Farmers' gazette, and Cheraw advertiser. (Cheraw, S.C.) 1839-1843, February 23, 1842, Image 1
<&J?B mm&W BBmmwm??h T ;
~ .... cilhR lW.SOU fH.CAROM.VA, WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 83. 1813 NUMBER IS SB
VOLUME VII Kjllu . ..... ' ' " - - ?v
IT - -*.. 1 ' ' ?rr*t- -FT , y l.n I \ m i ft >11 ,rTl p? -
By ZTf* MAC LiLlX.
Tkbms:?Published weekly at three dollars a
year; with an addition, when not paid within
three months, of twenty per cent per annum.
Two new subscribers may tako tlie JMpef at
^ fire dollars in advance; anu ten at twenty.
Four subscribers, not receiving their papers
in town, may pay a year's subscription with leu
dollars, In advance.
A year's subscription always due ir> advance, j
Papers not discontinued tosoia'lt subscribers j
in arrears.
Advertisements not exceeding 1 lim'S inserted :
r one dollar the first time, am! fifty cents CilUli
nbsequont time. For insertions at intervals dl
two weeks 75 cents after the first, and a dollar
if the intorvds are longer. Payment due in
advance for advertisements. When the nuiiiVr
f insertions is not marked on the copy, tiie
advertisement will be inserted, and charged til
rdered out.
0"The postage must b; paid on letters to tlii
editor on the business of the office.
" 'a g1 w^u}s.j az,7~[
ARTIFICIAL GRASSK3.
From the Temperance Advocate.
PmHINO CSKKK AGRICULTURAL SOCIRTV.
T1 i? Pnmmides aunoinled to nronnre
* "" r i i i
and present a dfmnoir or Essay, to be bv
this Society forwarded to the State Agricultural
3->ciety, be? leave to report:
That in the discharge of this duty, they
% have been influenced by the hope that a
tew facts, the result of experience, will be j
fnore and better calculated to promote
the subject, which the State Society had
in view, when thev parsed the Resolutions,
which have called forth this It -port, than
any theoretical essay, however well written
or plausible it might be. There is
no pursuit of man, which depends so j
much upon circumstances, as that of
Agriculture. There is, therefore, no purnutt
in which general principles are so often
misapn'ied. Consequently, finespun
theories are not weil calculated to promote
the general intercut.
In selecting, the cultivation of the or.
tifiria! grasses, as the subject of a m".
inoir, to be submitted to the^State Society,
the improvement of the-soil, is (be ullcrior
object to be kept in view. To accomplish
this* the ground must be stocked '
with the grass seed every time it is sown
in either wheat, rye or oats. Tile grass j
iwiei generally are red clover, red top or !
Herds grass, Orchard gras; and Tim dhy.
To adopt this course, the farmer must be
' p??parcd to let his land lie to grass r.t least ,
- ' . I I * A .! 11 i '
Itirae years, otherwise me owject wm not
be accomplished. The advantage* to be
derived, are first the pes*arc tor uis stock,
second, preventing the land from washing,
third, the vegetable matter which is left
upon the soil to turn under when ploughed
down. To improve ic soil, you must
have manure, to make manure you must
have stock; to keep stock, you must have
grpaw. 'Therefore, it is considered that' i
the cultivation of grass is of as much, if
1
pot moro imj>orta?ice, than moat ot the ,
crop* we do cultivate. It is said hy some,
who laugh at the idea of sowing grass
eed, that we have a plenty of grans with
out sowing. The grasses, however,
^ which we want, are those which come
culv and continue late. Such is the ted
clover, red top and orchard grass; of the
timothy, we cannot speak from experience
Having said this much, l?v way of introduction.
wc will now speak of facts. J
The facts reported, have been the cx- 1
perience of one of your Committee.. i
fn the month of February, about |
thirty acres of ground, then growing ,
Wheat and rye upon it, was sowed with 1 (
red clover seed. The seed was sowed (
Upon the ground, and permitted to go
down with the ?now and rains. The
method adopted in sowing was, to mix
u?..rl Miilh u.hcc m.-tilf: mnwt na inii.th
?*sed to the bushel of a*hc> a? wa.i intend- ''
etl for one acre, which was about eight
pounds of seed. The clover grew up m j
the spring, and at (he tine of cutting the !
