The daily phoenix. (Columbia, S.C.) 1865-1878, December 23, 1871, Image 2
r J! arni'] lkmm*~u~vm i tax ^isf^
V>Uf UAJ UlJiUX. I U, i V.
8atnr?ay'Morning. Pcccmbsr 23.1871.
Tita Kellar-, of Impeachment by tit?
to impeach Scott and Parker baa felled;
It ia MfjMtJed, and very commonly r?e
llleved, that the money of Scott aid
Parker aeoared tba defeat of the iin
peaoboaent effort. The money stolen bj
tba ria? ha? been ?ed to defeat the peo?
ple from whom the money has be}n
|atoIen43?jjtij^ ??r(- a t?me, wpo
the day? *ad BBiBEini done ita corrupt
'work. ~ Eight upon, tho heels of the ex
pojare^of the Joint Invesligatiog Ooln
jnltl?ee '??be legislativo majority of the
Houso naya.'let Scott and Parker go.
tWe. now declare wa? o poo this legislative
|maJo-rftjr.~ ihell call these people,
-Iront Speaker Muses down, to account
before the public tribunal. . They have
'grossly betrayed the publio interests and
7? elded ; ta . the. po wer of m 0 o ey. Pur*
:oaased'''hf-SooU* and Parjter! Soul
"olavesKrWe now Bummon our friande tu
minontynave made a good effort, what?
ever the motive. iOatside ot the Legis?
lature let oa now move, ' for the ring
mast and shall !be destroyed, TBUTH
and JD8TI0B haye] deolared t*, and shall
their decree not stand? - i
The Arong Kxpaoted Report.
We received on yesterday, from one
of the oommittee, a copy of the "Report
of the Joint Special Financial Investigating
Committee, appointed by the General As?
sembly, at its regular tension, 1870-71,"
Bi Ft"Whittemore and S. A. S wai la be?
ing' the oommittee on the part of the
Senate, and John B. Dennis, W. H,
Gardner, Jr., and Timothy Hurley be?
ing the oommittee on the part of the
House of Representativos. This is a re?
markiiblo pamphlet ot nearly 300 pages
of matter. It o o vern a large field, and
one which it seems that the oommit?
tee have well explored through all its
dark ways and devious windings and
Serbonian bogs. The joint oommittee
examined the State Treasury, receipt?
and expenditures, appropriations, de?
posita in banks, the enrollment and or?
ganization of the militia, and the em?
ployment of an armed force, the Land
Commission, ' the Financial Board, the
publie debt, contingent liabilities of the
State, the Sinking Fund Commission,
bills of the> Bank ot the State, phos?
phates, ?ko. This, with numerous tables
and statements, makes up a record of
corruption, fraud and robbery that will
shock the sensibilities -of the country.
The operations of Gov. Scott and Adju?
tant-General Moses in connection with
the purchase of the State arms will
show these swindling officials in their
true colors.
We have not had time as yet to ana?
lyze this monstrous record of the extra?
vagance and the plundering of the State
officials. If, upon the showing, the Le?
gislature does not proceed to call Scott,
Parker and others to account, then must
the legislative majority share in the
shame of the most corrupt regime that
the oiviliaed world ever saw.
This committee buvo brought much to
light that but for them would have re?
mained hid. Whoever the members of the
committee or whatever their motives may
be-good, bad or mixed-they have done
the State an essential service, and opened
the way to the unveiling of a gigantic
system of fraud and robbery. We shall
refer frequently to this report. It is n
mine, whence we expect to draw material
enough to keep up, for a long time, the
fire, by means of whioh we expect ere
long to consume this corrupting, deadlj
growth that covers with its upas-like in?
fluence all the departments of our local
Government. When tho veils aro torc
away all, what a spectacle will the Mo
kaunas-the veiled prophets-of the
State present? Swift thought of a coun?
try where horses were the rulers aud
men were the subjects. He novel
.. dreamed of a State, in the ni noleen tl
oentury, where men-high-minded men
-were to be the ruled, and rogues and
swindlers the rulers.
One Isaao H. Hunter, of North Caro?
line, a young negro man, lately lectured
in New York, to a mixed andienco ol
about forty persona. He strongly advo?
cated universal amnesty for the South,
and believed that the effect would be to
harmonize the raoes and to promote all
the industries. Hunter, whose head ic
evidently level, was very severe on thc
carpet-bsggers, who, he says, infest the
South, by pretence of friendship, secure
the colored vote, and then rob the coun?
try of all they can lay their hands on.
Hunter further thinks inut universal
amnesty would do away with standing
armies and oarpet-bag politicians. Very
good for Hunter. Not a bad Hunter is
he.
Mr. Greeley also spoke on this occa?
sion, and represented his well known
views in favor of amnesty, of which he
bas been long an advocate. Well done,
Hnnter and Greeley 1
The Columbia Board ot Trade had a
large and spirited meeting, last evening,
to advance those interests with which
they have charged themselves in behalf
of this oity. Upon motion, 1,000 copies
of the law proceedings, thus far insti?
tuted, with the accompanying affidavits
against the Oity Oouuoil and the parties
connected with the Oity Hall, were or?
dered to be printed. These pamphlets
will bo ready this morning, and will be
lound at the store of the Messrs. B war?
field.
Th? H?!> ?wi?-"!?.
We Lave already published the sob-1
stance of tho sworn uib\d* vita 4M thia
snbjeot, of Mvftars. Troy ?fad Fry, lpf Mr.
