The Anderson intelligencer. (Anderson Court House, S.C.) 1860-1914, April 13, 1876, Image 2
?AY, /J
JAS. A. HOY'.,
E.B. MURR/" r*MU??
THURSDAY MORNING, APRIL 13, 1876.
COUNTY CONVENTION.
In accordance with the call of the State
Executive Committee of the Democratic
party in South Carolina, it h hereby an?
nounced that there will be a County Con?
vention held at Anderson C. H. on Sat?
urday, l?V? ?r/ April next, for the purpose
of electing six delegates to the State
Democratic Convention which meets in
Columbia on the 4th of May next.
The basis of representation in the
County Convention, as fixed by the Cen?
tral Executive Committee, will be as fol?
lows: Each Democratic Club in Ander?
son County shall be entitled to one dele?
gate for twenty-five members or under,
and an additional delegate for each addi?
tional twenty-five members.
The Clubs are earnestly requested to
renew their diligence in procuring mem?
bers between this time and the meeting
of the County Couvention, so that the
fullest representation may be secured by
each Club. The executive committees
are specially invoked to increase the
membership of their respective Clubs.
Delegates to the County Convention will
come prepared to report the exact num?
ber of persons belonging to their clubs,
so that the aggregate membership may
be ascertained.
JAMES A. HOYT,
County Chairman.
AN OLD TRICK IN A NEW DRESS.
The preamble and resolutions adopted
by the .Republican County Convention
on Saturday last will be found in this
issue. This fresh device to catch unwary
Democrats needs a little puncturing, and
it will not be amiss to send the antidote
along with the poison. For the sake of j
convenience, and-because we have reason
to believe that this precious scheme ema
anates from that source, we will treat the
preamble and resolutions as the produc?
tion of Senator Cochran, whose favorite
plan to "divide and conquer" is herewith
revealed. He sees plainly enough that a
thorongh and enthusiastic organization
of the Democracy portends a speedy over?
throw of his power and influence in our
local elections, and that it is necessary
for him to manage adroitly to stem the
tide which is rapidly hastening his down?
fall in politics. He throws out the bait
with insinuating grace, trusting thereby
to delnde and deceive unsuspecting Dem?
ocrats into false security, or win them over
to an open advocacy of this pet scheme.
But Mr. Cochran might as well understand
now as hereafter that he has deceived
many good citizens of Anderson just |
?nee too often by his flattering demon?
strations for compromise and concilia?
tion. In the last campaign, when there
was a coalition ticket for State officers in
the field, the masses of Democratic
voters were friendly disposed towards
any one who seemed desirous of electing
that ticket, and it was easy enough to set
a trap for wavering and disorganized
voters. Mr. Cochran was successful in
the effort then made by him, because his
true purposes were not exposed to the
public gaze, and a large number of Dem?
ocrats were really earnest in their belief |
that his motives were sincere and his
object the public good. Had the subse?
quent conduct of Mr. Cochran justified
this favorable opinion, his present effort I
would be received quite differently. But |
the moment he failed to meet just expec?
tations, and outraged decency by casting
his vote for a notorious villain like
Whipper. he forfeited the last vestige j
of confidence as to the purity of his in?
tentions and the worthiness of his mo?
tives. Hence, the overture now made
will be received with scorn and derision,
and none will more readily reject his
propositions than the Democrats whose
votes assisted him in the last election.
It was their trust and confidence which
he betrayed on that memorable Black
Thursday, and universal condemnation
has resulted therefrom. ?
The facts of the case are burlesqued in
the boastful declaration that nominations
were put aside in the last campaign, in
order that each member of the Republi?
can party "might be free to cast his vote j
as his feelings and judgment might dic?
tate." Mr. Cochran was working to se?
cure his own election, and he was all
things to all men, so4that his name was j
upon the ticket, but he was just as much
the nominee of the Republicans as if he
had been regularly nominated. Their
ballots were cast for him solidly and j
almost without exception, which was
rendered certain by the distribution of j
printed tickets through the customary
channels. So long as the "feelings and
judgment" of the Republicans were
friendly to his own eleotion, entire free?
dom might be allowed as to the balance
of the ticket for local officers. Here was
his true aim, object and sole desire, and
we have no doubt that he feels a comfor?
table assurance "that such a course re?
sulted in good" to himself, although we
are unable to discover the benefit derived
from his service as a representative of |
the people.
The preamble and resolutions are a
mixture of conceit, arrogance and impu?
dence. The recommendation is made
against nominations, "unless the Demo?
cratic party shall by party machinery,
and free application of the party lash,
put before the people men who, in our
opinion, are objectionable to a majority
of the conservative voters of Anderson
County." As the contingency seems to
depend upon the judgment of Mr. Coch?
ran, and taking as a criterion all past
experience since he has been in politics,
the Democrats may safely conclude that
their nominees will be objectionable. It
would appear reasonable to any one, ex?
cept a tricky, scheming politician like
Mr. Cochran, that the Democrats were
competent to make their own selection,
and pronounce judgment as to the fitness
of their candidates for official position.
But this wily Senator has become so ac?
customed to interjecting his "opinions"
into the Democratic ranks that he con?
cludes he has unlimited freedom in this
respect, and he forgets that his "influ?
ence" is on the decline in Anderson
County. Yet, if the Democrats are not
subservient enough to consult Mr. Coch?
ran in regard to nominations, we are
made to understand that the Republicans
are pledged "to vote for firm, just, expe
rienced and competent men, though they
be Democrats in the fullest sense of the
word*" Now, as we comprehend the
organization of the Democracy, its mem?
bers are pledged to sustain the party
nominations, recognizing the folly of al?
lowing Republicans to control the elec*
tions. Hence, every Democrat in any
true sense of the word would indignantly
reject a proposition from the Republicans
to become their candidate, in order to
produce division and discord among po?
litical friends. It is incontestibly true
that unless professed Democrats consent
to become the candidates of the Repub?
licans next fall, this programme of the
artful Senator cannot be carried out. It
requires two to make a bargain in this
instance, and the members of the Dem?
ocratic party are forewarned by these
resolutions that such bargain will be at?
tempted by the Republicausi But we
would lik'j to know whence the Republi?
cans derive the right to counsel, direct
or supervise the Democracy. Such dic?
tation and supervision from a corrupt
and degraded party amount to insuffera?
ble arrogance and sublime impudence,
and we are quite, mistaken in the charac?
ter and purposes of the Anderson De?
mocracy, unless this impertinence and
presumption are promptly and prop?
erly repelled at the outset of the cam?
paign.
