedly based on ihe
opinion of this witness, in the face of
the opinions of Nicholas Ittner of At
lanta. J. E. Burgess of Savannah.
Charles F. McKenzie of Augusta, J. E.
Parrish of Lynchburg, G. H. Hadlow
of Jacksonville, and T. C. Brown of
Augusta'.'
The following extracts from the rec
ords of the Capitol commission will no
doubt prove interesting to the public:
"Upon motion of Mr. Derhsun:
"Resolved, That when the work on
the State house is finished, prior to
accepting the same, the architect shall
notify the governor, who shall call
the commission together, who with
the architect shall Inspect the work,
ami if the same is satisfactory the cer
tificate shall issue."
Columbia. S. C. May 22. 1902.
Hon. M. B. McSweeney, Chairman
State House Commission:
Hear Sir?1 wish to report that Me
llvaln. Unkefer Co.. contractors, have
completed the work as outlined by me
on the State house. That is-, tin: spir
it, intent and meaning of the plans,
specifications and modifications of the
same, and are entitled to the final pay
ment.
Frank P. Milburn.
P. S. This report to be tiled when
the commission are satisfied with the
work as done.
"Resolved, That it appears to the
commission for the completion of tlie?
State house that the work is satisfac
tory and that the contract has been
substantially performed.
Whereupon Mr. Marshall made the
following motion as ;i substitute:
Resolved. That in the opinion of this
commission the work done under the
contract to complete the State house
mis not been performed by the con
tractors according to the plans, speci
fications and contract, and therefore
the work done is not satisfactory to
tin- commission."
A roll call having l.n demanded up
on the question cd' the adoption of Mr.
Marshall's substitute, the substitute
was rejected by a vote of 7 to l. as fol
lows:
Voting yes -Marshall?1.
Those voting no?McSweeney. Jen
nings. Mower. Johnson, Wilson, Bel
linger, Derham?7.
CONCLUSION.
I have tried to briefly and calmly
show the public the plain facts connect
ed with tie- State house work, with-I
nit resorting to rant, and cheap clap
trap about bamboozling, etc.
I have no desire to conceal anything
from the public and I court the fullest
Investigation, feeling sure of a com-,
.nletu vindication from the cruel at-;
tack which has been made upon my |
character for the llrsl time.
Very respectfully,
Frank P. Milburn. I
A I'Ki: U H'-Mt WITH A ItKCOItD.
The Rev. .lohn Ituppc of GnflTney Uns
Tied -us Matrimonial Knots.
Special in The state-.
Gaffney, Feb. IS.?Rev. John Ruppe,
who has possibly inaried more cou
ples than any other man in this con il
ly marred two more North Carolina
? hi. lies last Sunday. These were Mr.
?\. .Moore ami Miss I.. K. Settlcliiyer,
of Henrietta, and Mr. C, A. Hawkins
and Miss Haltic McSwairi. of Boiling
Springs. This make: a total of 438 J
knots lied by this aged divine. Many
are the people who can date their
greatest happiness to the lime when
they .stood trembling before him.
.Miss Blanche Wilson has gone on
a trip north.
Mr. II. K. Osborno has announced
hiins.-lf a candidate for thy office of
alderman from Ward Six.
Mr. '!'. Davonporl has sold bis gro
cery business to .Mrs. T. Davenport,
v. ho will .-undue: tl." business at the
sane- place. Mr. Davonpori will be
come a knight of tin- grip. His line
will be ^roi cries.
Help is litprechilfil.
(?.-..pie's Recorder (coloredi.
It is indeed gratifying t-> note 'he
interesl ihe Columbia Dally State, ihe
white citizens of Columbia and else
where, and Dr. Ra> of lower Rich la ml
county arc taking In raising and dis
tributing contributions of money, food
and clothing for and t > th.lored suf
ferers of lower Rich land. All remem
ber how th. ir crops were all swept
away by hail, wind and rain last year,
and how hundreds of lhe poorer das;
have undergone almost starvation.
Now these white friends, from tii-ii
bounteous storehouses, are mosl liber
ally contributing to the n.Is the
sufferers.
Being a Columbian, we do all ihe
more appreciate Ijiis manifest Chris
tian beneficence. May I lie blessed
restore !?? these benefactors leii :'?>'?'?.