grain, was generally about six inches. \ l
The sun)m r of 1^37, it was pastured,
after the crop of grain was taken off, with j
hogs and small cattle, and soine times ,,
horses and milk cows. The summer of I
1838, no stock was permitted iogo upon
if, until it was in bloom, about the middle
of June, to first of July, when about fifty
1 ?? C Mn/lt fi ft If /?AIA*U ? n<l I
IIO^.I, KflWUtll I (;i l y nuu ill i r vwu J| Iinv
some horses, were permitted to pasture 1
upon it, until the crop was eaten off*. The
Stock were then taken off* and the clover
hen grew up again, and made very good '
fall pasture, though not so good as the
first. The spring of 1639, about fifteen
bdshels of plaster of paris was put upon
part of the field, about one bushel to the
icre. The crop of clover was not so good <
this year as the crop of 1836. but made
very good pasture, and was treated much
fts it was in 1838. This year satisfi'ed
the^proorictor of one fact, of which before [
he had doubt, vi7j that red clover will I
stand our summer heat and dry seasons.
If it withstood the dry seasons of 1838 |
and 1839, we may expect it to withstand j
our ordinary dry sca-o is. The fall crop j
of 1839, was perm tted to go to seed and j
- -1? i ? t 1 !
ripen, when me wnoie w;i*? tumcu ui.mvi,
with a large two horse plough, brought
from New York for that express purpose.
In the last of November and month of
December, as the season would permit,
the ground was agimi sowed with w beat
nod rye, and a better crop was taken
off it, at the harvest of 18 10, than eve.
was on it since it became what is termed
old land. The clover at the time of liar
vest was generally from eight to twelve
inches high. No stock was permitted to
go upon it until the clover wets blooming:
k. -
! rit this time it \Va>? generally eighteen
inches high, and some stalks measured
two feet. It was then a sight well calculated
to satisfy any one, that it requires
hut to try and we can grow clover. The
spring of 1841, the clover came on as
usual, hut the weeds Sprang up and smothered
it so that the crop was not so good
as either crops. It is intended to fall on
the ground this winter, and plant corn in
it tiie next year, then sow again in wheat
and rye. with a view to see whether a
sufficiency of seed is in the ground to
stock it again with clover, of which a
doubt is entertained. The land upon
w hifiii.this clover grew, is a stiff soil, ori<Mual
growth of timber, hickory, post.oak,
r* c? # - .
black-oak, black-jack, and some few pine.
The location is upon the south fork of
Fishing Creek in Chester District, about
fifteen acres of the laud his been cleared
upwards of forty years, the remainder about
twenty-five years. There has been
no manure put upon it at any time, except
about one aero, an I thaUbut very trifling.
The cost of the clover seed was a few
cents under oight dollars por bushel, delivered
on the farm, so that each acre had
about one dollar's worth of seed Upon it.
That seed stocked the yrotlnd for five
years and two heavy crop* of wheat and
rye taken olFit in the time and after the
first year, the pasturage is considered,
worth morth more than a!l the expense
would be, if it bad to be stocked every
year with seed, and ten per cent, upon
the val.je of the land. Hogs will fatten
to make good pork, without any other
feed, hv giving thern a little salt occasionally.
The richness of the hotter and
milk is known oniv to thoss who have
seen such. Care is to be taken when
cows arc first put upon the clover, not to
put them on until (bedew isoflT the clov.
er in the morning, and not Jet them stay
ou long at onetime, for a few days ; afterwards
by keeping them otf until the
dew is dried up, no injury is to be apprehended.
There is no injury to be apprehended
to hogs at all. No serious inIi.
j avar r. ft, n#p!(inr<>(! it-111) horses 1
,i.i; .,.JV?v. -
it will salivate a little the second crop,
but hy giving dry food, the salivation
nil! sown stop. No part of this clover was
c.it for hay. but in another experiment it
has been mowed success full v.