Does any one imagine that the Repub?
licans would manifest solicitude in regard
to Democratic nominations, in case the
situation of parties might be reversed in
this County ? Is it likely that we would
hear so much from Mr. Cochrau and his
friends about the party lash and party
machinery? When and where did the
Republicans in South Carolina give up
any partisan advantage, or elect Demo?
crats to office ? It will be time enough
to consider this scheme, intended to pro?
duce division among Democrats, when
the Republicans in other counties begin
to divide offices, "outside of any- mere
party feeling or party zeal." As a hope- j
less and helpless minority, the Republi?
cans are driven to this extremity in An?
derson County, and every true, genuine
Democrat will see to it that the impossi?
bility of its success is made apparent at
once.
THE DEMOCRATIC STATE CONVEN
HON.
It is only three weeks until tbe Demo?
cratic State Convention will meet in
Columbia for the purpose of electing
delegates to the National Convention,
and to take such further action as the
Convention may deem proper and neces?
sary. Among other things which will
claim the attention of tbe delegates, the
re-organization of the State Executive
Committee will demand wise and con?
siderate action. The ablest, truest and
strongest men to be found in the State
ought to be selected to conduct the ensu?
ing campaign, which will require astute?
ness and executive talent of the highest
order to give shape to the conduct of the
campaign, and bring victory to the Dem?
ocratic standard. In point of fact, the
Democracy has never enjoyed a close,
thorough and compact organization in
South Carolina, and there are many diffi?
culties to encounter in training and dis?
ciplining an army of voters, whose indi?
viduality has been maintained to a large
extent under the partial organization
and ineffectual resistance heretofore
made against the Republican party.
The truth is apparent, however, that the
organization now in progress all over the
State indicates greater thoroughness and
compactness than ever before, and the
measure of success already attained in
this regard will render the work of the
State Executive Committee comparative?
ly light and pleasant We have every
confidence that the State Convention
will act wisely and discreetly iu the selec?
tion of gentlemen to perfect measures
for the ultimate triumph of the Democ?
racy. Upon this choice will largely de?
pend the destines of the State, for ineffi?
ciency, inertness and indifference in the
discharge of the trust which will be com?
mitted to them will surely bring defeat
and disaster.
As to what further action will be
necessary at the State Convention, we
have a decided conviction that the busi?
ness of the delegates is to restrict their
action into the narrowest limits. It is
too early to venture upon shaping a
policy for the party, although we have
the most positive .views in regard to the
proper policy, when the time arrives to
take a position from which we are not to
recede as a party, under any circum?
stances. We do not share in the belief
that aught of harm has been done by free
and uiitrammeled discussion of this sub?
ject, for the unrestrained expression of
opinion from newspapers and public men
will serve to shed light upon our condi?
tion as a State, and enable the masses to
direct understandingly future move?
ments. Among the greatest needs of
this State is the dissemination of politi?
cal information, and the enlistment of
the property-holders in an active and
zealous endeavor to rescue their State
from the clutches of rapacious adventu?
rers, whose efforts to keep political con?
trol have been unintentionally aided by
apathetic conduct on the part of the
more substantial citizens. We need dis?
cussion of every measure and every phase
of policy intended to benefit the State,
and there can be no valid reason for
stifling argument or postponing reflection
upon grave issues which are certain to
demand solution in the near future. In?
deed, so far from the discussion as to
straightout nominations or a fusion with
any portion of tbe Republicans being
premature, we are convinced that more
time is necessary for the proper elucida?
tion of these plans, and hence we favor
the State Convention pretermitting any
definite action until a later day, by which
the people will be allowed ample time in
every portion of the State to express
their matured judgment upon the issues
of tbe approaching campaign.
It is unnecessary to reiterate our pur?
pose to sustain whatever policy may be
determined upon in this campaign,
whether it is deemed wise to enter again
upon the fusion plan or to make a strict
party fight. Our preferences are well
known, and have not been hid under a
bushel. We are firmly of the opinion
that tbe time for compromise and coali?
tion has passed, and that the citizens of
South Carolina arc not to expect sound,
economical and safe government at the
hands of the Republicans, who have dis
graced the commonwealth and degraded
the name of American citizen before the
civilized world. All previous efforts to
bring good out of evil have fligually
failed. Retrenchment and reform are
mere by-Words, when left to the corrupt
majority controlling the Republican
party; the power of taxation is looked
upon as a species of party machinery, by
which an ignorant rabble is to be main?
tained in official position, and moved as
puppets in the hands of unscrupulous,
designing and ambitious leaders; the
judiciary, which ought to be the last bul?
wark of freemen, is dragged down to the
lowest depths of infamy and degradation
by the elevation of thieves and villains
to the bench. In short, there is no
device of avarice} corruption and men?
dacity Which has not been employed to
maintain party ascendancy, and fealty to
party obligations is made supreme over
every other consideration, from the high?
est to the lowest of its leaders. Under
these circumstances, we can no longer
hug the phantom of coalition, nor be se?
duced into devious paths of expediency,
if we would bring peace, prosperity and
advancement into our borders. The
incubus of bad government depresses
every material and social interest, and
only by united, determined and self
sacrificing effort can the State be wrested
from the unholy grasp of foul cormorants,
whose wits are exercised at all times to
secure greedy gain, and whose polluting
touch mu3t be avoided as the deadliest
venom.
EDITORIAL NOTES.
A. T. Stewart, the New York dry goods
merchant, is dead. He leaves a large
estate, and no heirs except distant rela?
tives in Scotland. It is supposed that he
has left large amounts to various associa?
tions in and around New York.