We thank them. is aboiti tie- only pay
back tint w?? enn give.
\ fatal K*|itii?imi.
Buffalo. N. V.. 21.?Two men
were asphyxiated, one burned t-. death
and several were seriously injusod in
a.; explosion ,,r i.last furnace gas mi
ihe pinnl of the Lucka wanna Steel
company today. The dead are: Goo.
Reynolds, a mason: Mieh.Hil S. Smith,
a mason. Frank Prenati, employed in
tin power house.
% GIRLS WHO LEAVE HOME. I
8 I
".': W rill en lor The Mate by \V. ?. ?<-'
jjj U..?,!>. *
The readers of The Stute, or rather
that portion of them who have paid
the writer the compliment of reading
Iiis articles, which have appeared from
time to time in Its columns need
hardly be reminded of his position on
the subject of education. There is.
however, one thing in connection with
the .pie: lion to whi m he begs to enter
a protest, although it is don..- with a
considerable degree of reluctance.
Ii i? possible, of course, that this
evil, and the word Is used advisedly,
may not owe its origin to our system
of education, but to a change of pub
lic sentiment, which has found de
velopment outside of higher education.
Then, too. the fact must be recogniz
ed thai in all human affairs, it mat
ters not how good the general ten
dency is. there must be some evil; but
while giving full acknowledgme.it to
this truth, every effort should he made
to keep the evil incident thereto to
the lowest possible point.
The evil to which allusion is made is
the craze that has found lodgment in
the mind of almost every girl that
just as soon as she leaves the college
or high school she must lind some
kind of employment, despite the fact
that in the large majority of cases It
involves leaving her home and being
thrown with strangers. Any system
of education or of public sentiment
that instills a feeling of this kind into
the mind of a girl, that she must be in
dependent and make her own way in
the world, is radically and Inexcusably
wrong.
There are, of course, many cases
where this seeking for employment is
painfully necessary, and where this is
the case a girl should he encouraged
ami rendered every assistance; but
where this condition does not exist,
she is both unjust to herself and her
parents when she voluntarily leaves
them jus: at the time when they will
derive so much pleasure from her
presence ju the house. She has been
sorely missed during the four years she
has spent ai college, but this separation
was cheerfully borne by her parents,
for they could look forward to the lime
when she would finish her education
and once more be with them to bright
en their hotne. Independence and the
desire to make one's own way in the
world, is both natural and commend
able, but there is such a thing as car
rying even a good impulse too far, and
there is something radically wrong in
any system of home or school train
ing that, implants the idea in the mind
of a girl that she should not be de
pendent on her father, even when he
is abundantly able to provide for her
wants.
Even if it be granted that she can
have more social enjoyment in the
town or city than in the country home
of her parents, this furnishes no sutli
cient excuse for her to leave her par
ents when her presence and help af
fords them such unalloyed happiness.
It often happens that the mother, get
ting on in years, is worn out with toil
and care. She has given all her
strength and time to the raising and
training of her children, and to her
it is an inexpressible pleasure when
her daughter insists on assuming some
of her duties and responsibilities, and
enables lu-r to enjoy a well-earned
rest.
A number of years ago it was the
writer's good fortune to be a frequent
visitor at a home where the conditio;,
above mentioned existed. The moth
er's health was not good and the oldest
daughter had simply relieved her of all
household cares, not even allowing the
younger children to trouble her with
any of their troubles. This daughter
was accomplished, well educated, a
very line musician and could easily
have secured a position to teach. This
she would have liked to do. but she
felt that her first duly was at home,
and the discharge of this sacred duty
Will ever he | he sweetest ami linder
est recollection of her life, for when
she was called on to see that mother
pass away she was sustained ami
soothe.! by the consciousness that she
had done all that lay in her power to
make her mother's last years pass in
peace and happiness.
One of the greatest and noblest men
Robert K. Lee?who has ever lived on
this earth, made duty the watchword
of his whole life, and no sacrifice <<r
danger ever restrained him from do
ing what lie conceived to be right. The
path of duty often calls us to walk
in ways that humanly speaking are
Hie very reverse of the ones we would
choose, but then there should ever bo
present the though! that after all the
strongest happiness conies from the
consciousness of having done our ut
most to promote the happiness of those
who are dear to us. Fortunate, in
deed, is the daughter who. when she
looks for the last lime on the face of
her mother, with her tired hands fold
ed across h'-r bosom, can feel that she
never brought tears to the now closed
eyes 01 pangs of sorrow to the un
selfish heart, winch, has forever ceas
ed to Inn1
If she r 1 feel thus then she has a
pea e and joy than '.'.ill be her greatest
so as long as life endures, for what
ever, for weal or woe, the future has
in store for her, this is something thai
no earthly powei can take away.
