The Anderson intelligencer. (Anderson Court House, S.C.) 1860-1914, January 18, 1877, Image 1
?SAZSS^QF.. SUSSCRLPTl&X.-Jyro Dollaxs
per annum, and Oxb Dollar for aix months.
Subscriptions are not taken for a leu period
than six aaonths.
Liberal deduction! made to clubs of ton or
more subscribers.
RATES OF ADVERTISING.?One Dollar p*r
? quare ot one ineb for the first insertion, and Fifty
Cents per square for subsequent insertions less than
three months. No advertisements counted lees
tHsn a square.
Liberal contracts will be made with those wishing
to advertise for three, six or twelve mouths. Ad?
vertising by contract must be confined to the im?
mediate business of the firm or Individual contrac?
ting. ' 1
Obituary Notices exceeding five lines, Tributes
of Bespect, and all personal communications or
matters of individual interest, will be charged for
at advertising rates. Announcements of marriages
and deaths, and notices of a religious character, are
respectfully solicited, and will be inserted gratis
ELECTION OF COUNTY OFFICERS.
A Decision of the Question whether
theke was a lawful election^by
County Officers in Novembeb?
An Appeal to the Supbeme Coubt.
Before Judge Reed, in the Court of
General Sessions for Charleston County,
an agreement was made in the case of
Jacob Williman vs. John H. Ostendorff,
who were co n t es tints for the Cleric of the
Court in said County, to. hare a contro?
versy without action, or a friendly suit to
determine which of the contestants was
entitled to the office. The question in
difference submitted to the Court was
whether, under the Constiution and laws
of the State of South Carolina, Mr. Wil?
liman, as holding the office till his succes?
sor should be elected and qualified, is
such clerk, or whether Mr. Ostendortt is
such successor and entitled to the office
by reason of the-rotes cast for him on
the 7th November, 1876, and the subse?
quent declaration of the board of State
canvassers.
It was-agfeed tnat Mr. O^errddrff had
been commissioned, and had taken the
oath of office and given the bond as re?
quired by law, and is in all respects duly
qualified to perform the duties of said
office, provided that the 7th day of No?
vember was the proper day for holding
the election for said office.
The case was elaborately argued on
both sides, and. Judge Reed announced.
his decision and opinion in the-case as
follows^
In Be. Jacob Williman and John H. Os?
tendorff, to be Clark of CouvL?Conlro
vcrtj!mu&tir Action.
To determine the .question submitted
to! the Court in the case made, it is neces?
sary to recur to and state the principal
constitutional and legislative provisions
in regard to the election of State and
county officers. f
It is provided by Section 11, Article 2
of the Constitution, reading it as amen?
ded in 1872-3, that "the first election for
Senators and Representatives * * *
shall be held on the 14th, 15th and 16th
days of April of the present year, (1868)
and the second election shall be held on
the third Wednesday in October, 1870,
and forever thereafter on the first Tues?
day following the first Monday in No?
vember in every second year." So that
the 7th November last was unquestiona?
bly the day fixed by the constitution for
the election of members of the General
Assembly.
In Article 3, Section 2 and 5, it is pro?
vided that the Governor and Lieutenant
Governor "shall be elected at the first
genera! election held under the constitu?
tion for members of the General Assem?
bly, and at each general election there?
after." The term general election is ap?
plied by the constitution to the election
of Senators and Representatives, and
would seem to be fixed thereby.
In section 23 of the same article it is
provided-thafc "there shall be elected by
the qualifier! voters of the State a "Comp?
troller General, a Treasurer and a Secre?
tary of State, who shall hold their respec?
tive offices' for the term of four years,"
but no time is fixed for the election.
Section 19 of. Article 4 provides that
three persons shall be elected by the
qualified voters of each county for the
term of two years, who shall constitute a
board of County Commissioners, but no
time is prescribed for their election.
Section 20 provides for the election of
a Probate Judge for each county for the
term of two years, but is silent as to the
time of election.
Section 27 provides that "thereshall
be elected in each county * * * one
Clerk of the Court * * * who shall
hold his office for four years, and until
his successor shall be elected and quali?
fied/' but fixes no time for his election.
Section 28 provides that "an Attorney
General for the State shall be elected by
the qualified electors for the term of four
years," fixing, however, no time for the
election.
Section 30 provides for the election of
a Sheriff ana * Coroner for each county,
fiv the term of four years each, but is
silent as to the ti me of their election..
Section 1, Article 10, provides for a
Superintendent of Education, who shall
be elected at the same time that the State
officers are elected.
Section 3, Article 13, provides for the
election of an Adjutant and Inspector
General at the same time that the State
officers are elected, and
Section 10, Article 14, directs the time
when all State officers shall be elected, to
wit: at the general election of Senators
and Representatives, which is, as has
been shown, "on the first Tuesday follow?
ing the first Monday in November of
every second year," as to those officers
whose term is for two years, and in every
fourth year as to those whose terms are
for four years.
The constitution is, therefore, entirely
silent as to the time when county officers
shall be elected, and has been so regarded
and treated by the convention that
framed it, and by the General Assem?
bly.
This, as to the constitution, is demon?
strated by an ordinance ratified on the
7th of March, 1868, to be found in the
Revised Statutes immediately following
the constitution; and as to the General
Assembly, by the legislation that has
been bad on the subject. By the ordi?
nance referred to, an election was oidered
to be held for the. ratification of the con?
stitution and the election of State officers
on the 14th, 15th an<t 16th days of April
of the same year, and a board of com?
missioners, appointed by the same ordi?
nance, were authorized aud required to
order an election for all county officers, to
be held within thirty days after the rati?
fication of the constitution. The first
election fi^r'county officer* waa provided
for, therefoTey* by the" cohVen*tion that
framed the constitution, and was held in
fmrsuance of the ordinance in May, 1868,
eaving it to the General Assembly to
provide for all f?ttire elections.
This they proceeded to do, and the
first, act on the subject to which my at?
tention has been called is that of the 14th
of February, 1870, as re-enacted in the
Revised Statutes, part 1st, title 2d, chap?
ter 10, page 38, "of the election of county
officers." The first 8ection of that act
provides that "there shall be a general
election for the election of the following
county officers, to wit: Judge of Probate,
County Commissioners, School Commis?
sioners, held in each county on the third
Wednesday of October, 1870, and on the
same day in every second year thereafter,
and for the election of Sheriff and Clerk
of the Court of Common Pleas on the
third Wednesday of October, 1872, and
on the same duy in every fourth year
thereafter."