The Rock Hill Grange says: "Some
ugly rumors are afloat to the effect that
Chamberlain and Mackey were paid $50,
000 worth of State bonds by Parker for
his release. The statement in so far as
Chamberlain is concerned is highly im
probable. Chamberlain had been too
intimately associated with Parker, proba?
bly too deeply implicated; to desire, or
indeed be able to imprison his former
partner, and instead of receiving any?
thing for his release, it is more probable
that he paid for the writ of habeas corpus
himself, but not to the extent rumor
gives, unless perchance they were the re?
mains of some fraudulent bonds issued
by the financial board. The late attempt
to investigate Mackey proved that the
judge more than possessed the confidence
of the Governor. There is a great deal
of duplicity lying concealed behind the
placid face of the champion reformer."
That eminent soldier and lusty patriot,
Maj. Lewis Merrill, who found it so
profitable to arrest persons in South Car?
olina on the charge that they were Ku
Klus, and while receiving his pay as an
array officer drew the sum of $21,000
from the State Treasury for his services
in procuring witnesses for the Ku Klux
prosecutions, has been examined recently
by the Military Committee of the House
of Representatives. When he was sum?
moned to appear before tbe committee,
he was so very innocent that he asked
the chairman why he had been required
to appear, saying: "If it is to get my
views on any intricate subject, I wish you
would tell me now, so I can study and
enlighten your committee." Gen. Ban?
ning blandly informed him that he would
be heard at length on the situation of
affaire in South Carolina during the Ku
Klux raids, whereupon Merrill turned
his back and slunk away. Besides his
acceptance of the money from South
Carolina, while acting as an officer of the
United States army, and lobbying for
weeks to secure that gift from the Legis?
lature, the illegal and arbitrary acts of
Maj. Merrill in Louisiana at a later
period ought to have caused him to be
court martialed long ago. Gen. Custer
has also charged Merrill with taking a
bribe at a court martial in Texas. His
partisan services in South Carolina and
Louisiana greatly endeared him to the
administration, and he was recently ap?
pointed as one of the representatives of
the government at the Philadelphia Ex?
position, though by respectable army
officers he has long been deemed a dis?
grace to the service. It is hoped that
the examination of the Military Commit?
tee will bring his career to a sudden and
{inglorious conclusion.
JOTTINGS BY THE WAY.
NUMBER 4.
' Mauldin's Mountain lies two miles to
the west of Easley Station, on the Air
Line Railroad. This is a commanding
eminence, rising gradually from sur?
rounding hills and valleys to the height
of several hundred feet above the land
around the base. This elevated spot was
occupied as an observatory during last
summer by an exploring party from some
distant region, taking observations of the
surrounding country. The mountain is
perhaps a mile in circumference, and for
some distance above the base has a pro?
lific soil, and is in cultivation. The
mountain has been for twenty years or
more the property of the Mauldin family.
A portion of the cleared land has been
cultivated in cotton for successive years,
and, strange to say, on this mountain
side, by the aid of fertilizers, an average
of nearly or quite a bale to the acre has
been realized, and that, too, on the north
side of the mountain. The soil is well
adapted to the cultivation of cotton, but
rather light and porous, and thus inclined
to wash.
Boggs' Mountain, a twin neighbor, lies
a little farther to the west on the Air
Line. Its altitude and circumference is
about equal to that of Mauldin's Moun?
tain, and, like its neighbor, is partially
in cultivation, and produces remunera?
tive crops. *
Along this region of country the ches
nut is an extensive growth. Mr. Wm.
Mauldin, merchant at Easley Station,
has recently fenced a large field mainly
with chesnut rails. This kind of timber
is preferred even to the oak for rails on
account of its lightness and durability.
Mrs. Win. Mauldin, a most excellent
lady, devotes a great deal of time to the
cultivation of flowers, and is succeeding
finely. She has a small pit, facing the
south, and with glazed windows is ena?
bled to preserve her flowers in spring?
like verdure of bloom. The Calla, or
Lily of the Nile, is a remarkable plant,
with a stem reaching some two or three
feet high) with broad and heavy leaves
falling gracefully on either side of the
stem, and crowned with a large white
flower at top. Some persons suppose
that this plant afforded the covering or
hiding place for the infant Moses, when
secreted by a tender mother from the
cruel edict of a tyrant king.
R. H. T.
REPUBLICAN RESOLUTIONS.
Rooms Republican Party, )
Anderson, 6. 0., April 8, 1876. j
Messrs. Editors i In accordance with
a resolution passed, I respectfully ask
that you publish the following preamble
and resolutions.
Respectfully, &c,
JOHN R. COCHRAN.
Whereas, iu the last general election
in this State the Republican party of
Anderson County deemed it wise "and
prudent, in order to promote harmony
and good feeling and to secure the fullest
exercise of the right of suffrage, to make
no nominations for any office, in order
that each voter of our party might be
free to cast his vote as his feeliugs and
judgment might dictate, unbiased and
untrammelled by party ties; and
whereas we feel assured that such a
course resulted in good, and furnished
an example on the part of the Republi?
can party of an earnest desire to promote
pence and harmony and to secure honest
and competent officers; therefore, be it
Resolved by this Convention, That in
the elections of 1876 we recommend that
no nominations be made on our part for
members of the Legislature or County
officers, unless the Democratic party
shall, by party machinery and a free
application of the party lash, place be?
fore the people men who, in our opinion,
are objectionable to a majority of the
conservative voters of Anderson County,
in which event we pledge ourselves to vote
for men firm, just, experienced and com?
petent, though they be Democrats in the
fullest sense of the word?men who are
known by their intelligence and honor to
be fully qualified to fill the different offi?
ces, outside of any mere party feeling or
party zeal.
Resolved, That we will not vote in the
coming election for any one who has not
the moral courage to go before the peo?
ple, and rely on his own merits and qual?
ifications for support, and not upon party
rings, cliques, men, clubs or leagues.
Resolved, That the Anderson Intelligen?
cer, Anderson Journal and Columbia
Daily Union-Herald be requested to pub?
lish these proceedings.
