The Charleston daily news. (Charleston, S.C.) 1865-1873, May 12, 1871, Image 1
VOLUME XI.-NUMBER 1671.
CHARLESTON, WEDNESDAY" MORNING, MAY 3, 1871.
EIGHT DOLLARS A YEAR.
THE PEOPLE'S CONVENTION.
I II I It D DAY.
Reports of thc Executive Committee
J: i fd MIK Proposed Essential to th?
Peace and Welfare at the State-Th?
Bine Ridge and Greenville Railroad
Bill of the Last Legislature Severely
Censured - .Nearly Tun Millions of |
Debt.
[SPECIAL TELEGRAM TO THE NEWS.]
COLUMBIA, Thursday, May ll.
The convention met at 12 o'clock. The
morning session was consumed in reading
and acting on reports. The executive' com?
mittee reported that they had considered a
plan to meet the expenses o? the convention,
and recommended that each delegate deposit
with the clerk five dollars for that purpose.
Adopted.
Judge Aldrich, irom the executive commit?
tee, reported on the subject of taxation with?
out representation, reviewing the causes of
the present condition, and recommending the
passage of a resolution'that the Legislature be
req^fested to pass an election law, by which
sixty thousand taxpayers shall have propor?
tionate representation with ninety thousand
voters. A lopted.
Hon. J. Chesuut, from the same committee,
reported cn Mr. Chamberlain's resolution, in?
quiring into the alleged violence now prevail?
ing in several counties of this State, Ac; that
they learn, with recret. that violence prevail?
ed in several counties, btu that they have the
satisfaction to know that in by far the larger
number of counties not a single instance ol
such violation has been reported. It is
due to bad government. Corruption is fol?
lowed by larcenies; incendiarism is practiced
by deluded men;"" and corporeal punishment
and homicide have resulted in cases where
fraud and oppression were lound to exist.
These are lamentable truths; but the commit?
tee believe the remedy to be found in the re?
moval of bad and in the appoint ment of com?
petent, honest men. Adopted.
Hon. J. Chesnut, from the same committee,
reported thft that the paper ot Mr. Dudley,
which l\;d been recommitted, pass as
amended: Desiring to be fully under
stood by the citizens of the country, the
convention declares that it meditates no
resistance to the general government; that
the reconstruction measures are finalities;
that we look to time and peaceful agencies for
the solution ol difficulties in the administra?
tion; that the present exigencies demand more
enlightened efforts than those Intended to pro?
mote the success ol mere party, and that the
fon?wing measures of reform are essential to
the peaot and welfare of the State: 1. The
adoption by the Legislature of minority rep?
resentation. 2. Retrenchment by abolishing
unnecessary offices. 3. Reducing salaries. 4.
That the public debt be not increased, and the
Governor prevent the negotiation of the ster?
ling bonds. 5. Relief from the payment of
two taxes in one year. C. To fill offices with
competent, honest men. 7. Amendment of
the election law, to prevent lraud in the con?
trol or count ol the ballot. 6. R .'duct ion of the I
pay, mileage, and abridgement of the sessions
of the Legislature. Adopted unanimously.
Mr. Screven, from the committee on elec- |
tions, presented a report recommending that
the executive committee confer with the Gov- |
ernor and invite his co-operation in memorial?
izing the Legislature to chango the election
law, especially with reference to the ten days'
custody ol the ballot-boxes. Adopted.
Greenfield, of Columbia, offered a resolution
that the executive committee Inquire into the
irauds connected with the investigating com?
mittee of the election ol the Third Congres?
sional District appointed by the Legislature ol
1869. .
The convection Then adjourned lill 4 o'clock.
In the afternoon Mr. F. F. Warley, ol the
executive committee, made a report on the
resolution instructing them to inquire and re?
port upon what terms and for what considera?
tion the making and execution of the Blue
Ridge Railroad Company, and other compa?
nies^ of a mortgage to Henry Clews, Henry
Gourdin and George S. Cameron, to secure
the payment of certain bonds, was ratified and
confirmed by the Legislature, and the said
mortgage declared to be a -lien prior to that
of the Stat e on all property described in said
mortgage, and on the entire line ol the Blue
Ridge Railroad, and on all other properties ol
the several companies, or which they, or
either of them,.may herealter acquire"-and
say that for some reason the Legislature has
transferred to private individuals the State's
lien on the Blue Ridge, and the entire proper
ties in the Greenville and Columbia Railroad. ]
Such dealings are in the nature of fraud. I
Therefore,
Hesol'ed, That tl'e convention request ?
Messrs Porter & Conner to give the report ?
a careful consideration, and take the neces- <
sary steps to. prevent, by p ocess of law, the
consummation of this Iniquitous proceeding, j (
Mr. Warley followed in a severe speech, iu
which he denounced both corporations Sor the
use of corrupting influences with the Legisla?
ture. He said that some Carolinians are more 11
to blame thai ihe carpet-baggers, and charged
that Hie president of the Blue Ridge Railroad
boldly asserted belore thc committee th.it he
,/as prepared to spend hail a million ol" dollars
So defeat Whlttcmore's bill, and bribed sena?
tors to do so. The speech produced a profound
impression, especially when, in closing, he
said that he was personally responsible for
every fact stated.
The committee of eleven will probably make
theif'report to-morrow, which will be thc
voice of the convention, and embody the
practica] resui'.s of its labors. Much good*has
already resulted froid its deliberations, and it
is confideutiy believed that incalculably, benefit
viii be experienced frotn it, both politically
and financially. It will probably adjourn to?
morrow evening.
Messrs. Trenhoita and Smith, after a tull
examination of tile books ot the treasurer and
comptroller, find that the total debt ol the
State, issued or authorized, to be nine million
eight hundred thousand dollars.
PROCEEDINGS OE TUE CONVENTION
Second Day.
FROM Ol'? OWN COIlRESrONPENT.]
COLUMBIA, Wednesday. May IO.