By the second section of the County
Commissioners' act of the 13th of April,
1875, (15th Statute, 986,) an effort was
made to take the election of these officers
out of the act referred to, which effort
was consummated by the act of 24th of
March, 1876, (16th Statute, 163,) and the
election of County Commissioners is now
fixed to come off with the general elec?
tion in November of every second year.
These acts demonstrate that the Legisla?
ture of 1375-76 did not consider the time
for electing county officers as prescribed
by the constitution, or by any statute ip
relation to the; (Jcneral'election, as providea
for in that instrument.
The term general election, as will be
seen, was applied in the constitution only
to the election of *nembers of the Gen?
erat Assembly, but ?ere the Legislature
applies it to the election of county offi?
cers, and it seems to hare been used in?
differently by that body as descriptive of
either State or county elections, if held
in the several counties at the same time.
This will appear by rc Vence to the 1st
section of an act entitled "Of County
Sheriffs," Chapter 20, page 157 of the
Revised Statutes, and also in the 1st sec?
tion of an act entitled "Of County Coro?
ner," Chapter 21, page 170, Revised
Statutes.
On the 1st March, 1870, the General
Assembly passed another act entitled, as
republishcd in the Revised Statutes,
Title 2, Chapter 8, page 29, "Of the man?
ner of conducting elections and returning
votes." The first section of that act pro?
vides "that the general elections in this
State shall be held pursuant to the consti?
tution thereof, on the third Wednesday in.
October, 1870, and forever thereafter on
the same day in every second year, and
shall be regulated and conducted accord?
ing to rules, principles and provisions
herein prescribed." It has been adjudged
that the provisions Of this act in the first
and other sections are inconsistent with
the act of the 14th February, and if not
operating as a repeal of the former cither
directly or by implication, at least furn
I isbes a presumption that the Legislature
intended to include the election of all
officers, State and county, and hence cov
ering the election of Clerk of the Court.
It will be seen that this act was passed
by the same Assembly at the same session
and only fourteen days after the act of
the 14th of February, and whilst it was
designed in its several provisions follow?
ing the first section to direct the manner
pf holding and declaring all elections, it
in no way conflicts in its first section or
elsewhere with the terms of the act of
the 14th February fixing the time for
holding elections for the principal county
officers. It does, indeed, in the first sec?
tion prescribe the time for holding the
general elections, (which Is, perhapa,"not
inappropriate, considering the number of
State officers to be voted for,) but in pur?
suance to the constitution and the elec?
tion for Senators and Representatives is
that that is termed general in the consti?
tution, and the only one it attempts to
fix the. time for holding. The act of the
14th of February, 1870, was intended to
supply an omission in the constitution by
fixing a time for holding elections for the
principal county officers thereby created,
whilst that of the 1st of March, 1870, was
to enforce the mandate of the constitution
prescribing the time for holding the gen?
eral election?that is, the election for
members of the General Assembly, and
to arrange the machinery for conducting
and declaring all elections. These sta?
tutes are, therefore, designed to aid in
carrying out the scheme of the constitu?
tion, and are in no way inconsistent with
each other. But even if there was sub?
stance in the argument as to the effect of
the first section of the act of the 1st of
March, 1870, it has been repealed by the
act of the 19th of March, 1874, 15 Sta?
tutes, 788, leaving the balance of that
statute, and the act of the 14th of Feb?
ruary, 1870, except as to County Com?
missioners, of full force as the law of the
land, and the only law directing and au?
thorizing the election of Clerk of the
Court.
This view, I am inclined to think, is in
accord with the intention of the fraraers
of the constitution and of the members
of the General Assembly who passed the
acts referred to. The office of Senators
and Representatives, as also of the mem?
bers of the Executive department and of
most of the State officers who are directed
by the constitution to be elected at the
same time, are political in their charac?
ter, and it is entirely proper, not only
that they should be elected together, but
that for the convenience of the electors
and the good order of society the election
should be held on the same day upon
which members of Congress and Presi?
dential Electors are chosen. Not so,
however, with the county offices. Most
of these are judical in'their character and
the incumbents should be chosen exclu?
sively on account of their peculiar quali?
fications and character. Indeed, the pub?
lic interest demands that their selection
should be entirely unconnected with the
excitements and contentions of a politi?
cal election, and it would be vastly better
for the general weal if six months instead
of three weeks could intervene between
the day of their appointment and the
general election. For being chosen on
the day of the political election they are
driven to become partisans, and the idea
of a partisan Judge of Probate, a partisan
Clerk of Court or a partisan County
Commissioner is abhorrent to a decent
regard for public justice, and to require
i an aspirant for any of these offices to go
upon the hustings and engage in a parti
I san scramble is to unfit him for an impar?
tial discharge of the important trusts to
be confided to him. I am, therefore, in?
duced to believe that considerations like
these led to the fixing of the election of
these important officers on a different day
than that upon which the general elec?
tions are held. However that may be, it
is my business to declare the law as I find
it, and to my mind the construction I
have given to the matter in controversy
is so clear that I do not perceive how
there can be two opinions upon the sub?
ject.
It is therefore adjudged, That the elec?
tion held for Clerk of the Court of Com?
mon Pleas for Charleston County on the
7th of November last was without war?
rant of law, and that the defendant, John
H. C jtendorff, acquired no legal title to
the office thereby.
And it isfurthe. adjudged, That Jacob
Willimaq, thefplainttff,[holds 015er .under
the constitution, and is authorised and
requireb^tc^'exercisV the duties7 T>f the
office until a successor shall have been
lawfully appointed.
January 9,1877. J. P. Reed.
The Court room was crowded with the
members of the bar and eager spectators
who had assembled, many of them from
sheer curiosity, to hear the termination
of the case and to learn who was Clerk.
During the reading of the opinion strict
order and silence were maintained, and
at the announcement of Court's judgment
the counsel for Ostendorff gave notice of
an immediate appeal to the Supreme
Court. Ostendorff hung around the
Court room for awhile and then retired.
?Edward W. Lee, Mr. Williman's deputy,
who has been holding the fort with him
since the late election and has determined
to sink or swim with him, came triumph?
antly forward, and quietly proceeded to
assist Mr. Winkler in the duties of the
offne.