JOHN R. COCHRAN, Chm'n.
SOUTH CAROLINA POLITICS-CHAM
BERLAIN TO GRANT.
the governor asks the moral sup?
port of the president in his war
on moses and whipper?strong ap?
peal for the integrity and self
respect of the party?its frigid
reception.
The Washington correspondent of the
New York Herald says that the following
letter was addressed to President Grant
some time ago by Governor Chamberlain,
of South Carolina, and that South Caro?
lina Republicans complain that it has
received neither reply nor attention from
the President, while the organs of Grant
continue to abuse Got. Chamberlain and
misrepresent his political aims. A copy
of the letter is given for publication now,
but it is not stated who furnished the
copy. The Governor's organ, the Union
Herald, states that no copy was retained
by its author, and it is reasonable to con?
clude that some one connected with the
White House has been instrumental in
letting this document see the light. The
letter uses some strong language, and is
as follows:
To His Excellency Vie F) csident:
Sir : I am induced by recent extraor?
dinary circumstances occurring in this
State to address you by this communica?
tion, as the head, in a certain sense, of
the Republican party. The General As?
sembly of this State on the 16th inst.
elected W. J. Whipper and F. J. Moses,
jr., as judges of the Circuit Court of this
State, the former for the circuit em?
bracing the city of Charleston and con?
stituting by far the most important cir?
cuit of the State in point of population,
wealth and business. The character of
F. J. Moses, jr., is known to you and to
the world. Unless the entirely universal
opinion of all who are familiar with his
career is mistaken he is as infamous a
character as ever in any age disgraced
and prostituted public position. The
character of W. J. Whipper, according
to my belief and the belief of all good
men in this State, so far as I am in-,
formed, differs from that of Moses only
in extent to which opportunity has
allowed him to exhibit it. The election
of these two men to judicial offices sends
a thrill of horror through the State.
It compels men of all parties who respect
decency, virtue or civilization to utter
their loudest protests against the outrage
of their election. They have not even
the poor qualification of such a degree of
legal learning as to qualify them for the
intelligent discharge of any judicial duty.
The least of all the evils inflicted on . the
people of this State by their election is
the fact that it compels all Republicans
who love or honor the principles of their
party to refuse to countenance or tolerate
such representatives.
I am a Republican, of just as many
years' standing as I have seen years of
discretion. I have been a strict party
man, adhering to my party here in South
Carolina through good report and evil
report, never for once quitting its ranks
amid the greatest discouragements aris?
ing from the bad conduct and suicidal
policy of many of its most prominent
members; but the time has now come
when no self-respecting Republican can
tolerate the ascendancy of such men as,
in this instance, have been forced upon
us. For you or me, as Republicans, to
countenance the election of Moses and
Whipper is as impossible as it would be
lor Governor Tilden, as a Democrat, to
countenance the election of Wm. M.
Tweed and George G. Barnard to judi?
cial positions in New York. I cannot
and will not do it, be the consequences
what they may politically: And yet I
know there are men who will charge me
in this crisis as they have charged me
hitherto with treachery to the Republi?
can party, because I cannot keen silent
and still support a party loaded down
with such men. The newspaper in
Washington which has sometimes been
called your organ, doubtless erroneously,
will quite likely denounce me with re?
newed vigor for what simple self-respect
will compel me to do iu view of this out?
rage. I tell you, Mr. Presideut, no act
of mine, if I were the greatest living
traitor to my party, could be so fatal to
that party as the election of Whipper
and Moses has been and will be. I want
above all things to save South Carolina
for the Republican party in the coming
Presidential struggle, but I cannot save
it, nobody can save it, if the party here
or the party at Washington, or in the
North, do less than denounce this thing
unsparingly, and join their efforts to those
of the honest Republicans here in an
effort to overthrow the power of such
men as Whipper and Moses and their
aiders and abettors.
Our only salvation is in cutting loose
from all contamination with these men,
and requiring all who arc amenable to
our influence to do the same. To try to
save the seven electoral votes of South
Carolina at the price of silence under this
infliction will co.st us, in my judgment,
many times that number of votes else?
where. We want your moral and politi?
cal support in this struggle with politi?
cal iniquity in its worst form. It is as
suicidal to give countenance to Whippcr
and Moses acre as it would be to give
countenance to the whisky thieves in St.
Louis. The party fealty of such men is
disastrous to the party. I have written
earnestly. I can not do otherwise. Let
no man convince you that I am anything
but a Republican, until common decency
compels me to be something else. Give
us your countenance as you have give*
it, as I believe, in the past, and if we
cannot save South Carolina to the party,
we can prevent our party here from be?
coming a thousand-fold greater burden
to the National Republican party than it
has ever been before. We propose to
declare war on this Whipper-Moses gang.
We propose to ask the National Repub?
lican party to sustain us, and we know
that you and all true Republicans will
bid us God speed when you know the
depths of degradation into which these
men are plunging us. This letter is, of
course, addressed only to you, but you
can make any use of it you see fit, and I
remain your sincere friend and fellow
Republican,
D. H. Chamberlain.
Governor of South Carolina.
THE GREENVILLE LIBEL SUIT.
A Condensed Statement of the Case.
The suit of Wm. E. Earle against the
proprietors of the Greenville Enterprise
and Mountaineer for ten thousand dollars
damages for libel, rests upon the follow?
ing facts:
On the 18th of July, 1875, the Enter?
prise and Mountaineer, which was edited
by Col. S. S. Crittenden, published the
proceedings of the Council Chamber of
the Grangers of Greenville County. The
Republican, edited by Capt. Earle and
J. M. Runion, the following week con?
tained an article ridiculing the Grange
and some of its members, and concluded
by asserting that its objects were not ag?
ricultural, but charging by clear implica?
tion that it was a political body. Then
the Enterprise and Mountaineer published
the following article:
"Contemptible?The Republican af?
fects to speak contemptuously of the
Patrons of Husbandry of Greenville
County."