E. J. Booti. Mr. 0. Et1 Baldwiffj, Mr*
Hardy Solomon and Mr. il, D. S#n; a 11
of which went to ?hoj?tb*?..the. groper
contract price of the City. Hail was about
$80,000; and that certain members, if
not al), of the City Oonnoil knew this
faot, and yet snffered the cont rao t to
bo yarded, to Allen, for ,5138, OOO -at
lojx't-.feQ.Q?? JO?SL ^e.-IegUimate^QoOi
tract price, fho matter bas ?ince aa
Humed no ol ber form, and tho proofs of a
regularly organised conspiracy to de?
fraud the city out of a large sum of
Vi w4 iipbn* rsoprd ; Tbi8 re?
sult-ibis unveiling of au infam?os
transaction-ia due't o the course t ken
at the.last i^y, Mesara, Clark Waripg, Ii.
W. J o li o sou and Mr, Parkins, the archi?
tect. Tliey properly determined to make
a full and candid disclosure of all the
facta that tbey were conversant With.
Thoy bave taken their place with the
good, citizens of the city, and are ready
to unite with them in tl?e effort to pro?
tect the public inVereatfj... They have
bb oiren well. Tbe > affld avi tn I of1 'Mesera,
Waring, Johnson and parkina are very
important. We give these . Affidavits.
Tbey will speak for themselves, Tbey
give the main grounds upon which tbe
prosecutors, through their attorneyp,
Messrs. Waties & Bacbman, and McMas?
ter and LeOonte,?and J. T. Rhett, Esq.,
make the charge of conspiracy to de?
fraud the oily, against Comptroller-Gen?
eral Neagle, State Sanator J. M. Allen
and Alderman and Judge of Probate
W. H. Wigg. The whole matter is now
in tbe hands of tho law. Until Decem?
ber 27 next, the present injunction and
reatraiut stand. .The following -are'til?
affidavits referred to;
AFFIDAVIT Of R. "W. JOHNSON.-Per?
sonally appeared before me, Robert W.
Johnson, who, on oath, says that he wai
appivHuuoa vj vii ?r?fXA> nwgia ?uuu
the'last of tho eu mm er or tho first of tin
fall, who introduced the subject of th?
Oily Hall; said that a good deal of worl
would be done here; suggested that thi
contractors who would bid should mak<
liberal estimates, ?nd not work for no
thing, and proposed that the workahoub
be divided ont amongst the contractor
-the brick work to one, the carpen te
work to one, and the mill work to tb
other. Tbe brick work was to be fo
Mr. Clark Waring; the carpenter -worl
and mill work was for James M. Allei
and myself-as to the division of wbiol
it was not then clearly defined. I toi
him I did not see how his plan wool
work. He answered me that it woul
work; that be could sud would so tl
mattera that it would have to work; tba
bo oonld tie up the money and block tb
matter. I Baw him again, and tallie
on this matter a second time, an
to the same purport. Both of these coi
versations were before the plana an
specifications came. The evening th
plans and specifications came, Dr. Nei
gie told me that they had come, and th
bids would b? advertised in the mort
ing'a PHOENIX-at the same time reques
ing me to go to the Asylum, and est
mate what I would ask to finish Allen
1 contract, showing me at the same tin
Allen's contract, assigned to him.
spent several days at it, sent in my esl
mate, and have never heard from it sine
We, on that occasion, again discuss*
the matter of tbe City Hall. He urgi
' again the proposition made at our fir
interview, paying, moreover, that 1
wished the contract awarded to Mr. /
lon. He expected me to bid, and so b
that the contract should b*< awarded
1 Mr. Allen.
About 1 o'clock on the day that it'w
i advertised that the bids were to be dos
' at 12 o'clock, Di*. Neagle came to me.
1 bad Bupposeil that the bids were th
1 closed, according to the ?dvertiaemei
i He solicited me to bid, naming t
i amount-I do not recollect now wb
I amount that was-allowing me a h
hour to hand in my bid. I did sot ha:
' in my bid at that time. I went home
> my dinner, and went in the country
' look after some work, and got rid
the matter. .On my return, I u
James M. Allen, and I informed b
1 that I would not bid, as I had li
i no time to make a proper estima
? He intimated that the mutter would
, fixed up, anyhow; I think he used I
words "wo wonld fix the matter." J i
deratood from bim that he desired me
I make the bid; we parted. Later in I
r evening, about 5 o'clock, I was at 1
j Wing's mill; Mr. W. H. Wigg, Chairm
of the Building Committee, rode np a
1 solicited my bid. I told Mr. Wigg I <
' not wish to bid, os I was not pr?par?e
having had no proper opportunity
make an estimate. Mr. Wigg appeal
disappointed and hesitated. I intimai
' to Mr. Wigg that the time for biddi
1 was out. He said he had extended i
f time to half-past 5, and intimated tba
. was for the purpose of getting my b
I think ho said they were waiting for t
Mr. W. H. Wigg drove off. Very shot
1 after that Mr. J. L. Neagle drove up e
i culled to me, saying: "Halloo, Johns*
i yon have left me." I then went up
( Dr. Neagle and said: "Doctor, I do i
wish to bid." He then requested me
' put in a bid of 8141,000. X suid to b
i "Doctor, that is enormous." He tl
. toldme that it was only 83,500 over
bid that would take the contract,
then told me wbut the bids were that 1
been made; ui Mr. Waring's and 1
' Alien's each. I said, I do not wish
bid. He Baid those who wish help m
help others. I gave Neagle to und
stand that I would put in the bid s
gested. I walked, then, to Dr. Wilso
new building and found Mr. Wigg.
said to bim, I believe I will make a p
at it. I fixed up the bid, 8141,500; w
round about 0 o'clock to IUr. Wig
office, and banded it to him. Ne
having the plans or specifications, I o
not say wbut would be a fair price for
work. J do say that all the bids w
enormous, in my judgment. I recen
mot Dr. ?eagle and asked him if he 1
awarded the whole contract to Mr. \
ring. He said, uotjali o? it; I wish }
to do a good deal of that york,
spoke of the City Hall contract.' T
con verna lion took placo about a w<
ago. R. W. JOHNSON
Sworn to before me this 10th day
December.