Later in the day Col. Simonton sub?
mitted the following writ of ouster, which
the Judge signed:
The State of South Carolina, Charleston
County. The State ex rcf. Jacob Willi
man vs. John H. Ostendorff.
The proceeding)- in this case having
been submitted to the Court on a ca-ie
stated in a controversy without action,
and it appearing to the Court that the
election under which the respondent
claims was not held at the time prescribed
j by Jaw, to wit: on the third Wednesday
)0 October, 1876, and that the relator,
under the Constitution, holds- ovfer fc?tii
a successor 10 him has been duly elected
and qualified.
It is adjudged, That the defendant,
John H. Ostendorff, be ousted from th*
office of the Clerk of Court of General
Sessions and Common Pleas.
And be it further adjudged, That Jacob
Williman, named in the proceedings and
a plaintiff in this action, is and he is
hereby declared to be entitled to hold
said office in that he was the duly elected
Clerk of the said Court, under the elec?
tion held in 1872, and, having qualified
as such, is entitled to hold the same until
his successor is duly elected and qualified.
January 9, 1877. J. P. Keed.
Upon the issuing of this order the
counsel for Sir. Williman were served
with notice of appeal by Major Stone on
behalf of Ostendorff, and the case will
be taken immediately to the Supreme
Court.
air. Williman did not make his ap?
pearance, being confined to his room by
sickness. According to the agreement
entered into by the counsel on both sides,
Mr. Williman will be entitled to enter
immediately upon the duties of the office,
while Ostendorff resorts to an appeal to
the Supreme Court. Should the Supremo
Court sustain the decision of the Court
below, Mr. Williman holds over until
another regular election be held or an
extra election be ordered. But if the
Supreme Court should reverse the decis?
ion of Judge Reed, then Ostendorff will
enter upon the duties of the office, and
will be entitled to all the fees. &c, which
have accrued during Mr. Williman'b oc?
cupancy of the office.
Sonth Carolines Senator, (Jen. X. C.
Butler.
No one supposes that the Democratic
Legislature of South Carolina either
would or could please the Northern
Radicals in theiir choice of a United
States Senator. The vials of their wrath
were all ready to be poured out upon the
devoted head of any gentleman, thus
honored by the legal Legislature of the
Palmetto State. It is not to be wondered
at, therefore, that all the barrel organs of
the Grant dynasty are abusing, to the
best of their ability, the distinguishe i
soldier and statesman who will alone rep?
resent South Carolina in the United
States Senate *ft:r the fourth of March
next. In this section Gen. Butler is
known to us all as one of the most moder?
ate and conservative men in South Caro?
lina, and knowing this fact, it is not nec?
essary for us to enlarge upon it. But we
take pleasure in reproducing from the
Philadelphia Times, a journal thoroughly
independent in politics, the following ar?
ticle. In speaking of General Butler's
career and antecedents, it says:
"And what are the facts? Mr. Butler
is a highly cultured South Carolinian,
who has ever been conspicuous for his
conservative counsels and actions. He
served under Hampton during the rebel?
lion, lost a leg at Brandy Station, rose to
the rank of Major-General in the insur?
gent army by his merits as a soldier, and,
like ail brave men on both sides, when
the war ended he bowed to the arbitra?
ment of the sword, and has ever been in
accord with Hampton in teaching, alike
by precept and example, submission to
the government in the generous spirit
that is due from faithful citizenship. He
was at Hamburg on professional business
pn the day of the horrible butchery, and:
as the preliminary hearing proved, had
no part in.the bloody affair, except to
make exhaustive efforts to maintain the
peace. But his prominence as a citizen
made him an inviting target for those
Who sought to turn a cowardly murder to
political advantage, instead of judicially
ascertaining the truth and punishing the
guilty, and his name has been insepara?
bly interwoven with that revolting trage?
dy. Gov. Chamberlain was then the un?
disputed Governor of South Carolina,
with the regular troops practically at his
command, with his State militia armed
and absolutely under his orders, with Re?
publican judges in every judicial district,
and with Republican machinery for the
selection of jurors. He had but to com ?
mand the law, whose agencies were **1
in political accord with himself, to en?
force swift judgment against the murder?
ers, for atrocious murderers there were at
Hamburg beyond a question. But that
did not suit the purpose of the man who
was charged with the preservation of the
peace of the State and the enforcement
of the laws. Instead of summoning the
law to assert its majesty, he rushed away
to Washington and called for "more
troops" with dramatic Sourish to fire the
Northern heart. In a public letter he
associated the name of Mr. Butler with
the massacre, to which the accused pub?
licly answered that he was innocent, that
he was voluntarily in the hands of the
law, and that he challenged prompt and
searching judicial investigation of the
murderous affair, so that the innocent
should be acquitted aud the guilty pun?
ished; Nor aid Mr. Butler, like Gover?
nor Chamberlain, stop with a newspaper
Sreclamation. At the earliest moment
c appeared before a Republican judge
and asked?not for his discharge, but for
a reference of the case to the proper tri?
bunal for the most exhaustive'investiga?
tion. The Republican Judge held this
"red-handed ruffian," this "moving spirit
in the bloodiest deed recorded in our
modern history," to bail in the sum of
one thousand dollars for his appearance
at the court for trial. This was last mid?
summer, and why has he not been tried ?
Why has the Republican Governor not
made his Republican judge call in his
Republican jurors and try Mr. Butler for
the Hamburg massacre? Five blacks
were horribly butchered after they had
been captured and disarmed. There
must be a clear case of most diabolical
murder against some parties, and if Mr.
Butler aided or abetted the murderers, be
is equally guilty with them alike in law
and morals, and why has he not been
tried? He has publicly challenged
Chamberlain to try him before all tbe
Chamberlain legal machinery, and he
gave notice that ne would then and there
show who wore, the real authors of the
Hamburg tragedy that he had striven
most earnestly to prevent. It was this
notice that made Chamberlain retreat
from the trial of Butler. It was the fear
that Butler would prove that the Ham?
burg massacre was concocted and forced
to consummation by political leaders
most trusted in the counsels of Chamber?
lain, and that it would be established
before a Republican court aud a Repub?
lican jury that the Hamburg outbreak
was one of the deliberately planned fea?
tures of tbe Chamberlain political cam?
paign to arouse the country, furnish an
excuse to place South Carolina under
martial law and thus insure a new lease
of carpet-bag power in that State. From
August lust until now Mr. Butler has
defied Chamberlain in his own courts,
and as yet be is without any to accuse
him at the bar of justice. Such is the
truth of Mr. Butler's association with the
Hamburg butchery so far as the public
cau judge from an impartial hearing of
both sides."