Then followed two articles in the Re?
publican, headed "Contemptible" and
"Contemptuously," which reflected upon
Col. Crittenden personally, and, among
other things, spoke cf civil judgments
which existed against him. Col. Critten?
den met J. M. Runion, one of the editors
of the Republican, and asked if he was
the author of the offensive articles in the
Republican, and receiving an evasive
reply, caned him upon the streets of
Greenville. Runion, therefore, let it be
known that Capt. Earle was the author
of tbe articles, and a correspondence fol?
lowed between Col. Crittenden and Capt.
Earle, in which the former denounced
the latter as a braggart and coward. The
Republican then contained a card from
Capt. Earle, agaiu reflecting upon Col.
Crittenden, whereupon he published the
following in the Enterprise and Mountain?
eer, of which he was editor and the Bai?
ley's proprietors:
"Judgments.?Sometimes judgments
are rendered in civil courts against a man
who retains the respect of his fellow-men.
But there are judgments when rendered
against a man by the community in which
he lives, and who have marked his course
from boyhood up?judgments against him
for want of honor and principle, and the
lack of every instinct of a gentleman,
which leave him naked and forlorn in?
deed?a moral bankrupt. Such judg?
ments have long been entered against
W. E. Earle."
Other articles followed in each of these
papers, in which these editors abused each
other, and at last Capt. Earle published
a card in which he informed the public
that the libels published in the Enterprise
and Mountaineer should be investigated
by a criminal and civil action in the
Courts. The article published above is
the one upon which a civil action for
$10,000 damages for libel was instituted
against the proprietors of the Enterprise
and Mountaineer. In answer to. the com?
plaint, the defendants alleged the facts
which induced the publication of the
libel as we have given them, and further
plead that the article complained of was
true, and cited the following facts, which
they promised to prove:
1. That Wm. E. Earle, at the close of
the war, went in the night time to the
house of a man named John Dill, in
Greenville County, representing himself
as a Federal officer, under an assumed
name, and ordered him to bring out a
fine horse, wbich he took and carried
away, without giving any compensation;
that for this highway robberry a "true
bill" was found against him, and the
friends of the plaintiff induced the pros?
ecutor to consent to a nolle prosegui, by
leading him to believe a tract of land
would be given him, which he claimed
the plaintiff* had wrongfully deprived
him of.
2. That on the same night, under his
assumed name, he went to the house of
an old Union man named Crane, who was
a worthy citizen, and made a negro man
whip him most cruelly; that Capt Earle
was indicted, and that as Crane, who
never recovered from his injuries, was
unable to be present, Mrs. Crane was the
only witness to prove the battery, and
under a ruling of the presiding Judge
her testimony was excluded, and the
plaintiff went upon the stand and swore
that young men did the whipping, and
that he made them stop, while, in fact, it
was done at the command of the plaintiff.
3. That the plaintiff, as an attorney,
ssucd a complaint against A. T. Reese,
who answered it within the twenty days,
but the plaintiff" at the expiration of the
twenty days, went before the Clerk and
falsely swore that no answer had ever
been served upon him. Under this, exe?
cution was issued and the land advertised
for sale.
4. While a magistrate, the plaintiff
compounded a felony committed in An?
derson County by his brother, John H.
Earle, in stealing $26 in money from J.
S. King and a pair of saddle-bags and
clothing from J. W. Sitton, for which he
was about to be prosecuted, by paying
$25 to the father of J. W. Sitton, who
was a minor, and giving his note to J. S.
King for $100, which he afterwards paid.
5. That the plaintiff, as attorney for
Edwin Bates & Co., of Charleston, who
held a mortgage on a tract of laud be?
longing to Edward Powell for $314,
bought the tract of land when sold by the
Sheriff under a junior execution for $30,
subject to said mortgage. He did uot in?
form Iiis clients that he had purchased
the land, and was liable for the whole of
their debt, but falselv and fraudulently
wrote them that he had with difficulty
effected a compromise with J. W. Powell
(son of Edward Powell) at $250, and ad?
vised them to accept said offer, which
they did, although the said Powell did
not make nor know anything of said
offer. He then sent them a check for
$250, less his commissions, and sold the
land to John Timmons for $600, defraud?
ing his clients out of $64, in violation of
his oath as an attorney.
Upon the side of the Plaintiff, Messrs.
Simpson & Moore, J. H. Whitncr, S.
McGowan and J. L. Cothran were the
attorneys, while Messrs. Whitncr Symmes,
M. C. Butler, W. H. Perry and M. L.
Bonham appeared for the defense. The
defendants put up Ex-Gov. Perry and
about thirty-five witnesses, among whom
were Col. N. H. Davis, Rev. J. C. Fur
man, Hon. R. E. Bowen, Hamlin Beattie,
Esq., and other prominent citizens of
Greenville, who testified that the charac?
ter of Capt. Earle was bad in the com
munity in which they live. In a number
of instances the cross-examination elici?
ted th"c fact that the plaintiff had brought
suits against the party testifying, but they
gave their testimony'as founded on the
reputation of the plaintiff in the commu?
nity. The defense then offered the testi?
mony of Messrs. S. J. King and J; W.
Sitton which substantiated the fourth
charge in the answer; of John Dill,
Milton Dill and William Wooten, who
substantiated the first charge in the an?
swer ; of Mrs. Sarah Crane, who substan?
tiated the second charge of the answer ;
of J. Mims Sullivan, W. A. McDaniel,
J. L. Southern, John Timmons and J.
Powell, who substantiated the fifth charge
of the answer; and of J. Powell and J.
L. Southern to substantiate the third
charge. They also offered the testimony
j of C. A. Cars in regard to the first and
second cbarges1
Judge Cooke refused to admit the arti?
cles published in the Republican by Capt.
Earlc against Col. Crittenden, the editor
of the Enterprise and Mountaineer, in this
case, on the ground that they were not
against the Baileys, and could not justify
them.
The plaintiff offered in reply the testi?
mony of Messrs. Blythc, Humphreys,
Reed and Waiden, who exculpated Cant.
Earlc from being the principal in the
raid charged in the first and second
charges of the answer.
There was a large amount of testimo?
ny for the plaintiff, going to establish his
general good character. Among these
witnesses were Dr. Broaddus and Messrs.