A girl when she first leaves col
lege au.l enters, as i; were, upon the
threshold of her life, stands in great
need of her mother's counsel and pro
tection, and it is a misfortune when
stress of circumstances deprives her
of this safeguard. If Liiere be on*
thing 011 earth thai comes as a gift
from Heaven it is '!:?? love of a moth
er for her child. N'o pen can portray
it: no plummet can sound its depths,
for it is as deep and wide as a fath
omless sei, t.i wide!! no measurement
can be given.
The writer trusts that he may b<
pardoned for giving one more iiiuv
tratioii of the sacrifice of inchtiattor
io duty, the facts of which are just uj
related
A good man;.' years ago (here ex
isted an engagement between tw<
young people, but I here was. in t hi
estimation of the young lady at least
an inseparable barrier in the way o!
it.': immediate consummation, thai ob
st.e l ? beii,g an invalid me'li- r. fm
whose ear.- the daughter consider..-'
herself responsible. After the laps,
of a good many years the mother pass
ed away and a short lime after hoi
? I'-ath tiie daughter married the g- n
tIonian to whom she had I.n so Ion:
attacli.-d. They were both gel
ling a!.>ieg in years then, but can any
one deal.1 that thai loving daughh
found irreal happiness in th- few year:
, f bei married life"." Ii is very easy t<
believe ihai in 1 Iiis short time then
came :?> !:??:? enough ??! earthly hnppi
ness 10 compensate for her long year:
of sacrifice to a snen d duty.
Ii has always been a source of won
1,1 the writer ihal some truly grea
writer has never made a special pom
of t r> inu at least i" port ay niotJ
er's love ior a child, following ? ui itia
'..-..- from us birth, and when it firs
draws sustenance from her bosom
through the years o| :'. gradual menta
and physical ilcvciopmeiit. So far a
tie- writer's knowledge extends this 1
for th-- novelist an unexplored mite
wailing for- the touch of a masie
h .nd I.- bring lls jewels mho the ligh
of today.
Baltimore. I". h. -1.?R was though
thai not a lit'-- was I >si In the fire hen
bm a charred body supposed to h
"f n colored man has been fotin
in the water ai Rowley's wharf. Th
bod) is badly burned as to be Uli
recognizable.
SUEZ V DHEARY DITCH.
Cunal Cleft Through Urgion llnrc of
All Save UIIiIIcmI Klrimem.
Iw. E. Curtis in Chicago Record-Her
ald.
. Alloal on the Red sen. Jan. IS.?
Every vessel passing through the Suez
je anal is compelled tn lake a pilot, he
cause skippers u:' ordinary vessels can
not be trusted to navigate the narrow
channel, for the slightest deviation
? may cause damage that will cost thou
1 sands of dollars to repair. Each year,
however, navigation is rendered easier
by the widening of the channel and
; by the excavation of additional sidings
or basins where vessels can pass.
From the moment the pilot goes on the
i bridge he takes charge'>f (he move
j ments of the ship and is responsible for
whatever may happen, regulating the
i speed according to tonnage and
draught.
Vessels cannot pass in motion. When
! they meet the one which arrives first
at the signal station is compelled to
stop and tie up In the basin until the
other goes by. These basins are found
, at intervals of u few miles, and at
every basin is a "gare" or station in
i barge of a signal officer, who corre
sponds to a train dispatcher on one
of our railroads, and the block system
is used to regulate the movement of
vessels. Formerly no tralllc was al
lowed at niuht. but now it is carried on
without interruption by the aid of
{electric lights on the shore and search
; lights on the vessels.
The canal looks exactly what it Is?