So long as this distinguished Carolinian
is thus nown to tne enlightened press
and people of the North, he can afford to
pass over iu silence the petty mouthing
of those Radical papers whose political
creed begins and ends with hatred to the
South and L6r people'.
THE STRUGGLE IN LOUISIANA.
Initial Success of the Democrats?A
Peaceful Revolution Accomplished.
SpteUxl Correspondence of the Kew York Herald.
New Orleans, La., Jan. 9,1877.
The long expected hour of contest has
arrived, and though thus far in its pro?
gress no gun has been fired, the events of
the day have left the Republicans no
foothold in the State except that bound?
ed by the walls of the State House and
the Custom House. That this has been
accomplished, and without bloodshed, is
owing to the fact, which is admitted by
all parties, that the Packard government,
like its predecessor, has not one iota of
moral support in this community, while
its physical backing, when deprived of
the co-operation of federal troops, has
proved almost equally insignificant.
The question upon which the issue was
made to-day was solely whether Sheriff
Handy (Democrat) should be supported
in defending possession of the court
buildings. It was known that the Pack?
ard Supreme Court would sit to-day.
The new Superior Civil Court had already
set, and it was believed by the citizens
that if this was peaceably submitted to
the question of a de facto government
would be decided against them. This
they were resolved to combat, and all
day Mondav Generals Ogden, Penn,
Nicholls and" other advisers were in earn?
est consultation. A preventive policy
was at first determined upon, but the
new members of the Supreme Court being
called in council no decision was arrived
at in time for action on Monday.
It was nearly twelve.o'clock last night
before the Governor and his advisers de?
termined to act upon the vigorous policy
recommended by Generals Penn and
Ogden. At that late hour orders were
issued through couriers ordering the dif?
ferent military organizations in the city,
amounting to between 2,000 and 3,000
well armed men, besides a similar num?
ber with side arms only, to be in position
near the temporary State House, oppo?
site Lafayette square, by nine a. m.
The night, though bitterly cold, was
an eventful one. Couriers dashed
through the streets, cabs rumbled in
every direction, while the rat-tat-tat upon
the doors and ringing of bells echoed in
every neighborhood, summoning the
faithful to the field. Scarcely had day?
light dawned before groups of men were
seen hurrying through the streets in every
direction.
By eight o'clock armed parties began
to assemble in the neighborhood, but it
was not until.ten o'clock that the crowd
commenced augmenting by the arrival of
organized bodies of citizen soldiers who
were in their every-day clothes, and
armed with every description of weapon
from the Winchester down to the saloon
rifle.. By. eleven a. m. General Ogden
appeared on the field and rapidly com?
pleted the organization, which shortly
after moved down to the levee toward
Jackson square, numbering about 1,000
completely armed men, one battery of
artillery, consisting of two nine pound
howitzers and about 3,000 men with side
arms only. As they marched down, Gen?
eral Penn heading the column, their
ranks constantly augmented. From
every direction people, armed with every
describable species of weapon, were soon
hastening to the'scene of conflict.
Arriving opposite Jackson square,
which fronts the court buildings, where a
large crowd had already assembled, one
company was despatched, under com?
mand of Captain J. D. Hill, to demand
the surrender. In the meanwhile the
Packard Supreme Court had opened at
ten o'clock, with Judges Ludeling, King
and Leonard. Sheriff Handy having re?
fused to recognize their authority he was
suspended and Alfred Bo urges sworn in
in his place. About the time the head
of General Ogdcn's column reached the
Sound they had adjourned in respect to
e memory of Judge Saucier, who died
yesterday, and thereupon left the build?
ing unmolested by the crowd assembled.
Shortly after the gates were thrown
open by "the police, who surrendered the
court room, the Third precint station and
the State. Arsenal, all of which are
located in the same building and which
the forces of General Ogden proceeded to
occupy. Sheriff Handy at once notified
the Nicholls Supreme Judges, who im?
mediately repaired to the court room,
where the Supreme Court was duly open?
ed by the Sheriff and shortly after ad?
journed, leaving the former in full pos?
session. General Ogden remained in
possession until one p. m., when be
moved the forces to the levee, threaten?
ing the State House.
Pending the progress of these events
Chief Boylan, under the orders of Lieu?
tenant Governor Wiltz, demanded the
surrender of the Central police station,
corner of Carondelet and Lafayette
streets. He was informed that it only
needed a show of force to effect it, and
this being made by one o'clock p. m. all
the important points, with the exception
of the State House, were in the hands of
the new governraeut, the other police
stations being abandoned. Shortly be?
fore three o'clock p. m. Governor Nicholls
issued the following proclamation :
Executive Department, )
New Orleans, January 9,1877. j
7b the People of IjOuisiana: I should
be most profoundly surprised and disap?
pointed should any citizen of Louisiana
at this moment so far forget himself as to
be guilty of any excess whatever. There
is danger in collecting together in large
bodies. I urge you, therefore, to return
at once peacefully to your homes. The
greater the wrongs to which you have
Been subjected the greater to your credit
should you recognize and recollect your
own simple ana plain duty as citizens.
Let no one be injured, however obnox?
ious he may be, and let the people of the
whole country see that we are law-abiding,
ju?t and moderate.
Francis T. Nicholls,
Governor of the State of Louisiana.
In the State House the greatest appre?
hensions prevailed. Early in the morn
itig Packard telegraphed to President
Grant to recognize his government to?
day or all was lost. The Metropolitan
Telegraph wires were cut during the
morning and application was made bv
Packard to the United States Signa't
Corps by whom men were furnished, and
an active signalling between the State
House and Custom House was continued
during the day.
During the previous night all the arms
from the different police stations and the
most reliable portion of the force itself
had been concentrated at the State House, j
A strong disposition was manifested to
advance on this stronghold, and once
during the day, when an attack was made
by a number of boys, five shots were fired ,
from the windows, but only into the op?
posite wall. No one was hurt, however.
Soon after Mayor Austin drove up in a
carriage and read Governor Nicholls pro?
clamation, when part of the crowd dis?
persed, but the larger portion remained.