The proceedings in the convention to-day
have coHsisied chiefly ol the presentation ol
resolutions aud their reference to the execu?
tive committee, of which General James Ches?
nut is chairman. The absence, too, ol other
committees, 1er the purpose of consultation,
made it unnecessary to prolong Hie morning
sessioD, aDd it accordingly adjourned at an
early hour to meet at 7 P. 31.
The following is the full text ol resolutions
offered during the day, the synopsis of which
was published in our special telegraphic dis?
patches ye.-terdaj morning:
BvVudge A. P. Aldrich :
li<solved, That the executive committee,
with tl.e president, shad have it in charge
protecl. the interests represented 07 this c<
vent ion ir the interval of adjournment
keep In view the current legislation, and
call the convention together at such times
they may think proper. Also, that a coma
tee of live be appointed by the execii'ive co
inlttee to prepare a truthlul and condens
report of the condron of the Stat-?, now a
since Hie war, r-ud ibat the same be print
and distributed;
By Colonel William Wallace :
Whereas, Crimes hitherto unknown
South Carolina, viz : embezzlement of pub
ninds and bribery in the Legislature, have t
come so flagrant as lo make the govemraen
by-word anil reproach In the eyes ol'a civiliz
world-committed as they have been almi
openly in the presence ot the Executive a
the attorney-general ol' Hie State-whose di;
it is tc see that all offenders are brought
justice; and whereas these violations of law
the part ol'those occupying high places in li
government, committed almost openly a:
willi impunity, beget a spirit of lawlessue
throughout Hie State,
Resolved. That the attorney-general be i
structed to And out and prosecute all sn
offender?, and that a committee of five mei
hers of ibis convention be appointed to a
that officer in the discharge of this duty.
By Hon. A. B. Woodruff, of Spartanbnrg:
Resolved, That it be referred to the comm
tee of eleven to report a* to Hie propriety
proposing some Dian, through the Govern
or otherwise, by which the law requiring :
official notices 'to be published in eena
papers be repealed, or so modified as to r
move said requisition.
By Mr. M. C. Smart, of Beaufort :
Recognizing our obligations as delegates
this Suite, in voluntary convent i a um-mole
to adopt snell measures as in our- juo'gmei
will be most conductive to social harmon
mutual co-operation In and support ol' tl
government, and confidence in the llnanci
condition of. the Slate; recelvint. and a
ceptiui: in good faith the assurances of bis E:
cellency the Governor that lie will render an
aid in l.ls power to lacilitale such object, an
that any plan which this convention ma
adopt, consistent with our system of Iree goi
eminent, will deserve the earnest atteniion <
lue General Assembly; appreciating his sw.
gestion as to the proper mode for remedvln
existing evils, to wit : to secure for the Slut
the services of citizens whose -experience an
person il character would furnish a sufficier
guarantee for wise legislation and judiclon
expenditures of ihe public funds : Be it. lien
fore.
Rtso'ved, That the executive committee (
this convention be, and they are hereby, rc
quested lo nominate a committee, to consi?
of not less than three nor more than ten corr
pelent persons, who shall make ami cause t
be mace a thorough investigation of all ihe lit
biliiies ol this State.
Resolved, That his Excellency the Governo
be. and be is hereby requested, to render an;
aid in his power to the accomplishment of ihi?
object, and as an Important agency exists li
the Stale ol New York, a visit to which wouli
entail much expense on the members ol (hi
committee, this aid be extended (o oinbrac?
transportation of ibis committee.
Resolved, That the officers of the various de
partments be, and are hereby requested, ti
give the committee access to all sources of in
lormation within tbelr power.
Resolved, That the executive committee
be coniinuons in its organization, subject tc
the call of his Excellency and its chairman.
Reso'ved, That in addition to the dutiei
hereinbefore provided for the; members of this
commiitee, the executive commiitee shall, by
conference and communication with his Ex?
cellency the Governor, whenever by bim de?
sired, assist him to secure the services of -citi?
zens to All the various offices of Stale and
county.
Resbived, That we are opposed to repudia?
tion, and nope that the r?sull of ihe arrange?
ment herein provided for will secure the
prompt payment of all lawful obligations:
Provided, however, that we distinctly reserve
the right to iiirther action on this point until
after the reports herein contemplated are
made.
By Major F. F. Warley, of Darlington:
Resolved, That this convention, represent?
ing the taxpayers ol' the State of Soul li Caro?
lina, and authorized to speak for Hiern, sol?
emnly declare the intention ot the people io
resist, by all lawful means, the payment of any
debt hereafter contracted by Hie present State
government,, or by any subsequent govern?
ment, In which Ibe taxpayers are not repre?
sented. *
By Mr. Robert Adams, of Richland:
Wherios, Taxation without adequate repre?
sentation is an anomaly in a tree R--publican
government; and whereas the taxpayers of
ihe Slate cf South Carolina are now laboring
under the intolerable burden arising from
non-representation in the l?gislative councils
of the State; therefore.
Resolved, That we recommend to the Gov?
ernor a suspension of the collection of tax^s
for the year 1871, until the adjournment of Hie
next session ol the Legislature.
Resolved, That it is the sense of this conven
Uon that the necessities of ihe taxpayers 0!
South Carolina imperatively require such sus?
pension
By Colonel T. Y. Simons :
Resolved, That this convention ol the-pro?
perty-holders and taxpayers ol Hie Slate of
South Carolina do hereby deem it our duty to
declare that the bonds heretofore Issued, with?
out legal sanction, and the so-called sterling
loan, or auy other bonds or -obligation bere?
ifter issued, purporting To bo under and by
virtue of the authority ol t he Stale, ss at pres?
ent constituted, will not bc heid binding on
JS; and that we recommend to the people ol'
the Slate, in every manner and at ail times, to
.esist the payment, thereof, or the enforce?
ment of any tax lo pay the same, by ull legHl
uate means within their power.