I a big ditch on a desert of sam on
which foxes, jackals, hyenas and oc
casionally lions are seen by the watch
men in the signal tower At some
j places the banks of earth on either
? side are so high that passengers on the
j steamer cannot see over them, but for
i most of the journey you have a wide
j sweep on both sides back to the moun
| tains that rise from the desert, and
j at a certain point for a mile or two
, Moun.1 Sinai ;s visible .'!7 mll?s to the
: southeast, and is pointed out to you
by the captain or the deck steward.
Naked Arab hoys run along the banks
crying for baksheesh and easily keep
abreast of the creeping vessel, grab
hing at pennies which passengers
throw them from the deck. Half the
: coins roll down in the water, which is
exasperating to the youngsters. They
I do not like to stop and dive for them
while there is a chance of getting more,
' but I Imagine they mark' the spots and
? oniii bark to recover lost backsheesh
when they have left tin- vessel.
There are only two towns of any
; account on the canal. One is Ismalia,
' a half way point, with a population of
. 4.000. it is the only monument In honor
.of the Khedive Ismail, who did the
; most and spent the most to carry out
the enterprise, and lost his throne
] thereby. It is rather a pretty town,
; abundantly irrigated, and hence has
? lovely gardens and groves of palms
land other trees. Here reside most of
the engineers and other officers of the
canal, because it Is preferable to Port
I Said. There is a hospital for sick em
j ployees, a club for the benefit of the
officers, and several good houses, in
cluding one erected especially for the
: entertainment of M. de Lesseps, when
I he should be pleased to use it. Beyond
Ismalia. as before, are occasional
oases |n the desert?groves of palms
and luxuriant gardens surrounding the
; stations of the canal officials, for
wherever you can turn water on that
I lonely desert everything will grow with
I a wild luxuriance. It seems as if the
I earth suddenly released germinating
I power that had been accumulating
I during centuries of suppression.
The chief interest is found in the
town of Suez, because it is the crossing
; place of the great caravans of camels
j that furnish transportation betwen the
j two continents of Asia and Africa, and
I travel regularly between Cairo, Da
; mascus and Bagdad; also because bib
lical historians believe that here the
waters of the Red sea opened 3,500
years ago and allowed 3.000,000 of the
children of Israel tu cross over upon
dry bottom. It requires a considerable
concession to the imagination and a
[strength of faith that a majority of
j mankind do not possess to accept this
I theory, but no one knows to the con
trary, and experience has taught me
j never Lo doubt the faith of interesting
s;oiie.<. if you do, you deprive your
j self and others cd' muc h pleasure. It
; is like- analyzing the attraction of a
? pretty woman, nr separating her fea
tures into lots, classifying them and
measuring them by the Venus de RIllo.
On the other side of the Bed sea,
which, by the way. is not red, but blue
, ?as blue as the sky In June?you can
: see the purple peaks of the Sinaitic
, range, and a few miles from the shore,
' which you can reach in three hours
' by donkey, one of these remarkable
j oases that are frequently found in the
I desert. This particular one is called
. the Wells of .Moses. There is a com
fortless hotel kept by an Arab, where
beds and refreshment can be obtained,
but It is better to start early in the
! morning, so as to get buck the same
day, and take a luncheon in a basket
. from Suez. The trip c an be- easily
? made while- the vessel is coaling.
I The children of Israel, according to
the Bible, wandered three days In the
wilderness of Shut- and found no water,
and when they came to .Marah they
[could not drink the waters, for they
'were bitter, and the people murmured
against .Moses, sayin: "What shall we
drink'.'" and he cried unto the Lord
and the Lord showed him a tree which
he cast Into the- waters and the waters
were made sweet. And they came to
Elim, where there were 1- wells of
wafer, and three score and ten palm
trees, and they encamped there- by the
waters. And Miriam, the- prophetess,
ti>.- sister Hi Aaron, look a timbrel
in her hand, and all the women .vent
oul after In r with timbrels and with
dances. That beautiful scene, one of
the most dramatic in the who!.- Bible-,
is I??-11I to have taken place here,
for these wells are the wells of Ellin,
and three and ten palm trees still
shelter a collection ,,i a dozen or more
springs. The village is peopled by
I naked Arabs, sinewy, springy, en
during fellows, whose flesh shines like"
polished mahogany, and who must re
semble tie- young m?--n of Israel whei
they started on ihe journey that was
nol finished for in years.