Hudson, Shumate, Wellford, Mauldin and
others. Messrs. Wells and Scoficld testi?
fied in reference to the third charge
against the plaintiff, and were of opinion
that his affidavit was made through a
mistake. There was also testimony that
Earle had paid as much for the land in
Edwin Bates & Co's. case as it was worth.
At the close of the testimony, argu?
ments were made by the distinguished
counsel on both sides of the case, and
the Jury, after receiving instructions
from the Court, retired to their room.
A fter considering the matter for several
hours, they agreed upon a verdict of $50
for the plaintiff; and thus the greatest
libel suit ever entered against au up
country paper ended. It can hardly be
denied that the plaintiff is greatly wors?
ted by bringing this action,, for it has
given very general and wide publicity to
the charges which are made against Him,
without securing a verdict large enough
to convince the public that there is noth?
ing contained in some one or more of
them. The expenses of the litigation
must have been heavy on both sides, and
therefore it appears to us that each party
comes out of the fray somewhat scathed.
The case was one which afforded a rare
opportunity for legal display, and was
utilized to the fullest extent by the able
advocates who were contending for the
respective parties. Its result should teach
publishers to be careful as to their attacks
upon the private character of individu?
als, and especially to teach men who are
assailed by the press that they should be
cautious in instituting suits for damages,
for it is an old adage that the courts are
poor places for men to submit their char?
acters for arbitrament.
HOW MACKEY WAS SAVED.
The Report of the Lancaster Commit?
tee to the Citizens of the County.
Messrs. J. B. Erwin, N. G. B. Chafee,
T. F. Clyburn, and J. M. Caskey, the
committee of citizens of Lancaster Coun?
ty appointed by a mass meeting of
citizens to present to the Legislature
charges of illegal and tyrannical conduct
against Judge Mackey, make the follow?
ing report to the people of the county:
We, the undersigned, deem it our duty
to make report of our actings and doings
as a committee appointed by a public
meeting of the citizens of Lancaster
County to proceed to Columbia and lay
before the Governor and the Federal As?
sembly of the State of South Carolina
very grave charges against the Hon. T.
J.Mackey, judge of the Sixth Circuit,
for illegal and tyrannical acts, such as in
our opinion disqualify him for hold?
ing longer the commission of circuit
judge. This duty on our part becomes
more especially necessary from the fact
that iu the exercise of a sound discretion
we felt compelled not to carry into exe?
cution part of the instruction given us,
to wit: That we declined for very suffi?
cient reasons (in our opinion) to call
upon the Governor.
A VERY SHORT STATEMENT
of the manner of conducting our mission,
and its results we think will satisfy our
constituents that we have carried out
their wishes as far as possible to do, in
view of the influences with which we
were confronted in Columbia. Upon ar?
riving in that city we at once put our?
selves in communication with the Speak?
er of the House of Representatives, who
informed us that representing as we did
the people of the county, the proper
method of bringing the grievances com?
plained of before that body was by a pe?
tition setting the same forth and asking
for an investigation of the charges which
might be preferred against the Hon. T.
J. Mackey for his various acts of the of?
ficial misconduct. Acting upon such in?
timidation, we filed with the Speaker a
respectful petition, which has been pub?
lished in all the public prints. It seems
that before our arrival certain
OTHER CHARGES
of a grave nature had been preferred by
other parties from another county in the
circuit, and that a resolution to investi?
gate those charges had been defeated.
With those charges we had no connec?
tion, and about them we knew absolute?
ly nothing, so we acted independently as
your representatives. The vote in the
House of Representatives on a resolution
of investigation based upon our petition
was reached on Friday, the 17th of March,
and the very surprising result of defeat?
ing the resolution was attained by nine
majority. A motion was made to recon?
sider the vote on this resolution, was sub?
sequently also lost.
THE GREAT SERIOUS OBSTRUCTIONS
by which we confronted in our efforts to
carry out your instructions were princi?
pally and signally the whole official and
personal influence of the Governor of
the State exercised against us, and a de?
fection of a portion of the Conservative
members of the House. Governor
Chamberlain we found, in advance of
our arrival had committed himself as the
partisan of Judge Mackey, and in a pur?
ported interview between himself and a
reporter of the Union-Herald newspaper
had thrown himself into the breach to
prevent any investigation of the charges
previously preferred. And upon our.
presenting onr petition to the House, and
while the debate was going on, we found
that he was using every engine of official
power, by bringing members, both Re?
publican and Conservative, to his execu?
tive office, and importuning and other?
wise inducing them to defeat so reasona?
ble a request as that preferred by as, to
investigate the official conduct of a judi?
cial officer.
For these reasons we thought it would
be entirely derogatory to the dignity of
our constituents and our own, that we
should approach Governor Chamberlain
at all, ami were convinced that an inter?
view with one so committed could be pro?
ductive of no good results. Of the ac?
tion of that portion of
THE CONSERVATIVE MEMBERS
who thought proper to oppose our en?
deavors, and who defeated our reasonable
request, we have to speak with feelings
which are actually painful. No good
reason could be assigned by any of them
why they should not vote for the resolu?
tion, and we were entirely at a loss to
know what influences were brought to
bear upon them during the pendency of
this matter. After mature deliberation
we have, from facts which came within
our knowledge, come to the conclusion
that their conduct on this occasion was
ocured by the hold which the Govern?
or of the State has on their minds aiid
actionsi They have been so closely al?
lied with him in attempting to confine
legislation within reasonable bounds, and
of defeating corrupt measures in the
General Assembly, that some of these
gentlemen seem to have
lost their identity
and to have forgotten that Governor
Chamberlain is the acknowledged head
of a party which since its existence and
now is "inimcal to every interest of the
State of South Carolina; and that in
following'him in certain good measures
which he has attempted to carry out,
they have been by his influence blindly
led to do great injustice to the citizens of
Lancaster County.
We take great pleasure in recommend?
ing to you the conduct on this occasion (?I
Messrs. Ferguson, of Greenville, R. M.