I WINTHROP WILLIAMS.
Notary Public
AFFIDAVIT OP CJAUK WAWNQ.-T
sonni ly appeared before me Clark \
ring, who, ca oath, says thai ?OBI? time
in tba first part ot tbe full, or (be lest
part of ibo summer, be was approached
oyJ. Xi. Nea?le on Ibe ,*ubjeet ol the
?^lding,ot tho City Hal!, w h otto gusted
that tbe oon tractors sh cold ?oTwdas to
seoare ai f?ir remuneration for their
work ; .ibat yoar deponent agreed 1 witb
him. This was mentioned beTore Ibo
contract was io be given ont That after?
wards, to wit: justbefore the giving out
of the oon tract, he said J. L. Neagle aaw
him nt or in the immediate vicinity of
Mr. Wigg's office. This was within fi
few months of riiy bainding hi my bid,
and within about tbe Isafe hour of the?
expiration of the time Coe bidding. Tbe
Building Committee wa? in Mr; Wigg's
offioe. Mr. J. L. Neagle snggested to
me tbe amount ($140,000) tbat I sbonld
bid, and I pat in the said bid in accord?
ance wj tb bis suggestion. I had no
time, nor could I have tbeu made Dor?
ree t ettim ates. Afterwards, Mtv Jv L.
Neagle brought me a contract, saying
tbat it was drawn by bis lawyer, tbe im?
port of which was, that I sbonld take
Mr. Allen's oontraot for a price left
blank. Then afterwards he wrote a lot?
ter to him, ft copy of which is altaohod
to this affidavit. I agreed to tbe terms
expressed therein, and went to work on
thom, to wit: for tho som of 685,000.
Mr. J. Li. Neagle paid me some money
on account. I think 885,000 to be a fair
Srice for the Whole building, done np in
ret-rale order, first class work, in ac?
cordance with tbe plan and npecifloa
tiona of tho arohiteot, Mr. Parkins.
CLARK WARING.
S~crn to bofore me, this 19th Decem?
ber, 1871 W. S. MONTEITH, I
Notary Public
COLUMBIA, S. C., October 12, 1971.
C. Waring, Esq.-DEAR Sin: I am
fully authorized by Mr. James M. Allen,
in writing, to say that be will execute
tbe oontraot I handed you yesterday;
and I now agree for himself and myself
to pay yon $85,000 for the execution of
his oontraot with the City Gounod of
Columbia, for the ereotion of a City
Hall; and further agree to execute the
said oontraot handed you yesterday, on
my return to the city, which will be
within this mouth. Very respectfully,
(Signed) J. L. NEAGLE.
Copy of originel letter banded to me
by Clark Waring, and verified by Messrs,
Shiver and Rhett. 1
W. C. SWAFF1?LD.
AFFIDAVIT No. 2 OF CLARK WABINO.
Personally appeared before me Clark
Waring, Esq , who, on oath, says that
be received, tc-day, 20th December,
1871, the letter from Mr. Parkins and
the estimate enclosed for the City Hall,
of which oorreot copies aro attached to
this affidavit. The lettet I opened in
the pr?senos of Mr. W.C. Swaffield, and
I showed to him the contents. I desire
to state, as supplementary to my affida?
vit of yesterday, that I told Mr. W. H.
Wifcjg that the time was too short to esti?
mate iu. Mr. W. H. Wigg said he
could not allow the plans to leave bis
offioe except at night. C. WARING.
Sworn to before me, 20th December,
1871. TKOS. J. LAMOTTE,
* Notary Public
ATLANTA, GA., December 18, 1871.
G. Waring, Esq.-DEAR SIB: En ot osad
I send you a dctuiled estimate ot City
Hall made by ns. I am sorry to keep
yon waiting, bnt it was unavoidable.
Now, then, as I take the DAILY PUOSNIX,
I am kept posted as to the action of the
Board of Trade, ko. Mecsrs. Fry and
Troy have an estimate too low. I am
satisfied of that, for I have looked the
matter over carefully, aocording to the
catalogues of iron work in our offioe, and
from information that I have in the
getting np of iron work on the Kimball
House, the sum I have set down is little
enough to insure good work and a fair
profit of twenty per cent. 1 have con?
sulted our plumbers, gas fitters and
paiutera, and I do not think I have over?
estimated a .thing-unless it might be
doors, sashes and blinds, and that would
be the difference of freight to Columbia.
Glass-French plate-is considerably
higher since the war (Franco-Prussian)
than bofore. It coats heavy, when you
come to paint brick work. It absorbs
so mnch oil-we know, from experience
on the Kimball Hoase. The brick work
I pat at the prices yon and I named in
the hotel. I always figuro carper t T
work in tbe bulk, which, to me, is the
best. Mr. Peck, here, thinks my figures
named too high for carpenters' work.