In the spring of 1*37, about one and a
half acres of ground vhich had been previously
well manured by cowpenning, and
i crop of turnips taken off it the winter
>f lSd-j, was sowed in clover and orchard
jr.ass together. The grass seeds were
own witli oats. The orchard grass, it
was ascertained afterward*, was not sow.
ui sutficiently thick, as it came in hunch,
a. A heavy crop of oats was taken otF
the ground, and the clover was cut that
lutumn, w very good crop, though not
well cut on account of the out stubble.?
in the year ofH3i, the clover was twice
wt each cutting, about eighteen inches
n * ~
and two feet hi gh. The orchard grass
began to spread upon the ground this
vear, and hy the next spring, Hot), took
the ground from the clover generally,
where it happened to I* thick. The
years I84U, and 1844, me grass na? i>een
permitted tori|>en its seed, and then cut.
It is a hard grass for hay. when p?riuittcd
tostaun until the blown come* upon it,
[>ut when it i* young it is tender, and
stock is very fond of it. The advantage
sf this grass, as a pas.lire grass, is that
it comes early in the spring. On the
first of April, 1841, it was sixteen incite*
long in tlse hhuie, and afforded a go d
hit for cattle. Another advantage, it
continues green .and is good pasturage
late in the fall. After til the natural
grasses in our fields are dead and of no
service, this grass is green and good paslurag'.
On the tenth of November,
1841 stock were tnrr.ed upon it, and had
green grass of from eight to twelve inch,
nss i* the.hladc. Whether if the grass
had Seen thick upon the ground, the sods
tun it.I hnvA r.ikfn the same hold, is not
known, but as it is, the sods appear to We
as firmlv fixed in the ground as broom
grass. This grns* is of very rapid growth
and in a fow days after being cut, shows
itself springing up nunin. The result of
experience is, that it is a fine grass for
pasture; hut not so-good for hay. No
manure was put upon this ground from
the time the grass seedsWere sown. The
. I
soil is a yellow sandy, with a yellowish j
clay subsoil, lias been cleared upwards
thirty years.
' In the spring of 1837, about one ncre,
and in the'spring of 1830, about three
acres were sown in red top grass seed.?
In each case, thfc grass seeds were sown
* ? --.. ? l. * I rt/i/* /if nri*/iiirwl
Willi OIIIN. t inn JMV-V*; m
a small branch nr s. The one acre was
originally wet and boggy, lint lying at
the font of a long cleared land* (he wash
upon it* has covered it from six (rt ten
inches deep and it is no'tV perfectly dry.
The year before the grass seeds Were
sown, it was well manured and planted in
corn, and produced a very good rrop.?
The crop of oats Was good. The first
year could hardly lie seen, The next not
a good crop. Each year since that, a
very good crop of hay, hut amount hv
weight not known. The crop ?{ 1941,
was generally from two to three feet
high when cut: and as thick upon the
r,.... . ^
i ground as it could stand. This makes!
| an excellent hr.y, and upon a soil weli J
| pfdpnreo, yields a bountiful return. The .
I three acft!s Was before the west side of i
the branch, and was old meadow land,
which had been used as a natural mead- i
ow for a great many years. The natural I
grass had boen entirely subdued by weeds
of different kinds, and the ground abondoned
as a meadow, add turned Utit, as
it is usually termed, about five or six
years before being ploughed up, it was
again put under fence, but the natural
grasses done no good. The winter of
1837 and 18^8, a heavy doat of long *ta.
ble manure was put upon it. Then fal- |
lowed, as well as the nature of the ground j
I would permit, and planted in corn. There
was a bad stand of corn, in consequence
of cut worm destroying it. In the spring
of 1839, it was sowed with oats and fed '
top grass seed. There was but an ordi-!
nary crop of eats. The grass has been
standing lor hay ever iince, and the crop j
of 1841, was a very good crop, though j
not so good generally, as the one acre,
hut it was owing to the fact that it was j
j not so thick upou the ground. It is he- !
leived that the next crop will be bolter, as
it appears to be spreading over th? j
ground. A part of this, however, was ;
j three feet high by measurement. The !