Resolved, That we deem it our duty to waru
ill persons not to receive by way ol' purchase,
oau or otherwise, any bonds or obligations
Hereafter issued, purporting to hind the prop
iily or pledge Ibe credit of ihe State: and
Jiat all ?uch bond* or obligations will be held
0 be null and void, as having been issued
corruptly and improvidently.
MINORITY REPRESENTATION.
The committee on suffrage anil elections,
:hrough Mr. J. P. Thomas, made a lengthy re?
port, rec ommending the adoption of thc plan,
ivhicii has been tried several times in England
iud Amerlci ':nown as cumulative voting.
Die report explains Hie modus operandi,
dwells upon the advantages of Um new sys
Lem, both to ?he minority and minority,, and
expresses the belie! that it will result in re?
storing oenee mu! prosperity to ihe State, ll
concludes willi Hie recommendation thal the
Legislature, at its next session, pass a bill pro?
viding ?or the cumulative system OJ" voting
and representation.
Mr. Tiiomas sustained tho report in a speech
In which was discussed the prospects ol the
two races.
Ex-titvernor Manning, of Clarendon, moved
that Hie report be laid on the table, bul with,
drew his motion, and jiekled Hie floor lo Hon.
Geo. A. Trenholm, who made a masterly ad?
dress on the situation, and warmly advocated
Hie principle of universal suffrage as Hie foun?
dation upon which must rest every truly Re?
publican government. We are. be said, in
Hie march of intelligence aud progress, and
the convictions of all reasoning men go to es?
tablish universal suffrage as ihe heritage 0;
every living man. Armed with this grand
idea of ihe age. Hie support ol'every ciiizen of
South Carolina could be demanded, amii: union
ot interests would :oliow> out of which would
grow ju-lice, peace and harmony.
Ex Governor Manning renewed bis motioa
to lay the report on the table, and made a
speech, in which lie declared that be was nota
compromise man, and entertained no qualified
political sentiments on this subject. Give us
equal laws, and we would baye proper repre?
sentation; then we would have justice through?
out the land.
General Gary replied warmly, advocating
the adoption of the report. 1
Hon. Gabriel Cannon exprcs?ed the hope ;
that, a? far as practicable, the discussion of
this an J other m> asures should be conducted ;
with ? spirit of moderation, and, .abo ve ?all
Hiing?, that politics should be avoided.
General James Chesuut was in favor of tok?
ing an immediate vote upon the report, be?
cause he believed Hie mind of the convention
was already Axed on the subject, and it only
consumed time to prolong the discussion. At
Iiis suggestion, the report was.read a second
time, whereupon he moved its adoption. Hon.
D. H. Chamberlain now took the floor, and
held the undivided attention and interest of
the convenlion, whlie he addressed the body
as follows :
Gentlemen-I am aware, from the length of
this (legate, that the convention are ^axions
to reach a vote on the subject. While I had
hoped lo have spoken upon it at sorae.length.
I shall better promote the object which I have
at heart by confining myself to a few remarks.
We are here, If we are honest in our declara?
tions, simply as citizens of a common State,
and not as "members oj' political parties. We
are interested alike in the welfare of that
State. My position here is peculiar, and Mn
many of its features trying. On all sides I am
surrounded by members ot a political party to
which I do not belong, and in coming - here I
have left behind me those with wliotn I have
hitherto been associated in my political career,
But anx'ous as I am to save the common
peace.and welfare of thc State, I say to those
who taunt me for my conduct, that neither
they nor any one else can read me out ol' my
political party, with'which I have chose to as
sociate myself. Pardon me for saying again,
however, that outside of this convention lum
a Republican, and it ls because I desire to vin?
dicate the decency of Republicanism that I am
willing to hazard all political .prospects in an
honest effort to promote the cause of right,
and to save the State.
In the first place. genllemj?rj. it is necessary
to modify the absolute control which a mere
utunerlc?l majority has obtained over the
State, and io secure.for intelligence and prop
erl v a proper representation in the affairs of
Hie government. And, looking about for
some device which, without violence to the
fundamenta; principle upon which our gov?
ernment rests, will bring relief from the
grievances which ?ti?llct our people. I have
fixed upon this system of cumulative voting
because it is not "only just In its theory, but it
will prove itself right lu its results. It takes
nothing irom the rights of the majority. It gives
them a predominating control, but notan abso?
lute dispositioc of the entire fortunes of thc
State. Do yon believe tor a moment then,
when you put into an ignorant Assembly,
many of whom can neither read nor write,
forty-seven gentlemen whom I might select in
this body, that you would not shame them
into decency, or frighten them from crime?
[Applause.] Who does not know -that the
preseuce ol' one honest man puts to flight
band of robbers ? Now, according to this sys
tem,.voir deny nothing which belongs to the
majority, but from the moment you place i
the lower house forty-seven ol your ables
citizens, bad legislation will cease, and
good legislation will becin. Are the oppo
nents of. this measure on this floor
so intense in their demotion to political ideas,
that they will refuse a proposition which
gives to them a repr?sentation ol one-third
and a'corresponding influence in public affairs
I hope not, lor when by force of political sue
cess they have gathered a majorily of the
State to their side, there will then be left to
us who differ the same rluhts we are now ac?
cording lo them. Is it not fair, just, right
Its immediate results are relief hom present
grievances, aud it points to the 'future, where
ill interests, no matter what may be the
political fortunes of the State, will be pro
tected.
Now, I say to you, gentlemen, give us who
have to do with making this practicable, some
thing that we can honestly lake back to our
political associates, and, in the name of the
property and Intelligence of the State, secure
An* right. Let lhere be peace between us
low, and prosperity hereaiter. Strengthen
mr hands, who desire to do what in us lies, to
nake South Carolina safe for every man In his
Ife. career nnd private interests. I say again,
t ls right. Cram it.
The question occurring on Hie adoption of
he report, it was agreed to by a large majori
y. not more than five or six voling in the neg
Ulve.