It is difficult to understand why and
how they hap,.-med in be wandorinp
about so long down here. If you vvil
lock ai tiie map you will see thai Sues
is .-lim,.si on a line wilh Cairo, and it
was lhe m-'st natural rendezvous of tin
tribes, w im were scattered all alom
the Nil.- from Memphis, which Is jm-i
above t'nho. in Thebes, which is jusi
below Luxor. The account In tin
Bible is i.doused, and we are cum
P >?!??? i to t ike :i good deal of these ira
ilitioiis en ...eh. but, as i have already
suggested, j- is worth while tn do so.
Tile Bed s'-i is 1,4(10 miles long, an
its gre nest .. idlh is >?> miles. It i:
Dutti (!;?? shape of a sausage, and la
; ? rs ai both cuds. cm one s.i? !>? i
Arabia, the nmsi mysterious and prim
itive .if all countries, and on the othe
sid-- Egypt. Nubia and ihe Soudan
Ai t!i" north end what is known as t?i?
Siuuith' peninsula projects souihwan
and divides the sea into two arm
and near the point of ihe peninsula 1
Tor. the landing place for Sinnt. i>p
posile Tor i-' .I.!..-! Ez-Zelt. whid
means "the mountain of oil." where pe
iroleum was discovered some years :i-'
am! - rented e.r. al excitement. Hun
II reds of thousands oi dollars hav
I.I. expended m sinking wells an.
bending docks, warehouses and r< tin
cries, bin have all been abandonee
because, for some reason, the maun
facturers could wt eomfiete with ti:
Standard 'HI ?-hi.p.my or the Russii.
factories on the lilack and Caspia
seas.
people Ihink l ha I there is a good den
more wealth in Arabia than we kn< \
of. It was once vi greater Importal!J
j than now, and in ancient days pro
duced considerable gold and other met
1 tils, but now it ships little but dates.
I wool and coffee, and even these are
,' gradually falling off. -Mocha coffee is
produced at the extreme end of the
; Arabian peninsula, in a province called
i Yemen, and derives its name from the
little port it Is shipped from. But the
: people have no enterprise, the coffee
' orchards have been injured by Insects
and blight, and the trees have not been
J renewed. This is acounted for by bad
government. As everywhere else in
the dondnions of the sultan of Turkey,
for Arabia is nominally a part of the
ottoman empire, the officials receive
no salaries, and live off blackmail.
Hence, whenever a citizen gets a little
ahead, when he shows signs of pros
; perity, he immediately becomes an
: object of plunder and persecution by
I the tax gatherer and by every other
representative of the government.
! There is no incentive for the coffee
I growers to extend their orchards or
I to increase their product.
One does not. realize, until he comes
, face to face with the fact, that Arabia
j is nearly half as large as the United
I States. Its area is almost as great as
i that of India, and is nearly equal to
1 that of our States east of the Missis
sippi river. The population Is un
i known, because there has never been
; a census, but It is suposed to be be
I tween seven and twelve millions. The
', distance from north to south is more
?than a thousand miles, and from east
to west it varies from 500 to S00. Yet
in till this enormous territory there is
[ no centralized authority. The Interior
is goverened by petty sheiks, each
being absolute over the members of
his own tribe. Along a coast line of
nearly 2.500 miles are only six ports.
I where the sultan of Turkey maintains
'pasha governors and garrisons to pro
ject the codec ~rs of customs, who are
I required to paj him a certain amount
of tribute every year, and they wring
I t out of the people any way they can.
The relationship between the gov
ernment at Constantinople and the
; Bedouins of Arabia is very slender,
[and is due solely to the cohesive power
; of the Mohammedan religion. There Is
I ao law in Arabia but the Koran; there
I ire no courts but the priests; there are
j no malls, no postofTlceH, no postage
! stamps, and a person who wants to
I communicate with a distant fried must
? send his letter by a messenger, which
is expensive, or by a caravan, which Is
the common way. There Is no tele
graph line, no newspaper, no railroad,
and, strange to say, not a river In all
[ that vast area except a few shallow,
rocky beds, which during the spring
, bring down water from the melting
j snow on the mountain tops to the sea.
! but for nine months In the year are
i as dry as a crematory.
The captain tells me that they pro
duce a curious phenomenon. The coast
of the Red sea Is lined with coral
banks, built by those mysterious and
j wonderful little masons who, like some
: men that I know of. hate fresh water,
j and wherever the spring floods fall Into
j the sea there is always a wide break
j In the coral reef.