I I.n.l mlimli tlua nPAUT.' IU ivlm t lUfnl.
V JI i II |;vn WIIIVIS ill(<9 011/rr.ij !? ?*? ? ?W V??. ,
led culil black-jack land* some places wa- i
ter rises in it, which ha?* beea attempted i
to be remedied by cutting a'ditch a long
its margin, but has hcert so far unsucceas- j
ful. Whether this grass wiii grow well j
upon high dry soil, cannot b? stated from '
any experience, hut no doubt is enter-I
taincd that it will. This grass makes an i
excellent pasture, both early and late, j
and at this time, the 10th of Movcmlier, j
i the small cattle and horses are grazing j
j upon the meadow, with apparent delight, J
that they have treated with the luxury of j
green grass.
Nothing can he said ahout Timothy
grass, from experience, more than that it
is helcived it will grow, because, if ten
or fifteen stalks will grow luxuriantly,
there is no reason why acres should not.
An attempt was made with tho timothy,
but from defective seed (it is supposed) '
but a few stalks of it grew. They were j
about three to feet high to the top of the j
seed stalk.
Your Committee have thus presented i
the result of the experience of one of its j
members, upow the growth of what is cal- I
led the artificial grasses, in contradiction j
to the natural grasaes of the country.? i
The fact is to be ascertained, whether we .
have not grasses growing in our fields, i
which if cultivated, might not he equai
to any which is brought from abroad. It
is found that the rye graas grows spontaneous
in our fields, and if cultivated, ;
might prove of great value to us. In i
looking out for grasses, however, we
ought to look for those which grow from
the old root, arid not from the seed, be-;
- ? . i '
cause thoee which come Iroin the seed,;
never come to maturity early io the year
and are, therefore, not so beneficial as a
pasture grass.
So much has been written on the atib- j
jeet of grasses their values compared
with each other, the lime of cutting them ;
the manner of curing hay, Ate# that it is :
thought unnecessary to say anV thing,
hut what hay been the rssult of our expe- ,
l rienec. So well satisfied have # been ;
with the result of our experience, that we !
have determined to go into business upon j
a larger scale, with a view to the improvement
of the soil directly, by turning 1
under the clover j indirectly by procu- ,
ring .an abundance of food fur stock of alt i
kinds, without which manure cannot be ,
made. This we cipect to do by making
hav of herds graas and timothy. One of;
your committee has now on hand, rsady '
to Imj committed to the earth, thirty j
bushels of red top seed, cost in Philadel- ,
piiia sixty-two and a half cents per hush- |
el. Three bushels of tunolhy, cost in
Philadelphia four dollars twelve and a half j
cents per bushel. Nine bushels of clover t,
seed, cost in Philadelphia six dollars and j
fifty cents per bushel for part in New j
York. We have been thus particular in j
giving prices, because we known some of j
our citizens imposed upon in the purchase j
of grass seeds, f?>r want of a knowledge of
their current prices. Clover seed i? gen- j
crallysoldhv the pound, and a bushel j
weighs from sixty two to sixty-five
pounds.
We have thus, Mr. President, given j
our mite to aid a cause, which has been i
so long neglected in our state, but which ,
is now, we hope, nboi/t to rise to a high j
rank in the estimation of society. That I
the farmers will no longer suffer them- j
selves to be looked upon as beings of an j
inferior order, hut stand forth as they are j
the lords of the soil, the sovereigns of the I
country. R. G. MILLS,
Chairman.
Fishing Creek, Nov. 10, 1841.
])r. Granville Sharpe PalMson formerly
Professor of Anatomy in the Jefferson
Medical College is among the applicants
for the benefit of the General Bankrupt
Law, in New York city.