La:-o in the afternoon several deserters
from the Packard police went over to the
Nich dls militia and reported the Repub?
lican forces badly dom-Taiized.
During th" day the Legislature mot iu
Session and attempted to ballot for Sena?
tor, but Warraoth withdrawing with his
friends broke the quorum. Late this
evening they are still in possession, but
at Adjutant Penn's office it is reported
that it will certainly be abandoned during
the night.
About five o'clock p. m. General Og
den, who had kept his men massed upon
the levee, received orders to dismiss his
command, which immediately formed
into line and marched up town amid tbe
enthusiastic cheers of the people who
lined the streets.
In the way of quiet irony they made a
detour toward Kampart srteet, which
took them past ex-Gov. Kellogg's resi?
dence.
By six p. ra. the forces were all dis?
missed, the city perfectly quiet in charge
of the new police, and were it not for the
air of jollity upon all faces it would
hardly be conceived that a popular revo?
lution had occurred, overthrowing one
State government and establishing an?
other. One great cause of the satisfac?
tion manifest, no doubt, lay in its having
been bloodless.
Only one casualty occurred, and that
at the Arsenal where a soldier was woun?
ded in the leg by the accidental discharge
of his musket.
The Arsenal, when captured, contained
two Gatling guns, three Napoleons and
about 900 stand of small arms. Of these
about 800 were immediately issued to
unarmed companies. Two companies are
in charge for the night. These, with a
picket cordon around the State House,
which permits anybody to leave but no
one to enter, constitute the only force
now on duty.
Before the column moved down to the
court buildings this morning a detach
ment of sharpshooters were detailed by
General Ogden, who took position upon
the roofs and galleries of all adjacent
houses commanding the position. The
forces were thoroughly drilled and dis?
ciplined, and consisting of the best peo?
ple of the community, carried a moral
impressment sadly demoralizing to tbe
Metropolitan police. Throughout the
entire proceedings the United States
troops remained closely confined In their
quarters, and, bey6nd cheering the Wash?
ington Artillery as it passed the windows
of the Custom House on its way to the
front, made no demonstration whatever.
Late in the afternoon General Green,
of General Augurs staff, had an interview
with Governor Nicholls, the particulars
of which have not yet transpired. Gen.
Augur, on being visited, reiterated his
often expressed information that his in?
structions were to keep the peace, and
that he would only interfere in case of
it being broken. It seems tbe action of
to-day was not regarded in that light.
It is highly probable the Nicholls'
Legislature will assemble in the State
House to-morrow or next day.
The Democratic Legislature, with a
quorum in both houses, voted for a Uni
nited States Senator. J. 0. Eustice re?
ceived a majority of the votes cast for
Senator for the term ending in 1879.
There was no choice for Senator for the
long term.
Orders have been issued to the picket
cordon to permit free ingress and egress
to the State House. Everything quiet.
The Republican Legislature is still in
session at twelve o'clock midnight, and
will continue so all night and until
twelve o'clock to-morrow, endeavoring to
obtain a quorum so as to ballot for United
States Senator. Up to twelve p. m. this
had not been secured. Warmoth seems
determined to keep it broken.
Mr. Packard had been at the State
House all day, and announced his inten?
tion to defend his government to the last
extremity. He had concentrated his
forces on that point and the Court House,
and was much chagrined to learn that
the defences of the latter had surrendered
without striking a blow.
All kinds of sensational rumors are
afloat to-night, notably one that the State
House is to be attacked. On this subject
prominent Democrats stated that the
plan of the Democrats was to have the
Supreme Court enjoin Packard from
usurping the functions of Governor, and
in the event of his refusing to have him
arrested for contempt.
Nothing was done by the House com?
mittee to-day beyond continuing the ex?
amination of Colonel Zacharie in regard
to the action of the Returning Board.
Ex-Governor Kellogg, who has re?
mained all day in the State House, is
evidently dumbfounded at the turn affairs
have taken. He bad never believed that
the people would undertake so desperate
a measure. He expresses his determina?
tion to hold the State House, believing
that a conflict is sure to secure the inter?
ference of the United States military.
All kinds of rumors are in circulation,
principally emanating from the State
House?one to the effect that General
Grant has telegraphed General Augur to
disperse all illegal bodies of armed men
and that Governor Nicholls and Govern?
or Packard had each been served with
copies. It is admitted, however, that the
practical effect of this order depends upon
General Augur's interpretation of the
word "illegal," to which the largest lati?
tude seems to be given. At General
Nicholl's headquarters this is positively
denied.
Another rumor states that Mod on has
telegraphed announcing that tbe Demo?
cratic Supreme Court will not be recog?
nized, and that the Packard government
will be sustained by the Executive An?
other, upon better authority, but still
doubtful, says that General Graut will
to-morrow issue a proclamation settling
the whole issue definitely in favor of tin
Packard government.
Governor Packard upon being inter?
viewed, appeared to be utterly in thedark.
remarking that he expected despatches
in an hour. After a close investigation
your correspondent is inclined to think
that this must all be taken cum grano
sali?.
The Republicans are badly demoral?
ized, ami from every visible appearance,
their power is melting like snow before I
the sun. Without federal interference, j
and that promptly their cause is evident?
ly hopeless.
The Nicholls government have a
strong police force on duty throughout
the city.
Hamvton's Letter.?The Galveston
News (Dem.) does not regard General
Hampton's letter to Governor Hayes in
the same light that most Democratic
journals do. Its comments are as fol?
lows:
Ham [.ton's letter to Hayes must be re?
garded as another fine stroke of policy by
j that master of political tact. It places
the cause of good government in South
Carolina, which is still sadly misunder?
stood by many of Mr. Haves' partisans,
. in a new and striking light bet?re all in
j telligent Republicans who have been
I misled as to the actual condition of
! things in that unhappy State and the
\ nature of the political conflict there.
! This we suppose to have been its sole
purpose; as the similar communication to
Mr. Tilden save* General Hampton from
any possible suspicion of a harsraiti, and
such a purpose, it is to bp hoped, the !et
tcr will materially sub-erve.
? When you're in a quandary whattO
write about, an article on snow ought al?
ways to cover the ground these times.
THE DUAL GOVERNMENTS.
Operation of the Hampton machinery
of Government? Chamberlain's Reli?
ance on Washington for Support.
Correspondence New York Herald.
Columbia, Jan. 7,1877.