As things have assumed such a shape, I
desire to say this: That so far as I am
ooucerned, I fear that tho committee
will have to answer the stigma that
the citizens have brought about. I
have simply said yes and no to com?
mittees. My private opinion has been
in reserve, os you well know. Had I
been asked questions by the Building or
Special Committee, as to the cost, my
opinion would then have been clear aud
not misrepresented. I hope, however,
the oitizenB will not pass Bnup judgment
upon you and Mr. Johnson, witbont first
looking into the matter. If Messrs. Fry
and Troy take tbat job at that price, they
will certainly lose money. Now, then,
this estimate is for your uwn private use.
If any questions are asked, you may say
that I say it cannot be built for that
amount.
As to those srohes in church, do them
as you think best. If there is any other
mle in arranging, by which tho termina?
tions of arabes are made, please do them
accordingly. Trusting to your good
judgment, I am, yours, Seo.,
(Sighed) W. A. PARKINS.
I Hero follows estimate of City Hall,
Columbia, S. C., by Parkina & Allen,
Architects, Atlanta, Ga., footing up and
making the sum of $88,407.95.]
Tbi? matter is now before the com?
munity. It will bo seen bow far onr afr
formations have been established. Wo
congratulate the citizens upon the indi?
cations that tbny will at least be saved
the sum of $50,000 or. $60,000. For
farther information upou this subject,
wo refer the citizens to the pamphlet or?
dered by tho Board of Trade, aud which
will be found to contain all the affidavits
and orders made thus far iu behalf of tho
prosecution.
The committees in tho several Coun?
ties of the State, charged with tho col?
lection of funds to make np counsel
fees, aro requested to tinko their reporte
at onee to General Hampton, Chairman,
at Columbia, S. C.
Road tho developments contained in
this issue, and seo the conspiracy un?
veiled, whereby it was arranged to rob
the oity oj over $50,000- Press the ringi
II I in I ILLmilUJULJil Ul I I U 1 ...
Tit? Murder or Murphy.
Waoall attention to Major Morgans
communication, published below. The
murder ol poo* Murphy vas . fool one,
and yet va IsaVfc that BO efforts what?
! ever ha ve toto 061*3 o to discover the per?
petrators of tb? outrage. Ia it not the
doty ol the ffovernor to issuo hia pro?
clamation offor|og a reward, for the dis?
covery of the murderer or murderers?
Is thia thing to be suffered to paas un?
noticed and qnhoded by the aa t hori t ios?
Are we withopt law, except the law of
robbery? Bead Major Morgan's lettor.
Ho is a moat intelligent and reliable
gentleman, ?od a valuable citizen:
HAMPTON PLANTATION, Deo. 21, 1871.
Editors Columbia Phonix~B\Ka : Being
a stranger io your -midst, and having
uni j recently moved into your diet rio t, 1
would be moon obliged if yon would en?
lighten me in certain particulars aa to
tho customs and habits of your people,
irrespective of race, color, or political
opinions. I mowed on to thia plantation
on the evening of the 18tb, and no
sooner had arrived than I was compelled
to separate two ladies of color, who
were lighting with carving-knives. Thia
was very refreshing to a tired man,
wanting to go to sleep; and by way of
making me feel, more secure and com?
fortable, I was informed, the next morn
lag? that a whito man bad been mur?
dered at the railroad pump, on this place.
And I must aay, that it waa very re?
assuring to eeo that the papera actually
noticed the fact that a murder had taken
place, and devoted aotually ten or twelve
lines to recording it. But have no steps
been taken to find ont who the murder?
ers were? Ia it too true that the mur?
dered Irishman was only a white mau?
But, unfortunately, I labor under asimi?
lar disability or affliction myself, and it
is painful to my amour propre to think
that, if I am murdered to-night, no mort
notice will be taken of my demiau than
has been taken of that of Mr. Murphy.
This plantation has between 2U0 and
SOO negroes on it, and they are notori?
ously the most rascally gaug in th?
country. Why were no inquiries madt
amongst them? I don ft pretend to sa j
that it waa negroes who committed tht
murder; but why, at the same time, wai
there not some examination as to when
I the white men who live in the neighbor
hood were, ou the night of the murder
myself amoug the number? As the Go
vernor ia too bust/ to take notice of m
trifling a matter us tho murder of a whiti
man, will thu gentlemen of Richland jon
me in offering a reward for the detectioi
of the criminals? The viotim wus poor
and bad few or no frionds, I hour,
myself never Laving seen him, speal
only from hearsay. But does that justif;
his murder being passed over in ulmus
total silence? lc is n pity that this fou
murder cannot be traced to the Ku Kin
Klan, so that we would have marti?
law-for any law would be better thai
the state of anarchy prevailing in tbi
neighborhood. And this is thu oouutr
that civilized foreigners aie invited t
settle in I It sounds too much lik
"Will yon walk into my parlor? sai
the spider to the fly." A naval o iliac
! moe sent to report upon tho custom
I "ad manners of a cannibal tribe ia th
i'uciflo, made the following brief repori
"Their oustoma are bad; and, as fe
manners, they have none." I siuccrel
trust my experience in Richland will nc
force me to the same conclusion. I an
respectfully yours, J. M. MORGAN.
NEGRO KU KL?XISH.-The York vii
Enquirer gives a long account of tl
operations of a body of negro outlav
in York. Col. Merrill had hotter loc
oat for his laurels. Will he stamp 01
j negro outlawry, as hu prides himself c
j stamping tho life out of white Ku Klu
ism. Let Colonel Merrill look after tl
peace of his little principality.
Observe the wood notice of Messi
C. E. Thomas ?fe Co. They are rehab
wood dealers.
< m ? ?
Board of Ti nat, ea of Columbia Fe mn
College.