> v5 . r
0
CONGRESS. |
fi KNATK, I
The following r port of Ihe rerfta'ks bf Mr: |
Calhoun, when presenting the prMcoe<iln|fs of'
the Legi.?!a'ure of South Carolina; tfri^|ic fth ;
inst., ii by the odrrespoiiilcnt of the Charleston '
Mercury.
Mr. Calhoun said, he had received frovn J
the same source, the proceedings of his [
Legislature on the subject of the contro- j
versy between the States of Virginia and
New York, which he asked might he read, j
The report having been read, Mr. C. said ;
it would be seen that these proceedings j
grew out of a law passed by the State of
Virgirffans a rflcttsure of necessity to pro.
i ^ I k n?L>/ll r fn I .1^4 t U 4 IrsJtt jl
ICl/l IIVIKCH ao'" 1,1 l,,v; |>UMIITJII ,I.VIUI[|. u
by the State of New York, and that South
Carolina had backed Virginia in 'he position
she assumed, and had passed a similar
law. It was not his purpose to say a }
woid in vindication of the course pursued
by these two statah If any vindication
were necessary, it Was amply made by
the very able Report of the Legislature [
just read ; but he rote to ask i'ne earnest
and solemn attention of the Senate, and
especially Senators from the non-slaveholding
Stares, to the result of (he course
pursued by the Abolitionists. The present J
was a suitable occasion to do so, as it was (
one of the stages of its progress*. Whatever
doubt might have existed of the tendency
of the Abolition movement at its J
origin, there could he none now, that it ,
would end in the dissolution aud over.1
throw of the Government, if it was not
arrested, and speedily arrested. He would
pass over the result which had already to
a considerable extent been produced?
the estrangement of those who should he
the best of friends, and repeat lite profound
conviction, that the inevitable tendfcncy
of the abolition movement was to j
destroy the union of these States. Sla- I
very in the South, was not simple slavery,
but a political institution, and to her
tho most important and essential of all
others. What was the object of Divine
Providence in commingling the two race*
together in such large and nearly equal j
numbers, it was not for thena to inquire, j
They were, and it was only under the j
present relation of master and slave that }
they could exist. Break that relation,;
and the inevitable result must be, the expulsion
of, or destruction of one or the
other by forco. In this posture of affairs,
what was the course to be pursued
by the South? She must piotect and
defend herself by all the means placed |
within her power by the Constitution.? I
The communication betweeu the North (
and tho South has become daugerous to j
the latter, not because there was a body {
of fanatics in the North, but because they
wiclJ a power sufficient to gotern the
legislation of some of the States in passing
laws which a (feet the property and
endanger the institutions of the South,
and to counteract the mischevious tendency
of such laws, the Legislature of;
"" j' # %" 0 I
Virginia has, with consummate judgment, i
moderation and patriotism, made such j
amendments to her police laws as were |
rendered necessary, and South Carolina
has assumed a position by her side. What j
would he the result if the course now pur-1
sued by certain portions of the North 1
should be persisted in ? Why just in pro.
portion as the communication between
the two sections should become dan.
gofous, the' Southern Slates would move
in a body f they would he compelled to
move in a body, and pass laws restricting
the intercourse with the North, until the ;
communication would he slapped alto*
gethcr?by mail, as well as commercial,
for the nam*regulations will he applied to
stages, steamboats and railroad cars, as
to vessels navigating the ocean. This
do they would, and do they must. He
called upon gentlemen of the North, ho
appealed to them in the name of our corn "'in
munirv and nf naf riot ism. whether
...v.. -- r I
such a stale of things between the two
portions of this Union was desirable.
He referred to the proceedings in the
other wing of the capitol; he referred to
the proceedings of a Convention of four
hundred delegates recently held in New
York, in which the slaves of the Southern
States were invited ty leave their masters,
and the mode of doing it successfully,
pointed out to them, and they were promised
protection and nssistance when they
reached the North. He would not coin,
mr.-nt on the mistaken views relative to
the position of the Southern slaves, which
were entertained at the North, but would
assert, without the fear of contradiction,
that there was no body of laborers in any
portion of the world without the limits of
the United States, who were so comforta
blein their physical condition, or had so
great a proportion of the avails of their
labor applied to their benefit. He would
not contrast their condition with tint of
the white laborer in our own country. He
appealed to gentlemen from the North,
for the sake of our common country, to
exert their influence to put a stop to me*,
sures which, if persisted in, will destroy
one.third of the Union, and extirpate one
if not both the races that now inhabit itThe
remarks of i\fr. Calhoun were lis.
tened to with the most profound attention,
and ! cannot but hope fhat his earnest
apd solemn appeal will have a mast snlu.
tary effect. ' The document was then ordered
to be printed.