The Senate committee has been in ses?
sion now nearly one month, and has ex?
amined about 260 witnesses, a large ma?
jority of whom were negroes carefully
collected by United States District At?
torney Corbin from the vicinity of the
scenes of the Hamburg and Ellenton
riots. About one-fourth of the witnesses
were white men introduced by Senator
Merriman, Democrat, and I have infor?
mation which states that the testimony
of the latter has successfully rebutted
that given before the committee by Mr.
Corbin's witnesses.
the committee's mission.
The mission of this committee was
strictly to investigate whether any citizen
of the age of twenty-one had been denied
or abridged in their right to vote, but
Messrs. Chriatiancy ana Cameron have
gone into an elaborate and exhaustive
collection of outrages, atrocities and hor?
rors. So far, however, it has been clear?
ly and successfully established that be?
yond the unostentatious displays made by
the whites during the campaign, there
was little or no intimidation of votes
practiced, and that intimidation of ne?
groes by negroes was more extensive than
by whites. This was further demonstra?
ted by the fact that the Republican party
polled a larger vote at the last election
than it ever did before, which satisfacto?
rily refutes the charge of intimidation.
the outeage mill.
With these results staring them in the
face, the mission of the committee is a
failure as far as the party is concerned,
and hence it was necessary that they
should go into the outrage mill business
to enable them to make some sort of par?
ty capital. I am informed that on this
score the distinguished Republican Sen?
ators will also fail, for. it is well known
that neither the Hamburg affair nor the
Ellenton riot had any political signifi?
cance whatever.
j the gubernatorial question.
It is stated that Judge T. J. Mackey
will appear before the committee on
Tuesday next, and will produce docu?
mentary evidence very damaging to
Chamberlain. The latter, it is stated; is
engaged in preparing an elaborate docu?
ment, showing the grounds upon which
his proclamation was issued, for the com?
mittee. It will be hard for him to prove
that there was a necessity for a procla?
mation or for troops in the face of the
fact that he never attempted the arrest of
one of the Hamburg or Ellenton rioters.
the hampton government.
Hamptou's government floats- along
steadily. Contributions, under his call
for ten per cent, of last year's tax levy,
are rapidly flowing in from the tax-pay?
ers, and he has already placed the chari?
table institutions and the Penitentiary in
a condition far above any immediate or
prospective want. He is in daily receipt
of proffers of money and renewed assu?
rances of allegiance, and each mail
brings him a basketful of letters, to all
of which he gives bis personal supervis?
ion and attention. If this continues, as
the indications are that it certainly will,
the Chamberlain dynasty will assuredly
be starved out. despite the presence of the
company of United States troops at the
State House.
public meetings
of the taxpayers are being held in every
county in the State, which are in many
instances largely attended by negroes, at
which resolutions are passed condemning
Chamberlain's government as a usurpa?
tion, refusing to pay him a cent of tribute,
and indorsiug Hampton and pledging
him the support of all the taxpayers in
the State.
chamberlain on the situation.
Singular to relate, in the face of these
substantial overtures to Hampton and
these unanimous public demonstrations
in his favor, Chamberlain regards it all
with seeming philosophical equanimity.
He remarked to me to-day that the action
of the Hampton government in provi?
ding for the lunatics, orphans, and con?
victs relieved him of his greatest embar?
rassment, and he was gratified that the
Democratic taxpayers and other charita?
bly disposed persons had assumed the
care of these unfortunates. Chamberlain,
does not think that this voluntary contri?
bution of taxes will have any effect
whatever in deciding which is the legal
Governor of the State, and he congratu?
lates himself that such grave responsi?
bility has been temporarily removed from
his shoulders.
reliance on washington.
He says that the question of the Gov?
ernorship cannot be decided by the peo?
ple of the State now nor by any tribunal
in the State, but that it will be settled in
' Washington, either by Congress or by the
President. The. Governor, believes that
I the present condition of affairs will drag
aloug until the 4th of March next, unless
i Congress sooner disposes of the question
! of the Governorship. He feels safe a?t
long as President Grant remains in the'
White House, and thinks that after his
term expires he will be supported by
Hayes, who, he firmly believes, will be
inaugurated. If, on the other hand, Til
den should occupy the Presidential chair
for the next four years he has but little
doubt that the latter would recognize
Hampton and his government. .
the senatorial question.
Another view taken by Chamberlain is
that, if Congress fails to act in the matter
l?efore tlie 4th of March, the question as
to the legality of the State government
will come up squarely before the Senate
upon the application of General Butler,
the Democratio Senator elect, and of Uni?
ted Slates and District Attorney Corbin,
the Republican Senator elect, tor admis?
sion to that body.
the proclamation programme.
Under the influence of the sharp criti?
cisms in the Northern papers and advi?
ces from Washington, Gov. Chamberlain
seem? to have abandoned the anti ipated
prugramme of issuing a proclamation
against Hampton and his government, as
such a game would be too dangerous.
He uow says that he does not look for?
ward to any collisions or clashes of au?
thority that would be serious, and that
all minor conflicts a? to the possession of
offices would find an easy and peaceful
dilution in the courts. This in the first
time he has been known to trust any(
thing to a decision of the Stale courts,
und the Governor wa- in a degree felici?
tous and cheerful, which was-quite unu?
sual for him.
assurances from washington.
This frame of mind was, I found, in
the main, the effect of a telegram receiv?
ed by hi in from Washington. The dis
Sitch informed him that Congressmen
anks Lapiiani and Lawrence, tue Re?
publican members oi the House commit?
tee who were here in ventilating the elec?
toral vote of the State, had called upon
the President since their arrival in Wash?
ington, and hud assured him that Cham,?.,
beriaiu was elected Governor of the State.
Tbe House committee did not go into an
examination of tbe vote for Governor
except in an incidental manner, and
while the six Democrats are assured of
Hampton's election, the three Republi?
cans seem to be equally assured of Cham
berlan'a election according to his advices
from Washington.
the hayes-mackey interview.
Governor Chamberlain chuckled over
the annoyance occasioned among the
Democrats by Judge. Mackey's officious
zeal in visiting Governor Hayes and ma?
king professions and overtures which
have been published as coming from and
authorized by Hampton. He said that
while Governor Hampton had deuied.
these published reports,yet, nevertheless,
he could not divest himself of tbe fact
that Mackey was the accredited bearer
of a letter from him to Hayes which, in
itself, placed Hampton, in an awkward
position.
gov. Hampton's disclaimer.