Smith and Woodruff, of Spartanbur/,
Coit and Redfearn, of Chesterfield, and
others, about fourteen in number, Con?
servatives, who treated us with great
consideration and did all in their power
to further your wishes; and also those
Republicans who boldly stood up for the
rights of the oppressed citizens of Lan?
caster County, and bid defiance to the
party lash used on the occasion by Gov?
ernor D. H. Chamberlain.
? A petition twenty yards in length
and signed by over two thousand one
hundred citizens has been sent to the
Centennial Commissioners asking them
not to grant permission to sell intoxica?
ting drinks on the grounds.
MARKETS.
Anderson, April 13, 1876.
Cotton market dull. Sales light. Mid?
dlings, Hi cents.
Charleston, April 10,187G.
Cotton market easier. Middling 12 11-16
@12j.
New York, April 10.
Cotton quiet. Middling 13 5-10(0)13?.
OBITUARY.
Departed this life, in Anderson County,
S. C, March lGth, 1876, Mrs. ELIZABETH
HALL, wife of Martin Hall, deceased.
Mrs. Hall was born in Union county, 8. C,
Marth 5th, 1800, and was married to Martin
Hall, of Anderson County, in the year 1825,
into which county she immediately removed
and lived until the day of her death.
Mrs. Hall was a wife indeed. As such,
she may have been equalled but not sur?
passed: She always prided herself in the
happiness of her husband; always found
her happiness in his, his joys were hers,
though they came to him often through tbe
sacrihees which she willingly made. She
lived nearly fifty years in true and devoted
love and sympathy with her husband.
And although she never was a mother in
reality, yet she filled the capacity of a
mother, (and Mr. Hall that of a father,) for
a number of years to the commendation of |
all; giving that advice, that training, and
religious instruction to the orphans, that
were in the providence of God placed in her
hands for maternal care, as would necessari?
ly lead the mind to that Redeemer whom
she in early life had embraced, loved and
served. Truly, she was a faithful and an
affectionate mother to the motherless. As
a church member, she can very appropriate?
ly be numbered among the first class of
Baptist women. She was always found in
her seat at the Cross Roads Baptist Church
only when prevented by Providence. She
loved and delighted in the Kingdom of her
Lord, "the house of His abode." What a
great blessing it might be to all Baptist
churches and their pastors if the whole Bap?
tist sisterhood would be as faithful to their
respective churches and pastors as she was.
But she is gone, no more to help the church,
no more to assist the pastor. She has doubt?
less gone to receive her great reward, for she
was eminently a Christian woman, ready
and willing to"engage in every good work.
HER FORMER PASTOR.
ANNOUNCEMENTS.
?ST The friends of JAMES H. McCON
NELL respectfully announce him as a can?
didate for Sheriff of Anderson County at
the next election.
The many friends of Wi T. CrRTJBBS
announce him as a suitable person for the
office of Sheriff at the next ensuing elec?
tion. Help our one-arm Confederate soldier.
SPECIAL NOTICES.
The Scriptures say Naaman would not
believe when told that to be cured of lep?
rosy, he had only to bathe in the river
Jordan. His unbelief brought days of
suffering upon him, as it does upon those
who delay taking Merrell's Hepatixe
for the Liver. When the. skin and eyes
become yellow in the spring season, with
pains in the head and bones of the body,
and a heavy feeling about the stomach
after meals; there is but one chance to
escape. Sickness of some sort is sure to
come, unless the bile and bad blood is
carried out of the system. Go to your
druggist, Messrs. Simpson & Sadler, and
get a bottle of Merrell's Hepatine,
that cures all diseases of the liver.
Doctors arc guessers. If they guess
right you are all right?provided you pay
the bill. If they guess wroug, you go to
the graveyard?they go to their dinner.
Merrell's Hepatixe has cured more
cases of liver disease, indigestion, consti?
pation and dyspepsia, than all the doctors
and pills in the world combined. Ask
your druggist, Messrs. Simpson & Sadler,
about this medicine?Hepatine. Each
bottle contains fifty doses, and will cure
any case of liver complaint in the world.
Globe Flower Cough Syrup cures
cough, colds, and will positively cure
consumption. For sale by Messrs. Simp?
son & Sadler._
Don't Beg the Question.
It is an infallible sign that a cause is weak
when its claims are sought to be established
by mere bold assertion without argument or
substantial proof. Dr. Tutt asserts that his
Hair Dye is the best, and he adduces un?
doubted evidence to substantiate the truth
uf the assertion.
READ WHAT EXPERTS SAY
New Orleans, May 10, 1871.
Dr. . Tctt :?Dear Sir: We, the under?
signed, wish to inform you that we have
tried your Hair Dye, and find it to be the
best we have ever used. For its natural
black color, it far excels all other dyes. Our
customers will have no other. Since we be?
gan its use, our business in the dyeing de?
partment has rapidly increased. We think
it a great triumph.
ANTHONY HAAS, 1 Rfl ._
CHARLES HOHN, \ Barbc?. .
No. 6 N. Royal Street.
Remember This.
Now is the time of the year for Pneumo?
nia. Lung Fever, Coughs, Colds, and fatal
results of predisposition to Consumption
and other Throat and Lung JJiscase. Bos
chee's German Syrup has been used in this
neighborhood for the past two or three years
without a single failure to cure. If you
have not used this medicine vourself, po* to
vour Druggist, Wilhite & Williams, and ask
him of its wonderful success among his cus?
tomers. Two doses will relieve the worst
ease. If you have no faith in any medicine,
just buy a Sample Bottle of Boschce's Ger?
man Syrup for 10 cents and try it. Regular
size Bottle 75 cents. Don't neglect a cough
to save 75 cents.
Good Taste.
In nothing do men and women show
their possession of this quality, or the want
of it, so much as in the appearance of their
homes. People of good taste and judgment
in North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia
Florida and Alabama, patronize Mr P p'
Toale, of Charleston, S. C, who supplies
Hiebest doors, sashes, blinds, newels cor?
nices, Ac., and the best paint to make them
beautiful. Also, plain and ornamental class
of the best I rench and American manufac?
ture.