S!i.*v ?xvv_Vfh 7th.
States refusing (lie Ijand Distribution.
The following involution, submitted
j some ddjrs since by Mr. G'lAHV was then
i taken u(*f
! Rctblved, 'ifhiit the Committed on the
Pubiit: Lands be instructed to inquire into
the expediency of jtfovidfrfg by law that,
whenever any State or sUtes shall refuse
their proj)#rtion bf* the proceeds of the
puhlfc' land?, such proportion shall be dis
tributed among the residue of the assenting
States,'
Mr. King said he presumed the Senator
was not serious in presenting fhe resolution
; and, if he was not disprtfed to ask
action upon it, he would movt to lay the
subject on the table.
Mr. Clay said he had much niitfre rea- j
son to srtpposo the Senator waSfrotScrimrs i
in what he had said, than the Senator to
suppose he was not serious in offering his
resolution. He would toll the Senator
from Alabama what were his vie^s.upon
this subject. His resolution was' to hi- i
quire what should be done with the land 1
revenue appropriated to a State, when '
that state refused to receive the portion
thus appropriated* He would not make I
a hasty disposition of the land whrch any
Legislature, under the influence of party
feeling, miyht refuse to receive. Thaf,
he conc< ivi d< would be unj i$'t to (be pen- |
pie themselves, who, he thought, held
different opinions from their Lcgrsfrt(d(es i
upon this subject. He believed, how.
ever, that if the People continued to oh
ini'f ii E-f rl twn r>r 11 > r/in f .anials I itrftj uhrmlri
r; ",,vv ??
state thoir objections, that something
should be done with the lands thus refused.
He would rtsfc, what was to he
done? His opinion was, that aft* &ny
State perseveringly refused to redeivc
this land, it would he proper for Congress
to make some other disposition of the proportion
belonging to such State.
Mr. King said he did not think the
Senator was serious* He had tofrt us
over and over nga.n that the land belongkd
to tho states; and would he, because
a State regarded the land sales as a comO
g
mon fund, and declined to receive if, np.
propriate it to otiier Stafes? Did it belong
to tho State so refusfrtg, or to the
other States ? If it belonged to a dissenting
State, would they appropriate it 10
others because that state refiWtrd to receive
it ?
Mr. K closed with a call for the y?ris
and nays; which were ordered by tire
Senate*
Mr. Clay hoped ?jbartrld know how
many Would vote for andf how many
against this resolution. lie had said that
the land belonged to Alabama : and, if
they refused to receive it, what (ben ?
The case was like that of a father dispensing
his property to his children. If
one child refused to receivo his jrortion,
could not the father appropriate that
child's portton to the rest of the family?
The General Government, as the parent
of the States, had given the land to (he
states, and one of the family of States
had refused to receive her portion. Now,
if Alabama or South Carolina refiwed to
receive her portion, let it bcr given to others.
lie was ready to vote for (h'? proposition
at any moment.
Gentlemen had called the distribution
policy one of robbery and plunder. How
robbery? H<?w plunder? If ho was
disposed ]to retort, he might show thot
the robbery rested net with the receiving
states. Nothing was to he gained by
this language. Who wcro the robbers ?
Congress was the agent of this robbery,
and the states the receivers of the stolen
goods. Congress, aft* f ten years labor,
ing to effect the object, had paasod ttvfe
bill, and the people of the states receiving
'.heir proportions would have had the ben.
crfits of it. And this was called robbery.