In this connection Gov. Hampton is
.very emphatic in disclaiming all respon?
sibility for tbe views announced by Judge
T. J. Mackey in his interview with Mr.
Hayes. In the coune of a conversation
with your correspondent this afternoon
he stated that Judge Mackey went to
Ohio on private business, and was not
sent by him, nor. authorized. in apy way
to speak for him or for tbe Democracy of
South Carolina. The views be expressed
were his own, and General Hampton can
only account for the misconception which
has arisen upon the supposition that
Judge Mackey's declaration of bis own
views were in some manner confounded
with those he gave as coming from Hamp?
ton. ? ;?/? Ii "
tilden elected.j
General Hampton said in conversation
that he has always believed that Tilden
was fairly elected, hot has entertained
grave doubts as to whether he would be \
allowed to take his* seat,. He said: .;
i "Our people desire a peaceful, consti?
tutional solution of these questions, and I
we trust this will be had. Peace is essen?
tial to us, and we of tbe South should j
take no part in the . settlement of the
Presidential question until called on to
do so by some legitimate authority." ;
A GRAND SLEIGHING CARNITAL.
A Day of Jovial Fun at the Capital
?The Masquerade Procession Ex?
cited Great Merriment.
Washington, Jan. 6,1877.'
All Washington was gloriously excited
this afternoon-by a carnival sleighing
procession on Pennsylvania avenue, which
transcended in fantastic scenes and fun
any public frolic here since the grand
carnival of 1870. The broad avenue?
freshly paved with snow, and resembling,
in its width, at least, a Parisian boule?
vard?was before three o'clock lined with
thousands of people, on foot, under um?
brellas, and in carriages, moist and ex?
pectant spectators of the show. Neither
the Senate nor the Supreme Court was in
session, and the dignitaries of both those
bodies came down from their homes with
their wives, children and coachmen.
Half the houses in the capital were emp?
tied of their occupants, who crowded the
walks, on both sides of the avenue till
near night-fall and stayed there despite
the bail and rain. At an early hour the
House of Representatives adjourned and
poured forth its members and clerks to
swell the moving mass of lookers-on.
Among these not the least interesting
were the colored population of Washing?
ton, the shrewdest, best natured, wittiest
and most intelligent negro multitude in
any American city, and who hail from
every part of tbe Union, North and
South. From their rollicking lips came
chiefly the shouts which greeted the roys
terers of the carnival.
The L.ter appeared en masse in sleighs,
cutters, hogsheads, boxes and barrels on
runners and in procession formed a spec?
tacle prodigiously comical. The vehicles
in which they rode would have sufficed
to excite mirth enough, representing as
they did every style of winter equipage
introduced in the United States since the
day of Washington; but tbe masquers,
the costumes and their mishaps caused
the greatest glee, and for hours tbe ave?
nue was in an uproar.
It seemed as though the museums of
all nations had been ransacked for an?
cient garments to encase the volunteers
of this odd festival. The 'jungles of Af?
rica and India; the- forests of both
Americas, and the wilds of the British
possessions north of the United States con?
tributed, along with the toy and costum?
es' shops, to their, make-up. As they
went by behind .horses, both fleet and
slow, they presented forms, of giants,
monkey a, tigers,' opossums, dwarfs,
whales, ostriches, bears and wolves, al?
ternating between sleighfuls of viridly
bedecked mock specimens of emperors,
princesses aud queens. "Is dem/' ex?
claimed a wondering darkey, "de same
crowns. dey 'pears in when dey is on de
thrones?" ' ':
"Of course. Now, I neva knowed it.
Dar was Jim Blossom, my brudder-in
law, de minstrel, man, what perfawmed
before Queen Victory. He said she
didn't wear no crown." A mighty sled,
bearing 100 maequeraders, and drawn by
a dozen mules, hitched tandem, went by
with waving of flags and many voices.
Another side, occupied by men with
blackened faces and attired like women,
in calico dresses, sped fast. A sleigh full
of men in pasteboard masks, with long
noses and scarlet cheeks, followed by a
cutter crammed with boys, imitating in
dress and motions a cluster of orang?
outangs, excited merriment which was
swollen into great peals of laughter as a
vehicle on runners, representing tbe Lou?
isiana Returning: .Board came into view.
The personages composing this board
were none too complimentary to the orig?
inals; indeed; their aspect was as practi?
cal a* can be fancied. Not the group of1
Molly Maguires in a cutter close after J
them,, nor even the silent four members'
of the Eu Klux Klan, who tailed off this1
branch of the procession, matched their j
ferocious looks. The cheers and cachi-j
nations of thousands of spectators roiled
down the ayenue in a roar, as resounding
as the Nor Year's guns from the Navy
Yard.
Nothing in the pageant was more de,
lightful thari*tbe good humor with which
all classes of people beheld all kinds of
satires and burlesques upon the present,
political difficulties. Such satires, how?
ever clumsy, were numerous, but they
provoked naught but hearty.laughter, aud
harm leas witticisms. Tbe very Cabinet'
officers, and other office-holders of both
parties who poked out their heads from
; their carriage windows to view the spec?
tacle, laughed, shook and choked behind
their handkerchiefs.
Ruins or an Ancient Settlement.
?The ruins of the oldest settlement ou
the upper James River were discovered a
few days ago on the upper Fails Planta
lion by a Manchester (Va.) antiquary.
They are supposed to be the remains of
an old ftone. house or fort which was
erected by Col. Thomas Slagg, near the
Three Islands, in the year 1663.
VPuach. in his dictionary gives the
definition of ..the. word "conscience^"
"?Iy rule for another mau'a conduct,"
lJg\3?tFAVfBMlUUW.'-'\\? 111WMWBWI
require' cash' p?rmenu far adrertiidn* ordered br
Executors", Administrators and other 'fiduciaries
and herewith append'the rates for the ordinary
notices, which will only be inserted when the
money comes with the orgerj, ,.
Citations, two insertions^ - ?-- - - $3.00
Estate Notices, three insertions,- ? m 2.06
Final Settlements, flTe Insertions - - 3.00
TO CORRESPONDENTS.?In order to receive
attention, communications raujt be acconip&aled
by the true .name and address of the writer. Re?
jected manuscripts will not be returned, unless the
necessary stamps are furnished to repay the postage
thereon.