This board, as recently constituted I
set of South Carolina Conference,
hereby called to mest up-stairs, at t
office of Christian Neighbor, on Tnesdu
January ?), at 1% o'olook P. M.
J. W. KELLY.
Thc board, as at present constitute
oonsists of the following persons; J. 1
Kully, chairman; S. H. Browne, ]
Brown, T. G. Herbert, R. P. Franl
H. M. Mood, H A. C. Walker, W.
Fleming, A. J. Canthen, O. A. Dari
J. H. Zimmerman and E. J. Meyunrd
clericals; J. W. Parker, L. D. Chili
i R. D. Se un, J. H. Ki osier. Wade Han:
ton, Sr., R. C. Shiver, J. H. Kinard,
H. Baldwin, E. T. Rombert, W. L. C
Pass, W. L, J. Reidtind ft. T. Wrigl
laymen.
This meeting of the board is imp*
taut, and all are respectfully request
to be present.? Thp session may cou
nae on Wednesday, the lUth. Traveli
expenses will be paid, if necessary, u
homes will bo provided for those Iron
distance, if desired, J. W. K
St??r Papers friendly to the ipstitqti
j will please oopy.
I Sour? CAROLINA SECURITIES IN N
j YORK.-Tho New York Herald, of Tu
1 day, the 19th instant, iu its financ
? review, says: "Tho Southern lint \
< depressed by the newspaper ucaoni te
' recent proceedings in tho Legislature*
! South Carolina and Virginia. 'J
bonds of the former State were acliv
weak on tho oSlclal report of au uv
issue, and the mow July issue fell
thirty-live.''
--
DROWNKP IN A MIL EY TIVER.-T
colored men undertook tu cronu Ash
River Woduesday afternoon in a buttei
loaded with wood, When they got m
way in the river they swamped, and t
of them, with poe arm. was drown
The other was saved by a boat, wh
went to his resnue from tho Suvaui
and Charleston Railroad wharf, where
, wus taken in nattily. -Char lesion Court
-.-*?++-*
GIN HOCMB, Seo , BURNED.-Un Thu
day night last the gin-house, gin goarii
about ten bales of seed cotton, u war.
and several other articles, belonging
Gen. Wullaoe, were totally destroyed
Are. Loss from $1,200 to $1,500. I
not known how the Are occurred,
[Union Times
I Cold reuther prevails in Europe as
thia country.' At tho thermome
bas markdd eight below zero, and I
cold has been' ex pert erl efd 'in other
calitiea.'
THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT OOUBT
TBIAII OF EU KLUX OASES.-FRIDAY,
December 21.-The court convened et
ll A. M.,IIon.HugbL. Bond nud Hon.
George 8. li ry an presiding.
Mr. Chamberlain closed the argument
folvlbfejrt&seontion in the oms? ol the
United States vs. Thomas B. Wbitesides
and John W. Mitchell-the counsel for
the defence having bsen beard yester?
day'. Ho referred, in his opening re?
marks, to the identity, in its most impor?
tant fea tores, of the case in band with
that of th? One previously argued, in
whioh B. H. Mitchell WM defendant, and
regretted that, on thiaaoooant, he would
be forced to repeat, in a great measure,
the views presented by him there, inns
much as he would not be allowed to pr??
same that the jary were cognizant of
aught relating to the nature of the
offence . charged, eave ?hat may have
been brought: to their knowledge ia the
inrestigation and argument of the case
now before them. - There was one point
of difference, however, betweea the two
oases, to .which be desired.to advert, and
that was, that the defendants, Themas
B. Wbitesides and John W. Mitchell,
unlike Robert Hayes Mitchell, were not
the ignorant dupes of others,, and led
against their inclination and without a
proper appreciation of the oonseqnenoeB
into this vile conspiracy, bat were men
of property, intelligence and influence
in their community, who would not
deign to follow, but aspired to lead, and
who should be made to shoulder the fall
responsibility of their actions. The
speaker then, following the line of hie
former urgument, tcok np first the writ?
ten constitution and by-laws of the Eu
Klux Klan, and endeavored to fasten
upon the organization tho criminal cha
rooter charged in the indictment, by tb?
terms of its written agreement. First,
be would note the expression, "We arc
on tho side of oonstitutional liberty, at
bequeathed to us in its parity by om
lorefatberu"-au iunooent expression
enough at first glance, but, when viewec
by the light of its surroundings, preg
nant with tho most portentous meaning
The testimony of Davis, be said, dis
dosed the true meaning of the words t<
be the constitution, without the thir
teentb, fourteenth and fifteenth amend
meuts, tbe constitution that recognize!
slavery, and by authority of which, tin
'poo: slave, though ho might h~?
escaped within a footstep of the shore
of Cn tjudu, could be dragged back agaii
to the master's lash. He then revertei
to tho provisions of the Ku Klux agree
ment, requiring members to be armed
disguised uud furnished with signal in
strumeuts, and the subsequent article
prohibiting the admibaion uf auy perso;
of color; all uf which, be maintained
pointed inevitably to the conclusion
1st. By tbe anning, thu going in dit
guise, the secrecy, aud the terrihl
penalty of death affixed for the Haft
keeping of their secrets, that tbe put
pose was unlawful, aud snob, as coal
not stand the scrutiny of the open ligfc
of day. 2 1 By the provision prohibit
ing persons of color from membership,
that it was directed against that class c
people; and 3d. That by the declare
opposition to the thirteenth, fourteeut
and fifteenth amendments, was discovei
ed the intention to interfere aud prevei
the froe exeroise of the right of votin j
this right being dependent upon thot
amendments. These facts, he claimer
reasonably inferred from the puraseoiog
of the written ugreement, coupled wit
j the declarations of confessed member
I and confirmed by tho character of tl
I atrocities perpetrated in pursuance i
thu objects of tho organization, wei
proof as strong as holy writ, that tl
pupoaes of the conspiracy were suoh i
were charged in the indictment. Tl
evidence adduced to connect the defen
auts with this conspiracy, was then r
viewed at length, and the ooofitotii
testimony us to the presence of the d
fendauts at tho whipping of Charl
Leach, explained in a manner aatisfa
i tory to the prosecution.