What was to be gained by sueb cfimirM*
tion ? What was the question submitted 7
It was one of distribution, involving iiidi.
rect taxation to the extent of supplying
the means in the Treastrfv withdrawn
from it by the bill. It proposed that the
Government should be hereafter carried
on without relying upon tho land fund
which belonged to the states.
Mr. Calhoun said that the Senator
from Kentucky showed profound iguor.
ance if he expected that South Carolina
could be bribed try this fiiftd. Nineteen
twentieths of the people of his state were
opposed to this hill. It was a great question,
and he held it as far more important
than gentlemen upon either Hide ot the
Chamber. It was n question of revenuo
?of union ; and, if a hold man were to
desire the dissolution of the Union, he
con!J not wish a stronger means to accomplish
it. He knew that (he Senator from
Kentucky was ardently attached to this
Union, and therefore cheerfully acquitted
him of any such object in his defence of
this measure; but any man wishing to
accomplish this could not have the way
more clearly pointed out than by the operations
of this measure.
Mr. C. proceeded to comment upon
this measure as one of revenue. The effect,
lie said, was to make orte-third of
the Union fiat the to* w"hich wruld be
created by the withdrawal of this fund.
The tax-paying portions of the country
had to pay the tax created by withdrawing
the money from the National Treasury
through the operation* of the distribution
bill. In regard to the land, theques!
tion was, whether the (and belonged to
the States or the Union. If it belonged
to the Union, you had no right to touch
a dollar of it. South Carolina nnd Alabama
regarded it as belonging to tho
Union ; and,* so regarding it, they hid5 <J%j3
thought it improper to npprbpridte thr
money to Slate purposes . In regard to .
the immediate question before the Senate, .- --SEflj a
htf hoped the Senator would go to - aH
lengths, and carry out his objects. He.
saw light ahead, and in two years alt of
the measures of the party who had made
this tfifddf tWeff measures', would bo swept V* ^
Mr. stalth, of Indian#, stated this fei^
i sons why he should rtrffi fn fai ?r of the
j. resolution} though he would .not hav<*: v'
1 isetf, ft# Said, had not the yeas and nayr heen
called. As a matter of courtesy,-'
he should vote for the proposed inquiry.'
It had not been usual to refuse to authorise
suc'n inquiries, when asked for. * In
\oting for the inquiry, in no way did lie'
* ommit himself upon the matter involved
\ >n the inquiry. His impressions wore,
however, in opposithm to that disposition
'of the refused d/sfrikufion which might*
he inferred front rhe resolution submitted.
Mr. S. complained also tff the dH?" . oj
cussion which* ?md arisen on thiif-hfejdet "1
(nsoiH (ft' place', hnd.gtfy# fWlltftf that
utkun I I % a 11 Ir\ Vor\ua I tkw l<frwl'
wilt; II Uiv; ifiu iv i |||? IflllU uvoiuvw
tion act came up- for consideration/ hcf
| should go fully into the subject/
: Mr. Allen continued, the debate.
| rose not to discuss th'e immediate questtoif
i raised by the Senators from South Urfro*'
; iina and Alabama, lie wished to say
that he concurred in the remark, that the
question was whether we should leafre if
to the states to lay taxes for Sittc p irposes,
or an indirect tax by the" General
Government for State purposes. Sbalfthe
State lax itself for its own purposes,"
or should the taxing power of this Gov
: rftrment be exerted to,support the States?
lie rose to say that this was tho question' ^
I at issue, and no othef. He tone to Ex.,
! this admissirm, made by the friends of .
the bill. Shall, then, the Stale Governments
tax themselves for-their own oh*'
jects, or shall the General Government"
be taxed for these objects?
Mr. (/lay said be hoped itlfii IfWF <fcrlflro.,
j ?ty of eitil war which/ tWtf tfMffie of
his remarks', the SehfttOf from Ohio pre.'
; dieted asriconsequence of this.alt of tho
last session' would he averted. Thflrt
an argument to frighten old wtftflenwifh.