49* We are not responsible for the -views and
opinions of our correspondents.
All communications should be addressed to "Ed- <
itors Intelligencer," and all checks, drafts, mosey
orders, Ac, should be made payable to the order
of . hoyt A co.,
Anderson, S. c.
A Detailed Statement of the Florid*
Canvass.
Washington, Jan. 7,1877.
Here is the story of the Florida Can?
vassing Board, frcm the Democratic side.
It is a plain story, easily understood;
and it is thought here that, before the
Republicans claim Florida for Mr.
Hayes, they ought to show this tale to be
false. :
Florida has thirty-nine counties.
When the Returning Board met they be?
gan by an attempt to ascertain bow the
vote stood on the face of the returns.
But they met at once with a difficulty, in
Baker county, from which two returns
came up, one of which gave the State to
Hayes, the other to Tilden. Under the
Florida law the County Canvassers are
required to meet at the office of theCoun
ty Clerk, within six days after the elec?
tion, to canvass the vote and compile the
official returns. The Board of Canvassers
are the County Clerk, the County Judge,
and a justice of the peace or Sheriff. In
the case of Baker county the Judge (a
Republican) refused to meet the clerk,
ana, after waiting for him, the clerk
called in a justice of the peace and pro?
ceeded publicly to canvass the official
precinct returns and sent the result thus
made by two of the three persons desig?
nated by law to the Secretary of State.
This return gave the State to Tilden by
103 majority. The County Judge, who
bad refused to meet the other two at the
same time called in a person who had
been appointed Justice of the Peace after
the election had been held, and these two
canvassed, not the official returns, but
duplicates that covered only two of the
four precincts, and sent their returns to
the Secretary of State, which gave the
8tate to Hayes . iby 42. The Returning
Board decided, as, was, proper, that the
clerkV return was the correct one, and
this was' therefore allowed and counted,
j Next comes Clay county. Here the
county canvassers,-also Republicans, left'
out one precinct, on. the ground .that it.
did not appear that the inspectors took
the oath prescribed by law. But they
made a statement with their' returns,
showing that this precinct gave 24 Dem?
ocratic majority, and the Returning
Board held. that the objection was mot
good, and, therefore, counted the pre?
cinct.
But, having gone so far, the Board be?
gan to throw out votes. In Monroe
county they threw out a Democratic pre*
cinct on the ground that the canvass
there was not completed on the night of
the election, as the law demands. The
inspectors completed the count at one
o'clock, but oue of their number, a Re?
publican, fell ill, and moved to defer the
declaration of the return until the -iest
I morning. There was no pretence of *
fraud.
In Hamilton county the Board fluag
out Jasper precinct, on the ground that
during the election two of the inspectors,
both" Republicans," deserted the polls,
j One of these deserting inspectors?a Re?
publican,, be it remembered?-himself
made the affidavit of the irregularity on
which the Board flung out the vote.
There was no attempt to impeach the
rectitude of the vote.
In Jackson county the Board threw oat
votes on the ground that the ballot boxes
were placed so high that the colored
voters could not see into them. But all
the election officers were Republicans
and the boxes were all alike.
In Mantee county the whole vote was
flung out on the ground that there was no
County Clerk to attend to the registra?
tion and other duties. The circumstan?
ces were these: The Clerk of the county
Was a Republican, appointed by Gov.
Stearns; he resigned shortly before the
election. The inhabitant* appealed to
him to resume his duties, but he refuse'!.
They asked the Governor to appoint an?
other, but the new appointee refused to
qualify. Hence no new registration of
voters could be made, and the law re?
quires that every voter shall previously
and in the same year have been register?
ed. After consultation it was determin?
ed to open the polls and to accept the
votes of all who had registered before the
previous election, each voter appending
an affidavit that be bad so registered.
The commissioners, inspectors and Coun?
ty Judge did their duty. The county is
strongly Democratic and the Democrats
claim that'they lost between 200 and 800
votes by the discouragement of their vo?
ters and the impossibility to register new
voters. However that may be, the Re?
turning Board flung out the whole coun?
ty- ' "
By these operations the State was count?
ed not only for Hayes'but also for Stearns,
the Republican Governor,, candidate for
re-election. But Drew, the Democratic,
candidate for Governor, appealed to the
Supreme Court; and the Court, on the
evidence before it, and which is above
briefly recited and was not disputed, or?
dered. the Returning Board to recanvass
the whole State, mentioning particularly
four counties. The Board complied lite*
rally with the' order of the Court; but
when they came to Baker county they
accepted the returns which . before they
bad rejected as false, and they flung out
the whole of Clay, to which on the first
count they had made no objection and
where no fraud was charged. Thus they
fave the State on the second count to
)rew and the Democratic State officers,
but still maintained it for Hayes.
This is the Democratic side* of the sto?
ry, obtained from a moderate and well
informed source. It must be remember?
ed that in all the counties which were
flung out the election officers were Re?
publicans, and that the wrong or infor?
mality asserted was caused by them; that
the Board first counted in both Stearns
and Hayes, and on a recount were able
to count in Hayes only by arbitrarily
flinging out votes to which, on their first
count and when they could not calculate
so closely, they made no objection. It
is clearly necessary that the republicans
?who possessed all the election'machinery,
shall show that this story of the Florida
election is false. They cannot afford to
have Mr. Hayescounted in by such frauds
as are above recounted.
Sensible Advice.?The following
sensible-advice was given by the"late
Prof. Maury to his son, then at school:
To the truly wise and good man, office,
place, honors, distinctions are desirable
or welcome only as they increase his
sphere of usefulness and enlarge his priv?
ilege of doing good. To win such privi?
leges, I .hope will be th: highest pbiut to?
wards which the ambition of any one of
;my sons will ever he directed. I do not
know where their lot may be -_a.?:. for
they are all to lie the artificers of their
own fortune. But whatever it may be, I
hope they will let politics alone, seek to
be useful member* of the community iu
which they live, and study the welfare of
the commonwealth to winch they belong.
Let this be a rule of conduct with you
now, for little hoys nay make themseh'es
useful as well as great men.
? "This is very bracing weather, sir,"
said a bland landlord to an unhappy
boarder. ; "0lad to hear, it,";.wan..the
reply. "Hope it will brace up your -
breakfast coffee, which has been very pale j i:
Iftdweak of late,"