I J migo Bond repeated to the jury tl
! same charge, with a change only
j names and dates, that be had given upt
the submission of the ouse of Bobe
; Hu\ os Mitchell, und they retired to thi
j room.
At 4 P. M., the jury not having i
' turned, the court took a recess until
I P. M.
! Court convened at G o'clock, purst,?
j to adjournment, when the jury return
I to the court room, the foreman annoui
; ing their failure to agree upou a verdi
Judge Bond ordered the jury to a rcoc
sideratinu of the case, and the verd
not being returned at 9 o'clock last nigl
the court adjourned over to Weduesd
morning,, the 27th, at ll o'clock; t
jory being looked up.
-:-s
A small billi pup and a Now found la
? dog were engiged in a long fight ni
. tbe Lakeview (N. J.) depot, on the ?
Railway, ono day lust week. The b
tie would undoubtedly have eaded ii
draw, had not tbe little dog palled 1
i antagonist on tho track nod held h
there until a train came along The !
| tie dog crouched down, and the tn
went over him without hurting bi
' while the big dog was ground to sansi
meat. Affidavits oun he produced
prove this assertion from th? Erie R
road agent of that station.
We understand that arrangements i
being mode to laud the Grand Duke
Pensacola-nut, we suppose, howev
' until after Grant has put him ashore
Charleston and pointed ont a sprig
j the Russian form of government wh
he bas planted and is endeavoring
! cultivate in South Carolina. It won
doubtless, be very interesting to hi
and might go far towards cementing
friendship of the nations.
! A bovy of naiioy Soben eoludy g
have formed a sooiety to be known
tho "Let ber rip club." The object
to let their lovely waists expand, fn
from tho iuoumbrance of oorsets. He
skirts swing no moro, the dress be
adapted to u reasonable display of an?
without them. It is a aousiblo Sooiet;
as the Jio-?ton Pout would say, "off-c.
got it in."
? I . ? I I ? ? I ?' l l' lt?'I H. ?I H'M ll ?
South Carolina Bank and Treat Ct
COLUMBIA! H C., DKOBMBElt,-9K, M
1 >i:siM-..sy will not be trauaaetuu' by I
I j Hank on Christmas day. AH paper i
able on that duv must be arranged, to-day
Dec 23 1 J. C. liOATH.Oaahle
Notice,
CiriZEKB'SAVINOe BANK OS! 8. C..
Cou ?nu, Utooniber 23,187
MUNDAY being Ch i isl mus, thia Bank
be ohmed. All paper maturing on t
day munt bo attended to to-day.
Dec 29 I J. ?1. HAWYF.lt. Asa'tCaahie:
Notice.
/\Ult Banking House will bo cloaed for bi
KJ noaa on Monday, 25ili instant. All pa
din: that day must bo au'.iuipaiod.
Deo28 I EDWIN J. HCOl'T, SON A C(
LEGISLATIVE PKOCKBUI1G*.
SENATE.
FmuAX, December 22. 1871.
The fcena?e set at 12 M., Praftdent
Banaler in the ?b? ir.
TUe following message from his Excel?
le nor the Qo vern or ?as read, and, on
motion of Mr. Wbi tteraore, the m oas age
was received as io formation and ordered
to be spread opon tbe journal of the
Senate:
To th? Gentlemen of the Senate and House |
of Representatives:
I herewith trsusmit for your informs*
tion a proolatnation, convening the Gen-1
eral Assembly ot 12 o'clock noon, on to?
morrow, tba 23d day of December, 1871?
pursuant to the authority vested in me
by the Constitution of the State. To
adjourn and leave the Chief Magistrate
and Treasurer of the State in office, with I
a resolution, aoousicg them ot "nigh
orimes and misdemeanors," pending in
the House of Represen ta ti vee, would be I
a roost dangerous precedent, as it would |
enable one branch oi the General As?
sembly, which alone ean prefer the I
charges, to paraly ze the executive arm of |
tbe State; while it denies the accused
their right to meet the accusers face to
face. If the pending resolution of im
?eaohment express the aense of the
[ouse of Representativos, and is, in
their judgment, warranted by the law
and the facts, it is their duty to the
State to so declare, and not adjourn and
leave in power officers whose acte merit
such charges. If the resolution does
not express the sense of the House, then
ju at i ce to the people and the accused im
peratively demands that they should BO
declare without further delay. Very re?
spectfully,
ROBERT K. SCOTT, Governor.
Mr. Wbi tte m o re submitted the report
of the Joint Special Investigating Com?
mittee appointed by tbe General Assem?
bly in 1870 and 1871. The report occu?
pies 279 pages of closely printed matter.
Laid over.
Pursuant to notioe. Mr. Whittemore
offered a resolution to further prevent
tbe issue of stooks and bouda of the
State. Read and referred.
At 123_ o'clock, the Senate took a re?
cess until Monday, the 5th day of Janu?
ary, 1872, at 12 M.