Various reports from the executive commit
ee were read, and ordered lor consideration
o-morrow rrue convention then adjourned.
GREELEY IN JUE SO UTH.
NEW YORK, May ll.
Horace Greeley leaves to day for the South,
liter delivering Hie animal address belore the
Hate Agricultural Society, ot Texas, iie will
ixplore the proposed line of the Texas and
'aclflc Railroad, and be absent several, weeks,
naking a'6hort tarry in each of the principal
ilties en route. He will reach Cincinnati on
rriday, and New Orleans on Sunday. He
viii spend Monday in New Orleans, go thence
o Galveston, and deliver an address at Hous
on on the 22d.
POLICE! POLICE.'
POUT DOVER, May ll.
Tile fight between Coburn and Mace was pre
ented by the Canadian authorities. The men.
ii splendid condition, entered the ring shortly
lier noon. During the first round, and be
jre a Wow hud been shuck, the sheriff and
ounty judffc, backed by a number of soldiers
rom Slmcoe, dispersed the crowd, wno fled in
very direction. The Dght '.:us been indetlnite
r postponed.
THE WEALTH I R THIS HAY.
WASHINGTON, May ll.
It is probable that the barometer will con
iune fulling very generally on Friday, with in
rea-ing cloudiness, and Ibat light winds will
irevail from the .Mississippi tu the Atlantic.
J.L KELL DECLARED" GOVERNOR.
HAI:'KORD, May il.
Dotti Houses passed a resolution declaring
?ewell elected. Ile wi:!, be iuaugiirated on
Puesthy, to which day the Legislature has u'?l
ourned.
CR A SS ll OPP EUS ANO INDIANS.
SAX FRANCISCO, May n.
Clouds of grasshoppers are destroying Hie
:rops ia Los Angelos County.
The citizens of Arizona hilve killed eighty
?Y.e Indians ?iud captured twenty-five children.
These indians had boen protected r-.t f 0rl
han!, but in return "stole properly and mur?
iere I citizens.
WASHING TON Nil WS.
WasintcuToN, May ll.
Robeson has returned. The Russian Prince
has postponed Iiis visit tiii rail.
G-.'nerui Babcock succeeds General Micliier
is" superintendent of public buiidiugs and
?rounds.
The committee on foreign relations have
jeen iu session four hours, and still are not
.ady to report to the Senate .
STATUE OF PROFESSOR HORSE.
NEW YORK, May ll.
The inauguration of_the telegraphers' statue
o Professor Morse in the Central Park is
3nally fixed for the 10th of June at i P. M. It
ivas found inpossible to complete it by Hie
Mth in tant.
THE STATE FINIMES.
A BUSINESS MAN'S VIEW OE TBE
CA SE.
Remarks of Colonel Richart! Lathers,
of"Charleston, In the Taxpayers' Con?
vention at Columbia, Tacscta v, May 9,
1S71.
In the Taxpayers' Convention, on Tuesday
last, Colonel Richard Lathers said that he felt
that it would be proper for him as a represen?
tative of the Chamber ol Commerce to state
th?? views entertained by himself and other
gentlemen at some length, to the end that the
objects of the convention might be clearly un?
derstood. . -
By the reconstruction policy, he corfiiniied,
a system of government was instituted in
the State which ls without example In the
history of civilization for fraud, ignorance and
oppression. The rights of property were ig?
nored, intelligence disfranchised, laws and
usages abolished, and the Legislature, and in?
deed .'very lunction of thc judiciary and gov?
ernment, State,counly and city, was exercised
(willi few exceptions) by freed slaves without
education, and white adventurers without
conscience or the least sympathy ia the rights
md interests of those they undertook to gov
ern. The few exceptions In the way of hon?
esty or capacity which brightens this dark pic?
ture ol legislative depravity, more frequently
justifies the conservative claims of the colored
mun to a patriotic regard for his native Stale,
Liian the production of any well-grounded hope
af a practical relorm on the part ol the o
whelming majority, whose aim seems to be to
acquire wealth by ihe most unblushing cor
ruption.
Indeed the members of the Senate and the
House o? Representatives, as well as the offi
;ials, do not hesitate openly to charge each
jther with fraud and corruption; and there Is
i well-set?ed tarif! for legislative action of
-his kind most accurately graduated.
A considerable portion- of the last session
>1 the Legislature was consumed in mutual
criminations of this kind, and one ol the sena
ors actually proclaimed his independence :-f
nvestigalions.of fraud and corruption on the
?round that his own frauds would bear In?
vestigation quite as well as those ol hi3 ac?
cusers, and Hie challenge was not accepted,
die Governor of the State, ip his. veto of
i bill 1er legislative expenses the last sea
?on, says: "I regard the money already
ippropriated during this session and the, sum
ncluded in this bill, amounting in the aggre?
gate to four hundred thousand dollar?, as
limply enormous for one.sesslbn. Ii is beyond
he comprehension of any one how the General
VsSembly could legitimately expend one-half
hat amount ol' money." And the matter lura
;d out to be a fraud, as the Governor insinu
iles. Last "winter a committee of both
jrauches of the Legislature was appointed lo
nxestlgate the frauds and blackmailing con
lected with the Blue Ridge Railroad legisla
Jon of the previous session. The Governor,
he main witness, appeared before this com
n'ittee, and accused the former Legislature of
di sorts of vlllany. Alluding to the bill grant
ng aid to the road, the Governor say
1 When the bill came up a member of the
louse came to one of Die parties and
<ald : kThe report can't go through until
f get five hundred dollars.' " And when
in injunction was served on the fiscal
)flicers ol the State to prevent the endorse
nent of the bonds, the Governor alleges that
he parties procuring the Injunction proposed
o withdraw the same if $25,000 would be paid,
ifler many clear and explicit charges ol fraud
ind corruptions,-the Governor, with an honest
mrst of indignation against this corrupt body,
;ay : "I know of the loot, or have been told so
>y a hundred different persons, that money
lad been paid to get u certain report through
it the last session. I want to say, do you
nppose that if our Saviour would come here
vith a bill ever so good, and want to get it
brough, or it was thought best to get upa
?oinmittee lo investigate Him, do you suppose
ie wouldn't be crucified again if He dldu't pay
omething to prevent lt. * * * * I learned
tlterwards that they privately demanded of the
iresident ol the road ?500 a piece, as it was
tubllcly stated by themselves that they did
lot get enough ont of the road when the
till passed." I need hardly occupy your
line with the hundreds of frauds and tor
uptions which are too well-known to the
mbllc to need repetition, but I cannot re
rain from calling your attention to the expen
llttires of the county commissioners of
Charleston lor the current year ending Ocio
>er last, amounting lo $238,841. The Gover
iorinhi3 messages, transmitting Hie same to
lie Legislature, properly remarks : That
.these amounts are of startling magnitude,
ind ii is worthy, of consideration whether tiley
?annoi be materially.reduced." I believe ?in
uvestigalion, counected with llios? (randi
ins been had or proposed.