Oml war! for what 7 Fof passing a di?-'^
tribution bill. In regard to the question'
argued by the Senator from Ohio, if if1
wa* properly stated, Mr, C. hoped ho* ' \
! would reiterate it until it was beard hy'"M*
{ every man. and women, nnd ohiki in thef*" wH
country. He had him.olf over and over"
! agairt declarer! that there was n? p<Jwht' y
I in the Constitution to levy taxes for tho!
purposes of di-tribution. No o/w on InV ... >
side of the question had ever contend-d - J j
for such a power. The nearest appro*** .'*?
matron to it was the recornmetidntfoirf of
i thtf ?fenatOf'? friend ni the Hermitage**
Gcffitfral J,tcfcso?r, who proposed tt distri-' ^
bution after taxes had beep levied. Now,*
S what did the friends of the distribution
| policy propose ? Nothing more than this*
j The public land was the common proper/
tv of the Slates, and the Whigs proposed ~ :
to give to the states what was their owuv
Was this robbery? Was it pluidee't
i Now, said Mr. Clay, will'the SvnatW
| from Ohio stato me fairly ? If he will*- .
Ire will but repeat what the Whig* have
| consfrtMly proclaimed upon this floor for
ten long years: that the land belongatf
! to lire stales, and tfie Whigs proposed tOf ' . ' ,
: give them what was already' their Ok**. > ^ ^
! Mr. Clay then replied very briefly (n - v- - *
..ft. a * I < .t... J ! . /. * ' '{#> r'<jS&
1 tr*> last remarK* or ine rrenaior from* ->?/- m
I South Carolina. He j?hM he did not profess
to kn<nv much of the pwple of South' , J
i Carolina* JAe had never been in th?r ; ; ^
state, and had only had the pleasure otf ^ . *
communicating with gentlemen of that >. . - t r
?5* he had met them in one or other
of the branches of Congress. In regard .
to the question under consideration^ ho
i neither knew, nor?with respect he said
| It-?cared whether the state vrouid receive
the money or not.
But (continued Mr. C ) the Senator front.
I South Ciroliua thinks the1 (treasure will lead
j to disunion. . ,
Mr. (jafioun slid, by way of expfanatiuty *
thrft the tendency of the measure would
to lead to (I'sunion.
[ Mr. Clay said he thought differeW^ sod
i that the effect of th'?f tfistrrbuiitnr would, <ui
the contrary, be one ot thp strongest bonds of
I I lf>> I 7(11(1(1
Mr. VYoodhury tboti^bt tlW Steoaetor front
[Kentucky must be tinder name mistake as to
the receipts from lands under the distribution . *
bill. The title to the land was with the gene,
j ral government. It.was a truat fund. Tim
i money deceived from the sales of land would
go into'the Treasury. It one 6f tho Stated
j refused to receive its proportion of the mocrny
j from the sale of land, it would go iuto> thw
i Treasury, and would be confiscated and ap*.
i preprinted to (he euuwnou pu'posej of tb?
' Union.
In regard to the effect rtpos the faees of
the Union* it was obvious that the State#
would be taxed f?>r their fulf proportion re- ..T
ceived under the distribution bdl. m>p?
fttdehfed States would have to submit to an
indirect taxation lor the support of lbs G'or1
crnment. The operation 6f the' scheme was s
} tct compel indirect taxation for the purposes of .
| distribution.
! Mr. Allen thought he tad not' misrepresent,
j ed the Senator from Kentucky, for. the reason
I that the effect of his proposition would lead to
the results lie had named. The' system* "war
a stre^b of the taxhg power, afl'-icting the
: peope, and two millions and a h*J had l)U
ready oeen lost to :he Peopte by it
1 Mr. Mangum moved to amend the retold*
' lion by add ug thereto the words 44 or in whnt
manner thi*e proportions ought to be disposed
of, or .whether any <j'S|>oaiuoa ought to b#
made of them.'' f
v !"* ;.r' . * %
JV *-Jt ' ,# *.. a - ... ""-dfci
yi/*-. \ A, * v W<*- Jrft '*A * ' ' Jl** * - ?