HOUSE OP REPRESENTATIVES.
The House mot at 12 M., Speaker
Moses in the Chair.
The consideration of the resolution
relative to Governor Scott's impeach?
ment caused a very lively debate be?
tween Meas rs. Bowen, Whipper, Lee,
Jones and Byas.
On motion of Mr. Mobley, the resolv?
ing clause of the resolution was stricken
out, by a vote of 63 yeas to 84 naya.
Tbe resolution of Mr. Bowen, to im?
peach Niles G. Parker, Treasurer of the
Slate, was taken up, and debated by
Messrs. Bowen, Yooum, Jamison, Whip?
per, Byas, Jones and Horley, when tbe
vote was taken, aud resulted aa follows:
Yeas 27; nays 62.
The Committee on Contingent Aa
couuts reported favorably upon the ac?
counts of A. Palmer and Columbia Post
Office; which were ordered for payment.
The House, at 4P. M., took a recess
until Janury 5. 1872. at 7 P. M.
NlOKEBSON HoUSK.
COLUMBIA, 8. C., Deo. 16, 1871.
lb his Excellency R. K. Scott, Governor of
South Carolina.
Sra: One year ago, in connection with
Messrs. Goss, Thomson and Tinsley, of
the Town Council of Union, I requested
you to obtain assistance from the United
States military to carry ont the law upon
my oirouit. Events since then have
I evinced the correctness of my position,
that that arm only could suppress the
danger. My application was disregard?
ed, and I now publish this letter, in
order that it may effect a practical result
and that I may not be held responsible
for the lachesse ol others again. -
The Cirooit Court of this Stute has
undisputed concurrent jurisdiction with
that of the United States in the troubles
of my oirouit. I call upon you, as the
Executive of the State, to take such
steps as will bring thane matters properly
before the courts of the State. I believe
that this is necessary, in order to evince
that reconstruction is not a failure. Jf,
with 40,000 Republican majority in this
State, and laws of our own making, we
cannot take care of ourselves, we give sn
argument to tbe Democracy we cannot
answer. My duty on the bench has pnt
me too long on the picket line, in tim
battle, to yield my position upon this
point, unless from failure upon the patt
of the main body to sustain me. Alone
and unsupported I havo maintained my
post.
I oall upon you. inasmuch as my
courts commecpeat fjnion on the second
Monday in January, and at York on the
third Monday, to see that these troubles
are brought before these courts. There
can be no exense. 1st. If /am tho ob?
stacle, my place can be filled by ap?
pointment from the Chief Justice. lam
willing to abide bis action and exchange
with any brother of tbe benob. A year
ago, for prudential reasons, personal to
myself, I made an application to that
effect. These reasons no longer exist,
and as I had to take the responsibility
then I um willing to do so now. 2d. If
the obstacle is iu the Solicitor, whose
duty it is to briog these matters before \
I the court, it will be eminently proper
that the Attorney-General, who ls con?
versant with the particulars, from his !
connection with the ynited States esses,
should take charge of them and bring j
tbem before the State courts. If the ?
obstacle is in the juries of any of these
Counties, upon a proper showing made j
to the Presiding Judge that the State
cannot get justice in that County, so- j
oording to the Apt of 1870, the venue
oan be ohauged to any County in the ,
State, and under the supervision of any i
other Circuit if n ?ge, if necessary. 4th. I
If the obstacle ia, as heretofore, want of j
prisoners and witnesses, that is already !
removed, for the President bas done tbe j
work, for yon and will be glad to fulfill ?
the requirements of the Ku Klox bill
and turn them ?10T to the qtate snthori- '
ties.
I have written jin candor, without r??
crira.natipp, fn tjip hopo that i/e may !
evince that repooetruote ci South Carolins
is capable of self-government. I believe
that she in, and 1 am not willing to yield
tbe point without exhausting overy
reqaody aoourding to law. Very respect?
fully, your obedient sor yap t..
WM. M. THOMAS. I
A golden mle for a yoong lady, is al- ?
ways to oouverse with her female Mends
as if a genileman was one of the party, I
and with yoong men as if their female I
friends were present.
Indiana averages forty-nine divorcee
a day, the yoar round.
OUT MATT juts.-The prim of single
GOprss of the PEGSSTX fs ave esnte.,
The Pnonn* oflk? i* supplied wit* ?11
oeoessary material for an haudaome card*,
bill head?, postor?, pamphlets, bo ud-bil If,
circulars, ?nd other printing the? na j he
desired, es ?BJ offlee to the Bots th. Give
ni a mil and test oar work.
A oomplete outfit, with the exception
of ? prese, for e ooautry paper is offered
for sale st a very low rate, tat lieu lars
cen be obtained at PHOBXIX office. l<
A potato bank, belonging to Mr. Joe.
Newman, (on the Winnsboro road,) waa
robbed of several bushels on Tbarsdsy
night, and as GUSUCVK esicl attasapt made
to fire the adjacent out booses.
Secure tickets in the Booth Carolina
Land and Immigration Association. D.
Gambrill, Esq., lethe agent in Coln ta?
bla. There are a number of valuable
prises. *
Messrs. Daffie & Ohspmea have pro?
vided for the Christ mas holidays, by tar-'ita
lng in a heavy stock of articles Bbitafclo .
for presents-ladlee' work-boxes, writing
desks, ?bromo?, books, etc. ; beatties a
beautiful assortment of colored picture
books for children. Nothing moro ap
propri?t? contd be selected for a young?
ster than one of these beautiful volumes.