1TF.US.
Road? ami bridges.<los,2J5
Public bnlliiidgs.28,n->i
Coufliablca and trial justices.38.SG0
Sherill', clerk ol cutiuty and coroner...w,07l
Total.I.$238,841
Perhaps before the war these items would
lave reached (30,000 lo $75,00". Trial juslic-s,
slate couti ables and herds o? expensive and
iseless officials are rapidly corrupting the peo
de. and ealing oui their substance.
When we reflect that this ls the expense o
jut one of the thirly odd counties of the State
'pending over a quarter of a million under the
lower of a mere commission, wc need not lie
surprised that the laxes of the Stale this year
vaches oyer $-.'.000,000. against ?ess than
1100,009 before the war. As the laxes
o be paid il;ls year aggregates over
?4,000,000, as it includes two levies which
s i-T-iyhl thc amount paid beiju-e the wal?
li Ti iy one year, wc may weil be con
it rained to look to our rulers for same mitiga
ion, and :i?k for a convection of taxpayers to
consider the grave issues which ihe Ignorance
md ?'uiid ol ihe Legislature aw precipitating
upon ns in a practical confiscation o? o:?r prop
jrty by taxation, and Ute probable loss lo our
creditors, by the certain bankruptcy of the
State. The recently developed frauds of the
and commission, by which Hie Stau: hos been
made to pay seven hundred and rtlty thous
ind dollars for properly acknowledged to "be
worthless for the purposes intended, and im
possible of sale ai even il50,000, making a.
?lear ioss to our over-btirtbened taxpayers of
?GOO, UGO in a single year, which, before Ibo
?var, would have paid Hie expenses of the
Slate for one year and a ball, ls but ihe de?
velopment or lhat class of legislaiion on
which the few honest and conservative men oi
Lhe Radical party are unable to resist, unles?
the election lawB can be so changed as to
ifford minority representation ?mo Hie Legis?
lature and all lhe offices throughout the Stale.
This, I believe, can be effected with the co
jperatlon ol'Hie respectable and honest Re?
publicans, who are desirous to aid the
Conservative people of the State to obt
fair show of Influence in the making
laws and levying the taxes, which alike
cern the interests of us all.
The resolutions ot tile Chamber ?I I
merce and the Board of Trade, to TV
you have so patriotically responded,
plain and simple. They recognize
practical value of the right of representa
and the protection of the rights of prof
against fraud and misrule. They allege g
frauds on the part ol the Legislature an
many of the,offlcials ol the State. Apart 1
the imlversal criminal representation,
quotations already cited being tne hones
missions and indignant charges of hiB
cellency the Governor against his own pi
proves beyond question the truth ol thesi
legations, and also his inability to save
community from the preponderance of
motion in the Legislature, because the ho
and intelligent portion of Iiis party are
feeble in power to overcome the mass ol
norance and corruption 'which sways
destinies of the State. The action cont
plated by these resolutions ls to give pr
notice that the sterling bonds must not
negotiated or regarded as binding on the
perry and good laith of the people ol' the St
and if argument and proofs of the wist
and honesty ol this measure were wantin
should propose only to adduce the two |
tests entered in the Journals ol the two Hoi
against the passage qf the bill authorizing
loan, but which were disregarded by the
jorlly : ?
We. the undersigned members of tbe Sen
protest against the passage of a bill entitled
bill to create a debt of the State of South Caroll
tu be kuoAn as tlic sterling lunded debt,
same, or the proceeds thereof, to be excluait
used In exchange for or In payment of the ex
lng public debt of the State or South Carolina, "
the following reasons :
. .1st. Because to create any further debt at
present time ts unwise and unnecessary.
2d. Because the existing debtor the state
unknown, and a correct Knowledge of lt cam
bc obtained.
3d. Because lt is admitted by the champions
this bill and its fnends;iia: tue flnun.-nil rn;
agers named In Its text are not the proper pers<
tu be clothed with such a tlscal trust.
4th. Because" lt wid increase the burthen
taxation, now already oppressive, and swell l
aggi eenie of the Interest on thc ex.sting and I
sterling funded debt to the amount ur $1,000,0
or ai the rate or six mills per dollar per anni
upon all the property of the State or South Ca
lum.
fitb. Because the agent cr agents who are to 1
gotlate and manage the proceeds of the sales
the $6,000,000 in sterling bonds for twenty yet
to come, are not required tn any way to give sec
rity or any kind for the enormous trust conlld
to them.
Ctn. Because the question or such a large I
debtcdness, viz : $6,000.000 in gold-the large
ever at any one time in the history or the Legisi
ture of the state of South Carolina authorized
should have been submitted io the qualin
voters or th? State for their approval ur rejecHo
berere ihe General Assembly put it beyond UH
power to control.