ATTENTION!
A FRENCH SHOE-MAKER from Paris,
who has had Twenty-five Years' experience
has opened a Shop at Pendlcton, S. C, and
invites the patronage of the people
All work guaranteed.
April 13, 187G 30 4?
Carolina Collegiate Institute.
THE THIRD TERM of this Institution
will beKin MONDAY, APRIL 17th.
Board, exclusive of washing and lights, if
paid promptly in advance, $10 per month ;
otherwise, $12.50.
W. J. LIGON, President.
April 13, 187G_39_2
Threshermen's Outfit.
IAM-agent for the celebrated CARD
WELL THRESHER, the FARMER
ENGINE, and DOORS, SASH and BLINDS
that I will sell at factory prices. Threshers.
3=200 and $250. Five-horse Engines. $615.00..
C. E. HORTON,
Williamston, S. C.
April 13. 1870_39_3__
NOTICE.
ALL persons are forewarned against liar
boring my grandson, George Bowman,,
who has left my employ, and is now in An?
derson County. He is light complected,,
stout built, and about twelve years of age..
Persons employing him will take warning
that the law will be enforced against them,
as lie has unlawfully left me.
GEORGE BOWMAN,
Oak Bower, Hart Co., Ga.
April 13, 1876_39_8?
SHERIFF'S SALE.
BY JAS. H. McCONNELL, Auctioneer.
BY virtue of various Executions to me
directed, I will expose to sale on the
First Monday in May next, at Anderson C.
H.. the following property, to wit:
Two set of Double Harness, four set of
Single Harness, three Blind Bridles, three
Saddles. Levied on as the property of M.
Heldman, at the suit of B. F. Crayton &
Sons vs. M. Heldman, and J. R. Fant vs.
M. Heldman. Terms cash.
WM. McGUKIN, Sheriff.
April 12,1876_39_2
IN BANKRUPTCY.
In the District Court of the United States
for the District of South Carolina.
In Re.
Arthur P. Hubbard,
Bankrupt.
"VyOTICE is hereby given that a meeting;
aM of the creditors of said Bankrupt will
be held before the undersigned, Register, at
Newberry, on the 27th April, 18 < 6, at 4
o'clock p. m., to consider a composition of
his debts, to be proposed by said Bankrupt.
C. G. J.EGER, Register,
Newberry, S. C
April 13, 1876_39_2_
james h. morgan. thomas w. davis. -
m. a. morgan.
JAMES I MORGAN & CO.,
DEALERS IN
STAPLE & FANCY
IDIR/IT OOOIDS,
Groceries, &c,
GREENVILLE, - S. C.
CHEAP_STORE!
SPRING, SUMMER GOODS
1876 AT 1876
Greatly Reduced Prices.
WE;f
E arc now receiving the largest stock.
DRY GOODS,
BOOTS and
V SHOES,
Ever brought to this market. We, have our
Boots and Shoes manufactured to order, and
thereby save the profit of the middle man
for the consume?. We have also in connec?
tion with our business, a large
Grocery and Provision Department
Well supplied, and suited to the wants of
the farmer.
Polite and attentive salesmen, who wiU
with pleasure spare no pains in showing the
stock.
Wagon Yard for campus free of charge.
Call and examine, and be convinced.
JAMES H. MORGAN & CO.,
Corner Buncombe and Coffee Streets,
Greenville, S. C.
Agents for the Bivingsville Yarns.
Shirtings and Sheetings.
April 13,1876_39_2m
THE GRANGERS'
?
LIFE AND HEALTH
INSURANCE COMPANY
of the
United States of America.
Authorized Capital, - $4,500,000,
Of which $100.000 is to be owned in
each Department.
PARINT OFFICE, MOBILE, ALA.
P. E. DAVIDSON, President.
M. G. HUDSON, Vice President.
R. W. FORT. Secretary.
South Carolina Department, Colum?
bia. S. C.
Capital Stock, - - ?100,000.
Tiros. B. Jeter, President.
Tuo?. A. McCreery, Vice President.
H. P. Green, Secretary.
McMaster & LeConte,
Attorncvp, Columbia, S. C.
J. H. Evtks, *
Attorney, gpartonburg, S. C.
Dr. B. W. Taylor,
Medical Director.
Security I Economy I Liberality II
Are the leading principles of this Compa?
ny. All approved forms of Life and En?
dowment Policies issued. Also, Term Poli?
cies of one, three, five or seven years.
All Life Policies non-forfeiting after an?
nual payments, when the insured will be
entitled to a Paid-up Policy, or cash surren?
der thereof.
Dividends may be used to protect Policies
against lapsing in case of failure to pay pre?
miums. This, with the non-forfjuting and
cash surrender features, are sufficient to
make this Company popular among think?
ing men.
Good Agents wanted.
B.F. MAULDIN, Jr., Agent,
Anderson, S. C.
April 13, 1876 39
MILLINERY. GOODS.
JUST RECEIVED, a select assortment of
Spring and Summer Goods, such as
Ladies Hats and Bonnets, Flowers, Rib?
bons. Collars, Cuffs, Ac, which will be sold
at the lowest ligurci for cash. I ask my
friends and customers to examine the stock
and prices before buying elsewhere.
Mantua-Making and Stamping attended
to as usual.
MISS DELL A KEYS,
Up Stairs, No. 3 Brick Range.
April 6, 1876 38 3m
THE ANSON HARDY
PUBLISHERS AND PRINTERS
Commission House.
Every article in the Publishing and Print?
ing business bought at the lowest market
prices. ?
Strictly upon Commmion. Send for circular.
ANSON HARDY, AUBURNOALE, MASS.
Fob 10, 1876 30 6m
STOCKHOLDERS' MEETING.
THE Stockholders of the Anderson Edu?
cational Association are requested to meet
in the Court House on FRIDAY, 14th of
April, at eleven o'clock a. m. Every stock?
holder is urged to be represented, either in
person or by proxy, as business of the ut?
most importance will be considered.
By order of the President.
JOHN B. MOORE, Secretary.
April 6, 1876 38 2