! The mountains of Arabia reach an
altitude of 10,000 feet, and in spots
where borings have been made the sand
Is more than C00 feet deep. It is the
prevailing Impresion that Arabia is a
vast expanse of desert, but that is .a
mistake. There are wide strips of bar
ren stind, which are irreclaimable for
cultivation only because they cannot
be reached by water, but two-thirds of
the country is capable of cultivation,
and. lying at an altitude of 3,000 feet
above the sou, .night' produce cotton,
sugar and other semi-tropical staples
in unlimited quantities. Although
there are no streams plenty of water
can lie had for irrigation purposes by
digging 20 or 30 feet, and the introduc
tion of windmills would simplify the
pumping problem. On the coast It is
Intensely hot, and the humidity of the
atmosphere during the summer season
makes life almost unendurable, but In
! the interior, upon the table lands along
; the mountain slopes and in the va'leys,
(the mercury seldom rises above S5 do
' grees, even In mid-summer. While
i the direct rays of the sun are intense.
[ it is cool in the shade, and at night the
j mercury often falls below 50.
j More than two-thirds of the popuiu
; tlon a'-e Bedouin nomads, without per
j manent places of abode, who live in
: tents made of camel's hair, just like
i the patriarchs of old. They have enor
mous docks of sheep and goats, and
herds of catle and camels. The follow
the grass and move from place to place
with all their possessions. There are.
i however, several prosperous cities of
'considerable population and commerce,
i Trade is conducted by camel caravans,
? which cross the desert regularly, and
i transport enormous quantities of dates,
woo! and other merchandise.
William E. Curtis.
A School for f>rnwo-l:|M,
Gas ton In (N. C.) Gazette.
I The Statesvillc Landmark refers ts
the pluck of a boy 17 years old and of
a man twice that age who recently
buckled down to books at Buie's Creek
academy without knowing how to read.
The boy didn't know his letters, the
man began In the first reader. Yea.
that is plucky in a sense. Not that
the task is so great, but that the
I nerve to get one's consent to undertake
! it at those ages is so rare, f'.ut it
Sought not to be rare. The task Is not
great, not difficult of accomplishment,
j Little children who live with books
and picture blocks learn to tend be
i fore they are six years of ate, learn
1 without special teaching: with some
direct and regular instruction they
i would b arn sooner. We do not believe
that there is in the State an illiterate
1 grown man Of ordinary intelligence
and industry that could not learn to
read In six weeks, write in ten weeks,
and get a good beginning in arithmetic
in a f. w more weeks, if he would only
give these things attention and reg
ular study. Why hasn't somebody
st ilted a school for grown men who
cannot read and write'.' The gap be
tween the man who cannot rend and
the man who can?how great and how
wide it is! What storehouses of rich
ness and vast and fertile fields are
shut away from him who cannot read.
Beyond the Alps lies Italy?and the
Al| - ill this case nr.; riot impassable.
Th - gap is wide but not difficult to
hint who tries, and the prize is 9o
worth the winning! The man who
cannot thinks the way is hard; the
man who can knows it Is not. The
grown man who cannot read and write
?somebody show him. somebody help
him. Here's missionary work for one.
and priceless happiness for two.
SPKfTI.ATORS IN TROUBLE.
Ilavr lleeii Starting Wnr Rumor? Im
i tnl? for Honey Purpose"..
Ibuue. Feb. 21.?Rumors of warlike
preparations by Italy having been cir
culated a semi-official communication
has emanated from the government
which is in substance as follows:
Stories of alleged armaments and of
the movements of warships and troops
for service abroad are entirely false.
Indications exist that this false news
is connected with stock exchange
speculations and those responsible
have been brought before the law
? ourts to be punished u.irding to law
with imprisonment of from three to
thirty months.
rho communication evidently alludes
to riie insistence by a portion of the
press thai Italy will be antagonistic to
Austria in the Balkans and to the
predictions r?f international complica
tions thus causing a f?ll in Italian
bends and a rise In the exchange on
geld.
F)r. JanieMOB'ii Siicrms.
Cape Town. Fob. 21.?Dr. Jameson
has succeeded in completing a casiaet.