"th. Because the credit or the State must bell
paired as thc column of indebtedness ls Increase
. 8'h. Because the excessive taxation that ..s
follow Hus new created debt will produce disco
tent and dissatisfaction throughout the whe
State, and will Inspire opposlilon to ihe gover
ment, that will disrupt tue peace and tncrea
the disorder now so threatening and deplored
our community.
,Slgued.) B. F. WHITTEMORE,
K. E. DICKSON.
W. E. HOLCOMBE,
. . JOUN WILSON,
Ci. W. DUVAI.L,
D. BlEM?N,
J. FOSTER.
The protest ol the members of the House :
We think the meosnte a good one, and
pronerly inausgcd and directed, might be prodi
tlvc of good and substantial results. But belie
lng that a majority or those composing tne "Una
clal boards" are without financial Kuuwledge ai
experience, which ls so eminently required
suecesslnlly carry out such grave and Importa
measures as the one In question, and runtier I:
llevlng that 6uch safeguards os wlil properly a:
etllclenily protect the rights or the State ba
been neglected, we are constrained to vute
above Indi ated.
(Sigued.) . E. II. FROST,
'B. A; BOSEMON,
CHAKI.ES S. Run,
JoSEi-n D. BOSTON,
C. J. AN DELL,
FORTUNE GILES,
W. W. JKRVEY,
M. GOGGINS.
I wUl close this evidence of fraud and cc
ruption by quoting from the protest again
the Greenville Railroad, made by leading rr
nority members of the House, and entered i
the Journal February 26, 1871.
1st. Because lt (the bill) ls a deliberate and wllf
attempt on the part of those in whose Iniere
the bPi was Humed, to enrich themselves at tl
expense or Mic State.
4ih. Because Hie effect 01 its passage will bc 1
Injure the credit of the State abroad, which eve
now does no rest upon the most secure and sw
stamin: basis, owlug, we fear, to thc imstrvauagi
ment and cupidity ot those to whom the affairs c
thc State are intrusted.
Thus you will perceive I have confined rn;
self to documentary prools from Radical o?
cial sources, and, did lime permit, I com
greatly swell the record from the?proceedlng
ol the Legislature and official publications <
the past two years. Thu conclusive reason
and facts produced by these able and timel
protests of leading senators und mern ?ers c
the "House, recorded in Ute journals at th
time ol the passage of the bills, nol only prov
the corruption and unfitness of Hie Legislatur
und the leading officials entrusted with th
funds of the Stale, and wielding the'destinie
ol'the people, but sustains these chargesb
Radical leslimuny, which cannot be disputed
and which ls most creditable to Hie con
servutive action ol ihe.Individuals concerned
rising, as they do, above party Issues, whosi
action at:<l conservative statements I desiri
now to acknowledge as the most conclusive
evidence of lue propriety of resisting all futur?
negotiations pledging Hie laith ol'Hie Stale
so long as the pet-pie whose property is to b?
pledged are denied Hie rigiit ol protectin<;
their interests by pruner representation in Hit
Legislature.
Leaving for the discussion of others Hit
various forms ol' oppression and misrule
under which the State suffers, I pro?
pose lo . call your . attention to the repu?
diation 01 the party in power, and the disgrace
which has.lallen upon tho hitherto unquestion?
able financial integrity of the Slate. I refer
IO thc wilful refusal to pay the. matured fire
loun debt.
it appears that the Legislature of Hie Stale,
in Hie session of 1838, authorized Hie Governor
to negotiate a loan for soins two millions of
dollars, to rebuild that part cf the City ol
Charleston, then lying in ruin-;, caused by the
deslruciive lire v.iiio'.i ha? devastated that
city: pledging not only lim lallli and credit of
the State, out the. capita! and profils of the
Hank of lue State for tho prompt payment ot
the interest and lur die liquidation of the prin?
cipal as ihe luiui should mature.
The proceeds ol tills loan was to be deposit?
ed in the Bunk of Hie State, aud lo become a
patt ol'the capital-of .said bank, to be loaned
out to property-owners in the burnt district of
Charleston, secured by bond and mortgage of
the respective lots to be rebuilt upon by said
loans.
The president of the bank and the Governor
of the State, jointly, appointed Mr. McDuffie
as their agent to proceed to London and nego?
tiate Hie loan. On Mr. McDuflie's arrival in
London, he published an address, iu which he
made the. following statement :
The Legislature, in order to make assurance
doubly sure, has provided thar, lu addition to the
general pledge of the faith and resources of the
state, particular funds shall be specilkally appro
piiaied and solemnly pledged aud s^t apart to se?
cure ihe punctual payment of the interest and
principal or this loan. As this iona wlL par
consist, of the profits which snail accrae from
two millions now to be borrowed, the mods
which lt is to be used will be staled, Ute to
deposited in the Bans of the State of South Ca
lina, aa so much capital, to be employed l>y t'
bank*, acting as the tincal agent of the State In i
conipll-hlng the objects or the loan, viz : to i
the citizens or Charleston to rebuild their c'ty.
Upon the faith of these representations ai
pledges of the legislative enactments re .ferr
to, Messrs. Baring Brothers & Co. b.;car,
the purchasers of the Lrger portion ci t
bonds, and through their influence most of t
balance was negotiated, on most favoral
terms to the St3te, J. ih-uk, at 93 per cern
and at the low rate ol ."> per cent, interest. I
cause of the peculiar nature of the semirit
having not only the honor and faith of t
State, which had always met its engagcmer
promptly, but had also the capital and prof
of the bank to fall back upon, and the lurch
power of a legal remedy in the courts in ca
of default of payment, which remedy could n
be resorted to against a sovereign State.
The bank, therefore, became not on Iv tl
debtor of the holder ot theac bond:, oct w
agent lor the State and trustee for the cred
ors. The proceed.? of these loans wetevlei
out by the bank as contemplated by the ste
ute. Charleston was rebuilt and the loai
made long since returned to the bank, with
large profit lo the State on the transadlo
interest charged by the bank being mui
greater than the interest paid by it to tl
English capitalists-?l23,500'matured ta w
paid by the bank in 1858, leaving outstandh
?109,000; in round numbers, about $645,000
gold, which became payable July 1,18G5.