Diaries, of different styles, for 1872 ?Wo
also be obtained at their establishment.
Messrs. Black & Waring and George
Huggins, insurance agents, have tur
nibbed us with calendars, put forth by
their respective companies. Some of
them are beautifully executed.
TUB "PILORI**"-THE CI VII. BIOHTS
Bm?.-This truly magnificent, work of
art bas been on exhibition in Irwin's
Hall for several nights? and bas afforded
intense gratification to all who bare at?
tended ita exhibition. On Thursday
night, several colored females-among
them Congressman B. B. Elliott's wife
attending the exhibition of the "Pil?
grim" panorama, without male protect?
ors, seatedjtbemselves among the whites.
A portion of the audienoo intimating a
purpose to leave thc hall, Mr. Warren,
i the manager, requested the said colored
persons to change their seats, or vacate
the ball, tendering at the same time the
admission fee, which was accepted, and
the parties left the hall.
Last night, Mr. Warren was arrested
by virtue of a warrant issned by Trini
Justice Thompson, dud carried before
said officer, npou charge of violation of
the Civil Bights bill. Bail to theamount
of $2,000 was required and famished,
and the defendant ordered to anew*r at
j the Court of General Sessions, on the
I first M ou day of February next. Con?
gressman Sliiott is pushing the matter
uncompromisingly.
Marti BkBBAKOBMKltTS.- Th? 'Northern
mail opens at 3.00 P. M.; olosea 7.16
A. M. Charleston day mail opuua 4.?U
P. M.; closes 6.00 A. M. Charleston
night mail opens 6.80 A. M.; closes6.HO
P. M. Greenville mail opens 6.45 P.
M.; dotes 6.00 A. M. Western mail
opens9.00 A M.; closes 1. SO P. M. On
Sunday office open from 3 to 4 P. M.
MAKUK AU ruuiNo Etrrr.asaisK IN Cman?.
TON -Charleston id fast becoming a manu?
facturing aa well aa a commercial city. Tbe
largest manufactory of doora, sashes, blinda.
Au., Ul tho Seat ber ii States la that of Mr. P.
P. TOALK, ou Horlbeok'a Wharf, in that oity,
sales rooms at No ?0 Hayno street. Mr.
TOALE'U advertisement appeara in another
column. Nov 2|
-=-?
LUT OP New AovuimsiaiaNTM
A. L. Tyler-Change of Bobe Jule.
P. Cautwell-Jamaica Bom.
Ohas/ E. Thomas & Oo.- Wood.
Edwin J. Scott, Soo & Co.-Notice.
Jacob Levin-Turkey sj etc.
Beport of Ceutial National Bank.
Collins, Dowus Sc Co.-Gorden Se?ds.
South Carolina Bank & Trust Co.
J. H. Sawyer-Notice.
John T. ty|p|0|j?|^j?]^
Woodl Wood'.!*
I S\r\f\ CORDS now on baud aud to ar
lelLrVrvJ rive. Parties needing wood can
ba supplied during Christin?? wet k. Orders
oan be left, aa usual, at W. C. Fisher's drug
.t ire, or at Co operativo Store.
_D"?.??_. CHAS, jg THOMAS A CO.
Beport of tho Cop4U}o?
OV Til li
Central National Bank,
AT Columbia, in tho Mato of Smth Caro?
lina, at close of biuiueaa, December l?a
?1871:
! ll ESO U UCEM.
, Loaua and Discounts ... ...$260,98a 88
I Dotted Sia<ea Sonda to aeeara Cir
I cid at io o. >*0.tfiO (JO
I Other Stocka, Honda and Slot t
! gages. ... 10q Ol?
I Dne from Redeeming an i Reserve
I Agenta. 29
? Dna from other National Sacka. .. 8.109 80
i Une from other Banks and Hankers 12,940 81
I Heal Katata. 1,926 00
I Furniture and Fit turua. a. WIS 64
j Current Expenaea, including hale
I risa. . 4 605 6:1
Taxes paid. 1,431 SQ
Premium on United Statea Sunda |8 3R8 74
Cash Item?, iuoluding
stamps.77... ?7fi4.
nilla ot other National
Bank?.7. 4,745 flt)
Fractional Currency, in?
cluding Niokela. 1,089 30
Specie. 301 SO B
Legal Tender Nott.-j.18,4(10 00 -20.360 12
SCI 1,919 tv.
LIABILITIES.
Cspital Stock paid lu.$11)0.000 Or)
SurplusFnnd. ' 3,,0t.fi 00
Pr ?t and Loss, not including lute
t eat on United Slates Bonds. 16,(171 HO
National Bank Circulation, out?
standing .'. 135.000 0Q
Dividends unpaid. ' 6177
Individual Deposita. 156,68^24
Du? to National Banka. GOBS
Notes aud Bills rcdjsconnted. M.OOO Po
?511.919 Kt;
3TATE OF SO]! TH CAROLINA, j
Cops?)/ OP RICHLANU. \
I, A. O. Breni?er, Cashier of the Central
National Bank ol Colombia,' do solemnly
.wear that the above statement is true, tn. tho
best of my knowledge and belief.
A. Q. BHEN1ZEK. Cashier.
Suhacrihed and aworn tq before me, this
23d December, jayi.
O. ff. O. BUTT, Notary Puhlit.
Correct--Attest :
JOHN B. PALMER,
ll. IJ. BRYAN,
R. D. BENN. Dec 23 1
Fire Cracker?.
IAA WHOLE and Bair Bozos Ooldeu
IUI J Chop FIRE CRACKERS, for aale
low. E. HOPE.