The Legislature of 1865, flndlDg the Sta
unable to pay these obligations promptly, d
honestly propose to devote the assets of tl
bank to the payment of these bonds ajd th
outstanding circulation, giving the preforent
to the bonds, under the pledges made ')j M
McDuffie, and the statut? under which he ni
gotiated the loan. But the present admlnii
tration initiated a policy- which has led tc ei
pensive and troublesome litigation, aol th!
loan left unpaid and virtually repudiated fe
five years, although the Messrs. Bariag o
ferod to renew the bonds on the same .ibert
terms which had been extended to the Slat
of Massachusetts in London, provided th
securities orgi nally pledged should be devote<
in good faith to the. Indebtedness. Anothe
Issue of this fire loan, made about the sam?
time; in the United Slates, under the sam
statute, and for the same purpose, araduntinj
to $318,000, and advertised* to be paid la goli
January 1,1871, was repudiated also, alt'iougl
the fiscal agent, Mr. Klinpton, gave notice
by public advertisement, in New York, Collina
bia and Charleston, that principal and lr teres
would be paid on that day.
It Is true that legal questions have arlsei
between various creditors ot the Bank of th'
State as to priority of loans. But this litiga
ti on seems to be the only resource of tho cred
itors as long as the authorities of the Stati
continue to repudiate the indebtedness if thi
State; for in all issues now pending against thi
assets ol the bank the State is bound, in goot
faith, to pay the Utigants^ecause the State ii
liable for the deficiency.of the bank tc mab
good its obligation.
The want of financial skill 1B as evident a
the repudiation of these debts are glaring anc
dishonest. How can a State hope to negotiate
loans when defaulting in payments airead;
due, and attempting nlso to deprive tnt credi
tor of securities, pledged in good faith, to ob
tain the loan ?
While these legislators were repudiating
their contracts with the Messrs. Baring, ttn<
refusing to make any provision lor tte pay
ment of their fire loan bonds, due five year
since, and even passing laws to deprive then
of'the assets of the bank pledged for .'.he se
airily of these bonds-In a spirit of extraoi
d-nary liberality with the taxpayers' money
they were passing laws to increase tie bur
dens of the people by the payment ol Interes
on the bonds in gold, which bonds they hoi
largely purchased at a great depreciation, an
by investing $750,000 in land to be distribute!
among their lavorites; and all this time the
kept an agent in New York, bonowinj
the money on call, and hypothecating th
bonds of lhe State in the wildest manner
and endorsing Hie bonds of railroads to an al
most indefinite exient, so that leading mern
bers of the Senate openly avowed pheir in
ability to compute the actual indebtedness o
the Slate, as I have already quoted lo you
Ace you surprised that the credit of the State
should have fallen so low ? Bepudiatioit is al
ways a-celine which never falls to bring "astin'
and severe punishment home to the perpetra
tors. An individual or a State may become s<
reduced by misfortune or bad management ai
lo be uuabie to meet obligations, but no indi
vidual or State lias ever profited byan exercls?
of bad laith, no matter how ingenious the ar
guinema used in justification.
I have seen the -Tovernor of a State almos
repulsed from a banker's office when applying
for a loan, willi Uuiied . States bouda ai
security, because Iiis State having repudiatec
some territorial issues of bonds. The hankel
refused to hold intercourse willi bim officially.
South Carolina lias been terribly impoverish?
ed by the war, and her sons insulted anil
robbed by these adventurers which have been
forced upon lier, but the honor of the State is
in the custody pf her sons, and 'will suffer no
diminution at their hands.
We have everything here buta good ?overn
ment and active capital. Our people are in?
telligent, Industrious, and honest; our sod is
productive and our climate genial. Controver?
sies like this, if conducted with conservative
decision, will gradually enlist large numbers
om ol the ranks ol the par'.y which hav j been
acting against us. I am confident that Hie
con-xrvative element of that party are
a-sham-'d of'.heir company, and aro too Ameri?
can ai heart *.o sustain 'he practices ami meas?
ures we complain ot. Capital will flow in
upon us when we can demonstrate the safety
and profit of investments iu our produci ve in?
dustry, by Hie r-uppressiou of the frauds and
extravagance which now threaten to drive
Hie State lalo bankruptcy, as our rulers
have already disgraced us by repudiation.
Railroads and manufactories will be organiz?
ed, and our laborers will be able lo enjoy the
fruits of their industry, which is now taken
from them tinder the forms of taxes, to pam?
per corrupt and ignorant representatives who
amuse the newspaper correspondence of the
country, and demonstrate that civilization is
not always onward, even wiien directed by
ihe party of progress.
While we mus: investiga... and use every
effort to correct the evils which have befallen
the Slate, and co-operate with all parlies and
all persons who will lend us a helping bund to
restore her to her former position of cignily
and power, and her ^citizens to all the rights
and immauiiies becoming freemen, still we
.must not be discouraged if our progress tails
below our hopes. We cannot disguise; from
ourselv?s that the fearful losses of the late
civil war have net only seriously impaired our
power o: reproduction as citizens of this State,
but have also entallec? heavy burdens on us aa
" citizens or the United States. The production
ol wealth must be necessarily elow for years to
come, and therefore the greater necessity o f
enforcing the most rigid economy' on those
who expend the public money of the State
and that of the Federal Government.
The taxable value of the property of the
State, in 18G0, was $490,003,000, and the taxe s
only $392,000; now the taxable property has
been reduced to $184,000,000, and the taxes in?
creased to $2,000,00i)-^so, you perceive, while
your property has been reduced to less than
half its tonner value, your taxes have been
increased five hundred per cent.
Indeed, the recent census reports show a
heavy decrease in the property ol the Southern
States, nearly $2,000,000,000, and the present *
debt of the United States, say $2,500,000.000,
Just about balances the accumuUtlons of the
people for the past ten years, leaving no prouts
-and hence the steady but Blow decline of
real estate and other property depending on
accumulations ol wealth for an advance In
price.
The Government, of the United States are
now drawing from the hard earnings of the
people some $400,000,000 per annum, which ls
at least $1,000,000 more than the surplus earn?
ings have shown tor the yearly average of the
last ten years.
From 1850 to 18G0 the increase ci wealth in
the United States was $4,500,000,000, or bat
$450,000,000 annually. From I860 to 1870 the
increase is but $2,500,000,000, or $250,000,000
annually.-1 simply adduce these figures to
show that we must not be too sanguine for the
future with these burdens of Radical ride in
the National and State governments thrown
upon us. Nor yet must we be discouraged by
the falling off In value of real 'estate and other
property, and the limited profits ot our indus?
try. With ail these drawbacks, we compare fa?
vorably with every section of the country.
And the restoration ot' Intelligent; and honest
men to power, working under the true doc?
trines of the Constitution at Washington and v
Columbia, which is not far off, will soon re?
store that prosperity and true national great?
ness which formerly characterized us as a
people.
Mr. President, I desire to offer the following
resolution :
Resolved. That a committee of three be appointed
by the president to investigate and report a plan
to restore the credit, of the State, and to confer
with the representatives or the tire loan securi?
ties which have been repudiated by the State au?
thorities, with u view lo repairing the damages to
the good faith oj the State, by influencing an
early payment of the principal and interest of
said obligations. _ _
A GREAT BATTLE IMMINENT.
Escape of General Kossel from Parla?
Stringency- of the Commune's Diacl
pllnc-Germany'Remita a Half Mil?
liard of the War Debt-Terrific Bom.
bardaient of Paris-Grand Massing of
Troops on Both Sides.
PAMS, May 10.
Al a secret silting of the Commune Tuesday,
it was decided to Insist on the resignation of
ihe committee of public safety, and that the
appointment of their successors bo made-im?
mediately. The Commune also decided to
meet three .days of each week, except In case
of emergency, when the sittings will be held
permanently. Its sessions will be held in lhe
Hotel de Ville.
Delescluze announced that General Bossel "
adheres to his resignation, and appeared to
the Commune to forego all animosities. The
meeting was characterized with recrimina-,
tlons between members of the central com?
mittee and those of the committee on public
safety.
The tri-color is floating from the corner of
Fort Issy, but the fort is apparently not
occupied by the Versallllsts. The Commune
announces that it is unoccupied .and unten?
able.
The sub-committee of organization, in a pro?
clamation Issued to-day, orders the most re?
lentless measures towards the besiegers. No
soldier will be allowed to depart in the slight?
est degree from lhi3 duty, and all troops are
forbidden to cease firing upon Versallllsts who
may attempt to surrender, while fugitives an d
stragglers are to be sabred when caught, or il
In numerous bodies to be fired into mercilessly
by cannon and mitrailleurs.
- BERLIN, May 10.
Prince Bismarck has met the request of the
Versailles Government In a very liberal spirit.
By the treaty ot peace Just signed, he has
agreed to a reduction of the war Indemnity by
haifa milliard of lrancB, consequently the
Germans receive immediately a French .bond
for four and a half milliards of francs, payable
within one year, and endorsed by French and
German bankers. The bond is convertible
Into stocks or consols, whichever Germany
may prefer. Two milliards of francs are
already taken by Baron Rothschild and Baron
Erlanger, the Frenen bankers, and by Herr
Hahu, the German banker. Immediately on
the ratification of the treaty, the majority of
the German forces will leave France.. The
forts east and south of Paris' will be surren?
dered to the Versailles Government lmmedate
ly, and all prisoners in Germany returned to
France a3 rapidly a3 railroads can transport
them. The Germans will hold only Belfort,
Languey and Nancy as hostages, until the ful?
filment of the conditions.
LONDON, May io.
There was brisk fighting at Neulliy last
uight. The Versailles troops have turned
electric lights towards Paris. Rossel's resig?
nation has been accepted, and he is placed
under arrest. Delescluze has been appointed
to the position vacated by Rossel. Dombrow
ski was offered the command of the army, but
refuses uoless it is made supreme. Durassier,
commander of the insurgent garrison in
Vunvres, was wounded to-day. The forces ol
the Versailles Government are assembling In
the Bois de Boulogne in large numbers. The
column in the Place Vendome was partially
destroyed to-day. Ciuseret is under examina?
tion at Hie Hotel de Ville. He was removed
from the Maz?is prison this morning.
SEVRES. May 10-Night.
The grand attack on Paris is imminent.
I Thousands of yards of trenches are completed,,
and the assaulting columns are within five
hundred yards ol the ramparts of Paris, all
ready for the order to advance to the assault.
Daring the past twenty-four hours the gov
ernment batteries have been firing an average
of eighty shots per minute. This unprece?
dented bombardment is having a terrible ef?
fect upon the insurgents.
VERSAILLES, May io-9 p. M.
The great assault upon the fcrtifijations wil I
bo made to-night. Pont du Jour has been
knocked to pieces by the fire from the battery
at Montretout.
VERSAILLES, May ll.
The cannonade continues. The effect is de?
scribed as tremendous. Fort Vanvres still
resists. The government troops carried the
barricades of Rue La Reine.
The Latest.
PARIS, May ll.
General Rossel wa3 arrested yesterday and
placed ia the custody ol M. Gerandin. At 5
o'clock yesterday both of them disappeared
and have not yet been recaptured.
The principal attack of the Versallllsts is ex- '
pected at Auteuil and Pont Du Jour. Both
sides are massing troops for a great battle.
Delescluze has been appointed Minister o?
War to the Commune. TheoSclal reports to
the Commune deny that the Versalliste haye
gained any victories.